Background
What is before the Court for determination is the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion application dated 8th July 2026 in which she seeks the following Orders:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
What is before the Court for determination is the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion application dated 8th July 2026 in which she seeks the following Orders:
Paragraph 1 →It is my considered view that since the suit property was meant for residential purpose and there is no indication that the Plaintiff legally changed it to commercial use, I find the Plaintiff has not demonstrated a prima facie case to warrant the orders of interlocutory injunction as sought.
Paragraph 25 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC L CASE NO. E311 OF 2026
PATRICIA WAIRIMU MUGEKE ……………….…………… PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
RICHARD MWANGI MUGEKE ………….………………. DEFENDANT
RULING
1. What is before the Court for determination is the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion application dated 8th July 2026 in which she seeks the following Orders:
a) Spent.
b) That pending the hearing and determination of this suit, an order of temporary injunction be and is hereby issued restraining the Defendant, whether by himself, his servants, agents or any person acting under his authority, from entering, accessing, occupying, interfering with or in any manner whatsoever interfacing with the Plaintiff’s residential house and the portion thereof exclusively occupied and utilized by the Plaintiff, her lawful guests, invitees and appointed agent, without the Plaintiff’s express consent or an order of this Honourable court.
c) That pending the hearing and determination of this suit, the Defendant be restrained from mobilising, acting in concert with, or utilizing neighbours, residents’ associations, or any administrative or local authorities to intimidate, harass or interfere with the Plaintiff’s occupation, use and enjoyment of her residential house.
d) Spent.
e) Spent.
f) That the costs of this application be provided for.
2. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the Plaintiff’s supporting affidavit. She avers that she is jointly registered to Nairobi/Block 148/1907 with the Defendant, and that each of them has separate residential houses. Further, that she relocated to the United Kingdom with her daughter and commenced utilizing her residence for lawful short-term accommodation through Airbnb and related booking platforms, which involves temporary guests occupying her residence for specified periods. She claims that about June 2026, beds and additional furniture were delivered to her residence when the Defendant began alleging that she was converting it, into a hostel and communicated the said allegations through Karen Neighborhood WhatsApp group, questioned her use of her residence and created an atmosphere hostile to her proprietary interest. She contends that even after exiting the said WhatsApp group, the Defendant continued to send her direct WhatsApp threatening including intimidating statements and threatened to have her guest removed. Further, that he also threatened to embarrass her through her social media platforms and residents’ groups.
3. She states that the Defendant, together with neighboring proprietors have commenced construction of a gate and access control mechanism affecting the access road serving her residence without consulting her and she is apprehensive that the gate may be used to restrict her access to the suit property. She insists that the Defendant’s interference with her property has caused her distress, inconvenience and disruption of its beneficial utilization and unless restrained, she will continue to be prejudiced.
Response
4. In opposition, the Defendant filed a replying affidavit and a further
affidavit. He avers that he purchased LR NO. Nairobi/Block/148/1907 as his family residential property and out of sympathy, allowed his sister to construct her residential house thereon on condition that she would reimburse him, half of the costs of the land and get the requisite government approvals for the house she would build. He confirms that the suit property was jointly registered to their names in 2023 and contends that it was their salient understanding that their residences would serve their respective families for peace and comfort.
5. He claims that contrary to their understanding, his sister made her residence a place of parties and constant engagement and in 2023, she informed him that she intended to build additional structures in the form of a double storey unit that would comprise two bedrooms per floor. Further, that despite his objections she put up a fence within the common area of the compound without consulting him.
6. He confirms that in 2025, the Plaintiff relocated with her daughter to Britain and it was agreed that she could rent out her residence for income but to his surprise, she started to use it as an Airbnb facility with different guests staying on short term basis. He contends that in June 2026, he saw a consignment of twenty (20) beds, mattresses and beddings being delivered to the Plaintiff’s residence, which meant the residence was being converted into a hostel, adding that CCTV has captured in excess of twenty (20) people moving into the said premises at ago, a state of affairs he contends became untenable as there are young children in his residence.
7. He concedes that he raised questions of security of their home and neighborhood, and whether the Plaintiff had been licensed to operate commercially but the Plaintiff claimed he was interfering with the use of her property. He explains that since the situation was getting out of hand, he informed neighborhood associations including Makanda Close and the Karen Lang’ata District Association (KLDA) and the County Government of Nairobi, who planned to inspect the Plaintiff’s house but she refused to open it for inspection.
8. He points out that it is the neighborhood association that decided to have a common gate at the common drive way, where movement in and out of the estate will be monitored for security purposes, and the Plaintiff was aware of the same. He asserts that the suit property falls under zone 12 of the Nairobi City County’s development policies, where only a single family dwelling residential house is approved, adding that the Plaintiff has no relevant approvals authenticating her use of the suit property.
9. The Plaintiff filed a further affidavit in rejoinder to the Defendant’s response. She avers that there is no order from any competent authority declaring her use of the suit property unlawful and reiterates that the gate complained of, is being constructed on a public access road serving several properties including hers without authorization to do so.
10. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions.
Submissions
11. The Plaintiff submits that she has met the threshold for grant of injunctions as set in Giella v Cassman Brown & Co. Ltd [1973] EA 358. She points out that she has established proprietary rights arising from her joint proprietorship to the suit property which she enjoys protection of under Article 40 of the Constitution. Further, that her evidence demonstrates a continuing course of interference with her proprietary rights by the Defendant through intimidation, harassment and participation in the construction of a gate on the public access road serving the suit property.
12. She also submits that the injury she has suffered due to the Defendant’s actions extend beyond financial loss as it affects her peaceful occupation, access and beneficial enjoyment of her property. Further, that the balance of convenience favours preserving the status quo and protecting the parties’ equal rights pending trial.
13. To buttress her averments, she relied on the following decisions: Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielsen & 2 others [2014] eKLR; Isabel Chelangat v Samuel Toro Rotich & 5 others [2012] eKLR; Diana Muchiri v Lydia Wariara Njenga & another [2014] KEELC 527 and Jaswant Kuarba Banesingh Jethwa v Praded Kumar Jethwa [2023] eKLR.
14. On his part, the Defendant submits that the Plaintiff has not met the threshold for grant of injunctions sought as she failed to establish a prima facie case that meets the definition in Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd [2003] eKLR, being that she has no relevant approval for change of use of her house from the approved residential house to a commercial enterprise. Further, that she has not demonstrated that she will suffer irreparable loss as there is no evidence of intimidation of her guests including herself. Further, that she comes to equity with unclean hands as she has no approvals for her land use. He argues that the orders sought are incapable of being issued against him as the allegation that he is interfering with the suit property by putting up a gate is untrue, as he does not own the public access road upon which residents of Makanda Close are putting up a gate and in any case the plaintiff was privy to the said construction as it was a matter discussed upon for close to a year.
15. He insists that the Plaintiff has no superior right over him to turn her residence into a fully-fledged commercial enterprise and that the balance of convenience tilts in his favour as grant of an injunction risks heavier injustice to him and the neighborhood as they will have to live in fear of the risk the plaintiff’s guests pose. To buttress his averments, he relied on the following decisions: N v N [1991] KLR and Njogu v County Government of Uasin Gishu (Civil Appeal 12 of 2020) [2025] KECA 1040(KLR).
Analysis and Determination
16. Upon consideration of the instant Notice of Motion application including the respective affidavits and parties’ submissions, the sole issue for determination is whether the Defendant should be restrained from interfering with the Plaintiff’s possession of her residence on Nairobi/Block 148/1907.
17. In line with the principles on injunctions as espoused in the case of Giella v Cassman Brown & Company Limited (1973) E A 358 as well as the definition of a prima facie case as stated in the case of Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd [2003] eKLR, the Court will proceed to determine whether the Plaintiff has demonstrated a prima facie case to warrant the orders of interlocutory injunction as sought.
18. It is not disputed that the suit property, Nairobi/Block 148/1907 is registered jointly to the Plaintiff and the Defendant, who have established their residential homes thereon. According to the parties, they co-existed peacefully until 2025 when the Plaintiff relocated to Britain.
19. The Plaintiff claims that upon her relocation, she began utilizing her residence for short-term accommodation through Airbnb and other booking platforms. She contends that in June 2026, the Defendant began questioning her use of the premises, alleging that she was converting it into a hostel. Further, that the Defendant then posted the allegation on a residents’ whatsapp group and sent her intimidating including threatening messages.
20. She states that the Defendant, together with neighboring proprietors, commenced construction of a gate and access-control mechanism on the access road serving the suit property without her authorization and this was aimed at restricting her access to the property and that of her guests. She urges the Court to issue an injunction to preserve equality of possession and peaceful enjoyment of the jointly owned property.
21. On his part, the Defendant contends that the suit property was intended to serve as their respective family residences, thus the Plaintiff’s decision to operate short-term accommodation through Airbnb has departed from their original understanding and is without the requisite approvals. He insists that the common gate is a security initiative undertaken by the Makanda Close Residents’ Association on the common drive way to the estate and that the Plaintiff was privy to the arrangement.
22. In this instance, I note the suit property is meant for residential use and is shared by the Plaintiff and Defendant. The Plaintiff has admitted to using her house as an Airbnb. Further, she has admitted that in June 2026, additional beds and furniture were delivered to her residence. The Plaintiff has not denied that the suit property falls under zone 12 of the Nairobi City County’s development policies, where only a single family dwelling residential house is approved.
23. The Plaintiff insists that the Defendant is interfering with her peaceful occupation of the suit property but has not provided the relevant approvals for change of use of her house from the approved residential house to a commercial enterprise. She admits that she relocated to Britain but claims her guests are being intimidated but has not presented materials before the Court.
24. The Plaintiff is aggrieved with a gate being built in the public access road but has not explained what prejudice she stands to suffer if the said gate is built. The Plaintiff has further not denied that she participated in discussions culminating in the building of the said gate. I opine that since the Makanda Close Residents’ Association common gate is a security initiative undertaken by the owners, there is no way this is interfering with the Plaintiff’s occupation of her property. Further, from the explanations provided by both parties, they were sharing the property as equals and none has a superior right over the other.
25. It is my considered view that since the suit property was meant for residential purpose and there is no indication that the Plaintiff legally changed it to commercial use, I find the Plaintiff has not demonstrated a prima facie case to warrant the orders of interlocutory injunction as sought.
26. In further associating myself with the decision in Nguruman Ltd. Vs. Jan Bonde Nielsen (2014) eKLR, where it was held that where a party fails to establish a prima facie case, the Court need not proceed to make a determination of the other two limbs on injunction, I will decline to deal with the said other two limbs.
27. In the foregoing, I find the Notice of Motion application dated the 8th
July 2026 unmerited and will dismiss it.
28. Costs will be in the cause
DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 14TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
CHRISTINE OCHIENG
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Wanyanga for Namada for Defendant/Respondent
Court Assistant: Joan