Land law

Karuru v Njenga [2026] KEELC 6522 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
ELC SUIT NO. 1002 OF 2014
Judgment date
14 October 2026
Judge(s)
CA Ochieng

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is before the Court for determination is the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion application dated the 16th September 2025 in which he seeks the following Orders:

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

Based on the facts as presented while associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that the Plaintiff failed to demonstrate sufficient cause why this suit should be reinstated. Further, I find the delay in prosecuting the suit as well as filing the instant application as inordinate. The Plaintiff has further sought to rely on Article 159 (2) (d) of the Constitution but I opine that this is not a cure for all ills even where a…

Paragraph 19 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC SUIT NO. 1002 OF 2014

SAMUEL NJOROGE KARURU ................................... PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

JOHN MIRINGU NJENGA ...................................... DEFENDANT

RULING

1. What is before the Court for determination is the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion application dated the 16th September 2025 in which he seeks the following Orders:

a) Spent.

b) That the Honourable Court be pleased to review, vary and /or set aside the orders (s) made herein on 19.05.2020 by Hon. Mr. Justice Eboso Benard Mweresa terminating for want of prosecution and to reinstate the same for determination of the pending revocation application.

c) That this matter be revived for hearing and final determination of the cause on merit.

d) That costs of the application be in the cause.

2. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the Plaintiff’s supporting affidavit. He avers that due to lack of financial means to engage legal counsel, he was representing himself in the suit and had limited knowledge of Civil Procedure and Court processes. He points out that the matter came up for Notice to Show Cause, herein referred to as ‘NTSC’ on 19th May 2020, before Hon. Mr. Justice Eboso during the height of COVID -19 pandemic, when Court operations were being conducted virtually. He claims that he did not attend the said NTSC because he was not privy to the date and did not receive prior notice and that even if he had been aware of the said date, he had no suitable electronic device and internet connection. He claims that he later became aware of the said hearing through a letter from the judiciary, addressed to his child’s school and which did not reach him in good time.

3. He contends that since the dismissal of the suit, the Defendant has continued to unlawfully encroach on his property, causing him loss. Further, that he has now secured legal representation and is ready to prosecute the matter to its logical conclusion. He reiterates that no prejudice will be suffered by the Respondent since he has an opportunity to respond.

Response

4. The Defendant filed a replying affidavit in opposition. He avers that the suit was lawfully dismissed on 19th May 2020 and that prior to the said dismissal, the Plaintiff had not taken any meaningful steps to prosecute it for several years, thereby demonstrating a lack of interest in the suit. Further, that the explanation attributing his failure to attend Court to the COVID 19 pandemic, lack of suitable electronic device, lack of internet access or alleged late service with the impugned NTSC is an afterthought and unsupported by evidence as there is no explanation for the period of delay from 2020 to 2025. Further, that litigation must come to an end as a suit dismissed over five (5) years ago ought not be revived, as he will be prejudiced since he treated the matter as fully concluded. He also denies unlawfully encroaching on the suit property.

5. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions.

Submissions

6. The Plaintiff submits that the impugned NTSC was sent via his child’s school, a non-procedural mode of service that failed to give him adequate notice thus he should not be penalized for failing to appear. Further, that in May 2020, Kenya’s judicial system transitioned to virtual Courts and he had no computer/smartphone or internet access thus denying him a hearing because of technological barriers during a global health emergency would amount to penalizing poverty and digital exclusion.

7. He urges the Court to consider its mandate under Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution, which is to administer justice without undue regard to procedural technicalities. He also urges the Court to consider that he was an unrepresented layman, financially constrained, and unaware of the formal steps required to set aside an ex parte dismissal until he was able to secure counsel. He reiterates that he has a triable grievance regarding his land which the Defendant continues to encroach upon while he will not suffer irreparable prejudice if the suit is reinstated.

8. To buttress his averments, the Plaintiff relied on the following decisions: Wachira Karani v Bildad Wachira [2016] eKLR; Philip Chemwolo & Another v Augustine Kubende [1982-1988] 1 KAR 1036; Esther Wamaitha Njihia & 2 Others v Safaricom Limited [2014] eKLR and CMC Holdings Ltd v James Mumo Nzioka [2004] eKLR Ivita v Kyumbu [1984] KLR 441.

9. On his part, the Defendant submits that while the Plaintiff bore the burden of demonstrating sufficient cause for failure to attend the NTSC hearing on 19th May 2020 and for the inordinate delay in seeking reinstatement between 2020 and 2025, his explanation fell short, given that the suit was instituted in 2014 and lay dormant for years before the dismissal in 2020. Further, that the delay in seeking reinstatement is inordinate and that reinstating the suit will occasion him grave prejudice.

10. To buttress his averments, the Defendant relied on the following decisions: Shah v Mbogo [1968] EA 93, Wachira Karani v Bildad Wachira [2016] eKLR; Wafula (Legal representative of Peter Mayeku Khisa-dcd) & another v Khisa [2025] KEELC 3127 (KLR) and Rajesh Rughani v Fifty Investments Limited & another [2016] KECA 829 (KLR).

Analysis and Determination

11. I have considered the instant Notice of Motion application including

the respective affidavits together with the parties’ submissions and the only issue for determination is whether the Plaintiff has demonstrated sufficient cause to reinstate this suit which was dismissed for want of prosecution on 19th May 2020.

12. The Plaintiff contends that he was unable to attend the NTSC hearing of 19th May 2020 when the suit was dismissed for want of prosecution because he was not aware of the hearing date. Further, that he got a letter through his child’s school, later on. He explains that he is a layman and that he acted in person in the suit as he could not afford counsel due to financial constraints. Further, that he is not conversant with the Civil Procedure Rules and was unaware of the processes to set aside dismissal orders until he instructed counsel.

13. He also contends that at the time of dismissal of the suit, the country was at the height of COVID - 19 pandemic and Court proceedings were being conducted virtually but he lacked the necessary electronic devices and internet access to participate in the proceedings. He further states that the Defendant continues to unlawfully encroach upon the suit property, thereby occasioning him loss and prejudice.

14. On his part, the Defendant accuses the Plaintiff of being indolent from the time the suit was filed in 2014 to the time of its dismissal in 2020 and contends that lack of legal representation/financial constraint does not excuse indolence. He argues that the explanations advanced by the Plaintiff, including the COVID-19 pandemic, lack of suitable electronic devices and internet access, and alleged failure to receive proper notice of the NTSC hearing, are unsupported by evidence and amount to an afterthought. He insists that the Plaintiff has not adequately explained the inordinate delay between the dismissal of the suit in 2020 and the filing of the instant application in 2025.

15. On making an application to reinstate a suit, Order 17 Rule 2(6) of the Civil Procedure Rules stipulates thus:

“(6) A party may apply to court after dismissal of a suit under this Order.”

16. In dealing with an application for reinstatement of a suit dismissed for want of prosecution, the conditions to be considered is well captured in the case of Ivita -v- Kyumbu (1984) KLR 441 as follows:

“The test is whether the delay is prolonged and

inexcusable and if it is, can justice be done despite such delay. Justice is justice to both the plaintiff and the defendant so both parties to the suit must be considered and the position of the judge too, because it is no easy task for the documents and or witnesses may be missing and evidence is weak due to the disappearance of human memory resulting from lapse of time; the defendant must satisfy the court that he will be prejudiced by the delay or even that the plaintiff will be prejudiced; he must show that justice will not be done in the case due to the prolonged delay on the part of the plaintiff.”

17. From the Court record, I note this suit was filed in 2014 but the Plaintiff never appeared in Court to prosecute it culminating in its dismissal for want of prosecution on 19th May, 2020. The Plaintiff has not explained why prior to the COVID 19 Pandemic in 2020, he never bothered to set down the suit for hearing for six years, let alone even undertake pretrial directions. Further, after this suit was dismissed for want of prosecution in 2020, the Plaintiff filed the instant application more than five (5) years later and seeks to blame his ignorance to the law as the reason for delay. It is trite that ignorance of the law cannot be used as an excuse and it was incumbent upon the Plaintiff to provide plausible reasons on why he failed to set his suit down for hearing.

18. The Plaintiff also relied on Article 159 of the Constitution and urged the Court to reinstate the suit. While declining to allow an application for reinstatement, this Court, Mutungi J, stated as follows in Cubi & 3 others v Hon Attorney General on Behalf of the Resident Magistrate Senior Resident Magistrate Court at Wang’uru; Kariuki & another (Interested Parties) [2025] KEELC 5498 (KLR):

“The Constitution, under Article 159[2][b], requires that justice be dispensed without any undue delay. It also provides under Article 159[2][d] that Justice shall be administered without undue regard to procedural technicalities. While procedural rules exist to foster fair hearing, certainty, and Judicial efficiency, Courts must draw a line between excusable oversight and systemic neglect. The Applicants have failed to demonstrate good faith, diligence, or any meaningful engagement with the Court process over a span of nearly nine years. Reinstatement of the dismissed suit would not serve the ends of Justice but would instead undermine the finality and efficiency of Court processes”.

19. Based on the facts as presented while associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that the Plaintiff failed to demonstrate sufficient cause why this suit should be reinstated. Further, I find the delay in prosecuting the suit as well as filing the instant application as inordinate. The Plaintiff has further sought to rely on Article 159 (2) (d) of the Constitution but I opine that this is not a cure for all ills even where a party has for several years failed to prosecute his case. In the circumstances, I will hence decline to reinstate this suit as this will not serve the ends of Justice.

20. In the foregoing, I find the instant Notice of Motion application unmerited and will disallow it.

21. Each party to bear their own costs.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 14TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

CHRISTINE OCHIENG

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Ms Gitonga for Defendant/Respondent

Kivuva for Plaintiff/Applicant

Court Assistant: Joan

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder