REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION NO. E105 OF 2024
EMMANUEL ELIJAH OTIENO T/A OTIENO LAW & COMPANY ADVOCATES………………………………………………….APPLICANT
-VERSUS-
DEVENDER PAL SINGH………………………………1ST RESPONDENT
SAIF ALAM……………………………………………2ND RESPONDENT
RAMA KRISHNA RAVURI……………………………3RD RESPONDENT
VIMALKUMAR DILIPBHAI PADHIYAR………………4TH RESPONDENT
PERVEZ AHMED SIDIQI……………………………….5TH RESPONDENT
MAHESH CHAND GUPTA………………………….6TH RESPONDENT
SANJAN DAS…………………………………..…….7TH RESPONDENT
JIGNESHKUMAR OGHADBHAI AHIR……………....8TH RESPONDENT
NAVEEN CHANDRA ACHARYA……………………..9TH RESPONDENT
BOKA NAGESHWAR RAO………………………….10TH RESPONDENT
AJAZ AHMAD………………………………………..11TH RESPONDENT
GIRIJA BALLAV MAHAPATRA…………………….12TH RESPONDENT
RAJEEV TAPULOL……………………………..…….13TH RESPONDENT
CHANCHAL SINGH………………………………….14TH RESPONDENT
VARUN SAXENA…………………………………….15TH RESPONDENT
RACHNA JAIN…………………………………..……16TH RESPONDENT
SANKET JAIN…………………………………….….17TH RESPONDENT
DINESH SHARDA………………………………...…..18TH RESPONDENT
RAHUL BHASKARRAO PATIL…………………….…19TH RESPONDENT
RAHUL RAJA HARISHCHAND……………………..20TH RESPONDENT
CLAIMANT SATHISH RAVI………………………....21ST RESPONDENT
NIRMAL KUMAR NARSARIA……………………....22ND RESPONDENT
VIRAIN KUMAR……………………………………...23RD RESPONDENT
MUKESH KUMAR……………………………………24TH RESPONDENT
DINESH KESAVAN…………………………………..25TH RESPONDENT
HIMANSHU VYAS………………………………..….26TH RESPONDENT
BABU YANGAIAH…………………………………...27TH RESPONDENT
ANIT VETTUVELIL MARCOS……………………....28TH RESPONDENT
JOMINI GEORGE…………………………………..29TH RESPONDENT
JITTO VARGHESE……………………………………30TH RESPONDENT
AMBIKA THIPPESWAMY………………………...…31ST RESPONDENT
LINGARAJU RAMANA………………………………32ND RESPONDENT
AMANDEEP SINGH DHAMI………………………...33RD RESPONDENT
SASANTH SIVAN………………………………….....34TH RESPONDENT
ABRAHAM GEORGE………………………………...35TH RESPONDENT
NIXON THANKACHAN…………………………...36TH RESPONDENT
TINTU JOSEPH……………………………………..37TH RESPONDENT
RAKEESH KUMAR AHIRWAR……………………..38TH RESPONDENT
SONAM SAXENA……………………………………..39TH RESPONDENT
SHEKHAR SUDAM POKALE……………………..…40TH RESPONDENT
DIPALI ULHAS DUKARE……………………………....41ST RESPONDENT
SUNEEL KUMAR KASUKURTHU……………...…..42ND RESPONDENT
ARISING FROM ELRCC/1027/2023
DEVENDER PAL SINGH & 41 OTHERS……………………CLAIMANTS
-VERSUS-
MEDIHEAL GROUP LIMITED & 2 OTHERS……………RESPONDENTS
RULING
1. This ruling relates to the Applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 6th February 2026 filed under certificate of urgency seeking judgment for Kshs. 4,303,376, being taxed and certified advocate–client costs, interest at 14% per annum from 11th December 2023, and costs.
2. The Applicant’s case is that the Advocate–Client Bill of Costs was taxed at Kshs. 4,303,376 in the ruling delivered by Hon. Aziza Ajwang on 17th October 2024, and a Certificate of Taxation was thereafter issued. Hon. Lady Justice Stella Rutto dismissed the Respondents' reference on 9th April 2025, thereby upholding the taxation. The amount remains unpaid.
3. The Respondents opposed the application through a Replying Affidavit sworn on 21st April 2026. They do not dispute the taxed amount but oppose interest, contending that it was neither sought in the bill nor awarded by the Taxing Officer, that the Certificate of Taxation contains no award of interest, and that the Applicant has not proved delivery of the bill or explained the proposed commencement date of 11th December 2023.
The Applicant’s Submissions
4. The Applicant submitted that the certified sum is undisputed and remains unpayable after dismissal of the reference. On interest, the Applicant relied on Rule 7 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order, arguing that the Respondents’ participation in the taxation and subsequent reference demonstrates knowledge of the bill. In rejoinder, the Applicant submitted that interest falls within the Court’s jurisdiction and urged the Court to consider the prolonged non-payment and inflation.
The Respondents’ submissions
5. The Respondents submitted that an earlier application had been withdrawn and marked as such by the Court. Their objection was confined to the issue of interest. They argued that the Applicant had not established the basis for interest from 11th December 2023, particularly as the Certificate of Taxation was issued later.
6. They further submit that Rule 7 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order requires delivery of the bill to the client and that no evidence had been produced showing the date of delivery.
7. They urged the Court to decline interest at 14% per annum.
Analysis and determination
8. The issues for determination are:
i. Whether judgment should be entered for Kshs. 4,303,376;
ii. Whether the Applicant is entitled to interest at 14% per annum and, if so, from what date.
9. Section 51(2) of the Advocates Act provides that a certificate of the Taxing Officer, unless set aside or altered, is final as to the amount of costs and permits the Court, where the retainer is not disputed, to enter judgment for the certified sum.
10. The Certificate of Taxation remains valid. The reference challenging the taxation was dismissed vide the ruling delivered on 9th April 2025, and the Respondents do not dispute the retainer or certified amount.
11. In the premise, Judgment is therefore entered for Kshs. 4,303,376 as taxed.
12. On the issue of interest, Rule 7 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order provides that an advocate may charge interest at 14% per annum on costs and disbursements from the expiration of one month after delivery of the bill to the client, provided the claim is raised before the bill is paid or tendered in full.
13. The right to interest under Rule 7 is distinct from taxation. The fact that interest was not included in the Certificate of Taxation does not, by itself, bar the Court from considering a properly raised claim. The decisive question is whether delivery of the bill, and the date thereof, have been proven.
14. Although participation in the taxation and the filing of a reference demonstrate knowledge of the bill, they do not establish the precise date of such delivery. The claim for interest from 11th December 2023 presupposes delivery by 11th November 2023. No affidavit of service, acknowledgment, correspondence or other evidence proving delivery on that date has been identified.
15. It is also my view that the date of taxation by Hon. Aziza Ajwang of 17th October 2024 does not automatically become the commencement date under Rule 7, since the Rule expressly links interest to the expiry of one month after delivery of the bill, rather than to the date of taxation, the Taxing Officer’s ruling, the Certificate of Taxation or determination of a reference.
16. Accordingly, the claim for interest at 14% per annum from 11th December 2023 is declined, and instead, the court, in its discretionary power and considering inflation, awards interest from 9th April 2025, being the date the Respondent’s reference was declined.
17. In conclusion, the Court grants the following orders: -
a. That Judgment is entered for the Applicant against the Respondents for the taxed sum of Kshs. 4,303,376/-
b. That the prayer for interest at 14% per annum from 11th December 2023 is declined.
c. That the judgment sum shall instead attract interest at court rates from 9th April, 2025 until payment in full.
d. I make no orders on costs in respect of this application.
18. It is so ordered.
SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 24TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Mr. Otieno present for the Applicant
Mr. Terer h/b for Mr. Ondati for the Respondents
Ms. Esther S -C/A