Background
What is before the Court for determination is the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion dated 6th May 2025 in which it seeks the following Orders:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
What is before the Court for determination is the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion dated 6th May 2025 in which it seeks the following Orders:
Paragraph 1 →In the foregoing, I find the Notices of Preliminary Objections unmerited and will disallow them. I find the instant Notice of Motion application dated 6th May 2025 merited and will allow it in the following terms:
Paragraph 34 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC CASE NO. 2278 OF 2007
KENYA ANTI-CORRUPTION
COMMISSION ………………………………………………..…… PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
ESTHER MUMBI KIRONJO ………….…………………… DEFENDANT
RULING
1. What is before the Court for determination is the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion dated 6th May 2025 in which it seeks the following Orders:
a) This Honourable Court be pleased to order that this suit be consolidated with the following matters:
1. ELC No. 136 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Kimeo Stores Limited.
2. ELC No. 1116 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Wariwax Generation Limited.
3. ELC No. 1117 of 2007 KACC Vs. Satellite Industrial Supplies Limited.
4. ELC No. 1118 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Parkside Medical Centre Limited.
5. ELC No. 69 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Rose W. Kimani.
6. ELC No. 517 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Phoebe W. Gakui.
7. ELC No. 624 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Bali Investments Limited.
8. ELC No. 124 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Jamma Consolidated Limited & Another.
9. ELC No. 334 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Amina Ahmed Abdi & 3 Others.
10. ELC No 535 of 2008 KACC –Vs- David G. Muriithi.
11. ELC No. 498 of 2008 KACC-VS-Henry M. Matege.
12. ELC No. 86 of 2007 KACC –Vs- Gitwany Investments Limited.
13. ELC No. 623 of 2008 KACC –Vs- Peter K. Nyagaka.
14. ELC No. 68 of 2007 KACC –Vs- Marewa Plantations Limited.
15. ELC No.71 of 2007 KACC -Vs -Philip K. Wainaina.
16. ELC No. 101 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Industrial Collaborative Limited.
17. ELC No. 70 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Catherine R. Njeri.
18. ELC NO. 67 of 2007 KACC –Vs- Abishax Heights Limited.
19. ELC No. 103 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Brookside Studios Limited.
20. ELC No. 295 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Albina G. Koskey.
21. ELC No. 84 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Chrisna Holdings Limited.
22. ELC No. 367 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Fred Wainaina.
23. ELC No. 100 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Mwangi H. C. Wangondu.
24. ELC No. 1492 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Wairimu Kanga.
25. ELC No. 2057 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Francis Maritim.
26. ELC No. 402 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Emrose Academy Limited.
27. ELC No. 29 of 2009 KACC -Vs- Yellow Horse Inns Limited.
28. ELC No. 280 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Musalia Mudavadi.
29. ELC No. 2092 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Kapsoen Estates Limited.
30. ELC No. 106 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Hammerheads Limited.
31. ELC No. 2058 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Virginia Turuka.
32. ELC No. 184 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Hellen Njambi Mbugua.
33. ELC No. 2056 of 2007(ELC No.1145 of 2007) KACC -Vs-Zipporah Naisenya Waiyaki.
34. ELC No. 4 of 2008 KACC -Vs-Mercy Mutugi Mugo.
35. ELC No. 105 of 2008 KACC -Vs-Carolizanne Gathoni Kuria.
36. ELC No. 107 of 2008 KACC -Vs-Catherine Ruria.
37. ELC No. 1993 of 2007 KACC -Vs-Noel K.
Wambua.
38. ELC No. 1942 of 2007 KACC -Vs-EVELYN Wanjiru Ngatunyi.
39. ELC No.2277 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Boinanje Services Limited.
40. ELC No. 366 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Benson Irungu Mbaria.
41. ELC No. 369 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Benson Irungu Mbaria.
42. ELC No. 621 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Morionson Holdings Limited.
43. ELC No. 496 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Mary W. Mwangi.
44. ELC No. 2278 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Esther Mumbi Kironjo.
45. ELC No. 66 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Kirichwa Estates.
46. ELC No. 55 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Harun Mathu.
47. ELC No. 2047 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Eva N. Gaitha.
b) That ELC 2278 of 2007 be deemed as lead file and the
proceedings be taken therein.
c) Spent.
d) This Honourable Court be pleased to make such other further orders as the interest of justice may demand in the circumstances.
e) Costs be in the cause.
2. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the supporting affidavit of Dedan Okwama, an investigator with the Plaintiff. He avers that the Plaintiff carried out investigations into allegations of irregular sub-division, sale and transfer of houses situated on LR No. 209/13539, I.R No. 76717, Woodley/Joseph Kang’ethe Estate, which revealed that the said houses were purportedly sold without the consent of the Minister for Local Government, without a resolution of the then Municipal Council and without consent from the Commissioner for Lands to transfer the said houses to private individuals and companies. Further, that following the discovery, the Plaintiff, pursuant to its statutory mandate, instituted civil suits for recovery against the persons who had allegedly bought houses on the suit land.
3. He points out that Nairobi ELC No. 2054 of 2007 Kenya Anti-
Corruption Commission versus Paul Moses Ngetha is one such suit and during its pendency, the Plaintiff made an application dated 23rd May 2013, seeking consolidation of the said suit with other related forty one (41) suits and on 11th July 2013, the Court declined to allow consolidation and instead designated ELC 2054 OF 2007 as the primary file, then gave directions that the suits listed in the said application for consolidation be stayed pending the hearing and determination of the said primary file.
4. He claims that the Plaintiff inadvertently left out seventeen (17) matters in its application dated 23rd May 2013 seeking consolidation, filed in ELC 2054 OF 2007 and to regularize all the matters, it wrote to the Court vide its letter dated 24th February 2015 seeking directions and that the Court directed that all matters pertaining to Woodley Estate would be mentioned together.
5. He contends that the primary suit, ELC NO. 2054 OF 2007 was heard and determined in the Plaintiff’s favour vide this Court’s judgement dated 27th February 2020, issued by Okong’o J, (as he then was). Aggrieved by the said decision, the Defendant in the said primary suit lodged an Appeal vide Civil Appeal No. E375 OF 2020 Paul Moses Ngetha v Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission & another, which was determined by the Court of Appeal vide judgement delivered on 8th November 2024, in favour of the Respondent (Plaintiff herein).
6. He contends that the Woodley Estate matters arise from the same investigation and raise similar issues of law hence the need for consolidation to enable expeditious and timely disposal. He argues that consolidation will avert different judgements being entered on the same issues of law, considering that there are also developing issues affecting Woodley estate matters including recovery of part of the estate by the County Government of Nairobi for the Development of the affordable housing project by the National Government.
Response
7. The application is opposed by several Defendants in the related Woodley estate matters, though they filed their responses in their respective files. The 4th Defendant in ELC 535 OF 2008, Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission v David Gachina Muriithi, Zipporah Mbesa Wandera, Mercy Mutuhi Mugo and Emmanuel Kuria Wagathoni filed Grounds of Opposition and a Preliminary Objection.
8. His Preliminary Objection is based on grounds that the application is untenable as it seeks, through consolidation, to bind parties who were not litigants in Civil Appeal No. E375 of 2020 to factual findings made in proceedings to which they were strangers, contrary to the rules of natural justice and the constitutional guarantee of a fair hearing under Articles 25(c), 48 and 50 of the Constitution. Further, that the application is an abuse of Court process as it seeks to relieve the Plaintiff of its statutory burden of proving its case against each Defendant individually, contrary to Sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act.
9. Vide his Grounds of Opposition, the said 4th Defendant contends that the Plaintiff has failed to establish that the pending suits raise substantially the same questions of fact and law so as to warrant consolidation. Further, that although the suits arise from properties formerly comprised in Woodley Estate, each suit concerns a separate parcel of land, a separate transaction, separate parties, separate pleadings and distinct factual issues requiring independent adjudication.
10. The Defendant in ELC 67 OF 2007- Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission v Abishax Heights Limited also filed Grounds of Opposition and a Preliminary Objection that mirrors the 4th Defendant’s in ELC 535 OF 2008. Similar pleadings were filed by the Defendants represented by messrs Kariuki Muigua & Company Advocates in ELC 1116 of 2007, 1117 of 2007, 1118 of 2007, 124 of 2008, 334 of 2008, 535 of 2008, 101 of 2007, 103 of 2007, 402 of 2008, 29 of 2009, 106 of 2008, 105 of 2008, 107 of 2008 and 1993 of 2007.
11. The Plaintiff in ELC 1511 of 2007, Peter Mureithi Ngatia v The County Government of Nairobi, filed a replying affidavit in opposition. He avers that his suit was withdrawn in the year 2010 thus it does not exist and therefore there cannot be consolidation with a concluded case. Further, that upon hearing the application dated 23rd May 2023 filed by the Plaintiff herein in the said matter, Hon. Justice Mutungi observed that: “That for the avoidance of doubt, the decision in ELC No. 2054 of 2007 will not have any binding effect on the other suits stayed to await the decision in ELC 2054 of 2007.”
12. He contends that the said finding has never been reviewed or set aside, but the instant application seeks to circumvent it.
13. The Defendant in ELC Case No. 1492 of 2007 filed a replying affidavit sworn by Kimamo Kuria, Advocate. He contends that consolidating the said case with the rest would disadvantage the Defendant who would not be accorded a fair hearing.
14. The Defendant in ELC NO. 66 OF 2007 filed a replying affidavit sworn by its director, Phoebe Nyaguthii Kariuki. She contends that the order staying proceedings in Woodley matters, made in ELC 2054 of 2007 was explicit that the decision and findings in ELC 2054 of 2007 would not bind the matters stayed. Further, that the transactions in all the said matters are different, thus each case ought to be determined on its own.
15. The Defendant in ELC 84 OF 2007 filed a replying affidavit in opposition. He avers that his case is distinct because unlike other Defendants in the suits filed by the Plaintiff, he has never taken possession of the suit property and that he has been ready and willing to surrender his interest in the suit property upon reimbursement. He therefore insists that there is no common question of law to warrant consolidation with other matters.
16. The Defendant in ELC 498 OF 2008 is deceased. John Patrick Gatete, an administrator of his estate filed a replying affidavit in opposition. He contends that the suit against the deceased abated one year upon his death by operation of law thus an attempt to consolidate the suit with others would be to unprocedurally revive the suit.
17. The Defendant in ELC 1492 of 2007 filed a replying affidavit in opposition, which mirrors the rest of the Defendants’ who are opposed to the application.
18. Some Defendants were categorical that they were not opposed to the application while the rest did not file responses.
19. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions.
Submissions
20. The Plaintiff submits that this suit and fourty seven (47) others arise
from the same set of facts being that it conducted investigations and established that LR No. 209/13539 was subdivided and the houses sitting on each subdivision unlawfully sold thus it instituted suits for recovery. Further, that all the suits raise identical questions of law and fact, specifically whether the alienation of the suit property was lawful, whether due process, including requisite approvals was followed and whether the Defendants acquired titles for resultant subdivisions. It insists that the reliefs sought across the suits are also substantially similar and are directed at recovery.
21. It reiterates that the suits listed at paragraph one (1) were stayed pending the outcome of the Primary file, ELC No. 2054 of 2007, and none has proceeded to full hearing, thus consolidation will eliminate the risk of inconsistent judgements, promote prudent use of judicial resources and save on costs and time. It also submits that in contrast, separate suits would occasion multiplicity of proceedings and an inefficient use of judicial resources contrary to the overriding objective under Sections 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act. It urges the Court to consider that no party will be prejudiced as proceedings will be streamlined for conclusive determination. To buttress its averments, it relied on the following decisions: Korean United Church of Kenya & 3 others v Seng Ha Sanga [2014] eKLR; Nyati Security Guards & Services Ltd v Municipal Council of Mombasa [2004] eKLR and EAN Kenya Limited v John Sawers & 4 others [2007] eKLR.
22. The 4th Defendant in ELC 535 OF 2008 submits that the Plaintiff has failed to satisfy the threshold upon which this Court may exercise its discretion to order consolidation of suits. He argues that consolidation is not a right available to a litigant upon request, but it is a discretionary case-management tool whose objective is to facilitate the fair, efficient and economical determination of disputes. He submits that the mere fact that various parcels of land in dispute originally formed part of Woodley Estate does not justify the consolidation of all pending suits as the legal and factual questions arising in each suit are not identical. He also argues that if the orders sought are granted, together with other Defendants’, their constitutional right to a fair hearing, access to justice and due process guaranteed under Articles 25(c), 48 and 50 of the Constitution would be undermined. He insists that each Defendant has a unique case and may rely upon different statutory protections, equitable doctrines or factual circumstances thus consolidation will be prejudicial. To buttress his averments, he relied on the case of Law Society of Kenya v Centre for Human Rights and Democracy & 12 others (Petition 14 of 2013) [2014] KESC 29 (KLR).
23. The Defendant in ELC 67 OF 2007 filed submissions that mirror the 4th Defendant’s in ELC 535 OF 2008. The Court has also carefully considered all submissions filed in opposition to the Application.
Analysis and Determination
24. Upon consideration of the instant Notice of Motion application including the respective affidavits, Grounds of Opposition, Notice of Preliminary Objections and rivalling submissions, the issue for determination is whether the Plaintiff has made a case for consolidation of this suit with the cases listed at paragraph one herein and if the Preliminary Objections raised in ELC 535 OF 2008 and in ELC 67 OF 2007 are merited.
25. The Plaintiff seeks consolidation of this matter with forty seven (47) others listed at paragraph one herein, on the basis that the said suits arise from similar facts, being recovery of houses sitting on LR No. 209/13539, which was subdivided and the said houses unlawfully sold. Further, it seeks for the instant suit to be the lead file. It also contends that the said forty-seven (47) files were stayed pending hearing of ELC No. 2054 of 2007, which was designated as the primary file. Further, that the said suit was heard and determined in its favour and the judgement upheld in Civil Appeal No. E375 OF 2020 Paul Moses Ngetha v Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission & another.
26. On their part, some of the Defendants who opposed the application contend that the threshold for consolidation was not met and that allowing the application risks trampling on their right to a fair hearing, access to justice and due process guaranteed under Articles 25(c), 48 and 50 of the Constitution.
27. Some Defendants also raised a preliminary objection claiming that the Plaintiff seeks to bind parties who were not litigants in Civil Appeal No. E375 of 2020 to factual findings made in proceedings to which they were strangers, contrary to the rules of natural justice and the constitutional guarantee of a fair hearing under Articles 25(c), 48 and 50 of the Constitution. On raising of a Preliminary Objection, in Mukisa Biscuits Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] 1 EA it was stated that:
“…..a preliminary objection consists of a point of law which has been pleaded or which arises by clear implication out of the pleadings, and which if argued as a preliminary point may dispose of the suit…..”
28. On consolidation of suits, Order 11 Rule 3 (1)(h) and (i) of the Civil Procedure Rules provides as follows:
“3. (1) With a view to furthering expeditious disposal of cases and case management the court shall within thirty days after the close of pleadings convene a Case Conference in which it shall;
h) consider consolidation of suits;..”
29. The Supreme Court stated as follows in Omoke v Kenyatta & 83 others (Petition 11 (E015) of 2021) [2021] KESC 27 (KLR):
“Consolidation of suits or appeals will be ordered where there are common questions of either law or fact in two or more suits or appeals and where it is desirable that all the related matters be disposed of at the same time.”
30. The same Court stated as follows in Law Society of Kenya v Centre
for Human Rights & Democracy & 12 others [2014] eKLR:
“The essence of consolidation is to facilitate the efficient and expeditious disposal of disputes, and to provide a framework for a fair and impartial dispensation of justice to the parties. Consolidation was never meant to confer any undue advantage upon the party that seeks it, nor was it intended to occasion any disadvantage towards the party that opposes it.”
31. In this instance, no party has disputed that the respective suit properties are resultant subdivisions of LR No. 209/13539, I.R No. 76717, Woodley/Joseph Kang’ethe Estate. Further, no party has disputed that the fulcrum of the dispute in ELC 2054 of 2007 revolved around one of the resultant subdivisions of LR No. 209/13539, I.R No. 76717, Woodley/Joseph Kang’ethe Estate. On perusal of proceedings in ELC 2054 of 2007 which proceeded as the rest of the matters now sought to be consolidated herein had been stayed, I note, the same questions of law arise. Further, that KACC (now EACC) seeks the same rights and reliefs arising from the disposal of resultant subdivisions of LR No. 209/13539, I.R No. 76717. I further note that there were a series of transactions touching on the resultant subdivisions of LR No. 209/13539, I. No. 76717. Even if majority of the parties herein have argued that they will be disadvantaged if the suits are consolidated since their rights to fair hearing will be curtailed, I opine that the intended consolidation will not prejudice or disadvantage any of them. To my mind, the consolidation will aid in the expeditious and timely disposal of these suits which all revolve around LR No. 209/13539, I.R No. 76717. Further, the Defendant in ELC 66 of 2007 has argued that the Court in ELC 2054 of 2007 had declined the application for consolidation of these suits but I beg to disagree as the Order therein is explicit that the Plaintiff’s application for consolidation in ELC 2054 of 2007 was abandoned, which in essence means it was not heard on merit.
32. I however note that the Plaintiff in ELC 1511 of 2007, Peter Mureithi Ngatia v The County Government of Nairobi contends that his suit was withdrawn in the year 2010 thus it does not exist and therefore it cannot be consolidated with this suit. Further, in ELC 498 of 2008, the Defendant died and the suit against him abated and hence cannot be consolidated.
33. In the circumstances, I will allow the consolidation of the suits named above save for ELC 1511 of 2007 and ELC 498 of 2008.
34. In the foregoing, I find the Notices of Preliminary Objections unmerited and will disallow them. I find the instant Notice of Motion application dated 6th May 2025 merited and will allow it in the following terms:
1) This suit be and is hereby consolidated with the following matters:
• ELC No. 136 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Kimeo Stores Limited.
• ELC No. 1116 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Wariwax Generation Limited.
• ELC No. 1117 of 2007 KACC Vs. Satellite Industrial Supplies Limited.
• ELC No. 1118 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Parkside Medical Centre Limited.
• ELC No. 69 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Rose W. Kimani.
• ELC No. 517 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Phoebe W. Gakui.
• ELC No. 624 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Bali Investments Limited.
• ELC No. 124 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Jamma Consolidated Limited & Another.
• ELC No. 334 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Amina Ahmed Abdi & 3 Others.
• ELC No 535 of 2008 KACC –Vs- David G. Muriithi.
• ELC No. 86 of 2007 KACC –Vs- Gitwany Investments Limited.
• ELC No. 623 of 2008 KACC –Vs- Peter K. Nyagaka.
• ELC No. 68 of 2007 KACC –Vs- Marewa Plantations Limited.
• ELC No. 71 of 2007 KACC -Vs -Philip K. Wainaina.
• ELC No. 101 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Industrial Collaborative Limited.
• ELC No. 70 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Catherine R. Njeri.
• ELC NO. 67 of 2007 KACC –Vs- Abishax Heights Limited.
• ELC No. 103 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Brookside Studios Limited.
• ELC No. 295 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Albina G. Koskey.
• ELC No. 84 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Chrisna Holdings Limited.
• ELC No. 367 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Fred Wainaina.
• ELC No. 100 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Mwangi H. C. Wangondu.
• ELC No. 1492 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Wairimu Kanga.
• ELC No. 2057 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Francis Maritim.
• ELC No. 402 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Emrose Academy Limited.
• ELC No. 29 of 2009 KACC -Vs- Yellow Horse Inns Limited.
• ELC No. 280 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Musalia Mudavadi.
• ELC No. 2092 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Kapsoen Estates Limited.
• ELC No. 106 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Hammerheads Limited.
• ELC No. 2058 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Virginia Turuka.
• ELC No. 184 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Hellen Njambi Mbugua.
• ELC No. 2056 of 2007(ELC No.1145 of 2007) KACC -Vs-Zipporah Naisenya Waiyaki.
• ELC No. 4 of 2008 KACC -Vs-Mercy Mutugi Mugo.
• ELC No. 105 of 2008 KACC -Vs-Carolizanne Gathoni Kuria.
• ELC No. 107 of 2008 KACC -Vs-Catherine Ruria.
• ELC No. 1993 of 2007 KACC -Vs-Noel K. Wambua.
• ELC No. 1942 of 2007 KACC -Vs-EVELYN Wanjiru Ngatunyi.
• ELC No. 2277 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Boinanje Services Limited.
• ELC No. 366 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Benson Irungu Mbaria.
• ELC No. 369 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Benson Irungu Mbaria.
• ELC No. 621 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Morionson Holdings Limited.
• ELC No. 496 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Mary W. Mwangi.
• ELC No. 2278 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Esther Mumbi Kironjo.
• ELC No. 66 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Kirichwa Estates.
• ELC No. 55 of 2008 KACC -Vs- Harun Mathu.
• ELC No. 2047 of 2007 KACC -Vs- Eva N. Gaitha.
2) That ELC 2278 of 2007 be deemed as lead file and the proceedings be taken therein.
3) Costs will be in the cause.
DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 12TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
CHRISTINE OCHIENG
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Cherono for Kenya Anti-corruption Commission (Plaintiff) in all matters
Wabuko for Kuria for Defendants in 142 of 2007, 204 of 2007
Karwanda for Defendant in 66 of 2007
Makau for Defendant in 100 of 2007
Yala for Mwangi for Defendant in Misc 4 of 2008
Namwonja for Defendant in 84 of 2007
Karanja for Defendant in 498 of 2008
Court Assistant: Joan