REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC NO. E115 OF 2023
GLADWELL WAIRIMU NGIGI ……………………………………1ST PLAINTIFF
TERESA WANJIRU MBARIA ……………………………………2ND PLAINTIFF
SALOME NDUTA MBARIA …………………………………….3RD PLAINTIFF
MONICA NYAMBURA MBARIA …………………………..…4TH PLAINTIFF
GRACE WAMBUI MBARIA ……………………………………5TH PLAINTIFF
=VERSUS=
JAMES MUCHINA MBARIA …………………………………1ST DEFENDANT
JACKSON MUCHINA MBARIA ……………………………2ND DEFENDANT
ANNTHONY GITAU MBARIA ………………………………3RD DEFENDANT
RULING
1. Before the Court for determination are two applications. The first application is a Notice dated 5th December 2025 brought under Sections 1A, 1B, 3, 3A, 63( e) and 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rules 1 and 2 and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules in which the Defendants/Applicants seek the following orders:
a) THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to review and/or vary the ruling of the Court delivered on 31st October 2025.
b) THAT the costs of the application be provided for.
2. The application is based on the grounds appearing on its face together with the supporting affidavit of James Muchina, the 1st Defendant, sworn even date.
THE DEFENDANTS CASE
3. The deponent averred that the Plaintiffs and the Defendants are siblings, born of the same father. He averred that the ruling delivered on 31st October 2025 was pursuant to the Defendants' preliminary objection to the Plaintiffs' Motion dated 7th May 2025, which objection was upheld and the Motion struck out with costs.
4. He further averred that the subject matter of the suit comprises the parcel of land known as 36/VII/1023 (originally 36/VII/232), registered in the Defendants' names. He deposed that the suit property was transferred to the Defendants by their late father, Joseph Mbaria Muchina, in 2016, as evidenced by the certificate of title.
5. The deponent contends that although this Court correctly found that it lacked jurisdiction to entertain issues relating to the distribution of a deceased person's estate, it erred in holding that the suit property belonged to Joseph Mbaria Muchina and therefore formed part of his estate. He further contends that this finding was erroneous and should be reviewed or varied.
6. He averred that the entire dispute concerns ownership of the suit property. He argued that the finding at the interlocutory stage was erroneous, as it would compromise the entire suit.
7. The second application is a Notice of Motion dated 27th January 2026, brought under Sections 1A, 1B, 3A, 63(e) and 80 of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 45 Rule 1 and 2 and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules in which the Plaintiffs/Applicants seek the following orders:
a) THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to review and/or vary the ruling of the Court delivered on 31st October 2025.
b) THAT the costs of this application be in the cause.’
c) THAT the Honourable Court be pleased to make such further order as it may deem just and expedient in the circumstances of this case.
8. The application is based on the grounds appearing on its face together with the supporting affidavit of Teresa Wanjiru Mbaria, the 2nd Plaintiff, sworn on even date and a supplementary affidavit sworn on 26th February 2026.
9. The deponent averred that the ruling delivered on 31st October 2025 contained a manifest and self-evident error, apparent on the face of the record. She stated that the certificate of title for the suit property is registered in the Defendants' names and is not part of the estate of the late Joseph Mbaria Muchina.
10. She contended that the primary issue in the main suit was the lawfulness, validity, and alleged fraudulent nature of the transfer of the suit property from the late Joseph Mbaria Muchina to the Defendants, which falls within this Court’s jurisdiction. She stated that the application dismissed by the ruling of 31st October 2025 did not seek any succession-related orders, but purely preservatory and protective measures over the proceeds generated from the suit property, directing that the proceeds be held in a joint interest-earning account in the names of both advocates on record, pending determination of the main suit, with the object of protecting the proceeds from dissipation, misuse, or unjust enrichment and ensuring that the outcome of the substantive suit was not rendered nugatory.
11. She argued that by dismissing that application and upholding the Defendants' preliminary objection on the ground that the matter ought to be ventilated before the Succession Court, this Court had misapprehended both the nature of the relief sought and the legal status of the suit property, thereby determining prematurely the issues that remained contested. She maintained that the application for preservatory orders was consequently dismissed in error, despite the underlying dispute centring on ownership, title, and alleged fraud.
12. She argued that unless the error is reviewed and corrected, and the application dated 7th May 2025 reinstated and determined on its merits, there is a real and imminent risk that the proceeds from the suit property would be dissipated, misapplied, or otherwise rendered irrecoverable, occasioning grave and irreparable prejudice to the Plaintiffs and undermining the final determination of the main suit. Accordingly, she urged the court to allow the application as prayed.
THE DEFENDANTS CASE
13. The Defendants filed a replying affidavit, sworn by the 1st Defendant on 2nd March 2026, in opposition to the application. The deponent averred that the impugned ruling cannot be reviewed, as the Plaintiffs proposed, by reinstating their Motion. He reiterated that the struck-out application had been dismissed for want of jurisdiction because it raised issues relating to the succession of the late Joseph Mbaria Muchina.
14. He further averred that the late Muchina died testate, having left a written will setting out the distribution of his estate, which is the subject of Nyahururu HCP&A No. E24 of 2024, In the Matter of the Estate of Joseph Mbaria Muchina.
15. The deponent contends that the struck-out application and its supporting affidavit introduced the late Muchina’s will into the proceedings, asserted that the suit property was listed in and bequeathed under the will to six beneficiaries, and raised issues concerning the distribution, administration, and protection of the deceased’s estate and the interests of its beneficiaries. He further contends that these matters were preserved for determination in the succession cause and that the supporting affidavit was misleading.
16. He averred that, given this reliance on the will and the estate-related matters raised, the struck-out application could not be resuscitated by way of review, as this court lacks jurisdiction in light of the pending Nyahururu Succession Cause. He further averred that the suit property had been registered in the Defendants' name since 2016, a period of almost ten years, and that the Defendants' use, control, management, and enjoyment of the rent therefrom cannot be halted on the basis of mere allegations of fraud. In conclusion, he urged the Court to dismiss the application with costs.
17. Both applications were canvassed by way of submissions.
THE 1ST DEFENDANT’S SUBMISSIONS
18. The 1st Defendant filed their submissions dated 5th March 2026.
19. On behalf of the 1st Defendant, Counsel submitted that both parties sought to review the ruling of 31st October 2025 on different grounds, and that the two applications should be addressed separately.
20.Counsel set out the law governing applications for review under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and under Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules. Counsel submitted that the Courts had clarified the grounds for review as being an error apparent on the face of the record, the discovery of new and important evidence, or any other sufficient reason.
21.Regarding the Defendants' application, counsel submitted that the Plaintiffs admitted the error apparent on the face of the ruling. Counsel further submitted that the ruling stated that it was not in dispute that the suit property belonged to Joseph Mbaria Muchina, whereas the certificate of title showed it was registered in the names of the three Defendants. Relying on Swai v Kenya Breweries Limited (Civil Appeal 275 of 2010) [2014] KECA 883 (KLR), Counsel contended that a review is permissible to correct an apparent error or omission that is self-evident and requires no elaborate argument. Counsel further submitted that the admitted error was self-evident and justified a review strictly limited to correcting that error, without extending to any other aspect of the ruling.
22.Regarding the Plaintiffs' application, Counsel submitted that the Plaintiffs had mischaracterized the error on the record as an error of law, whereas the struck-out application dated 7th May 2025 had in fact been dismissed for want of jurisdiction over succession matters. Counsel submitted that this holding was not an error on the face of the record but a correct statement of the law on jurisdiction.
23.Counsel contended that the Plaintiffs' request for the ruling to be set aside and substituted with one allowing the struck-out application amounted in substance to an appeal and a relitigation of the jurisdictional question, and that the proper remedy was an appeal, not a review.
24.Counsel submitted that the Plaintiffs' complaints that the Court had misapprehended the nature of the reliefs sought and had prematurely determined contested issues were matters of legal interpretation, properly challengeable only on appeal, thereby rendering the Plaintiffs' application an appeal disguised as review. Counsel relied on Swai v Kenya Breweries Limited to submit that an erroneous conclusion of law is not a ground for review but a ground for appeal. Counsel argued that permitting review on that basis would expose functus officio courts to collateral attack on their own decisions.
25.Counsel further submitted that the struck-out application concerned the management of the late Joseph Mbaria Muchina's estate and that several grounds challenged the late Mbaria's will, including the assertion that the suit property had been bequeathed to six of his children under it. Counsel admitted that the suit property was listed on page 3 of the will but argued that it was a matter for the succession court, as the will was the subject of Nyahururu HCP&A No. E24 of 2024.
26.Counsel submitted that ground 13 of the struck-out application, which invited the Court to consider the orderly administration of the estate and the protection of beneficiaries' interests, necessarily required determining what constituted the estate and who its beneficiaries were, matters within the Nyahururu Succession Court's jurisdiction. Accordingly, Counsel submitted that the court had correctly declined jurisdiction over the struck-out application, and any dissatisfaction lay in appeal rather than review.
27.In conclusion, Counsel urged the Court to allow the Defendants' application and to dismiss the Plaintiffs' application with costs.
THE PLAINTIFF’S SUBMISSIONS
28.The Plaintiffs filed their submissions dated 18th March 2026.
29.On behalf of the Plaintiffs, counsel submitted that Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules empower the Court to review its decision on the grounds of an error apparent on the face of the record, the discovery of new evidence, or any other sufficient reason. Counsel further submitted that the Plaintiffs relied primarily on the first ground.
30.Counsel further submitted that the Court's finding in paragraph 31 of the ruling dated 31st October 2025, that it was not in dispute that the suit property belonged to Joseph Mbaria Muchina, deceased, and therefore formed part of his estate, was contradicted by the certificate of title, which shows that the suit property is registered in the names of the Defendants. Counsel submitted that this error was self-evident, required no elaborate argument to establish, and was not contested by either party.
31.Counsel relied on Republic v Principal Secretary, Ministry of Internal Security & Another Ex Parte Schon Noorani & Another [2020] KEHC 9791 (KLR), in which Mativo J, citing Attorney General & Others v Boniface Byanyima and Levi Outa v Uganda Transport Company, described an error apparent on the face of the record as one so manifest and evident that it required no extraneous matter to demonstrate its incorrectness. Counsel submitted that, as both parties agreed that the statement did not reflect the position shown in the title documents, the Plaintiffs had satisfied the threshold for review.
32.Counsel opposed the Defendants' position that review should be confined to correcting the factual statement, while the order striking out the application for want of jurisdiction remained undisturbed. Counsel submitted that the Court's finding on jurisdiction was entirely premised on the erroneous belief that the property formed part of the deceased's estate. Counsel argued that this error had prematurely determined a contested factual question of ownership which directly informed the dismissal of the application.
33.Counsel further submitted that, as a matter of law, property registered in the Defendants' names cannot form part of the estate unless and until the disputed transfer is nullified by a court of competent jurisdiction. Counsel argued that the substratum of the suit, namely the legality, validity, and alleged fraudulent character of that transfer, fell squarely within the jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court rather than the Succession Court. Counsel submitted that, because the jurisdictional finding flowed directly from the documented factual error, correcting the error required a corresponding correction of the legal conclusion built upon it.
34.Regarding the third issue, Counsel invoked Section 112 of the Evidence Act on the burden of proof in civil proceedings, and relied on M'Bita Ntiro v Mbae Mwirichia & Another [2018] eKLR to submit that a party seeking judgment on a legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts must prove those facts. Counsel submitted that the Plaintiffs had discharged this burden and had demonstrated the effect of the factual error on the Court's ultimate conclusion. In conclusion, Counsel urged the Court to review its decision, correct the error, and reinstate the Plaintiffs' application dated 7th May 2025 for determination on its merits.
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION
35.Having considered the applications, the respective affidavits and the rival submissions, the following issues arise for determination:
i. Whether the 1st Defendant’s application dated 5th December 2025 is merited
ii. Whether the Plaintiffs’ application dated 27th January 2026 is merited.
36.The law governing applications for review is set out in Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules. Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act Cap 21 provides as follows:
“Any person who considers himself aggrieved—
a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed by this Act, but from which no appeal has been preferred; or
b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is allowed by this Act, may apply for a review of judgment to the court which passed the decree or made the order, and the court may make such order thereon as it thinks fit.”
37.Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides as follows:
“1. (1) Any person considering himself aggrieved—
a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed, but from which no appeal has been preferred; or
b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is hereby allowed, and who from the discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence, was not within his knowledge or could not be produced by him at the time when the decree was passed or the order made, or on account of some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or for any other sufficient reason, desires to obtain a review of the decree or order, may apply for a review of judgment to the court which passed the decree or made the order without unreasonable delay.”
38.The provisions of Order 45 were restated by the Court of Appeal in Benjoh Amalgamated Limited & Another vs Kenya Commercial Bank Limited (2014) eKLR where the Court held that:
“In the High Court, both the Civil Procedure Act in Section 80 and the Civil Procedure Rules in Order 45 Rule 1 confer on the court power to review. Rule 1 of Order 45 shows the circumstances in which such review would be considered, ranging from discovery of new and important matter or mistake or error apparent on the face of the record or any other sufficient reason, but Section 80 gives the High Court greater amplitude for review.”
39.Similarly, in Republic vs Public Procurement Administrative Review Board & 2 Others (2018) eKLR, the Court held that:
“Section 80 gives the power of review, and Order 45 sets out the rules. These rules restrict the grounds for review. The rules lay down the jurisdiction and scope of review.”
40.Both applications are based on the fact that there is an error apparent on the face of the ruling delivered on 31st October 2025.
41.In National Bank of Kenya Limited v. Ndungu Njau [1997] KECA 389 (KLR) quoted in Swai v Kenya Breweries Limited (Civil Appeal 275 of 2010) [2014] KECA 883 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held that:
“A review may be granted whenever the court considers that it is necessary to correct an apparent error or omission on the part of the Court. The error or omission must be self-evident and should not require an elaborate argument to be established. It will not be a sufficient ground for review that another Judge could have taken a different view of the matter. More can it be a ground for review that the Court proceeded on an incorrect exposition of the law and reached an erroneous conclusion of law. Misconstruing a statute or other provision of law cannot be ground for review.”
issue which has been hotly contested as in this case cannot be reviewed by the same Court which had adjudicated upon it.”
42.Similarly, in Nyamogo & Nyamogo v Kogo [2001] EA 170, the Court stated as follows:
“An error apparent on the face of the record cannot be defined precisely or exhaustively, there being an element of undefinitiveness inherent in its very nature and it must be determined judicially on the facts of each case. There is a real distinction between a mere erroneous decision and an error apparent on the face of the record. Where an error on a substantial point of law stares one in the face, and there could reasonably be no two opinions, a clear case of error apparent on the face of the record would be made out. An error which has to be established by a long drawn process of reasoning on points where there may conceivably be two opinions can hardly be said to be an error apparent on the face of the record. Again, if a view adopted by the court in the original record is a possible one, it cannot be an error apparent on the face of the record even though another view was possible. Mere error or wrong view is certainly no ground for review though it may be one for appeal.”
WHETHER THE 1ST DEFENDANT’S APPLICATION FOR REVIEW IS MERITED
43.The 1st Defendant seeks review of the ruling dated 31st October 2025 on the ground that this Court erred, at paragraph 31, in stating that "It is not in dispute that the property belongs to Joseph Mbaria Muchina, deceased, and therefore forms part of his estate."
44.In the impugned ruling, this Court noted that the Plaintiffs challenge the transfer of the suit property to the Defendants on the ground of fraud. The legality of that transfer is the crux of the suit. The certificate of title shows the suit property registered in the Defendants' names. The registered ownership of the suit property is therefore not in dispute, though the legality of the transfer is contested.
45.The error is self-evident on the face of the certificate of title, requires no elaborate argument to establish, and is conceded by the Plaintiffs.
46.This Court finds that there is an error apparent on the face of the record. The statement is hereby expunged from paragraph 31 of the ruling dated 31st October 2025. For the avoidance of doubt, nothing in the ruling dated 31st October 2025, or in this ruling, constitutes a determination of ownership of the suit property. That question remains for determination at the trial.
WHETHER THE PLAINTIFFS’ APPLICATION FOR REVIEW IS MERITED
47.The Plaintiffs urged this Court to set aside the order dated 7th May 2025 striking out their application, to reinstate that application, and to grant the preservation orders sought therein. Their contention is that the finding on jurisdiction flowed directly from the erroneous statement, and that correcting the error necessitates a corresponding correction of the legal conclusion built upon it.
48.The Plaintiffs have not controverted the 1st Defendant's averment that the application dated 7th May 2025 introduced the will of the late Joseph Mbaria Muchina, stated that the suit property was bequeathed thereunder to six beneficiaries, and, at ground 13, invited this Court to consider the orderly administration of the estate and the protection of the interests of its beneficiaries. The will is the subject of Nyahururu HCP&A No. E24 of 2024, In the Matter of the Estate of Joseph Mbaria Muchina.
49.The decision to decline jurisdiction over that application was a determination of a contested question, namely whether the reliefs sought were preservatory measures in a dispute over title or were directed at the administration of an estate pending before the Succession Court. The Plaintiffs' contention that this Court misapprehended the nature of the reliefs sought and prematurely determined contested issues invites this Court to re-evaluate the application and reach a different conclusion on the same material. It is therefore not an error apparent on the face of the record.
50.The Plaintiffs' contention that this Court reached an erroneous conclusion on its jurisdiction is a ground for appeal, not for review. To reinstate the application and determine it afresh would amount to this Court sitting in appeal over its own decision, which is not permissible.
51.To the extent that the Plaintiffs' application sought to correct the impugned statement, that prayer has been addressed under the first issue. This Court finds that the remainder of the Plaintiffs' application is without merit.
52.The upshot of the foregoing is that this Court makes the following orders:
iii. The Defendants' application dated 5th December 2025 is merited and is hereby allowed.
iv. The statement "It is not in dispute that the property belongs to Joseph Mbaria Muchina, deceased, and therefore forms part of his estate" is hereby expunged from paragraph 31 of the ruling delivered on 31st October 2025. The ruling otherwise stands.
v. Save to the extent of order (b), the Plaintiffs' application dated 27th January 2026 is devoid of merit and is hereby dismissed.
vi. Each party to bear its own costs.
RULING SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS THIS 9TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
…………………………………….
HON. T. MURIGI
JUDGE
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
Lochi holding brief for Waceke for the Plaintiffs
Thuku for the Defendants
Vena - Court assistant