Background
The Plaintiff filed suit against the Defendants and sought the following orders;
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The Plaintiff filed suit against the Defendants and sought the following orders;
Paragraph 1 →Having read and considered the pleadings, the evidence adduced at the hearing, and the written submissions, the key issue for determination is whether the Plaintiff has proven his case.
Paragraph 22 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC NO. E043 OF 2025
RICHARD KAMAU - PLAINTIFF
VS
ANNETTE WAMBUI KAMAU - 1ST DEFENDANT
BARON CAPITAL LIMITED - 2ND DEFENDANT
JUDGEMENT
Introduction and Pleadings
1. The Plaintiff filed suit against the Defendants and sought the following orders;
a. A declaration that the purported charge registered as entry No. 2 over L. R. No. 11884/12 [ suit land] on 8/5/24 in favour of the 2nd Defendant is illegal, irregular, fraudulent, null and void.
b. An order directing the Land Registrar, Nairobi Registry, to rectify the register by cancelling the charge registered in favour of the 2nd Defendant as entry No. 2 over the suit land.
c. An order of permanent injunction restraining the 1st and 2nd Defendants, their agents, servants and/or employees from interfering with the Plaintiffs' ownership and user and /or in any way dealing with the suit land.
d. General damages
e. Costs of the suit
2. The Plaintiff states that the 1st Defendant is his mother and that both are duly registered as co-owners of the suit land as tenants in common. In May 2024, he received an email from the 2nd Defendant demanding repayment of a loan his mother obtained, with the suit land as collateral.
3. He promptly conducted a title search, which verified that the title had been unlawfully encumbered to secure a loan of Kshs 713,830/- from the 2nd Defendant without his consent, knowledge, or authorisation. Consequently, he urged the Court to find the charge fraudulent, illegal, null, and void. The particulars of the Defendants' fraud and illegality are set out in paragraph 9 of the Plaint.
4. That the actions of the Defendants have occasioned loss and mental anguish to him
5. The 1st Defendant, despite service, failed to enter an appearance or file a statement of defence.
6. The 2nd Defendant denied the Plaintiff's claim in its entirety and sought strict proof of all the allegations.
7. Admitting that the Defendants are tenants in common of the suit land, he contended that the 1st Defendant charged her undivided share of the suit land and secured a loan from the 2nd Defendant. The Plaintiff was aware of and a party to the transaction throughout, and executed the requisite documents, thereby binding himself to the charge. On that basis, the 2nd Defendant advanced the loan in good faith as a bona fide chargee, without any notice of fraud, illegality or collusion with the 1st Defendant. In addition, the Plaintiff has not demonstrated any loss arising from the transaction. In any event, the 2nd Defendant is prejudiced by the default in repayment of the outstanding loan.
8. Richard Kamau testified and relied on his witness statement dated 14/5/25 and produced documents marked as PEX No 1-10 in support of his case.
9. He stated that he and the 1st Defendant are tenants in common and proprietors of the suit land having inherited it from his grandfather. He stated that the 1st Defendant is his mother.
10. He stated that unknown to him, his mother secured a loan from the 2nd Defendant, using the suit land as collateral. He confirmed that he neither signed the loan agreement nor the charge documentation. He became aware of the loan in May 2024 through an email from the 2nd Defendant demanding that he service the credit facility extended to his mother. Upon receiving the email, he promptly searched the title deed, which confirmed a charge of Kshs 717,830/- registered on 8/05/2024.
11. He stated that at the time his mother obtained the purported loan, he was residing in the United States of America. He left Kenya on 2/05/2021 and returned on 4/12/2024. He stated that he was unaware of the loan facility and that his consent had never been sought. He thereafter caused a restriction to be registered against the title on 5/9/24.
12. In April 2025, he received a 45-day redemption notice and a notice of sale of the property due to default in loan repayment. He instructed his lawyer to write to the 2nd Defendant and the auctioneer, contesting the proposed sale of the suit land on the basis that the Court had issued orders on 10/2/35 restraining the sale of the land, and that these orders had been duly served on the 2nd Defendant.
13. In addition, the witness reiterated that his purported signature is a forgery and the charge, by extension, is fraudulent, illegal, null and void.
14. In cross-examination, he stated that he did not report any forgery to the Police. He also stated that he did not seek to enter any judgment against the 1st Defendant for failing to enter an appearance or file a defence in the suit. Although he denied executing the charge, he confirmed that the accompanying documents, being the ID, photographs, and PIN, are his. He stated that he does not know how the 2nd Defendant obtained his personal documents. He added that he did not appear before the advocate to attest his signatures, nor did he execute any documents before the alleged advocate. In any event, he was out of the country at the time.
15. Samuel Kinyanjui Ngotho testified and relied on his witness statement dated 27/10/25 and produced documents marked as DEX No 1- 12.
16. He stated that he is the sole Director of the 2nd Defendant, a non-deposit Micro Finance Institution engaged in the business of advancing loan facilities in Kenya.
17. That in April 2024, the 1st Defendant sought and obtained a loan of Kshs 713830/-, repayable within 30 days at an interest rate of 20% per month. The suit land was offered as security. Upon searching the security, it was found to be co-owned with her son, the Plaintiff, as tenants in common. Accordingly, the Plaintiff and the 1st Defendant executed a charge document, which was registered against the title in favour of the 2nd Defendant.
18. That the loan was granted to the 1st Defendant in good faith, based on duly executed documents and the registered charge, without any knowledge of defects or illegality. The witness denied any collusion with the1st Defendant concerning the transaction and argued that the Plaintiff was fully aware of the transaction at all times, having provided consent and signed the charge instrument, thereby evidencing his involvement in creating the charge.
19. He added that the Plaintiff and the 1st Defendant have brought the suit in bad faith to avoid paying the outstanding loan. That their conduct is a deliberate scheme to defraud the 2nd Defendant.
20. In cross-examination, he stated that he had never met the Plaintiff and that it was the 1st Defendant who collected the documents for the son's execution. He admitted that the 1st Defendant alone executed the loan agreement. He was unaware that the Plaintiff resided abroad. He did not verify whether the Plaintiff appeared before Advocate Paul Mwangi to execute the charge documents. He mentioned that Advocate Paul Mwangi was not a witness in the case and denied any conspiracy with the 2nd Defendant regarding the transaction. He acknowledged that no valuation was conducted before the loan was disbursed to the 1st Defendant. He estimated the property at Kshs 15 million. He confirmed that, following the default, he instructed the auctioneer to sell the property to recover the outstanding loan.
21. At the close of the hearing, the parties elected to file and exchange written submissions. Save for the 2nd Defendant, none of the parties complied. I have read and considered the said submissions in reaching the judgment.
Analysis and determination
22. Having read and considered the pleadings, the evidence adduced at the hearing, and the written submissions, the key issue for determination is whether the Plaintiff has proven his case.
23. It is not in dispute that the Plaintiff is the son of the 1st Defendant and that both are registered proprietors of the suit land. It has not been disputed that the 1st Defendant entered into a loan agreement dated 29/4/2024 with the 2nd Defendant, which the 1st Defendant executed alone. Under the said loan agreement, the 1st Defendant sought a facility of Kshs 713,830/- at an interest rate of 20% per month. The agreement further provided that the suit land would be offered as collateral.
24. It is commonly acknowledged that a charge was created on 7/5/24 and subsequently registered against the title on 8/5/2024. The parties executed the charge, and Mr Paul Mwangi, Advocate, attested to their signatures. The Plaintiffs' PIN, ID and photographs are annexed to the charge.
25. The Plaintiff avers that he did not execute the documents and that the signatures on the charge documents are forgeries. He contends that the charge was procured by fraud and illegality and is therefore null and void, and invites the Court to cancel and rectify the title accordingly.
26. It is trite that he who alleges must proof. The burden of proof in civil cases is on a balance of probabilities. The burden of proof is anchored in statute. Sections 107 – 109 of the Evidence Act provide;
107. Burden of proof
(1) Whoever desires any Court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts must prove that those facts exist.
(2) When a person is bound to prove the existence of any fact it is said that the burden of proof lies on that person.
108. Incidence of burden
The burden of proof in a suit or proceeding lies on that person who would fail if no evidence at all were given on either side.
109. Proof of particular fact
The burden of proof as to any particular fact lies on the person who wishes the Court to believe in its existence, unless it is provided by any law that the proof of that fact shall lie on any particular person.
27. From the above provisions, it is clear that the burden of proof lies with the Plaintiff to prove her case to the standard of balance of probabilities.
28. It is settled that the Court cannot infer fraud. Fraud must be pleaded and particularised in the pleadings. In the case of Vijay Morjaria vs Nansingh Madhusingh Darbar & Another [2000] eKLR, the Court stated as follows:
“It is well established that fraud must be specifically pleaded and that particulars of the fraud alleged must be stated on the face of the pleading. The acts alleged to be fraudulent must, of course, be set out, and then it should be stated that these acts were done fraudulently. It is also settled law that fraudulent conduct must be distinctly alleged and distinctly proved, and it is not allowable to leave fraud to be inferred from the facts.” [Emphasis added].
29. Looking at the Plaint, the Court is satisfied that particulars of fraud have not only been pleaded but particularised under para 13 of the Plaint.
30. The standard of proof in matters fraud was settled by the Court in the case of Kinyanjui Kamau vs George Kamau [2015] eKLR when it expressed itself as follows;-
“… It is trite law that any allegations of fraud must be pleaded and strictly proved. See Ndolo vs Ndolo (2008) 1 KLR (G & F) 742 wherein the Court stated that: “....We start by saying that it was the Respondent who was alleging that the will was a forgery and the burden to prove that allegation lay squarely on him. Since the Respondent was making a serious charge of forgery or fraud, the standard of proof required of him was obviously higher than that required in ordinary civil cases, namely proof upon a balance of probabilities; but the burden of proof on the Respondent was certainly not one beyond a reasonable doubt as in criminal cases....”....In cases where fraud is alleged, it is not enough to simply infer fraud from the facts."
31. After a thorough examination of the evidence submitted by the Plaintiff, the Court concludes that the Plaintiff has not provided substantial proof that he did not sign the charge document or that his signature is forged. The Plaintiff could have obtained such evidence through the testimony of a qualified expert, such as a handwriting analyst, who could confirm the signature's authenticity. Without an expert witness, the Court cannot accept the Plaintiff's assertions. Furthermore, the Plaintiff has presented an alibi, claiming that he was abroad during the relevant period of the loan's procurement and the execution of the charge. However, this alone does not prove that he was unaware of the transaction, did not sign the documents, or that the signature is forged. In my view, this evidence is unsubstantiated and unpersuasive.
32. Final disposal orders
a. In the end, I find that the Plaintiff has failed to prove his case to the required standard.
b. Accordingly, the same is dismissed with costs to the 2nd Defendant.
33. Orders accordingly
DELIVERED, DATED AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 8TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026 VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS.
J. G. KEMEI
JUDGE
Delivered Online in the presence of:
1. Ms. Muthoni H/B for Ms. Wanjiku Maina for the Plaintiff
2. N/A for 1st Defendant
3. Mr. Simiyu for the 2nd Defendant
4. CA – Mr. Boniface