Background
Having listened to the arguments by both parties, I find that the issue for determination is Whether the objections raised by the Defendant should be upheld.
Paragraph 4 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Having listened to the arguments by both parties, I find that the issue for determination is Whether the objections raised by the Defendant should be upheld.
Paragraph 4 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI
ELC CASE 194 OF 2019
PATRICK MUSIMBA LIMITED………………...........................................…PLAINTIFF
-VERSUS-
CHINA RAILWAY NO 10
ENGINEER GROUP COMPANY LTD……….……………..……………1ST DEFENDANT
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY GOVERNMENT…………………………….2ND DEFENDANT
RULING
Introduction
1. The matter came up for hearing on the 29th September 2026 where PWI the Plaintiff herein testified relying on his witness statement and also relied on his list of documents dated 12th March 2022.
2. Counsel for the Defendant objected to the production of the said list of documents on grounds that the documents had not been marked and that the Plaintiff had not produced a certificate of electronic evidence to back the photos taken as exhibit.
3. The Plaintiff committed to filing the said certificate of electronic evidence but the Defendant objected indicating the time for compliance to the same had lapsed.
Analysis and determination
4. Having listened to the arguments by both parties, I find that the issue for determination is Whether the objections raised by the Defendant should be upheld.
5. Together with the amended plaint, the Plaintiff filed their list of witnesses. There was an accompanying witness statement of the said Dr Musimba. There is also filed the Plaintiffs’ list of documents which had a total of 13 annexures copies of which were supplied. These documents were also alluded to and explained in the witness statement of Dr Musimba.
6. On 29th September 2026, hearing commenced with the Plaintiffs calling Dr. Musimba as the sole witness. He gave his evidence and relied on the witness statement and list of documents therein the Defendant raised the objection.
7. Order 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules gives directions on pre trial procedure before a matter is set down for hearing. Order 11 has significance that goes to the root of justice. The common rule of natural justice known as Audi alteram partem is what is embodied, as a matter of practice, in the necessity of pretrial directions. Pretrial directions thus, stricto sensu contains the packaged rules that enable the right to a fair hearing.
8. In this case the court will be called upon to attempts to strike a balance between strictly observing the pretrial directions and relaxing such pretrial directions in the quest to achieve justice for both parties. In the case of David Kimani Gitau Vs Francis Wainaina [2016] eKLR Prof Jel Ngugi J, (as he then was) propounded this position as follows: “pre-trial procedures, like all rules of procedures, are the handmaidens of justice and not its mistress. Hence, they are not formulaic or talismanic steps which must be rigidly followed regardless of their utility to the trial process. Indeed, Order 11 of the Civil Procedure Code exists to ensure that the trial process is more efficient. Hence, a Court may, where circumstances and context permit or dictate skip, abbreviate or bespoke the pre-trial processes and procedures. The nature of this particular case indicates that this case might be a good candidate for that.
9. I agree with the reasoning the court in Methuselar Keyah Lubembe Vs Albina Kipkemoi [2019] eKLR where the court stated as follows: “In deciding whether to grant leave or not, a court of law would weigh the benefit to be achieved by allowing the documents against the possible harm to be suffered by refusal. That question is asked and considered on both sides of the case – the Plaintiff’s case as well as the Defendant’s case. That question is normally fashioned as to what decision would in the circumstances of each case serve the ends of justice.
10. I have to balance between justice to the Plaintiff and prejudice to the Defendants to achieve the right to a fair hearing for both parties. This is a matter where the Plaintiff’s case has just commenced and he has relied on list of documents filed over 4 years ago well within the knowledge of the Defendants. The Defendants have only but brought this objection at the time when the Plaintiff has in his testimony relied on the same. No prejudice whatsoever will be occasioned to the Defendants should bundle of document be allowed as their objection is not to the contents of it rather on procedure. The Plaintiff is highly likely to be prejudiced should the bundle not be allowed. In view, this is one of such cases when justice will be achieved only if Order 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules is not strictly followed.
11. In the case of Zacharia Okoth Obado Vs Edward Akong’o Oyugi & 2 others [2014] eKLR the Supreme Court agreed with the dicta of Kiage, JA in Nicholas Kiptoo Arap Korir Salat Vs IEBC & 6 others [2013] eKLR that: “Courts cannot aid in the bending or circumventing of rules and a shifting of goal posts for, while it may seem to aid one side, it unfairly harms the innocent party who strives to abide by the rules. I apprehend that it is in the even-handed and dispassionate application of rules that courts give assurance that there is a clear method in the manner in which things are done so that outcomes can be anticipated with a measure of confidence, certainty and clarity where issues of rules and their application are concerned…”
12. Ultimately, the Supreme Court has reposed considerable scope for discretion in the courts, on a case-by-case basis, when it opined thus: “In many cases, procedure is so closely intertwined with the substance of a case, that it befits not the attribute of mere technicality. The conventional wisdom, indeed, is that procedure is the handmaiden of justice. Where a procedural Motion bears the very ingredients of just determination, and yet it is overlooked by a litigant, the Court would not hesitate to declare the attendant pleadings incompetent. Yet procedure, in general terms, is not an end in itself. In certain cases, insistence on a strict observance of a rule of procedure, could undermine the cause of justice. Hence the pertinence of Article 159 (2) (d) of the Constitution.
13. I am bound to follow this route and find that given the crucial importance of the documents sought to be relied upon by the Plaintiff, it is my considered view that the same should be allowed.
14. On the issue of production of the certificate of electronic evidence, I do note that the Plaintiff has filed the same dated 29th September 2026.That unless it can be inferred that the Plaintiff acted intentionally and deliberately the same can be produced at any stage during the pendency of the hearing of the case. This Court has a mandate to do justice to all parties and not to be too strictly bound by procedural technicalities. This flows from the provisions of article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution. Where such evidence can be adduced, without causing undue prejudice to the other party, the Court ought to allow the production of it, so as to allow such party, the opportunity to present his case in full as in the case herein.
Final disposition
15. The upshot of the above is that I make the following orders: -
i. I reject the objection to the production of annexures 3-14 in the Plaintiff’s list of documents. I direct that all the documents be produced in evidence as Plaintiffs’ exhibits 1-14.
ii. The certificate of electronic evidence is deemed as duly filed and forms part of the Plaintiff’s list of documents.
iii. Costs to shall be in the cause.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 14th day of October 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
Mr. Kimathi for the Plaintiff
Mr. Okullo for 1st Defendant
N/A for 2nd Defendant
Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant