Employment law

Kenya Union of Water and Sewerage Employees v Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company Limited [2026] KEELRC 2575 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
ELRC CAUSE NO E402 OF 2024
Judgment date
25 September 2026
Judge(s)
B. O. M. Manani

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The court rejected the Claimant’s objection to the Respondent’s replying affidavit, declined all interim relief sought in the application dated 27 May 2024, and dismissed that application. Costs of the application were ordered to abide the outcome of the suit. The disputed entitlement to Ksh. 31,174,210 in agency fees remains for determination at the full trial.

Supporting judgment passages

21. Having regard to the foregoing, the court declines to grant the request in the application dated 27th May 2024.

Paragraph 21 →

22. As such, the application is dismissed.

Paragraph 22 →

23. Costs of the application to abide the results of the suit.

Paragraph 23 →
Issue 1Whether the Respondent’s replying affidavit should be struck out for misstating the application date and having been filed and served out of time.

Held. No. The objection was rejected. The incorrect application date was a technical misdescription because the affidavit otherwise addressed the application’s matters. The late filing and service objection had also been settled by the earlier order allowing service out of time.

Ratio. An affidavit may be received despite a misdescription or other formal irregularity, and striking out is confined to an affidavit that is scandalous, irrelevant, or oppressive. Technical objections that do not affect the affidavit’s substance should not defeat its admission.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

15. The court has considered the Claimant’s objection to the replying affidavit in the context of the foresaid provisions of the Constitution and statute. It is apparent that the issue which the Claimant raises concerns a mis-description of the date of the application under consideration in the affidavit. Other than this, the content of the affidavit speaks to the matters which have been raised in the application.

Paragraph 15 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

16. Further, the court record shows that on 27th January 2025, the court allowed the Respondent to serve the Claimant with the affidavit under attack out of time. This, in the court’s view, settled the grievance regarding the late filing and service of the affidavit.

Paragraph 16 →

17. The foregoing demonstrates that the Claimant’s objection to the replying affidavit is purely technical. It does not go to the substance of the affidavit. In the premises, it (the objection) is rejected.

Paragraph 17 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

12. Order 19 of the Civil Procedure Rules deals with affidavit evidence. Rule 7 thereof allows the court to receive in evidence any affidavit notwithstanding apparent defects in it. The rule provides, in particular, as follows:-

Paragraph 12 →

13. Rule 6 of the Order entitles the court to strike out an affidavit only if it is scandalous, irrelevant or oppressive. The Claimant does not raise any of these as the basis for its request to strike out the replying affidavit.

Paragraph 13 →

14. The court is alive to the edict in article 159 (2) (d) of the Constitution to administer justice without undue regard to technicalities. This edict is reiterated under section 20 (1) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act.

Paragraph 14 →
Issue 2Whether the Claimant was entitled, pending trial, to orders compelling resumption and payment of agency-fee deductions and/or requiring the Respondent to deposit Ksh. 31,174,210 in court.

Held. No. The court declined the interim relief and dismissed the application. There were unresolved disputes over whether the Ministerial Order operated retrospectively to 1 July 2021 and whether the CBA remained effective after 30 June 2023. Consequently, it was not clear that the claimed sum was due; that question was left for full trial.

Ratio. A pretrial order compelling payment or deposit of a claimed sum should not issue where the underlying entitlement is unclear because of material disputes requiring determination at a full trial.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

18. Looking at the positions expressed by the parties on the matter under consideration, it is apparent that there is disagreement of interpretation of the CBA between them vis a vis, the Ministerial Order on agency fees which was issued by the Ministry of Labour on 3rd February 2023. According to the Claimant, the Order related back to the effective date of the CBA (1st July 2021). On the other hand, the Respondent’s position is that the Ministry of Labour advised it (the Respondent) that the Order took effect from 3rd February 2023.

Paragraph 18 →

19. It is also apparent that there is disagreement regarding whether the CBA between the parties remained effective after its sunset date. According to the Claimant, it (the CBA) remained effective until a new CBA was agreed on. On the other hand, the Respondent holds the view that the CBA lapsed on its sunset date (30th June 2023) thereby bringing to closure the obligation to continue deducting and remitting the impugned agency fees.

Paragraph 19 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

20. The foregoing being the case, it is apparent that there is no clear case to warrant issuance of an order compelling the Respondent to deposit the impugned sum of Ksh. 31,174,210 in court before trial of the case. Whether this amount is actually due and owing is a matter which can only be determined through full trial of the case.

Paragraph 20 →

21. Having regard to the foregoing, the court declines to grant the request in the application dated 27th May 2024.

Paragraph 21 →

22. As such, the application is dismissed.

Paragraph 22 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

20. The foregoing being the case, it is apparent that there is no clear case to warrant issuance of an order compelling the Respondent to deposit the impugned sum of Ksh. 31,174,210 in court before trial of the case. Whether this amount is actually due and owing is a matter which can only be determined through full trial of the case.

Paragraph 20 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Claimant has instituted these proceedings against the Respondent alleging that the latter improperly failed to deduct and remit to it (the Claimant) agency fees from unionisable employees in line with the Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) between the parties. Accordingly, it (the Claimant) seeks, inter alia, an order that the Respondent be compelled to pay to it (the Claimant) a sum of Ksh. 31,174,210 being the alleged…

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Respondent’s replying affidavit should be struck out for referring to the wrong application date and for late filing; and whether, pending trial, the court should compel the Respondent to deposit in court or remit Ksh. 31,174,210 alleged to be…

Material facts

The parties had a Recognition Agreement and a CBA registered on 28 July 2022, effective from 1 July 2021 to 30 June 2023 or until replaced. The Claimant relied on a Ministerial Order dated 3 February 2023 authorising agency-fee deductions. It alleged that the…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO E402 OF 2024

KENYA UNION OF WATER AND SEWERAGE EMPLOYEES……………………………………………………….CLAIMANT

VERSUS

NAIROBI CITY WATER AND SEWERAGE COMPANY LIMITED…………………………………………...……………RESPONDENT

RULING

Background

1. The Claimant has instituted these proceedings against the Respondent alleging that the latter improperly failed to deduct and remit to it (the Claimant) agency fees from unionisable employees in line with the Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) between the parties. Accordingly, it (the Claimant) seeks, inter alia, an order that the Respondent be compelled to pay to it (the Claimant) a sum of Ksh. 31,174,210 being the alleged outstanding agency fees as at the time of filing suit.

2. Together with the Statement of Claim, the Claimant filed the application dated 27th May 2024 seeking the following interim reliefs:-

a) That the court issues an order to compel the Respondent to resume deduction of agency fees from its (the Respondent’s) employees who are non-members of the Claimant amounting to Ksh. 31,174,210 as at May 2024 and to deposit the money into the Claimant’s account held at the Co-operative Bank.

b) That pending determination of the application and trial of the case, the court compels the Respondent to deposit the aforesaid amount in court.

c) That the court directs that the cause be heard on priority basis.

d) That the court orders the Respondent to bear costs of the application.

3. The application is premised on the grounds appearing on the face thereof. It is also anchored on the supporting and supplementary affidavits of one Elijah Otieno Awach, the Claimant’s General Secretary.

4. The affiant avers that the parties to the action have a subsisting Recognition Agreement. He contends that pursuant to the agreement, the parties negotiated and registered a CBA on 28th July 2022.

5. The affiant avers that the effective date of the CBA was backdated to 1st July 2021 and was to remain in force until 30th June 2023 or until it was replaced by a subsequent CBA. The affiant further avers that the Claimant obtained a Ministerial Order dated 3rd February 2023 which directed and authorized the Respondent to start deducting and remitting agency fees under the CBA.

6. The affiant avers that after the Claimant served the Respondent with the Ministerial Order, the Respondent deducted and remitted the sum of Ksh. 2,390,054 covering the months of August, September, October and November 2023 but stopped further deductions. The affiant contends that the Respondent was supposed to collect the impugned agency fees from 1st July 2021 until the CBA was replaced. As such, he contends that the sum of Ksh. 31,174,210 had not been collected and remitted to the Claimant as at May 2024 and the amount remains outstanding.

7. The affiant avers that the Claimant’s efforts to have the Respondent remit the money have hit a dead end thus necessitating the filing of this suit. He avers that the Respondent has no legitimate reason to continue withholding this money.

8. The Respondent has opposed the application. It has filed a replying affidavit dated 27th December 2024 to anchor its opposition to the motion.

9. The Respondent acknowledges that the parties have a Recognition Agreement and a CBA which was registered as intimated by the Claimant. However, it contends that the Ministerial Order that was served on it directed it to effect deduction of agency fees within 30 days effective 3rd February 2023. As such, it contends that it commenced collection and remittance of agency fees from the aforesaid date.

10. The Respondent avers that the lifespan of the CBA between the parties came to a close on 30th June 2023. As such, it contends that it only collected agency fees from 3rd February 2023 (the date of the Ministerial Order) until 30th June 2023 (the sunset date for the CBA) and remitted the funds to the Claimant. As such, the Respondent denies that there is any agency fees which is still outstanding on account of the impugned CBA.

Analysis

11. The Claimant has challenged the validity and admissibility of the replying affidavit filed by the Respondent on the ground that it refers to a wrong date of the application under consideration and was filed out of time. As such, it prays that the affidavit be struck out.

12. Order 19 of the Civil Procedure Rules deals with affidavit evidence. Rule 7 thereof allows the court to receive in evidence any affidavit notwithstanding apparent defects in it. The rule provides, in particular, as follows:-

‘’The court may receive any affidavit sworn for the purpose of being used in any suit notwithstanding any defect by misdescription of the parties or otherwise in the title or other irregularity in the form thereof or on any technicality.’’

13. Rule 6 of the Order entitles the court to strike out an affidavit only if it is scandalous, irrelevant or oppressive. The Claimant does not raise any of these as the basis for its request to strike out the replying affidavit.

14. The court is alive to the edict in article 159 (2) (d) of the Constitution to administer justice without undue regard to technicalities. This edict is reiterated under section 20 (1) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act.

15. The court has considered the Claimant’s objection to the replying affidavit in the context of the foresaid provisions of the Constitution and statute. It is apparent that the issue which the Claimant raises concerns a mis-description of the date of the application under consideration in the affidavit. Other than this, the content of the affidavit speaks to the matters which have been raised in the application.

16. Further, the court record shows that on 27th January 2025, the court allowed the Respondent to serve the Claimant with the affidavit under attack out of time. This, in the court’s view, settled the grievance regarding the late filing and service of the affidavit.

17. The foregoing demonstrates that the Claimant’s objection to the replying affidavit is purely technical. It does not go to the substance of the affidavit. In the premises, it (the objection) is rejected.

18. Looking at the positions expressed by the parties on the matter under consideration, it is apparent that there is disagreement of interpretation of the CBA between them vis a vis, the Ministerial Order on agency fees which was issued by the Ministry of Labour on 3rd February 2023. According to the Claimant, the Order related back to the effective date of the CBA (1st July 2021). On the other hand, the Respondent’s position is that the Ministry of Labour advised it (the Respondent) that the Order took effect from 3rd February 2023.

19. It is also apparent that there is disagreement regarding whether the CBA between the parties remained effective after its sunset date. According to the Claimant, it (the CBA) remained effective until a new CBA was agreed on. On the other hand, the Respondent holds the view that the CBA lapsed on its sunset date (30th June 2023) thereby bringing to closure the obligation to continue deducting and remitting the impugned agency fees.

20. The foregoing being the case, it is apparent that there is no clear case to warrant issuance of an order compelling the Respondent to deposit the impugned sum of Ksh. 31,174,210 in court before trial of the case. Whether this amount is actually due and owing is a matter which can only be determined through full trial of the case.

Determination

21. Having regard to the foregoing, the court declines to grant the request in the application dated 27th May 2024.

22. As such, the application is dismissed.

23. Costs of the application to abide the results of the suit.

Dated, signed and delivered on the 25th day of September, 2026

B. O. M. MANANI

JUDGE

In the presence of:

…………….for the Claimant

…………….for the Respondent

ORDER

In light of the directions issued on 12th July 2022 by her Ladyship, the Chief Justice with respect to online court proceedings, this decision has been delivered to the parties online with their consent, the parties having waived compliance with Rule 28 (3) of the ELRC Procedure Rules which requires that all judgments and rulings shall be dated, signed and delivered in the open court.

B. O. M MANANI

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder