Background
The matter is coming up for determination on the Defendant’s Notice of Motion dated 17th February 2026 seeking the following orders
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The matter is coming up for determination on the Defendant’s Notice of Motion dated 17th February 2026 seeking the following orders
Paragraph 1 →Having considered the Notice of motion application, the replying affidavit and the Respondent’s submissions filed the only substantial issue for determination is whether the application is merited.
Paragraph 8 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI
ELCLC SUIT NO. E307 OF 2025
DORIS WARURI KIMORORI…………………………........RESPONDENT/ PLAINTIFF
-VERSUS-
STEPHEN OKOTH MWANGA………….…………………. APPLICANT/DEFENDANT
RULING
Introduction
1. The matter is coming up for determination on the Defendant’s Notice of Motion dated 17th February 2026 seeking the following orders
a) That this Honourable Court be pleased to strike out the Plaintiff's Plaint dated on the 31st January 2025 and dismiss the suit herein with costs to the Defendant.
b) That in the alternative, the proceedings in this suit be stayed pending the hearing and determination of MILIMANI ELCA No. E210 of 2024 (Stephen Okoth Mwanga-vs-Jovan Kariuki t/a Moran Auctioneers & Doris Waruri Kimorori
c) That the costs of this application be borne by the Plaintiff
2. The application was premised on grounds as in the supporting affidavit of the Applicant. He deponed that the matters raised in this suit are directly and substantially as the same matters in MILIMANI ELCA No. E210 of 2024 (Stephen Okoth Mwanga-vs-Jovan Kariuki t/a Moran Auctioneers & Doris Waruri Kimorori which offends the doctrine of sub judice under section 6 of the civil procedure Act
3. The Respondent opposed the application in a replying affidavit sworn on the 12th June 2026.She deponded that the matter was not sub judice to the MILIMANI ELCA No. E210 of 2024 as the issues in the two matters were totally different.
4. That in the appeal that arose from MILIMANI MCELC NO. E523 OF 2023, the Applicant approached the lower court challenging the process of levying distress for rent that had been initiated by Respondent whereas in this instant suit, the Respondent had filed seeking for recovery of liquidated outstanding rental arrears amounting to Kshs. 3,458,000.00 alongside claims for mesne profits for the period the Defendant stayed in the Suit Property after ceasing to be a Tennant.
5. That the issues raised in this instant suit could not have been addressed in the lower court matter that challenged the distress process leading up to the appeal and as it is the determination of the suits will bear totally different implications and hence the argument of conflicting decisions is baseless
Respondent’s submissions
6. Counsel submitted that the objection on sub judice fails as the appeal being relied on was dismissed on the 22nd October 2025 together with the review application
7. Counsel further reiterated as in the replying affidavit than even if the appeal was still active, the two matters do not raise the same issues as the earlier proceedings addressed the issue of distress and protective relief whereas this suit addresses the issue of rent arrears and mesne profits.
Analysis and determination
8. Having considered the Notice of motion application, the replying affidavit and the Respondent’s submissions filed the only substantial issue for determination is whether the application is merited.
9. In the instant suit the Applicant argued that by dint of section 6 of the Civil procedure Act, the trial court should dismiss the suit herein since the issues herein are the same issues in MILIMANI MCELC NO. E523 OF 2023which is before another competent court that is yet to make a determination on the same. The doctrine of sub-judice prevents a court from proceeding with the trial of any suit in which the matter in issue is directly and substantially the same with that in a previously instituted suit, between the same parties and pending before the same or another court of competent jurisdiction. The doctrine is enshrined under Section 6 of Civil Procedure Act which defines the doctrine as follows;“
No court shall proceed with the trial of any suit or proceedings in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit or proceeding between the same parties or between parties under whom they or any of them claim litigating under the same title, where such suit or proceeding is pending in the same court or any other court having jurisdiction in Kenya to grant the relief claimed.”
10. The rule is meant to prevent a duplication of the reliefs or a conflict thereof, to avoid confusion and chaos and ensure order in the legal system. In Republic vs Paul Kihara Kariuki, Attorney General & 2 others Ex parte Law Society of Kenya (2020) eKLR, Justice Mativo discussed the concept sub judice as follows: -“…there exists the concept of sub judice which in Latin means “under Judgement.” It denotes that a matter is being considered by a court or judge. The concept of sub judice that where an issue is pending in a court of law for adjudication between the same parties, any other court is barred from trying that issue so long as the first suit goes on. In such a situation, order is passed by the subsequent court to stay the proceeding and such order can be made at any stage.”
11. This is because since the issues in the two suits are similar, it is presumed that a determination of either of them will obviously render the other spent and of no further use, and a continuation of those proceedings would amount to res judicata. The Supreme Court of Kenya in Kenya National Commission on Human Rights vs Attorney General; Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & 16 others (Interested Parties) (Advisory Opinion Reference 1 of 2017) [2020] KESC 54 (KLR), stated therein as follows: -“‘ A party that seeks to invoke the doctrine of res sub-judice must therefore establish that; there is more than one suit over the same subject matter; that one suit was instituted before the other; that both suits are pending before courts of competent jurisdiction and lastly; that the suits are between the same parties or their representatives.”
12. There is no doubt that there are two suits pending before the courts, being this suit and MILIMANI MCELC NO. E523 OF 2023.The Respondent has raised the issue of the appeal standing dismissed hence there are no earlier proceedings to anchor the doctrine of sub judice on. To note is that this is a new issue that has been brought up in the Respondent’s submissions and not in any of their pleadings
13. It is trite law that Submissions are not pleadings and that new issues cannot be raised in submissions. In Republic Vs. Chairman Public Procurement Administrative Review Board & another Ex parte Zapkass Consulting and Training Limited & another [2014] Korir, J. stated:
“The Applicant, the Respondents and the interested party all introduced new issues in their submissions. Submissions are not pleadings. There is no evidence by way of affidavits to support the submissions. New issues raised by way of submissions are best ignored.”
14. I will therefore not address the issue of the appeal being dismissed as there has not been tendered any evidence to that effect and will move on to address the application on merit
15. I have perused the annexures to the supporting affidavit in the application and have not seen the memorandum of appeal to be able to establish the issued that have been raised in the same appeal. However, the Respondent has indicated that in the appeal arising out of MILIMANI MCELC NO. E523 OF 2023 the contention was on the process of levying distress for rent whereas in this suit the issue raised are for recovery of rental arrears and claim for mesne profits. These two issues on the face of it are different as one goes into procedure and the other into compensation.
16. The Applicant relies on the fact that the Respondent is a party to the said appeal which concerns the same subject matter as in this instant case. That alone is not enough reason to indicate that a suit is sub judice, that even though both the Applicant and the Respondents are parties in MILIMANI ELCA No. E210 of 2024 (Stephen Okoth Mwanga-vs-Jovan Kariuki t/a Moran Auctioneers & Doris Waruri Kimorori, the Applicant has to establish existence of other factors for the doctrine of sub judice to be invoked.
17. The court in Showcase Properties Limited Vs Kenya Commercial Bank Ltd & another [2023] KEHC 24601 (KLR) stated: -
A five-judge bench in the case of David Ndii & others Vs Attorney General & others 2021 eKLR, had this to say in regard to the doctrine of sub-judice‘‘The rationale behind this provision (Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act) is that it is vexatious and oppressive for a claimant to sue concurrently in two courts. Where there are two courts faced with substantially the same question or issue, that question or issue should be determined in only one of those courts, and the court will....’’For the doctrine of sub judice to be successfully invoked, the person seeking to invoke it has to demonstrate that the matter in issue in the subsequent suit is directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit, proceedings must be between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title and such suit
or proceeding must be pending in the same or any other Court having jurisdiction in Kenya to grant the relief claimed.”
18. From the foregoing, it is clear that for the doctrine of sub judice to apply, the following elements must be satisfied: the matter in issue in the subsequent suit must be directly and substantially the same as that in the earlier suit; the parties must be the same or litigating under the same title; and the earlier suit must be pending before a court of competent jurisdiction.
19. From the above analysis however, there can be no doubt that the matters in issue are totally different. That a determination on the court of appeal matter would not render this instant suit res judicata as the issues raised in this suit will not have been conclusively dealt with to conclusion in the court of appeal matter. Accordingly, this instant suit and the application herein cannot be said to be sub-judice.
Final disposition
The upshot of the above is that;
i. That the Notice of Motion application dated 17th February 2026 is not merited and is hereby dismissed.
ii. Costs be awarded to Respondent.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 22nd day of October 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
Mr. Adier for the Plaintiff/Respondent
N/A for the Respondent
Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant