Land law

Muita (Suing on Behalf of Ndundu Welfare Men and Women Group) v Kagunya (Sued as Administrator of the Estate of Meshack Mureithi Wambugu) [2026] KEELC 6551 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
ELC CASE NO. 628 OF 2016
Judgment date
12 October 2026
Judge(s)
CA Ochieng

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Judgement was entered in the matter on 27th November 2017. Subsequently, two applications that are before the Court for determination were filed.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The Defendant revealed that she was registered to Ruiru/Kiu Block 6/109 and that the Plaintiff moved the Court vide Ruiru CMC ELC 219 of 2024, to have her registration cancelled. A judgement was issued in that regard but she applied to set it aside as she had not been involved in the said matter. She contends that the said judgement was then set aside and the issue of ownership of Ruiru/Kiu Block 6/109 is live in that Court, between…

Paragraph 14 →

Reasoning passage

On perusal of the Court record, I note on the 30th May, 2018, Justice Eboso, rectified the error at paragraph 13 (a) of his judgement to read Defendant instead of Plaintiff. In the foregoing, I find that this prayer has been overtaken by events.

Paragraph 17 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC CASE NO. 628 OF 2016

HENRY NJUGUNA MUITA ………………………………..…. PLAINTIFF

(Suing on Behalf of Ndundu Welfare Men and Women Group)

VERSUS

ALICE WAMBUI KAGUNYA ………………………………. DEFENDANT

(Sued as Administrator of the estate of

MESHACK MUREITHI WAMBUGU)

RULING

1. Judgement was entered in the matter on 27th November 2017. Subsequently, two applications that are before the Court for determination were filed.

Notice of Motion dated 3rd June 2025

2. It is filed by the Plaintiff who seeks the following Orders:

a) Spent.

b) That the judgement and decree by Hon Justice Eboso delivered on 27th Nov 2017 ("the said judgement & decree") be amended so as to rectify the wrongly cited parcel number from Ruiru/Kiu block 6/998 to Ruiru/Kiu block 6/109 in the said judgement & decree and in paragraph 13 (a) of judgement to read Defendant not Plaintiff.

c) That in the circumstances the true and rightful Plaintiff’s /Applicant’s parcel number is Ruiru/Kiu block 6/109.

d) That costs of the application be provided for.

3. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the Plaintiff’s supporting affidavit. He avers that he is the registered owner of Ruiru/Kiu block 6/109 (formerly Ruiru/ Kiu block 6/ 998) and that due to some factors, the Ruiru District Surveyor and Ruiru Land Registrar changed the old number into new ones. However, this Court’s judgement and decree of 27th November 2017 reflected the old number, (Ruiru/Kiu block 6/998), thus the request for amendment and rectification for ease of enforcing the decree. He contends that there is an error at paragraph 13(a) of the judgement which indicated that the Plaintiff instead of the Defendant, should vacate suit property. He attached a copy of lease, correspondence addressed to the Court Executive Officer for rectification of judgement and correspondence from Ruiru Survey office.

Response

4. The Defendant filed a replying affidavit in opposition. She avers that the Plaintiff failed to disclose material facts, being that his title to Ruiru/Kiu block 6/109 was cancelled through judgement issued on 9th January 2025 at the Chief Magistrate’s Court in Ruiru CM ELC NO. E219 of 2024. She points out that the said suit was filed by the Plaintiff against the Ruiru District Land Registrar and District Land Surveyor, under the guise that there was mistake in allocation and without joining her to the said suit. Further, that upon learning of the said judgement, she filed an application for joinder which was allowed vide the said Court’s Ruling of 4th February 2026. Consequently, the impugned judgement was set aside for the matter to begin afresh.

5. She contends that the alleged changes in land parcel numbers and/or survey issues do not justify reopening or altering the valid judgment of this Court. Further, that the Plaintiff has not demonstrated any sufficient cause to warrant orders sought, thus allowing the application will prejudice her and defeat the principles of justice, fairness, and finality of litigation.

Notice of Motion dated 17th September 2025

6. It is filed by the Defendant who seeks the following Orders:

a) Spent.

b) That the firm of Kinyati & Company Advocates be allowed to come on record for the Applicant after judgement in this suit.

c) That this Honorable court be pleased to vary/lift /vacate any interim orders issued on the Respondents Application dated 3rd June, 2025.

d) That costs of this application be borne by the Respondent.

7. The application is premised on grounds on its face, and on the Defendant’s supporting affidavit, which mirrors her affidavit in opposition to the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion dated 3rd June 2025. In addition, she urges the Court to lift any Orders issued herein in the interim as the Plaintiff could use them to evict and dispose the suit property through misrepresentation and fraud citing his alleged ill motive allegedly demonstrated by his filing of Ruiru ELC 219 of 2024 as a shortcut to deprive her of the suit property.

Response

8. The Plaintiff filed a replying affidavit in opposition. He claims that on 25th September 1996, members of Ndundu Welfare Men and Women Group became absolute owners of Ruiru /Kiu block 6/998 and took possession. However, when they went to develop the land in the year 2015, they met illegal invaders, and filed the present suit and pursuant to this Court’s judgement, the Defendant was ordered to vacate or forcefully be evicted but at the point of executing the decree, a new map had been drawn and their LR Ruiru Kiu Block 6/998 changed to LR Ruiru Kiu Block 6/109 whose Lease the Defendant had irregularly acquired .He contends that LR Ruiru block 6/998 and LR Ruiru Kiu Block 6/109 is one and the same by virtue that even after change of numbers, the ground position did not change, eviction orders have not changed and the Defendant is one and the same as per decree issued. He also avers that the decree in Ruiru CMC ELC 219 of 2024 was a formality to regularize the changes and undo the mistakes in the land registry, and urges the Court to dismiss the Defendant’s application.

9. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions but the

Plaintiff did not file submissions.

Submissions

10. On her part, the Defendant submits that the Plaintiff’s application is an abuse of court process as it is built upon the existence of judgement in Ruiru CMC ELC 219 of 2024, yet it has already been vacated thus there remains no legal foundation upon which his motion can stand. Further, that he has not demonstrated what practical relief this Court can grant in respect of a judgment that has already been set aside and the parties in the said matter are now headed for a substantive hearing on 17th June 2026 where all questions relating to ownership, title, service and legality of transactions can properly be canvassed.

11. To buttress her averments, the Defendant relied on the following decisions: Macfoy v United Africa Co Ltd [1961] 3 All ER 1169; Muchanga Investments Limited v Safaris Unlimited (Africa) Ltd & 2 Others [2009] eKLR; John Harun Mwau & 3 Others v Attorney General & 2 Others [2012] eKLR; Attorney General & 2 Others v Okiya Omtatah Okoiti & 14 Others [2020] eKLR.

Analysis and Determination

12. Upon consideration of the instant Notice of Motion applications, the

respective affidavits including rivalling submissions, the following are the issues for determination:

• Whether the court should rectify parcel number Ruiru/Kiu block 6/998 to Ruiru/Kiu block 6/109 in this court’s judgement dated 27th November 2017 and paragraph 13 (a) of the said judgement corrected to read Defendant in place of Plaintiff.

• Whether the firm of Kinyati & Company Advocates should come on record for the Defendant.

• Whether any interim orders issued on the Plaintiff’s application dated 3rd June, 2025 should be varied/lifted.

13. It is not disputed that judgement was entered for the Plaintiff in this matter on 27th November 2017, in respect of Ruiru/Kiu Block 6/998. The Plaintiff claims that at the time of execution of the decree, it was discovered that the Defendant who was to be evicted, is on Ruiru/Kiu Block 6/109.The Plaintiff now urges the Court to rectify the decree to read Ruiru/Kiu Block 6/109, alleging that it is the same parcel, formerly known as Ruiru/Kiu Block 6/998, and to amend paragraph 13 (a) of the impugned judgement.

14. The Defendant revealed that she was registered to Ruiru/Kiu Block 6/109 and that the Plaintiff moved the Court vide Ruiru CMC ELC 219 of 2024, to have her registration cancelled. A judgement was issued in that regard but she applied to set it aside as she had not been involved in the said matter. She contends that the said judgement was then set aside and the issue of ownership of Ruiru/Kiu Block 6/109 is live in that Court, between the Plaintiff and herself.

15. On the first issue, this Court has power to correct clerical or arithmetical mistakes in a decree pursuant to Section 99 of the Civil Procedure Act which provides that:

“Clerical or arithmetical mistakes in judgments, decrees or orders, or errors arising therein from any accidental slip or omission, may at any time be corrected by the court either of its own motion or on the application of any of the parties.”

16. In Nguruman Limited v Attorney General & Another (2021) eKLR, the holding in Vallabhdas Karsandas Kaniga v Mansukhlal Jivraj and Others [1965] EA 780, was cited, where the East African Court of Appeal held that:

“Section 3(2) of the Appellate Jurisdiction Act confers on the Court of Appeal the same jurisdiction to amend judgments, decrees and orders that the High Court has under section 99 of the Civil Procedure Act, making it unnecessary to look to the inherent powers of the court. The words at any time" in section 99 clearly allow the Power of amendment to be exercised after the issue of a formal order..."Slip orders" made to rectify omissions resulting from the failure of counsel to ask for costs and other matters to which their clients are entitled.....A court will only apply the slip rules where it is fully satisfied that it is giving effect to the intention of the court at the time when judgment was given or, in the case of a matter which was overlooked, where it is satisfied, beyond doubt, as to the order which it would have made had the matter been brought to its attention…”

17. On perusal of the Court record, I note on the 30th May, 2018, Justice Eboso, rectified the error at paragraph 13 (a) of his judgement to read Defendant instead of Plaintiff. In the foregoing, I find that this prayer has been overtaken by events.

18. On the issue for review of the suit parcel from LR Ruiru Kiu Block 6/998, to LR Ruiru Kiu Block 6/109, the Supreme Court stated as follows in Menginya Salim Murgani v Kenya Revenue Authority [2014] eKLR:

“It is a general principle of law that a Court after passing Judgment, becomes functus officio and cannot revisit the Judgment on merits, or purport to exercise a judicial power over the same matter, save as provided by law.”

19. I note the Defendant has actually confirmed that there is the aforementioned active case pending in Ruiru Chief Magistrate’s Court whose fulcrum revolves arounds LR Ruiru Kiu Block 6/109, which the Plaintiff failed to divulge to this Court. In the circumstances, I find that this Court is functus officio and cannot amend the Judgement and Decree to change the identification of the suit parcel. Further, I opine that the Plaintiff was not being candid in seeking this prayer.

20. On the change of advocate post judgement, there is no opposition to the Defendant’s prayer that the firm of Kinyati & Company Advocates comes on record for her. In the foregoing, I will allow this prayer.

21. On the last issue, the Court record does not indicate that any interim prayers were issued on the Plaintiff’s application dated 3rd June, 2025

thus there is none to be lifted.

22. In the foregoing, I find the Plaintiff’s instant Notice of Motion application unmerited and will disallow it. I however find the Defendant’s Notice of Motion application partially successful and will allow prayer No. (b) only, to allow the firm of Kinyati & Company Advocates to come on record for the Defendant post judgement.

23. Each party to bear their own costs.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 12TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

CHRISTINE OCHIENG

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Wanjiru for Defendant

Court Assistant: Joan

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder