REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELCEP JR NO. E002 OF 2026 [ORIGINATING MOTION]
FRIENDS OF KARURA COMMUNITY
FOREST ASSOCIATION - APPLICANT
VS
KENYA FOREST SERVICE - 1ST RESPONDENT
NATIONAL YOUTH SERVICE - 2ND RESPONDENT
THE HON. ATTORNEY GENERAL - 3RD RESPONDENT
JUDGEMENT
Background
1. The Applicant moved this Court under the provisions of Articles 22, 23, 42, 47 and 258 of the Constitution and the Fair Administrative Actions Act [FAAA] and the Rules and the Forest Management and Conservation Act [FCMA] 2016 vide the Originating Motion dated 5/3/26, later amended on 26/3/26, seeking the following orders.
a. Spent
b. Due to the urgency and the Applicant’s unanswered letter dated 24/02/2026, the Applicant be and is exempt from further pursuing internal reliefs under Section 9(4) of the FAAA.
c. Pending the hearing and determination of the application, a conservatory order does issue suspending the ongoing or intended construction and excavation in and within the Karura Forest, including at the Rangers Village area, pending the hearing and determination of this application.
d. Pursuant to Article 23 of the Constitution of Kenya, the Court does grant the following or other applicable judicial review reliefs.
(i) A declaration does issue that the failure to relocate the Rangers’ Village from, and the intended construction of an NYS settlement, inside Karura Forest violates Articles 42, 47, and 69 of the Constitution.
(ii) An order or prohibition does issue, restraining the Respondents, whether by themselves or by their agents, servants, contractors, or any persons acting under their authority, from cutting, uprooting, or clearing trees, or from allocating land use within Karura Forest for the construction of any human settlement, including at the Rangers Village.
(iii) An order does issue preserving the status of Karura Forest and barring the Respondents from any construction or other activity likely to degrade, alienate, or otherwise interfere with the ecological integrity of the Karura Forest.
(iv) An order of Mandamus does issue compelling KFS to relocate from the forest within 24 months of the Court's order the 29 houses currently forming the Rangers Village to the designated location outside the forest fence but within the Kenya Forest Service Headquarters Compound.
(v) A structural interdict does issue directing the 1st Respondent to file an affidavit within;
a) 6 months
b) 12 months
c) 18 months
d) 24 months of the order
Illustrating the steps it has taken to comply with the order for relocation of the Ranger Village.
2. The application is supported by the grounds on the face of it and the supporting affidavit of Dr Karanja Njoroge, deponed on 6/3/26.
3. It was deponed that Kenya Forest Service’s [KFS] primary mandate under FCMA is to conserve, protect and manage all public forests in the Republic of Kenya in accordance with the provisions of the Act.
4. It is stated that the Applicant is a Community Forest Association registered under the Societies Act and, together with the 1st Respondent, actively participates in the management and conservation of Karura Forest [Forest] pursuant to the Forest Management Agreement [FMA or agreement] dated 21/4/2021 and the Karura Forest Plantation Management Plan in accordance with the [management plan] [FCMA]. Previous agreements executed in 2010, 2013, 2018 and 2020 between the parties evidence the parties' historical joint stewardship in managing and conserving the forest.
5. The Applicant avers that the joint management agreements supplement the Ngong Road and Karura Forest Plantation Management Plan [hereinafter called Ngong Kenya the Plan in accordance with Section 47 of the FCMA.
6. Under the Management plan, the Applicant and KFS agreed to relocate 29 ranger houses currently within the forest to a designated location outside the forest but within the KFS headquarters compound. In furtherance of the said agreement, the Applicant funded the construction of 26 houses; however, KFS allocated them to other staff and left the Rangers' village intact, contrary to the agreed arrangement.
7. The Applicant is therefore aggrieved that contrary to the Karura Forest Participatory Management Plan 2021-2026 [participatory plan], KFS has failed to relocate the 29 houses from the Ranger Village (Kijiji) to the designated location.
8. Further, on or about 22/11/24, it noticed that KFS, without consulting and/or involving the Applicant, unilaterally authorised a group to cut down trees and uproot stumps using heavy machinery at the Old Rangers Village, west of Junction [15] [b], which is well within the area under joint management, as per the beacon coordinates listed in Annex 3 of the agreement.
9. That its letter dated 24/2/26 seeking clarification did not elicit any response from KFS.
10. The Applicant has invoked the provisions of Articles 22 and 23 of the Constitution. It is averred that KFS has, inter alia, violated Articles 10, 42, 47, and 69 of the Constitution and various sections of the Fair Administrative Action Act.
11. It was averred that the 1st Respondent failed to relocate the Ranger Village from the forest to the designated location as planned under the Karura Forest Participatory Management Plan 2021-2026.
12. It was further averred that KFS acted contrary to the provisions of sections 4 and 64 of the FCMA by purporting to clear the forest to pave the way for the construction of an NYS settlement at the old Rangers village located about 1 kilometre from the KFS headquarters.
13. The Respondents' actions have continually undermined joint management and conservation of Karura Forest. That the decision to cut trees and uproot stumps without involving the Applicant, its co-manager, contravenes Articles 10 and 47 of the Constitution. By failing to inform both the public and the co–managers of the intended development activities, KFS failed to uphold the national values of governance, inclusivity, and accountability in the management of public resources.
14. Furthermore, KFS was alleged to have neglected to uphold the principles of sustainable development and the tenets of the precautionary principle in the utilization, management, and conservation of the environment and natural resources, specifically in its failure to undertake necessary precautions when making decisions that could potentially cause irreversible harm to the environment.
15. The Applicant maintains that, because Karura Forest is jointly managed, it must be informed of any planned activity likely to affect the forest's ecological integrity, such as tree clearing or the construction of settlements within the forest. KFS has never given any reason to support the said activities.
16. The Applicant avers that, under the management plan, it has a legitimate expectation that the Rangers village would be relocated by 2026 and that no further settlement would be established within the Karura Forest. The management plan contemplated relocating the Rangers Settlement to the KFS headquarters to safeguard the forest ecosystem. KFS's decision to permit the establishment of NYS barracks within the forest is inconsistent with these conservation objectives and violates the Applicant's legitimate expectations. Further, before KFS makes any administrative decision likely to adversely affect the forest's ecological health, the Applicant should be afforded a fair hearing, including prior notification and meaningful consultation. KFS's decision to permit afforestation without informing the Applicant violates its legitimate expectations and is amenable to review.
17. It was further averred that KFS, by failing to afford its co-managers an opportunity to be heard before commencing felling of trees, violated their right to a fair hearing, enshrined in Articles 47 and 50 of the Constitution and in Sections 4 (1), 7 (2) (a) (v) and 7 (2) (c) of the FAA, a right that is constitutionally protected.
18. Under the 2021-26 Management Plan, the Applicant and KFS jointly committed to build 34 houses and to relocate the 29 houses at the Rangers’ Village, originally situated within the forest, to the vicinity of the KFS Headquarters. Nonetheless, to date, KFS has failed to fulfil its public duty to relocate the Rangers’ Village. By failing to relocate the village, KFS has also failed to adhere to a public obligation mandated by the statutory management plan. Furthermore, the Respondents have initiated this litigation because KFS is establishing additional residences within the primary forest block.
19. In the end, it was averred that the continued clearing and development in the forest threaten irreversible ecological damage, including the loss of indigenous vegetation and wildlife, habitat destruction, and environmental degradation, which cannot be adequately remedied by damages.
The 1st Respondent's Response
20. The 1st Respondent opposed the Motion vide the Replying affidavit sworn by A L Lemarkoko, the Chief Conservator of Forests, who deponed that;
a. Karura Forest is a gazetted forest measuring 2570 acres comprising three blocks. It hosts its headquarters and other Government and international installations. KFS manages it under FCMA and through a Participatory Forest Management Model.
b. Under Section 45 of the FCMA, KFS entered into a forest management agreement with the Applicant to facilitate the collaborative and participatory forest management model.
c. The benefits accruing from the participatory model of management include: employment creation for forest communities such as Muji Wa Huruma, Githogoro, Deep Sea and Mathare areas; enhanced forest protection, as communities adjacent to the forest provide a social buffer zone for the forest; support for the livelihoods of forest communities; proceeds from the user rights under the agreement go towards supporting vulnerable communities; and outreach education and research programmes in respect of forest conservation and management.
d. Karura Forest management programmes include natural forest management [conservation and protection], research, development, outreach, and ecotourism development.
e. That all public forests have rangers, villages, or camps established within them for strategic reasons, including rapid responses to threats such as logging, poaching, forest encroachment, and forest fires; continuous surveillance of activities in the forest ecosystem; protection of sensitive ecosystems and fragile habitats; support for conservation activities such as patrols and biodiversity monitoring; management trials and infrastructure; and guidance for visitors and enforcement of forest regulations.
f. It is contended that the proposed relocation of Rangers village camp from within Karura Forest is ill-advised for the following reasons: it weakens the protection and conservation of the forest; it creates a security vacuum, undermining effective surveillance and exposing ecologically sensitive habitats to potential degradation and unauthorised development; and the proposed relocation is fraught with inconsistencies, lacks transparency, and is contrary to the principles of sustainable forest management and the public interest.
g. In respect of establishing nursery sites within the forest to achieve 30% tree cover by 2032, the Ministry of Environment, Climate Change and Forestry is implementing the 15 Billion tree growing and restoration campaign. KFS has therefore been directed to rehabilitate tree nurseries for raising tree seedlings across all forests, including Karura.
h. That the site identified for the nursery expansion is about 3 acres and is situated within the Tree Biotechnology Trust Programme nursery [an existing set of three nurseries] at KFS headquarters.
i. To accommodate additional nursery staff from NYS, a camp has been proposed within the existing Rangers Camp, which comprises 29 houses serving as rangers' residences. This camp dates back to the colonial era, and the justification for accommodating the NYS staff is the availability of essential amenities, such as water and electricity, that serve the camp.
j. Site clearing was carried out on 13th and 15th February 2026, with grass and shrubs removed. A total of 9 stumps were also uprooted to prepare for the fabricated container units.
k. Admitting that the Applicant and KFS have a joint management framework for the management and conservation of the forest, which requires consultation in respect of any activities likely to affect the forest's ecological integrity, the Applicant's allegations of deforestation with a view to setting up a settlement within the forest are untrue. Furthermore, the Applicant knew or had reason to know that the rangers' camp predated the management agreement and that it is critical to achieving KFS's mandate under FCMA.
l. The deponent denied that KFS has reneged on the 2021-2026 management plan. He deposed that relocating the rangers' camp is not possible because of its critical role in the overall management and conservation of the forest.
m. The deponent refuted any alleged deforestation in Karura. The existing camp is being remodelled to serve the expanded role. Except for the proposed installation of fabricated container units to house NYS personnel, which covers approximately 0.68 acres, no new structures will be built on the suit land. The forest's ecological integrity will not be altered.
n. Regarding EIA and public participation approvals, the deponent stated that they are not necessary, as the site is in respect of an existing old camp, and that the exercise does not include tree felling, altering waterways, or interfering with biodiversity.
o. Although Section 48 of the FCMA requires meaningful public participation in the development and implementation of the forest management plans, there was no public participation prior to the signing of the 2021-2026 management plan with key stakeholders, particularly regarding the forest's security needs. The failure to ensure proper public participation on camp relocation renders the plan procedurally flawed and unconstitutional, and continuing to implement it in its current form will cause irreparable environmental harm to the forest.
p. The responsibility for managing the forest infrastructure rests with KFS. The allegation that it needed to consult the Applicant is legally unfounded and falls outside the scope of the joint management plan. On the contrary, the existing camp supports KFS operations, including establishing and expanding its tree nurseries towards the planned national tree cover of 30%. The camp will in no way interfere with vegetation cover or biodiversity, or affect flora and fauna in the forest. No evidence to the contrary has been placed before the Court.
q. Further, he deposed that the alleged constitutional violations are merely a pretext to claw back the provisions of the FCMA and to indirectly impose unreasonable conditions on KFS. In any event, it was averred that the Applicant failed to present an EIA or a social impact assessment to demonstrate that the camp's continued presence in the forest harmed the ecosystem or violated the right to a clean and healthy environment.
r. The Court was urged to dismiss the motion with costs.
The 2nd and 3rd Respondents response
21. The 2nd and 3rd Respondents never entered appearance and did not file any responses to the Originating Summons.
The Site Visit
22. At the request of the parties, the site visit was conducted on 23/3/26, and a report dated the same day was filed. The Court will refer to the report later in the judgment.
The written submissions
23. The parties elected to canvass the motion by way of written submissions. I have read and considered the submissions in the judgment. The Applicant filed written submissions dated 16/3/26 and supplementary submissions dated 27/3/26, while the 1st Respondent's submissions are dated 16/6/26.
24. Regarding the exhaustion of local remedies before filing the instant motion, the Applicant submitted that Section 9(2) of the FAAA requires exhaustion of internal appeal or review mechanisms and of all other remedies available under any written law before reviewing an administrative action or decision under the Act. In the instant case, the Applicant seeks to rely on the exemption provisions under Section 9(4) of the FAAA on two grounds, namely that KFS ignored the Applicant's letter dated 24/2/26, which was an attempt to resolve the matter amicably in good faith in accordance with the agreement dated 21/4/21, and that the instant application raises issues of constitutional violations which fall outside the purview of the dispute resolution mechanism provided for in the agreement.
25. Regarding whether the KFS breached the Applicant's legitimate expectation, the Applicant submits that Section 47 of the FCMA, the Ngong Road and Karura Forest Plantation Management Plan, and the Karura Participatory Forest Management Plan 2021–2026 (the Management Plan) established a framework for the joint and participatory management and conservation of Karura Forest by the Applicant and KFS. Under this framework, the parties were required to manage the jointly managed area collaboratively and consultatively to achieve the Management Plan's objectives.
26. The Applicant further submits that it had a legitimate expectation that KFS would inform and consult it before undertaking any plans to clear vegetation within the forest and would refrain from activities likely to undermine the forest's ecological integrity. However, KFS deliberately cleared a section of the forest to pave the way for establishing a settlement at the old Rangers' Camp without informing, consulting, or involving the Applicant. Such conduct not only breached the parties' agreement and the Management Plan but also violated the Applicant's legitimate expectation to participate meaningfully in the management, conservation, and protection of Karura Forest.
27. It was submitted that Article 42 of the Constitution guarantees every individual the right to a clean and healthy environment, including the right to have the environment protected for the benefit of present and future generations through legislative and other measures. Article 69 of the Constitution provides for the sustainable exploitation, utilisation, management, and conservation of the environment and natural resources, and ensures the equitable sharing of benefits, including public participation in the management and conservation of the environment, inter alia. It was also argued that public participation forms part of the precautionary principle outlined in Article 10(d) of the Constitution and Section 18 of the Environmental & Land Court Act, which enshrines sustainable development.
28. It was therefore submitted that KFS's permitting entry into and felling of trees to facilitate the development of a settlement within Karura Forest violated Article 69 of the Constitution. The lack of consultation with the community or the Applicant prior to undertaking these activities breached the constitutional requirement for public participation. The approved plan included relocating the Rangers residing within the forest to an alternative site within the headquarters to conserve the forest. KFS's unilateral actions in cutting trees to establish a settlement at the former Rangers' village were undertaken without public consultation and breached Articles 10, 42, 47, and 69 of the Constitution.
29. Regarding the question whether KFS committed an illegality, it was submitted that Karura Forest is governed by the framework established under the FCMA, the Management Plan, the Karura Participatory Forest Management Plan 2021-2026, and the Agreement. The Management Plan stipulates relocating the rangers' residences to the headquarters to promote the sustainable conservation of the forest. It was further submitted that by engaging in activities outside the scope of the Plan, KFS has committed an illegality.
30. Furthermore, the Applicant asserts that KFS engaged in procedural impropriety by authorizing access to the forest and facilitating the clearing of vegetation without first securing the necessary Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) license. It is contended that KFS was legally obliged to adhere to Section 58 of the Environmental Management and Co-ordination Act (EMCA), which mandated the conduct of a comprehensive environmental impact assessment and the submission of an Environmental Impact Study Report to the National Environment Management Authority (NEMA) prior to initiating any activity that could potentially have a significant environmental impact.
31. The Applicant further submits that clearing trees and vegetation within Karura Forest to establish a settlement for the 2nd Respondent's staff at the Old Rangers' Camp constitutes a project with potentially substantial environmental implications. Accordingly, it falls within the mandatory provisions of Section 58 of EMCA. The Old Rangers' Camp is part of the collectively managed area and had been designated for relocation to another site within the management framework. By proceeding with the activities in question without conducting the requisite environmental impact assessment and obtaining the necessary approvals from NEMA, KFS violated its statutory obligations and acted in a procedurally unfair and unlawful manner, thereby contravening the principles of sustainable environmental management.
32. The Applicant contended that, by failing to provide reasons for clearing the forest area, KFS acted unreasonably. Consequently, there was no justification for establishing the settlement within the forest, as the parties had planned to relocate the old rangers' camp to the headquarters; thus, establishing another settlement within the forest was deemed unreasonable.
33. After amending its originating motion on 26/3/26, the Applicants filed their supplementary submissions. Regarding whether KFS failed to perform its public duty to relocate the Rangers Village from the forest, the Applicant submitted that Section 11(f) of FAAA empowers the Court, in judicial review proceedings, to order an administrator to perform a public duty owed in law and in respect of which the Applicant has a legally enforceable right.
34. In the present case, the Management Plan reinforces the provisions of Sections 47(1) and 49(1) of the FCMA, which, when read together with the agreement, delineate roles for both parties to be executed either collaboratively or independently, thereby facilitating the sustainable, participatory management and conservation of the forest. It was contended that, since the Applicant and KFS had committed to build 34 houses and to relocate the 29 old houses at the Rangers village inside the forest to the vicinity of the KFS headquarters, to date, KFS has failed in its public duty to relocate the Rangers village, thereby failing to perform a public duty under the statutorily underpinned management plan. That this suit was triggered by KFS's attempts to install additional residences within the main forest block.
35. In conclusion, the Applicant urged the Court to grant the orders sought.
36. On the competence of the originating motion and whether the orders sought therein can be granted, KFS argued that although the Court is empowered under Art 23(2) of the Constitution to fashion appropriate remedies, including declarations, injunctions, conservatory orders, judicial review, and compensation, inter alia, the Applicants have led no evidence to substantiate that the Rangers village, in itself, is a threat to the rights protected under Arts 42 and 69 of the Constitution. It was submitted that the remedies outlined under Art 23(2) do not confer on litigants the right to seek judicial management of public institutions.
37. It was further submitted that, in paragraphs 47-51 of its replying affidavit, KFS disputed the claim that the parties had mutually agreed to relocate the Rangers Village. The issue of relocation therefore remains highly disputed and cannot be conclusively determined without viva voce evidence, which should be subject to cross-examination. Additionally, it was argued that the location of the Rangers' residences is an operational matter within forest administration and management, falling exclusively within KFS's mandate under Section 45 of the FCMA Act. Moreover, the Applicant has failed to demonstrate any constitutional right that the Rangers Village infringes, as it is a historic facility that existed before the implementation of the management plan.
38. It was submitted that relocating Rangers Village requires an elaborate plan to identify an alternative site, relocate personnel, and reorganise operations, a process that cannot be achieved through a structural interdict.
39. It was further submitted that the Rangers Village is integral to forest conservation and management. That the proposed work consists of refurbishing, rehabilitating, and improving the existing structures within the Rangers Village to support the expansion of a tree nursery, rather than establishing a new development within the forest, contrary to the Applicant's allegations. The expansion of the nursery supports the fulfilment of constitutional and statutory obligations imposed on KFS under Article 69 of the Constitution read together with the FCMA, aimed at strengthening forest management and increasing forest cover.
40. Regarding whether the refurbishment of the rangers' village and the construction of temporary accommodation structures resulted in deforestation, Counsel for the 1st Respondent stated that the facilities will be established within the boundaries of the existing rangers' village and operational zone; therefore, there will be no loss of forest cover or disruption of the forest's ecological integrity. It was further added that the structures will house personnel engaged in establishing tree nurseries and seedling propagation for conservation programmes. The Applicants have not adduced any evidence of tree felling, destruction of indigenous vegetation, reduction of tree cover, or loss of habitat.
41. Counsel for the 1st Respondent submitted that, in the absence of evidence that the forest has been cleared or that illegal activities are likely to harm it, the Applicants have failed to establish a prima facie case for injunctive relief. No irreparable harm has been proved, and the balance of convenience favours protecting the forest. Granting the orders sought would cripple the 1st Respondent's ability to fulfil its legal mandate.
42. It was further submitted that there is no basis for issuing prohibitory or mandatory orders, as no illegality, environmental damage, or breach of statutory provisions has been demonstrated to warrant them. It was argued that removing the Ranger’s village would compromise forest security, surveillance, law enforcement, and conservation initiatives.
43. In conclusion, Counsel added that effective forest management requires forest officers, rangers, and conservation personnel to be present in the forest; refurbishing the rangers' village and providing temporary accommodation and facilities for personnel enhance, rather than diminish KFS's capacity to discharge its constitutional and statutory obligations. The Court was urged to dismiss the motion.
Analysis and determination.
44. Having considered the amended originating motion, the supporting affidavit and the Replying affidavit and rival submissions, the key issue is whether the Applicant is entitled to the orders sought;
a. Whether the Applicant has sufficiently demonstrated grounds for exemption from exhaustion pursuant to Section 9(4) of the FAAA.
b. Whether public participation consultation and procedural fairness rights were breached.
c. Whether the activities of KFS in clearing of trees and vegetation at the Rangers Camp violated or threatened a violation of Articles 42 and 69 of the Constitution.
d. Whether mandamus and a structural interdict should issue.
e. Costs.
45. The Applicant asserts that, pursuant to the FCMA, the Ngong Road and Karura Forest Plantation Management Plan, the Karura Participatory Forest Management Plan 2021-2026 [the plans], and the Agreement, it benefits from a joint participatory framework for the management and conservation of Karura Forest in collaboration with KFS.
46. Under this legal framework, KFS is obliged to involve the Applicant in the forest’s management and conservation, to the extent permitted by law and its constitutive documents. Notwithstanding this framework, it is averred that KFS has unilaterally authorised an external group to enter the forest, cut down trees, and uproot stumps using heavy machinery, without prior consultation or participation by the Applicant, thereby contravening the established management model.
47. In addition, the Applicant asserts that, under the current management plan, the parties mutually agreed to relocate the Rangers' camp from its existing location within the forest to the vicinity of the headquarters to strengthen forest management and conservation measures. Despite this agreement, KFS is establishing new settlements at the site instead of carrying out the relocation, contrary to the management plan and without involving the co-manager (the Applicant).
48. The Applicant further contends that these actions infringe rights protected under Articles 42 and 69 of the Constitution and violate the Applicant's legitimate expectation to participate in forest management. The Applicant sent a letter to KFS on 24/2/26 but received no response; consequently, the Applicant filed this motion.
49. KFS, on the other hand, acknowledges the management model and its benefits for the forest communities, including job creation, community-led forest conservation, livelihood enhancement, and outreach and research initiatives. KFS further confirms that the Rangers' camp is a historic facility comprising 29 old houses that form the central infrastructure of Karura Forest, as it accommodates its Rangers and other security personnel essential to the forest's protection and conservation.
50. KFS admitted to clearing tree vegetation and shrubs at the joint management area /rangers' camp to establish additional accommodation for NYS personnel expected to assist in expanding the tree nursery within the Technology Trust Program nursery at KFS headquarters. KFS maintains that the nursery expansion aligns with its mandate under the Act and is geared towards increasing tree cover in the country. KFS argues that establishing additional accommodation is therefore justified and that the Applicant was not involved, as the expansion is operational in nature.
51. Regarding the proposed relocation of the camp from its current position to the headquarters area, KFS has expressed strong objection, arguing that the camp's optimal location is within the forest to support efficient unit operations, given the extensive forested area and the delicate ecological habitats, including fauna and flora, which require continuous monitoring and surveillance. Relocating the camp outside the forest is ill-advised, as it would adversely affect protection and conservation efforts, pose security risks, and undermine conservation objectives. KFS terms this proposal highly sensitive and contested.
Exemption from exhaustion mechanisms pursuant to Section 9(4) of the FAAA.
52. The subject dispute concerns the management of a public forest and the protection of environmental rights. Under Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution and Section 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act, those matters fall within this Court's jurisdiction. Article 70 and Sections 13(3) and 13(7) of the Act permit appropriate environmental, constitutional and judicial review relief within that jurisdiction.
53. The provisions of Article 69 of the Constitution state as follows;
“69. (1) The State shall— (a) ensure sustainable exploitation, utilisation, management and conservation of the environment and natural resources, and ensure the equitable sharing of the accruing benefits; (b) work to achieve and maintain a tree cover of at least ten per cent of the land area of Kenya; (c) protect and enhance intellectual property in, and indigenous knowledge of, biodiversity and the genetic resources of the communities; Constitution of Kenya, 2010 (d) encourage public participation in the management, protection and conservation of the environment; (e) protect genetic resources and biological diversity; (f) establish systems of environmental impact assessment, environmental audit and monitoring of the environment; (g) eliminate processes and activities that are likely to endanger the environment; and (h) utilise the environment and natural resources for the benefit of the people of Kenya. (2) Every person has a duty to cooperate with State organs and other persons to protect and conserve the environment and ensure ecologically sustainable development and use of natural resources.”
54. The Constitution, being the supreme law of the land, obligates the State to manage and conserve natural resources, including forests, sustainably to achieve and maintain a tree cover of at least 10% of the land in Kenya. It also obligates the State to encourage public participation in the management, protection, and conservation of the environment, eliminate processes and activities likely to endanger the environment, and share the benefits with Kenyans. Developing tree cover is therefore a constitutional mandate of the KFS.
55. That said, the Constitution also provides for a participatory model of forest management, which informs the agreement and management plan between the two parties. To my mind, the guiding principle makes participation a constitutional and statutory tenet, not a discretionary Courtesy. While KFS holds the forest in trust, the law gives forest-adjacent communities, who bear the greatest costs of deforestation, the right to co-manage and conserve the forest with KFS. Shared stewardship of forests and the environment is one channel through which Kenyans' conservation aspirations are realised.
56. The FCMA is an Act of Parliament that operationalises the provisions of Article 69 of the Constitution regarding forest resources; it provides for the development and sustainable management, including conservation and rational utilisation, of all forest resources for the country's socio-economic development and related purposes.
57. The FCMA sets out three primary dispute resolution mechanisms. First, Section 51 provides that, in cases concerning the termination or modification of a management agreement, the Chief Conservator of Forests (CCF) must notify the association at least thirty days before terminating or withdrawing user rights. This thirty-day notice period gives the association an opportunity to contest the decision to terminate or withdraw user rights. If the association considers the CCF's decision unjust, it may appeal to the Board within thirty days of receiving notice of the decision.
58. Secondly, Section 70 of the FCMA provides that any dispute that may arise in respect of forest conservation, management, or utilisation shall, in the first instance, be referred to the lowest level of the devolved system of government as set out in the County Government Act Cap 265.
59. Thirdly, any matter that may remain unresolved in the manner prescribed above shall be referred to the National Environment Tribunal [NET] for determination. An appeal from that determination shall, where applicable, lie to the ELC Court under the ELC Act.
60. Section 70 of the FCMA sets out the basis for a specialised dispute-resolution mechanism to adjudicate conflicts, disputes, or grievances arising from the implementation, administration, or enforcement of the FCMA. These disputes may include forest management, user rights, community participation, and administrative actions by KFS or other related bodies. The dispute-resolution framework offers aggrieved parties a clear pathway to seek redress and is designed to promote peaceful, equitable resolution of competing interests, so that environmental objectives are not frustrated by prolonged, unresolved legal or communal conflicts. Orderly conflict resolution serves the broader public interest by supporting the development, sustainable management, conservation, and rational or equitable utilisation of forest resources, and by fostering the constitutional principles of fair administrative action and access to justice. The provisions also ensure that disputes are addressed expeditiously and in line with the specialised nature of forest and environmental governance.
61. The dispute resolution mechanism provided in the Management Agreement provides as follows;
“a) In the event of any dispute, question, or disagreement arising from or relating to this Agreement, the parties hereto shall use their best efforts to settle the dispute, question, or disagreement. To this end, they shall consult and negotiate with each other in good faith and, recognising their mutual interests, attempt to reach a just and equitable solution satisfactöry to both parties.
(b) Where the Association is aggrieved by the decision of the Service on the implementation of this agreement, it may within thirty (30) days after being notified of the decision, appeal to the Board of the Service against the decision.
(c) Notwithstanding the above provisions with respect to dispute resolution, any party aggrieved under this Agreement may refer the matter to dispute resolution pursuant to Section 70 of the Forest Conservation and Management Act, 2016”.
62. The Agreement further provides that in the event of any disagreement regarding the activity work plans and/or their implementation under the management plan, the joint management committee established under Clause 14 of the agreement serves as a practical forum for discussion, for receiving concerns, and for seeking a joint solution. In my view, Clause 14 of the plan do provide a mechanism for dispute resolution at the lowest level contemplated by the FCMA.
63. Jurisdiction does not dispense with the exhaustion of alternative dispute resolution mechanisms. Section 9(4) of the Fair Administrative Action Act permits an exemption on application where exceptional circumstances exist and the interests of justice so warrant. The Applicant has expressly sought such an exemption on the grounds that it has not received a response to its letter dated 24/2/26 and that the motion is urgent.
64. In this case, the Applicant has raised constitutional issues concerning violations of rights protected under Articles 42 and 69 of the Constitution. In my view, the dispute resolution mechanism provided under the FCMA and/or the agreement, namely the joint management committee, the Board and the NET, lacks jurisdiction to address violations of constitutional rights. Furthermore, NEMA did not issue any decision granting or refusing a licence that would justify an appeal to the NET. Thirdly, the unanswered letter dated 24/2/26 shows KFS's unwillingness to engage in good-faith resolution of the dispute under the agreement and/or the FCMA, hence rendering it inefficient and therefore impractical for the Court to return the Applicant to it. For that reason, the Court finds that it is in the interests of justice to allow the exemption.
Whether public participation consultation and procedural fairness rights were breached.
65. Section 7 of FCMA established the KFS with functions outlined under section 8 of the said Act as follows;
“The functions of the Service shall be to—
(a) conserve, protect and manage all public forests in accordance with the provisions of this Act;
(b) prepare and implement management plans for all public forests and, where requested, assist in preparation of management plans for community forests or private forests in consultation with the relevant owners;
(c) receive and consider applications for licenses or permits in relation to forest resources or management of forests or any other relevant matter in accordance with this Act;
(d) establish and implement benefit sharing arrangements in accordance with the provisions of this Act;
(e) assist county governments to build capacity in forestry and forest management in the counties;
(f) in consultation with relevant stakeholders, develop programmes for tourism and for recreational and ceremonial use of public forests;
(g) promote forestry education and training;
(h) register and maintain a register of all forest management plans prepared for public forests;
(i) collaborate with relevant persons in identifying research needs and applying research findings in relation to forests and forestry;
(j) manage water catchment areas in relation to soil and water conservation, carbon sequestration and other environmental services in collaboration with relevant stakeholders;
(k) prepare—
(i) a Forest Status Report for the Cabinet Secretary once in every two years; and
(ii) a Resource Assessment Report for the Cabinet Secretary once in every five years;
(l) consider and recommend to the Cabinet Secretary the establishment of public forests on unalienated public land or any other public land;
(m) consider and recommend to the Cabinet Secretary the determination and alteration of boundaries of public forests;
(n) establish forest conservancy areas for purposes of conservation and management;
(na) collect revenue and charges due to the national government in regard to forest resources and services in accordance with the Public Finance Management Act;
(nb) provide security for public and provisional forests;
(nc) provide technical assistance to the county governments in the development of agroforestry and commercial forestry in community land.
(o) approve the provision of credit facilities and technical training for community-based forest industries, and the provision of incentives to persons for the sustainable utilization of wood and non-wood forest products;
(p) implement and enforce rules and regulations governing importation, exportation and trade in forest produce; and
(q) develop, maintain and regularly update a geographic information system database of all forests in Kenya.
66. It is not in dispute that KFS is responsible for conserving and managing public forests.
67. The Act provides a participatory management model for the management and conservation of public forests, including Karura. A participatory forest management approach deliberately involves forest-adjacent communities and other stakeholders in managing forests within a framework that supports communities' livelihoods.
68. The management model is captured under Sections 45 and 48 of the FCMA as follows;
“ 45. Forest management agreements
(1) The Service may advertise, receive applications from any person, institution or organization and through a competitive process, approve and enter into an appropriate management agreement for all or part of a public forest.
(2) A management agreement entered into under subsection (1) shall specify—
(a) the period for which the forest shall be managed;
(b) the terms and conditions under which the Applicant shall manage the forest;
(c) any royalties and charges payable in respect thereof to the Service;
(d) the mechanism for settlement of disputes arising in respect of the agreement; (e) the circumstances under which the agreement may be terminated; and (f) the benefits which the Applicant shall extend to the local community.
(3) Nothing in this section shall be deemed to transfer or to vest in any person, institution, or organisation any right of ownership of any land declared to be a public, other than the privilege of management and control.
(4) No management agreement shall convert a public forest into a settlement area.
(5) The Cabinet Secretary may prescribe Regulations to give effect to this section.
“48. Application for community participation
1) A member of a forest community may, together with other members or persons resident in the same area, register a community forest association in accordance with the provisions of the Societies Act (Cap. 108).
2) A community forest association registered in accordance with this section may apply to the Service for permission to participate in the conservation and management of a public forest:
3) Provided no such application shall be made where there is an existing prior agreement or license in relation to that forest.
4) An application made in accordance with this section shall be in the prescribed form and shall provide—
a. a list of the members of the association and its address;
b. the Constitution of the association;
c. the association's financial regulations;
d. the area of forest for which the association proposes to undertake conservation and management;
e. the association's proposals concerning—
(i) use of forest resources;
(ii) methods of conservation of biodiversity;
(iii) methods of monitoring and protecting wildlife and plant populations and enforcing such protection; and
f. such other information as the Chief Conservator of Forests may require.
5) Where the Service grants permission in accordance with this section, it may impose such conditions as it may deem fit including the development of a forest management plan in accordance with this Act.
6) The Service shall maintain an up to date record of all associations that have been granted permissions in accordance with this section.”
69. Section 41 outlines what a joint management of a forest entails. It states as follows;
“41. Joint management of forests
(1) A forest owner may enter into an agreement with any person for the joint management of any forests for a period to be specified in the agreement.
(2) The agreement referred to in subsection (1) may enjoin such person to use or refrain from using such forest or any part thereof in order to ensure the conservation of biodiversity:
Provided that where an agreement enjoins such person to use or refrain from using the forest in any particular manner, it shall contain modalities of payment of compensation to such person for any loss incurred thereby.
(3) Where any person enters into an agreement in accordance with subsection (1) of this section, the agreement shall be enforceable against such person or his successors in title, assignees or any or all other persons deriving title from him.
(4) Nothing in this section shall render enforceable any conservation agreement entered into under subsection (1) where the use of such forest in accordance with such agreement contravenes the provisions of any law for the time being in force, or is inconsistent with any prior agreement relating to the use of such forest and which is binding on such owners, their successors in title.”
70. It is also undisputed that the parties have a participatory management arrangement. The question is whether KFS could proceed with the proposal to establish a new settlement in the forest without involving the Applicant.
71. As stated above, Sections 45 and 47 of the Forest Conservation and Management Act concern management agreements and plans. The obligations and roles of the Applicant and KFS are set out in Clauses 11 and 12 of the Agreement. Under Clause 13, the parties’ joint obligations include maintaining the fence, gates, buildings, and necessary infrastructure. Both parties are required to jointly prepare work plans and budgets for each financial year for approval by the KFS board.
72. Sections 48 and 49 of FCMA address community participation and the obligations of forest associations. However, the Applicant’s participation does not displace KFS’s statutory mandate. Equally, KFS’s mandate does not exclude the constitutional requirements of lawful and fair administrative action.
73. Under Table 19 of the Plan, the parties planned to relocate the 29 houses to the vicinity of KFS headquarters. KFS describes the works as refurbishment of an existing camp to accommodate additional manpower for establishing the tree nurseries. It is their position that, being an expansion, it remains an operational issue that requires no participation of the Applicant. However, its own account includes clearing and preparation for additional fabricated accommodation units within an identified footprint. The pictures annexed to the joint site visit show vegetation clearing and apparent ground levelling.
74. Articles 10, 47 and 69(1)(d) of the Constitution, read with Sections 4 and 5 of the Fair Administrative Action Act, require an appropriately participatory and fair process for administrative action affecting environmental interests. The extent of participation depends on the nature of the proposals and the persons affected. However, in the circumstances of this case, FCMA and the agreement have set out the scope of participation. Although the Act does not give the Applicant a veto over every operational decision of KFS, KFS cannot ignore the Applicant's involvement and participation, both of which are statutory.
75. It is trite that public participation must be both meaningful and qualitative. In the case of British American Tobacco Kenya, PLC (formerly British American Tobacco Kenya Limited) v Cabinet Secretary for the Ministry of Health & 2 others; Kenya Tobacco Control Alliance & another (Interested Parties); Mastermind Tobacco Kenya Limited (The Affected Party) [2019] eKLR, the Supreme Court succinctly expressed that meaningful public participation ought to have the following components:
a) clarity of the subject matter for the public to understand;
b) structures and processes (medium of engagement) of participation that are clear and simple;
c) opportunity for balanced influence from the public in general;
d) commitment to the process;
e) inclusive and effective representation;
f) integrity and transparency of the process;
g) capacity to engage on the part of the public, including that the
h) public must be first sensitised on the subject matter.”
76. As summarised, KFS’s response discloses no prior notice, no disclosure of the proposal, and no opportunity for the Applicant to make representations before implementation. KFS’s position was that such involvement was unnecessary. Given the admitted management Agreement, the plan, and the provisions of the FCMA and the Constitution, the Court cannot accept KFS’s position. Holding otherwise would reduce the Applicant from a real conservation partner to a spectator. Public participation, as one of the value systems ingrained in our Constitution, is a constitutional imperative in the conservation and management of natural resources, including forests. KFS cannot take it otherwise. It is not a discretionary Courtesy to be doled out at will.
77. On the basis of legitimate expectation, the admitted participatory arrangement supports the Applicant’s expectation of consultation regarding the material establishment of the NYS settlement within the jointly managed area.
78. I therefore find that the failure to afford meaningful prior consultation breached the Applicant’s right to fair administrative action in relation to clearing trees and vegetation and to establishing temporary accommodation for the NYS staff, notwithstanding its intended purpose.
Whether the activities of KFS in clearing of trees and vegetation at the Rangers Camp violated or threatened a violation of Articles 42 and 69 of the Constitution;
79. Art 42 of the Constitution provides as follows;
“Every person has the right to a clean and healthy environment, which includes the right—(a)to have the environment protected for the benefit of present and future generations through legislative and other measures, particularly those contemplated in Article 69; and (b) to have obligations relating to the environment fulfilled under Article 70.”
80. Article 69 of the said Constitution binds the State, here KFS, to ensure the sustainable exploitation, utilisation, management, and conservation of the forest, and to ensure the equitable sharing of resources by eliminating processes and activities that are likely to endanger the environment. The State is further mandated to encourage public participation in the management, protection, and conservation of the environment, and to eliminate processes and activities that are likely to endanger the environment.
81. The Applicant contends that to the extent that the EIA approvals were required for the tree clearing and levelling of the footprint near the Rangers Camp, KFS, in failing to procure the same, violated the right to a clean and healthy environment and KFS's obligation to manage the forest sustainably.
82. KFS responds that the camp already exists and that the new works will not affect biodiversity. The issue is whether that explanation is sufficient to dispense with the process prescribed by the Constitution and EMCA.
83. The site report dated 23/3/26 describes the findings on the ground as follows;
“Upon inspection, it was established that there was no construction ongoing at the site. However, there was evidence of limited site clearing, primarily involving shrubs and tree stumps. The site also serves as a residential camp for KFS, with 29 old housing units. Upon inquiry by the Court, the management of KFS indicated that the area had been identified and designated for temporary accommodation of NYS personnel who were to be housed in containers and are to assist in raising tree seedlings [nursery is located in a different site].”
84. The site report remains undisputed. Section 75 of FCMA provides that where a provision of this Act requires a person to conserve or protect the environment, the relevant provisions of the Environmental Management and Co-ordination Act (Cap. 387) also apply with respect to how the conservation or protection proceeds.
85. Section 58 of EMCA, read with the Second Schedule and the applicable assessment regulations, sets out the assessment requirements for a project. The appropriate process depends on the project's classification and environmental setting. Not every repair requires a full impact study. Conversely, an existing facility does not provide a general exemption for additional development. The Provision of Regulation 17, 18, 21 and 22 of EMCA [assessment and audit] are relevant.
86. No assessment or determination under NEMA supporting the claimed exemption is identified in KFS’s response, as summarised. Its assurance that ecological integrity will be maintained cannot substitute for the applicable regulatory process. Removing top vegetation, shrubs, and tree stumps constitutes environmental disturbance. The precautionary principle guides the exercise of environmental conservation when credible risks exist, even amid scientific uncertainty. Article 70 of the Constitution permits intervention to prevent threatened infringement and does not require proof of loss. In this case, additional accommodation within a gazetted public forest is proposed, and preparatory works have commenced without demonstrated consultation or regulatory compliance. These circumstances justify issuing a confined prohibitory order pending compliance. They do not, based on the material provided, warrant a conclusion that the historic Rangers Village is inherently unconstitutional or that all construction throughout the forest must be halted. The Court will issue final orders at a later stage.
Whether mandamus and a structural interdict should issue
87. The Applicant seeks orders to compel KFS to relocate 29 houses within 24 months. To obtain a writ of mandamus, the Applicant must show that KFS has failed to perform a public duty. In Kenya National Examination Council v Republic, ex parte Geoffrey Gathenji Njoroge & 9 others [1997] eKLR, the Court of Appeal clarified the scope of this remedy and distinguished between compelling the performance of a duty and directing a specific exercise of discretion.
88. Table 19 of the Management Plan provided that the parties shall secure funding to relocate Rangers from within the Forest to headquarters. Although a management plan may form the basis of an enforceable obligation, the circumstances of this case show that the parties did not disclose the considerations informing the planned activity. Neither party disclosed the approval process, conditions, or implementation provisions. The time frame was not provided, so as to hold KFS is liable for the delay in compliance. Other considerations include funding, the suitability of the proposed location, KFS’s technical input, and the availability of an alternative location. The Court agrees with KFS that the security of the Forest requires careful consideration. The Applicant averred that it constructed 26 houses for the Rangers, but KFS housed its staff instead, contrary to the intended purpose. KFS has not responded to this averment. For those reasons, and given the apparent contestations over the viability of the relocation exercise, the Court is unable to compel KFS by way of an order of mandamus.
89. Final orders for disposal
a) In the end, the Motion succeeds in part. The prayer concerning interim conservatory relief is overtaken by the final determination.
b) The Applicant is exempted under section 9(4) of the Fair Administrative Action Act from further exhaustion solely for determination of this motion, on the grounds stated above.
c) It is declared that KFS’s implementation of preparatory works for the proposed additional NYS accommodation at the Rangers Village, without prior meaningful consultation with the Applicant, breached the Applicant’s right to fair administrative action under Article 47 of the Constitution and the joint participatory management obligations under the FCMA, the Plan and the Agreement.
d) KFS, and persons implementing the proposed new settlement under its authority, are prohibited from further site clearing, excavation, installation of additional accommodation units or expansion of the proposed NYS accommodation footprint at the Rangers Village until proper and meaningful consultation and participation and environmental compliance requirements have been fulfilled.
e) For clarity, the prohibitory order in [d] above applies to the site clearing, excavation and installation of the additional accommodation proposal. It does not restrain existing ranger occupation, patrols, forest protection, nursery operations, or necessary ordinary repairs within the established footprint, provided those activities comply with applicable law.
f) The prayers compelling relocation of the 29 houses, requiring periodic relocation reports, and prohibiting all human settlement or all construction throughout Karura Forest are declined pending appropriate public participation as well as environmental review/compliance.
g) Each party shall bear its own costs, considering the public environmental interest, the Applicant’s partial success and the continuing participatory management agreement between the parties.
90. Orders accordingly
DELIVERED, DATED AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 8TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026 VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS.
J G KEMEI
JUDGE
Delivered online in the presence of:
1. Mr. Seda H/B for Mr. Muchiri for the Applicant
2. N/A for the Respondents
3. CA – Mr. Boniface