Employment law

Mulama v Board of Management Ngara Girls School Nairobi & 2 others [2026] KEELRC 2468 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
CAUSE NO. 1966 OF 2011
Judgment date
17 September 2026
Judge(s)
B. O. M. Manani

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The application partly succeeded. The court declined to join Hebros Auctioneers as an interested party, but declared the 9 December 2020 warrants expired on 30 January 2021 and null and void. It further declared the auctioneer’s proclamation and attempted attachment founded on those warrants irregular, as was the attempt to recover auctioneer’s fees without first having the bill of costs assessed by the court.

Supporting judgment passages

11. The upshot is that the court declines to join the auctioneer as an interested party in the cause.

Paragraph 11 →

12. However, it (the court) hereby declares that the warrants of attachment dated 9th December 2020 expired on 30th January 2021 and are thus null and void.

Paragraph 12 →

13. As such, the impugned proclamation and attempted attachment by the auctioneer in a bid to recover auctioneer’s costs, in so far as it is founded on the aforesaid warrants of attachment, is irregular. It is so declared.

Paragraph 13 →
Issue 1Whether Hebros Auctioneers should be joined as an interested party to the cause.

Held. No. The auctioneer was merely executing warrants issued by the court. Even if it exceeded its authority, the Respondents could challenge the irregular execution process without making the auctioneer a party; joinder was therefore declined.

Ratio. An auctioneer executing court-issued warrants need not be joined to the cause merely because its execution is challenged; alleged excess or irregularity may be addressed directly through proceedings challenging the execution process.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

5. The court notes that the auctioneer (proposed interested party) was merely seeking to execute warrants which were issued to him by the court. This, of itself, does not warrant his joinder as a party in the proceedings.

Paragraph 5 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

6. If the auctioneer has acted in excess of the authority which was granted to him by the court to execute the decree, the Respondents can move the court to declare the process irregular without seeking to make him a party to the cause. As such, the request to make the auctioneer an interested party in the cause is declined.

Paragraph 6 →

11. The upshot is that the court declines to join the auctioneer as an interested party in the cause.

Paragraph 11 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

5. The court notes that the auctioneer (proposed interested party) was merely seeking to execute warrants which were issued to him by the court. This, of itself, does not warrant his joinder as a party in the proceedings.

Paragraph 5 →

6. If the auctioneer has acted in excess of the authority which was granted to him by the court to execute the decree, the Respondents can move the court to declare the process irregular without seeking to make him a party to the cause. As such, the request to make the auctioneer an interested party in the cause is declined.

Paragraph 6 →
Issue 2Whether the auctioneer could rely on the 9 December 2020 warrants of attachment to proclaim and attach the 1st Respondent’s property years later.

Held. No. The warrants were required to be returned by 30 January 2021 and had expired. The court declared them null and void, and declared the proclamation and attempted attachment founded on them irregular.

Ratio. Under Order 22 rule 21 of the Civil Procedure Rules, the officer executing process must endorse and return it within the stipulated period. The auctioneer could not recover fees using expired warrants that had not been renewed.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

9. Further, the auctioneer appears to be riding on the warrants which the court issued on 9th December 2020 to recover his fees several years down the line without first having renewed the said warrants. This is irregular since the warrants were supposed to have been returned to court by 30th January 2021.

Paragraph 9 →

10. The requirement to return warrants of attachment, whether executed or not, within the timelines that are set out in the warrants is set out in Order 22 rule 21 of the Civil Procedure Rules which provides thus, ’’the officer entrusted with the execution of the process shall endorse thereon the day on, and the manner in which it was executed, and, if the latest day specified in the process for the return thereof has been exceeded, the reason for the delay, or, if it was not executed, the reason why it was not executed, and shall return the process with such endorsement to the court.’’ As such, the auctioneer is not entitled to recover his fees based on the expired warrants.

Paragraph 10 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

12. However, it (the court) hereby declares that the warrants of attachment dated 9th December 2020 expired on 30th January 2021 and are thus null and void.

Paragraph 12 →

13. As such, the impugned proclamation and attempted attachment by the auctioneer in a bid to recover auctioneer’s costs, in so far as it is founded on the aforesaid warrants of attachment, is irregular. It is so declared.

Paragraph 13 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

9. Further, the auctioneer appears to be riding on the warrants which the court issued on 9th December 2020 to recover his fees several years down the line without first having renewed the said warrants. This is irregular since the warrants were supposed to have been returned to court by 30th January 2021.

Paragraph 9 →

10. The requirement to return warrants of attachment, whether executed or not, within the timelines that are set out in the warrants is set out in Order 22 rule 21 of the Civil Procedure Rules which provides thus, ’’the officer entrusted with the execution of the process shall endorse thereon the day on, and the manner in which it was executed, and, if the latest day specified in the process for the return thereof has been exceeded, the reason for the delay, or, if it was not executed, the reason why it was not executed, and shall return the process with such endorsement to the court.’’ As such, the auctioneer is not entitled to recover his fees based on the expired warrants.

Paragraph 10 →
Issue 3Whether the auctioneer could execute for Ksh. 307,216 in alleged auctioneer’s fees without agreement by the parties or taxation/assessment of its bill of costs.

Held. No. There was no indication that the fees had been agreed or ascertained through taxation of the auctioneer’s bill of costs. The court declared the attempt to recover fees without first presenting the bill for court assessment irregular.

Ratio. Under rule 55 of the Auctioneers Rules, an auctioneer’s fees must be agreed by the parties or ascertained through taxation/assessment of the bill of costs before execution may issue for them.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

8. It appears from the aforesaid letter that what the auctioneer is trying to recover is his fees which he estimates at Ksh. 307,216.00. However, there is no indication that this amount was either agreed on by the parties or ascertained through taxation of the auctioneer’s bill of costs as required under rule 55 of the Auctioneer’s Rules. Absent this, the auctioneer cannot simply take out execution proceedings for the amount.

Paragraph 8 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

14. Further, the court declares that the attempts by the auctioneer to recover his fees without first presenting his bill of costs for assessment by the court is irregular.

Paragraph 14 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

8. It appears from the aforesaid letter that what the auctioneer is trying to recover is his fees which he estimates at Ksh. 307,216.00. However, there is no indication that this amount was either agreed on by the parties or ascertained through taxation of the auctioneer’s bill of costs as required under rule 55 of the Auctioneer’s Rules. Absent this, the auctioneer cannot simply take out execution proceedings for the amount.

Paragraph 8 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The 1st Respondent filed the application dated 2nd December 2025 seeking a series of reliefs which include: an order to join the proposed interested party as a party to the action; a declaration that the proclamation of its (the 1st Respondent) property by the proposed interested party is illegal; and an order to set aside and vacate the warrants of attachment pursuant to which the proposed interested party caused the impugned…

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether Hebros Auctioneers should be joined as an interested party; whether the warrants of attachment issued on 9 December 2020 remained valid; and whether the auctioneer could recover Ksh. 307,216.00 in alleged fees through execution without agreement or…

Material facts

In Mulama v Board of Management Ngara Girls School Nairobi & 2 others [2026] KEELRC 2468 (KLR), the court recorded that judgment had been entered on 14 November 2018 for the Claimant against the 1st Respondent for Ksh. 1,187,931.30. The 1st Respondent stated…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. 1966 OF 2011

SIMPROSE ATIENO MULAMA…..……………………………CLAIMANT

VERSUS

THE BOARD OF MANAGEMENT NGARA GIRLS SCHOOL NAIROBI…………………………………………………....1ST RESPONDENT

ASUMPTA NDUNGU MUNYASYA…………………..2ND RESPONDENT

AND

HEBROS AUCTIONEERS…………....INTENDED INTERESTED PARTY

RULING

Background

1. The 1st Respondent filed the application dated 2nd December 2025 seeking a series of reliefs which include: an order to join the proposed interested party as a party to the action; a declaration that the proclamation of its (the 1st Respondent) property by the proposed interested party is illegal; and an order to set aside and vacate the warrants of attachment pursuant to which the proposed interested party caused the impugned proclamation.

2. The application is supported by the grounds appearing on the face thereof and an affidavit sworn by one Beatrice Ndiga. The affiant avers that on 14th November 2018, the court entered judgment in the cause in favour of the Claimant against the 1st Respondent in which it awarded her (the Claimant) Ksh. 1,187,931.30. She contends that the Claimant took out warrants of attachment on 9th December 2020. However, she contends that the 1st Respondent paid the entire decretal sum before the warrants were executed. As such, she contends that the matter is fully settled.

3. The affiant avers that despite this, the proposed interested party has moved to enforce the aforesaid warrants. She contends that this is irregular since the warrants have expired and the decretal sum has, in any event, been fully paid. And hence the decision to seek the orders in the application.

4. The court record shows that the Claimant and proposed interested party were served with the application. However, they did not respond to it. As such, the motion is essentially not opposed.

Analysis

5. The court notes that the auctioneer (proposed interested party) was merely seeking to execute warrants which were issued to him by the court. This, of itself, does not warrant his joinder as a party in the proceedings.

6. If the auctioneer has acted in excess of the authority which was granted to him by the court to execute the decree, the Respondents can move the court to declare the process irregular without seeking to make him a party to the cause. As such, the request to make the auctioneer an interested party in the cause is declined.

7. The court 1st Respondent contends that it has paid the Claimant the sum of Ksh. 1,187,931.30 which was the subject of the warrant of attachment dated 9th December 2020. This position is confirmed by the auctioneer in his letter to the 1st Respondent dated 20th November 2025.

8. It appears from the aforesaid letter that what the auctioneer is trying to recover is his fees which he estimates at Ksh. 307,216.00. However, there is no indication that this amount was either agreed on by the parties or ascertained through taxation of the auctioneer’s bill of costs as required under rule 55 of the Auctioneer’s Rules. Absent this, the auctioneer cannot simply take out execution proceedings for the amount.

9. Further, the auctioneer appears to be riding on the warrants which the court issued on 9th December 2020 to recover his fees several years down the line without first having renewed the said warrants. This is irregular since the warrants were supposed to have been returned to court by 30th January 2021.

10. The requirement to return warrants of attachment, whether executed or not, within the timelines that are set out in the warrants is set out in Order 22 rule 21 of the Civil Procedure Rules which provides thus, ’’the officer entrusted with the execution of the process shall endorse thereon the day on, and the manner in which it was executed, and, if the latest day specified in the process for the return thereof has been exceeded, the reason for the delay, or, if it was not executed, the reason why it was not executed, and shall return the process with such endorsement to the court.’’ As such, the auctioneer is not entitled to recover his fees based on the expired warrants.

Determination

11. The upshot is that the court declines to join the auctioneer as an interested party in the cause.

12. However, it (the court) hereby declares that the warrants of attachment dated 9th December 2020 expired on 30th January 2021 and are thus null and void.

13. As such, the impugned proclamation and attempted attachment by the auctioneer in a bid to recover auctioneer’s costs, in so far as it is founded on the aforesaid warrants of attachment, is irregular. It is so declared.

14. Further, the court declares that the attempts by the auctioneer to recover his fees without first presenting his bill of costs for assessment by the court is irregular.

Dated, signed and delivered on the 17th day of September, 2026

B. O. M. MANANI

JUDGE

In the presence of:

…………….for the Applicant

…………….for the Respondent

ORDER

In light of the directions issued on 12th July 2022 by her Ladyship, the Chief Justice with respect to online court proceedings, this decision has been delivered to the parties online with their consent, the parties having waived compliance with Rule 28 (3) of the ELRC Procedure Rules which requires that all judgments and rulings shall be dated, signed and delivered in the open court.

B. O. M MANANI

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder