THE REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. 771 OF 2019
KENYA NATIONAL PRIVATE SECURITY
WORKERS UNION........................................CLAIMANT/RESPONDENT
VERSUS
BRINKS SECURITY SERVICES LIMITED……....RESPONDENT/APPLICANT
RULING
1. Before Court is the Respondent’s motion application dated 27th January, 2026, brought pursuant to Section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 9 Rule 9, and Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules, wherein it seeks the following reliefs: -
i. Spent
ii. THAT leave be granted for KMA Advocates to come on record for the Respondent/Applicant.
iii. Spent
iv. THAT the Honourable Court be pleased to review, vary and/ or set aside the Judgement delivered on 29th May 2025.
v. THAT upon review, the finding that the Respondent unlawfully and unfairly dismissed CW1, CW2 and CW3 on account of unionization be set aside.
vi. THAT the award of 6 months' compensation to CW1, CW2 and CW3 be vacated
vii. The said leave does operate as a stay of all proceedings.
viii. The costs of this application be provided for.
2. The application is supported by grounds on the face of the motion and the affidavit sworn by MARTIN MIYAGO on 27th January, 2026.
3. The Applicant, who is the Respondent in the suit, seeks a review of the judgment delivered on 29th May 2025, and a stay of execution, contending that its former advocates failed to act on instructions to seek the orders, despite a proclamation notice dated 23rd January 2026.
4. It argues that the finding of unfair dismissal on account of unionization was unsupported by evidence of union membership or participation in union activities. The Respondent maintains that it terminated the Claimants for misconduct, including misuse of its property, neglect of duties, and misrepresentation.
5. The Applicant further contends that the judgment contains an apparent error on the face of the record, as the Court acknowledged compliance with due process and the Claimants’ poor employment records, but nevertheless found the dismissals unfair and awarded six months’ compensation.
6. It therefore seeks a stay of execution, arguing that enforcement would occasion substantial loss.
7. The Claimant/Respondent opposed the application through a Replying affidavit sworn by Beatrice Ndunge Wanyama on 16th February, 2026.
8. The Claimant states that it filed the claim and an application under certificate of urgency on 14th November 2019, and that it served the same upon the Respondents. It avers further that the Respondent filed a Response dated 9th June 2020, through Ndirangu Kamau Advocates, and that it actively participated in the proceedings.
9. The Claimant states that the issue of whether the grievants were union members was never raised, including during pre-trial, and the matter was certified ready for hearing in the Respondents’ presence.
10. It is its position that on 24th April 2024, it was served with a Notice of Change of Advocates by Agnes & Matthews Law LLP, seeking to substitute a witness statement and file supplementary documents, and that on 30th October 2024, the Court directed the Claimant to serve the Respondent with the relevant Ministerial Order authorizing the deduction of union dues.
11. The Claimant avers that the Court further directed the Respondent to commence deduction of union dues in January 2025 and resolve the dispute accordingly. It avers further that despite service of the relevant Ministerial Order, the Respondent failed to remit the union dues, and that the matter proceeded for hearing by consent on 20th March 2025, and the judgment was delivered on 29th May 2025 in the presence of both parties’ advocates.
12. The Claimant states that the Respondent sought 30 days stay of execution, which the court granted. It avers that after the stay lapsed, it made unsuccessful attempts to contact the Respondent, but the Respondent subsequently proposed to settle the decretal sum and costs by installments, and requested account details by email.
13. The Claimant states that they have awaited payment since 16th July 2025 without success. They contend that the Respondent’s renewed challenge to the Grievants’ union membership, following a third change of advocates, is an afterthought intended to frustrate enforcement of the judgment and deny the Grievants justice.
14. The Claimant maintains that the union membership of the three Grievants, Francisco Kibaara, Allan Nangeso Olinda and Valerie Ambenyi Amalemba, was never disputed.
15. It asserts that the Grievants confirmed their membership in their statements and that the Respondent’s role was limited to deducting and remitting union dues to the Claimant’s account.
16. The Claimant prays that the motion be dismissed with costs.
17. Parties were directed to canvass the motion through written submissions. The Claimant filed submissions; the Respondent/Applicant did not.
Analysis and Determination
18. The issues arising for determination are:-
i. Whether KMA Advocates should be granted leave to come on record for the Respondent/Applicant.
ii. Whether the Applicant has established grounds for review, variation or setting aside of the judgment delivered on 29th May, 2025.
iii. Whether the Applicant has satisfied the conditions for stay of execution.
Whether KMA Advocates should be granted leave to come on record for the Respondent/Applicant
19. Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides that a change of advocates after judgment must be effected either by an application made with notice to all parties and an order of the court, or by a consent filed between the outgoing and incoming advocates.
20. In S.K. Tarwadi v Veronica Muehlemann [2019] KECA 22 (KLR), the Court explained that the provision safeguards the interests of advocates who have represented litigants to judgment. The same position was adopted in Miriam Mbeke Nyamasyo & others v Dishon Odhiambo & others [2022] KEELC 1506 (KLR).
21. In the present case, KMA Advocates have expressly sought leave through the motion dated 27th January, 2026. The application was served on the other parties, and I see no reason to decline the prayer.
22. I therefore allow the prayer for leave.
Whether the Applicant has established grounds for review, variation or setting aside of the judgment delivered on 29th May, 2025
23. Section 16 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act empowers this Court to review its judgments, awards, orders or decrees in accordance with the applicable rules. Rule 74 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024 governs review and requires an applicant to establish a recognized ground for review, such as discovery of new and important evidence, an error apparent on the face of the record, or another sufficient reason that warrants review. The rule further requires that the application must also be made without unreasonable delay.
24. In National Bank of Kenya Limited Vs Ndungu Njau [1997] KECA 389 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held that an error apparent on the face of the record must be self evident and must not require elaborate argument to establish, and further that review is not an opportunity for the court to reconsider its decision merely because a party believes that a different conclusion ought to have been reached.
25. The Applicant contends that the Court acknowledged that due process was followed and that the Grievants had poor employment records, yet found their dismissals unfair on account of unionization and awarded each six months' compensation. It argues further that the finding was unsupported by evidence of union membership or participation in union activities.
26. The question for this court is whether this contention demonstrates an error apparent on the face of the judgment or merely challenges the Court's assessment of the evidence.
27. The Applicant's allegation that the Court reached an inconsistent conclusion requires examination of the judgment, the evidence and the reasons for the finding of unfair dismissal. That exercise, in my view, will involve reconsideration of the merits of the case rather than correction of an obvious error. In National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Ndungu Njau (Supra), the Court of Appeal held that such a challenge is ordinarily a matter for appeal, not review.
28. Further, the Applicant has not identified any new and important evidence that was unavailable despite the exercise of due diligence when judgment was delivered. The alleged failure by its former advocates to act on instructions is also not, by itself, a ground for review. The Applicant participated in the proceedings, and its advocates were present when judgment was delivered.
29. The complaint therefore concerns the conduct of its former advocates and the merits of the decision, rather than a demonstrated error apparent on the face of the record.
30. Further, the Claimant's evidence is that union membership was never disputed during the proceedings and that the Respondent was served with the relevant Ministerial Order concerning deduction of union dues.
31. The Respondent also allegedly proposed to pay the decretal sum by installments after judgment. Although this proposal does not conclusively determine the merits of the present application, it is relevant to the history of the proceedings and the explanation now advanced for reopening the judgment.
32. The instant application was filed on 27th January, 2026, approximately eight months after judgment. While the period is not necessarily unreasonable, the Applicant has not provided sufficient explanation to justify review, particularly given its participation in the hearing and the absence of any identified new evidence.
33. In the upshot, I find and hold that the Applicant has not established any of the recognized grounds for review or variation of the judgment.
Whether the Applicant has satisfied the conditions for stay of execution
34. Order 42 Rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules requires an applicant seeking stay of execution pending appeal to demonstrate that substantial loss may result unless stay is granted, that the application was made without unreasonable delay, and that security for the due performance of the decree has been provided or is addressed as the court directs.
35. In Butt v Rent Restriction Tribunal [1979] eKLR, the Court of Appeal emphasized that the discretion to grant stay of execution should be exercised judiciously and in a manner that does not unnecessarily prevent an appeal from being pursued.
36. Similarly, in James Wangalwa & Another V Agnes Naliaka Cheseto [2012] KEHC 1094 (KLR), the Court held that the commencement of execution, by itself, does not constitute substantial loss. An applicant must demonstrate additional circumstances showing that execution would cause substantial prejudice.
37. The Applicant herein relies on the proclamation notice dated 23rd January, 2026, to assert that execution would occasion substantial loss. Execution of a lawful decree is not, without more, sufficient to establish substantial loss. The Applicant has not demonstrated any other circumstances showing that execution would occasion loss beyond the ordinary consequences of satisfying a monetary decree.
38. In the absence of a demonstrated basis for stay of execution and evidence satisfying the applicable conditions, the prayer cannot be granted merely because the Applicant intends to challenge the judgment.
39. Further, the Applicant also bore the burden of addressing security for the due performance of the decree, yet no sufficient basis has been demonstrated for granting stay on the terms sought.
40. Accordingly, the prayer for stay of execution is not merited, and it fails.
41. In whole, I make the following orders:-
i. That leave is hereby granted to KMA Advocates to come on record for the Respondent/Applicant.
ii. That the prayer for review, variation, or setting aside of the judgment delivered on 29th May 2025 is declined.
iii. That the prayer for stay of execution is equally declined.
iv. The Respondent/Applicant shall bear the costs of the application.
42. Orders accordingly.
SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Ms. Wanyama present for the Claimant/Respondent
N/A for the Respondent/Applicant
Ms. Faith -C/A