Background
The plaintiffs, by an application dated 10.7.2026, seek:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The plaintiffs’ application dated 10 July 2026 was dismissed with costs. The file was transferred to the Environment and Land Court at Limuru for disposal.
63. The application is dismissed with costs.
Paragraph 63 →
64. The file is hereby transferred to the ELC Court, Limuru, for disposal.
Paragraph 64 →
Held. No. The application was dismissed with costs. The court held that the competing affidavits disclosed a substantive dispute over title, succession dealings, transfers, subdivisions and survey records that could not properly be resolved on affidavit evidence. It also noted the unexplained delay, the potentially far-reaching effects of the requested relief, and that the applicants could seek searches, an estate inventory, a licensed surveyor, or relief in the succession court.
Ratio. A temporary injunction preserves the suit property and should not definitively determine contested ownership, fraud, title validity, or competing succession claims. At the interlocutory stage, those matters require trial evidence; the court considers whether the material justifies preservation rather than finally resolving them.
Issue
63. The application is dismissed with costs.
Paragraph 63 →
Held
63. The application is dismissed with costs.
Paragraph 63 →
61. Jurisdiction is everything. Without it, a court has to down its tools. See Owners of the Motor Vessel “ Lillian S” v Caltex Oil (Kenya) Ltd [1989] KLR 1 (EKLR) . From the plaint dated 10th July 2026, the suit properties fall within the jurisdiction of the Elc Court Limuru. The court has looked at the issues raised in the application and the dates the impugned court orders are said were made in courts of equal status, resulting in the resultant subdivisions and titles. The inordinate delay in challenging the processes is not explained at all. Any attempts to obtain copies of recent official search certificates and denial of the same by the relevant registers have not been explained in the supporting affidavits to confirm the process undertaken during the transmission. The reliefs sought may have far-reaching effects on both the instant parties and others, if the official search certificates were to be availed, to be issued at interlocutory stage.
Paragraph 61 →
Ratio
54. The purpose of a temporary injunction is to preserve the subject matter of the suit and ensure that the eventual determination in the proceedings is not rendered nugatory. It is not expected to make definitive findings on contested issues of ownership. Allegations of fraud, the validity of title, or the legal implications of competing succession proceedings, in my view all of which ought to be determined at the substantive hearing.
Paragraph 54 →
56. When alleging fraud, a party must state the specific facts in their pleadings and meet a heightened standard of proof—one that is stricter than the balance of probabilities, but less demanding than proof beyond a reasonable doubt. As stated above, at interlocutory proceedings, the court is not required to issue a definitive ruling on the fraud claims. Instead, its role is to evaluate whether the submitted evidence reveals a credible and significant dispute that justifies protection and preservation of the property or subject matter of the suit until trial.
Paragraph 56 →
Held. Yes. The court found from the plaint that the suit properties fall within the jurisdiction of the ELC at Limuru and transferred the file there for disposal.
Ratio. Jurisdiction is fundamental; because the suit properties fell within the jurisdiction of the ELC at Limuru, the matter was transferred to that court.
Issue
62. There is nothing that has stopped the applicants from seeking the search certificates, demanding the inventory of the deceased estate, engaging a licensed surveyor or moving to the succession court for reprieve if there has been intermeddling with the estate of the deceased in any way by the 1st respondent.
Paragraph 62 →
64. The file is hereby transferred to the ELC Court, Limuru, for disposal.
Paragraph 64 →
Held
64. The file is hereby transferred to the ELC Court, Limuru, for disposal.
Paragraph 64 →
Ratio
62. There is nothing that has stopped the applicants from seeking the search certificates, demanding the inventory of the deceased estate, engaging a licensed surveyor or moving to the succession court for reprieve if there has been intermeddling with the estate of the deceased in any way by the 1st respondent.
Paragraph 62 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The plaintiffs, by an application dated 10.7.2026, seek:
Paragraph 1 →The purpose of a temporary injunction is to preserve the subject matter of the suit and ensure that the eventual determination in the proceedings is not rendered nugatory. It is not expected to make definitive findings on contested issues of ownership. Allegations of fraud, the validity of title, or the legal implications of competing succession proceedings, in my view all of which ought to be determined at the substantive hearing.
Paragraph 54 →The application is dismissed with costs.
Paragraph 63 →Whether the plaintiffs met the threshold for temporary injunctive and related preservation orders over Limuru/Bibirioni/1252, its stated subdivisions, and Limuru/Bibirioni/1602; and whether the Nairobi court should entertain the matter where the properties…
The plaintiffs, joint administrators of the estate of Muiru Gikanga, alleged that the deceased was registered owner of Limuru/Bibirioni/1252 and 1602 and that dealings under a revoked grant, including subdivisions and transfers, had been cancelled. They…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
MILIMANI LAW COURTS
ELC LC NUMBER E318 OF 2026
GEORGE GATHERE MUIRU…………………..……..…………..1ST PLAINTIFF
FRANCIS MWANIKI MUIRU…………………..................... 2ND PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
HUMPHREY GATHAIRA MUIRU……………………………1ST DEFENDANT
CATHERINE WANJIKU GAKONDE……………………….2ND DEFENDANT
CYRUS KOMO CHEGE………………………………………3RD RESPONDENT
THE LAND REGISTRAR
KIAMBU LAND OFFICE………………..……………………4TH RESPONDENT
THE HON. ATTORNEY GENERAL……………………….5TH RESPONDENT
RULING
1. The plaintiffs, by an application dated 10.7.2026, seek:
a) Spent
b) That the defendants, either by themselves, their agents, servants and/or anyone acting on their behalf, be and are hereby restrained, prevented, and/or stopped from transferring, selling, subdividing, trespassing, developing, building, planting, or altering in any manner whatsoever those parcels of land known as LR Nos. Limuru/Bibirioni 1252 (including subdivisions Nos Limuru/ Bibilioni 1645, 1646, 1647, 1787 and 1788) and Limuru/Bibirioni 1602 pending the hearing and determination of this application or until further orders of the Court.
c) That the defendants, either by themselves, their agents, servants and/or anyone acting on their behalf, be restrained, prevented, and/or stopped from transferring, selling, subdividing, trespassing, developing, building, planting, or altering in any manner whatsoever those parcels of land known as LR Nos. Limuru/Bibirioni 1252 (including subdivisions Nos Limuru/ Bibilioni 1645, 1646, 1647,1787 and 1788) and Limuru/Bibirioni 1602 pending the hearing and determination of the main suit.
d) That the 4th defendant(Land Registrar) be directed to supply the applicants with official searches, Green/White Cards, any transfers, sale agreements and any relevant documents in respect of LR Nos. Limuru/Bibirioni 1252 (including subdivisions Nos Limuru/ Bibilioni 1645, 1646, 1647, 1787 and 1788) and Limuru/Bibirioni 1602 pending the hearing of this application and/or until further directions.
e) That the 4th defendant be directed to carry out a comprehensive survey and file a report to this court regarding Limuru/Bibirioni 1252 (including subdivisions Nos Limuru/ Bibilioni 1645, 1646, 1647, 1787 and 1788) and Limuru/Bibirioni 1602 pending the hearing and determination of this application.
f) That the 1st defendant, as a joint administrator of the Estate of Muiru Gikanga, do surrender title documents for LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni 1602 to the applicant and be directed to file a true inventory of the deceased estate pending the hearing and determination of the suit herein
g) That the OCS Tugoni Police Station do provide security to the applicants to take inventory of the estate of Jacob Muiru Gikanga on LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni 1252 (including subdivisions Nos Limuru/ Bibilioni 1645, 1646, 1647,1787 and 1788) LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni 1602 pending the hearing of this suit.
h) That the costs of this motion be provided for.
2. The application is founded on the grounds set out on the face thereof and on the supporting affidavit sworn by George Gathere Muiru on 10.7.2026.
3. The applicant deposes that he is a joint administrator of the Estate of Muiru Gikanga, having been appointed as such on 23.9. 2025. He has sworn the present affidavit on behalf of his co-administrator. Annexed thereto and marked GGM 1A and GGM 1B are the consent of the beneficiaries and the requisite authority.
4. The applicant deposes that at the time of his father's death, the deceased was survived by two widows and five sons and daughters, among other beneficiaries.
5. It is deposed that at the time of his death, the applicant's father was the sole registered proprietor of LR Nos. Limuru/Bibirioni/1252 and Limuru/Bibirioni/1602. Copies of the respective green and white cards are annexed and marked GGM 3 and GGM 4.
6. The applicant states that following the demise of the registered proprietor, one Fredrick Mwaniki Muiru (deceased) instituted Kiambu Chief Magistrate's Court Succession Cause No. 39 of 1985, in which a grant was issued but was subsequently revoked by the Court.
7. It is further deposed that Fredrick Mwaniki Muiru, while purporting to administer the estate, caused LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1252 to be subdivided into LR Nos. Limuru/Bibirioni/1645, 1646 and 1647, in collusion with the 2nd defendant. The said entries were subsequently cancelled pursuant to a consent order issued on 7.2.1986, and the property was restored to the original title.
8. The applicant further deposes that the 1st defendant subsequently petitioned the High Court at Nairobi in Succession Cause No. 2622 of 1999 and obtained a Grant of Letters of Administration on 20.6.2000. A copy thereof is annexed and marked GGM 6A.
9. It is deposed that on 28.11. 2001, a Certificate of Confirmation of Grant was issued to the 1st Defendant, under which he was to hold LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1602 for himself and the other beneficiaries. A copy of the confirmed grant is annexed and marked GGM 6B.
10. The Applicant states that, to date, no rectification of the confirmed grant has been undertaken to incorporate LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1252.
11. The Applicant further deposes that his late father had only sold two acres to be excised from LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1252, which interest was registered in the name of Ruth Wambui Gitee pursuant to Nairobi High Court Civil Appeal No. 18 of 1977. A copy of the relevant court order is annexed and marked GGM 7.
12. It is deposed that the family has no objection to Ruth Wambui Gitee retaining her two acres from LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1252. The Applicant maintains that the 1st Defendant was, notwithstanding the irregular manner in which the grant was obtained, required to hold the remainder of the estate for the benefit of all the beneficiaries. He further states that since the death of his father on 29.9.1982, there has been no lawful and proper final confirmation and distribution of the estate.
13. The applicant states that on or about 5.3.1985, the Land Registrar, Kiambu, was notified of the relevant court order and the subsequent cancellation of the transactions affecting the deceased's estate. Consequently, the 2nd and 3rd Defendants could not lawfully lay any subsequent claim to the property.
14. It is further deposed that in Kiambu Principal Magistrate's Court Miscellaneous Cause No. 176 of 1996, the 2nd defendant obtained orders on 10.3.2004 purporting to appoint Catherine Wanjiku Gakonde as guardian and manager of the property of Peter John Gakonde, and authorising her to register and sell LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1788. The said order is annexed and marked GGM 10.
15. The applicant contends that in obtaining the said orders, the 2nd defendant failed to disclose to the court material facts, particularly that LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1647, together with its subsequent subdivisions, including LR Nos. 1787 and 1788, had already been cancelled prior to the year 2004.
16. It is further deposed that on or about 4.1.1994, in SPM Case No. 269 of 1993, James Mwaniki Gacheche and Elizabeth Wangari Gachango v Ruth Wambui Gitee & Others, the court directed the Land Registrar, Kiambu, to cancel and delete all entries, dealings and subdivisions relating to LR Nos. Limuru/Bibirioni/1252 and 1645. A copy of the decree is annexed and marked GGM 11.
17. The applicant further states that in Succession Cause No. 2622 of 1999, the court directed that the Land Registrar should not subdivide, transfer or otherwise deal with any portion of the estate. A copy of the order dated 7.7. 2020 is annexed and marked GGM 12.
18. It is deposed that on 23.1. 2018, the District Surveyor's Office, Ministry of Lands, prepared a report confirming that the original parcel, LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1252, had illegal occupants and that there had been unlawful transactions affecting the property. The report addressed to the Deputy Registrar of the High Court is annexed and marked GGM 13.
19. The applicant therefore prays that the application be allowed as prayed.
20. In response, the 2nd defendant deposes vide a replying affidavit sworn by Catherine Wanjiku on 22.7.2026 that the Plaintiff's allegation that she is a trespasser on the suit property is not a recent development, but arises from the acquisition of the property by her late husband, John Gakonde, who lawfully purchased the property several years before the institution of the present proceedings.
21. It is deposed that the late Fredrick Mwaniki Muiru, while acting as administrator of the Estate of the late Muiru Gikanga pursuant to a grant issued by the Senior Principal Magistrate's Court at Kiambu, sold Land Parcel No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1788 to the 2nd Defendant's late husband for valuable consideration.
22. The 2nd defendant states that upon completion of the transaction, her late husband was duly registered as the proprietor of LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1788 on 14.5.1996 and was issued with a title deed. A copy of the title deed is annexed and marked CWG-1.
23. It is further deposed that following the purchase, the 2nd defendant's late husband and his family took possession of the property and have remained in open, peaceful, uninterrupted and exclusive occupation thereof since 1986. During that period, the family cultivated and developed the land and dealt with it as family property without interference or challenge from any person.
24. The 2nd defendant states that before her late husband's mental illness, he exercised all the rights and incidents of ownership over the property. In particular, he charged the property to Kenya Commercial Bank Limited as security for financial facilities advanced to him. The bank accepted his title and duly registered the charge against the property.
25. It is deposed that after her husband became mentally ill and was unable to manage his affairs, the 2nd Defendant applied to the Senior Principal Magistrate's Court at Kiambu for her appointment as his legal guardian and manager.
26. The 2nd defendant states that pursuant to an order made on 9.12.1996 in Kiambu Senior Principal Magistrate's Court Miscellaneous Application No. 176 of 1996, she was appointed the legal guardian and manager of her late husband's affairs and property, with authority to manage and protect his assets. A copy of the order is annexed and marked CWG-2.
27. Following her appointment, it is deposed that the 2nd defendant assumed responsibility for managing and protecting LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1788.
28. It is further deposed that on 1.7.2004, the 2nd defendant was registered as the proprietor of LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1788. A copy of the title deed is annexed and marked CWG-3.
29. The 2nd defendant states that the said parcel was subsequently and lawfully subdivided into LR Nos. Limuru/Bibirioni/3087, 3088, 3089, 3090, 3091 and 3092, and separate titles were issued by the Land Registry. Copies of the resultant titles are annexed and marked CWG-4.
30. It is deposed that the subdivision was undertaken openly and in accordance with the guidelines set out by the Land Registry, and that the resultant titles have remained valid and subsisting to date.
31. The 2nd defendant further states that following the creation of the resultant titles, she continued to exercise all rights of ownership over the suit property openly and without interruption.
32. It is deposed that when Kenya Commercial Bank sought to exercise its statutory power of sale over the charged property, the 2nd Defendant defended the proceedings in her capacity as the duly appointed legal guardian and manager of her late husband, with a view to safeguarding the family's proprietary interests. Copies of the pleadings and proceedings are annexed and marked CWG-5(a), (b), (c) and (d).
33. The 2nd defendant states that throughout the period when her late husband was the registered proprietor, and subsequently when she became the registered proprietor, including during the subdivision of the property and the proceedings involving KCB, neither the Plaintiff nor any other person challenged her ownership, possession or occupation of the suit property.
34. It is further deposed that the 2nd defendant's late husband acquired LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1788, from which the current subdivisions arose, and that neither the 2nd defendant nor her late husband has ever asserted any proprietary interest in LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/164.
35. The 2nd Defendant states that from the time her late husband acquired LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1788, through her appointment as his legal guardian and manager, and thereafter upon her registration as proprietor, she has continuously managed, occupied and dealt with the property openly and in the genuine belief that her family's interest therein was lawful.
36. It is deposed that the matters set out in the plaintiff's supporting affidavit do not accurately or fully portray the history of the 2nd defendant's family's acquisition, occupation and dealings with the suit property. The 2nd defendant maintains that she has set out the said history truthfully.
37. The 2nd defendant therefore prays that the Plaintiff's Notice of Motion be dismissed.
38. In a supplementary ffidavit sworn by George Gathere Muiru on 28.7.2026, the applicant denies that the 2nd defendant is the lawful registered proprietor of the suit property.
39. The applicant contends that the 2nd defendant has failed to identify the particular property in respect of which she claims ownership and is, in any event, neither competent nor entitled to claim ownership thereof. The applicant maintains that the 2nd defendant is a trespasser upon the estate of his late father, as she does not possess a confirmed grant authorising her to administer the estate of her late husband, who is alleged to have purchased the property.
40. It is deposed that there is no dispute that the grant allegedly and unlawfully obtained by Fredrick Mwaniki Muiru was revoked and that all transactions undertaken pursuant thereto were cancelled, resulting in the property reverting to the estate of Jacob Muiru. The applicant further contends that the 2nd defendant has failed to produce any sale agreement evidencing the alleged purchase.
41. In response to paragraph 5 of the eplying Affidavit, the Applicant maintains that the circumstances surrounding the transactions undertaken through Fredrick Mwaniki Muiru were fraudulent, as the transactions were revoked on 7.2.1988, making any resultant transactions undertaken thereafter null and void. The Applicant further contends that the purported title to LR No. 1788 was issued on 14.5.1986, long after the revocation of the grant.
42. The applicant denies that there was any lawful transaction between the late Gakonde and the 2nd defendant. He states that numerous court orders had been issued for the preservation of the estate, but that the same were disregarded. He therefore maintains that the 2nd Defendant's occupation and dealings with the property amount to trespass and fraudulent interference with the estate of Muiru deceased.
43. The applicant further contends that the title deed for LR No. 1788, annexed as CWG-1, is incomplete because Part A, relating to the property section, and Part C, relating to encumbrances, have not been produced before the Court. He also notes that no discharge of charge has been exhibited.
44. It is further deposed that the 2nd defendant's appointment as legal manager merely authorised her to manage and protect the property and did not confer upon her authority to dispose of it. The applicant contends that any such disposal would offend section 45 of the Law of Succession Act and amount to intermeddling with the estate. He therefore maintains that the order dated 9.12.1996 cannot confer a lawful basis for the alleged dealings.
45. The applicant further contends that LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1788 could not lawfully have existed for purposes of subdivision in 2004 because the High Court had already ordered that the property be reverted to the original owner. He therefore alleges that the subsequent subdivision constituted fraud and an unlawful interference with the Estate of Muiru.
46. It is deposed that the property described as LR No. Limuru/Bibirioni/1311, annexed and marked CWG-5, is unknown to the Plaintiff.
47. The applicant contends that the document nevertheless demonstrates the manner in which the 2nd defendant allegedly undertook the impugned transaction through fraudulent misrepresentation and concealment.
48. The applicant maintains that the 2nd and 4th defendants, acting pursuant to a scheme of fraudulent dealings, interfered with and tampered with the estate of the deceased despite the existence of several court orders directing that the estate be preserved.
49. Finally, the applicant reiterates that the transactions allegedly undertaken on 7.2.1986 were revoked and that, subsequently, on 4.1.1994, the Chief Land Registrar was directed to nullify, cancel and delete all entries, dealings and subdivisions relating to LR Nos. Limuru/Bibirioni/1645 and Limuru/Bibirioni/1252. The Applicant therefore contends that any transactions undertaken subsequent thereto were unlawful, null and void.
50. The primary legalS provision governing the grant of temporary injunction is Order 40 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. Section 63 ( e) of the Civil Procedure Acts . Under this provision, the Court is empowered to issue an injunction where it is demonstrated that the property in dispute is at risk of being wasted, damaged or alienated by any party to the proceedings, or where other circumstances warrant the preservation of the property pending the hearing and determination of the suit.
51. The principles governing the grant of interlocutory injunctions were set out in Giella v Cassman Brown & Co. Ltd [1973] EA 358. An applicant must demonstrate a prima facie case with a probability of success; establish that, absent an injunction, the applicant is likely to suffer injury that would not adequately be compensated by an award of damages; and, where the Court is in doubt, demonstrate that the balance of convenience favours the grant of the injunction.
52. In Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielsen & 2 Others [2014] eKLR, the Court emphasised that the three requirements are distinct and sequential. The applicant must first establish a prima facie case before the Court considers irreparable injury. The balance of convenience is considered where the Court remains in doubt after addressing the first two requirements.
53. A prima facie case was explained in Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 Others [2003] KLR 125 as a case in which, on the material presented, a tribunal properly directing itself would conclude that there exists a right which has apparently been infringed by the opposite party to call for an explanation or rebuttal from that party. In establishing the same, the Court must, however, exercise restraint and avoid determining the substantive issues in dispute at the interlocutory stage.
54. The purpose of a temporary injunction is to preserve the subject matter of the suit and ensure that the eventual determination in the proceedings is not rendered nugatory. It is not expected to make definitive findings on contested issues of ownership. Allegations of fraud, the validity of title, or the legal implications of competing succession proceedings, in my view all of which ought to be determined at the substantive hearing.
55. Article 40 of the Constitution and sections 24, 25 and 26 of the Land Registration Act protect the rights of registered property owners, subject to the exceptions provided by law. However, under section 26, a title may be challenged if it is proved that it was obtained through fraud or misrepresentation involving the registered owner, or whereof it was acquired illegally, through improper procedures or through a corrupt scheme.
56. When alleging fraud, a party must state the specific facts in their pleadings and meet a heightened standard of proof—one that is stricter than the balance of probabilities, but less demanding than proof beyond a reasonable doubt. As stated above, at interlocutory proceedings, the court is not required to issue a definitive ruling on the fraud claims. Instead, its role is to evaluate whether the submitted evidence reveals a credible and significant dispute that justifies protection and preservation of the property or subject matter of the suit until trial.
57. The applicants in this matter assert that the suit properties formed part of the estate of the late Muiru Gikanga. It is claimed that subsequent dealings over the estate were undertaken under a grant that was eventually revoked. In support of that position, the applicants rely on historical succession proceedings, cancellation orders, land registry records and a survey report dated 23.1. 2018.
58. The applicant’s claim is not based merely on an assertion that they have a beneficial interest in the property. They identify the specific parcels of land, explains their alleged history of dealings, and rely on court orders which, if their scope and continued legal effect are established, may have a significant impact on the validity of the subsequent transfers and subdivisions.
59. The 2nd defendant, on the other hand, relies on her title deed, registration of the property, long-term possession, subsequent subdivisions and her family’s dealings with the property, including a registered charge in favour of Kenya Commercial Bank Limited. Her case raises questions about whether the property was lawfully acquired in the first place, the effect of the alleged court orders revoking and cancelling the title, and the connection between Limuru/Bibirioni/1252, Limuru/Bibirioni/1788 and the parcels created from them.
60. The competing affidavits therefore disclose a substantive dispute that cannot properly be resolved solely based on the parties’ affidavits. The validity of the impugned titles will require examination of the relevant registers, instruments of transfer, succession orders and survey records, together with any other necessary oral evidence at the trial.
61. Jurisdiction is everything. Without it, a court has to down its tools. See Owners of the Motor Vessel “ Lillian S” v Caltex Oil (Kenya) Ltd [1989] KLR 1 (EKLR) . From the plaint dated 10th July 2026, the suit properties fall within the jurisdiction of the Elc Court Limuru. The court has looked at the issues raised in the application and the dates the impugned court orders are said were made in courts of equal status, resulting in the resultant subdivisions and titles. The inordinate delay in challenging the processes is not explained at all. Any attempts to obtain copies of recent official search certificates and denial of the same by the relevant registers have not been explained in the supporting affidavits to confirm the process undertaken during the transmission. The reliefs sought may have far-reaching effects on both the instant parties and others, if the official search certificates were to be availed, to be issued at interlocutory stage.
62. There is nothing that has stopped the applicants from seeking the search certificates, demanding the inventory of the deceased estate, engaging a licensed surveyor or moving to the succession court for reprieve if there has been intermeddling with the estate of the deceased in any way by the 1st respondent.
63. The application is dismissed with costs.
64. The file is hereby transferred to the ELC Court, Limuru, for disposal.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 14TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
…………………………
HON. JUSTICE C.K. NZILI
JUDGE
In the presence of :
Mr. Moseti for Gitanda for plaintiff
Mr. Lemayen for Muugua for 2nd defendant
Court Assistant: Julius
Legal Researcher: Bevalyn Nyakwana