REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
MILIMANI LAW COURTS
ELC L MISC NUMBER E225 OF 2026
MBAIKA THITU…………………...……………………..…………..APPLICANT
-VERSUS-
CALYSTUS WAFULA………...………..…………….……...........RESPONDENT
RULING
1. The court is called upon to determine two applications. The first is the Applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 17.7.2026, seeking enlargement of time to appeal against the decision of the Rent Restriction Tribunal in Tribunal Case No. E1535 of 2025 rendered on 6th May 2026. The 2nd prayer is for an order for stay of execution pending the hearing and determination of the intended appeal.
2. The second application is the Respondent’s application dated 29.9.2026, principally seeking to arrest the delivery of this ruling, have the two applications determined simultaneously and, in the alternative, the court to impose conditions upon any stay of execution that may be granted.
3. The Applicant’s application is supported by the grounds set out on the face thereof and by the affidavit of Mbaika Thithu sworn on 17.7. 2026.
4. It is deposed that the applicant is aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the decision and/or orders issued by the Honourable Chairperson of the Rent Restriction Tribunal in Tribunal Case No. E1535 of 2025, between the applicant and the Respondent.
5. The applicant deposes that upon the Tribunal determining his application, the only communication reflected on the Court Tracking System (CTS) was a note indicating “Not Allowed”.
6. It is deposed that there was no written ruling, reasons for the decision, or formal order uploaded onto the CTS. The applicant has annexed a copy of the CTS extract marked “SKO-1”.
7. The applicant further deposes that immediately after the ruling, his advocate made several follow-ups with the Tribunal Registry seeking certified copies of the ruling and formal order for purposes of appealing.
8. Despite the said efforts and follow-ups, it is deposed that the Tribunal Registry failed and/or declined to provide the ruling and/or formal order. Annexed and marked “SKO-2” is a copy of the Applicant’s letter dated 4.7. 2026 requesting a copy of the ruling.
9. It is deposed that owing to the failure by the Tribunal to avail the ruling and formal order, the applicant was unable to prepare and lodge a competent appeal within the statutory period prescribed by law.
10. The applicant therefore deposes that the delay in filing the intended appeal was neither deliberate, intentional, negligent nor inordinate, but was occasioned entirely by circumstances beyond his control.
11. It is further deposed that as soon as it became apparent that the Tribunal would not furnish the applicant with the requested documents within a reasonable period, the applicant instructed his advocate to institute the present application seeking enlargement of time within which to lodge the intended appeal.
12. The applicant deposes that this Honourable court is vested with jurisdiction under Sections 79G and 79 of the Civil Procedure Act, as read together with Order 50 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules, to enlarge time where sufficient cause has been demonstrated. The applicant further deposes that the intended appeal raises serious and arguable questions of law and fact and has overwhelming chances of success. Annexed and marked “SKO-3” is a copy of the draft Memorandum of Appeal.
13. It is deposed that unless this Honourable court grants leave to the applicant to lodge the intended appeal out of time, the Applicant stands to be unjustly deprived of his constitutional right to appeal and his right of access to justice.
14. The applicant further deposes that unless an order staying execution is granted, the Respondent is likely to proceed with execution, thereby rendering the intended appeal nugatory and defeating its purpose.
15. The applicant deposes that he stands to suffer substantial and irreparable loss unless execution of the impugned decision and/or decree is stayed pending the hearing and determination of the intended appeal.
16. It is further deposed that the Respondent shall suffer no prejudice that cannot adequately be compensated by an award of costs should the present application be allowed.
17. The applicant maintains that the application has been brought promptly, in good faith, and solely in the interests of justice.
18. The applicant also relies on a Supplementary Affidavit sworn on 21.9.2026, wherein he brings to the attention of the Court the fact that the Tribunal had previously rendered its judgment on 6.5.2026. A copy of the said judgment is annexed and marked “SKO-1”.
19. It is further deposed that following delivery of the judgment, a decree was extracted on 24.6.2026 in accordance with the Tribunal’s judgment. A copy of the said decree is annexed and marked “SKO-2”.
20. The applicant deposes that the documents annexed to the Supplementary Affidavit are intended to supplement and further clarify the matters set out in the Supporting Affidavit.
21. Regarding the 2nd application, the same is supported by grounds on its face and in an affidavit sworn or dated 29 September 2026.
22. The respondent says that he was the successful litigant before the Rent Restriction Tribunal, which delivered judgment on 6 May 2026, followed by the issuance of a decree on 24 June 2026. A copy of the said decree is annexed to the affidavit.
23. The respondent further deposes that he subsequently instituted ELC Suit No. E215 of 2026, seeking the formal adoption of the decree issued by the Rent Restriction Tribunal to facilitate execution. A copy of the application filed in ELC Suit No. E215 of 2026 is annexed to the affidavit.
24. The respondent avers that he was taken by surprise when, on 23 September 2026, during the hearing of his application in ELC Suit No. E215 of 2026, he learned for the first time that the applicant had instituted the present proceedings, being ELC Misc. No. E225 of 2026, without his knowledge or involvement.
25. The respondent further avers that he was never served with the Notice of Motion, Chamber Summons, or any Supporting Affidavit filed in the present matter. He contends that the applicant deliberately concealed these proceedings from him with the intention of obtaining orders without his knowledge.
26. The Respondent challenges the Affidavit of Service sworn by Mr Samwel Kerosi, which purports to indicate that service was effected upon him through WhatsApp. He categorically denies receiving any such communication or notice of the mention date.
27. The respondent further contends that the purported proof of service annexed to the Affidavit of Service displays only a single tick on the WhatsApp messaging interface. He maintains that this indicates that the message was sent from the sender’s device but does not establish that it was delivered to his device. A copy of the purported Affidavit of Service is annexed to the affidavit.
28. The respondent avers that, at the material time when service was allegedly effected, he did not possess a smartphone capable of receiving or accessing WhatsApp communications, thereby rendering the alleged mode of service impracticable and ineffective.
29. The respondent contends that, owing to the non-delivery of the mention notice, he remained wholly unaware of the present proceedings. He maintains that proceeding based on the alleged defective service would substantially prejudice his constitutional right to a fair hearing.
30. The respondent further avers that the statutory period for appealing against the decision of the Rent Restriction Tribunal under the Rent Restriction Act, Cap. 296, has long since lapsed. He contends that the Applicanthas failed to provide any reasonable explanation for the delay and alleges that the application is merely intended to buy time and frustrate the due administration of justice.
31. The respondent asserts that the applicant’s allegation that he is unable to satisfy the decree issued by the Tribunal is false and misleading, amounting to a deliberate misrepresentation of material facts before this Honourable Court.
32. Contrary to the applicant’s averments, the respondent maintains that the Applicantis a person of substantial financial means and has the immediate capacity to satisfy the decretal sum in its entirety.
33. The respondent contends that the present application has not been necessitated by any genuine inability on the applicant’s part to pay the decretal sum. Rather, he characterises it as a frivolous and vexatious abuse of the court process, allegedly brought with the malicious intention of frustrating him and delaying the execution of the decree.
34. The Respondent further avers that the applicant has approached this Honourable court with unclean hands and is seeking to misuse the court process to shield himself from, and defeat, the lawful findings and decision of the Rent Restriction Tribunal.
35. The Respondent maintains that, should this Honourable court be inclined to grant the Applicant’s request for stay of execution, such stay ought to be conditional upon stringent terms sufficient to safeguard the Respondent’s entitlement to the fruits of his judgment.
36. Accordingly, the Respondent prays that this Honourable court orders the applicant to deposit the entire decretal sum of Kshs. 741,450/= in Court within fourteen (14) days, in default of which execution should proceed without further interruption.
37. The applicant relies on written submissions dated 6 August 2026. reliance is placed on Nicholas Kiptoo Arap Korir Salat v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 7 others [2014] eKLR; Leo Sila Mutiso V Rose Hellen Wangari Mwangi [1999] 2 EA 231; Kenya Shell Limited V Benjamin Karuga Kibiru & Another [1986] KLR 410.
38. Section 8 of the Rent Restriction Act, Cap. 296, provides under subsection (1) that no appeal shall lie against a decision of the Tribunal except as expressly provided for under subsection (2).
39. Under section 8(2), a party aggrieved by a decision of the Tribunal has the legal right to appeal to the Environment and Land Court. The statutory appellate jurisdiction of this Court was recognized in Chege v Rent Restriction Tribunal & another [2025] KEHC 218 (KLR). The Court observed that section 8(2) of the Rent Restriction Act provides for appeals against decisions of the Tribunal and that, following the establishment and operationalisation of the Environment and Land Court, jurisdiction previously exercised by the High Court had been vested in the Environment and Land Court.
40. The period within which an appeal is required to be lodged is stipulated under Rule 2 of the Rent Restriction (Appeals) Rules, 1969. The Rule provides that an appeal brought pursuant to section 8(2) of the Rent Restriction Act shall be filed within fifteen days from the date of the decision, determination or order being challenged.
41. In computing this period, any time certified by the Tribunal as having been necessary for the preparation and delivery of a copy of the decision, determination or order to the appellant shall be excluded.
42. The exception in Rule 2 is crucial because it grants the appellate court the authority to accept a late appeal. However, the court will only do so if it is convinced that the appellant had a valid and justifiable reason for missing the filing deadline.
43. Rule 3 further provides that the Civil Procedure Rules apply, mutatis mutandis, to appeals under section 8(2).
44. Section 79G of the Civil Procedure Act and the ELC Act are also the primary statutory provisions governing the time for appeal generally. The specific regime under section 8(2) of the Rent Restriction Act and the Rent Restriction (Appeals) Rules applies.
45. The principles concerning enlargement of time were considered in Nicholas Kiptoo Arap Korir Salat v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 7 others [2014] eKLR. The Supreme Court set out the guiding considerations, to include whether the applicant has provided a reasonable explanation for the delay, whether the application was brought without undue delay and whether an extension would occasion prejudice to the opposing party.
46. In Kenya Power & Lighting Company Ltd v Majengo [2025] KEHC 343 (KLR), the court reiterated that extension of time is an equitable remedy available at the court's discretion and that the court considers the explanation for delay, prejudice, and whether the application has been brought without undue delay.
47. Similarly, in Barmasai & another v Ochung [2025] KEHC 6591 (KLR), the court reiterated that an applicant seeking enlargement of time must demonstrate good and sufficient cause and that the court should consider the length of delay, explanation for the delay, prospects of the intended appeal and prejudice to the respondent.
48. The issue that therefore falls for determination is whether, in light of the facts presented, the applicant has demonstrated good and sufficient cause to warrant the relief sought.
49. According to the Supplementary Affidavit, the Tribunal delivered its judgment on 6 May 2026, following which a decree was extracted on 24 June 2026. The applicant attributes the delay to the Tribunal's failure to avail the written decision and formal order despite efforts by his advocates to obtain the same. In support of this explanation, he has annexed a CTS extract bearing the notation “Not Allowed” and a subsequent letter dated 4 July 2026 requesting a copy of the ruling.
50. The court has carefully looked at the lower court file. The court notes that the applicant had filed an application dated 18th May 2026 for stay of execution, setting aside the judgment, reopening of the suit and leave to defend the suit.
51. The said application was disallowed on 4th June 2026. The judgment of the tribunal is dated 6th may 2026. The applicant, instead of appealing by 21st May 2026 before this court, had opted to file an application before the same tribunal.
52. He who comes to equity must come with clean hands and disclose all material facts. The supporting affidavit, the supplementary affidavit and the replying affidavit are all silent on these developments, save to state that the CTs only indicated that it was “not allowed”, with no reasons given. The intended appeal, according to the applicant, is against the judgment made on 6th May 2026 and not the order declining the application made on 4th June 2026.
53. Therefore, the inordinate delay from 6th May 2026 to the filing of this application cannot be attributed to the registry or the tribunal. The judgment dated 6th May 2026 and the refusal to allow the application dated 18th May 2026 on 4th June 2026 are two different events or orders. The applicant's account of the delay is missing.
54. Writing a letter dated 4th July 2026 to request the judgment and the order shows indolence on the part of the applicant. Time for filing the appeal had already expired by the time the applicant went back with an application before the tribunal. The court finds the delay in the ordinary course unexplained and unjustified.
55. Further, all that the applicant needed was a copy of the judgment to appeal and not the decree. Evidence of efforts to obtain the judgment by the deadline is missing. To only ask for the same in July 4TH 2026 was an afterthought following issuance of the decree. The applicant behaved like a beacon that only shines when there is light. He waited to wake up from his deep slumber after the decree to execute was extracted, and after respondent applied before this court for the adoption of the judgment. The court finds the application lacking merit. It is dismissed with costs.
56. Having disallowed the 1st application, the court finds the 2nd application overtaken by events. It is marked as spent with no order as to costs. File marked closed.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 14th DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
………………………………..
HON. JUSTICE C.K NZILI
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Mr. Korisi for applicant
Court Assistant: Julius
Legal Researcher: Bevalyn Nyakwana