Background
ALPHONSE NZIOKA MUTIO
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
ALPHONSE NZIOKA MUTIO
Paragraph 1 →I have carefully considered the proceedings in this Cause, the Affidavit of Protest, the witness statements, the evidence tendered before this court and the respective submissions filed by Advocates for the Parties and in my view, the pertinent issue for my determination is whether the protest herein is merited.
Paragraph 17 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS SUCCESSION CAUSE NO. 391 OF 2013
-VERSUS-
1. ALPHONSE NZIOKA MUTIO
2. FERDINAND MATILU MUTIO ......... PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS
RULING
1. This ruling is on the Protestor/Applicant’s Affidavit of Protest dated 12th February 2024. Basically, it is in opposition to the Amended Summons for confirmation of Grant dated 18th January 2024 brought by the Petitioners/Respondents. The Petitioners had proposed to have the Estate comprising the below listed properties be registered in the names of the Petitioners: -
i. Kalama/Nzuini/1475
ii. Kalama/Kitini/1704 measuring 1.9 Ha
iii. Konza Commercial Plot No. 416 Kwa Mautio – 30 x 80
iv. Konza Commercial Plot No. 1009 measuring 2 Acres
v. Konza Machakos/Konza North Block 1/382
vi. Konza Plot No. 524 measuring 2 Acres
vii. Konza Agricultural Plot No. 1549 measuring 10.8 Acres
viii. Membership share No. 527 Konza Ranching & Farming Society.
2. The protestor advanced the following grounds: -
a) That on 16/11/1987 during the lifetime of the deceased herein, her husband one PATRICK KIVINDYO MUASYA purchased land together with shares in membership No. 527 at Konza Ranching and Farming Co-operative Society and should, therefore, be excluded from the distribution to the Petitioners.
b) That among the witnesses of the said sale were the sons of the deceased namely Theobard M. Mutio (now deceased) and Matilu Mutio the 2nd Petitioner herein. After the Society was advised and or informed about the sale, it addressed a letter to the seller in cognizance of the change of ownership. The said letter was further confirmed by the area Chief vide his letter dated 10/04/2012.
c) That from the above it is abundantly clear that the protestor is entitled to the transfer of the said land and shares by the representatives of the deceased herein.
d) That the Petitioners as personal representatives of the deceased herein have never been willing to take out letters of administration in order to be in a position to transfer the land and shares to the Protestor’s deceased husband and this constrained him to cite them to do so. This Petition was filed after the Protestor cited the Petitioners in Succession Cause No. 479 of 2012.
3. In opposing the affidavit of protest, the Petitioners sought for dismissal of the protest by contending that the deceased herein never sold any land and or shares in Konza Ranching Co-operative Society as claimed by the Protestor.
4. The protest was heard by way of viva voce evidence. The Protestor was the sole witness while the Petitioners/Respondents called three witnesses in support of their respective cases.
Protestor/Applicant’s Case
5. PW1was Monicah Mwikali Muasya, the Protester adopted her witness statement dated 09/4/2024 as her evidence in chief and produced a Sale Agreement dated 16/11/1987 as her PExt.1. She stated that she was the wife to Patrick Muasya (now deceased). That she knew Mutio Mutwii Kamwilu, the deceased in this cause and that her deceased husband bought land No. 527 and the title to it came in No. 382. They only knew where the land is but the family of the deceased herein has not released the same to them. She stated that a member of the Mutio (deceased) family disputes that the deceased did not sell shares and that this was not true.
6. On cross-examination, the Protestor stated that the Sale Agreement is for long ago (1987) and that it was her first time to come to court over the same. She stated that Doctor Mwanzi Mulandi (now deceased) was their witness. That they bought land from the deceased. It was her late husband who was dealing with the deceased. She didn’t know the terms they agreed on. She didn’t read the agreement but she signed it. She stated that the owner (deceased herein) was given cash. She was not there when the money was paid. The person who received the money was Mutio. She confirmed that Theobard Mutio was the son of the deceased. She didn’t know who received the money. When they were signing the sale agreement, the sons of the deceased were not there. It was her, her late husband, the deceased herein and Doctor Mulandi. That the two sons of the deceased were present when they were dealing with her late husband. She didn’t know whether transfer was done. She knew the process of transferring land at Konza Ranch. For now, she didn’t know which document is normally filled. They found the agent and the three of them signed. She saw the deceased signing the agreement. She didn’t know who altered the agreement. The one she signed did not have alterations or cancellations.
7. In re-examination, the Protestor stated that the land was bought at Kshs.69,000/=. When they signed the agreement, the deceased and his wife were present. She didn’t know the name of the wife to the deceased. The wife didn’t sign anywhere. She was not present when the other two persons signed. Her late husband had a copy of the agreement. She was not present when the money was given but her late husband told her he had paid. Her husband and the deceased had no disagreements. Mutio (deceased) placed a finger impress and not a signature.
This marked the close of the Protestor’s case.
Petitioners/Respondents’ Case
8. DW1 was Ferdinant Matilu Mutio (2nd Petitioner) adopted his witness statement dated 11/4/2024 as his evidence in chief. He admitted knowing the deceased herein but denied knowing the Protestor. He denied knowledge of the Sale Agreement (PExt.1). He admitted that his name was in the said agreement and that the signature resembles his. He denied that his father, the deceased herein received any money from Patrick Kivindyo Muasya, He denied witnessing any sale agreement of the shares of his father. He stated that his father was known as MUTIO MUTWII KAMWILU whereas the purported sale agreement shows him with only two names as MUTIO MUTUI. His father didn’t know how to read and write. All his father’s plots at Konza Ranch have the name of MUTIO MUTWII and referred to documents 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 and other documents on the Petitioners’ list of documents which were produced as Petitioners exhibits DExt.2- 10 respectively. He went on to state that there was a dispute between his late father and Patrick Muasya because his father had not sold the land to Patrick as per the letter dated 12/12/1995 (Dext.6) in which Patrick had gone to claim the parcel. He stated that the deceased herein passed on in 2004. The Chief’s letter dated 10/4/2012 is not from their location. The form for attempted transfer of shares (DExt.10) is undated and incomplete. The witness maintained that the deceased did not sell the land to the Protestor’s deceased husband.
9. On cross-examination, he confirmed that the letter dated 12/9/1995 was from Konza Ranching and Framing Co-operative Society to his late father but he couldn’t see the names of his father properly in the letter but the name read “Mutio Mutui”. Konza had requested that the title deed was to be kept at Konza because someone was claiming the land. He denied that the deceased and Patrick discussed the land. They met the letter in court and did not have any document from Konza. In the year 2012, Patrick sued them for not transferring shares. The transfer Form (DMFI.10) emerged when they went for mediation. He denied having the title deed. The agreement was produced when they went to the Chief’s Office. He stated that his father (deceased herein) was putting a finger print. He didn’t know if the finger print in the agreement belongs to his father. He denied that the names in the agreement were for his brother. His brother is Theobard. He didn’t have an answer as to why the issue involved the same plot. He stated that the signature in the agreement resembles his in the identity card. He denied going to the DC’s office and that it is only the parents who did. The issue was involving Patrick and the land.
10. On re-examination, he stated that they filed the Succession Cause on their own. There are available titles for the deceased. They are yet to receive title for land Konza North/1/382 and whoever went to claim the same did not have any document.
11. DW2 was Muithyi Mutisya, the Senior Chief of Kalama Location, Kalama Sub-county within Machakos County. He testified that he knew the deceased in this Cause who was a resident from his location. He knew the deceased’s home and members of his family too. He adopted his witness statement dated 11/4/2024 as his evidence in chief. He confirmed that Mutio Mutwii is deceased. He referred to a letter dated 11/2/2013 that was written by him and produced the same as DExt.8. He also referred to another letter dated 10/4/2012 written by a Chief of Kyangala Location, Kalima Division, Mutuyu village. The letter came about when there was a dispute in the estate of the deceased. According to the letter, it appeared to have been source outside his location whereas the deceased was from his area. The said letter was unprocedural as it sourced for beneficiaries outside his area. The letter he originated is genuine on the beneficiaries of the estate. He stated that the dispute was about the sale of shares and 10 acres of land. He explained the process of disposing of any property that belong to the Konza Ranch and stated that there is a Form which is between the seller and buyer of the property which they take to their home area. Normally the seller takes the Form to the respective Assistant Chief who verifies the details as per the Form. The Form is usually already filled in by the time it leaves the Ranch. After the Assistant Chief verifies the same, it escalates to the respective area Chief who verifies further on all the details and if there is no objection, the Form is returned to the Ranch for the necessary action. The sample Form was produced as DExt.9. The details to be verified are the buyer, description of the property being sold and name of the buyer. The Form has a component of a family member who has to be a witness to the transaction. The Chief and Assistant Chief have to sign too. They don’t keep the signed copies but keep the records of all the details of the clients who visit their office. He denied that the deceased Mutio Mutwii Kamwilu and Patrick Kavindyu visited their office. Patrick only visited their office when a dispute arose and he needed information to file for succession. The purchaser/Protestor never visited their office on the matter. He further stated that when a seller had filled the Form, they would request for a consent from his family members to affirm the sale.
12. On cross-examination, he confirmed that there is a Form filled by the buyer and seller which is brought to their office for verification. The Form is brought after the sale and buying agreement has been initiated. When the two have agreed. The purpose of the Form is for either approval or disapproval of the sale. The Form is headed; “APPLICATION FORM FOR TRANSFER OF SHARES” and it comes from the Konza Ranch. He maintained that after signing the Form as the Chief, the same is not kept anywhere. The Form requires a family member to be present as a witness to the transferor/seller who has to append his/her name and the relationship with the member/ seller. The person witnessing doesn’t have to be a family member. He did have the sale agreement in this matter.
13. In re-examination, DW2 stated that the transfer Form has several purposes. It is meant for the transfer of the property in question. It goes through the Assistant Chief, The Chief and then back to the Konza Ranch whether approved or disapproved. It is not a regular Form. It has to go through all the processes. If it doesn’t the sale is disapproved.
14. DW3 was David Mulo Katu, the Secretary of Konza Ranch Self Help Group for 17 years since 2008. He stated that from 2006 he was a committee member. He was familiar with the sale of and transfer of shares by the members of the Ranch. He referred to a letter dated 30/8/2022 (DEXT.2) which was written by him and another letter dated 5/12/2023 written by the Chairman of the Ranch Mr. Mutangili. He also referred to a letter dated 12/9/1995 which shows that Patrick Kavindyo had lodged a complaint that a title deed for Konza North/1/382 he had bought that land. That where there is a dispute on the sale, the parties are summoned to the office. Where a party has a title deed, they are advised to go to court. The stated that the share that is in dispute is registered in the name of Mutio Mutwii. During his tenure, Patrick Kivindyo had never followed up. The Form before court has no Konza Ranch letter head. When one wants to sell the plot without a title, they fill the Form and verify with the Assistant and the Chief. One goes with the person buying, fill in the Form and provide personal details and identification documents. When the Form is doubtful, they disapprove and do not transfer the property. He stated that the sale agreement (PXEt.1) dated 16/11/1987 is in the name of the deceased’s son. The other family members were not present. He concluded that in 1987, the Ranch had no titles. Where there is a title, they don’t interfere.
15. On cross-examination, DW3 stated that he first saw the sale agreement when he was called by his lawyer the previous month. The seller therein is Mutio Mutwii whom he is related to as they are from the same clan. He stated that the Konza Ranch Form has a letter head. The Form looked fake. He insisted that where the properties have titles, they don’t involve themselves. The letter dated 12/9/1995 is addressing a complaint by Danson Mbuvi Mutavi who was a manager of the society. It is copied to Edward Mwinzi advising him to keep his title in his custody until further notice. Edward was a clerk in charge of storage of titles. Patrick Kavindyo Muasya who was also a member of the society lodged the complaint. By the time the sale agreement herein was done, the titles had not come out. They came out in 1992. He stated that parties fill in the transfer Form and bring the sale agreement. He denied handling any dispute between Mutio Mutwii and Patrick Kivindyo Muasya.
16. On re-examination, he stated that the letter dated 12/9/1995 was following a complaint lodged by Patrick and he was to follow up on the same. That in this case, the complainant after lodging the complaint, he disappeared. The Form referred to is for transfer of shares not physical land. What is being sold has to be specified. He stated that Mutio Mutwii and Patrick were both members of the society and they knew the procedure of buying shares. He maintained too that Patrick never went to their offices to present the Forms for transfer of shares.
This marked the close of the Petitioners/Respondents’ case.
Analysis and Determination
17. I have carefully considered the proceedings in this Cause, the Affidavit of Protest, the witness statements, the evidence tendered before this court and the respective submissions filed by Advocates for the Parties and in my view, the pertinent issue for my determination is whether the protest herein is merited.
18. According to rule 2 of the Probate and Administration Rules a “protester” is defined as “a person who has filed a protest under rule 40 (6) against the confirmation of a grant”.
19. Rule 40(6) referred to is of the same Probate and Administration Rules and it says thus:
“Any person wishing to object to the proposed confirmation of a grant shall file in the cause in duplicate at the principal registry an affidavit of protest in Form 10 against such confirmation stating the grounds of his objection”.
20. In short, the Protestor claims undisclosed and undescribed land together with shares in membership No. 527 at Konza Ranching and Farming Co-operative Society Limited from the deceased’s estate herein which she alleges were purchased from the deceased by the Protestor’s husband one Patrick Kivindyo Muasya (now deceased).
21. The Protester produced in evidence as PEXt.1 a handwritten piece of paper which she contends was the agreement of the purported sale between the deceased and Patrick Kavindyo Muasya, the late Protestor’s husband. I have keenly perused the purported sale agreement (“hereinafter referred to as “the agreement”) and the Affidavit of Protest and I note and analyse the following: -
• The buyer is Mutio Mutui and NOT Mutio Mutwii Kamwilu the deceased in this matter. No evidence was led by the Protestor to demonstrate that the two different names refer to one and the same person who is the deceased in this Cause.
• The agreement does not disclose how many shares of the deceased were allegedly transferred to the Purported purchaser contrary to what is pleaded in the affidavit of protest.
• Similarly, the agreement only refers to 10 acres of land situated at Konza Ranching Society but does not describe the exact land.
• At paragraph 2 of the Affidavit of protest, the Protestor avers that during the lifetime of the deceased, her husband purchased from him land but fails to describe which land despite the Protestor filing this protest after considering the properties listed in the Amended Summons for Confirmation of Grant dated 18th January 2024 forming the estate of the deceased. It is not clear which of the deceased’s Konza properties listed the Protestor is interested in.
• The agreement is faced with cancellations and alterations which the Protestor failed to explain, it being her own exhibit. She in fact stated on cross-examination that the one she signed did not have alterations or cancellations. Does this mean that the Protestor was disowning her own exhibit and as such, the same should not be considered by this court; Does it also mean that what the Protestor has presented before court is not what she alleged was the agreement she signed;
• Whereas the Protestor stated in re-examination that Mutio (deceased) placed a finger impress and not a signature, the agreement does not seem to show a finger impress of the deceased and if the Protestor is considering what appears against the name Mutio Mutui as a finger impress of the deceased herein, then she was under duty to prove and verify the same by calling for fingerprint database evidence on the same from the relevant Government departments who are custodians of the same for all adult Kenyan Citizens of the Republic of Kenya who are issued with National Identity cards including the deceased herein. This she failed to do.
• The Protestor has not adduced evidence to confirm that in deed, the name of the deceased and his shares were transferred to her late husband Patrick Kavindyu Muasya on the same day of the agreement being 16.11.1987 as indicated in the agreement.
• The agreement shows that the alleged purchase price of Kshs.60,000/- was received by T. M Mutio who is not the deceased. During cross examination, the protestor alleged that she was present when the agreement was executed. However, the part of the agreement where Kshs.60, 000/- was paid to T.M. Mutio was executed on a different day (20/11/1987 and 11/1/88) only signed by T.M. Mutio and no other witnesses. On cross exam the protestor confirmed that she doesn't know who was paid and doesn't know how payments were made.
• Part of the agreement shows that the purchase price of Kshs.69,000/=, was admittedly paid to a person (T. M. Mutio) who is not the deceased. No evidence has been tendered to show that the said person had authority to receive payment on behalf of the deceased.
22. From the evidence adduced, the deceased denied selling any land and his shares at Konza Ranch as alleged while he was alive. When the deceased contested the sale, the alleged purchaser lodged a complaint at the Konza Ranch. The deceased received a letter from Konza dated 12/9/1995 informing him of the complaint. Interestingly, according to the evidence of the Secretary of Konza Ranch (DW3), this complaint was never followed up since 1995 until the demise of the deceased herein.
23. Whereas the alleged sale agreement dated 16/11/1987 states that the vendor had transferred his shares at Konza Ranch on the same date, the Secretary of Konza Ranch stated that no transfer documents were ever filled with the ranch and the alleged purchaser never took any steps in court to enforce the purchase.
24. Accordingly, on the basis of the foregoing evidence, it is my considered view that the estate cannot be bound by an alleged transaction in which consideration did not pass to the deceased. In another way, an estate cannot be compelled to honour a contract whose consideration was diverted to a third party in the absence of proof of authority by the deceased. To hold otherwise would be to sanction speculation against the property of a deceased person.
25. It is trite that the Jurisdiction of the Probate Court in Succession proceedings is limited to:-
• Identification of beneficiaries; and
• Distribution of the free property of the deceased.
26. The above jurisdiction does not extend to determination of contested ownership claims by third parties. Therefore, the Protester’s claim cannot be determined in this succession matter. The Protester recourse if any would be to file a substantive suit against the Estate in a Civil Suit if she so wishes. See In re Estate of Alice Mumbua Mutua (Deceased) [2017] KEHC 8289 (KLR).
27. I agree with submissions by counsel for the Petitioners that the Probate & Administration proceedings are not the correct avenue for the Protester to seek her claim of land and shares. The Law of Succession Act deals with the succession of the deceased and the administration of the deceased’s Estate. There is no dispute in this matter over the beneficiaries of the deceased’s estate and how the estate should be distributed among the beneficiaries. The beneficiaries of the deceased have agreed on the free property of the deceased and the mode of distribution of the estate.
28. I am also not persuaded that the Protestor on the basis of my finding hereinabove can have any ground to claim land or shares from the deceased’s estate herein.
Disposition
29. In the premises, I make the following orders: -
a) The Affidavit of Protest dated 12th February 2024 has no merit and it is dismissed with costs to the Petitioners/Respondents assessed at Kshs.30,000/= which costs shall go to the Estate of the deceased in this Cause.
b) In order to avoid any further delay in the disposal of this Cause, the Amended Summons for Confirmation of Grant dated 18th January 2024 is hereby confirmed and the deceased’s estate is to be distributed according to the family agreement on distribution under paragraph 6 of the affidavit in support of the Amended Summons for Confirmation of Grant.
c) The matter will be mentioned after six (6) months from the date hereof for an update on the progress of transmission and distribution of the estate.
It is hereby so ordered.
RULING DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED ON VIRTUAL TEAMS AT MACHAKOS THIS 7TH OCTOBER 2026
NOEL I. ADAGI
JUDGE