Employment law

Nyamolo v National Syndemic Diseases Control Council (NSDCC) [2026] KEELRC 14940 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Petition E102 of 2024
Judgment date
30 October 2026
Judge(s)
Jemimah Keli

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The parties herein have two applications pending before the Court. The first is a Notice of Motion dated 27th July 2026, brought by the Respondent under Rule 74 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules 2024, seeking the following orders: -

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

The court finds that the only basis on which it would apply to defeat its jurisdiction would be on the basis of res judicata or sub judice. I upheld the decision in Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission v Kiai &5 others [2017]KECA 477 (KLR), where the Court of Appeal restated the essential elements that must all be satisfied, conjunctively and not disjunctively, before the bar of res judicata can be upheld:-

Paragraph 12 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC PETITION NO. E102 OF 2024

JUDICIAL REVIEW AND LABOUR RIGHTS DIVISION

KENNETH OLUOCH NYAMOLO…………………………………………………………………………...…PETITIONER

-VERSUS-

NATIONAL SYNDEMIC DISEASES CONTROL

COUNCIL (NSDCC)………………………………………………………...………………………………….…RESPONDENT

CORAM

Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli

C/ A Otieno

RULING

1. The parties herein have two applications pending before the Court. The first is a Notice of Motion dated 27th July 2026, brought by the Respondent under Rule 74 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules 2024, seeking the following orders: -

a) Spent.

b) Spent.

c) This Honourable Court be pleased to review the Certificate of Order Against the Government issued on 17th February 2026 and vary the quantified decretal amount therein to conform with the Judgment delivered on 25th September 2025.

d) This Honourable Court be pleased to set aside the quantified decretal amount contained in the Certificate of Order Against the Government issued on 17th February 2026.

e) This Honourable Court be pleased to direct that the decretal amount payable under the Judgment delivered on 25th September 2025 be computed strictly in accordance with the findings and orders contained in the said Judgment.

f) Upon the proper computation of the decretal amount, a corrected Certificate of Order Against the Government do issue.

g) The costs of this Application be provided for.

2. The Application was supported by the affidavit sworn by William Birech on 27th July 2026.

3.

号0-5:

号0-5:

Grounds of the application

a) The Honourable Court delivered judgment on 25th September 2025 awarding the Petitioner various monetary reliefs and directing that the monetary awards be computed. The Court did not determine the monetary value of the awards but expressly directed that the same be computed. Pursuant to the said Judgment, a Decree was extracted on 7th October 2025 which merely restated the orders contained in the Judgment but did not quantify the decretal amount payable.

b) Subsequently, a Certificate of Order Against the Government was issued on 17th February 2026 setting out the decretal amount payable. The Respondent states that it has since established that the computations adopted in the Certificate of Order Against the Government do not reflect the Judgment delivered by this Honourable Court and consequently resulted in an erroneous calculation of the decretal amount.

c) The present Application does not seek to reopen, vary or challenge the Judgment delivered on 25th September 2025 but seeks review of the Certificate of Order against the Government issued on 17th February 2026 so that the quantified decretal amount conforms to the Judgment of this Honourable Court.

d) It is in the interests of justice that the Certificate of Order Against the Government be reviewed so that it reflects the Judgment delivered by the Court.

e) Unless the orders sought are granted, the Respondent/Applicant stands to suffer substantial prejudice through enforcement of a Certificate of Order containing a decretal amount which is erroneous does not align with the Judgment.

号0-5:

号0-5:

Response to the application

4. The application was opposed by the Petitioner through a Replying Affidavit sworn on 29th July 2026 where he averred that:

a) Judgment was delivered in the Petitioner’s favour by Hon. Justice Nduma Nderi on 25th September 2025, directing the 1st Respondent to satisfy my earned dues within sixty (60) days.

b) The Respondents filed an Application for Stay of Execution before the Court of Appeal under Rule 5(2)(b) (Civil Appeal Application No. E660 of 2025). On 26th June 2026, the Court of Appeal (Coram: Tuiyott, Ndolo & Hassan, JJ.A.) in Civil Appeal (Application) No. E660 of 2025 delivered a binding Ruling explicitly DISMISSING WITH COSTS the Respondents’ application for a stay of execution of the Judgment in this matter.

c) Despite the Court of Appeal's conclusive dismissal of the stay, the Respondents have fraudulently moved this Court to grant/sustain orders of stay and/or arrest of execution based on a belated "computation challenge," thereby inducing this Court into an impermissible horizontal review of an Appellate Court ruling.

d) The orders of stay currently in force are nullity ab initio for want of jurisdiction, bring the judicial hierarchy into disrepute, and severely embarrass the Judiciary by creating an irreconcilable conflict between a decree of a court of the status of the High Court and the Court of Appeal.

e) The Court awarded the undisputed portion of the claim corresponding to 20 months, (1st December 2020 to 31st July 2022) which amounted to Ksh 4,907,018 /-, a detailed schedule computations totaling Ksh. 4,907,018 being the 20 Months running 1st December 2020 to 31st July 2022 as awarded by the Honourable Court was formally prepared and served upon the Respondent, but they neither responded, objected to, nor contested these figures which were filed in court, within the 60 days timeline issued by Court. The Respondents actively acted upon the email transmission of 27th October 2025 by negotiating and contesting only the Bill of Costs, which was compromised at KES 530,000 as reflected in the final computation schedule, but did not address the amounts due as damages, acting allowance salary arrears and gratuity, which were to be computed, filed in court and paid to the Petitioner within 60 days of the judgment.

f) A formal Certificate of Order Against the Government was issued on 17th February 2026 for Kshs. 4,907,018 /=, which together with statutory interest accrued up to the date of issuance, brought the total certified sum to Kshs. 5,693,706/=. The same was re-served on 3rd July 2026, having previously served the same in letters dated 21st November 2025 and 27th October 2025 electronically and physically.

g) The Respondent, having moved to the Court of Appeal to seek stay of execution following the Judgment of this Honourable Court delivered on 25th September 2025, cannot re-litigate the issue of stay of execution before a lower court after being denied the same relief by the Court of Appeal. The application is res judicata and an abuse of court process.

h) During the contempt of court proceedings initiated against the 1st Respondent for noncompliance, this Honourable Court explicitly observed and advised that having regularly obtained the Certificate of Order Against the Government, the proper and lawful recourse for the Petitioner is to institute Mandamus proceedings to enforce payment, which the Petitioner has commenced. The Respondents’ present Application is filed in bad faith specifically to obstruct, delay,and stand in the way of justice.

i) The Applicant never brought to the attention of the court the proceedings of the Court of appeal on stay, and is therefore concealing key facts in order to mislead the court.

j) The Respondent has failed to state or specify the decretal amount in their application, and to offer to deposit the decretal sum (or even their own admitted sum of KES 2,474,214.00) into an interest-earning joint account in the names of the parties' Advocates, as required by Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2010. The Respondents' omission to offer security demonstrates a complete lack of good faith and renders the prayer for a stay of execution legally untenable.

k) Having failed to comply with the primary direction of the Court and having ignored the Petitioner’s served computation for months, the Respondent cannot now seek equity, as equity aids the vigilant and not those who sleep on their rights.

l) Under the well-established doctrine of estoppel and the principle against approbation and reprobation, the Respondent cannot selectively adopt the negotiated costs from the email sent to them by the Petitioner while claiming ignorance of the decretal calculations attached thereto. The allegation by the Respondents that they were not served or were unaware of the Petitioner's computations is an intentional falsehood, a material misrepresentation, and an abuse of court process intended to mislead this Honourable Court.

m) The Certificate of Order Against the Government issued on 17th February 2026 for the sum of Kshs. 5,693,706.00 accurately reflects the Judgment of this Court, having been properly processed by the Deputy Registrar. On General Damages, the Court awarded three (3) months' gross salary, and the figure of Kshs. 1,460,000.00 aligns with the Petitioner’s actual gross remuneration package. The Respondents' proposed figure of Kshs. 1,350,435.00 is an attempt to understate his lawful entitlement. On Acting Allowance arrears, the Court expressly recognized that the Petitioner performed the full higher duties of Deputy Director, Finance & Administration. The Respondents' assertion that he is only entitled to a nominal 5% increment (KES 337,091.00) directly contradicts the substantive findings of the Judgment. On Gratuity Arrears, the award of 31% gratuity was based on the adjusted basic salary attached to the acting capacity, making the sum of KES 668,989.00 fully justified. The Court further recognized that the Decree Holders service gratuity was unlawfully remitted to Hazina Sacco in violation of Section 19 of the Employment Act 2007. This has not been included in the Computation and the Applicant/Judgement debtor is to immediately rectify, and refund the same.

n) There is no "error apparent on the face of the record" as alleged by the Respondent, rather, they seek to alter the substantive merits of the Judgment under the guise of Rule 74 of the ELRC (Procedure) Rules, 2024.

o) Upon delivering its Judgment on 25th September 2025, the Honorable Court became functus officio regarding the substantive rights and awards granted. This is buttressed by the Notice of Appeal filed.

p) It is in the interest of justice that this application be dismissed with costs.

5. The second application is a Notice of Motion application dated 29th July 2026 brought by the Petitioner brought under Articles 159 and 163 of the Constitution, Section 3A of the Appellate Jurisdiction Act, Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, and the inherent powers of the Court, seeking the following orders:-

a) Spent.

b) This Honourable Court be pleased to vacate, set aside, and discharge in toto the Orders of Stay of Execution/Stay of Enforcement/Arrest of Decree granted on 27th July 2026 in ELRC Petition No. E102 of 2024.

c) This Honourable Court be pleased to strike out the Respondents’ Application/Objection contesting computations dated 27th July 2026 for being an abuse of court process, res judicata, and brought without jurisdiction.

d) The costs of this Application be borne by the Respondents jointly and severally on an indemnity scale.

6. The Application was supported by the Petitioner’s Supporting Affidavit sworn on 29th July 2026.

7.

号0-5:

号0-5:

Grounds of the 2nd application

a) Judgment was delivered in the Petitioner’s favour by Hon. Justice Nduma Nderi on 25th September 2025, directing the 1st Respondent to satisfy his earned dues within sixty (60) days.

b) The Respondents filed an application for stay of execution before the Court of Appeal under Rule 5(2)(b) (Civil Appeal Application No. E660 of 2025). On 26th June 2026, the Court of Appeal (Coram: Tuiyott, Ndolo & Hassan, JJ.A.) in Civil Appeal (Application) No. E660 of 2025 delivered a binding Ruling explicitly dismissing with costs the Respondents’ application for a stay of execution of the Judgment in this matter, on the premise that the decree is a money decree, and the Petitioner is not a "man of straw," hence paying the decree poses no existential or financial threat to the public exchequer.

c) Despite the Court of Appeal's conclusive dismissal of the stay, the Respondents have fraudulently moved this Court to grant/sustain orders of stay and/or arrest of execution based on a belated "computation challenge," thereby inducing this Court into an impermissible horizontal review of an Appellate Court ruling. It is a grave legal anomaly and an embarrassment to the administration of justice for a trial court to issue a stay of execution after the Court of Appeal has evaluated the exact same decree and refused stay.

d) According to the Petitioner, the computation challenge is brought in bad-faith as an afterthought as the Certificate of Order Against Government itemizing the exact sum of Kshs. 5,693,706.00 was served on the Attorney General on 18th February 2026 and directly on the 1st Respondent's CEO on 3rd July 2026, and in spite of being directed by the Court in its Judgment of 25th September 2025 to compute the decretal amounts for the undisputed period of 1st December 2020 to 31st July 2022 as awarded, file and pay the same within sixty (60) days, the Respondent has failed, neglected, and/or refused to prepare, serve, or file any computations within the mandated 60-day window.

e) The orders of stay of execution currently in force are nullity ab initio for want of jurisdiction, bring the judicial hierarchy into disrepute, and severely embarrass the Judiciary by creating an irreconcilable conflict between a subordinate decree court and the Court of Appeal.

f) In strict adherence to the Judgment delivered on 25th September 2025, the Petitioner formally served the Respondents with the complete settlement package, comprising a cover letter, an Excel breakdown of the judgment calculations (Calculation of Remuneration Difference-Revised.xlsx), and the party-to-party Bill of Costs via email on 27th October 2025 at 12:59 PM reducing the claim from the 36 Months to the 20 Months awarded by Court. The Respondents acted upon the email by negotiating and contesting only the Bill of Costs, which the Petitioner conceded to and compromised at Kshs. 530,000/-as reflected in the final computation schedule. However, they elected not to object to or offer a counter-computation regarding the Excel calculation sheet attached to the self-same email transmission. Further, they never responded, objected, or filed a Reference against the served computation during the 21-day window. As such, they are fully estopped from raising the issue now having failed to comply with the primary direction of the Court and having ignored the served computation for months. The Petitioner relies on the maxim that equity aids the vigilant and not those who sleep on their rights.

g) In addition to the electronic service, a formal demand letter dated 21st November 2025 detailing the breakdown of Kshs. 5,693,706.00 was physically delivered to and received by the 1st Respondent, and affixed with the official stamp of the Chief Executive Officer, NSDCC dated 21st November 2025 at 12:03 p.m., three days prior to the expiration of the court-mandated 60-day window for payment. Under the well-established doctrine of estoppel and the principle against approbation and reprobation, the Respondent cannot selectively adopt the negotiated costs from the email while claiming ignorance of the decretal calculations attached thereto.

h) The Petitioner denies the allegation by the Respondent that they were not served or were unaware of the Petitioner's computations, and categorize it as an intentional falsehood, a material misrepresentation, and an abuse of court process intended to mislead the Court. The Court is informed that after serving both the Attorney General and the Respondent’s CEO as stated, the Respondent was given a statutory 21-day notice to object or concur. Having maintained total silence across both windows, the Respondents are legally estopped from manufacturing a "computation dispute" to arrest execution after losing at the Court of Appeal.

i) The Certificate of Order Against the Government issued on 17th February 2026 for Kshs. 5,693,706.00 accurately reflects the Judgment of this Court, having been properly processed by the Deputy Registrar reducing the original claim from the 36 Months to the 20 Months awarded by Court following the Respondents' default.

j) In the Court’s Ruling dated 15th May 2026, the Petitioner’s application for contempt of Court was struck out on the explicit basis that enforcement must proceed via Section 21 of Cap 40 (Mandamus). Granting stay of execution paralyzes the exact procedure the Court ordered should proceed.

号0-5:

号0-5:

Response to the application

8. The 2nd application was opposed by the Respondent through a Replying Affidavit sworn by William Birech on 28th August 2026 where he averred that:-

a) Judgment was delivered in Petition No. EI02 of 2024. Kenneth Oluoch v National Syndemic Diseases Control Council by the Honourable Justice Mathews Nderi Nduma on 25th September 2025, directing, among other things, that the monetary awards made therein be computed, filed and paid to the Applicant within sixty (60) days.

b) Immediately following the delivery of the Judgment, the Applicant/Decree Holder proceeded to extract a Decree dated 7'11October 2025 without prior notice to, or consultation with the Respondent/Judgment Debtor for purposes of-settling and agreeing on the terms and monetary computation of the awards made by the Court.

c) After the decree had been extracted, on 27th October, 2025, the Applicant forwarded to the Respondent his computation of the award given by the Court, and a Certificate of Order Against the Government was subsequently issued on 17th February 2026, certifying a total sum of Kshs. 5,693,706/- as payable by the Respondent.

d) Upon verification of the certified sum against its payroll and establishment records, the Respondent identified material discrepancies between the sum certified in the Certificate of Order Against the Government and the amounts properly arising from the Judgment.

e) Subsequently, the Respondent filed the Application dated 27th July 2026, pursuant to Rule 74 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024. seeking review of the impugned Certificate of Order Against the Government. The Review Application is supported by the Respondent’s Further Affidavit which contains the Respondent's alternative computation in detail.

f) On 27th July 2026, the Court granted ex-parte orders preserving the status quo pending the hearing and determination of the Review Application. It is those orders which the Applicant now seeks to set aside, together with an order striking out the Review Application in its entirety.

g) While it is true that the Respondent moved the Court of Appeal in Civil Appeal Application No. E660 of 2025 NSDCC-V- KENNETH OLUOCH NY AMOLO vide application dated 10th November 2025 seeking a stay of execution pending the hearing and determination of its intended appeal, and that the same was heard and dismissed by the Court of Appeal on 261h June 2026, the Application before the Court of Appeal was for stay of the judgment and orders granted by the Trial Court on 25th September 2025 under and brought Rule 5(2)(b) of the Court of Appeal Rules 2022, and not on the correctness or otherwise of the subsequent computation contained in the Certificate of Order Against Government issued on 17th February 2026.

h) By the time the Application for stay of execution was filed before the Court of Appeal, no Certificate of Order Against Government had been issued, the said Certificate was only issued on 17th February 2026.

i) The Respondent/Judgment Debtor's Application dated 27th July 2026 is not an appeal, but an application for review under Rule 74 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024 which provides that a person aggrieved by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed, but from which no appeal has been preferred, may apply for review. No appeal has been preferred against the amount stated in the Certificate of Order Against Government issued on 17th February 2026.

j) The ex-parte orders of 27th July 2026, and the Review Application to which they relate, concern an entirely separate and subsequent question: whether the sum of Kshs. 5,693,706/= certified in the Certificate of Order Against Government issued on 17th February 2026 faithfully and correctly reflected the monetary awards made in the trial court Judgment. This question was neither raised before nor determined by the Court of Appeal, as evidenced by the ruling dated 26th June 2026 which has no bearing on it.

k) This Court, in entertaining the Review Application and granting interim orders pending its determination, is exercising its own express jurisdiction under Rule 74 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024 over the correctness of a certificate issued in its own proceedings and is therefore not sitting in review of, or in conflict with, the Court of Appeal.

l) Further, Section 21(3) of the Government Proceedings Act (Cap 40) expressly empowers the Court by which any such order as aforesaid is made or any court to which an appeal against the order lies to direct that payment of the whole or part of a certified sum be suspended pending an appeal or otherwise and to have such a direction inserted in the certificate itself. The ex-parte orders of 27th July 2026, preserving the status quo pending determination of the Review Application, fall squarely within the suspension power expressly conferred on this Honourable Court by Section 21(3) of Cap 40, as well as the exercise of jurisdiction under Rule 74 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024 and are accordingly a lawful exercise of this Court's own statutory jurisdiction over the certificate, and not, as alleged, an unlawful or embarrassing conflict with the Court of Appeal's Ruling.

m) The temporary orders issued by this Honourable Court on 27th July 2026 were granted pending the hearing and determination of the Applicant's Application and were intended to preserve the position in respect to the Certificate of Order Against Government issued on 17th February 2026 pending determination of the issues raised therein.

n) The Ruling of 15th May 2026 determined the appropriate procedural route for enforcement of the Judgment; it did not determine, and was not asked to determine, whether the sum certified on 17th February 2026 was itself correctly computed.

o) The said temporary orders issued on the 27th July 2026 did not determine or purport to determine the issues addressed in this Honourable Court's Ruling of 15th May 2026 concerning the statutory procedure for enforcement of orders against the Government under Section 21 of the Government Proceedings Act, Cap. 40.

p) The Respondent's/judgement Debtor's invocation of Rule 74 of the Employment and Labour Relations (Procedure) Rules, 2024 to have the correctness of the certified sum determined does not foreclose, and is not inconsistent with, the Applicant's ability to pursue enforcement under Section 21 of the Government Proceedings Act, Cap 40 once the correct amount payable has been established. It would actually be premature and a miscarriage of justice for enforcement to proceed by mandamus for a sum which the Respondent has demonstrated, on its own verification, to be materially overstated.

q) The Respondent admits that the Judgment of 25th September 2025 directed that the monetary award be computed, filed and paid within sixty (60) days, but states that the Decree Holder, immediately following the delivery of the Judgment, proceeded to extract a Decree dated 7th October 2025 without prior notice to or consultation with the Respondent, for purposes of settlement. This was contrary to Rule 72(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024, which provides that a party preparing a draft decree shall submit it to the other party for approval. with or without amendment or rejection within seven days of service. before the same is submitted to the Registrar for signing and sealing.

r) The extracted Decree did not contain any quantified decretal sum or monetary tabulation of the awards made by the Court but merely reproduced the Orders granted by the Court on 25th September 2025.

s) Following the extraction of the decree, the Petitioner’s Advocates forwarded their unilateral computation of the monetary award to the Respondent on 27th October 2025, but it could not crystallise into a binding or certified sum capable of founding estoppel.

t) Upon extraction of a Certificate of Order Against Government quantifying the decretal amount at Kshs. 5,693,706/= in attempt to crystallise and enforce the unilateral computation as the decretal amount, and service of the same on the Respondent, the Respondent undertook internal verification of the same against the Respondent's salary records, payment history and the terms of the Judgment, and material discrepancies were identified.

u) With respect to the party-and-party costs, the Petitioner served the Respondent with a Bill of Costs dated 9th October 2025 to which the Respondent responded by filing submissions dated 24th October 2025 wherein they opposed the proposed party-and-party costs and proposed a sum of Kshs. 530,000/=. The said response was expressly limited to the Bill of Costs and therefore cannot in law or equity, be construed as an acceptance to the computations of costs relating to salary, acting allowance or gratuity. The doctrine of estoppel cannot be invoked to prevent a party from challenging a quantified Certificate that does not faithfully reflect the Judgment of the Court.

v) Equity does not aid a party who seeks to enforce a sum that is demonstrably higher than what was awarded. The Respondent is not seeking to avoid its lawful obligations but is seeking to ensure that only the correct amount arising from the Judgment is paid.

w) The allegation that the Respondent has made a material misrepresentation to the Court is denied, with the Respondent emphasizing that the present proceedings have been conducted openly and in good faith.

x) They also deny that the review application is res judicata stating that it raises a genuine, material and well-founded dispute as to whether the Certificate of Order Against Government correctly reflects the monetary awards made in the Judgment. Striking out the Review Application without a hearing on its merits would highly prejudice the Respondent and further deny the Respondent, a public institution, the opportunity to demonstrate that public funds should not be appropriated in satisfaction of a certificate that overstates the Respondent's true liability under the Judgment.

DECISION

9. Issues for determination

a. Jurisdiction of the court to determine the 1st application as raised in 2nd application.

b. Whether the application for review was meritorious.

c. Remedies.

The law

10. Rule 74 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules 2024, Articles 159 and 163 of the Constitution,

Section 3A of the Appellate Jurisdiction Act,

Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

11. The court’s jurisdiction to issue the order of stay of execution has been challenged pursuant to the decision of the Court of Appeal of 26th June 2026 declining a stay of execution. The court is aware that it must respect higher courts within the court hierarchy. Before the Court of Appeal, the respondent sought a stay of execution of the judgment in this petition pending hearing of the intended appeal. The court considered its Rule 5(2)b and found no merit in the application. The court found that the sums of the award were not disclosed as follows-

‘[14] How does the application fare in the face of these tests? Nowhere in the application does the applicant state that the respondent is unable to repay the decretal sums in the event the appeal is of good fortune. In the absence of such challenge, the pendulum of proof did not swing to the respondent to demonstrate financial ability. Secondly on this aspect, it has not been proved, nay asserted, that recovery of any sums that may be paid out to the respondent will be impossible or difficult to recover.

[15] Another contention made by the applicant is that the Kenyan taxpayer stands to lose colossal sums of money in settling the decretal sums. The applicant however does not say what those sums, which it describes as colossal, involve nor does it state that the sums are such that a payout would imperil its operations. And if we must add, we do not see how the decree which is three months’ salary, salary arrears for acting allowance for a period of about 19 months and gratuity for that period can be colossal.

[16] Accordingly, the notice of motion dated 10th November, 2025, is without merit and is hereby dismissed with costs to the respondent.’’

12. The court finds that the only basis on which it would apply to defeat its jurisdiction would be on the basis of res judicata or sub judice. I upheld the decision in Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission v Kiai &5 others [2017]KECA 477 (KLR), where the Court of Appeal restated the essential elements that must all be satisfied, conjunctively and not disjunctively, before the bar of res judicata can be upheld:-

a. The suit or issue was directly and substantially in issue in the former suit;

b. That former suit was between the same parties or parties under whom they or any of them claim;

c. Those parties were litigating under the same title;

d. The issue was heard and finally determined in the former suit; and

e. The court that formerly heard and determined the issue was competent to try the subsequent suit or the suit in which the issue is raised.’

13. The issue before the Court of Appeal was a stay of the judgment. In the instant application, the issue is a stay based on the ground of error in computation. The court finds that the Court of Appeal's decision acknowledged that the payable sum was not established, as the judgment left the computation to the respondent. The respondent appeared to have failed to compute, leading the applicant to compute.

14. The court, on perusal of the annexed computation comparison by the respondent finds material difference which, if true, would amount to unjust enrichment of the applicant. The court is guided in exercise of judicial authority by Article 159 of the Constitution –

‘159. Judicial authority

(1)Judicial authority is derived from the people and vests in, and shall be exercised by, the courts and tribunals established by or under this Constitution.

(2)In exercising judicial authority, the courts and tribunals shall be guided by the following principles—

(a)justice shall be done to all, irrespective of status;

(b)justice shall not be delayed

…

d)justice shall be administered without undue regard to procedural technicalities; and(e)the purpose and principles of this Constitution shall be protected and promoted.’

15. The court, taking into account that it is to dispense substantive justice and more, as the enforcement of the judgment is under its jurisdiction, having noted under the ruling dated 15th May 2026 that the petitioner could file for an Order of Mandamus. No way can it be said to be a good judgment for the court to allow enforcement of an erroneous decretal sum. Justice must be seen to be done. The judgment of the court is not challenged in the instant application, but the subsequent computation. I find in the instant case I would be doing injustice to the respondents by setting aside the order issued on the 21st September 2026. The order only temporarily stayed the execution of the certificate order against the Government on the basis that, prima facie, a case of wrong computation was disclosed. Ideally, the trial court ought to have, in the judgment, computed the amount, and the failure to do so left a gap which the court is called upon to address.

16. In the upshot, I hold that I have original jurisdiction on the computation under the judgment, which has not been the subject of the Court of Appeal decision. I hold that I have a duty to right the wrong in the computation to avoid unjust enrichment of the judgment holder.

On the merits of the application dated 27th July 2026.

17. The respondent opposed the application . The respondent submits that Rule 74(1) of the ELRC Rules 2024 and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides that review is strictly restricted to a party:

"Any person considering himself aggrieved by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed, but from which no appeal has been preferred... may apply for a review of judgment..."

18. The Respondent submitted that the Applicant’s own admission of appeal at Paragraphs 9, 10, 21, and 51 of their Further Affidavit and Submissions, the Applicant explicitly admits lodging a Notice of Appeal against the Judgment of 25th September 2025 and filing a substantive Record of Appeal. In National Bank of Kenya Ltd v. Ndung'u Njau [1997] eKLR, the Court of Appeal established that once a party files a Notice of Appeal, they have preferred an appeal as a matter of law, completely extinguishing the trial court's jurisdiction to entertain a Review Application.

19. The applicant submitted that the issue of computation was not before the Court of Appeal. I perused the judgment of the court and found the issue of computation was left to the respondent. The trial court did not compute the amount. I find that the amount payable is a matter for the original court to determine.

20. The court, in the interest of justice and to ensure fairness in the execution process , being that the correct decretal sum is established, proceeds to do so.

21. The respondent did delay in the computation, but that did not amend the judgment to effect that it was the respondent /applicant to compute. The proper thing was for the respondent/judgment holder to compute and have the court adopt his computation as a decree of the court, but instead obtained a decree based on his computation without the court's approval. The figures in the decree are not a judgment of the court.

22. The applicant has belatedly computed. The respondent on general damages states that the gross salary at exit of the petitioner was KSHS. 450145 X3 toward awrad of Kshs. 1,350,435. The applicant on the item submits - THAT regarding General Damages, the Court awarded three (3) months' gross salary. The figure of KES 1,460,000.00 aligns with my actual gross remuneration package, and the Respondents' proposed figure of KES 1,350,435.00 is an attempt to understate my lawful entitlement.

23. I find the petitioner is not candid as he does not deny the gross salary as stated by the Respondent. Even his own calculation is mathematically wrong as it would amount to 1,320,000. I adopt the figure by the respondent for 3 months' gross salary as general damages Kshs. 1,350,435.

24. In respect of the computation of the acting allowance arrears, the Petitioner, tabulates the same as Kshs. 2,778,029.

25. The Respondent’s case is that the Petitioner tabulates the same based on the difference in gross salary between NACC Job Grade 2 and NACC Job Grade 3, using the Level 6 salary band. He doesn't deduct the 46,186.20 paid monthly as acting allowance. Per the Petitioner’s calculation under this item, the amount due is Kshs. 2,778,029/-. According to the Respondent, the court ordered arrears in respect of acting allowance, not a gross salary. They tabulate acting allowance arrears taking into account the acting allowance actually paid, which was 15% of basic salary, against the 20% of basic salary recommended by the PSC. The Respondent contend that the amount paid as acting allowance was Kshs. 923,720, while the amount that should have been paid is Kshs. 1,260,811. They therefore tabulate the difference as Kshs. 337,091.

26. In the judgment delivered on 25th September 2025, on the claim for acting allowance arrears, the Court held as follows:

“Acting Allowance

It is not in dispute that the Petitioner was appointed to the position of Acting Deputy Director, Finance and Administration with effect from 15/12/2020 by a letter dated 14/12/2020. In terms of the said letter, the Petitioner was to be paid an Acting Allowance at the rate of 15% of his basic salary per month for the duration he was to remain in the acting capacity. By a letter dated 12/1/2021, the Petitioner was to be paid Kshs. 46,186.20 per month being 15% of his basic monthly salary of Kshs. 307,908.00 per month. It is not in dispute that the Petitioner confirmed to have received the said amount over and above his gross monthly salary until the acting position was stopped by a letter dated 18/8/2022 with effect from 1/8/2022. The Respondent produced a memo from the CEO to the Head Human Resources and Administration, communicating a decision of the Board to stop departmental heads of finance and Administration coordination and support and policy monitoring and research be reassigned within the Divisions of the said departments and the Heads of the affected Divisions report to the CEO. The resolution by the Board is dated 27/8/2022 and was communicated to the Heads including the Petitioner on 1' November 2022. The Respondent submitted that the stoppage of the Acting Allowance was in line with the Board resolution and that the claims by the Petitioner lacks merit.

The other contention by the Petitioner is that the Acting Allowance ought to have been in line with the Public Service Commission Regulations being the difference in salary between the substantive position held by the officer and the salary payable to the acting position held. The Petitioner claims the difference not paid to him in line with the public service regulations as set out in prayer b of the amended petition in the sum of Kshs. 6.815,294,00.

The Petitioner submitted that failure to pay the full acting allowance violated Article 41(2)(a) of the Constitution, section 34 of the Public Service Act,2017, and section 3.4 of the Human Resource Policies and Procedure Manual and the Human Resources Administration Policies and Regulation 2009 on Acting appointments.

The Respondent had no answer for the failure to implement the law and regulation in respect of the acting capacity by the Petitioner. The court finds that for the period not in dispute when the Petitioner was in acting capacity in respect of the position of Deputy Director Finance and Administration being 1st February 2022 up to and including 1st August 2022, the Petitioner was entitled to payment of Acting Allowance as stated by the Public Service Regulations and the Respondent's own Human Resource manual and Regulations. Accordingly, the Petitioner is to be paid the said amount less the amount received monthly during the period at Kshs. 46,186.20 per month. The difference payable for the period to be computed accordingly.

The Petitioner has failed to prove that he remained in acting capacity after

1st August 2022 and that claim lacks merit.”

27. In the final orders, on acting allowance, the Court held that:

“In the final analysis the court enters the following judgment in favour of the

Petitioner against the Respondent:

(b)Salary arrears in respect of Acting Allowance for the period 19th December 2020 to 31st July 2022 for the position of Deputy Director Finance and Administration.”

28. The matter that the Court must determine, therefore, is the rate of acting allowance as prescribed by the PSC Regulations and the Respondent's own Human Resource manual and Regulations. The Respondent indicates that the acting allowance rate is 20% of an officer’s basic salary, and admits that it paid the Petitioner 15% acting allowance during the period when he was appointed Acting Deputy Director Finance. It therefore admits that there is a difference of 5% of basic salary that the Petitioner is entitled to.

29. The Court agrees with the Respondent’s position and notes that the Public Service Commission recommended in its Human Resource Policies and Procedures Manual for the Public Service 2016, which would have been applicable at the material time, the rate of acting allowance as 20% of basic salary. Per the Petitioner’s payslips attached to the Respondent’s Replying Affidavit sworn on 7th April 2025, the Petitioner’s basic salary upto June 2021 was Kshs. 307, 908/-. 20% of this basic salary is 61,581.60. Less the Kshs. 46,186.20 already paid (15%) is Kshs. 15,395.40. For the period 19th December 2020 to June 2021 (6 months 13 days) is Kshs. 92,372.40 + Kshs. 6,671.34 is Kshs. 99,043.74. From July 2021 to July 2022, the basic salary was Kshs. 318,304/-. Applying this basic salary, 20% of the same is 63,660/-. Less 46,186.20, is 17,474.60. For the 12 months period is Kshs. 209,695.20. Per my calculation, the summation of the 5% difference for the entire period awarded in the judgment is Kshs. 308,738.94. The Respondent calculates the difference as Kshs. 337,091/-, hence I award this amount under the head of acting allowance arrears.

30. I am obliged to state that the Petitioner’s tabulations, which comprise the difference in gross salaries for the two job grades NACC 3 and 2, are plainly wrong. The court's judgment awarded the difference in acting allowances, not the difference in gross salaries.

31. For gratuity, the parties agree that the Petitioner is entitled to 31% of basic salary for NACC Grade 2, less the 31% paid based on basic salary for NACC Grade 3. The Respondent does not dispute the Petitioner’s tabulation of this difference at Kshs. 668,989/-, save to state that the same was offset against the loan facility owed to the Respondent by the Petitioner. According to the Respondent this amount is already paid.

32. The above tabulation is consistent with the Court’s finding on gratuity in the judgment delivered on 25th September 2025, where it held:

“Gratuity

The contract of employment between the parties provided for terminal gratuity calculated at the rate of 31% of the basic salary for each completed year of service. The claim for unpaid gratuity is limited to the last 3 years contract and is to be calculated taking into account the basic salary which ought to have been for the acting position of Acting Deputy Director of finance between the period 15th December 2020 upto 31st July 2022. The arrear gratuity payable to be computed accordingly.”

33. In the orders, the Court held that:

“In the final analysis the court enters the following judgment in favour of the

Petitioner against the Respondent:

(c)Gratuity arrears at 31% of earned salary per year from the period 19th

December 2020 to 319' July 2022.”

34. It is evident from the Petitioner’s payslips (the last item under deductions) attached to both the Petitioner and the Respondent’s Replying Affidavit sworn on 7th April 2025, that the Petitioner was indeed servicing a loan facility with Hazina Sacco. As at January 2022, the loan balance appears to have been Kshs. 3,591.450/-.

35. Is the Respondent authorized to set off the Petitioner’s gratuity against the outstanding loan?

36. In the case of JAVAN WERE MBANGO V H. YOUNG & CO. (EA) LTD [2012] KEELRC 24 (KLR) the Court, faced with similar circumstances, held as follows:

“In making payments to any employee, an employer must ensure that all the statutory deduction due are removed from the gross pay. And employer is therefore in law entitled to make a deduction of any amount which is authorised by any written law for the time being in force, collective agreement, wage determination, court order or arbitration award; This Court is guided by provision of Section 19 of the Employment Act.

Employees who out of their own free will join employees Sacco do so by virtue of their employment and do authorize the employer to make deductions from their salaries to the Sacco for their welfare and for the collective good of all. An employee is therefore stopped from claiming that once their employment is terminated, there are owed all their savings without taking into consideration the collective agreement under their Sacco and or cooperative society. Where an employee has enjoyed a loan facility from the collective kitty he is equally under a duty to make good any dues where his relationship with the collective is severed by virtue of the termination of his relationship with the principal.

At the time of termination, the claimant owed his Wanachuma Cooperative savings and Credit Society and amount of Kshs. 231,912.00 which was due. In computing terminal dues, the employer was under a duty as under Section 19 of the Act to make this deduction.”

37. The Claimant does not deny owing the stated amounts to Hazina Sacco, hence denying the set-off would amount to unjust enrichment of the Petitioner.

Disposal

38. The application dated 29th July 2026 is spent. The ex parte order was pending the determination of the application dated 27th July 2026, and it thus expired pursuant to this ruling. The application dated 27th July 2026 is determined as follows-

39. The application for review is allowed and the certificate of order against the Government is reviewed. The court holds that the gratuity amount was lawfully set off for a loan held by the decree holder at exit. The computation by the decree holder is set aside and substituted as follows-

a. 3 months' gross salary as general damages Kshs. 1,350,435.

b. salary arrears in acting allowance - Kshs. 337,091.

c. Acting arrears arrears – already paid.

d. Interest on a and b at court rates from the date of judgment (25th September 2025) till payment in full.

e. Costs of the suit to be borne by the respondent, which the parties have agreed on Kshs 530,000/- as pay to party costs.

The above are held as the monies outstanding as payment to the decree holder under the judgment.

40. The respondent /applicant delayed in computation and is not deserving of costs of the application. Each party to bear its own costs in the 2 applications.

41. It is so Ordered.

DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

JEMIMAH KELI,

JUDGE.

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Court Assistant: Otieno

Applicant/Decree Holder- Masaku

Respondent- Kioko

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder