Land law

Wanjohi & another v Auto Show Ltd & 2 others [2026] KEELC 6525 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
ELC CASE NO. 256 OF 2015
Judgment date
12 October 2026
Judge(s)
CA Ochieng

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is before the Court for determination are two applications.

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

From what I have highlighted above, I find that the 1st Defendant is not being candid when it seeks to set aside the impugned judgement and for the matter to commence afresh. In my view it failed to participate in the hearing of the matter despite having filed its Defence. It opted to Appeal the impugned judgement and is now making a turn around to seek to review the said judgement. I find that its attempt to blame the erstwhile…

Paragraph 23 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC CASE NO. 256 OF 2015

ISAAC GATHUNGU WANJOHI ............................. 1ST PLAINTIFF

ISABELLA NYAGUTHII WANJOHI ..................... 2ND PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

AUTO SHOW LIMITED ..................................... 1ST DEFENDANT

MBUGUA HOLDINGS LIMITED ....................... 2ND DEFENDANT

AND

JOHN NAMU NJUE ………………………….………………… APPLICANT

RULING

1. What is before the Court for determination are two applications.

Notice of Motion dated 10th February 2026

2. It is filed by the 1st Defendant which seeks the following Orders:

a) Spent.

b) That this Honourable court be pleased to grant leave to the firm of Kivuva Omuga & Co. Advocates to come on record for the Defendant/Applicant, Auto Show Limited, in place of the firm of Joe N Mwanthi & Co. Advocates, pursuant to Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

c) Spent.

d) That this Honourable court be pleased to set aside the decree/and judgement passed herein on 30th May 2024 and reopen the entire suit for hearing and determination on the merits.

e) That costs of this application be in the cause.

3. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the supporting affidavit sworn by John Muya Kariuki, the 1st Defendant’s director. He avers that the 1st Defendant instructed messrs Joe N. Mwanthi & Co. Advocates to act for it in the matter but unbeknown to it, the said advocates filed an application dated 27th June 2023 to cease acting, without notifying it, or advising it, of the implications of such cessation. He links the said cessation to act to being the reason the 1st Defendant was not allegedly aware of subsequent court attendances, proceedings and the final judgement herein. He avers that the suit proceeded without the 1st Defendant’s participation and that it learnt of the impugned judgement in January 2026 after perusal of this Court’s records. He contends that the 1st Defendant has a triable defence thus it stands to suffer prejudice if the impugned judgment is not set aside.

Response

4. The application is opposed by the Plaintiffs vide the 1st Plaintiff’s supporting affidavit. He avers that after filing the suit vide a plaint dated 18th November 2024, messrs Joe N Mwanthi & Co. Advocates entered appearance for the 1st Defendant vide a Memorandum of Appearance dated 22nd April 2015 and subsequently filed a Statement of Defence, list of witnesses, witness statements and a list and bundle of documents. Further, that later in the proceedings, the Plaintiffs were granted leave to amend their Plaint, which they did on 10th February 2023. He points out that on 14th June 2023, the matter was coming up for hearing when the 1st Defendant’s former advocate informed the Court that he had no instructions to proceed with the hearing and later filed a formal application to cease acting, which was allowed but the Court directed the Plaintiffs to personally serve the 1st Defendant with a hearing notice which they did, thus it was aware of the hearing of 18th October 2023 but it failed to attend Court. He insists that on the said hearing date, upon being satisfied that the 1st and 2nd Defendants were duly served with a hearing notice, the Court proceeded with the hearing of the Plaintiffs’ case, closed the 1st and 2nd Defendants’ case, and gave a mention date for 30th November 2024 to confirm filing of submissions. He claims that on the said mention date, the Defendants were represented by messrs Othieno & Company Advocates who filed a Preliminary Objection alleging that the 2nd Defendant had not been served with summons to enter appearance. However, the said advocates did not turn up for hearing of the said Preliminary Objection thus it was dismissed and the Court proceeded to issue judgement.

5. He avers that upon delivery of judgement, the 1st Defendant instructed messrs Kibanya Kamau Associates to file and serve a Notice of Appeal with respect to the said judgement thus the 1st Defendant has been aware of this Court’s proceedings and judgement the entire time. He accuses the 1st Defendant of attempting to forestall execution proceedings by filing the instant application twenty one (21) months after judgement and urges the Court to find that it has been indolent thus it should not be allowed to blame its previous counsel as it is trite that a case belongs to a litigant not his advocate.

Notice of Motion dated 17th March 2026

6. It is filed by the Applicant who seeks the following Orders;

a) Spent.

b) That the Officer Commanding Station (OCS) Kasarani Police Station do supervise and offer security to the Applicant during the execution of the decree dated 18th November 2024 upon the 1st and 3rd Defendants at LR No. 28/1 Nairobi.

c) That the cost of this application be borne by the 1st and 2nd Defendants.

7. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the Applicant’s supporting affidavit. He avers that he is a licensed auctioneer t/a Vision Root Auctioneers and that on 6th March 2026, he received instructions to execute this Court’s decree dated 18th November 2024, against the Defendants. Further, that on the same day, they located the suit property at Ruaka and met a Mr. Wambua whom they found there and who informed them that he was an employee of the 1st Defendant, and served him with the Decree and Certificate of Costs. He claims that they returned to the suit property on 13th March 2026 to execute the Decree but the Defendants and their employees were uncooperative to the extent that they refused to give them entry and became violent thus there is need for police to provide security for the execution to be effected by demolition and eviction of the Defendants.

8. The application is not opposed.

9. The applications were canvassed by way of written submissions.

Submissions

10. The 1st Defendant submits that under Order 12 Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Rules, this Court has unfettered jurisdiction to set aside a judgement entered in the absence of a party to avoid injustice and that under Section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, it has inherent powers to make such orders as may be necessary for the ends of justice to be met. It insists that its failure to participate in the proceedings was neither deliberate nor intentional. Further, that it reasonably believed that it was represented in the suit while its Counsel withdrew from proceedings without informing it. It also submits that its defence raises triable issues and that the suit property has been the subject of significant investment and development for a considerable period thus to deny it an opportunity to be heard will amount to grave injustice and a violation of its right to hearing. It reiterates that there has been no undue delay of filing the application upon discovery of the suit in January 2026.It also submits that the court has a constitutional obligation under Article 159(2) (e) of the Constitution to promote substantive justice without undue regard to technicalities.

11. To buttress its averments, the 1st Defendant relied on the following decisions: Housing Finance Co. of Kenya v Gallery Homes (K) Limited & 4 Others [2016] eKLR; National Bank of Kenya v Ndungu Njau [1997] eKLR; Erick O. Matara & another v Beatrice Matara [2007] eKLR; Jenkings v Young Brothers Transport Ltd [2003] eKLR; Kenya Power & Lighting Company Limited v Nathan Karanja Gachoka [2016] eKLR and Mithis Mwachari & others v Agnes Ntinyari & Others [2018] eKLR.

12. On their part, the Plaintiffs submits that the power of this Court to set aside judgement under Order 12 Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Rules is discretionary, but discretion ought to be exercised judiciously. They urge the Court to consider that there was proper service on the 1st Defendant thus there is no sufficient cause for non-attendance. They argue that a litigant cannot purport to delegate primary responsibility to prosecute their case upon advocates, the 1st Defendant was just indolent in prosecuting its defence. The also submit that the application was filed after inordinate delay which is inexcusable and the Defendants have no defence that raises triable issues as alleged. Further, that to permit the reopening of the case at this stage would require this Court to sit on appeal of its own judgement.

13. To buttress their averments, the Plaintiffs relied on the following decisions: Agneta Agisa Mudukiza v Teresa Noel & another [2018] KEELC 2208(KLR); Hotenga Njeri Munga v Celina Wairimu & 2 others [2021] KEELC 1512; Mwala v Kenya Bureau of Standards EALR (2001) 1EA 148; Muita (Deceased) & another v Gitahi (Civil Appeal 748 of 2007) [2024] KEHC 209 (KLR), and Southern Empire Traders v Nakuru Players Theatre Club) [2018] eKLR.

Analysis and Determination

14. I have considered the instant two Notice of Motion applications including the respective affidavits as well as rivalling submissions and the following are the issues for determination:

a) Whether leave should be granted to the firm of Kivuva Omuga & Co. Advocates to come on record for the 1st Defendant.

b) Whether the 1st Defendant warrants this court’s discretion to set aside its judgement entered on 30th May 2024.

c) Whether the Officer Commanding Station (OCS) Kasarani Police Station should provide security during the execution of the decree herein.

15. It is not disputed that judgement was entered in this matter on 30th May 2024. It is also not in dispute that the 1st Defendants’ case was closed by the Court in its absence, which the Plaintiffs claim was deliberate since it was aware of the hearing date of 18th October 2023 and made post judgement follow ups, including instructing an advocate to file a Notice of Appeal.

16. On its part, the 1st Defendant claims that the suit proceeded in its absence, which its attributes to its previous advocate’s alleged negligence because they ceased acting without allegedly informing it.

17. On the first issue, the 1st Defendant seeks orders that the firm of messrs Oscar Otieno and Co. Advocates be allowed to come on record as its advocates, given that judgement has been entered herein. Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides that:

“Where there is a change of advocate, or when a party decides to act in person having previously engaged an advocate, after judgment has been passed, such change or intention to act in person shall not be effected without an order of the court-

a. Upon an application with notice to all parties or

b. Upon a consent filed between the outgoing advocate and the proposed incoming advocate or party intending to act in person, as the case may be.”

18. Since there is no objection to this prayer, noting that it is a requirement for an advocate who intends to come on record for a litigant post judgement to obtain consent from the erstwhile advocate or seek leave of Court to do so, I will proceed to allow the firm of messrs Oscar Otieno and Co. Advocates to come on record for the 1st Defendant in this matter.

19. On the second issue, Order 12 Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Rules gives this Court discretion, upon such terms as may be just, to set aside or vary a judgment or Order entered under that provision, in this case upon the 1st Defendant’s non attendance at the hearing of the suit.

20. In CMC Holding Limited v Nzioki [2004] KECA 143 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held that:

“Our view is that in law, the discretion that a court of law has, in deciding whether or not to set aside ex parte order such as before us was meant to ensure that a litigant does not suffer injustice or hardship as a result of among other things an excusable mistake or error. It would in our mind not be a proper use of such a discretion if the Court turns its back to a litigant who clearly demonstrates such an excusable mistake, inadvertence, accident or error. Such an exercise of discretion would in our mind be wrong in principle.”

21. The Plaintiffs have argued that the 1st Defendant is not deserving of this Court’s discretion to set aside the impugned judgement since it cannot purport to blame its advocates for its predicament as a suit belongs to a litigant. It also contends that the 1st Defendant was indolent, that it has no triable defence and that the application is filed after inordinate delay. The Court will examine its record to determine whether the 1st Defendant was indolent and whether it squandered its chance to be heard as alleged by the Plaintiffs. In Mwangangi v Mugi [2024] KEHC 6321 (KLR), the Court in dismissing a similar application held as follows:

“Whereas it is true that mistakes of an advocate should not be visited on a litigant, it is also that suits belong to the parties not their advocates. Thus, where a litigant has instructed an advocate in a matter, he or she has an obligation to follow up on instructions given to ensure that they were executed and executed in good time. This principle was enunciated in the Court of Appeal in Habo Agencies Limited v Wilfred Odhiambo Musingo (2015) eKLR where the court stated:- It is not enough for a party in litigation to simply blame the Advocates on record for all manner of transgressions in the conduct of the litigation. Courts have always emphasized that parties have a responsibility to show interest in and to follow up their cases even when they are represented by counsel. Similarly in Bi-Mach Engineers Limited v James Kahoro Mwangi (2011) eKLR, the court reiterated the duty of an applicant to follow up on instructions given to an advocate and expressed itself as follows:- The applicant had a duty to pursue his advocates to find out the position on the litigation but there is no disclosure that the applicant bothered to follow up on the matter with his erstwhile advocates. It is not enough simply to accuse the advocate of failure to inform as if there is no duty of the client to pursue his matter. If the advocate was simply guilty of inaction, that is not an excusable mistake which the court may consider with some sympathy. The applicant has not shown any attempts he made to find out from his advocates the position of the matter or follow up on the judgment. The applicant only faults his advocates for not telling him about the judgment. From the foregoing, it is my considered view that the applicant has not satisfactorily explained the delay in filing the intended appeal………”

22. On perusal of the Court record, I note on the 10th July, 2023, Mr. Mwanthi represented the 1st Defendant in Court when the hearing date was scheduled on the 18th October, 2023. On 18th October, 2023, the Plaintiffs confirmed they served the Defendants and the matter proceeded for hearing. On the 30th November, 2023 when the matter was scheduled for mention to fix a judgement date, the 2nd Defendant was represented by a Counsel. I note the 2nd Defendant even filed a Notice of Appointment of Advocates and Notice of Preliminary Objection dated the 28th November, 2023, by messrs Othieno & Company Advocates, but the said firm failed to prosecute the said Notice of Preliminary Objection, culminating in its dismissal. Further, messrs Kibanya & Kamau & Associates filed a Notice of Appeal against the judgement dated the 12th June, 2024 on the 14th June, 2024.

23. From what I have highlighted above, I find that the 1st Defendant is not being candid when it seeks to set aside the impugned judgement and for the matter to commence afresh. In my view it failed to participate in the hearing of the matter despite having filed its Defence. It opted to Appeal the impugned judgement and is now making a turn around to seek to review the said judgement. I find that its attempt to blame the erstwhile advocate for not informing it of the hearing is simply an excuse. In the foregoing, while associating myself with the decisions cited, I find that the 1st Defendant has not provided plausible reasons nor demonstrated sufficient cause why the impugned judgement should be set aside and I will decline to do so.

24. On the third issue, the prayer for police assistance in executing this court’s decree was not opposed. Since I have declined to set aside the impugned judgement noting that the 1st Defendant did not oppose the said prayer seeking police assistance in executing the Decree, I will allow this prayer.

25. In the foregoing, I find the Notice of Motion dated 17th March 2026 is merited and will allow it. I however find the Notice of Motion application dated the 10th February, 2026 unmerited and will dismiss it with costs.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 12TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

CHRISTINE OCHIENG

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Ms Onyango for Plaintiffs

Court Assistant: Joan

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder