Land law

Ndungu v Wangechi [2026] KEELC 6558 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Environment and Land Case E179 of 2023
Judgment date
9 October 2026
Judge(s)
TW Murigi

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

By a Plaint dated 17th November 2023, the Plaintiff seeks judgment against the Defendant as follows:

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

In the end, I find that the Plaintiff has not proved his case against the Defendant on the balance of probabilities, as required by law.

Paragraph 31 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELCLC E179 OF 2023

JOHN NDUNGU …………………………………………………… PLAINTIFF

=VERSUS=

PAUL GICHANE WANGECHI …………………………………… DEFENDANT

JUDGEMENT

1.By a Plaint dated 17th November 2023, the Plaintiff seeks judgment against the Defendant as follows:

i. An order of permanent and perpetual injunction restricting the Defendant, whether by himself, his agents, proxies and/or third parties, from encroaching, trespassing, erecting illegal structures, excavating, constructing, developing, blocking access roads or in any manner interfering with the Plaintiff's peaceful enjoyment, use and utilization of his property, Land Reference No. 36/V/167, original number 36/V/4/50 situate in the City of Nairobi.

ii. An order of eviction do issue, evicting the Defendant, his agents, proxies and/or third parties or anyone acting under his name or behest from the suit property, Land Reference No. 36/V/167, original number 36/V/4/50, situate in the City of Nairobi, with immediate effect.

iii. General Damages for trespass.

iv. Cost of this suit.

v. Interest on (c) and (d) above.

vi. Any other relief that this Honourable Court may deem fit to grant.

2.The Defendant entered appearance but did not file a Defence. The matter proceeded as an undefended suit.

THE PLAINTIFF’S CASE

3.The Plaintiff, John Ndungu, testified as PW1 and was the sole witness in support of his case. He adopted his witness statement dated 17th November 2023 as his evidence-in-chief. He also produced the documents in his list in support of his evidence.

4.The Plaintiff testified that he is the registered proprietor of L.R. No. 36/V/167 (originally Number 36/V/4/50), situated in the City of Nairobi and measuring approximately 0.0242 hectares, by virtue of an indenture of conveyance. He further stated that he had constructed a four-storey building on the suit property, which accommodates approximately sixty tenants, both residential and commercial.

5.He further testified that the Defendant, without any colour of right or justification, encroached upon and trespassed on the suit property and unlawfully constructed semi-permanent mabati structures, which were converted into kiosks without the Plaintiff's consent or permission. He relied on the particulars of the alleged trespass set out in paragraph 5 of the plaint as follows:

a) Entering and taking possession of the Plaintiff’s property without his knowledge, permission and/or consent.

b) Illegally and unlawfully constructing semi-permanent makeshift mabati structures on the Plaintiff’s land without his consent and/or authority.

c) Operating the said structures as kiosks.

d) Blocking the Plaintiff from accessing his property.

e) Preventing the Plaintiff from carrying out meaningful development on his property.

f) Preventing the Plaintiff from earning income and/or commercial gain on his property.

6.The Plaintiff contends that the illegal constructions blocked all access roads to the property, thereby denying him access. He stated that the Defendant commenced excavation works to erect permanent structures, during which part of the existing building was demolished, thereby interfering with the tenants' peaceful occupation. He further stated that the front shops he had constructed using container sheets were vandalised by the Defendant and his associates to forcibly create space for illegal constructions activities.

7.He further testified that the Defendant had rendered the premises uninhabitable by erecting illegal structures and by the conduct of youths to whom the kiosks had been let, thereby driving away prospective tenants. The Plaintiff pleaded that he had plans to construct a modern storey building on the suit property but was unable to realise them owing to the illegal structures and the hostility occasioned by persons allegedly planted on the property by the Defendant.

8.He explained that despite several attempts to have the Defendant vacate the property and demolish the illegal structures, the Defendant refused to vacate, despite having no right, claim, or interest in the suit property. In conclusion, he urged the Court to grant the orders sought in the Plaint.

9.After the hearing concluded, the Plaintiff filed written submissions in support of his case.

THE PLAINTIFF’S SUBMISSIONS

10.The Plaintiff filed his submissions dated 12th February 2026.

11.On behalf of the Plaintiff, Counsel relied on Section 3 of the Trespass Act, which criminalises entering, remaining on, erecting structures on, cultivating, tilling or grazing stock on private land without the occupier's consent and without reasonable excuse. Further reliance was placed on the Court of Appeal's decision in Doshi v Chemutut & 7 Others (Civil Appeal E020 of 2023) [2025] KECA 776 (KLR), which held that trespass is an injury to a possessory right, that the proper plaintiff is the person with title or deemed possession at the time of trespass, and that a plaintiff must prove a right to immediate and exclusive possession.

12.Counsel submitted that the Plaintiff’s ownership of the suit property as evidenced by the indenture was not contested. Counsel further submitted that the Defendant trespassed and encroached on the property's entrance by constructing semi-permanent mabati structures converted into kiosks, thereby blocking the tenant's access to the suit property. He further relied on Municipal Council of Eldoret v Titus Gatitu Njau [2020] eKLR, which applied M'Mukanya v M'Mbijiwe (1984) KLR 761, to submit that trespass violates the right to possession, which is distinct from ownership, and requires proof of a right to immediate and exclusive possession. Counsel submitted that the Plaintiff, as the rightful owner, is entitled to quiet possession and access to the suit property, which the Defendant's structures have hindered.

13.Counsel also relied on Section 12 of the Trespass Act, which empowers the Court to order the removal of persons, families, stock and property from land. Counsel further relied on Ricks v Cheber & Another [2025] KEELC 4247 (KLR) to submit that a title owner's right to absolute and exclusive possession cannot be realised where a third party interferes with that right, and that an eviction order secures such exclusivity. Counsel submitted that, having proved encroachment and trespass, the Court should issue an eviction order to halt the continuing illegality and restore the Plaintiff’s exclusive possession and occupation.

14.Counsel further relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Attorney General v Zinj Limited (Petition 1 of 2020) [2021] KESC 23 (KLR) to submit that any loss arising from a tortious act attracts redress, including an award of damages, with the quantum depending on the nature of the right violated, the extent of the violation and the gravity of the injury. Further reliance was placed on Ricks v Cheber & Another [2025] KEELC 4247 (KLR), which held that damages for trespass must be assessed in accordance with established principles to reflect either the diminution in value or the cost of reinstating the land. Counsel asserted that the overriding purpose of awarding damages for trespass is to restore the claimant to his position before the harm.

15.Counsel submitted that the Plaintiff had repeatedly notified the Defendant of the encroachment, but the Defendant failed to stop the trespass. Counsel further submitted that, having established the trespass, the Plaintiff should be awarded general damages to restore him to his prior position.

16.In conclusion, Counsel urged the Court to grant the prayers sought in the Plaint with costs.

ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION

17.Having considered the Pleadings, the evidence on record and the Plaintiff's submissions, the following issues arise for determination:

vii. Whether the Plaintiff proved trespass against the Defendant; and

viii. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the orders sought.

18.The Plaintiff contends that the Defendant has, without any colour of right, trespassed on the suit property. The record shows that the Defendant entered an appearance and filed an application to be reinstated to the property following an alleged demolition. In the supporting affidavit, the Defendant admitted ownership of four kiosks constructed on the road reserves adjacent to Plot No. 36/5/167.

19.Although the suit was undefended, the Plaintiff has a duty to prove his case on a balance of probabilities, as required by law. Section 107 of the Evidence Act provides as follows:

(1) Whoever desires any court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts must prove that those facts exist.

(2) When a person is bound to prove the existence of any fact, it is said that the burden of proof lies on that person.

20. In Karugi & Another v Kabiya & 3 Others [1983] eKLR, the Court of Appeal held that:

“The burden is on the plaintiff to prove his case remains the same, though it is true that, where the matter is not defended, or, as here, validly defended, that burden may become easier to discharge.

