Land law

Imanyara v Elgon Kenya Ltd [2026] KEELC 6564 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Environment and Land Miscellaneous Application E245 of 2025
Judgment date
9 October 2026
Judge(s)
TW Murigi

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

By a Chamber Summons dated 12th August 2025, brought under Paragraph 11(2) of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order, the Plaintiff/Applicant seeks the following orders:

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

He further argued that the Taxing Master erred in principle and law by failing to properly analyse the evidence and case law submitted in opposition to the Respondent's Bill of Costs. He also asserted that the Taxing Master failed to appreciate that the claim against the Respondent did not involve any complex issues of law, as the Respondent had pleaded none.

Paragraph 5 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELCL MISC APPLICATION NO. E245 OF 2025

MILTON MUGAMBI IMANYARA ………………………………. APPLICANT

=VERSUS=

ELGON KENYA LIMITED ……………………………………… RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

1. By a Chamber Summons dated 12th August 2025, brought under Paragraph 11(2) of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order, the Plaintiff/Applicant seeks the following orders:

a. That this Honourable Court be pleased to set aside the decision of the Taxing Master delivered on 30th July 2025 with respect to the 3rd

Defendant’s Party & Party Bill of Costs dated 24th July 2024.

b. That the 3rd Defendant’s Party & Party Bill of Costs dated 24th July 2024 be referred back for taxation before a different Taxing Officer with appropriate directions.

c. That this Honourable Court be pleased to grant any other relief that may be just to meet the ends of justice in this case.

d. That the costs of this Application be provided for

2. The application is based on the grounds appearing on its face together with the supporting affidavit of the Applicant sworn on even date.

THE APPLICANT’S CASE

3. The Applicant averred that on 30th July 2025, the Taxing Officer, Hon. Vincent Kiplagat, erred in principle and in law by taxing the Respondent's Party and Party Bill of Costs dated 24th July 2024 at KShs 790,711.67/=.

4. He contended that the Taxing Master erred in principle and law by failing to assess and apply the correct value of the subject matter of the suit and by disregarding the following uncontroverted facts:

a) That the claim against the Respondent was unliquidated, the subject matter of the suit having sought restoration of the affected section of the public road adjoining L.R. No. 18997/23 and 18997/27 to its original condition, level, and width, without any quantification of the value of such restoration.

b) That the suit having been dismissed, it was impractical to determine the value of the subject matter from the pleadings or the judgment of the court.

5. He further argued that the Taxing Master erred in principle and law by failing to properly analyse the evidence and case law submitted in opposition to the Respondent's Bill of Costs. He also asserted that the Taxing Master failed to appreciate that the claim against the Respondent did not involve any complex issues of law, as the Respondent had pleaded none.

6. The Applicant contends that the cumulative effect of the Taxing Master's errors amounted to unfair and unjust exploitation of the Applicant's right of access to justice. He further contends that the taxed sum of KShs 790,711.67/= was excessive, exploitative, and unjust in the circumstances.

7. In conclusion, he urged the Court to allow the application as prayed.

THE RESPONDENT’S CASE

8. The Respondent opposed the Reference by Grounds of Opposition dated 23rd October 2025, on the ground that it was fatally defective for failing to comply with the mandatory provisions of Paragraph 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order, which requires a party to file a Notice of Objection to Taxation before filing a Reference.

9. The Respondent relied on the decision in Nyiha, Mukoma & Company Advocates v Reynolds Mwangi Kinyanjui & Another, Nairobi ELC Misc. Application No. 148 of 2014, in which the court held that filing a notice of objection to taxation is a fundamental step in filing a reference, and that failure to comply is not a technical irregularity capable of being cured under Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution for the sake of substantive justice. The Respondent urged this Court to adopt this position in the present matter.

10. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions.

THE APPLICANT’S SUBMISSIONS

11. The Applicant filed his submissions dated 15th February 2026.

12. The Applicant submitted that the requirement under Paragraph 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order to file a Notice of Objection to Taxation before filing a Reference Application is intended to afford the Taxing Master an opportunity to provide detailed reasons for a decision, a requirement that arose from the former practice of taxing masters recording only the amount taxed off, without accompanying reasons. The Applicant contended that, where, as in the present case, the Taxing Master's ruling was comprehensive and already contained the reasons for the decision on the disputed items, it would be superfluous to request further reasons before proceeding by way of reference.

13. To support this argument, the Applicant relied on Ahmednasir Abdikadir & Company Advocates v National Bank of Kenya Limited [2006] 1 EA 5, in which the Court held that where the reasons for taxing disputed items had already been set out in a considered ruling, there was no need to seek further reasons merely to satisfy the wording of Rule 11(2).

14. The Applicant further cited Evans Thiga Guturu, Advocate v Kenya Commercial Bank Limited, Nairobi HC Misc. Application No. 343 of 2011, in which Odunga J held that reasons need only be sought where none appear on the face of the taxing master's decision, and that requiring further reasons where they already exist would produce absurd results. The Applicant also relied on National Oil Corporation Limited v Real Energy Limited & Another [2016] eKLR, cited with approval in China Young Tai Engineering Company Limited v Lubullelah & Associates Advocates, Nairobi Misc. Civil Application No. E823 of 2022, to argue that a party's failure to seek reasons is immaterial if the taxing master's decision already contains them.

15. The Applicant submitted that the Ruling delivered on 30th July 2025, titled "Ruling and Reasons for Taxation on 1st, 2nd and 3rd Defendant Party and Party Bill of Costs," was comprehensive and self-contained. Accordingly, requesting further reasons would be a foolhardy and superfluous procedural exercise. On this basis, the Applicant argued that the Respondent's contention—that non-compliance with Paragraph 11 rendered the Ruling fatally defective—was fallacious and could not stand.

16. The Applicant further submitted that the Respondent had not disputed the factual and legal arguments advanced in the Reference Application. In conclusion, the Applicant urged the Court to allow the application as prayed.

17. As at the time of writing this ruling, the Respondent had not filed its submissions as directed

ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION

18. Having considered the application, the Grounds of Opposition and the Applicant’s submissions, the following issues arise for determination:

a. Whether the reference is competent; and

b. Whether the Taxing Officer erred in principle in assessing the instruction fees in the 3rd Defendant's Party and Party Bill of Costs dated 24th July 2024;

WHETHER THE REFERENCE IS COMPETENT

19. The reference is brought under Rule 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order, which provides as follows:

(1) Should any party object to the decision of the taxing officer, he may within fourteen days after the decision give notice in writing to the taxing officer of the items of taxation to which he objects.

(2) The taxing officer shall forthwith record and forward to the objector the reasons for his decision on those items and the objector may within fourteen days from the receipt of the reasons apply to a judge by chamber summons, which shall be served on all the parties concerned, setting out the grounds of his objection.

(3) Any person aggrieved by the decision of the judge upon any objection referred to such judge under subsection (2) may, with the leave of the judge but not otherwise, appeal to the Court of Appeal.

(4) The High Court shall have power in its discretion by order to enlarge the time fixed by subparagraph (1) or subparagraph (2) far the taking of any step; application for such an order may be made by chamber summons upon giving to every other interested party not less than three clear days’ notice in writing or as the Court may direct, and may be so made notwithstanding that the time sought to be enlarged may have already expired.

20. The Respondent argued that the reference was fatally defective because the Applicant had not given the Taxing Officer notice of objection before filing it. The Applicant did not dispute that no notice had been given, but argued that notice was unnecessary because the Taxing Officer's ruling already stated the reasons for the decision.

21. The purpose of the notice under Paragraph 11(1) is to enable the Taxing Officer to record and forward the reasons for the decision on the items objected to. In Kipkorir, Titoo & Kiara Advocates v Deposit Protection Fund Board (Civil Appeal 220 of 2004) [2005] KECA 325 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held as follows:

" It is true that the taxing officer did not record the reasons for the decision on the items objected to after receipt of the respondent’s notice. It seems that the taxing officer decided to rely on the reasons in the ruling on taxation dated 23rd February, 2004. That ruling at least indicated the formula that the taxing officer applied to assess the instructions fees. Although there was no strict compliance with Rule 11 (2) of the Order, we are nevertheless satisfied that there was substantial compliance."

22. In Ahmednasir Abdikadir & Co. Advocates v National Bank of Kenya Limited (2) [2006] 1 EA 5, as cited in Evans Thiga Gaturu, Advocate v Kenya Commercial Bank Limited [2012] KEHC 4274 (KLR), the Court held as follows:

"Although rule 11(1) of the Advocates Remuneration Order stipulates that any party who wishes to object to the decision of the taxing officer, should do so within 14 days after the said decision and thereafter file his reference within 14 days from the date of the receipt of the reasons, where the reasons for the taxation on the disputed items in the bill are already contained in the considered ruling, there is no need to seek for further reasons simply because of the unfortunate wording of subrule (2) of rule 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order demands so."

23. This Court notes that in Nyiha, Mukoma & Company Advocates v Reynolds Mwangi Kinyanjui & another, Nairobi ELC Misc. Application No. 148 of 2014, the Court held that failing to file a notice of objection to taxation under Paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order before filing a reference was fatal to the application. This Court is inclined to follow the reasoning in Kipkorir, Titoo & Kiara Advocates (supra) and Ahmednasir Abdikadir (supra). The procedure in Paragraph 11 is intended to secure the reasons for the decision; it is not an end in itself.

24. In the matter at hand, the Taxing Officer's decision dated 30th July 2025 sets out the reasons for assessing the instruction fees. The reference was filed on 12th August 2025, within the fourteen-day period for giving notice of objection. The Respondent has not shown that it suffered any prejudice from the absence of the notice. On the evidence presented, this Court finds that the reference is competent.

WHETHER THE TAXING OFFICER ERRED IN PRINCIPLE IN ASSESSING THE INSTRUCTION FEES

25. This reference relates specifically to the taxation of item 1—the instruction fees—in the 3rd Defendant’s Party and Party Bill of Costs.

26. The 3rd Defendant sought Kshs. 3,000,000/= in instruction fees. Although the subject matter was alleged to be worth Kshs. 95 million, the Court noted that no documentary evidence was adduced to support that assertion. The Taxing Officer assessed the fees at Kshs. 500,000/=.

27. It is trite that, in a reference, a Court will not interfere with the exercise of a Taxing Officer’s discretion unless the Taxing Officer erred in principle in assessing costs.

28. The Principles of taxation were aptly stated in Premchand Raichand Ltd and another v Quarry Services of East Africa Ltd and Others (1972) EA 162, where the court observed as follows:

“(a) That costs should not be allowed to rise to a level as to confine access to justice to the wealthy;

(b) That a successful litigant ought to be fairly reimbursed for costs he has had to incur

(c) That the general level of remuneration of advocates must be such as to attract recruits to the profession and

(d) That, as far as practicable, there should be consistency in the awards made.

(g) The court will only interfere when the award of the taxing officer is so high or so low as to amount to an injustice to one party.”

29. Similarly, in Kipkorir, Titoo & Kiara Advocates vs Deposit Protection Fund Board (2005) 1 KLR 528, the Court of Appeal stated that:

“On a reference to a judge from the taxation by the Taxing Officer, the Judge will not normally interfere with the exercise of discretion by the taxing officer unless the taxing officer erred in principle in assessing the costs- an example of an error of principle is where the costs allowed are so manifestly excessive as to justify an inference that the taxing officer acted on erroneous principles.”

30. In Kamunyori & Company Advocates v. Development Bank of Kenya Limited [2015] eKLR, the court stated as follows:

“.. failure to ascertain the correct subject matter in a suit for the purpose of taxation is an error of principle. So too, failure to ascribe the correct value to the subject matter is an error of principle. Authorities on taxation show that a Judge will normally not interfere with the Taxing Officer’s decision on taxation unless it is based on an error of principle. Where it is shown that the sum awarded was so manifestly excessive as to justify interference, an error of principle can be inferred. If the instruction fee is arrived at on the wrong principles, it will be set aside”

31. The Court of Appeal in Joreth Ltd. v. Kigano & Associates [2002] KECA 153 (KLR) similarly held that a court hearing a reference against the taxing officer’s assessment of the instruction fee should not interfere with the assessment of costs unless the taxing officer had misdirected himself on a matter of principle.

32. The Applicant's first complaint is that the Taxing Officer failed to appreciate that the claim was unliquidated and that its value could not be determined from the pleadings or the judgment. Having considered the judgment annexed to the reference, this Court is satisfied that the Taxing Officer correctly found that the value of the subject matter could not be ascertained from either. The suit concerned alleged excavations on a public road, a claim that the Court found was not established. The Taxing Officer was therefore required to exercise his discretion in assessing the instruction fees, taking into account the factors identified by the Court of Appeal in Joreth Ltd v Kigano & Associates (Civil Appeal 66 of 1999) [2002] KECA 153 (KLR):

“…a bill of costs ought to be determined from the pleadings judgment or settlement (if such be the case) but if the same is not so ascertainable the taxing officer is entitled to use his discretion to assess such instruction fee as he considers just, taking into account, amongst other matters, the nature and importance of the cause or matter, the interest of the parties, the general conduct of the proceedings, any direction by the trial judge and all other relevant circumstances.”

33. The Respondent contended that the value of the suit property was Kshs. 95,000,000/=, being the purchase price at which the Plaintiff testified that he had acquired his property. However, the Plaintiff's property was not the subject matter of the suit, and its purchase price could not, therefore, be attributed to the value of the subject matter.

34. The Applicant further contended that the suit raised no complex issues of law. Complexity is only one consideration set out in Joreth Limited (supra). The nature and importance of the matter, the parties' interests, and the conduct of the proceedings are equally relevant. The suit concerned the restoration of a section of a public road adjoining L.R. Nos. 18997/23 and 18997/27 and was heard to conclusion. The Applicant has not shown that the Taxing Officer took into account an irrelevant consideration or disregarded a relevant one. This court is not persuaded that the assessed sum is so manifestly excessive as to justify an inference of an error of principle, particularly given that the suit was litigated for ten years.

35. Based on the material before this Court, the Applicant has not demonstrated that the Taxing Officer erred in principle in assessing the instruction fees.

36. The upshot of the foregoing is that the Chamber Summons dated 12th August 2025 is without merit and is hereby dismissed with costs to the Respondent.

RULING SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS THIS 9TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

…………………………………….

HON. T. MURIGI

JUDGE

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Omwenga holding brief for Mugambi Imanyara for the Applicant

Vena – Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder