Background
Before the Court is the Statement of Claim dated 2nd February, 2022, where the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Before the Court is the Statement of Claim dated 2nd February, 2022, where the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-
Paragraph 1 →In the end, the Claimant’s Claim is hereby determined in the following terms: -
Paragraph 82 →The Respondent prays that the Court finds that the Statement of Claim discloses no actionable claim, that the Claimant lacks the requisite locus standi, that there was no CBA to be signed, and dismiss the claim with costs.
Paragraph 34 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E072 OF 2022
KENYA UNION OF COMMERCIAL FOOD &
ALLIED WORKERS………………………………………………CLAIMANT
VERSUS
JADE COLLECTIONS LIMITED……………………………... RESPONDENT
Introduction
1. Before the Court is the Statement of Claim dated 2nd February, 2022, where the Claimant seeks the following remedies as against the Respondent:-
(i) The Hon. Court adopts and upholds the clauses already negotiated and agreed between the parties as placed under paragraph 30 herein.
(ii) The Honourable court adopt the Claimant’s proposals as placed herein under paragraph 5 on the clauses not agreed upon and declare them reasonable,
(iii) Upon granting of order (ii) above, the Honourable Court order the Respondent to sign the 2018-2020 Collective Bargaining Agreement within 30 days from the date of judgment.
(iv) A permanent order restraining the Respondent from intimidating, victimizing, coercing, disciplining and terminating employees on the basis of their trade union membership.
(v) This Honourable court grant any other relief as it may deem fit
(vi) Cost of the suit be borne by the Respondent.
2. The Claimant also filed its list and bundle of documents dated 2nd January, 2022 and indicated that it would not be calling any witness and would rely on the documents filed.
3. The Respondent entered appearance on 15th March, 2022 and subsequently filed its Memorandum of Response dated 19th February, 2026 together with their witness statement and list and bundle of documents dated 27th February, 2026.
4. The matter was canvassed by way of documentary evidence.
The Claimant’s Case.
5. The Claimant states that the parties entered into a Recognition Agreement on 24th April, 2018, following the determination in ELRC Cause No. 526 of 2014, and that the agreement remains in force. It maintains that the Recognition Agreement forms the basis for the collective bargaining between the parties.
6. The Claimant states that pursuant to the Recognition Agreement, it initiated negotiations for the parties’ first Collective Bargaining Agreement on 11th July, 2018, by submitting proposals covering 39 clauses, ranging from basic minimum wages to the effective date and duration of the agreement.
7. It is the Claimant’s case that the Respondent acknowledged receipt of the proposals on 17th July, 2018 and subsequently submitted counterproposals on 7th September, 2018.
8. The Claimant avers that the parties held joint negotiation meetings on 25th September, 2018, 31st October, 2018 and 13th November, 2018, during which they reached an agreement on 21 clauses of the proposed CBA.
9. It argues that they failed to agree on the remaining 18 clauses, which include basic minimum wage, wage increase, house allowance, commuter allowance, annual leave, sick leave, compassionate leave, study leave, medical treatment, redundancy, disciplinary procedure, termination of employment, acting appointment, gratuity, pension, long-service increment, bonus, and the effective date and duration of the agreement.
10. The Claimant further maintains that the unresolved clauses were subjected to conciliation under Part VIII of the Labour Relations Act, 2007. It avers that efforts by the Conciliator and the Federation of Kenya Employers did not resolve the dispute.
11. According to the Claimant, the Conciliator declined to issue a Certificate of Unresolved Dispute despite a written request, prompting the institution of the present proceedings.
12. The Claimant further states that it made genuine efforts to conclude the CBA, but that the Respondent maintained a rigid position during negotiations, thereby frustrating the process.
13. The Claimant sought reliance on Articles 41(1), 41(2) and 41(5) of the Constitution and the parties’ Recognition Agreement to contend that the Respondent was obliged to engage in collective bargaining and to respect employees’ rights to fair labour practices, fair remuneration and reasonable working conditions.
14. The Claimant urges the Court to allow her claim as drawn.
The Claimant’s Submissions.
15. In its written submissions, the Claimant reiterated that a valid Recognition Agreement existed between the parties and that it had initiated the CBA negotiations by submitting proposals on 11th July, 2018. It relied on the correspondence exchanged between the parties and the minutes of the negotiation meetings to show that negotiations took place and that the parties agreed on 21 clauses, leaving 18 unresolved.
16. On the dispute resolution process, the Claimant submits that the outstanding clauses were subjected to conciliation and that the conciliator declined to issue a Certificate of Unresolved Dispute despite a written request. It submits that the procedural steps necessary for the institution of the claim were undertaken and that the absence of the certificate should not defeat the claim.
17. The Claimant also addressed the CPMU report dated 5th December 2022, arguing that the economic analysis, particularly the wage bill figures and the period used to assess the Respondent’s financial performance, are disputed. It states that the report did not adequately analyze the Respondent’s financial position for the relevant compensable period, which it identified as 1st August, 2016 to July 2018, the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic and branch closures that occurred outside that period.
18. The Claimant urged the Court to consider its proposals alongside the Respondent’s counterproposals and the CPMU report when determining the outstanding clauses.
19. It maintained that its proposals were reasonable and appropriate for the parties’ first CBA and sought orders adopting the agreed clauses and determining the outstanding clauses, directing the parties to sign the CBA within 30 days of judgment and requiring the Respondent to present a signed agreement and the relevant schedule forms for registration.
20. On the validity of the Recognition Agreement, the Claimant reiterated that the agreement was signed on 24th April, 2018 following the judgment in ELRC Cause No. 526 of 2014, which established that the simple majority threshold under Section 54(1) of the Labour Relations Act, 2007, was met. It argued that the Respondent has not produced evidence that the Recognition Agreement was challenged, terminated or revoked in accordance with Section 54(5) of the Act.
21. The Claimant further submits that Sections 54(1) and 57(1) of the Labour Relations Act require an employer that recognizes a trade union to conclude a CBA with the recognized union. It maintained that the simple majority requirement related to recognition and was not a separate requirement to be proved afresh for purposes of negotiating each CBA. It therefore contends that it has the legal standing and representational capacity to negotiate the agreement.
22. On the reasonableness of the proposed terms, the Claimant reiterated that its proposals had to be assessed against the Respondent’s counterproposals, the CPMU report and the applicable statutory wage orders.
23. It further submits that the proposed minimum wages were based on the statutory wage rates in effect in May 2018, with modest improvements intended to prevent the negotiated wages from falling below subsequently revised statutory minimum wages. It also urged the Court to consider the effect of inflation and the rising cost of living on employees’ remuneration.
24. The Claimant submits that collective bargaining is conducted between the union and the employer through their representatives, and that the absence of individual union members from negotiation meetings did not invalidate the negotiations. It relied on Sections 48 and 55 of the Labour Relations Act to support its position on union representation and the functions of shop-floor representatives.
25. The Claimant consequently urged the Court to allow its claim.
26. It also sought costs of the suit.
The Respondent’s Case
27. The Respondent states that the Recognition Agreement dated 24th April, 2018 was not capable of giving rise to an actionable claim. It contends that the agreement was merely procedural, not a concluded agreement, and did not create enforceable obligations on the proposed terms of the CBA.
28. The Respondent disputes the validity of the Recognition Agreement and maintains that there was no valid agreement capable of supporting the negotiations initiated on 11th July, 2018. It further denies the Claimant’s proposals on the 39 clauses, describing the proposed figures as exaggerated, unilateral and unreasonable, and contends that the Respondent did not have the employee categories upon which the proposals were based.
29. The Respondent further denies that the parties agreed on the clauses identified by the Claimant. It avers that any purported agreement was entered into by a person who lacked the requisite authority, mandate or capacity to bind the Respondent.
30. The Respondent also denies that the negotiations and conciliation meetings had failed because of its conduct, asserting instead that the Claimant insisted on proceeding without the Respondent’s legal representative.
31. The Respondent further questions whether the Claimant had unionisable employees within its establishment who were members of the union.
32. It maintains that no employees attended the conciliation meetings as members of the Claimant Union, raising doubt about the alleged membership. It further contends that the conciliator did not issue a Certificate of Unresolved Dispute because the dispute did not qualify for such a certificate, and that the institution of the claim was therefore premature.
33. The Respondent states that it did not deliberately delay the conclusion of the CBA negotiations and disputes the Claimant’s allegations concerning the unresolved clauses.
34. The Respondent prays that the Court finds that the Statement of Claim discloses no actionable claim, that the Claimant lacks the requisite locus standi, that there was no CBA to be signed, and dismiss the claim with costs.
The Respondent’s Submissions.
35. On the validity of the Recognition Agreement, the Respondent placed reliance on Section 54(1) of the Labour Relations Act, 2007, to submit that recognition for purposes of collective bargaining depended on proof that the union represented a simple majority of the employer’s unionisable employees.
36. It further submits that the Claimant has not produced check-off forms, membership registers, signed union deduction forms, or other evidence demonstrating that it recruited the requisite majority.
37. The Respondent submits that the Recognition Agreement relied upon by the Claimant was disputed and that the Claimant has not established the statutory foundation for the negotiations. It relied on Communication Workers’ Union v Safaricom Limited [2014] KEELRC 1302 (KLR) and Kenya Union of Commercial Food and Allied Workers v Naivas Limited [2015] KEELRC 749 (KLR) to support its submissions on recognition and the majority membership requirement.
38. It contends that the Claimant failed to establish its representational capacity and that the Court could not compel the Respondent to negotiate or conclude a CBA in the absence of proof of the statutory threshold.
39. On the reasonableness and sustainability of the proposed clauses, the Respondent submits that the Claimant has invited the Court to adopt its proposals wholesale, while challenging the CPMU report without producing an alternative economic or financial analysis.
40. It submits that the Court should consider the Respondent’s ability to pay, prevailing economic conditions, productivity, the sustainability of labour costs, and the interests of both employees and the employer.
41. The Respondent relied on Kenya Game Hunting & Safari Workers Union v Micato Safaris [2016] KEELRC 1040 (KLR), to submit that wage increases should cushion employees against inflation, but must be considered alongside improved performance and the sustainability of the wage bill.
42. It is its submission that the Claimant’s proposed wage increases and benefits were unsupported by sufficient evidence and that the Court should not impose financial obligations merely because the union considered its proposals reasonable.
43. On the absence of a Certificate of Unresolved Dispute, the Respondent relies on Sections 68, 69 and 73 of the Labour Relations Act, 2007, to submit that conciliation is a statutory dispute resolution mechanism and that failing to obtain and file the certificate shows the statutory process has not been fully exhausted.
44. On whether the Court should adopt the Claimant’s proposals, the Respondent submits that Article 41(5) of the Constitution protects the right to collective bargaining, but does not authorize one party to impose its preferred terms on the other. It argues that adopting the disputed proposals wholesale would substitute judicial determination for the voluntary process of collective bargaining and would impose terms to which the Respondent has not consented.
45. The Respondent relied on Kenya Quarry and Workers Union v Mineral Enterprises Limited [2023] KEELRC 681 (KLR), to submit that collective bargaining must remain a voluntary process founded on consultation, negotiation and consensus.
46. It maintained that the parties have not reached consensus on the outstanding clauses, and that any purported agreements entered into by persons without authority could not bind it.
47. The Respondent urged the Court to find that the Claimant has failed to establish the validity and enforceability of the Recognition Agreement, has not proved that it represented the requisite majority of the Respondent’s unionisable employees, and has failed to demonstrate the reasonableness and sustainability of its proposals.
48. It consequently sought dismissal of the Memorandum of Claim with costs.
Analysis and Determination
49. The issues arising from the pleadings and the parties’ submissions are:
i. Whether the Claimant has established a valid and subsisting Recognition Agreement and the requisite capacity to negotiate a Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA).
ii. Whether the absence of a Certificate of Unresolved Dispute renders the claim premature.
iii. Whether the parties agreed on 21 clauses of the proposed CBA and, if so, whether the Respondent should be compelled to execute them.
iv. Whether the Court should adopt the Claimant’s proposals on the 18 disputed clauses and compel execution of the 2018–2020 CBA.
Whether the Claimant has established a valid and subsisting Recognition Agreement and the requisite capacity to negotiate a Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA)
50. Article 41(5) of the Constitution guarantees every trade union, employers’ organization and employer the right to engage in collective bargaining. Sections 54 and 57(1) of the Labour Relations Act, 2007 provide the statutory framework for union recognition and collective bargaining.
51. Section 57(1) requires an employer that has recognized a trade union in accordance with the Act to conclude a CBA with that union setting out the terms and conditions of service of the unionisable employees covered by the Recognition Agreement.
52. The Claimant contends that a Recognition Agreement was executed between the parties herein on 24th April, 2018, following the determination in ELRC Cause No. 526 of 2014, in which the requisite simple majority was established. It further contends that the agreement has never been terminated or revoked.
53. The Respondent, on the other hand, disputes the validity of the agreement and insists that the Claimant has not shown that it represents a simple majority of her unionisable employees.
54. The relevant consideration is whether the Recognition Agreement was validly executed and remains in force. Under Section 54(5) of the Labour Relations Act, an employer seeking to revoke or terminate a Recognition Agreement must follow the statutory procedure set out therein.
55. In Kenya Union of Commercial, Food and Allied Workers v Eldomatt Supermarket Limited [2022] KEELRC 1776 (KLR), the Court observed that an employer disputing a Recognition Agreement could not merely disown it without demonstrating that it had pursued the statutory process for its termination. The Court also emphasized the importance of establishing the actual membership position where the requisite majority becomes a live issue.
56. The court record herein confirms that the Recognition Agreement was executed and no evidence was led to show that the agreement has since been lawfully terminated. Accordingly, the Respondent cannot defeat the Claimant’s standing merely by denying the agreement's validity.
57. In light of the foregoing, I reach the conclusion that a valid Recognition Agreement exists between the parties herein, and it then follows that the parties have capacity to negotiate a Collective Bargaining Agreement.
Whether the absence of a Certificate of Unresolved Dispute renders the claim premature
58. Sections 62, 65, 67, 69 and 73 of the Labour Relations Act provide the framework for reporting, conciliation and adjudication of trade disputes. Section 73(1) allows a party to refer a trade dispute to this Court if it remains unresolved after conciliation.
59. In Kenya Tea Growers Association v Kenya Plantation & Agricultural Workers Union [2018] KECA 706 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held that the ELRC may determine economic disputes concerning CBA terms, but only after the statutory dispute resolution procedure has been followed. It clarified that the jurisdictional requirement is compliance with the conciliation process, not merely the production of a particular document.
60. Section 69 recognizes two circumstances in which a trade dispute is deemed unresolved. First, when the conciliator issues a certificate, and second, at the expiry of 30 days from the conciliator’s appointment, unless the parties have agreed to extend the conciliator’s term.
61. In the present case, the Claimant maintains that the disputed clauses were referred to conciliation, that the process failed to resolve them, and that the conciliator declined to issue a certificate despite a written request. Conversely, the Respondent contends that the absence of the certificate demonstrates that the dispute was not properly referred to Court.
62. In my view, the Respondent’s objection cannot succeed merely because the certificate was not issued. The Court record confirms that a trade dispute was formally reported, a conciliator was appointed, and the statutory conciliation process was undertaken, but it did not resolve the dispute.
63. In the circumstances, Section 69 permits that the dispute be treated as unresolved notwithstanding the absence of a certificate.
64. I therefore decline to dismiss the claim solely on the basis that the certificate was not issued.
Whether the Court should adopt the 21 allegedly agreed clauses
65. The Claimant asserts that the parties agreed on 21 clauses during the negotiations held on 25th September, 31st October and 13th November 2018. The Respondent disputes that assertion, contending that the purported agreement was made by a person who lacked authority to bind it.
66. Article 41(5) of the Constitution protects Collective Bargaining, while Section 57 of the Labour Relations Act requires recognized employers and unions to conclude CBAs. The Court must, however, distinguish between clauses that were actually agreed upon and those that remained contested.
67. In Kenya Tea Growers Association v Kenya Plantation & Agricultural Workers Union [2018] KECA 706 (KLR), the Court of Appeal affirmed the importance of collective bargaining as a process founded on the parties’ freedom to negotiate. The Court also recognized this court’s power to adjudicate unresolved economic disputes once the parties had exhausted the statutory procedure.
68. Further, in Kenya Quarry and Workers Union v Mineral Enterprises Limited [2023] KEELRC 681 (KLR), the Court addressed a dispute over the execution of a draft CBA and emphasized the need to bring negotiations to a conclusion.
69. That decision, however, does not dispense with the need to establish which terms the parties actually agreed upon.
70. The final minutes of the negotiation meetings placed before the court are for a meeting that was held on4th February, 2019. The minutes show that twenty (20) items remained outstanding.
71. Further, the Court cannot establish from the minutes provided how many items were conclusively agreed upon, as the minutes repeatedly go back and forth on the same issues, with agreements at some points and subsequent disagreements on the same items.
72. In the premise, the Claimant’s assertion that 21 clauses were agreed upon by duly authorized representatives cannot be confirmed, and the Court is thus unable to uphold the clauses for inclusion in the CBA at this point.
Whether the Court should adopt the Claimant’s proposals on the 18 disputed clauses
73. The Claimant seeks adoption of its proposals concerning basic minimum wages, wage increases, house and commuter allowances, leave, medical treatment, redundancy, disciplinary procedures, termination, gratuity, pension, bonuses and other employment benefits.
74. It argues that its proposals are reasonable, taking into account inflation, the rising cost of living and the applicable wage orders. The Respondent, on its part, maintains that the proposals are excessive and unsupported by adequate evidence of its financial capacity to sustain the resulting wage bill.
75. In Kenya Union of Commercial, Food and Allied Workers v Eldoret Packers Limited [2025] KEELRC 1365 (KLR), it was held that the Court may intervene where a party frustrates the negotiation process, including by refusing to provide counterproposals or cooperate during conciliation.
76. On the evidence before the Court, there is insufficient detail about the individual proposals and the CPMU’s actual findings to justify adoption of all the 18 disputed clauses in the terms proposed by the Claimant.
Whether the Respondent should be compelled to sign the CBA
77. The Claimant further seeks an order compelling the Respondent to execute the 2018–2020 CBA within 30 days of this judgment. The Respondent argues that no concluded CBA exists and that the Court cannot impose on it terms it has not consented to.
78. The distinction is between compelling compliance with an existing obligation and imposing terms that have not been agreed upon or judicially determined.
79. Section 57(1) of the Labour Relations Act imposes an obligation on a recognized employer to conclude a CBA with the recognized union. In Kenya Tea Growers Association (Supra), the Court of Appeal confirmed that the ELRC can adjudicate unresolved disputes over CBA terms after compliance with the statutory conciliation process. It also made clear that this power must be exercised judiciously, on the evidence, and without disregarding the principles governing collective bargaining.
80. Having found that the document/draft CBA, if I could call it so, between the parties contains unresolved terms, I cannot order execution before those terms have been conclusively agreed upon.
81. In the circumstances, I hereby order execution of the CBA once the agreed clauses have been verified and the outstanding clauses have been resolved through negotiated settlement.
82. In the end, the Claimant’s Claim is hereby determined in the following terms: -
a) That the prayer to uphold the 21 CBA clauses is declined.
b) That the prayer to adopt the Claimant’s 18 disputed clauses individually is equally declined.
c) That the Respondent be and is hereby ordered to negotiate and execute the final CBA with the Claimant within 60 days of this judgment.
d) Parties shall bear their own costs in the interest of continuing industrial relations.
83. Judgment accordingly.
SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Mr. Tacko h/b for Mr. Nyumba for the Claimant
Ms. Mugala h/b for Mr. Ndegwa for the Respondent
Ms. Esther - C/A