21. Similarly, in Gichinga Kibutha Vs Caroline Nduku (2018) eKLR, the Court held that;

“It is not automatic that instances where the evidence is not controverted the Claimants shall have his way in Court. He must discharge the burden of proof. He must prove his case however much the opponent has not made a presence in the contest.”

WHETHER THE PLAINTIFF PROVED TRESPASS AGAINST THE DEFENDANT

22. Section 3 (1) of the Trespass Act provides as follows:

"Any person who without reasonable excuse enters, is or remains upon or erects any structure on, or cultivates or tills or grazes stock or permits stock to be on, private land without the consent of the occupier thereof shall be guilty of an offence.”

23. Trespass has been defined by Clerk and Lindley in Torts, 18th edition as;

“any unjustifiable intrusion by one person upon the land in possession.’’

24. In Doshi v Chemutut & 7 others (Civil Appeal E020 of 2023) [2025] KECA 776 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held that trespass is an injury to a possessory right, and therefore the proper plaintiff in an action of trespass to land is the person with title to the land, or a person deemed to have been in possession at the time of the trespass. In William Kamunge Gakui v Eustace Gitonga Gakui (Civil Appeal 16 of 2013) [2014] KECA 39 (KLR), the Court held that a plaintiff must prove that he has the right to immediate and exclusive possession of the land.

25. It follows that a plaintiff in an action for trespass must prove his right to possession of the land and an unjustified intrusion upon it by the person he has sued. Both elements must be established against the defendant.

26. On the first limb, the Plaintiff produced an indenture of conveyance dated 25th September 1992, which transferred the suit property to him. The indenture has not been challenged, and nothing on record impeaches it. As held by the Court of Appeal in Charles Ogejo Ochieng v Geoffrey Okumu [1995] KECA 169 (KLR), registered proprietorship is sufficient to vest legal possession in the proprietor, and such possession supports an action for trespass against a person wrongfully on the land. This Court is therefore satisfied that the Plaintiff has established ownership of the suit property and is entitled to its possession.

27. On the second limb, the Plaintiff produced photographs dated 31st October 2019 and 10th November 2023 showing semi-permanent structures, together with demand letters dated 7th and 14th November 2019. In the affidavit sworn in support of his application for reinstatement, the Defendant admitted owning four kiosks. That admission constitutes an admission within the meaning of Sections 17 and 18 of the Evidence Act and establishes the link between the Defendant and the kiosks.

28. The admission, however, places the kiosks on the road reserve adjacent to the suit property, not on the property itself. The question is therefore not who owns the structures, but where they stand. The burden of proving that the kiosks are within the boundaries of LR No. 36/V/167 lies with the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff has not sufficiently established that the structures fall within the boundaries of the suit property. No survey report, beacon certificate or site visit report was placed before this Court to show that the kiosks encroach upon the Plaintiff's land.

29. Based on the evidence presented to this Court, the Plaintiff has not demonstrated, on a balance of probabilities, that the Defendant's kiosks are situated on the suit property. Consequently, the Plaintiff has not established the claim of trespass.

WHETHER THE PLAINTIFF IS ENTITLED TO THE ORDERS SOUGHT

30. The Plaintiff seeks a permanent injunction restraining the Defendant from trespassing on or interfering with the suit property, and an order of eviction. Although the Plaintiff has established ownership of the suit property, he has not shown that the Defendant's structures are situated within it. In the absence of evidence of trespass, the Court cannot grant a permanent injunction or order eviction. The Plaintiff also sought damages for trespass. An award of damages presupposes that trespass has been established, which the Plaintiff has not demonstrated. Consequently, the claim for general damages fails.

31. In the end, I find that the Plaintiff has not proved his case against the Defendant on the balance of probabilities, as required by law.

32. The upshot of the foregoing is that the Plaintiff’s suit lacks merit and is hereby dismissed with no orders as to costs.

JUDGMENT SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS THIS 9th DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

…………………………………….

HON. T. MURIGI

JUDGE

IN THE PRESENCE OF

Ms Kyule holding brief for Ayieko for the Plaintiff

Vena - Court assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder