Background
The 1st Defendant/Applicant, Ndonga Limited filed the Notice of Motion dated 3rd December 2025 seeking the following orders:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The 1st Defendant/Applicant, Ndonga Limited filed the Notice of Motion dated 3rd December 2025 seeking the following orders:
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC CASE NO. 93 OF 2016
(CONSOLIDATED WITH ELC CASE NO. 1073 OF 2016)
NCBA BANK KENYA PLC (FORMERLY COMMERCIAL BANK OF AFRICA LIMITED)……………..…………….....PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT
VERSUS
NDONGA LIMITED........................................1ST DEFENDANT/APPLICANT
DIAMOND TRUST BANK KENYA LIMITED....................2ND DEFENDANT
DALALI TRADERS AUCTIONEERS..................................3RD DEFENDANT
CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR...................................................4TH DEFENDANT
GLADYS NJERI KANG'ETHE.............................................5TH DEFENDANT
GEORGE JAMES KIRERU KANG'ETHE..........................6TH DEFENDANT
EDWARD NJUGUNA KANG'ETHE....................................7TH DEFENDANT
PHILIPS INTERNATIONAL AUCTIONEERS............INTERESTED PARTY
CONSOLIDATED WITH
ELC CASE NO. 1073 OF 2016
NDONGA LIMITED...........................................................................PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
COMMERCIAL BANK OF AFRICA LIMITED..................1ST DEFENDANT
GARAM INVESTMENT AUCTIONEERS...........................2ND DEFENDANT
RULING
1. The 1st Defendant/Applicant, Ndonga Limited filed the Notice of Motion dated 3rd December 2025 seeking the following orders:
1. Spent
2. That the orders issued on 26th August 2024, and subsequently affirmed by the ruling delivered on 20th June 2025, in respect of the application dated 13th August 2024, be reviewed, varied and/or set aside.
3. That the condition requiring the 1st Defendant/Applicant to deposit Kshs.300,000/- monthly towards the alleged loan account pending the hearing and determination of the suit be vacated and/or set aside.
4. That costs of the application be provided for.
2. The application is supported by the affidavit of Patrick Kang'ethe Njuguna sworn on 3rd December 2025. The Applicant's case is that the dispute in the consolidated suits concerns the validity, legality and enforceability of the alleged transfer and charge over L.R. No. 209/12513, I.R. No. 64007. The Applicant contends that material evidence subsequently obtained demonstrates that the alleged transfer and charge were never registered and that entries appearing on the title and attributed to the then Principal Land Registration Officer, C.K. Ngetich, were forged.
3. The Applicant relies on, among other documents, a letter from the Directorate of Criminal Investigations dated 14th July 2016, a letter from the Bank dated 11th November 2016, correspondence from Hamilton Harrison & Mathews dated 16th May 2018, and the statement of C.K. Ngetich dated 10th June 2016.
4. Particular emphasis is placed on the correspondence from Hamilton Harrison & Mathews, which the Applicant says expressly stated that the charge was “not registered and is worthless.” The Applicant also relies on the statement attributed to C.K. Ngetich in which he allegedly disowns the signatures appearing on the disputed entries.
5. The Applicant Contends that the material now placed before the Court establishes that the security was never perfected. On that basis, it submits that there is no lawful foundation for compelling it to continue making monthly payments of Kshs.300,000/- towards the alleged loan account.
6. The Applicant further maintains that the documents relied upon were not in its possession when the orders of 26th August 2024 were made and that their subsequent discovery constitutes new and important evidence within the meaning of Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules.
7. In response to the Respondent’s replying affidavit, the Applicant filed a Supplementary Affidavit where the deponent maintains that the Respondent has not controverted the authenticity or substance of the documents relied upon.
8. The Applicant contends that the Deed of Assignment relied upon by the Respondent concerns L.R. No. 209/2489/34 and not L.R. No. 209/12513, and therefore cannot provide a basis for the monthly payment imposed in relation to the latter property.
9. The Applicant also refers to separate proceedings allegedly instituted by the Respondent against its former advocates concerning the same transaction and submits that the Respondent's position is inconsistent with the evidence concerning registration of the security.
The Respondent's case
10. The application is opposed by the Plaintiff/Respondent. Jackson Kingori, Legal Counsel of NCBA Bank Kenya PLC, swore a Replying Affidavit on 12th January 2026.
11. The Respondent's case is that the application does not satisfy any of the statutory grounds for review. It contends that the matters now relied upon were already within the Applicant's knowledge, had been pleaded in the consolidated suits and had been raised in the earlier application dated 13th August 2024. The Respondent maintains that there was neither discovery of new and important evidence, an error apparent on the face of the record, nor any sufficient reason warranting review of the orders of 26th August 2024.
12. The Respondent further states that the facilities advanced to the Applicant were duly approved, accepted and disbursed pursuant to the relevant facility documentation. It states that as at 29th July 2024, the outstanding balance stood at Kshs.186,852,800.95, exclusive of continuing contractual interest. The Applicant, according to the Respondent, has not disputed receiving and utilising the funds advanced.
13. The Respondent further relies on the alternative monetary claim in the amended pleadings and maintains that a dispute concerning the validity or perfection of security does not extinguish the underlying obligation to repay money actually advanced.
14. The Respondent relies on the Supreme Court decision in Standard Chartered Financial Services Limited v Manchester Outfitters (Suiting Division) Limited now called King Woolen Mills Limited & 2 others, Petition No. E012 of 2024, [2025] KESC 68 (KLR). It also relies on a Deed of Assignment of Rental Income and contends that the property generates substantial rental income, making the existing monthly payment of Kshs.300,000/- modest in relation to both the rental income and the outstanding indebtedness.
15. The Respondent also refers to correspondence dated 25th February 2016, which it says demonstrates that the Applicant's advocates acknowledged the validity of the title and charge and proposed settlement of the outstanding loan.
16. In its submissions, the Respondent further asks the Court to increase the monthly payment from Kshs.300,000/- to Kshs.1,500,000/-.
Submissions
17. The Applicant submitted that it had satisfied the requirements for review under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules. It relied on Republic v Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal Ex parte Apollo Mboya [2019] KEHC 6379 (KLR) and Funzi Island Development Limited & 2 others v County Council of Kwale & 2 others, Civil Appeal No. 252 of 2005, [2014] KECA 882 (KLR).
18. The Respondent submitted that the Applicant had not established any ground for review and was merely seeking to reopen matters which had already been determined. It relied principally on Pancras T. Swai v Kenya Breweries Limited, Civil Appeal No. 275 of 2010, [2014] KECA 883 (KLR), Hamida Ali v Patrick Kingondo [2022] KEELC 15735 (KLR) and Standard Chartered Financial Services Limited v Manchester Outfitters, supra.
Analysis and Determination
19. Having considered the application, the affidavits, the documents placed before the Court, the orders of 26th August 2024, the ruling delivered on 20th June 2025 and the respective submissions, the following issues arise for determination:
i. Whether the Applicant has established a ground for review under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules;
ii. Whether the alleged non-registration or invalidity of the charge provides a basis for vacating the order requiring payment of Kshs.300,000/- monthly; and
20. Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act confers upon the Court jurisdiction to review its decree or order. Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules circumscribes the exercise of that jurisdiction. The Applicant principally relies on discovery of new and important evidence and, in the alternative, error apparent on the face of the record and sufficient reason.
21. The Court of Appeal in Pancras T. Swai v Kenya Breweries Limited, supra, stated:
“The discovery of new and important matter or evidence or mistake or error apparent on the face of the record or for any other sufficient reason in rule 1 of Order 44 (now Order 45 in 2010 Civil Procedure Rules) relates to issues of facts which may emerge from evidence. The discovery does not relate or refer to issues of law.”
The order issued by the Court Hon. Justice Omange on 26/8/24 was;
“That the Plaintiff in 93 of 2016 and the Interested Party are hereby restrained from auctioning the suit property pending hearing and determination of the Application. This is subject to the applicant depositing an amount of Kshs.300,000 monthly towards the loan account. First installment is due on 26/8/2024”
“The exercise of due diligence referred to in rule 1 refers to discovery of facts but does not relate to ascertainment of existing law which the court is deemed to be alive to.”
22. The documents relied upon in support of review of the orders herein comprise the DCI letter dated 14th July 2016, the Bank's letter dated 11th November 2016, the correspondence from Hamilton Harrison & Mathews dated 16th May 2018 and the statement of C.K. Ngetich dated 10th June 2016.
23. There is no dispute that these documents substantially pre-date the order of 26th August 2024. More importantly, the question concerning the registration and validity of the transfer and charge was not introduced for the first time by the present application. It had already formed part of the Applicant's case in the consolidated proceedings and had also been raised in the earlier application dated 13th August 2024.
24. The Applicant's contention that the documents were not in its possession when the earlier application was heard is material. Possession of a document and knowledge of the facts to which that document relates are not necessarily the same thing. The question under Order 45, however, is whether the evidence could, after the exercise of due diligence, have been produced at the time the order was made.
25. The Applicant has not placed before the Court sufficient evidence explaining why the DCI correspondence of 2016, the Bank's correspondence of 2016 or the statement of C.K. Ngetich of 2016 could not have been obtained and presented when the earlier application was heard. The documents had existed for several years before the impugned order.
26. The correspondence from Hamilton Harrison & Mathews stands on a somewhat different footing, in that the Applicant contends that it emanated from the Respondent's advocates and was not within its possession. Even accepting that position, however, the correspondence principally reinforces an issue that was already central to the Applicant's case, namely the alleged non-registration of the charge.
27. The material before the Court therefore does not establish the discovery of a new issue which was unavailable to the Applicant despite the exercise of due diligence. What has been placed before the Court is additional evidence intended to strengthen an issue that was already known and pleaded.
28. The jurisdiction of review cannot be converted into an opportunity to re-argue the merits of an earlier decision. The Applicant's complaint, properly examined, challenges the basis upon which the earlier Court imposed and subsequently maintained the monthly payment condition. That is a challenge to the correctness of the earlier decision and is not, in the circumstances presented, an error apparent on the face of the record.
29. The Court in Republic v Advocates Disciplinary Tribunal Ex parte Apollo Mboya, supra, stated that:
“The error or omission must be self-evident and should not require an elaborate argument to be established.”
30 The alleged error in the present matter is not self-evident from the face of the order. Its determination would require examination of the registration documents, the circumstances in which the entries were made, the correspondence exchanged by the parties and advocates, the alleged signatures and the legal effect of the alleged non-registration of the charge. Such an inquiry falls outside the narrow scope of review.
31. The allegations of forgery are undoubtedly serious but require proof. The documents now relied upon may form part of the evidence in the substantive proceedings, but they do not enable this Court, on the present application, to make a final determination that the signatures attributed to C.K. Ngetich were forged or that the transfer and charge were unlawfully registered.
32. The Court, accordingly makes no final finding on the validity of the transfer or charge, the authenticity of the disputed signatures, or the alleged forgery. Those matters remain for determination in the substantive proceedings upon the evidence properly placed before the trial Court.
33. The Court has also examined the issue raised on whether the existence or validity of security extinguishes the obligation to repay the loan. The Court is of the view that the underlying obligation arising from a lending agreement and the existence or validity of security are distinct matters. The Supreme Court in Standard Chartered Financial Services Limited v Manchester Outfitters (Suiting Division) Limited now called King Woolen Mills Limited & 2 others, stated:
“The existence of security for the funds was therefore ancillary.”
…
“The loan agreement creates a personal obligation to repay the money advanced. That obligation exists independent of any security, whether a charge, debenture, or guarantee.”
…
“Equity will not treat the debt as extinguished simply because the security was defective or incomplete, or that none was furnished; the right to repayment survives even if the security fails.”
34. The Applicant's reliance on the alleged non-registration of the charge therefore
does not, of itself, establish that the debt has ceased to exist or that every interim
measure directed at preservation of the subject matter must necessarily fall.
35. The Court, however warns that this finding does not determine the validity of
the charge in this suit and neither does it determine the final amount due to the Respondent. Those questions remain subject to the evidence and determination in the substantive proceedings.
36. The issue also arose as to whether the Kshs.300,000/- monthly payment should
be vacated. In the Court’s view, the order of 26th August 2024 requiring the Applicant to deposit Kshs.300,000/- monthly was an interim condition attached to the injunctive protection granted by the Court. It was not a final determination of the Respondent's right to realise the security, nor was it a final determination of the Applicant's indebtedness. The Applicant has not demonstrated that circumstances have arisen which render the payment condition incapable of performance or that its continued enforcement would occasion prejudice sufficient to bring the application within the jurisdiction of review.
37. The Respondent has placed before the Court evidence of the outstanding
facility, which it states stood at Kshs.186,852,800.95 as at 29th July 2024, together with evidence concerning rental income from the property. The existence and quantum of the ultimate indebtedness remain matters for determination in the substantive proceedings.
38. In the circumstances, the Applicant has not established a sufficient basis for vacating the Kshs.300,000/- monthly condition. The condition therefore remains in force as part of the interim orders of 26th August 2024, as affirmed by the ruling of 20th June 2025.
Determination
39. The Applicant has not established discovery of new and important evidence within the meaning of Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules. It has equally not established an error apparent on the face of the record or any other sufficient reason warranting review of the orders of 26th August 2024 as affirmed by the ruling delivered on 20th June 2025.
40. The alleged defects in the transfer and charge, including the allegations of forgery, remain matters for determination in the substantive proceedings. They do not, on the material presently before the Court, constitute a basis for vacating the interim payment condition.
41. In the result, the Notice of Motion dated 3rd December 2025 is without merit and is dismissed with costs to the Plaintiff/Respondent.
Delivered, dated and signed via Microsoft Teams this 8th day of October 2026.
HON. L. G. KIMANI
JUDGE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
The Ruling read in the presence of-
Kabaiku for Plaintiff in 93/2016
Karaya for 1st Defendant in 93/2016 while in 1073 for Plaintiff
M/s Thondeka for 5, 6 & 7th Defendant