Land law

Koena Limited v Mugambi (Sued in the Capacity of the Administrator of the Estate of Margaret Njiru M’Rithaa) [2026] KEELC 7378 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
ELC CASE NO. 109 OF 2023
Judgment date
8 October 2026
Judge(s)
LG Kimani

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Defendant/Applicant filed the Notice of Motion dated 14th January 2026, seeking orders that the Plaintiff's suit be dismissed for want of prosecution, and that costs of the application be provided for.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The Court has considered the application herein and the submissions. The principal issue for determination is whether the suit ought to be dismissed for want of prosecution under Order 17 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. The Defendant/Applicant’s application is dated 14th January 2026, while the last recorded step in the proceedings was the delivery of a ruling on 16th December 2024. The Court therefore has to determine…

Paragraph 11 →

Reasoning passage

Order 17 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, permits dismissal where no application has been made or step taken by either party for one year. The Court finds that this statutory threshold has been met because more than one year had elapsed between the ruling of 16th December 2024 and the filing of the dismissal application on 14th January 2026.

Paragraph 12 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI ELC CASE NO. 109 OF 2023

KOENA LIMITED..................................................PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT

-VERSUS-

PAUL GITOBU MUGAMBI (Sued in the Capacity of the Administrator of the Estate of Margaret Njiru M’Rithaa) ...............DEFENDANT/APPLICANT

RULING

1. The Defendant/Applicant filed the Notice of Motion dated 14th January 2026, seeking orders that the Plaintiff's suit be dismissed for want of prosecution, and that costs of the application be provided for.

2. The application is premised on the grounds that the Plaintiff instituted the present suit on 6th October 2023 together with an application dated 28th September 2023, which application the Plaintiff actively prosecuted and which this Court heard and determined vide a ruling delivered on 16th December 2024.

3. It is contended that since the delivery of that ruling, the Plaintiff has not taken any step whatsoever to prosecute or advance the main suit, has failed and/or neglected to fix the matter for pre-trial directions or hearing, and has demonstrated no interest in prosecution of the suit. The Applicant contends that this prolonged and unexplained inaction amounts to inordinate and inexcusable delay that is prejudicial to him and to the beneficiaries of the estate he represents, that the continued pendency of the suit serves no useful purpose and only contributes to backlog at the registry, and that it amounts to an abuse of the process of the Court.

4. It is further contended that this Court is clothed with the discretionary power to dismiss suits for want of prosecution in circumstances of unreasonable, inordinate and unjustified delay, that no prejudice would be occasioned to the Respondent were the orders sought to be granted, and that the application has been brought promptly, without delay and in good faith. On that basis, the Applicant urges that it is in the interest of justice that litigation be brought to an end and that the suit be dismissed with costs.

5. The application is supported by the affidavit of Paul Gitobu Mugambi sworn on 14th January 2026, in which he reiterates the matters raised in support of the application and contends that the prolonged and unexplained inaction by the Plaintiff amounts to a loss of interest on the part of the Plaintiff and that it is in the interest of justice that the litigation come to an end.

6. The Defendant/Applicant subsequently swore a Supplementary Affidavit on 18th March 2026. Responding to the Plaintiff/Respondent’s response dated 17th February 2026. He avers that the Respondent has failed, neglected and/or refused to annex or provide any correspondence as proof of the negotiations alluded to in paragraphs 5 to 8 of the said Response. He deposes that it is a settled principle of law that a party who seeks to prove a fact in an affidavit is obligated to exhibit the documents relied upon, citing the decision in Francis A. Mbalenga v Cecilia W. Maema [2017] eKLR.

7. On that basis, the deponent avers that the response is fatally defective for want of proof, he further deposes that, contrary to the Respondent's averments, the parties have not engaged in any negotiations since 16th December 2024, and that the alleged negotiations do not exist and are merely intended to mislead the Court.

Applicant’s submissions

8. The Defendant/Applicant confirmed the factual basis for the application and relies on Article 159(2)(b) of the Constitution, Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, and Order 17 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules, together with authorities including Nilesh Premchand Mulji Shah & another t/a Ketan Emporium v M.D. Popat and others & another [2016] KEHC 6855 (KLR), and Naftali Onyango v National Bank of Kenya [2005] eKLR (citing Allen v Sir Alfred McAlpine & Sons Ltd [1968] 1 All ER 543). The applicable test is whether the delay is inordinate and inexcusable and, if so, whether it has caused serious prejudice to the Defendant or whether justice can still be done despite the delay.

9. Applying that test, the Applicant notes that the suit was filed on 6th October 2023, the interlocutory application was determined on 16th December 2024, and no further step was taken until the dismissal application was filed on 14th January 2026. The Applicant therefore maintains that the Respondent, having failed to substantiate the alleged settlement negotiations or otherwise explain the prolonged inactivity, has caused prejudice through continued pendency of the suit and that the suit should consequently be dismissed for want of prosecution.

10. The Respondent’s Replying Affidavit although confirmed by the Applicant as having been filed and served was not uploaded in the system and is not in the Court’s physical file. The Respondent were further given 7 days to file submissions from 19th May, 2026 and by the time of writing this Ruling the Respondent have not filed submissions. We proceed now to analysis and determination.

Analysis And Determination.

11. The Court has considered the application herein and the submissions. The principal issue for determination is whether the suit ought to be dismissed for want of prosecution under Order 17 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. The Defendant/Applicant’s application is dated 14th January 2026, while the last recorded step in the proceedings was the delivery of a ruling on 16th December 2024. The Court therefore has to determine whether the period of inactivity justified the remedy of dismissing the suit.

12. Order 17 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, permits dismissal where no application has been made or step taken by either party for one year. The Court finds that this statutory threshold has been met because more than one year had elapsed between the ruling of 16th December 2024 and the filing of the dismissal application on 14th January 2026.

13. However, the Court is of the view that satisfaction of the one-year threshold was not, by itself, conclusive of the matter. The governing test was derived principally from Ivita v Kyumbu [1984] KLR 441 where Chesoni J. stated:

“The test is whether the delay is prolonged and inexcusable, and, if it is, can justice be done despite such delay.”

14. The Court further recognizes that justice must be considered from the perspective of both parties and the Court, because, even prolonged delay does not necessarily require dismissal where the Plaintiff provides a satisfactory explanation. In the case of Mwangi S. Kimenyi v Attorney General and Another, Civil Suit Misc. No. 720 of 2009, the Court stated that prolonged and inexcusable delay may justify dismissal where it causes grave injustice, but that delay alone should not prevent the Court from doing substantive justice. Among the matters to be considered are whether the delay was intentional and contumelious, whether the conduct constituted an abuse of the Court process, whether the delay was inordinate and inexcusable, whether it created a substantial risk to a fair trial, and what prejudice dismissal would cause the Plaintiff.

15. The court is of the view that dismissal of a suit without determination of the merits is “draconian act which drives the plaintiff from the judgment-seat” and consequently requires the careful and judicious exercise of the Court's discretion.

16. The court has considered, the above relevant considerations for the court in order to arrive at a conclusion of whether to dismiss the suit for want of prosecution.

17. The said factors must be considered together and in the context of the particular case. The question is therefore not simply whether one year had elapsed, but whether the length of the delay, the explanation given, the conduct of the parties, the nature of the proceedings, the prejudice caused and the interests of justice collectively justified dismissal.

18. On the application of the law to the facts in this case, the Court accepts that there has been a period of inactivity exceeding one year. Nevertheless, there is no evidence that the Plaintiff had deliberately abandoned the proceedings. In particular, there was no evidence that the Court had issued a peremptory order requiring the Plaintiff to take a particular step within a specified period and that the Plaintiff had deliberately disobeyed it.

19. Although the Court has not seen the replying affidavit alluded to in the supplementary affidavit of the Applicant, it can be gathered that the Plaintiff explained the inactivity by stating that the parties had been engaged in negotiations for an out-of-court settlement. The Applicant challenged the claim to negotiations on the basis of lack of documentary proof but did not outrightly state that there were no negotiations.

20. Having also looked at the Court record, the Court finds no evidence that the Plaintiff's inactivity constitutes an abuse of the process of the Court. There was no indication that the suit had been deliberately kept pending to obtain a collateral advantage, frustrate the Defendant, or buy time.

21. The Defendant argued that the continued pendency of the suit caused anxiety and uncertainty to him and to the beneficiaries of the estate he represented. The Court acknowledges the legitimate interest of a Defendant in finality and that prolonged litigation carries uncertainty and expense. However, the Court holds that the relevant prejudice must concern the Defendant's ability to receive a fair trial. The Defendant has not demonstrated specific prejudice such as loss or unavailability of witnesses, destruction or loss of documents, inability to trace relevant evidence, aggravated costs, or any other hardship materially affecting the defence of the case. The Court therefore finds that the Defendant has not established a substantial risk to a fair trial or grave injustice.

22. The Court has considered the prejudice that dismissal would cause the Plaintiff. The subject matter of the litigation, involves registered land subject of a sale agreement valued at Kshs. 135,000,000, together with issues relating to the administration of a deceased person's estate. The Court is of the view that dismissal would permanently terminate the Plaintiff's opportunity to have the substantive proprietary dispute determined on its merits and dismissal would occasion substantial prejudice to the Plaintiff.

Determination

23. Having weighed all the circumstances, the Court concludes that although

there had been delay in prosecuting the suit, the delay had not been

demonstrated to be so inordinate and inexcusable, nor had it caused such

substantial prejudice, as to justify the drastic remedy of dismissal. The absence

of deliberate or contemptuous conduct, the absence of a disobeyed order, the

absence of specific prejudice to the Defendant, and the significant prejudice

that dismissal would cause the Plaintiff all weigh against dismissal.

24. The Court therefore holds that the interests of justice would be better served

by sustaining the suit, while imposing firm and time-bound directions to

ensure that it is prosecuted expeditiously.

25. Accordingly, the Court makes the following orders:

a) The Notice of Motion dated 14th January 2026 be and is hereby dismissed and the suit herein be and is hereby sustained.

b) The parties shall comply with all outstanding pre-trial requirements under the applicable law and file a statement of agreed issues within twenty-one (21) days from the date hereof.

c) In the event that the parties are unable to agree on the issues for determination, each party shall file its own proposed issues within seven (7) days immediately after expiry of the said twenty-one (21) days.

d) The matter shall thereafter be mentioned before the Deputy Registrar of this Court for confirmation of compliance and further directions towards fixing the suit for hearing.

e) The Plaintiff/Respondent shall bear the costs of the application dated 14th January 2026 assessed at Kshs 10,000/- payable before the hearing date.

Delivered, dated and signed via Microsoft Teams this 8th day of October 2026.

HON. L. G. KIMANI

JUDGE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

The Ruling read in the presence of-

Ms Kwaboka holding brief for Mr. Nyambega for Defendant/Applicant.

Samora for Plaintiff/Respondent.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder