Land law

Gatabaki & another v Attorney General & 9 others [2026] KEELC 6450 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
ELC PETITION NO. 44 OF 2018
Judgment date
13 October 2026
Judge(s)
JO Mboya

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this court for determination is the notice of motion dated 9th July, 2026 filed by the 10th respondent, and it is expressed to be brought under Order 50 Rule 5 of the Civil Procedure Rules seeking the following orders:-

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The application was canvassed through written submissions. The 10th respondent filed its written submissions dated 7th August, 2026. The petitioners filed their written submissions dated 11th August, 2026 and 15th September, 2026. I have considered the application, the replies thereof and the written submissions filed. In my view, the issue for determination is whether the 10th respondent has demonstrated sufficient cause for the court…

Paragraph 10 →

Reasoning passage

The petitioners further argued that they have suffered prejudice through further delay and added costs. The delay attributable to this lapse is a matter of days, and the matter remains fixed for hearing on 19th October, 2026. In my view, there is need to do substantive justice to all parties involved in this suit and the three and four days delay is excusable. I say so because the default in this case is short and not deliberate. To…

Paragraph 16 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the 10th respondent had shown sufficient cause for enlargement of time and for its affidavits filed on 15 and 16 June 2026 to be deemed properly filed within time.

Material facts

Following directions issued on 2 June 2026, Equity Bank (Kenya) Limited, the 10th respondent, was to file and serve responses to the petition and cross-petition within ten days, by 12 June 2026. It filed affidavits by Moses Ndirangu and Charles Gathogo on 15…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC PETITION NO. 44 OF 2018

NANCY WANJA GATABAKI………...........………….......................…….…..1ST PETITIONER

NANCY WANJA GATABAKI

JOSEPHINE BEATRICE GATHONI

AND SUSAN ESTHER WANGARI (as the

Administrators of the estate of the late

DR. SAMUEL MUNDATI GATABAKI)…….......……..….................………..2ND PETITIONER

VERSUS

THE HON. ATTORNEY GENERAL…………..................................……….1ST RESPONDENT

THE CABINET SECRETARY FOR

THE MINISTRY OF LANDS…………....……...............................……..…..2ND RESPONDENT


THE CABINET SECRETARY FOR

THE MINISTRY OF TRANSPORT &

INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT...............................................3RD RESPONDENT
CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR
………………….........................................…..4TH RESPONDENT

NATIONAL LAND COMMISSION……………..................................……..5TH RESPONDENT

KENYA URBAN ROADS AUTHORITY………................................……..6TH RESPONDENT

CHIEF VALUER, COUNTY

GOVERNMENT OF NAIROBI..............................................................7TH RESPONDENT

THE DIRECTOR OF SURVEY………………...................................….…..8TH RESPONDENT

THE DIRECTOR OF CITY PLANNING………………….....................…….9TH RESPONDENT

EQUITY BANK (KENYA) LIMITED…………………......................………10TH RESPONDENT

RULING

1. Before this court for determination is the notice of motion dated 9th July, 2026 filed by the 10th respondent, and it is expressed to be brought under Order 50 Rule 5 of the Civil Procedure Rules seeking the following orders:-

1. Spent.

2. The time within which the 10th respondent should file the affidavit of Moses Ndirangu sworn on 15th June, 2026 and the affidavit of Charles Gathogo sworn on 16th June, 2026 be extended to 15th and 16th June, 2026. The said affidavits be deemed to have been filed within time.

3. The costs of this application be provided for.

2. The application is premised on the grounds inter alia that on 2nd June 2026, the court directed the 10th respondent to file and serve its responses to the petition and the cross-petition within ten days, which period lapsed on 12th June, 2026. The application is supported by the affidavit of Moses Ndirangu, the director, credit of the 10th respondent sworn on 10th July, 2026. The 10th respondent deposed that following the directions issued by the court on 2nd June 2026, the bank was required to file and serve its responses to the petition and the cross-petition within ten days, the period having lapsed on 12th June, 2026. It was deposed that it was not possible to meet the bank’s advocates immediately following the court’s directions, principally owing to their court commitments. Further, that a copy of the response was forwarded on 10th June, 2026 which was executed and returned the same on 12th June, 2026.

3. The 10th respondent deposed that Kiragu Kimani SC was away attending to personal issues, and that Charles Gathogo executed and returned his affidavit on 15th June, 2026. This led to the subsequent filing of the responses on 15th and 16th June, 2026 which were immediately served upon all parties. It was deposed that the delay was not deliberate nor intended to obstruct the due administration of justice, and no prejudice has been occasioned to the petitioners, the cross-petitioner or any other party. The 10th respondent asserts that the affidavits contain material facts and evidence necessary for the fair determination of the petition and the cross-petition.

4. In response thereto, the 1st petitioner filed the replying affidavit sworn on 6th July, 2026. She deposed that the application presents the delay as a mere lapse of three and four days, respectively, yet fails to disclose the broader history of the bank’s repeated non-compliance with the court’s directions. Further, that the 10th respondent’s default must be considered in the context of its failure to file a substantive response to the 2nd further amended petition dated 4th April, 2025 until June 2026, approximately fourteen months after service and without leave of the court.

5. While tracing the procedural history of the matter, the 1st petitioner deposed that on the material day, the court granted the 10th respondent a final period of ten days which expired on 12th June, 2026. These directions were peremptory and the 10th respondent was expressly notified of the consequences of non-compliance. Nevertheless, the impugned affidavits were filed without prior leave of the court. She took issue with the explanations given for the delay, and deposed that the advocates’ court commitments, as well as the alleged absence and ill health of lead counsel do not constitute sufficient justification for the default, particularly as the deadline had already expired on 12th June, 2026.

6. The 1st petitioner challenged the reliance on the length of the affidavit and the volume of its exhibits, pointing out that the 10th respondent had been in the proceedings since its joinder and had received repeated opportunities to prepare and file its substantive case. She deposed that they continue to suffer prejudice through further delay in the determination of their compensation claim, additional legal expenses and disruption of the orderly conduct of the proceedings. She deposed that Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution, the overriding objective and the inherent jurisdiction of the court are intended to advance substantive justice and ought not to be invoked to excuse indolence or disregard of clear court directions.

7. The petitioners also filed undated grounds of opposition. The same raise issues similar to those canvassed in the replying affidavit, and there is no need to reproduce the same.

8. In further response, the 10th respondent filed a further affidavit sworn on 5th August, 2026. While reiterating the contents of its supporting affidavit, the 10th respondent deposed that the directions given by the court on 2nd June 2026, did not issue an “unless” order despite knowing the procedural history. While admitting the delays in filing pleadings, the 10th respondent pointed out that it has always filed its responses nonetheless and the same were not deliberate.

9. The 1st petitioner filed the supplementary affidavit sworn on 11th August, 2026 and deposed that any party needing to respond can seek directions within a defined period, and the hearing date can be preserved. She argued that their own timing issues do not cure or excuse the 10th respondent’s separate default, and each party’s request must be judged on its own facts.

10. The application was canvassed through written submissions. The 10th respondent filed its written submissions dated 7th August, 2026. The petitioners filed their written submissions dated 11th August, 2026 and 15th September, 2026. I have considered the application, the replies thereof and the written submissions filed. In my view, the issue for determination is whether the 10th respondent has demonstrated sufficient cause for the court to enlarge time and deem the affidavits of 15th and 16th June, 2026 properly filed.

12. To begin with, the application is brought under Order 50 Rule 5 of the Civil Procedure Rules while the general enlargement power is ordinarily Order 50 Rule 6. The power to enlarge time is discretionary. It must be exercised judiciously, and not arbitrarily. In an application such as this, the relevant considerations which the court evaluates are the length of the delay, the reason for it, whether there is an arguable case, the prejudice to the other side, and the interests of justice. These were the major pillars for consideration stated by the supreme court in the case of Nicholas Kiptoo Arap Korir Salat vs. IEBC & 7 Others [2014] eKLR.

13. In applying these considerations to the instant case, on 2nd June 2026, this court directed that responses be filed within ten days, which expired on 12th June, 2026. The impugned affidavits were filed on 15th and 16th June 2026, which was three and four days late. It is necessary to point out that despite the short delay, the affidavits were served on all parties immediately. The explanation for the delay is that counsel was unavailable, that lead counsel was away on personal matters, and that the deponents executed the affidavits on 12th and 15th June, 2026. While the explanation may not be plausible, counsel’s diary commitments are ordinary incidents of practice, and no application for extension was made before time lapsed. I do agree with the petitioners that a litigant should not treat court timelines as optional.

14. However, the question is whether the explanation, taken with the other factors, amounts to sufficient cause. In my view, the reasons for delay do not need to be flawless to be excusable. The 10th respondent’s affidavit has 44 paragraphs and about 195 pages of annexures, which supports the account that preparing and executing it took time. Nothing before me suggests the delay was deliberate or tactical.

15. I note that the petitioners have taken time to exhibit the previous patterns of delay in this matter which they maintain have been caused by the 10th respondent. This history cannot be ignored. However, I do not read it as showing deliberate obstruction. After the 10th respondent was joined, it applied to strike out the second further amended petition. On 15th December 2025, the court dismissed that application and directed that the bank’s points be raised as responses so that the matter could be heard on its merits. The delay was part of that process. Equally, the petitioners have admitted delay on their part and have sought to regularize the filing of their pleadings.

16. The petitioners further argued that they have suffered prejudice through further delay and added costs. The delay attributable to this lapse is a matter of days, and the matter remains fixed for hearing on 19th October, 2026. In my view, there is need to do substantive justice to all parties involved in this suit and the three and four days delay is excusable. I say so because the default in this case is short and not deliberate. To cure this, the petitioner can be granted leave to file their responses, if any, within the time provided by the court. I find that, taken as a whole, sufficient cause has been shown. Fairness and the interests of justice require that the record is complete before the hearing, and that each party is allowed to properly ventilate its case.

11. From the above, I find merit in the notice of motion dated 9th July, 2026 as follows:-

i. The time within which the 10th respondent should file the affidavit of Moses Ndirangu sworn on 15th June, 2026 and the affidavit of Charles Gathogo sworn on 16th June, 2026 is hereby extended to 15th and 16th June, 2026. The said affidavits are deemed to have been filed within time.

ii. The petitioners are granted leave to file further affidavits in need be, the same to be filed and served within 3 days from the date hereof.

iii. Costs in the cause.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED VIRTUALLY

THIS 13TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

HON. MBOGO C.G.

JUDGE

13/10/2026.

In the presence of:

Mr. Benson Agunga - Court assistant

Mr. Lawson Ondieki for the 10th Respondent/Applicant

Mr. Patrick Ndambiri holding brief for Mr. Paul K. Muite (senior counsel) & Mr. Gatheru Gathemia & Mr. Gideon Muturi for the Petitioners/Respondents & also for the 3rd Cross-petitioner

Mr. Kiprotich for the 7th & 9th Respondents

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder