Land law

Kassam v Amershi & another [2026] KEELC 6604 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
ELC CIVIL SUIT NO. 1019 OF 2016
Judgment date
14 October 2026
Judge(s)
C.K Nzili

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The court refused the parties’ request for the matter to proceed before the former judge. It directed that the suit continue before the current court from the stage at which the hearing was interrupted, subject to Order 18 of the Civil Procedure Rules and the parties’ fair-hearing rights. Parties may raise justified procedural applications concerning recorded evidence, including recall of witnesses, and the matter is to be fixed for priority hearing subject to the court diary.

Supporting judgment passages

10. In the absence of such a direction and having considered the circumstances of the matter, the Court directs that the suit shall proceed before this Court and not before the former Court. The fact that some witnesses have already testified before the previous Judge does not, in itself, preclude this Court from proceeding with the hearing, subject to the applicable provisions of the law.

Paragraph 10 →

11. Accordingly, the matter shall proceed from the stage at which the hearing was interrupted, subject to the provisions of Order 18 of the Civil Procedure Rules and the parties’ right to a fair hearing.

Paragraph 11 →

12. The parties shall be at liberty to raise any appropriate procedural issues concerning the evidence already recorded, including any application for the recall of a witness, where justified in law.

Paragraph 12 →
Issue 1Whether, after the former judge’s transfer and after three witnesses had testified, the suit should proceed before the former court or before the current court.

Held. Decided: the suit shall proceed before the current court, not the former court. The current court lacked capacity to place the matter before the former court because that court no longer had jurisdiction unless the transferring authority issued directions. Prior testimony before the former judge did not itself bar the current court from continuing the hearing. The case will continue from the interrupted stage, subject to Order 18 and fair-hearing rights; parties may seek appropriate procedural relief concerning recorded evidence, including witness recall where legally justified.

Ratio. Order 18 Rule 8 permits a successor judge, where the predecessor is prevented from concluding the trial, to use evidence already taken as if taken before that successor and to continue the matter from where the predecessor stopped. A return to the former court requires directions from the transferring authority where that court no longer has jurisdiction; the fact that witnesses testified before the former judge is not, by itself, a bar to continuation by the successor judge.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

9. From the above it, is clear that this court dealt with the pending application left by my predecessor after her transfer. Following delivery of the ruling, counsel for the parties requested that the matter proceed before the former Court on the ground that three witnesses had already testified. The power to decide to have the matter placed before the former court is beyond the capacity of this court, since the said court no longer has jurisdiction over this matter unless the transferring authority grants such directions upon request by the parties herein.

Paragraph 9 →

10. In the absence of such a direction and having considered the circumstances of the matter, the Court directs that the suit shall proceed before this Court and not before the former Court. The fact that some witnesses have already testified before the previous Judge does not, in itself, preclude this Court from proceeding with the hearing, subject to the applicable provisions of the law.

Paragraph 10 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

10. In the absence of such a direction and having considered the circumstances of the matter, the Court directs that the suit shall proceed before this Court and not before the former Court. The fact that some witnesses have already testified before the previous Judge does not, in itself, preclude this Court from proceeding with the hearing, subject to the applicable provisions of the law.

Paragraph 10 →

11. Accordingly, the matter shall proceed from the stage at which the hearing was interrupted, subject to the provisions of Order 18 of the Civil Procedure Rules and the parties’ right to a fair hearing.

Paragraph 11 →

12. The parties shall be at liberty to raise any appropriate procedural issues concerning the evidence already recorded, including any application for the recall of a witness, where justified in law.

Paragraph 12 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

7. Order 18 Rule 8 of the Civil Procedure Code deals with the power to deal with instances where a judge is prevented from concluding a trial of a suit. His successor is allowed to deal with any evidence taken down as if that evidence had been taken down by him or under his directions. He may proceed with the suit or the application from where his predecessor left it.

Paragraph 7 →

9. From the above it, is clear that this court dealt with the pending application left by my predecessor after her transfer. Following delivery of the ruling, counsel for the parties requested that the matter proceed before the former Court on the ground that three witnesses had already testified. The power to decide to have the matter placed before the former court is beyond the capacity of this court, since the said court no longer has jurisdiction over this matter unless the transferring authority grants such directions upon request by the parties herein.

Paragraph 9 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Court notes that the matter first came up for hearing on 27.01.2025, when PW1, Mr Alnoor Hassam Ebrahim Kassam, testified and adopted his witness statement and list of documents as part of his evidence. However, counsel for the 2nd Defendant objected on the ground that the documents intended to be relied upon had not been served upon them. Consequently, the Court directed the Plaintiff to supply the said documents to the 2nd…

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether, after the former judge’s transfer and after three witnesses had testified, the suit should be placed before that former court or should continue before the succeeding judge; and what procedural safeguards should govern further hearing.

Material facts

The plaintiff, Alnoor Hassam Ebrahim Kassam, had testified as PW1 and adopted his witness statement and documents on 27 January 2025. The 2nd defendant objected that the documents had not been served, leading to directions for service and several…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

MILIMANI LAW COURTS

ELC CIVIL SUIT NO. 1019 OF 2016

ALNOOR HASSAM EBRAHIM KASSAM.………………..PLAINTIFF

-VERSUS-

SHAHNAZ AMIN AMERSHI………...……….........1st DEFENDANT

ALEYA RIYAZ TAJDIN DHANJI…………………2ND DEFENDANT

RULING

1. The Court notes that the matter first came up for hearing on 27.01.2025, when PW1, Mr Alnoor Hassam Ebrahim Kassam, testified and adopted his witness statement and list of documents as part of his evidence. However, counsel for the 2nd Defendant objected on the ground that the documents intended to be relied upon had not been served upon them. Consequently, the Court directed the Plaintiff to supply the said documents to the 2nd Defendant. The matter was adjourned to 30.04.2025.

2. When the matter came up for hearing on 30th April 2025, counsel for the Plaintiff indicated readiness to proceed with the case. Counsel for the 2nd Defendant, however, was not ready to proceed, citing the late service of a new bundle of documents filed by the Plaintiff. The matter was therefore adjourned to 05.06.2025.

3. On 05.06.2025, the Court initially indicated that the parties would proceed with the hearing. However, the proceedings were interrupted by the Court's engagement in official duties, necessitating a further adjournment to 11.06.2025.

4. On 11.06.2025, the Plaintiff's case proceeded, and three witnesses testified, namely the Plaintiff herein; PW2, Moaze Kaba; and PW3, Rajinder Kaur. Upon conclusion of the proceedings on that day, the Court fixed the matter for further hearing on 02.12.2025.

5. When the matter came up for hearing on 02.12.2025, counsel for the Plaintiff informed the Court that the Plaintiff had filed an application for injunction dated 21.11.2025 and sought a hearing date for the same.

6. When the matter came before me for mention on 13.07.2026, the Court fixed 23.09.2026 as the date for delivery of the ruling on the pending application. The ruling was duly delivered on 23.09.2026, whereupon counsel for the parties requested that the matter proceed before the former Court, noting that three witnesses had already testified.

7. Order 18 Rule 8 of the Civil Procedure Code deals with the power to deal with instances where a judge is prevented from concluding a trial of a suit. His successor is allowed to deal with any evidence taken down as if that evidence had been taken down by him or under his directions. He may proceed with the suit or the application from where his predecessor left it.

8. The guiding principles were set out in Abdi Adan Mohamed V Republic [2017] Eklr that it is highly desirable that a trial judge hears a case to conclusion and ultimately render judgment, as it is important for a final arbiter to be in a position to weigh the evidence taken together with his observation of the witness's demeanor. The considerations were also set out in G.R Mandavia versus Rattan Singh [1965] EA 118, the court has to strike a balance between the overriding objective and justice vis-a-vis the cost-effectiveness of the order

9. From the above it, is clear that this court dealt with the pending application left by my predecessor after her transfer. Following delivery of the ruling, counsel for the parties requested that the matter proceed before the former Court on the ground that three witnesses had already testified. The power to decide to have the matter placed before the former court is beyond the capacity of this court, since the said court no longer has jurisdiction over this matter unless the transferring authority grants such directions upon request by the parties herein.

10. In the absence of such a direction and having considered the circumstances of the matter, the Court directs that the suit shall proceed before this Court and not before the former Court. The fact that some witnesses have already testified before the previous Judge does not, in itself, preclude this Court from proceeding with the hearing, subject to the applicable provisions of the law.

11. Accordingly, the matter shall proceed from the stage at which the hearing was interrupted, subject to the provisions of Order 18 of the Civil Procedure Rules and the parties’ right to a fair hearing.

12. The parties shall be at liberty to raise any appropriate procedural issues concerning the evidence already recorded, including any application for the recall of a witness, where justified in law.

13. The matter shall be fixed for further hearing on a priority basis, subject to the Court’s diary.

14. It is so ordered.

Dated, signed and delivered on this 14th day of October, 2026.

………………………….

Hon. Justice C.K Nzili

Judge

In the presence of;

Mr.Otieno for plaintiff

Miss Koki for 2nd defendant

Mr. Nduli for 1st defendant

Court assistant ; Julius

Legal Researcher ; Bevalyn Nyakwana

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder