Land law

Njeru v Muchai & another (Sued as the Personal Representatives of Frank Bob Muigai (Deceased) & another [2026] KEELC 6524 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
ELC SUIT NO. 152 OF 2013
Judgment date
13 October 2026
Judge(s)
CA Ochieng

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is before the Court for determination is the 2nd Defendant’ s Notice of Motion application dated 29th April 2026 in which she seeks the following Orders:

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

In my view I find that the 2nd Defendant was properly served with summons to enter appearance and was indeed represented by the firm of SW Ndegwa & Co. Advocates but she chose not to participate in these proceedings. I hence find that the judgement entered herein against the 1st and 2nd Defendants was a regular one.

Paragraph 28 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC SUIT NO. 152 OF 2013

BONIFACE GIKUYA NJERU ……………………………….… PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

GRACE WAKONYO MUCHAI AND

Esther Nyokabi Muigai

Sued as the Personal Representatives

OF FRANK BOB MUIGAI (DECEASED) .............. 1ST DEFENDANT

ALICE WANJIRU ……………………………….………. 2ND DEFENDANT

RULING

1. What is before the Court for determination is the 2nd Defendant’ s Notice of Motion application dated 29th April 2026 in which she seeks the following Orders:

a) Spent.

b) That this Honourable Court be pleased to grant the firm of MEG Advocates LLP leave to come on record for the 2nd Defendant.

c) Spent.

d) That the default judgment entered herein against

the 2nd Defendant/Applicant and all consequential

decrees, orders, and proceedings arising therefrom (including the Eviction Order) be set aside ex debito justitiae as the same is an irregular judgment for want of proper service of Summons to Enter Appearance.

e) That in the alternative and without prejudice to the foregoing, the said default judgment be set aside on merit as the 2nd Defendant/Applicant has a bona fide defence disclosing triable issues, with high probability of success.

f) That the 2nd Defendant/Applicant be granted leave to file and serve her Statement of Defence, Witness Statement, List of Witnesses, List of Documents, and any other consequential pleadings within 14 days of the order herein with proceedings beginning de novo.

g) That the costs of this Application be in the cause.

2. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the 2nd Defendant’s supporting affidavit. She avers that she is a widow of the late Frank Bob Muigai, and the bona fide occupant and owner of Plot No. P9496, Ruai, which she claims is her matrimonial home where she has resided continuously, openly, and without interruption for over twenty (20) years thus she has an equitable interest in the property.

3. She contends that the Plaintiff obtained an eviction order in the suit and on 27th April 2026, accompanied by armed police officers, they went to her home and threatened to evict her thus unless the Court grants a stay of execution, she will be evicted yet she is elderly and did not even know that a case existed against her until the police arrived at her doorstep, as she has never been served with summons to enter appearance, pleadings and hearing notices. Further, that it is her advocates who upon search, discovered that a default judgment had been entered against her in the suit, with the Plaintiff claiming to have served her through messrs S. W Ndegwa & Co. Advocates whom she contends she has never instructed.

4. She claims that an eviction will cause her irreparable loss that no amount of money can ever compensate her, because a widow's home is not just a piece of land, it is her life, security, memories of her late husband and her place of dignity. She points out that the original suit was filed in 2013 against her late husband, Frank Bob Muigai and on 24th March 2014, the Plaintiff and her late husband entered into a consent judgment which purported to order her eviction from the suit property, even though she was not a party to the suit at that time. Further, that recognizing that she was never served with any documents, the Court set aside that said consent judgment on 21st November 2019 vide an Order of Hon. Justice B.M. Eboso and ordered that she be joined as a Defendant to the suit so that she could be heard, but she was never served.

5. On a without prejudice basis, she avers that she has a defence which raises several triable issues that ought to be heard by this Court. She points out that under the customary law applicable at the time, her late husband could not lawfully sell the matrimonial home without her consent. Further, that her overriding interest as a spouse in occupation takes precedence and that the transaction between the Plaintiff and her late husband is tainted with fraud and collusion. She insists that if the Plaintiff has a claim, it lies against the estate of her late husband for recovery not against her for eviction from her home. She urges the Court to uphold her right to hearing under Article 50(1) of the Constitution.

Response

6. The Plaintiff filed a replying affidavit in opposition. He avers that he is the registered owner of the suit property vide purchase from the late Frank Bob Muigai through an agreement of sale dated 24th June, 2011 and he paid a purchase price of Kshs.1.2 million. Further, that the late Frank Bob Muigai also filed a witness statement dated 17th November 2021, affirming his ownership of the suit property and stating that following the sale, he requested the 2nd Defendant to vacate the suit property but she refused to do so, adding that this Court confirmed his ownership.

7. He confirms that the 2nd Defendant was joined in this suit pursuant to a Court order issued on 17th January, 2020. Summons to Enter Appearance dated 4th February, 2020 were subsequently extracted and service effected upon her through the firm of messrs S. W. Ndegwa & Co. Advocates, who had filed a Notice of Appointment of Advocates dated 15th May, 2017, affirming that they had been instructed by the 2nd Defendant to act on her behalf thus his advocates served all pleadings, documents, and correspondence relating to this matter upon her advocates on record, through their registered email address, S.W.Ndegwa5@gmail.com.

8. He avers that at one point, the 2nd Defendant was personally served and he accompanied a Court process server on 2nd May, 2017 to effect service of a hearing notice dated 16th February, 2017 for the hearing on 16th May, 2017. He claims that shortly after the said personal service, the firm of messrs S. W Ndegwa & Company Advocates wrote a letter dated 11th July 2017 to his then advocates whereby the lawyers protested service of a hearing notice upon the 2nd Defendant directly, adding that it confirms the 2nd Defendant was in communication with her advocates.

9. He urges the Court to dismiss the application on the basis that the 2nd Defendant has no document of ownership, no document to support her case that the suit property is matrimonial property, and no proof that she was the deceased’s wife and even if she was the deceased’s wife, spousal consent was not applicable at the time of purchase. He claims that he is aware that the late Frank Bob Muigai was only married to the 1st Defendant and that she co-administers his estate with their daughter, one Esther Nyokabi Muigai.

10. He also contends that he stands to suffer prejudice if the application is allowed, as it would permit the 2nd Defendant to continue unlawfully residing on his property, which he lawfully acquired and of which he has been deprived of exclusive possession since purchase. He therefore urges the Court to set aside the status quo orders of 4th May 2026 unless the 2nd Defendant deposits kshs.500, 000 in respect of mesne profits in Court.

11. In response to the Plaintiff’s reply, the 2nd Defendant filed a supplementary affidavit. She avers that a Notice of Appointment of Advocates filed before a party is formally joined as a Defendant cannot constitute a valid appointment of advocates for the purpose of receiving summons to enter appearance. She further reiterates that the alleged summons to enter appearance dated 4th February 2020 were not served upon her personally and that there is no affidavit of service to that effect. She also denies ever instructing messrs S.W Ndegwa & Co. Advocates and urges the Court to find the said advocates’ alleged instructions to represent her would only favour the Plaintiff, given his alleged earlier collusion to enter into a consent judgement with her late husband in order to deprive her of the suit property. Further, that the said advocates did not file a Memorandum of Appearance in the matter therefore they cannot be said to have represented her.

12. On her marital status to Frank Bob Muigai (deceased), she insists that she was customarily married to him and that the existence of a customary marriage is a matter of fact that must be tried and determined in evidence. She also contends that the Plaintiff will not be prejudiced if the matter is allowed to proceed to hearing as he is not in occupation of the suit property while in contrast, she risks being condemned unheard. She also avers that the bundle of emails allegedly served on S.w.ndegwa5@gmail.com are accompanied by a delivery receipt thus there is no evidence that they were served.

13. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions.

Submissions

14. The 2nd Defendant submits that the Plaintiff never discharged the obligation to serve her with summons to enter appearance as required under Order 5 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules. Further, that even if S.W. Ndegwa & Co Advocates had instructions to represent her, which is denied, a Notice of Appointment to allegedly represent her was filed on 15th May 2017 when she was an ‘Intended Third Party’ in the matter, and no Memorandum of Appearance was ever filed on her behalf as required under Order 6 Rule 1 and 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules. Further, that a Notice of Appointment cannot substitute a Memorandum of Appearance thus she never formally entered appearance in these proceedings.

15. She also submits that the default judgment entered on 22nd September 2025 is not merely irregular, it is void ab initio and must be set aside as a matter of right, for contravening her right to hearing under Article 50(1) of the Constitution. Further, that the alleged service by email to her alleged advocates without a delivery receipt is not valid service under Order 5 Rule 22 (b) of the Civil Procedure Rules as amended by Legal Notice No. 22 of 2020, which provides that email service is only deemed to have been effected when the sender receives a delivery receipt. She reiterates that her defence raises triable issues being; whether the suit property is matrimonial property and whether spousal consent was obtained, validity of title, fraud and collusion, overriding interest and her marital status to the deceased.

16. To buttress her averments, the 2nd Defendant relied on the following decisions: Royal Media Services Ltd v Ominde & another (Civil Appeal E1195 of 2023) [2024] KEHC 9124 (KLR) (30 July 2024); Law Society of Kenya v Martin Day & 3 others [2015] eKLR; Abdulbasit Mohamed Ahmed Dahman & another v Fidelity Commercial Bank Limited [2016] eKLR; Firenze Investment Limited v Kenya Way Limited [2001] eKLR; Five Star Agencies Limited & another v Mutisya & another (Civil Appeal E013 of 2025) [2026] KEHC 4016 (KLR) (27 March 2026); James Kanyiita Nderitu & Another v Marios Philotas Ghikas & Another [2016] KECA 470 (KLR) (Civil Appeal 6 of 2015); BOD County Referral Hospital Kitale & another v DN (Civil Appeal E043 of 2023) [2025] KEHC 5344 (KLR) (30 April 2025); Kungu v Chege (Environment & Land Case E016 of 2021) [2022] KEELC 13589 (KLR), Commission for Human Rights and Justice v Jacob Kimutai Torutt & 5 Others [2021] eKLR; Patel v EA Cargo Handling Services Ltd [1974] EA 75 and Koros v Miriuki & another (Civil Appeal E229 of 2023) [2025].

17. On his part, the Plaintiff submits that the 2nd Defendant admits that the firm of messrs S.W. Ndegwa & Company Advocates were on record for her by virtue of seeking leave of this Court to allow new advocates to come on record for her. Further, that under Order 9 Rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules, any process served upon a party’s recognized agent, is of equal legal effect as though it had been served personally upon the party, unless the Court orders otherwise, thus the 2nd Defendant was properly served through messrs S.W Ndegwa & Co. Advocates. He points out that the record also indicates, pursuant to George Ogola Omondi ‘s affidavit of service, that the 2nd Defendant was personally served with Summons to Enter Appearance on 10th February, 2020.

18. On the 2nd Defendant’s contention that delivery receipts to show that emails were served upon the firm of S. W Ndegwa & Co Advocates were not availed, he submits that it is only the said firm that can dispute service. Further, on the allegation that no Memorandum of Appearance was filed on behalf of the 2nd Defendant, he submits that where an advocate has filed a Notice of Appointment of Advocates, there is no law that requires him to subsequently file a Memorandum of Appearance upon Summons being issued against his client and which makes failure to do so nullify his continued representation of that party.

19. He insists that the 2nd Defendant was not a wife of the deceased, citing the fact that she is not an administrator of his estate and that there is no consent she gave allowing the 1st Defendant to petition, but even if she was a wife, at the time the suit land was sold and transferred, spousal consent was not a statutory requirement as it was introduced by Section 79 (3) of the Land Act in May 2012, hence it cannot operate retrospectively to invalidate a completed transaction. He also submits that the alleged defence does not raise triable issues as the suit property is not matrimonial property and the 2nd Defendant’s claim for adverse possession is not available to her as she is not recognizing his ownership of the suit property.

20. To buttress his averments, the Plaintiff relied on several cases including: Florence Asami Agoro & 5 others v Samuel Oyindi Agoro & 2 others [2019] eKLR, and Eshai Tropical Gardens Limited v Nyangori & 2 others (Environment & Land Case 130 of 2016) [2025] KEELC 3982 (KLR) (15 May 2025) (Ruling).

Analysis and Determination

21. Upon consideration of the instant Notice of Motion application

including the respective affidavits as well as the rivalling submissions,

the following are issues for determination:

a) Whether the firm of MEG Advocates LLP should be granted leave to come on record for the 2nd Defendant.

b) Whether the 2nd Defendant has demonstrated sufficient cause to warrant setting aside this court’s judgement entered on 22nd September 2025, either ex debito justitiae or on the basis of a triable defence.

22. Judgement was entered for the Plaintiff on 22nd Septembers 2025, declaring him owner of the property known as P9496 and eviction orders were issued against the 2nd Defendant. The 2nd Defendant contends that she was not served with summons to enter appearance, pleadings and hearing notices therefore judgment ought to be set aside ex debito justitiae. In the alternative and on a without prejudice basis, she seeks that judgement be set aside on the basis that she has a merited defence which raises triable issues that the suit property is matrimonial property and that her late husband, Frank Bob Muigai could not sell it, without her consent. She also claims an equitable interest on the basis that she has resided thereon continuously, openly, and without interruption for over twenty (20) years.

23. In opposition, the Plaintiff contends that the firm of messrs S. W.

Ndegwa & Co. Advocates had filed a Notice of Appointment of Advocates dated 15th May, 2017, to act on the 2nd Defendant’s behalf thus his advocates served all pleadings to him. He also contends that summons to enter appearance were personally served on the 2nd Defendant and that there is an affidavit of service on record to that effect. He denies that the 2nd Defendant’s alleged defence raises triable issues and contends that the suit property is not matrimonial property.

24. On the first issue, Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides that:

“Where there is a change of advocate, or when a party decides to act in person having previously engaged an advocate, after judgment has been passed, such change or intention to act in person shall not be effected without an order of the court-

a. upon an application with notice to all parties or

b. upon a consent filed between the outgoing advocate and the proposed incoming advocate or party intending to act in person, as the case may be.”

25. Since there is no opposition to this prayer, I will rely on the legal provisions cited above and allow the firm of messrs MEG Advocates LLP to come on record for the 2nd Defendant.

26. On the second issue, this Court has discretion to set aside default judgement. On whether the judgement should be set aside ex debito justitiae, it is trite that judgement entered without proper service, is to be vacated as of right once it is brought to the Court’s attention. It is regarded as an irregular default judgement as per the distinguishing authority of the Court of Appeal in James Kanyiita Nderitu & Another [2016] KECA 470 (KLR), where the Court stated that:

“From the outset, it cannot be gainsaid that a distinction has always existed between a default judgement that is regularly entered and one which is irregularly entered. In a regular default judgement, the defendant will have been duly served with summons to enter appearance or to file defence, resulting in default judgment. Such a defendant is entitled, under order 10 rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules, to move the court to set aside the default judgement and to grant him leave to defend the suit. In such a scenario, the court has unfettered discretion in determining whether or not to set aside default judgment, and will take into account such factors as the reason for failure of the defendant to file his memorandum of appearance or defence, as the case may be; the length of time that has elapsed since the default judgment was entered; whether the intended defence raises triable issues; the respective prejudice each party is likely to suffer and whether on the whole it is in the interest of justice to set aside the default judgment, among others. ……In an irregular default judgment, on the other hand; judgment will have been entered against a defendant who has not been served or properly served with summons to enter appearance. In such a situation, the default judgment is set aside ex debito justiae, as a matter of right. The court does not even have to be moved by a party once it comes to its notice that the judgment is irregular; it can set aside the default judgment on its own motion….”

27. On perusal of the Court record, I note as per the affidavit of service sworn by Bernard Okoyo Ochieng, the 2nd Defendant had initially been served with a hearing notice including a notice of motion application on the 2nd May, 2017. Further, it is evident from the record that the 2nd Defendant was earlier on represented by the firm of messrs S.W Ndegwa Advocates. I also note that on the 15th June, 2022, the 2nd Defendant was represented in Court by SW Ndegwa Advocate. Further, he informed Court that the 2nd Defendant entered appearance but did not file defence. On 16th September, 2024, SW Ndegwa Advocate further appeared for the 2nd Defendant when a hearing date was scheduled on the 5th February, 2025. Thereafter the 2nd Defendant nor her advocate did not attend Court and the matter proceeded for hearing culminating in the impugned judgement sought to be set aside. Further, the process server Simon Jumba Indiaka swore an affidavit of service dated the 11th February, 2025 confirming he served both SW Ndegwa Advocate and the 1st Defendant’s legal representatives with the hearing notice. From the affidavit of service sworn by Simon Jumba Indiaka, it is evident the firm of messrs SW Ndegwa & Co Advocates were served on the 19th May, 2025 with the Plaintiff’s submissions as well as a mention notice. Further, the 1st Defendants were also served. Despite service, none of the Defendants attended Court. Yet in the affidavit of service sworn by George Ogola Omondi, the 2nd Defendant’s advocate messrs SW Ndegwa & Company Advocates was served with a pre trial notice dated the 6th December, 2019, on the 14th January, 2020. Further, vide the affidavit of service sworn by George Ogola Omondi, on the 10th December, 2020, he confirms that on the 10th February, 2020, he served the Summons to enter appearance together with the amended Plaint upon the 2nd Defendant through her daughter Penina Wanjiku who was an adult as the 2nd Defendant was not around.

28. In my view I find that the 2nd Defendant was properly served with summons to enter appearance and was indeed represented by the firm of SW Ndegwa & Co. Advocates but she chose not to participate in these proceedings. I hence find that the judgement entered herein against the 1st and 2nd Defendants was a regular one.

29. In Anjeli Limited v Kenga Simba & 12 others; Chengo Omar & 19 others (Intended Interested Parties) [2021] KEELC 1463 (KLR), it was held that:

“If a party is properly served and opts not to come to court, he can have nobody but himself to blame when judgment is entered against him. Nobody should shun a court proceeding thinking that they will automatically get an order for setting aside the judgment.”

30. In the foregoing while associating myself with the decisions cited, I find that the 2nd Defendant was properly served, hired an advocate, ignored to participate fully in the proceedings which she now seeks to set aside. Further, she claims to be a wife of Frank Bob Muigai (deceased) yet the estate is represented by the 1st Defendants and she has not furnished Court with proceedings from the Probate & Administration Cause confirming she was the deceased spouse or beneficiary.

31. In the circumstances, I find the instant Notice of Motion application unmerited and will dismiss it.

32. Each party to bear their own costs.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 13TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

CHRISTINE OCHIENG

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Kamotho for Plaintiff/Respondent

Miano for 2nd Defendant/Applicant

Court Assistant: Joan

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder