Background
The Claimant sued the Respondent vide a Memorandum of Claim dated 13th June, 2017 and pleaded:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Judgment for the Claimant. The court awarded Kshs.284,971 comprising Kshs.175,000 compensation for unfair termination, Kshs.35,000 notice pay, Kshs.35,000 September 2016 salary, Kshs.3,498 for four October 2016 days, and Kshs.36,473 accrued leave. The sum is subject to PAYE and attracts court-rate interest from judgment until payment. The Respondent must issue a certificate of service within 30 days; the Claimant receives costs. Reinstatement/re-engagement, off-days, discrimination, and service-pay claims were declined.
35. In sum, and having considered written submissions filed on behalf of both parties herein, Judgment is hereby entered for the Claimant against the Respondent as follows:-
Paragraph 35 →
Total = ……………………Kshs.284,971/=
Passage 98 →
36. The awarded sum shall be subject to PAYE (Pay As You Earn) tax pursuant to Section 49(2) of the Employment Act.
Paragraph 36 →
Held. Decided. The Claimant proved on a balance of probabilities that he was employed by the Respondent as a Manager from 10 February 2015 to 4 October 2016, at Kshs.35,000 per month.
Ratio. An oral employment contract is valid under the Employment Act. Where the employer fails to provide the required written contract or particulars, it bears the burden concerning alleged contractual terms. The undisputed NSSF statement naming the Respondent, together with corroborating employment documents, established the employment relationship.
Issue
(a) Whether the Claimant was employed by the Respondent as pleaded by him.
Passage 65 →
Held
21. I return a finding, and declare, that the Claimant was employed by the Respondent as a Manager on 10th February, 2015 upto 4th October, 2016 when his employment was terminated by the Respondent, and that he was earning Kshs.35,000/= per month as per his (the Claimant’s) testimony/evidence.
Paragraph 21 →
Ratio
14. On the first issue, I am satisfied that the Claimant proved, on a balance of probabilities, that he was employed by the Respondent as pleaded by him. Among the evidential documents produced by the Claimant is an NSSF statement covering, inter-alia, the pleaded period of employment. The Respondent is named on the said statement as having been the Claimant’s employer. The Respondent did not dispute the validity of the said public document, which also bears the Respondent’s employer number (20393946). All that RW-1 told the Court was that the Claimant had not filed a certificate of electronic evidence regarding the said NSSF statement.
Paragraph 14 →
18. The absence of a written employment contract cannot invalidate the fact of the Claimant having been the Respondent’s employee. Under Section 8 of the Employment Act, a contract of employment may be oral or written; and the said Act applies to both. The Claimant pleaded that his employment contract was oral, and that he was never issued with an itemised payslip.
Paragraph 18 →
“(7) If in any legal proceedings an employer fails to produce a written contract or the written particulars prescribed in sub-section (1), the burden of proving or disproving an alleged term of employment stipulated in the contract shall be on the employer”.
Passage 76 →
Held. Decided. The termination was unlawful and unfair, both procedurally and substantively.
Ratio. The Respondent gave neither termination notice nor pay in lieu, did not accord the Claimant the mandatory hearing, and failed to prove a valid reason for termination. An employer must prove the reason for termination; failure to do so renders termination unfair.
Issue
(b) Whether termination of the Claimant’s employment was unfair.
Passage 66 →
Held
22. On the second issue, I find and hold that termination of the Claimant’s employment was unlawful and unfair as he is not shown to have been given a termination notice pursuant to Section 35(1)(c) of the Employment Act, or to have been paid in lieu of notice. Further, the Respondent did not demonstrate that it had a valid reason for terminating the Claimant’s employment. The Respondent maintained that there had been no valid employment contract between itself and the Claimant, despite the evidence adduced by the Claimant. Further, the Respondent is not shown to have adhered to the mandatory procedure set out in Section 41 of the Employment Act.
Paragraph 22 →
24. Termination of the Claimant’s employment by the Respondent was procedurally unfair for lack of termination notice, fair hearing before termination, and was substantively unfair for lack of a valid reason for termination as provided in Section 45(2) of the Employment Act.
Paragraph 24 →
Ratio
22. On the second issue, I find and hold that termination of the Claimant’s employment was unlawful and unfair as he is not shown to have been given a termination notice pursuant to Section 35(1)(c) of the Employment Act, or to have been paid in lieu of notice. Further, the Respondent did not demonstrate that it had a valid reason for terminating the Claimant’s employment. The Respondent maintained that there had been no valid employment contract between itself and the Claimant, despite the evidence adduced by the Claimant. Further, the Respondent is not shown to have adhered to the mandatory procedure set out in Section 41 of the Employment Act.
Paragraph 22 →
“(1) In any claim arising out of a termination of a contract, the employer shall be required to prove the reason or reasons for the termination, and where the employer fails to do so, the termination shall be deemed to have been unfair within the meaning of Section 45.”
Passage 80 →
24. Termination of the Claimant’s employment by the Respondent was procedurally unfair for lack of termination notice, fair hearing before termination, and was substantively unfair for lack of a valid reason for termination as provided in Section 45(2) of the Employment Act.
Paragraph 24 →
Held. Decided in part. Reinstatement/re-engagement was refused because termination occurred over three years earlier. The court awarded five months’ compensation (Kshs.175,000), one month’s notice pay (Kshs.35,000), September salary (Kshs.35,000), four days’ October salary (Kshs.3,498), and accrued leave (Kshs.36,473). It refused off-days because no specific untaken and unpaid days were proved, discrimination because it was unproved, and service pay because the Claimant contributed to NSSF. A certificate of service was ordered.
Ratio. Reinstatement was inappropriate after the lengthy lapse since termination. Leave pay was due because the employer, despite its statutory record-keeping duty, produced no leave records. Service pay is unavailable to an NSSF contributor. The remaining rejected claims failed for want of proof.
Issue
(c) Whether the reliefs sought by the Claimant are merited.
Passage 67 →
Held
25. On the third issue, and having made a finding that termination of the Claimant's employment was unfair, and having noted that the Claimant’s employment was terminated over 3 years ago, I disallow the principal prayer for reinstatement and/or re-engagement.
Paragraph 25 →
35. In sum, and having considered written submissions filed on behalf of both parties herein, Judgment is hereby entered for the Claimant against the Respondent as follows:-
Paragraph 35 →
38. The Respondent shall issue the Claimant with a certificate of service pursuant to Section 51 of the Employment Act within thirty days from the date of this Judgment.
Paragraph 38 →
Ratio
30. The claim for Kshs.36,473/= being payment for accrued leave days is allowed. Section 74(f) of the Employment Act obligates an employer to keep records on employee’s leave, days taken and days due. No such records were produced by the Respondent. Indeed, no employment records were produced by the Respondent despite RW-1’s testimony that the Respondent had about 20 employees at the material time.
Paragraph 30 →
32. The claim for Kshs.2,000,000/= being compensation for discrimination is declined. Discrimination was not proved.
Paragraph 32 →
33. The claim for Kshs.17,500/= being service pay is declined. The Claimant demonstrated that he was a member of/contributor to NSSF. Section 35(6)(d) of the Employment Act disqualifies him from claiming service pay.
Paragraph 33 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The Claimant sued the Respondent vide a Memorandum of Claim dated 13th June, 2017 and pleaded:-
Paragraph 1 →I allow the alternative relief/prayer in the manner stated herein below.
Paragraph 26 →On the first issue, I am satisfied that the Claimant proved, on a balance of probabilities, that he was employed by the Respondent as pleaded by him. Among the evidential documents produced by the Claimant is an NSSF statement covering, inter-alia, the pleaded period of employment. The Respondent is named on the said statement as having been the Claimant’s employer. The Respondent did not dispute the validity of the said public…
Paragraph 14 →The court identified three questions: whether Edward Linganga Khabongo was employed by Speed Eye Investments Limited t/a Salt Club and Restaurant; whether the termination of his employment was unfair; and whether the reliefs sought were merited.
The claimant alleged that he worked orally as the respondent’s Hotel Manager from 10 February 2015 to 4 October 2016 at a monthly salary of Kshs.35,000. He said he was dismissed without notice or hearing, through directions to report to the director, and was…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. 1917 OF 2017
(Before Hon. Lady Justice Agnes Kitiku Nzei)
EDWARD LINGANGA KHABONGO CLAIMANT
VERSUS
SPEED EYE INVESTMENTS LIMITED T/A
SALT CLUB AND RESTAURANT ..RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. The Claimant sued the Respondent vide a Memorandum of Claim dated 13th June, 2017 and pleaded:-
(a) that the Claimant was employed by the Respondent as a Manager on 10th February, 2015 until 4th October, 2016, with the initial three (3) months being a probationary period.
(b) that the Claimant worked for the Respondent as a Hotel Manager [in] Salt Club and Restaurant, Mfangano Street Nairobi, earning a net sum of Kshs.35,000/=.
(c) that the Claimant’s contract was oral, and that upon completion of probation, his employment became permanent.
(d) that the Claimant’s employment was terminated by the Respondent on 4th October, 2016 without notice; and without payment of the salary for September 2016.
(e) that the Claimant was not given/granted leave or paid in lieu thereof.
(f) that the Claimant was never issued with an itemised payslip during the period of his employment.
(g) that prior to the Claimant’s termination, the Respondent hired 2 trainee managers to work under the Claimant, and whom the Claimant paid Kshs.50,000/= per month, which amounted to discrimination against the Claimant.
(h) that the Claimant reported the matter [of his termination] to Nairobi Labour Office on 12th October, 2016, upon which a letter was written to the Respondent. That the Respondent did not respond to the letter.
(i) that termination of the Claimant’s employment was unlawful and unjustified, as no reason was offered.
(j) that the Claimant was terminated without being accorded an opportunity to be heard; and without notice, contrary to the law.
(k) that the Claimant was not paid his terminal dues.
2. The Claimant sought the following reliefs:-
(a) A declaration that termination of the Claimant was unlawful, and hence null and void.
(b) Re-engagement/Reinstatement of the Claimant in work comparable to that in which he had been employed prior to dismissal, at the same wages and without loss of benefits, salary and allowances.
(c) In the alternative to reinstatement, monetary compensation as follows:-
(i) Compensation (12 x 35,000) …… Kshs.420,000/=.
(ii) One month notice ……… Kshs.35,000/=.
(iii) September 2016 salary …… Kshs.35,000/=.
(iv) Leave days …………………… Kshs.36,473/=.
(v) 28 days off …………………… Kshs.32,648/=.
(vi) Compensation for discrimination …… Kshs.2,000,000/=.
(vii) Service ……………………… Kshs.17,500/=.
(viii) 4 days October 2016 ……… Kshs.3,498/=.
Total = Kshs.2,580,389/=.
(d) Interest at Court rates from the date of termination until payment in full.
(e) Certificate of service.
(f) Costs of the suit.
(g) Any other remedy the Court may deem fit to grant in the circumstance.
3. Documents filed alongside the Memorandum of Claim included an affidavit in verification of the claim, the Claimant’s written witness statement dated 12th June, 2017 and a list of documents dated 13th June, 2017, listing 3 letters written by the Ministry of Labour to the Respondent on 19th & 26th October, 2017 and 2nd November, 2016 respectively, and a demand letter (dated 21st November, 2016). The Claimant also filed a further list of documents dated 30th September, 2024, listing his work place Identity Card, NSSF Statement, a letter of commitment from the Managers, payment receipt for the Respondent’s Single Business Permit (issued by Nairobi City County on 3rd February, 2016), a letter to Nairobi City County dated 4th August, 2016, the Respondent’s certificate of incorporation, CR 12 and PIN.
4. The Respondent defended the suit vide a Memorandum of Response dated 18th November, 2023 and denied the Claimant’s claim. The Respondent pleaded:-
(a) that there was no valid contract between itself and the Claimant, and that the Claimant was not earning the pleaded sum.
(b) that the Claimant was not entitled to any terminal dues as there was no valid contract between the parties herein.
5. The Claimant also filed a written witness statement of Albert Karakacha dated 4th November, 2023.
6. The Court’s record shows that an ex-parte Judgment delivered on 27th March, 2023 (Dr. Jacob Gakeri, J) was set aside and a fresh trial ordered pursuant to a written consent dated 30th October, 2023 and recorded by the Court on 16th November, 2023.
7. The ordered fresh trial commenced before me on 19th February, 2025. The Claimant testified and adopted his filed witness statement as his testimony; and produced in evidence the documents referred to in paragraph 3 of this Judgment. The Claimant further testified:-
(a) that he (the Claimant) joined the Respondent on 10th February, 2015; and that the Respondent started paying his NSSF contributions in May 2015; and paid upto 2016.
(b) that the Respondent’s Managers made the Claimant/employees to sign a letter of commitment on meeting set targets. That the Claimant and another manager (Benjamin Oyoo) signed the undated letter of commitment.
(c) that as a Manager, the Claimant was in charge of getting (obtaining) all permits and licences; and even wrote a letter to Nairobi Water and Sewerage Company Limited on 4th August, 2016 over a sewerage problem in the [Respondent’s] premises (exhibit 9).
(d) That the Respondent’s documents produced in evidence by the Claimant had been given to him for purposes of registering the Respondent for NHIF, NSSF and Tourism Trust Fund.
(e) that the Claimant’s employment was terminated on 4th October, 2016 via a text message by the General Manager (Mr. Wanyama) telling him not to report to work, but to instead report to the Director’s office in Tumaini House.
(f) that the Claimant reported to the Director’s office on 5th October, 2016, and that the Director told him that he had sacked him as he needed someone who could take his business to the next level.
(g) that the Claimant was not paid his salary for September 2016. That he complained to the Labour Office but the Respondent’s Director did not appear at the Labour Office.
(h) that the Claimant used to report on duty at 6.00 a.m and leave at 10.00 p.m after meeting the targets set by the Director each day; never went on leave, and could be called to work even on his off days.
(i) that the Claimant earned Kshs.35,000/= per month while the other Manager, Benjamin Oyoo, earned Kshs.45,000/=.
(j) that the Claimant was not paid anything upon termination.
8. Cross-examined, the Claimant testified that there were 32 other people working with him, and that he had not been given any contract. The Claimant further testified:-
(a) that he was being paid Kshs.35,000/=, and that he used to sign a voucher on payment, which he was not allowed to take. That he worked for 18 months.
(b) that he had nothing to show that the other Manager, Benjamin Oyoo, was being paid Kshs.45,000/=; and therefore demonstrate discrimination.
(c) that the undated letter of commitment (signed by the Managers) was signed sometimes in July 2015.
9. The Respondent called 1 witness, Albert Karakacha (RW-1), who adopted his filed witness statement as his testimony.
10. Cross-examined, RW-1 testified that he was one of the Directors of Speed Eye Investments Limited which was managing Salt Club & Restaurant. The witness denied having known the Claimant or having employed him. He maintained that the Claimant should produce documents to show that he worked for the Respondent. That the Respondent had almost 20 staff (employees) in 2015 – 2016, and had a manager and a supervisor. That he was not able to mention the names of all the employees who had worked for him, and could not remember how he used to pay them in 2015 to 2016. That he (RW-1) issues job identity cards to his employees. That he had not issued the Job Card produced in evidence by the Claimant.
11. RW-1 further testified that he used to make NSSF remittances for his employees. That employment of the Respondent’s employees was done by the Manager, and that RW-1 did not know how much they were being paid. That RW-1 only got a list of the employees employed by the Manager.
12. Re-examined, RW-1 testified that he was not authorised by the company (the Respondent) to share private data of employees. That records of employees’ leave days and off-days were there.
13. Having considered the pleadings filed herein by both parties and the evidence adduced in Court thereon, issues that fall for determination, in my view, are as follows:-
(a) Whether the Claimant was employed by the Respondent as pleaded by him.
(b) Whether termination of the Claimant’s employment was unfair.
(c) Whether the reliefs sought by the Claimant are merited.
14. On the first issue, I am satisfied that the Claimant proved, on a balance of probabilities, that he was employed by the Respondent as pleaded by him. Among the evidential documents produced by the Claimant is an NSSF statement covering, inter-alia, the pleaded period of employment. The Respondent is named on the said statement as having been the Claimant’s employer. The Respondent did not dispute the validity of the said public document, which also bears the Respondent’s employer number (20393946). All that RW-1 told the Court was that the Claimant had not filed a certificate of electronic evidence regarding the said NSSF statement.
15. The substance and content of the aforesaid NSSF statement not having been disputed by the Respondent, the evidential value of the said document cannot be ignored, and especially when there is on record other corroborative evidence on record such as the Claimant’s job card at the Respondent company, a letter written to a third party by the Respondent and signed by the Claimant in his capacity as the Respondent’s Manager, and other documents of the Respondent that could only have come to the Claimant’s possession as the Respondent’s manager/employee.
16. The Claimant testified that some of those documents were given to him by RW-1’s Personal Assistant (Ruth) in 2015 for purposes of registering the Claimant for NSSF and NHIF. The Respondent did not rebut and/or challenge this evidence. How else could the Claimant have gained possession of the Respondent’s KRA PIN Certificate, Certificate of Incorporation, receipt on payment for issuance of a business permit and a copy of the Respondent’s Director’s (RW-1’s) National Identity Card? The Respondent did not offer an alternative explanation on how the Claimant may have obtained the said documents.
17. Section 20(1) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act provides as follows:-
“(1) In any proceedings to which this Act applies, the Court shall act without undue regard to technicalities”.
18. The absence of a written employment contract cannot invalidate the fact of the Claimant having been the Respondent’s employee. Under Section 8 of the Employment Act, a contract of employment may be oral or written; and the said Act applies to both. The Claimant pleaded that his employment contract was oral, and that he was never issued with an itemised payslip.
19. Section 9(2) of the Employment Act obligates an employer to cause an employment contract to be drawn up, stating particulars of employment. The Respondent herein is shown to have abdicated that statutory obligation; and cannot be allowed to hide behind its own breach of the law.
20. Section 10(7) of the Employment Act provides as follows:-
“(7) If in any legal proceedings an employer fails to produce a written contract or the written particulars prescribed in sub-section (1), the burden of proving or disproving an alleged term of employment stipulated in the contract shall be on the employer”.
21. I return a finding, and declare, that the Claimant was employed by the Respondent as a Manager on 10th February, 2015 upto 4th October, 2016 when his employment was terminated by the Respondent, and that he was earning Kshs.35,000/= per month as per his (the Claimant’s) testimony/evidence.
22. On the second issue, I find and hold that termination of the Claimant’s employment was unlawful and unfair as he is not shown to have been given a termination notice pursuant to Section 35(1)(c) of the Employment Act, or to have been paid in lieu of notice. Further, the Respondent did not demonstrate that it had a valid reason for terminating the Claimant’s employment. The Respondent maintained that there had been no valid employment contract between itself and the Claimant, despite the evidence adduced by the Claimant. Further, the Respondent is not shown to have adhered to the mandatory procedure set out in Section 41 of the Employment Act.
23. Section 43(1) of the Employment Act, 2007 provides as follows:
“(1) In any claim arising out of a termination of a contract, the employer shall be required to prove the reason or reasons for the termination, and where the employer fails to do so, the termination shall be deemed to have been unfair within the meaning of Section 45.”
24. Termination of the Claimant’s employment by the Respondent was procedurally unfair for lack of termination notice, fair hearing before termination, and was substantively unfair for lack of a valid reason for termination as provided in Section 45(2) of the Employment Act.
25. On the third issue, and having made a finding that termination of the Claimant's employment was unfair, and having noted that the Claimant’s employment was terminated over 3 years ago, I disallow the principal prayer for reinstatement and/or re-engagement.
26. I allow the alternative relief/prayer in the manner stated herein below.
27. I award the Claimant the equivalent of five (5) months’ salary being compensation for unfair termination of employment. That is, Kshs.35,000/= x 5 = Kshs.175,000/=, which I award to the Claimant.
28. I also award the Claimant Kshs.35,000/= being one month salary in lieu of notice, pursuant to Section 35(1)(c) of the Employment Act.
29. The Claimant is also awarded Kshs.35,000/= being unpaid salary for September 2016. The Respondent did not controvert and/or rebut the Claimant’s evidence that his salary for the said month was not paid. The claim for Kshs.3,498/= being unpaid salary for 4 days worked in October 2016 is allowed.
30. The claim for Kshs.36,473/= being payment for accrued leave days is allowed. Section 74(f) of the Employment Act obligates an employer to keep records on employee’s leave, days taken and days due. No such records were produced by the Respondent. Indeed, no employment records were produced by the Respondent despite RW-1’s testimony that the Respondent had about 20 employees at the material time.
31. The claim based on the alleged 28 off days is declined. The Claimant testified that he used to take some off days, and pleaded that he worked 6 days [a week]. No evidence was adduced to demonstrate specific untaken and unpaid off days.
32. The claim for Kshs.2,000,000/= being compensation for discrimination is declined. Discrimination was not proved.
33. The claim for Kshs.17,500/= being service pay is declined. The Claimant demonstrated that he was a member of/contributor to NSSF. Section 35(6)(d) of the Employment Act disqualifies him from claiming service pay.
34. The claim for issuance of a certificate of service is allowed pursuant to Section 51 of the Employment Act.
35. In sum, and having considered written submissions filed on behalf of both parties herein, Judgment is hereby entered for the Claimant against the Respondent as follows:-
(a) Compensation for unfair termination of employment …………………………………………………. Kshs.175,000/=.
(b) Payment in lieu of notice ………………… Kshs.35,000/=.
(c) Unpaid salary for September 2016 …… Kshs.35,000/=.
(d) Unpaid salary for 4 days worked in October 2016 …………………………………………………… Kshs.3,498/=.
(e) Unpaid leave days ………………………… Kshs.36,473/=.
Total = ……………………Kshs.284,971/=
36. The awarded sum shall be subject to PAYE (Pay As You Earn) tax pursuant to Section 49(2) of the Employment Act.
37. The awarded sum shall attract interest at Court rates, from the date of this Judgment until payment in full.
38. The Respondent shall issue the Claimant with a certificate of service pursuant to Section 51 of the Employment Act within thirty days from the date of this Judgment.
39. The Claimant is awarded costs of the suit.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS
25TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
AGNES KITIKU NZEI
JUDGE
ORDER
This Judgment has been delivered via Microsoft Teams Online Platform. A signed copy will be availed to each party upon payment of the applicable Court fees.
AGNES KITIKU NZEI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Mr. Ogicho for the Claimant
Mr. Gitonga for the Respondent