Land law

Foremost Enterprises Ltd v Gitonga & 6 others [2026] KEELC 6486 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Land Case E224 of 2026
Judgment date
13 October 2026
Judge(s)
CA Ochieng

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is before the Court for determination is the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion application dated 26th May 2026 in which it seeks the following Orders:

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

In the foregoing, I find the instant Notice of Motion application merited and will allow it.

Paragraph 22 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC L CASE NO. E224 OF 2026

FOREMOST ENTERPRISES LIMITED ……………….….. PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

ROSEMARY GITONGA ……………………………….… 1ST DEFENDANT

MOHAMMED DIRIR ……………………………….….. 2ND DEFENDANT

MOHAMMED UGAS ……………………………….…… 3RD DEFENDANT

FREDRICK GITONGA …………………………..…….. 4TH DEFENDANT

DENNIS NYAMU …………………………………..….… 5TH DEFENDANT

MOHAMMED KHAYRE ……………………………..… 6TH DEFENDANT

239 WASHIKA RESIDENCY LIMITED ………..…. 7TH DEFENDANT

RULING

1. What is before the Court for determination is the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion application dated 26th May 2026 in which it seeks the following Orders:

a) Spent.

b) Spent.

c) That this Honourable court be pleased to grant a temporary injunction against the Defendants/Respondents by themselves, their servants, agents and /or any persons acting under their authority from entering upon, occupying, trespassing onto, encroaching upon and /or any way interfering with the Applicant’s quiet possession and use of the suit property being all that property known as Sectional Title No. Nairobi / Block 13 /81/4 (Town House Number 4) pending hearing and determination of the suit.

d) That upon granting prayers 2 and 3 hereinabove, the Honourable Court be pleased to direct the officer Commanding Station, Muthangari Police Station to oversee the enforcement of the orders of this Honourable Court.

e) That costs of this application be provided for.

2. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the supporting affidavit sworn by Penninah Ruguru Thungu, the Plaintiff’s director. She avers that the Plaintiff is the registered proprietor of Sectional Title No. Nairobi/Block 13/81/4 (Town House Number 4) vide purchase from the 7th Defendant, and which property is among eight (8) houses erected within a gated residential development known as 239 Washika Residency in Lavington area. She explains that in April 2025, the Defendants began making claims that part of its portion of land, together with a portion of the opposite property is part of the estate’s common area and demanded that they cede it, in default of which, the portion would be forcefully converted into a common area.

3. She claims that a meeting of house owners in the gated estate was held on 25th April 2026 and it was agreed that boundaries would be confirmed from the sectional plan before any action could be taken. However, by a letter dated 30th April 2026 addressed to all homeowners by the 7th Defendant, it was alleged that part of the Plaintiff’s portion of land and of the opposite property constitute common property. She avers that in another meeting of homeowners held on 23rd May 2026, it was concluded that the fence separating the Plaintiff’s property and the property opposite to it, would be demolished, which she contends contradicts the registered sectional plan provided by the 7th Defendant to the Plaintiff at the time of purchase. She contends that the Defendants sent goons to demolish the fence separating the Plaintiff’s property and its neighbour on 25th May 2026 but they were not successful. She insists that the planned demolition will constitute an unlawful invasion of the Plaintiff’s property and occasion it damage.

Response

4. In opposition, the 7th Defendant filed a replying affidavit sworn by the 6th Defendant. He avers that about 11th January 2021, Ecostay Limited and Pirogue Limited entered into a Joint Venture Agreement for the construction of eight (8) townhouses which were to be erected on Land Reference Number 3734/239 (Original number 3734/126) Lavington. He explains that the parties agreed to incorporate a management company, which is the 7th Defendant, to manage the common parts of the development and to own the reversionary interest in the property. He states that thereafter, individual units were transferred to their respective purchasers, including the Plaintiff who purchased its townhouse subject to the terms and conditions contained in the Sale Agreement between them, sectional plan, and the management structure established for the estate and all applicable laws governing sectional developments.

5. He admits that the 7th Defendant issued the letter dated 30th April 2026 and concedes that in the meeting held on 23rd May 2026, a

resolution to remove the impugned fence was passed by a majority of the unit owners present as concerns were raised regarding the Plaintiff’s occupation and enclosure of a portion of land believed by the proprietors to constitute common property within the development.

6. He contends that the Plaintiff’s Certificate of Title for Sectional Title No. Nairobi/Block 13/81/4 only confers ownership of the sectional unit described therein together with the corresponding undivided interest in the common property and does not confer exclusive ownership over the disputed area thus it cannot exclude other proprietors from the use and enjoyment of common property. Further, that there is no evidence that the disputed area forms part of its sectional unit.

7. In response, to the Defendants’ reply, the Plaintiff filed a further affidavit sworn by its director. She avers that the 6th Defendant has no authority to make any presentation on behalf of the 7th Defendant as he is neither a director or shareholder. Further, that the Defendants failed to disclose that the 7th Defendant was incorporated in 2021 by the 1st and 4th Defendants together with Ecostay Limited as directors shareholders and one Mr. Issa Mohamed Fidow as a director with the 1st and 4th Defendants holding 60% shareholding in the company despite only owning two of eight units, thereby controlling the decision making processes relating to the management and administration of the impugned development to its exclusion. Further, that the only management structure revealed to the Plaintiff was the property manager of the 7th Defendant, with no information on the directors and shareholders.

8. She points out that the Plaintiff’s advocates sought information on the sectional plans the 7th Defendant was basing on, to claim part of its property as common property but no response was forthcoming. She insists that none of the Defendants contested the boundaries at the time the Plaintiff occupied its house, where two young children live and would be greatly traumatized with demolition. She insists that property rights cannot be overridden, varied and /or extinguished by minutes or resolutions of a meeting.

9. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions.

Submissions

10. The Plaintiff submits that it has met the threshold for grant of a

temporary injunction as set out in the case of Giella v Cassman Brown & Co. Ltd [1973] EA, having proved ownership of the suit property, and established that prior to purchase, the 7th Defendant furnished it with the sectional plan of the entire development of 239 Washika Residency, which demarcated the boundaries of the eight (8) properties within the development, including the suit property that was demarcated by a fence and which it occupied with the same boundaries including demarcations without any objection from the Defendants. Further, that the said boundaries are confirmed vide its attached expert survey report.

11. It also submits that an infringement of its proprietary rights and peaceful occupation of the suit property shall affect the occupants of the suit premises, including young children who will be exposed to psychological loss that cannot be compensated by an award of damages. It insists that it has not encroached on the common boundary thus it shall stand to suffer irreparable harm if a temporary injunction is not issued. Further, that the balance of convenience favours it, as its evidence has not been controverted while the Defendants have not adduced any evidence in support of their claim. To buttress its averments, the Plaintiff relied on the case of Vivo Energy Kenya Limited v Maloba Petrol Station Limited & 3 others [2015] eKLR.

12. On their part, the Defendants submits that they do not dispute that the Plaintiff is the registered proprietor of the suit property, but they dispute its assertion that its title confers exclusive proprietary rights over the additional portion enclosed by its fence and contend that it is common property. They urge the Court to resist the invitation to convert the Plaintiffs’ privately commissioned expert report into a final determination of proprietary rights and urges it to find that the Plaintiff has not established an exclusive right over the disputed area necessary to justify an interlocutory injunction.

13. They also submit that the Plaintiff failed to demonstrate irreparable harm warranting interlocutory relief. It points out that while it contends that its director resides in the suit property with two young children who would allegedly suffer trauma and psychological injury if the disputed fence is removed, it does not establish irreparable injury on the part of the Plaintiff, a corporate entity. In addition, that removal of the fence would not deprive the Plaintiff of its registered sectional unit but would merely restore access to an area that is common property therefore it would not suffer injury.

14. They submit that granting the injunction would effectively confer upon the Plaintiff exclusive possession of the disputed portion for the duration of the suit and exclude the other proprietors from an area over which they assert collective proprietary rights. They argue that the balance of convenience favours them since where competing proprietary claims remain unresolved; the equitable course is not to confer exclusive rights upon one proprietor but to preserve the rights of all parties pending substantive determination.

15. To buttress their averments, the Defendants relied on the following decisions: Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielson & 2 Others [2014] eKLR; Mrao vs First American Bank of Kenya Limited & 2 Others (2003) KLR and Maikuma Wekesa Buchunju v Donald Wekesa Muyundo & 7 others [2018] eKLR.

Analysis and Determination

16. I have considered the instant Notice of Motion including the respective

affidavits as well as rivalling submissions and the only issue for

determination is whether the Plaintiff has met the threshold for grant of an interlocutory injunction restraining the Defendants from interfering with its property, Sectional Title No. Nairobi / Block 13 /81/4 (Town House Number 4) pending hearing and determination of the suit.

17. In line with the principles established in the decision of Giella v Cassman Brown (1973) EA 358, including the definition of a prima facie case as stated in the case of Mrao Ltd vs First American Bank of Kenya Limited & 2 Others (2003) KLR, I will proceed to decipher whether the Plaintiff has established a prima facie case to warrant the Orders of interim injunction sought.

18. The Plaintiff claims that the suit property is among eight (8) houses erected within a gated residential development known as 239 Washika Residency in Lavington area. Further, that it occupied the said property within the boundaries delineated in the sectional plan provided to it at the time of purchase, without objection from the Defendants. It is its contention, that in April 2025 the 7th Defendant began making claims that part of its portion of land, together with a portion of the opposite property is part of the estate’s common area and demanded that they cede it and even sent goons who were repulsed.

19. While the Defendants do not dispute that the Plaintiff is the registered proprietor of the suit property, they contend that the disputed portion enclosed by its fence is common property. They insist that the decision to remove the fence was lawfully passed by a majority of home owners in the subject gated estate.

20. Looking at the documents presented by the Plaintiff which includes the Certificate of Title, Sectional Plan and Photographs, I opine that the Plaintiff has demonstrated proprietary interest over the suit property. I note that the Defendants decided to make a decision to demolish the fence without involving the Plaintiff. The Defendants have not disputed the Sectional Plan and I note it is the 7th Defendant that furnished the Plaintiff with the said Sectional Plan as well as selling to it, its portion. In the circumstances, I hence find that the Plaintiff has demonstrated a prima facie case to warrant the Orders of interlocutory injunction sought.

21. The Plaintiff explained that there are occupants in the suit property

which include small children who will be tramautized in case of the intended demolition of the fence. Further, that the decision of the demolition was simply made in a meeting. It is my considered view that since the Plaintiff has demonstrated proprietary interest over the suit property which has occupants, it will suffer irreparable harm which cannot be compensated by way of damages, if the demolition proceeds. Further, I find that the balance of convenience tilts in favour of granting an interlocutory injunction pending outcome of the suit.

22. In the foregoing, I find the instant Notice of Motion application merited and will allow it.

23. Costs will be in the cause.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 13TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

CHRISTINE OCHIENG

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Chege for Applicant

Gitau for Defendants

Court Assistant: Joan

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder