Background
This is an appeal against the Judgment of the court in Kangundo Magistrate’s Court Succession Cause No. E004 of 2024, in the Matter of the Estate of John Ndambuki Kibinda (Deceased).
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
This is an appeal against the Judgment of the court in Kangundo Magistrate’s Court Succession Cause No. E004 of 2024, in the Matter of the Estate of John Ndambuki Kibinda (Deceased).
Paragraph 1 →A partial consent was reached by the parties and adopted by the court, where Robert Ngao Ndambuki and George Mutunga Ndambuki were appointed as administrators representing the 1st house and the 2nd house respectively. The parties further agreed that the only issue for determination was whether Matungulu/Sengani/1624 formed part of the deceased’s estate.
Paragraph 20 →I find that the deceased’s settlement arrangements are a material factor to be considered in distribution, but it cannot be decided in the absence of some beneficiaries.
Paragraph 89 →The High Court considered whether Matungulu/Sengani/1624 formed part of John Ndambuki Kibinda’s estate; whether the magistrate could allocate it exclusively to the first house on the evidence; whether the magistrate honoured the parties’ partial consent on…
John Ndambuki Kibinda died intestate on 2 August 1983. Robert Ngao Ndambuki petitioned for administration in 2023, initially listing two parcels. Protesters asserted that the deceased had two houses, that a third parcel, Matungulu/Sengani/1682, was omitted,…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS
FAMILY APPEAL NO. E016 OF 2025
PRISCILLA NTHOKI MUSELA ……………..……..……………………..1ST APPELLANT
GEORGE MUTUNGA NDAMBUKI………………………………..……..2ND APPELLANT
JOHN DANSON KIBINDA………………………………………..……….3RD APPELLANT
BONIFACE MUTISO NDAMBUKI……………………………………….4TH APPELLANT
VICTORIA NGALI KIBINDA……………………………………………..5TH APPELLANT
THOMAS KIVINDA NDAMBUKI………………………………………..6TH APPELLANT
VERSUS
ROBERT NGAO NDAMBUKI…………………………………….…………RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. This is an appeal against the Judgment of the court in Kangundo Magistrate’s Court Succession Cause No. E004 of 2024, in the Matter of the Estate of John Ndambuki Kibinda (Deceased).
2. The deceased, John Ndambuki Kibinda, died intestate on 2nd August 1983 at Kangundo Hospital.
3. On 13/12/2023, the Respondent, Robert Ngao Ndambuki, petitioned the Kangundo Law Court for a grant of letters of administration intestate in respect of the deceased's estate. He described himself as a son of the deceased.
4. In the Petition and accompanying affidavit, the persons stated to have survived the deceased were Mukonyo Ndambuki, described as his wife; David Muasa Ndambuki, his son; Robert Ngao Ndambuki, his son; and Agnes Mutinda Ndambuki, his daughter.
5. The Petition initially disclosed two assets forming part of the estate, namely Machakos/Nguluni/352 and Matungulu/Sengani/1624, with an estimated total value of Kshs. 2,000,000.
6. The grant of letters of administration was issued to the Respondent on 27/3/2024 listing the properties known as Matungulu/ Nguluni/352 and Matungulu/Sengani/1624.
7. A Protest was subsequently filed by the 3rd Protestor, being a son of the deceased, averring that the said grant was obtained fraudulently, by misrepresentation that he was a son of the deceased, whereas children from his two houses survived the deceased; the Respondent and his siblings were not children of the deceased.
8. The protesters stated that two houses survived the deceased. The first house comprised Elizabeth Mukui Ndambuki, the deceased's first wife, and her children, while the second house comprised Tabitha Syokwia Ndambuki, the deceased's second wife and her children.
9. The protesters further stated that the deceased left the following parcels of land as part of his estate: Machakos/nguluni/352, Matungulu/Sengani/1624 and Matungulu/Sengani/1682.
10. The protesters alleged that the Respondent had failed to disclose Matungulu/Sengani/1682 as an asset of the estate when petitioning for the grant, having disclosed only Machakos/nguluni/352 and Matungulu/Sengani/16.
11. On that basis, the protesters sought the revocation or annulment of the grant issued to the Respondent and prayed that the true beneficiaries be allowed to appoint administrators of the deceased's estate.
12. In response to the protest, the Respondent filed a replying affidavit sworn on 18th November 2024. He stated that the deceased had married two wives, namely Elizabeth Mukui Ndambuki, the 1st wife, and Tabitha Syokwia Ndambuki, the 2nd wife.
13. The Respondent stated that the 1st wife had six daughters and no son and that, in accordance with Kamba customary practices, she married Mukonyo Ndambuki, the Respondent's mother, under an arrangement known as Iweto, for purposes of having male children on behalf of the husband. He stated that the deceased subsequently had three children with Mukonyo Ndambuki, namely Agnes Mutinda Ndambuki, David Muasa Ndambuki and Robert Ngao Ndambuki.
14. The Respondent stated that the deceased had, during his lifetime, distributed his parcels of land amongst the two houses, with each family occupying and utilising the parcel allocated to it.
15. The Respondent stated that Machakos/Nguluni/352 was allocated to and occupied by the 1st house. He further stated that Matungulu/Sengani/1624 had been gifted to the 1st wife by her father, Mbelenzu, but was registered in the deceased's name because, at the time, women were traditionally not permitted to hold land in their own names. He maintained that the said parcel did not form part of the deceased's estate, notwithstanding that it was registered in the deceased's name.
16. The Respondent stated that the Protesters were aware of the foregoing arrangement and had never utilised Matungulu/Sengani/1624, which he stated was exclusively occupied and utilised by the 1st house. He further stated that the 2nd house occupied and utilised Matungulu/Sengani/1682.
17. On the alleged concealment of beneficiaries and properties, the Respondent stated that, when petitioning for the grant, he had been advised to file the succession cause in respect of the properties allocated to the 1st house. He subsequently consulted an advocate who advised that the earlier advice was incorrect and that succession ought to be undertaken with the involvement of all beneficiaries and in respect of all the deceased's properties.
18. The Respondent stated that the omission of the Protesters and Matungulu/Sengani/1682 from the Petition was not deliberate, but resulted from lack of proper legal advice. He maintained that the Protesters were children of the deceased and proposed that the Court appoint one administrator from each house and that the matter proceed to distribution.
19. The Protest was heard by way of oral evidence.
20. A partial consent was reached by the parties and adopted by the court, where Robert Ngao Ndambuki and George Mutunga Ndambuki were appointed as administrators representing the 1st house and the 2nd house respectively. The parties further agreed that the only issue for determination was whether Matungulu/Sengani/1624 formed part of the deceased’s estate.
21. PW1, John Danson Kibinda, a son of the deceased, adopted his statement as his evidence. He testified that the deceased owned three parcels of land, namely Machakos/Nguluni/352, Matungulu/Sengani/1624 and Matungulu/Sengani/1682. He produced an official search in respect of Matungulu/Sengani/1624 showing the deceased as the registered proprietor. He stated that the property did not belong to Mbelenzu Mumo, whom he stated was not the father of the deceased’s first wife, Elizabeth Mukui.
22. On cross-examination, PW1 stated that Sengani 1624 was being utilized by Elizabeth Mukui, the 1st wife of the deceased, and that the children of the 1st house were currently utilizing the land. He stated that the 2nd house was not utilizing the land. He disputed the assertion that the land belonged to Mbelenzu Mumo and stated that it had not been given to the 1st wife by her father as a gift, but was his grandfather's land, his grandfather being Kivinda.
23. PW2, Thomas Kivinda Ndambuki, also a son of the deceased, adopted his statement dated 13th December 2024 and the documents filed in support of his case.
24. On cross-examination, PW2 stated that the 2nd House was utilizing parcel No. 1624. He stated that it was not true that the other family was utilizing the other parcels, stating that they were using parcel No. 352, while parcel No. 1682 was not being utilized by the 1st House. He proposed that the land be subdivided among the deceased’s beneficiaries
25. The Respondent called three witnesses. DW1, Robert Ngao Ndambuki, the Administrator, adopted his statement dated 9th January 2025 as his evidence. He testified that Matungulu/Sengani/1624 did not belong to the deceased as it had been given to Elizabeth Mukui, the deceased’s first wife, by her father, Mbelenzu Mumo. He stated that the land had been utilized exclusively by the first wife and that the second house had never utilized the property.
26. On cross-examination, DW1 stated that he had included Matungulu/Sengani/1624 as part of the deceased’s estate and that, according to the official search, the property was registered in the deceased’s name. He further stated that the first wife’s utilization of the land was proof of ownership.
27. DW2, John Kiumba Mbelenzu, testified that he knew the deceased because the deceased had married his aunt, Elizabeth Mukui. He stated that Matungulu/Sengani/1624 had been given to Elizabeth Mukui by her father, Mbelenzu Mumo, and that the property did not belong to the deceased.
28. On cross-examination, DW2 stated that the property had been given to Elizabeth Mukui approximately 70 years earlier. He confirmed that he was not present when the alleged gift was made.
29. DW3, Mary Mumbua Kituu, testified that the deceased was her father and Elizabeth Mukui was her mother. On cross-examination, DW3 stated that Matungulu/Sengani/1624 had been included as part of the deceased’s estate because it was registered in his name.
30. The Protestors submitted that the central issue before the trial court was whether Matungulu/Sengani/1624 formed part of the estate of the deceased, John Ndambuki Kibinda alias Ndambuki Kivinda.
31. They submitted that when the Administrator, Robert Ngao Ndambuki, initially petitioned for the grant, he listed Machakos/Nguluni/352 and Matungulu/Sengani/1624 as assets of the deceased. They submitted that the Administrator had annexed a certificate of official search dated 19th December 2023, which showed the deceased as the registered proprietor of the two properties. They also referred to a subsequent certificate of official search dated 29th May 2024, which similarly showed the deceased as the registered proprietor of Matungulu/Sengani/1624.
32. The Protestors pointed out that none of the Respondent’s witnesses was present when the alleged gift was made and that no documentary evidence had been produced to establish the alleged gift.
33. The Protestors submitted that the deceased had been registered as proprietor of Matungulu/Sengani/1624 in 1991 and that the registration had never been challenged by Elizabeth Mukui during her lifetime or by any person claiming on her behalf.
34. They relied on sections 27, 28 and 143 of the Registered Land Act, Cap. 300 (repealed) and the authorities cited in their submissions on the effect of registration and rectification of the register.
35. On that basis, the Protestors submitted that Matungulu/Sengani/1624 formed part of the estate of the deceased and ought to be available for distribution as part of the estate. They proposed that Machakos/Nguluni/352, measuring 13.912 acres, be shared amongst the beneficiaries of the 1st House, while Matungulu/Sengani/1682, measuring 8.895 acres, and Matungulu/Sengani/1624, measuring 2.223 acres, be shared amongst the beneficiaries of the 2nd House.
36. They relied on the decision cited in their submissions and urged the Court to allow the Protest and distribute the estate in accordance with their proposed mode of distribution.
37. The Petitioner/Administrator submitted that the beneficiaries of the estate were not in dispute and that the parties had agreed that Machakos/nguluni/352 was occupied by the 1st House and should be distributed to that House, while Matungulu/sengani/1624 was occupied by the 2nd House and should be distributed to that House. It was therefore submitted that the only issue requiring determination was the ownership of Machakos/Nguluni/1624 and the House to which it should be distributed
38. The Administrator, Robert Ngao Ndambuki, adopted his statement dated 9th January 2025. He explained that, when filing the succession cause, he had initially been misadvised that succession proceedings could be filed in respect of only the properties in which particular parties were interested. Upon obtaining further legal advice, he was advised that the succession cause ought to encompass the entire estate. He maintained that the failure to include the Protestors was therefore not deliberate but resulted from lack of proper legal advice.
39. The Administrator submitted that the deceased had married two wives, namely Elizabeth Mukui Ndambuki, now deceased, as the 1st wife and Tabitha Syokwia Ndambuki, now deceased, as the 2nd wife. He set out the respective children of the two houses and further stated that the 1st wife, having had six daughters and no son, entered into an Iweto arrangement, through which she married another woman, Mukonyo Ndambuki, in about 1965 for purposes of obtaining male children. He stated that three children were born through that arrangement, namely Agnes Mutinda Ndambuki, David Muasa Ndambuki and Robert Ngao Ndambuki.
40. The Administrator submitted that the children of the 1st House were all named after the deceased and that their mother was equally a beneficiary. He stated that, during the deceased’s lifetime, he had never heard any complaint from the Protestors concerning the ownership or use of the disputed property.
41. On Matungulu/Sengani/1624, the Administrator submitted that although the property remained registered in the deceased’s name, the circumstances surrounding its registration and use supported the position that it had been allocated to the 1st House.
42. The Administrator relied on the fact that Matungulu/Sengani/1624 had been used by the 1st House, while the Protestors had confirmed that they had never used the land. He submitted that the deceased had shared the properties during his lifetime and that the arrangement concerning the disputed property had existed during his lifetime.
43. The Administrator submitted that, even if the Court found that Matungulu/Sengani/1624 formed part of the estate, the property should be distributed to the 1st House, which, according to the Administrator, was the House that had been allocated and exclusively used the property. He argued that disturbing the existing arrangement would create friction between the two Houses and urged the Court to maintain the existing status quo
44. The Administrator consequently prayed that Matungulu/Sengani/1624 be distributed to the 1st House and that the prevailing family arrangement be maintained.
45. Although the court found no evidence proving that parcel 1624 had been gifted to the 1st wife by her father, it nevertheless held that the deceased's established arrangement of allowing the 1st House exclusive use of the parcel, coupled with the 2nd House's failure to challenge that arrangement during his lifetime, justified applying estoppel and confirming the property for the benefit of the 1st House.
46. The Appellants, being dissatisfied with the judgment of the Principal Magistrate’s Court at Kangundo delivered on 26th August 2025 in MCSUCC E004 of 2024, preferred the present appeal against the dismissal of their Protest.
47. The Appellants faulted the trial court for dismissing their Protest and proceeding to distribute the estate without regard to the parties’ consent, appointing Robert Ngao Ndambuki and George Mutunga Ndambuki as Administrators of the 1st and 2nd Houses respectively. They further challenged the trial court’s finding that Ndambuki Mukonyo (deceased) was the first wife of the deceased, contending that the deceased’s first wife was Elizabeth Mukui Ndambuki (deceased), consequently, the trial court erred in treating the children of Ndambuki Mukonyo as the children of Elizabeth Mukui Ndambuki.
48. The Appellants also faulted the trial court for proceeding to distribute the estate without first allowing the Administrators and beneficiaries to file an application for confirmation of the Grant and without obtaining the consent of all the beneficiaries.
49. Further, the Appellants challenged the specific orders relating to the three parcels of land. They took issue with the order that Machakos/nguluni/352 and Matungulu/Sengani/1624 be registered in the name of Robert Ngao Ndambuki on his behalf and in trust for the children of the first wife, Ndambuki Mukonyo. They also challenged the order that Matungulu/Sengani/1682 be registered in the name of John Danson Kibinda, contending that he was not the duly appointed Administrator of the 2nd House.
50. On that basis, the Appellants sought that the appeal be allowed, the judgment delivered on 26th August 2025 be set aside, costs of the appeal be awarded to the Respondent and such other relief as the Court may deem fit.
51. The Appellants submitted that the learned trial Magistrate erred in law and fact in arriving at the decision delivered on 26th August 2025. They contended that the beneficiaries of the estate were not in dispute and that the parties had, by consent dated 9th June 2025, agreed on the appointment of Robert Ngao Ndambuki as Administrator for the 1st House and George Mutunga Ndambuki as Administrator for the 2nd House. It was their submission that the consent was material to the determination of the dispute and ought to have been given due consideration in the distribution of the estate.
52. The Appellants further submitted that the trial court erred in determining that Matungulu/Sengani/1624 ought to be distributed to the 1st House. They challenged the finding that the deceased had settled his two houses on their respective parcels of land and argued that the evidence on record did not establish that the deceased had intended parcel 1624 to exclusively belong to the 1st House. They contended that the fact that the 1st House had been utilising the property did not, without more, establish ownership or entitlement to the exclusion of the beneficiaries of the 2nd House.
53. The Appellants also challenged the trial court’s reliance on the doctrine of estoppel and the decision in Re Estate of the Late Siwanyang Ngilotochi (Deceased) (2021) eKLR. They submitted that the circumstances of the present case were distinguishable and that the court ought not to have used the long-standing occupation of parcel 1624 by the 1st House as a basis for altering the manner in which the estate was to be distributed. They maintained that the registered ownership of the property remained in the name of the deceased and that the property therefore formed part of his estate available for distribution.
54. It was further submitted that the trial court erred in directing that Matungulu/Sengani/1682 be registered in the name of John Danson Kibinda on his behalf and for the children of the 2nd House, rather than recognising the arrangement agreed upon by the parties concerning the administration of the estate. The Appellants contended that the court thereby went beyond the issue that had been placed before it and effectively determined the mode of distribution of the estate.
55. The Appellants urged the appellate court to allow the appeal, set aside the judgment and orders of the trial court dated 26th August 2025, and permit the beneficiaries to proceed with the confirmation and distribution of the estate in accordance with the Law of Succession Act and the applicable law. They also prayed for the costs of the appeal.
56. The Respondent submitted that the transmission of the estate had already been effected and that each beneficiary had received their share. The Respondent acknowledged that, as a first appeal, this Court is required to reconsider and re-evaluate the evidence on record and draw its own conclusions, while bearing in mind that it did not hear the witnesses testify.
57. The Respondent submitted that there was no dispute concerning the properties left by the deceased or the beneficiaries entitled to the estate. It was submitted that, by consent, Machakos/Nguluni/352 was allocated to the 1st House while Matungulu/Sengani/1624 was allocated to the 2nd House, leaving the ownership and distribution of Matungulu/Sengani/1682 as the only issue for determination. The Respondent maintained that the evidence of the parties and their witnesses established that the deceased had settled the two houses on their respective parcels during his lifetime. According to the Respondent, the 1st House was settled on Machakos/Nguluni/352 together with the Iweto and her children, while the 1st wife and her children were permitted to exclusively utilise Matungulu/Sengani/1624. The 2nd House was settled on Matungulu/Sengani/1682 and had never utilised parcel 1624 during the deceased’s lifetime.
58. The Respondent submitted that the Appellants’ evidence confirmed that the 2nd House had never utilised Matungulu/Sengani/1624 and that the parcel had been occupied exclusively by the 1st House. It was argued that the trial court was therefore correct in finding that the deceased had distributed his properties during his lifetime and that altering the existing arrangement would not serve the interests of justice. The Respondent relied on In Re Estate of the Late Siwanyang Ngilot o chi (Deceased) (2021) KEHC 5918 (KLR), Eldoret Civil Appeal No. 66 of 2002, Mary Rono v Jane Rono & William Rono (2005) eKLR, In Re Estate of Kanyari Njari (Deceased) (2019) KEHC 4317 (KLR), and Cleopa Amutala Namayi v Judith Were (2015) eKLR, in support of maintaining the arrangements established by the deceased during his lifetime.
59. On the second ground of appeal, the Respondent submitted that the parties had recorded a consent before the trial court appointing Robert Ngao Ndambuki and George Mutunga Ndambuki as administrators representing the 1st and 2nd Houses respectively. The consent further recognised the occupation of Machakos/Nguluni/352 by the 1st House and Matungulu/Sengani/1624 by the 2nd House and limited the issue for determination to the ownership, occupation and distribution of Matungulu/Sengani/1682.
60. The Respondent conceded that the trial court did not recall this aspect of the consent when appointing Robert Ngao Ndambuki as sole administrator, but submitted that this was an insignificant error which could have been corrected by review rather than appeal, particularly as there was no dispute on the issue. It was also submitted that transmission had already been effected.
61. The Respondent addressed the complaint concerning the identity of the deceased’s first wife. It was submitted that the deceased’s first wife was Elizabeth Mukui Ndambuki, while Tabitha Syokwia Ndambuki was the second wife. The Respondent explained that Elizabeth Mukui had six daughters and, in accordance with the evidence presented concerning the Iweto arrangement, had married another woman, Mukonyo Ndambuki, in about 1965 for purposes of having male children. The Respondent stated that the Iweto arrangement resulted in three children, namely Agnes Mutinda Ndambuki, David Muasa Ndambuki and Robert Ngao Ndambuki. It was therefore submitted that the trial court’s reference to the first wife as Ndambuki Mukonyo instead of Elizabeth Mukui Ndambuki was an error which could have been corrected through review rather than appeal
62. With regard to the fourth ground of appeal, the Respondent submitted that it represented both the 1st House and the Iweto, through the administrator Robert Ngao Ndambuki.
63. The Respondent submitted that the complaint was misplaced because summons for confirmation of grant dated 30th January 2024 were on the record, and the Appellants had filed an affidavit of protest dated 7th October 2024 against the summons for confirmation. It was therefore argued that the matter proceeded to confirmation and hearing of the protest through viva voce evidence, together with the documents and statements filed by the parties.
64. The Respondent repeated that the error concerning the name of the first wife could have been corrected through review. It further submitted that the seventh ground did not challenge the distribution of Matungulu/Sengani/1624 to the 1st House and therefore urged the Court not to disturb the trial court’s order concerning that property.
65. The Respondent submitted that the trial court had correctly distributed Matungulu/Sengani/1682 to the 2nd House in accordance with the consent of the parties. The only error, according to the Respondent, was that the property was directed to be registered in the name of John Danson Kibinda rather than George Mutunga Ndambuki, who had been agreed upon as the administrator representing the 2nd House. The Respondent maintained that this too was an error capable of correction through review rather than appeal because there was no dispute regarding the entitlement of the 2nd House to the property.
66. I have considered the record of appeal, the amended memorandum of appeal and the rival submissions in the case from which I have identified the following points for determination: whether Matungulu/Sengani/1624 formed part of the deceased’s estate, whether the trial court was entitled to allocate Matungulu/Sengani/1624 exclusively to the first house based on the evidence adduced before it, whether the court respected the parties consent, whether the trial court lawfully distributed the estate and directed registration in the names of individual beneficiaries without following the proper confirmation procedure.
67. In Selle and Another vs Associated Motor Boat Company Ltd and Others (1968) EA 123, the Court of Appeal stated that an appellate court must re-consider and re-evaluate the evidence and reach its own conclusions while bearing in mind that it did not have the advantage of seeing and hearing the witnesses.
68. It was submitted by the Appellants and admitted by the Respondent that the parties recorded a partial consent before the trial court on 9th June 2025 that Robert Ngao Ndambuki and George Mutunga Ndambuki be appointed as administrators to represent the 1st and the 2nd house respectively, which consent the trial court went against by appointing Robert Ngao Ndambuki as sole administrator. At pages 122-123 of the Record of Appeal, the court record reflects that indeed the parties entered into a consent which was adopted as an order of the trial court. The trial court therefore went against its orders in ordering land reference Matungulu/Sengani/1624 to be registered in the name of John Danson Kibinda on his behalf and the children of the 2nd wife instead of George Mutunga Ndambuki, as agreed by the parties and adopted by the trial court.
69. The Respondent also conceded that the trial court erred by holding that Ndambuki Mukonyo (deceased) was the 1st wife of the deceased, whereas it was not disputed by either party that the 1st wife of the deceased was Elizabeth Mukui Ndambuki. I, however, note that the trial court, in doing so, described Ndambuki Mukonyo as deceased, which wasn’t the case, as she is indicated to be alive.
70. It therefore obviously follows that the orders by the trial court that referred to Ndambuki Mukonyo as the 1st wife instead of Elizabeth Mukui Ndambuki were all issued in error, as stated in the grounds of appeal.
71. The Respondent also concedes to ground 8 of the Appeal that the trial court erred by ordering that the property known as Matungulu/ Sengani/1682 was to be registered in the name of John Danson Kibinda, who was not the agreed administrator of the 2nd House as per the consent of the parties which was adopted as an order of the court.
72. The other point raised by the Appellants is that the trial court did not follow the procedure provided in law; the Appellants submitted that the parties agreed that the court determines whether land parcel Matungulu/sengani/1682 formed part of the estate of the deceased, which the trial court did.
73. The Appellant submitted that once that issue was resolved, the trial court ought to have permitted the parties to take out a grant of letters of administration intestate in the name of the consented administrators and thereafter give the administrators and beneficiaries time to file summons for confirmation of grant.
74. The Appellants submitted that their protest was against the confirmation of grant filed by the Respondent dated 30th January 2024. That grant had failed to include the proper beneficiaries and the property known as Matungulu/Sengani/1682. The Respondent admitted that he had omitted including Matungulu/ Sengani/ 1682 from the deceased’s properties. The trial court, while accepting that the said property formed part of the estate of the deceased, went ahead and distributed the deceased’s estate.
75. I have looked at the dispositive orders of the trial court; the court dismissed the protest to the summons for confirmation, confirmed the grant on terms set out in the judgment, and ordered each party to bear their own costs.
76. Section 71 (2) (b) of the Law of Succession Act provides that if the court is not so satisfied, it may issue to some other person or persons in accordance with the provisions of sections 56 to 66 inclusive, a confirmed grant of letters of administration in respect of the estate or so much thereof as may be administered, provided that in intestacy, the grant of letters of administration shall not be confirmed until the court is satisfied as to the respective identities and shares of all persons beneficially entitled; and when confirmed the grant shall specify all such persons and their respective shares.
77. I don’t believe that the trial court considered the proviso to section 71, since in the instant case, not all the beneficiaries entitled were included and their shares disclosed; for instance, I didn’t see any consents from some of Elizabeth Mukui Ndambuki’s living daughters to the summons for confirmation, which is a failure to establish all beneficiaries required by law.
78. Lastly, there is the issue of the land parcel number Matungulu/Sengani/1624, which the trial court rightly held belonged to the deceased and formed part of his estate available for distribution.
79. The trial court invoked estoppel for the sake of maintaining harmony in the homestead. The Court relied on the case of Re: Estate of the late Siwanyang Ngilotochi (deceased) (2021) eKLR. In that case, a wife of the deceased had been settled on land which she rejected, compelling her husband to buy and settle her on a different parcel of land; upon her husband’s demise, she objected to the transmission of the parcel of land she had earlier rejected to others; the court held that she was estopped from laying claim to land that she had rejected. The facts of that case are distinguishable on the application of estoppel to the present.
80. In the present case, the Respondent’s case was that the property in issue was gifted to Elizabeth Mukui by her father. The trial court rejected that evidence and correctly held that it formed part of the estate of the deceased available for distribution.
81. I also find that the Respondent did not establish the elements of estoppel: knowledge, acquiescence, and legally relevant reliance.
82. That said, the Court of Appeal in the case of Scholastica Ndululu Suva-vs-Agnes Nthenya Suva (2019) eKLR, while acknowledging the discretion of courts in the distribution of properties of deceased polygamous persons, stated as follows;
[17] It is therefore evident that, although section 40 of the Law of Succession Act provides a general provision for the distribution of the estate of a polygamous deceased person, the court has discretion to take into account factual circumstances of the particular case that may be relevant in ensuring equitable and fair distribution of the estate
83. Section 40(1) of the Law of Succession Act provides for distribution of the estate of a polygamous deceased’s person as follows:
“40(1) where an intestate has married more than once under any system of law permitting polygamy, his personal and household effects and the residue of the net intestate estate shall, in the first instance, be divided among the houses according to the number of children in each house, but also adding any wife surviving him as an additional unit to the number of children.”
84. In Mary Rono vs Jane Rono & another (supra), Waki JA in the leading judgment accepted the proposition that the Court had the discretion in ensuring a fair distribution of the deceased’s estate but that the discretion must be exercised judicially on a sound legal and factual basis. In the same judgment, Omollo JA stated the position more clearly as follows:
“My understanding of that section is that while the net intestate estate is to be distributed according to houses, each house being treated as a unit, yet the judge doing the distribution still has discretion to take into account or consider the number of children in each house. If Parliament had intended that there must be equality between houses they would have been no need to provide in the section that the number of children in each house be taken into account. Nor do I see any provision in the Act that each child must receive the same or equal portion. That would clearly work injustice, particularly in the case of a young child who is still to be maintained, educated and generally seen through life. If such a child, whether a girl or a boy, were to get an equal inheritance with another who is already working and for whom no school fees and things like that were to be provided, such equality would work an injustice, and for my part, I am satisfied that the Act does not provide for that kind of equality.”
85. In Douglas Njuguna Muigai & vs John Bosco Maina Kariuki & another, the Court of Appeal noted the absurdity of a blind application of section 40(1) of the Law of Succession Act as follows:
“Back to section 40(1) of the Law of Succession Act, which provides that a widow shall be considered as a unit alongside the children of the deceased when it comes to the distribution of the deceased’s estate. In this case, Jerioth Wangechi, the first wife of the deceased, who even participated in the dowry negotiations for her co-wives, is equated to the last-born child of the 3rd wife of the deceased. Her contribution and support to the deceased as a spouse are not recognized and, in our view, that failure to recognize her contribution is tantamount to discrimination.
86. That the ascertainable arrangements of the deceased person on how his/her property was to be distributed are relevant in the distribution of the estate of a deceased person is not in dispute. The court in Re: Estate of the late Siwanyang Ngilotochi (deceased) (2021) eKLR approved a distribution that accorded with the deceased’s wishes.
87. Similarly, the Court of Appeal in Kahiro v Mburu & 2 others (Civil Appeal Suit 43 of 2018) [2022] KECA 650 (KLR) (13 May 2022) (Judgment) upheld the ascertained wishes of the deceased on how he wanted his property distributed; the Court held as follows;
27. An analysis of the evidence discloses that the deceased was polygamous and had two families, which meant that the distribution of the estate would require to be in terms of section 40 of the Law of Succession Act. The provision specifies that, where a deceased is polygamous, his estate shall “…be divided among the houses according to the number of children in each house, also adding any wife surviving him as an additional unit to the number of children”. As to whether the deceased’s settlement arrangements were adopted by the court in the mode of distribution, the evidence is clear that prior to his demise, the deceased made definitive arrangements in the apportionment of his properties among the two families. We say so because Lucy’s evidence confirmed that she resided with the deceased in Thika, and that Teresiah resided in Kiserian, Kajiado. Lucy’s witnesses, Njogu Mututo and Muhia Nguku, also corroborated this evidence. Further support of these arrangements is to be found in Teresiah’s evidence, which was that the two Kajiado plots were purchased prior to the deceased’s marriage to her; that after he married Lucy, they moved away from Kiserian, Kajiado to live in Thika, where she farmed a portion of the Thika Kabati plot; and that she had continued to reside there even after the deceased’s demise. From this evidence, it can be discerned that the deceased intended for Teresiah to reside in Kiserian, Kajiado and for Lucy to reside in Thika. Whilst distributing the deceased’s estate, there is no question that the trial judge maintained the arrangement prevailing when the deceased was alive and following his demise, to the extent that the Kiserian, Kajiado plots remained with Teresiah and the Thika Kabati plot with Lucy. By distributing the properties in the extant manner, it cannot be said that the learned judge disregarded the deceased’s settlement arrangements
88. In the present matter, the evidence from witnesses, including those of the protestor, is that the deceased settled his two wives in their respective lands and allowed the 1st wife and her house to use land parcel Matungulu/Sengani/1624 exclusively of the 2nd wife and her children, that arrangement subsisted throughout the lifetime of the deceased and more than (40) forty years after his demise.
89. I find that the deceased’s settlement arrangements are a material factor to be considered in distribution, but it cannot be decided in the absence of some beneficiaries.
90. Since the issue framed for determination by the parties was whether Matungulu/Sengani/1624 formed part of the estate of the deceased available for distribution, the trial court ought to have allowed the ordinary process of confirmation to take its course after determining that issue.
91. In sum, I find that the appeal succeeds in part: the trial court disregarded the parties' consent that was adopted as an order of the court; the court incorrectly identified the deceased’s first wife and directed registration of the estate inconsistent with the agreed administration arrangement; the court failed to observe the procedure set out under section 71 of the Law of Succession Act.
Consequently, I order as follows;
A. The judgment delivered on 26th August 2025 is hereby set aside
B. Orders for confirmation of grant made on 26th August 2025 are hereby set aside
C. That Robert Ngao Ndambuki and George Mutunga Ndambuki are hereby appointed as administrators for the 1st house and 2nd house, respectively
D. That the Administrators shall file fresh summons for confirmation of grant not later than 30 days from the date of this judgment
E. Each party shall bear their own costs.
Dated, signed and delivered via Microsoft Teams at Mombasa, this 15th day of October 2026
Emmanuel Bitta
Judge of the High Court
In the presence of
Nechesah C/A
Nzuva for the Appellants
Muumbi for the Respondent