Land law

Gachui (Suing in her Capacity as the Executrix of the Estate of James Mungai Gachui (Deceased) v Ouko & 2 others [2026] KEELC 6528 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Environmental and Land Originating Summons 330 of 2011
Judgment date
12 October 2026
Judge(s)
CA Ochieng

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is before the Court for determination are two pending applications.

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

Based on the facts as presented while relying on the legal provisions cited as well as associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that since the Defendants already applied for stay of execution in the Court of Appeal, which did not grant it, they cannot turn around to apply for stay of proceedings in this Court. In the foregoing, I find that stay of proceedings is not warranted and will decline to grant it.

Paragraph 27 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC SUIT NO. 330 OF 2011 (O.S)

ANNE PEARL KARIMI GACHUI

Suing in her Capacity as the Executrix of the Estate of

JAMES MUNGAI GACHUI (DECEASED) …………..…… PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

AARON OUKO ………………………………………….…. 1ST DEFENDANT

ROSALYNE DOLA OUKO …………………….………. 2ND DEFENDANT

ANDREW ATINDA OUKO ……………………….…… 3RD DEFENDANT

RULING

1. What is before the Court for determination are two pending applications.

Notice of Motion dated 25th February 2025

2. It is filed by the Plaintiff who seeks the following Orders:

a) That the Honourable Court be pleased to find that the first, second, and third Respondents are in contempt of Court for disobeying and/ or willfully disregarding the orders given herein on 13th October 2022.

b) That the Honourable Court be pleased to issue a Notice to Show Cause against the Respondents to show cause why they should not be committed to civil jail for contempt of the Court orders of 13th October 2022.

c) Any other or further order that the Court may deem fit to grant.

d) The costs of this application be awarded to the Applicant.

3. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the Plaintiff’s supporting affidavit. She avers that vide the judgment of 13th October 2022, this Court directed the Defendants to issue her with a title in respect of a portion identified as L.R. No. 3589/6 (G) measuring 4. 942acres and a decree was subsequently extracted, requiring the Defendants to immediately process title to her in that respect. She points out that the Defendants were at all times represented by advocates in the suit thus they are aware of this Court’s orders.

4. She contends that she is aware that the Defendants have completed the sub-division of the suit parcel, and that her advocates have written to them seeking a copy of the title to no avail. Further, that instead of complying with this Court’s Order, the Respondents have filed an Appeal and sought stay, but the said Appeal was however not certified urgent and stay was declined. He contends that from the Defendant’s conduct, it is clear that they have no intention of obeying Court Orders.

Response

5. The application is opposed by the Defendants vide the 1st Defendant’s replying affidavit. He denies allegations that the Defendants are in disobedience of this Court Orders of 13th October 2022, and confirms that there is a pending Appeal against the said orders in Nairobi Civil Appeal E721 OF 2023, and a stay application in Nairobi Civil Application E512 OF 2024. He urges the Court to await the final determination of the appellate Court.

6. He argues that the elements that must be proved to make the case for civil contempt have not been met, and points out that the Plaintiff has not annexed to its application, any evidence of service to substantiate its claim that the Defendants had actual and personal knowledge of the impugned Court Order but deliberately acted in breach. Further, that there is no demonstration that the Defendants have willfully neglected to obey the impugned Court Order.

Notice of Motion dated 27th October 2025

7. It is filed by the Defendants who seek the following Orders;

a) Spent.

b) Spent.

c) That the Honourable Court be pleased to issue an order of stay of further proceedings herein pending the hearing and determination of Nairobi Civil Application No. E512 OF 2024 Rosalyn Dola Ouko and 2 others v Anne Pearl Karimi filed at the Court of Appeal.

d) That the Honourable court be pleased to issue an order of stay of further proceedings herein pending the hearing and determination of Nairobi Civil Appeal No. E721 OF 2023 Rosalyn Dola Ouko and 2 others v Anne Pearl Karimi filed at the Court of Appeal.

e) That the costs if the application be borne by the Plaintiff.

8. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the 1st Defendant’s supporting affidavit. He avers that the Defendants, aggrieved by this Court’s judgement issued on 13th October 2022, filed Civil Appeal E721 OF 2023 Rosalyn Dola Ouko and 2 others v Anne Pearl Karimi at the Court of Appeal, where they have taken directions for hearing and have even filed submissions. Further, that simultaneously with the said Appeal, they filed Nairobi Civil Application E512 OF 2024, Rosalyn Dola Ouko and 2 others v Anne Pearl Karimi, under Rule 5(2)(b) of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2022. He contends that taking into consideration that the Court of Appeal is now seized with the appeal and application, it is prudent that the Court halts proceedings to avoid the likelihood of the said appeal and application, which are arguable, being rendered moot and overtaken by events. He insists that the Defendants will be prejudiced by the failure of this Court to grant an order of stay of proceedings since the contempt of Court proceedings carry serious consequences, which are likely to result to the Defendants’ conviction and a possibility of serving a sentence or payment of a fine before the appeal and application are heard and determined by the Court of Appeal.

Response

9. The application is opposed by the Plaintiff who filed Grounds of Opposition. She avers that the issue of contempt ought to be determined as a preliminary issue. Further, that the application is an attempt by the Defendants to prevent her from enjoying the fruits of her judgement as it seeks to stay proceedings at post judgment stage. She points out that the Court of Appeal has declined to certify the Defendants’ application for stay as urgent or to issue any orders of stay thus the instant application is an abuse of process.

10. The applications were canvassed by way of written submissions.

Submissions

11. In support of her Notice of Motion dated 25th February 2025, the Plaintiff submits that despite this Court’s judgement of 13th October 2022, requiring the Defendants’ to complete the subdivision in respect of the suit property and issue her with a title, the Defendants have continued to disobey the said orders despite being aware of the same as knowledge of the terms of an order supersedes personal service. She reiterates that the Defendants were represented by an advocate in the entire proceedings.

12. To buttress her averments, the Plaintiff relied on the following decisions: Bia Tosha Distributors Limited v Kenya Breweries Limited & 6 others (Petition 15 of 2020) [2023] eKLR; Shimmers Plaza Limited v National Bank of Kenya Ltd [2015] eKLR; North Tetu Farmers Co. Ltd v Joseph Nderitu Wanjohi [2016] eKLR; Muititika v Baharini Farm Ltd [1985] eKLR; Sam Nyamweya & 3 others v Kenya Premier League Limited & 2 others [2015] eKLR and Abdulrazak Muhsin Shariff v Kadzo Masha Kazungu & 2 others [2014] eKLR .

13. In opposition to the Defendants’ application for stay, the Plaintiff submits that the Defendants have not satisfied the requirements for grant of stay as espoused in the case of Kenya Power & Lighting Company Limited v Esther Wanjiru Wokabi [2014] KEHC 3174(KLR). Further, that they have not satisfied the threshold under Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules as they have not demonstrated any loss they are likely to suffer if stay is not granted and they have not offered any security for due performance of the Decree.

14. She also submits that the merits of the Defendants’ case do not raise an arguable appeal warranting this Court to issue an order of stay of proceedings and that the application is filed after inordinate delay, more than three (3) years after the judgement was delivered in the matter. Further, that the Defendants have not provided any sufficient cause for grant of an order of stay of proceedings, but they just seek to evade contempt proceedings arising out of their failure to comply with this Court’s judgement. She also argues that an application brought by a person in contempt ought not be entertained until such contempt has been purged.

15. To buttress her averments, she relied on the following decisions: Kenya Wildlife Service v James Mutembei [2019] eKLR; Board of Management, Eldoret Secondary School v Board of Trustees, Good News Church of Africa (Civil Application E084 OF 2021) [2023]KECA 261(KLR) (17 March 2023) (Ruling); Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance v Cabinet Secretary for Devolution and Planning & another; Centre for Human and Civic Education & another (Interested Parties);Kenya National Commission for Human Rights(Amicus Curiae) (Petition 351 of 2025) [2017] KEHC 8755 (KLR) (Constitutional and Human Rights) (12 May 2017) (Ruling), and Wangalwa & another v Agnes Naliaka Cheseto [2012] eKLR.

16. On their part, in opposition to the Plaintiff’s application for contempt, the Defendants submit that to find one guilty of contempt of Court, two fundamental elements must be proved; knowledge of the order and willful act of disobedience and in this case, none has been demonstrated. They insist that the Plaintiff has not annexed to her application any evidence to substantiate her claim of service or evidence that they had actual and personal knowledge of the impugned Court order, and elected to disobey. Further, that the Plaintiff has not adduced any evidence of the decree being endorsed with a notice of penal consequences as required.

17. They insist that there is no willful and deliberate disobedience of the Court orders, as they were aggrieved by the decision of the Court and opted to file Civil Appeal E721 of 2023 and Civil Application E512 of 2024. Further, that the exercise of the right of appeal and stay of execution is neither willful nor deliberate disobedience of Court orders.

18. To buttress their averments, they relied on the following decisions: Mweru & Others v National Land Commission & 2 Others [2020] KEHC 9233 (KLR); Republic v Kenya School of Law & 2 others Ex parte Juliet Wanjiru Njoroge & 5 others [2015] KEHC 6933 (KLR); SMEC International Property Limited v Principal Secretary, Ministry of East African Community and Regional Development & Another [2023] KEHC 22837 (KLR); Nyamodi Ochieng Nyamogo & another v Kenya Posts & Telecommunications Corporation [1994] KECA 114 (KLR), and others which the court has carefully considered.

19. In support of their stay application, the Defendants submit that under Order 46 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules, this Court has jurisdiction to grant an order for stay of proceedings pending Appeal, and that the said jurisdiction is reinforced by its inherent jurisdiction under Section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act.

20. They further submit that given the serious consequences that emanates from contempt of Court proceedings, it is essential that an order of stay of these proceedings be issued to allow them to pursue their right of appeal at the Court of Appeal as the Plaintiff is not prejudiced in any way. To this end, they relied on the case of Anders Bruel TA Queens cross Aviation v Nyabura Musyimi & 2 Others 2015 KEHC 1899 (KLR).

Analysis and Determination

21. Upon consideration of the two instant Notice of Motion applications including the respective affidavits as well as rivalling submissions, the following are the issues for determination:

• Whether the Defendants have met the threshold for grant of stay of further proceedings herein pending the hearing and determination of Nairobi Civil Application No. E512 OF 2024 and Nairobi Civil Appeal No. E721 OF 2023.

• Whether the Defendants are in contempt of this court’s orders of 13th October 2022.

22. Judgment was delivered in the matter on 13th October 2022, directing the Defendants to process and issue the Plaintiff with title in respect of L.R. No. 3589/6(G), measuring approximately 4.942 acres. It is the Plaintiff’s case that the Defendants have willfully disobeyed the said orders, which she contends they were aware of by virtue of being represented through proceedings in the suit and by virtue of having lodged an Appeal.

23. The Defendants contend that they are not in contempt of the impugned judgement, as they were dissatisfied by it and subsequently lodged Civil Appeal No. E721 of 2023 against it entirely and Civil Application No. E512 of 2024 seeking stay of execution before the Court of Appeal. They argue that pursing their right of Appeal cannot be termed as being in disobedience of Court orders. They insist that there is no evidence that they were served with the impugned orders or that they willfully disobeyed them, and that the Plaintiff has not adduced any evidence of the decree being endorsed with a notice of penal consequences as required.

24. On the first issue, the Defendants’ application for stay is brought pursuant to Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules. They seek stay to halt the proceedings herein until their Appeal and application are determined by the Court of Appeal. In essence, they seek to stop the contempt proceedings arising from the alleged failure to comply with the judgment of 13th October 2022.

25. Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides that:

“(1)No appeal or second appeal shall operate as a stay of execution or proceedings under a decree or order appealed from except in so far as the court appealed from may order but, the court appealed from may for sufficient cause order stay of execution of such decree or order, and whether the application for such stay shall have been granted or refused by the court appealed from, the court to which such appeal is preferred shall be at liberty, on application being made, to consider such application and to make such order thereon as may to it seem just, and any person aggrieved by an order of stay made by the court from whose decision the appeal is preferred may apply to the appellate court to have such order set aside.(2)No order for stay of execution shall be made under subrule (1) unless—(a)the court is satisfied that substantial loss may result to the applicant unless the order is made and that the application has been made without unreasonable delay; and(b)such security as the court orders for the due performance of such decree or order as may ultimately be binding on him has been given by the applicant.”

26. In Kenya Wildlife Service v James Mutembei [2019] KEHC 10478 (KLR), it was held that:

“Stay of proceedings is a grave judicial action which seriously interferes with the right of a litigant to conduct his litigation. It impinges on the right of access to justice, the right to be heard without delay, and overall, the right to a fair trial. Therefore, the test for stay of proceedings is high and stringent. This is a power which, it has been emphasized, ought to be exercised sparingly, and only in exceptional cases… Stay of proceedings is a grave judicial action which seriously interferes with the right of a litigant to conduct his litigation…It will be exercised where the proceedings are shown to be frivolous, vexatious or harassing or to be manifestly groundless or in which there is no cause of action in law or equity…..”

27. Based on the facts as presented while relying on the legal provisions cited as well as associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that since the Defendants already applied for stay of execution in the Court of Appeal, which did not grant it, they cannot turn around to apply for stay of proceedings in this Court. In the foregoing, I find that stay of proceedings is not warranted and will decline to grant it.

28. As to whether the Defendants are in contempt of the impugned judgement, I wish to make reference to the case of Mutitika v Baharini Farm Ltd [1985] KECA 60 (KLR):

“In our view the standard of proof in contempt

proceedings must be higher than proof on the balance of probabilities, almost but not exactly, beyond reasonable doubt. We envisage no difficulty in courts determining the suggested standard of proof. The standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt ought to be left where it belongs, to wit, in criminal cases.”

29. Further, in Wildlife Lodges Limited v Narok County Council & 3 others [2011] KECA 280 (KLR) the Court of Appeal stated that:

“It was the plain and unqualified obligation of every person against or in respect of whom an order was made by a Court of competent jurisdiction to obey it until that order was discharged, and disobedience of such an order would, as a general rule, result in the person disobeying it being in contempt and punishable by committal or attachment and in an application to the court by him not being entertained until he had purged his contempt. A party who knows of an order, whether null or valid, regular or irregular, cannot be permitted to disobey it…...”

30. The Defendants claimed they were not served with the Court Orders as there is no affidavit of service which was filed to that effect. I however note that the Defendants were represented by an Advocate at the point the judgement was delivered. In my view they cannot feign ignorance of the Court Order as they have even lodged an Appeal. It is further well settled that knowledge of Court orders supersedes personal service. In Shimmers Plaza Limited v National Bank of Kenya Limited [2015] KECA 945 (KLR), the Court of Appeal stated that:

“Kenya's growing jurisprudence right from the High court has reiterated that knowledge of a court order suffices to prove service and dispense with personal service for the purposes of contempt proceedings. For instance, Lenaola J in the case of Basil Criticos Vs Attorney General and 8 Others [2012] eKLR pronounced himself as follows:- “...the law has changed and as it stands today knowledge supersedes personal service.....where a party clearly acts and shows that he had knowledge of a Court Order; the strict requirement that personal service must be proved is rendered unnecessary”

31. In the foregoing, while associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that the Defendants are indeed in contempt of the Judgement of the 13th October 2022, as they were represented by Counsel.

32. In the circumstances, I find the Notice of Motion application dated the

25th February 2025 merited and will allow it. I however find the Notice

of Motion application dated the 27th October 2025 unmerited and will dismiss it with costs.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 12TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

CHRISTINE OCHIENG

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Kahuria for Plaintiff

Ms Lukoye for Defendants

Court Assistant: Joan

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder