REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC CASE NO. E028 OF 2026
DR. CHRISTOPHER ORINA KENYARIRI............................1ST PLAINTIFF
KENYARIRI INVESTMENTS LTD........................................2ND PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
DOUBLE WIN COMPANY LIMITED.................................1ST DEFENDANT
MIAO YUNFEI......................................................................2ND DEFENDANT
LIU YUPING............................................................................3RD DEFENDANT
THE OWNERS OF SECTIONAL PLAN NO. CFAGVQ3HOE MANAGEMENT CORPORATION………………………..4TH DEFENDANT
RULING
1. The Plaintiffs filed a Notice of Motion dated 2nd February 2026 under Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 40 Rules 1, 2 and 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules and Sections 17, 18, 20 and 24 of the Sectional Properties Act, 2020. The application seeks the following orders:
1) Spent.
2) That pending the hearing and determination of the suit, this Honourable Court be pleased to issue a temporary injunction restraining the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Defendants/Developers, their servants, agents, employees or any other person acting under their authority from convening, purporting to convene, presiding over, conducting or facilitating any meetings of unit owners through any entity other than The Owners of Sectional Plan No. CFAGVQ3HOE Management Corporation.
3) That this Honourable Court be pleased to declare that the meeting held on 6th December 2025 under the name “Sandalwood Gardens Management Corporation” was irregular, unlawful and of no legal consequence.
4) That this Honourable Court be pleased to declare that only The Owners of Sectional Plan No. CFAGVQ3HOE Management Corporation, established by operation of law upon registration of the sectional plan, has authority to convene meetings of unit owners.
5) That this Honourable Court be pleased to direct the Developer to convene the first meeting of owners using the Corporation established by operation of law upon registration of the sectional plan, within 30 days of the order of this Honourable Court.
7) That the costs of the Application be provided for.
2. The Plaintiffs, through the Affidavit and Supplementary Affidavit of Dr. Christopher Orina Kenyariri, contend that Sandalwood Gardens is a sectional development governed by the Sectional Properties Act, 2020. Upon registration of Sectional Plan No. CFAGVQ3HOE, a Management Corporation was automatically constituted by operation of Section 17(1), namely The Owners of Sectional Plan No. CFAGVQ3HOE Management Corporation (the “statutory Corporation”).
3. They argue that the statutory Corporation became a body corporate capable of suing, being sued and exercising statutory powers immediately upon registration of the sectional plan. Its existence does not depend on the subsequent election of a board, appointment of office bearers or registration on the Ardhi Sasa platform. Section 27 merely provides for the election of the board as an internal governance process within an already existing Corporation.
4. The Plaintiffs challenge the Developer’s convening of meetings on 6th December 2025 and 14th March 2026 under the name “Sandalwood Gardens Management Corporation.” They contend that the first meeting lacked the requisite quorum and that, despite their objection of 5 January 2026, the Developer proceeded to convene a reconvened meeting under the same name. According to the Plaintiffs, no such entity is recognised or created by the Sectional Properties Act, 2020, and the Defendants have produced no legal instrument establishing it or giving it the statutory Corporation’s powers.
5. They further rely on Section 17(6), which excludes the application of the Companies Act to the statutory Corporation, and argue that the Developer cannot create, rename or substitute another entity for the Corporation established by statute. They also dispute the suggestion that the Corporation cannot operate until all units are transferred to purchasers, relying on Kanyi & 3 Others v Nextgen Office Suites Limited & 4 Others [2023] KEELC 16434 (KLR).
6. The Plaintiffs maintain that, following registration of the sectional plan, the Developer’s management role is limited to its rights as owner of any remaining units, while management of the development falls within the statutory framework of the Act. They further argue that Regulation 24 of the Sectional Properties Regulations, 2021 cannot override Section 17(1) or create a parallel legal entity.
7. Accordingly, they contend that meetings conducted through the purported “Sandalwood Gardens Management Corporation” are unlawful and that any resulting resolutions could undermine the statutory governance of the development and affect unit owners’ proprietary and management rights. The threatened prejudice is therefore said to extend beyond financial loss to governance and administration of the sectional property, with a risk of creating a fait accompli.
8. The Plaintiffs consequently assert that they have established a prima facie case with a probability of success, and that the balance of convenience favours preserving the statutory governance structure by restraining the Defendants from proceeding with or acting through the purported “Sandalwood Gardens Management Corporation” pending determination of the suit.
The Defendants’ Response
9. The application is opposed by the Replying Affidavit sworn by Liu Xianrong on 6th March 2026, a Sales Representative of the 1st Defendant. The Defendants contend that the application is premature, speculative, legally untenable and an abuse of the Court process, particularly as the meeting scheduled for 14th March 2026 had not occurred when the application was filed.
10. The Defendants distinguish between registration of the sectional plan and the subsequent registration and operationalisation of the Management Corporation. They rely on the Ardhi Sasa extract to demonstrate that registration of the Corporation requires further particulars, including the persons constituting its management. They contend that, at the time the sectional plan was registered, only a minority of the units had been transferred, making it impracticable to constitute the Corporation before the registered proprietors were identified.
11. The Defendants maintain that the Developer deliberately refrained from appointing itself as the Corporation’s management and instead sought to facilitate a democratic election of a board or management committee by the unit owners. They state that the 14th March 2026 meeting was convened for that purpose and was open to and consented to by the homeowners. They deny any unilateral appointment of officials and rely on Kanyi & 3 Others v Nextgen Office Suites Limited & 4 Others [2023] KEELC 16434 (KLR) in support of their position.
12. The Defendants further contend that the Plaintiffs have not demonstrated an enforceable right that has been infringed, noting that the impugned meeting had not taken place and there was no evidence that any unlawful resolution was contemplated. They argue that the alleged irreparable harm is speculative and unsupported by evidence, while the balance of convenience favours allowing the meeting to proceed because it is necessary for the election of officials and proper management of the development, which comprises more than fifty units.
13. Finally, the Defendants contend that the interlocutory application is not anchored on the Amended Plaint dated 26th February 2026, which principally concerns recognition and registration of parking spaces, whereas the application challenges the Management Corporation and the convening of meetings.
Submissions by the Plaintiffs
14. The Plaintiffs submitted that the application raises a narrow but important question: who, upon registration of a sectional plan, has authority to convene meetings of the unit owners?
15. Counsel submitted that Section 17(1) answers that question by providing for the constitution of the Corporation upon registration of the sectional plan. The Plaintiffs submitted that the Corporation constituted under Section 17 is the statutory body responsible for the management and administration of the sectional property and that the Developer has no power to create or use a different entity to exercise those functions.
16. On the principles applicable to interlocutory injunctions, the Plaintiffs relied on Giella v Cassman Brown & Co. Ltd (1973) EA 358 and Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 Others [2003] KLR 125 stating that the statute expressly identifies the Corporation and no statutory basis had been shown for the entity called “Sandalwood Gardens Management Corporation.”
17. On irreparable harm, the Plaintiffs submitted that the injury threatened was institutional and structural. They argued that aJllowing the meeting to proceed could result in resolutions affecting the governance of the sectional property, levies, common property and proprietary rights, thereby creating competing governance structures.
18. On balance of convenience, the Plaintiffs submitted that the injunction would merely preserve the statutory position and would not prevent the Developer from convening a lawful meeting of the Corporation in compliance with Section 27 of the Act.
19. The Plaintiffs also submitted that Articles 10, 40 and 47 of the Constitution support compliance with the statutory governance framework.
Submissions by the Defendants
20. The Defendants filed written submissions dated 14th May 2026. They identified the issues for determination as whether the Plaintiffs had satisfied the conditions for the grant of an injunction and whether the application was incompetent for want of nexus with the substantive suit.
21. On the injunction, the Defendants relied on Giella v Cassman Brown, Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielsen & 2 Others [2014] eKLR and Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 Others [2003] eKLR.
22. The Defendants submitted that the meeting was convened for the lawful purpose of electing officials and facilitating compliance with the statutory requirements relating to registration of the Management Corporation. They relied on Kanyi & 3 Others v Nextgen Office Suites Limited & 4 Others [2023] eKLR and Regulation 24 of the Sectional Properties Regulations, 2021.
23. It was submitted that the Plaintiffs had not established a prima facie case because no right had been infringed and because the meeting had not taken place.
24. The Defendants further submitted that the Plaintiffs had not demonstrated irreparable harm and that the balance of convenience favoured the majority of unit owners who stood to benefit from the meeting.
25. On pleadings, the Defendants relied on Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & Another v Stephen Mutinda Mule & 3 Others [2014] eKLR, submitting that parties are bound by their pleadings and that the Court cannot grant relief on an issue that does not arise from the pleadings.
Analysis and Determination
26. The Court has considered the Notice of Motion herein, replying affidavit and submissions by Counsel for the parties. The dispute herein primarily relates to the management and administration of sectional property, the statutory Management Corporation established under the Sectional Properties Act and the authority to convene meetings of unit owners. The dispute similarly concerns the statutory obligations arising from registration of the sectional plan.
27. The Court of Appeal in Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielsen & 2 Others [2014] eKLR set out the three sequential requirements for granting an interlocutory injunction stating that:
“In an interlocutory injunction application, the applicant has to satisfy the triple requirements to;
(a) establish his case only at a prima facie level,
(b) demonstrate irreparable injury if a temporary injunction is not granted, and
(c) ally any doubts as to (b) by showing that the balance of convenience is in his favour.”
27. The Court then famously described these as:
“the three pillars on which rests the foundation of any order of injunction, interlocutory or permanent.”
28. On whether a prima facie case has been established, the starting point for the Court is Section 17 of the Sectional Properties Act, which provides:
1. On the registration of a sectional plan, there shall be constituted a Corporation under the name ‘The Owners, Sectional Plan No. (the number to be specified being the number given to the plan on registration)
2. The Registrar shall issue a certificate of registration of the corporation
3. A Corporation shall consist of all those persons—
(a) who are the owners of units in the parcel to which the sectional plan relates; or
(b) who are entitled to the parcel when the sectional arrangement is terminated under this Act.
4. The Corporation shall have perpetual succession and a common seal.
5. The Corporation shall be regulated in accordance with this Act and the bylaws specified in the regulations shall subject thereto, have effect in relation to the corporation and its board.
6. The provisions of the Companies Act (Cap. 486) shall not apply to the Corporation.
29. The language of the statute herein is clear and mandatory. It provides that the Corporation is constituted on registration of the sectional plan and it’s name is given. Section 17(3) provides that the membership of the Corporation is made of the owners of units in the parcel to which the sectional plan relates. Section 17(4) provides for perpetual succession and a common seal. Section 18 provides that the Corporation shall be capable of suing and being sued in its corporate name.
30. Section 26 provides for the Board of the Corporation and Section 27 provides for the Developer’s obligation to convene a meeting of the Corporation at which a board shall be elected. Section 27 provides:
When a developer registers a sectional plan, he shall within—
(a) ninety days from the day that fifty percent of the units are sold; or
(b) one hundred and eighty days from the day that the first unit is sold, whichever is sooner, convene a meeting of the Corporation at which a board shall be elected.”
31. From the foregoing, it is noted that Section 17 establishes the Corporation while Section 27 provides for the meeting at which its board is elected. The two are distinct events and the election of the board cannot, therefore, be treated as the event which creates the Corporation.
32. The statutory trigger for creation of the Corporation is registration of the sectional plan. Contaray to what is claimed by the Respondents, the provisions do not state that the Corporation comes into existence only after the election of its Board, appointment of office bearers or completion of an administrative process on the Ardhi Sasa platform.
33. Regulation 9 of the Sectional Properties Regulations requires an application for registration of the Corporation to accompany the application for registration of the sectional plan, and provides for the registration of the Corporation and issuance of its certificate. The Regulations therefore reinforce rather than contradict this position.
34. The Court therefore finds, at this interlocutory stage, that the statutory framework recognises one Corporation constituted under Section 17 in respect of the registered sectional plan. The name of the said corporation is provided for and provision is made that the Registrar is to issue a certificate of registration of the corporation. The Defendants have not placed before the Court the certificate of incorporation issued by the Registrar or evidence demonstrating that “Sandalwood Gardens Management Corporation” is the Corporation constituted under Section 17 in respect of Sectional Plan No. CFAGVQ3HOE. In the Court’s view, the mere description of a meeting as a meeting of “Sandalwood Gardens Management Corporation” does not establish that the entity is the statutory Corporation.
35. The decision in Kanyi & 3 Others v Nextgen Office Suites Limited & 4 Others [2023] KEELC 16434 (KLR) does not assist the Defendants to the extent that it is relied upon as authority for the establishment of a parallel entity. The Court there considered the statutory requirement relating to the Corporation and the unit owners. The Court in the above case did not authorise the creation of a separate management corporation outside the statutory framework.
36. The Defendants have placed considerable reliance upon the fact that the meeting scheduled for 14th March 2026 was intended to facilitate the election of the Board. To that extent, the Defendants' argument has merit. The election of the Board is an essential part of the statutory governance structure. The Regulations expressly contemplate election of members of the Board as business at a general meeting of the Corporation.
37. In the Court’s view, the difficulty for the Defendants is that if the meeting was a meeting of the statutory Corporation for purposes of electing its Board, then it ought to have been conducted by that statutotry Corporation. If, on the other hand, it was a meeting of a separate entity known as “Sandalwood Gardens Management Corporation,” the Defendants must demonstrate the legal basis upon which that separate entity could exercise or purport to exercise the statutory functions of the Corporation established under section 17.
38. On the material presently before the Court, the Defendants have not satisfactorily shown this. The Court is unable, at this stage, to accept the proposition that the statutory Corporation could be bypassed simply because the Developer considered it necessary to facilitate the management of the development.
39. The Court is therefore satisfied that the Plaintiffs have demonstrated a legal right under the statutory framework which calls for protection pending the determination of the suit. The Court thus finds that a prima facie case has been established.
40. The second question is whether the Plaintiffs will suffer irreparable injury if the injunction is not granted. The alleged injury in the present case concerns the governance structure of the sectional development and not merely a monetary claim. If a meeting is convened through an entity whose statutory authority is not demonstrated, resolutions may be made purporting to constitute management organs or otherwise regulate the affairs of the development. Such an occurrence could result in competing governance structures and further disputes.
41. The Court is satisfied that the threatened injury is sufficiently serious and is not adequately addressed by an award of damages.
42. Having found that the Plaintiffs have established a prima facie case and demonstrated the possibility of irreparable injury, the Court considers the balance of convenience. In the Court’s view, the balance favours preservation of the statutory governance framework.
43. The injunction does not prevent the Developer from complying with Section 27 of the Sectional Properties Act and the Regulations thereunder. It only prevents the exercise of the functions of the statutory Corporation through an entity whose legal foundation has not been demonstrated.
44. It would therefore be more prejudicial to allow a disputed governance structure to be established pending trial than to preserve the position contemplated by the statute.
Declaratory reliefs
45. On the prayers remaining for determination, prayer 3 seeks a declaration that the meeting held on 6th December 2025 under the name “Sandalwood Gardens Management Corporation” was irregular, unlawful and of no legal consequence. Prayer 4 seeks a declaration that only The Owners of Sectional Plan No. CFAGVQ3HOE Management Corporation has authority to convene meetings of unit owners. In the Court’s view, these are final declaratory orders. Their grant at an interlocutory stage would substantially determine the substantive dispute between the parties.
46. The Court will therefore not make final declarations at this interlocutory stage. The legality of the meeting of 6th December 2025 and the status and authority of the entity described as “Sandalwood Gardens Management Corporation” shall be finally determined upon hearing of the substantive suit.
47. Prayer 5 seeks an order directing the Developer to convene the first meeting of owners using the statutory Corporation within thirty days. The order sought is mandatory in nature. In Kenya Breweries Ltd & Another v Washington O. Okeyo [2002] 1 EA 109, the Court of Appeal stated:
“A mandatory injunction ought not to be granted on an interlocutory application in the absence of special circumstances.”
48. The Court further stated that a higher degree of assurance is required before such an order can be granted. In the present case, the Court has found it necessary to preserve the statutory position, but there remain issues concerning the registration and operationalisation of the Corporation and the steps to be undertaken by the parties under the Act and Regulations. The mandatory order sought under Prayer 5 is therefore not appropriate for determination at this interlocutory stage.
49. The Defendants contend that the application introduces a dispute not pleaded in the Plaint. The principle that parties are bound by their pleadings is settled that the Court cannot grant a relief founded upon a cause of action which has not been pleaded. However, the present application concerns the management of the same sectional development and invokes rights and obligations arising under the Sectional Properties Act. The Court is called upon to consider whether the subject matter should be preserved pending determination of the suit. The objection therefore does not, in the circumstances of this interlocutory application, defeat the Plaintiffs’ prayer for preservation.
Conclusion
50. The Court is satisfied that the Plaintiffs have established the requirements for the grant of a prohibitory interlocutory injunction pending hearing and determination of the suit herein.
51. The Defendants have not demonstrated, at this stage, that the entity described as “Sandalwood Gardens Management Corporation” is the statutory Corporation constituted under Section 17 of the Act or that it has independent statutory authority to exercise the functions of that Corporation.
52. The Court will, however, refrain from making the final declarations sought under Prayers 3 and 4 and from granting the mandatory order sought under Prayer 5 at this stage.
Dispositive orders
53. Accordingly, the Court allows the Notice of Motion dated 2nd February 2026 in the following terms:
1) Pending the hearing and determination of the suit, an injunction is hereby issued restraining the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Defendants, their servants, agents, employees or any person acting under their authority from convening, purporting to convene, presiding over, conducting or facilitating meetings of unit owners through any entity other than The Owners of Sectional Plan No. CFAGVQ3HOE Management Corporation.
2) For avoidance of doubt, this order does not prevent the Developer from taking any steps lawfully required under Section 27 of the Sectional Properties Act, 2020, including convening a meeting of the statutory Corporation in accordance with the Act.
3) Prayers 3 and 4 and 5 are declined at this interlocutory stage and shall abide the hearing and determination of the substantive suit
4) Costs of the application shall be in the cause.
Delivered, dated and signed via Microsoft Teams this 8th day of October 2026.
HON. L. G. KIMANI
JUDGE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
The Ruling read in the presence of-
M/s Achola holding brief for Kenyariri for Plaintiff
M/s Achieng for Respondents