Constitutional law

Kenya Union of Clinical Officers v Public Service Commission & 4 others [2026] KEELRC 2653 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
CONSTITUTIONAL PETITION NO. E153 OF 2024
Judgment date
25 September 2026
Judge(s)
Jemimah Keli

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The petition partly succeeded. The court held that repeated short-term UHC contracts deliberately circumvented the members’ Article 41 fair-labour rights. It ordered the interested parties to regularise the members’ employment terms and conditions to accord with the Constitution and Employment Act, and to file a progress/compliance report within three months. Each party was to bear its own costs.

Supporting judgment passages

72. In the upshot, the court held that the short-term contracts of 3 years to 1 year given to the members of the petitioner, as directed by the 1st interested party, were a deliberate conduct by the interested parties of circumventing fair labour rights under Article 41 of the Constitution.

Paragraph 72 →

73. I direct and order the interested parties to regularise the petitioner’s members’ employment terms and conditions of service to accord with fair labour practices in accordance with the Constitution and the Employment Act forthwith and, within 3 months, file a report with the court on the progress/compliance.

Paragraph 73 →

74. Each party to bear its own costs in the petition.

Paragraph 74 →
Issue 1Whether there exists an employer-employee relationship between members of the Petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Universal Health Coverage Programme and the Respondents.

Held. Decided. The Ministry of Health was the employer, supported by the Public Service Commission in recruitment. Because counties received the workers and issued contracts as directed by those national entities, the court found a tripartite employment relationship for which national and county governments were jointly and severally responsible.

Ratio. Where the national health authorities recruited and controlled UHC workers’ employment while counties received them and issued directed contracts, the arrangement constituted a tripartite employment relationship attracting joint and several responsibility of the national and county governments.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

a. Whether there exists an employer-employee relationship between members of the Petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Universal Health Coverage Programme and the Respondents.

Passage 758 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

53. I find that from the facts by the petitioner, it was evident that the employer of the clinical officers under the programme is the Ministry of Health supported by the Public Service Commission in the recruitment. The counties received the workers and issued contracts as directed by the 1st and 2nd interested parties. This was a tripartite employment relationship for which both national and county governments must be held jointly and severally responsible. Indeed, it is evident from the affidavit of Makueni County Government that it is the national government, through the 1st and 2nd interested parties, that holds the key to the fate of the long-term employment of the members of the Petitioner. I say no more.

Paragraph 53 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

53. I find that from the facts by the petitioner, it was evident that the employer of the clinical officers under the programme is the Ministry of Health supported by the Public Service Commission in the recruitment. The counties received the workers and issued contracts as directed by the 1st and 2nd interested parties. This was a tripartite employment relationship for which both national and county governments must be held jointly and severally responsible. Indeed, it is evident from the affidavit of Makueni County Government that it is the national government, through the 1st and 2nd interested parties, that holds the key to the fate of the long-term employment of the members of the Petitioner. I say no more.

Paragraph 53 →
Issue 2Whether the Honourable Court can rewrite the fixed term contracts of the members of the Petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Coverage Programme.

Held. Decided. The court held that it could not rewrite the fixed-term contracts. However, it found that the prolonged uncertainty over the UHC workers’ status was an unfair labour practice and ultimately ordered regularisation of their terms and conditions rather than rewriting the contracts.

Ratio. A court does not rewrite fixed-term contracts. But prolonged rolling short-term arrangements that leave workers’ employment status unresolved may deliberately circumvent labour protections and violate Article 41, warranting regularisation consistent with fair labour practices.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

b. Whether the Honourable Court can rewrite the fixed term contracts of the members of the Petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Coverage Programme.

Passage 759 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

54. The court agreed that it cannot rewrite contracts of members of the petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Coverage Programme. The court’s judicial authority is not fettered by the said contracts. The petitioner raised an issue of equal pay for equal work and discrimination as against clinical officers employed by the county public service boards. Unfortunately, no evidence was placed before the court to support the assertions.

Paragraph 54 →

57. The court finds the continued limbo of the fate of the said UHC staff employed under the programme amounts to unfair labour practice. The Ministry of Health and the Public Service Commission owe the said workers a duty of care to direct on their fate in the same way they directed on their recruitment and deployment.

Paragraph 57 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

54. The court agreed that it cannot rewrite contracts of members of the petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Coverage Programme. The court’s judicial authority is not fettered by the said contracts. The petitioner raised an issue of equal pay for equal work and discrimination as against clinical officers employed by the county public service boards. Unfortunately, no evidence was placed before the court to support the assertions.

Paragraph 54 →

61. I hold that the short-term arrangements for a continued long period for the UHC workers are a deliberate circumvention of labour protections; and it violates the right to fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution. The Ministry of Health, as the initial employer, has failed to provide directions on the employment terms of the said UHC programme workers, and thus cannot escape responsibility.

Paragraph 61 →
Issue 3Whether the Respondents violated the right to fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution and national labour standards.

Held. Decided. Yes. The short-term arrangements, initially for three years and then one year, over a continued period were held to be a deliberate circumvention of labour protections and a violation of Article 41. The Ministry of Health, as initial employer, failed to provide directions on the workers’ employment terms and could not escape responsibility.

Ratio. An employer cannot retain workers in prolonged rolling short-term arrangements as a means of avoiding labour protections. Such conduct violates the constitutional right to fair labour practices, particularly where it leaves workers’ employment status uncertain after long service.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

c. Whether the Respondents violated the right to fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution and national labour standards.

Passage 760 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

60. I upheld the above Court of Appeal decision to apply in the instant case. The court condemns the 1st interested party's act of recommending short-term contracts for workers under the Ministry of Health UHC programme, thereby circumventing the said workers' right to fair labour practices. The 1st interested party is responsible for ensuring fair labour practices across the public service. The 2nd interested party had a duty to issue the relevant directions sought in the letter of the Makueni County Government dated 26th August 2025 regarding the employment of workers under its programme.

Paragraph 60 →

61. I hold that the short-term arrangements for a continued long period for the UHC workers are a deliberate circumvention of labour protections; and it violates the right to fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution. The Ministry of Health, as the initial employer, has failed to provide directions on the employment terms of the said UHC programme workers, and thus cannot escape responsibility.

Paragraph 61 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

60. I upheld the above Court of Appeal decision to apply in the instant case. The court condemns the 1st interested party's act of recommending short-term contracts for workers under the Ministry of Health UHC programme, thereby circumventing the said workers' right to fair labour practices. The 1st interested party is responsible for ensuring fair labour practices across the public service. The 2nd interested party had a duty to issue the relevant directions sought in the letter of the Makueni County Government dated 26th August 2025 regarding the employment of workers under its programme.

Paragraph 60 →

61. I hold that the short-term arrangements for a continued long period for the UHC workers are a deliberate circumvention of labour protections; and it violates the right to fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution. The Ministry of Health, as the initial employer, has failed to provide directions on the employment terms of the said UHC programme workers, and thus cannot escape responsibility.

Paragraph 61 →
Issue 4Whether the Respondents’ actions violated the principle of equality and non-discrimination under Article 27 of the Constitution.

Held. Decided. No discrimination was proved. The petitioner did not adduce evidence establishing that its members were paid less than comparable peers or otherwise treated discriminatorily; it bore the burden of proof.

Ratio. An allegation of unequal pay or discriminatory treatment must be supported by evidence. Without proof of the asserted differential treatment, the court cannot find discrimination under Article 27.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

d. Whether the Respondents’ actions violated the principle of equality and non-discrimination under Article 27 of the Constitution.

Passage 761 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

62. I found no evidence to prove the allegation of less pay to the members of the petitioner than their peers employed by the respondents. The petitioner had the burden of proving discrimination. I upheld the instant case the above decision of the Court of Appeal (Embu County Government) where it was held-

Paragraph 62 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

62. I found no evidence to prove the allegation of less pay to the members of the petitioner than their peers employed by the respondents. The petitioner had the burden of proving discrimination. I upheld the instant case the above decision of the Court of Appeal (Embu County Government) where it was held-

Paragraph 62 →
Issue 5Whether the Respondents/interested parties’ actions breached the Petitioner’s right to fair administrative action under Article 47 of the Constitution.

Not reached

Held. Not reached. Although the court listed Article 47 as an issue, it made no separate substantive finding or order on a breach of fair administrative action; its dispositive finding concerned Article 41 fair-labour rights.

Ratio. This issue was not decided. No separate Article 47 determination was articulated.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

e. Whether the Respondents/interested parties’ actions breached the Petitioner’s right to fair administrative action under Article 47 of the Constitution.

Passage 762 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

72. In the upshot, the court held that the short-term contracts of 3 years to 1 year given to the members of the petitioner, as directed by the 1st interested party, were a deliberate conduct by the interested parties of circumventing fair labour rights under Article 41 of the Constitution.

Paragraph 72 →
Issue 6Whether the Petitioner is entitled to the relief sought.

Held. Decided in part. The court ordered regularisation of the members’ employment terms and conditions and a compliance report within three months. It declined gratuity because the relied-on Gazette Notice was not annexed and the contracts were complete on their terms; it could not decide the requested declaration concerning the IGRTC deliberations because their record was absent; and it made no NSSF-remittance order because remittance was already a statutory duty and no non-compliance was proved. Each party bore its own costs.

Ratio. Regularisation was warranted to remedy the Article 41 violation. Mandamus cannot compel a public body to exercise a discretionary duty in a particular manner, especially where that would entail budgetary appropriation. Requested relief also requires supporting evidence; a court will not grant relief based on an unproduced instrument or unproven non-compliance.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

f. Whether the Petitioner is entitled to the relief sought.

Passage 763 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

67. It is my finding that the law places an obligation on 1st interested party to deal with grievances on employment of all public officers under their jurisdiction. The Ministry of Health is the owner of the programme in which the petitioner's members are employed. The court noted that it was undisputed that the Ministry of Health circular dated 2nd April 2024 requested approval from the Public Service Commission on transition UHC Clinical Officers. I adopt the order by the Court of Appeal in Kenya County Government Workers' Union v Embu County Government & another [2026] KECA 1481 (KLR) as a relief to the grievance on the employment status of the workers under the UHC programme and order as follows- I direct and order the interested parties to regularize the petitioner’s members’ employment terms and conditions of service to accord with fair labour practices in accordance with the Constitution and the Employment Act forthwith and within 3 months file a report of the court on the progress.

Paragraph 67 →

69. I did not find the record of the deliberations made in the Intergovernmental Relations Technical Committee (IGRTC) summit on 24th of March 2023 thus was unable to make any decision on the same.

Paragraph 69 →

70. The court finds that the employer had a duty to comply with deductions and to remit them as required. The court need not make such an order as it is a statutory duty and there is no evidence before the court of non-compliance.

Paragraph 70 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

66. The 12th respondent on the order of Mandamus sought submitted that the Court cannot compel budgetary appropriation without violating the principle of separation of powers. It relied on Kenya National Examination Council v Republic ex parte Geoffrey Gathenji Njoroge [1997] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal held that an order of mandamus cannot compel a public body to perform a duty in a specific way where the law leaves discretion as to the mode of performance. I agreed with the submission.

Paragraph 66 →

68. I did not find the Gazette Notice in the annexures to the petition. I decline to make the order as the members of the petitioner hold contracts of employment, and the respondents had been guided on how to remunerate them. The contracts had terms of service and are complete on their own.

Paragraph 68 →

70. The court finds that the employer had a duty to comply with deductions and to remit them as required. The court need not make such an order as it is a statutory duty and there is no evidence before the court of non-compliance.

Paragraph 70 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Petitioner is a registered trade union with a mandate to represent the interests of clinical officers on employment and labour relations matters pursuant to the Labour Relations Act. The petitioner commenced this suit vide an Amended Petition dated 26th May 2025 seeking:-

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The 1st Interested Party avers that there is no employer employee relationship between it and the Petitioner's members, hence the issue of discrimination by the employer is denied. The 1st Interested Party also opposes the claim of discrimination against the Petitioner’s members on the premise that no evidence has been adduced showing that a different group of health workers were treated differentially and favourably. They also deny…

Paragraph 22 →

Decision / orders

I direct and order the interested parties to regularise the petitioner’s members’ employment terms and conditions of service to accord with fair labour practices in accordance with the Constitution and the Employment Act forthwith and, within 3 months, file a report with the court on the progress/compliance.

Paragraph 73 →

Reasoning passage

The court finds that the parties are in agreement on issues for determination which the court concluded were as follows-

Paragraph 49 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the UHC clinical officers’ employment relationship lay with the national government, county governments, or both; whether the court could rewrite their fixed-term contracts; whether repeated short-term engagement violated Article 41; whether…

Material facts

The petitioner union represented clinical officers recruited for the Ministry of Health Universal Health Coverage (UHC) Programme during the COVID-19 period, deployed to counties, and retained through successive contracts. It alleged that they performed…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CONSTITUTIONAL PETITION NO. E153 OF 2024

IN THE MATTER OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA, 2010

AND

IN THE MATTER OF THE ALLEGED CONTRAVENTION AND VIOLATION OF

ARTICLES 6(2) (3), 19, 21(1), 23(1) (3), 27(1) (2), 41, 43, 47(1) AND 174 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA, 2010

AND

IN THE MATTER OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA (PROTECTION OF RIGHTS

AND FUNDAMENTAL FREEDOMS) PRACTICE AND

PROCEDURE RULES, 2013

BETWEEN

KENYA UNION OF CLINICAL OFFICERS……………………………………...PETITIONER

-VERSUS-

PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION……….……………………..………...…1ST RESPONDENT

MINISTRY OF HEALTH……………………………………………….……2ND RESPONDENT

THE COUNCIL OF GOVERNORS…..……………………………………....3RD RESPONDENT

THE HONOURABLE ATTORNEY GENERAL…..………...….………...…4TH RESPONDENT

AND

THE SALARIES AND REMUNERATION COMMISSION……….……INTERESTED PARTY

CORAM

Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli

C/A Otieno

JUDGMENT

Introduction

1. The Petitioner is a registered trade union with a mandate to represent the interests of clinical officers on employment and labour relations matters pursuant to the Labour Relations Act. The petitioner commenced this suit vide an Amended Petition dated 26th May 2025 seeking:-

a) An order of MANDAMUS be issued directing the Ministry of Health, Council of Governors, Public Service Commission, Salaries and Remuneration Commission, and the National Treasury to immediately initiate the process of transitioning all the clinical officers currently under the UHC programme as per the circular issued by the Ministry of Health, Ref No. SDPH&PS.1/1/170 dated 2nd of April 2024 and remunerate them as per the SRC guidelines without discrimination.

b) An order of MANDAMUS be issued directing the 47 Respondents and the Ministry of Health to pay gratuities for all the four-years served by the clinical officers under the Universal Health programme contract as per the gazette notice No. 8091 dated 12th October 2020.

c) A DECLARATION that the deliberations made in the Intergovernmental Relations Technical Committee (IGRTC) summit on 24th of March 2023 are unconstitutional and unlawful as they violate the principle of “equal pay for equal work” and have prevented the transitioning of terms of UHC clinical officers to permanent and pensionable terms.

d) An order of MANDAMUS compelling the 47 Respondents and the Ministry of Health to remit all the already deducted NSSF contribution for the UHC clinical officers.

e) This Honourable Court be pleased to issue any other orders that it may deem fit and just to ensure that the rule of law is upheld.

f) Costs of this petition.

2. The Amended Petition was filed alongside the Verifying Affidavit of ISAAC NKAPIANI sworn on 30th September 2024, with the bundle of documents in support of the Petition attached. The Petitioner later filed a Further Affidavit sworn by GEORGE M. GIBORE on 24th June 2025 with a further bundle of documents attached.

3. In response to the Amended Petition, the 1st Interested Party filed a Response dated 25th March 2025. On their part, the 12th Respondent, Kiambu County Government, filed Grounds of Opposition dated 13th April 2026; while the 22nd Respondent, the Makueni County Government, filed a Replying Affidavit sworn by REDEMPTA KAVINDU on 22nd May 2026.

The Petitioner’s case in summary

4. The Petitioner’s case is that in April 2020, a group of health workers were recruited by the Public Service Commission on behalf of the National Government under a one-year Universal Health Coverage internship contract which was meant to assist in the achievement of Universal Health Care as well as aid in the fight against COVID-19. Specifically, in June 2020, at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, the Ministry of Health employed approximately 9,000 workers on a three-year UHC contract at a consolidated salary of Ksh. 50,000 for Diploma Holders and Ksh. 100,000 for Degree Holders, and deployed them to different County Governments. The list per County of the Clinical Officers Serving under Universal Health Coverage (UHC) are: -

BARINGO COUNTY

1. JOHN KIPTOO

2. ELIJAH SIRMA

3. FRIDAH SORNO

4. ALEX NGENY

5. HOSEA BARASEL

6. WILSON MABATUK

7. BETHWEL KIBET

8. SAMWEL KIPROP

9. JAMES KOECH

10. METRINE KIMOSOP

11. PATZY CHEPKETE

12. DEBORA TANUI

13. JONES LEMARKOKO

14. MARY MOROGO

15. VALENTINE YATOR

16. ROSE KORIR

17. JULIA KIPROP

18. PETER BARASA

19. HOSEA RUGUT

NAIROBI COUNTY

1. MAUREEN AKOTH OLOO

2. JACQUELINE NYOKABI MUCHIRI

3. TERENCE WANJALA

4. PATRICK KINOTI MUTHUURI

5. JOAN CHEMOS

6. HARRISON G. MUCHOKI

7. DICKSON MURIGI

8. MARY KERANDI

9. PETER GICHURU WANJOHI

10. LILIAN AGANDA

11. MWITA JOEL DANIEL

TANA RIVER COUNTY

1. KIAGE MEDINA KERUBO

2. MAKAMBI ANNAH BIYAKI

3. KAINGU ALFRED SAMINI

4. MUTIE VINCENT MUTUA

5. HASSAN FARAJ ABDISHEIKH

6. FURUMATA MOSES HERO

7. CHIMMEGAH CHRISTIAN SADIKI

8. AYAKO TABITHA BITUTU

9. ONTIRI ESINA NYANGARA

10. ODUGE AUSTINE ODHIAMBO

11. ASSOR EDDY HARO

12. BAHAMISH ABUBAKAR ALI

13. JILLO BRIAN BUYA

14. MASESE JOASH OMWENO

15. WADESA FATUMA TULIA

16. NGIGI SOLOMON NGOROGE

17. JACINTA KAIDZA KAHINDI

18. WAWIRE NEWTON KAKAI

19. WAMBUI ANNE NYOKABI

20. BARISA OMAR MARO

21. ANNO MARY MBUTA

22. UMURU EMILY NKANDUNGU

23. KOMORA HUNTER SAKASO

24. ELLY VIKAMBA SHIMBIRA

MURANG’A COUNTY

1. GIATI BEATRICE WANJIRU

2. MUCHIRI GEOFFREY MAINA

3. KAHIRO EVERLYNE NJAMBI

4. NJARAMBA ELIZABETH WANJIRU

5. KAMANDE SAMUEL MWANGI

6. NONKEPA WINNIE NJERI

7. THUMBI WINNIE WANJIRU

8. KARANJA MARTIN MUIRURI

9. NJOROGE ESTHER WANJIRU

10. KARANJA PETER MICHUKI

11. KIBOI DORIS NYAKWEA

12. MWANGI STEPHEN KARANJA

13.THIONG’O FRANCIS MACHECHA

14. WACHIRA ESTHER NYAMBURA

15. MOI EMMA MORAA

16. MUCHOKI LOISE WAIRIMU

17. MUIGAI NAOMI NJERI

18. GOKO MARYLYNE WAHURA

19. KIHUMBA EUNICE WANJIRU

20. NDULWA BENEDICT MUTISYA

21. GOKO MARYLYNE WAHURA

TAITA TAVETA COUNTY

1. MERCY KALUNDA

2. JACKLINE MCHILI

3. KELVIN MGHULO

4. NICHOLUS MBOGHO

5. JENTA MKALA

6. CHRISTINE MWASARU

7. ISABELLA MWAMBURI

8. GLADYS MWAMBURI

9. JUSTUS KANYINGINYI

10. VALENTINE NYANGE

KILIFI COUNTY

1. CAROLYNE DZAME HEBA

2. DAVID TUMAINI KITSAO

3. AKIBA KALUGHO JACOB

4. MOSES MRABU TUNE

5. ANNA KAZOSI CHENGO

6. MACKLINE KASENA THOYA

7. ROSE SYOMBUA KAMUYA

8. ABEL NZAI LWEMBE

9. FRIDA DAMA KAHINDI

10. HANNINGTON KAMOTI MWANDENGE

11. GIFT KENGA KARISA

12. JAMES NDAA KALUME

13. ERIC MUNGA KAI

14. ABDILLAHI ALI ABDALLA

15. PURITY MAPENZI HARRISON

16. AMANI NZARO DANIEL SHEHE

17. LENOX LEWA MBAGA

KWALE COUNTY

1. SAMUEL CHIGUMBA NYAE

2. RAMADHAN NDURYA JOTO

3. NURU MWAMBOGA NYAUME

4. RAMADHAN HAMISI BALUNA

5. MICHAEL MRABU KOMBO

6. ATHUMAN RAJAB NGALA

7. CHARLES CHIGODI NYAE

8. MANONO ALI MWANZORI

9. MEALI ALI NYAA

10. ATHUMANI OMARI NGOE

11. MUDZO SALIM MWAMAYUGO

12. HAMISI DZERI MONGOLO

13. NASSORO RAJAB CHANJARI

MERU COUNTY

1. EMILY NTONJIRA

2. BONFACE KAINGA

3. NELSON KIMATHI

4. PIUS MUNGATHIA

5. CAROLINE GATWIRI

6. LUCY KANANU

7. JUDY MUTWIRI

8. MBEERIA TIMOTHY

9. EVAH MUTHONI

10. CATHERINE GITHENDU

11. JUDITH KATHURE

12. RONNY MUTAI

13. DENNIS RIUNGU

14. MILLICENT GAKII

15. JOHN NGEERA

16. PATRICK MUTHURI

17. MUGIRA PETER

18. LUCY KANORIO

19. SALLY KABURU

20. FRIDAH KINYA

21. MAKENA ISAAC

22. NELLY MBURUGU

KITUI COUNTY

1. GABRIEL MUTINDA

2. ELIZABETH KALAU MUTAMBU

3. FRANCIS NGUMA

4. TITUS NGUI

5. ROBERT MUTUA

6. MARTIN MUIA

7. DAVID OLANDO OMUSIKOYE

8. ANDREW MUTUA

9. BRIDGET MWENDWA

10. ERIC KIOKO

11. RHODA NYAGA

12. MIKE NDAMBUKI

13. JACINTA BRAMWEL

14. LUCY IVUTI

KIRINYAGA COUNTY

1. BANCY WANJIRA KARIUKI

2. MOSES MURIITHI

3. TERESA MUTHONI MURIITHI

4. LUCY KINYUA

5. JOHN MITHAMO

6. KENNEDY KINYUA WAWERU

7. GRACE WAMBUI NDIRANGU

8. ELEMINIA WANJIKU

9. CHARLES MWANGI

10. ABDIQAFAR ISSAK

11. PHILIS MURIITHI

12. JOSHUA JUMA

13. IMMACULATE NYAWIRA MUTHIKE

VIHIGA COUNTY

1. OBURA MOSES AMBWAYA

2. KIRADA CHURCHIL

3. MUKENYE IRENE

4. ODUORY EVANS OWINO

5. ABULI WILLIAM

6. MWAYI BRENDA MUHONJA

7. OTUNGA PAULINE ROSEMARY

8. NANDI SHARON KAGEHA

9. ALIONA BOAZ MUDENYU

10. ONGAYA BRILLIAN NGATI

11. OSIDE MILLYCENT OBINDI

12. MASWAJE HILDA

13. AFUNE JOHNSTONE MUHANJI

WEST POKOT COUNTY

1. SHADRACK RENGETEE

2. BENSON KORINGURA

3. ELPHAS KIPTOO

4. DAMARIS CHERUTO

5. GLORIA KAKUKO

6. HILDAH CHEMASUET

7. DAVID TANUI

8. MBAKA WRIGHT

9. NELLY LOKWAKIT

10. CHIRCHIR ENOCH

11. JAIRUS RUTO

12. GRACE NGURIATUDO

13. KORLEM JOSEPH

14. JEREMIAH PKEMOI

15. FEDDY TONYIRWO

UASIN GISHU COUNTY

1. JOAN LEMISO

2. NAHASHON MATELONG

3. JOHN TANUI

4. JAEL CHEPTOO

5. REUBEN LIMO

6. CONSTANTINE JERUTO

7. KENETH METRO

8. MARION TUTTO

9. NICK LAGAT

10. ELSY JEPKOSGEI

11. JUDITH KIBOS

12. DOMINIC KEMBOI

13. EDWIN KOGO

14. ANDREW KIPTUI

WAJIR COUNTY

1. MOHAMED HABASOW

2. BISHARA ALI ABEY

3. ABDI NOOR MOHAMED

4. UGAZ KASIM

5. ALI ADAN

6. MOHAMED SALAT

7. OMAR ALI

NAROK COUNTY

1. DANIEL MATHENGE GICHUKI

2. ISAAC NKAPIANI

3. BOWEN LEONARD

4. LUCY MALASO

5. DANIEL SIMEL NKARABALI

6. SOKOINE LEKURUON ALLAN

7. CHEPKORIR GEORGINA

8. MERITEI TIKANI

9. VICTOR LETUYA KIMIRINY

10. LUCY NAILATEI KOOKE

11. VALENTINE CHEPKEMOI TUM

12. BENARD KIPKORIR CHERUIYOT

13. ESHO NAMUNYAK BEATRICE

14. MURIRA ANNE WAMAITHA

MARSABIT COUNTY

1. MOHAMMED GALMAGAR

2. ABDI HALKANO GODANA

3. MOHAMED ALI

4. ARBE MOLU

5. GUYO GIRO SORA

6. ROBINSON EKUMBA KASAMANI

7. BORU SORA JILLO

8. FARAH AHMED ABDI

9. AHMED GOLLO SORA

10. AMINA HUSSEIN MOHAMED

11. WOCHE WOSHE

12. GUYO JARSO MEKONA

13. ANTONY ABDUB BASHUNA

14. MOHAMED AMIN

NYANDARUA COUNTY

1. JULIA WANGARI MAINA

2. MARY MENYI KANGATA

3. RICHARD WANDIGA WAWERU

4. EMILY WANJIKU KIMANI

5. STEPHEN KURIA GITUNDU

6. FRANCIS KIRERU

7. FARIDA KAVUTHA KITHUMBI

8. TABITHA NJERI NJOROGE

9. SALOME WANGUI NDURUNGO

10. MIRIAM WANJIKU KIRAGU

11. MIDIAN WANJIKU KAMAU

12. SAMUEL GATOTO KIHARA

13. ESTER WANJIKU NJENGA

14. JEDIDAH MUMBI MURAGE

15. JULIANA MUTHONI WANGOMBE

16. JOHN NGIGI GICHUKI

17. MARTIN MUNENE KINOTI

18. HANNAH WANJIRU NDEGWA

19. DANCAN MWAURA KARIMA

20. SAMSON KIHUGA IRUNGU

NAKURU COUNTY

1. JACKLINE WANJIRA NDERITU

2. KIBET DAISY JERUTO

3. JANET ANYANGO MUTIMBA

4. NANCY KERUBO

5. LILIAN CHEPCHIRCHIR

6. SANG MATHEW KIPKEMOI

7. RAHAB G NJOKI NJUE

8. MERCY CHERONO RUTO

9. NAOMY GATHONI KURIA

10. JAMES NJUGUNA

11. BENJAMIN KURIA

12. ROSE C. ROTICH

13. REUBEN MWIRIGI KINUTHIA

14. DOROTHY CHEMUTAI

15. NAOMI SAFARI

16. SITIENEI KENNEDY KIPKEMOI

17. DOMINIC SHIVONJE

18. CATHERINE KIMANI

19. SAMUEL NDUNGU

20. LELA CHEBET

21. FRANK LOKWAM

22. JOSEPH MUNGAI

23. CELILIA NJOKI KEFA

BUSIA COUNTY

1. HUMPHREY EKAMURAN ORACHI

2. NEWTON ALUBALA

3. BRENDA AKINYI OKOLA

4. MICHAEL HARRISON NDUDE

5. JUDITH NABWIRE

6. JUSTUS OMUSIKOYO MAKOKHA

7. LINUS OWIRE JUMA

8. KENETH KICHWANG'I ILUKU

9. TEDDY LUGENDO ADUNDO

10. GODWIN WANDERA

11. EDWIN JUMA

12. LINET WANAMBIRO

13. DUNCAN OMETA OPILI

14. BENTA NEKESA WECHULI

15. JOAN BARASA INYOKOPE

BUNGOMA COUNTY

1. ALIAS SAM MTAI

2. AMBROSE MUKHOLI

3. HOLYN KIRUI

4. JOEL BWAYO

5. DAISY NZIOKA

6. CAROLYNE WENDO

7. KEVIN NYAMARI

8. CLARE BIKOKWA

9. GABRIEL WANYAMA

10. DUNCAN NYONGESA

11. BRIAN WEKESA

12. VICTORIA NJERI

13. CLAIRE WAKOLI

14. SERAPHINE MWONGULA

15. ASHTONE WANYONYI

16. GEORGEADIS MUKHAWANA

17. MATANDA BENSON

18. MARTIN NDONG'A

MACHAKOS COUNTY

1. DENNIS KILONZO

2. JOHNSON MUTUA

3. FRANCIS MUTUKU

4. FAITH KIMEU

5. EDITH KALONDU

6. MAGGIE MUSYOKI

7. NAOMI MWENDE

8. VICTORIA MUNYAO

9. BRIAN MANTHI

10. DENIS OTWAL

11. VASCALYNE MWANGANGI

12. CATHERINE WAMBUA

13. JACINTA NZILANI

14. CARO NZISA

KIAMBU COUNTY

1. GLADYS MUTHONI NJOROGE

2. JOSEPH NDUNGU NJERI

3. PASCALYN WANGECHI KOINE

4. DAVID MWANGI MACHARIA

5. MARYANN WANJIRU MUTHEE

6. MBUTHIA MONICAH NJERI

7. KAMORE KELVIN THIGA

8. QUEENTER NOLLINE WASONGA

9. LILIAN NJERI KARUMBI

10. JOYCE MUTHONI WAINOI

11. SYLVIA WANJIRU NGUNJIRI

12. ZIPPORAH WAITHIRA GATUBI

13. HELLEN WANGUI KIMANI

LAMU COUNTY

1. LINDA WAIRIMA WAITIKI

2. ADAN HABIBA ALI

3. NGANGA ERICK GITAU

4. CHARO NICHOLAS SHUKURU

5. AWADH IDDEH SALIM

6. NJAGI GERALD MAINA

7. WINSTONE SABWA

8. RANDU KITHI KARISA

9. OSETE BENSON LILUMBE

10. MASOUD KHADIJA ALI

11. MOHAMED ISMAIL SALIM

MOMBASA COUNTY

1. RUKIA SAIDI ZUBERI

2. HABIBA MOHAMED JIMMY

3. MAXMILLA NTHENYA JIMMY

4. REUBEN MAGANDE

5. OLIVER WAFULA KISIANGANI

6. SULEIMAN BAJEBI

7. ELIJAH MWAI

8. LAURENT KISINGO

THARAKA NITHI COUNTY

1. JAPHET MWENDA MUMBERE

2. ASHFORD MUNENE PETER

3. ALICE MUTHONI KAMWARA

4. EUNICE KANINI GITI

5. ISAAC MUNENE MURIUKI

6. JUDY MAKENA KAIBUNG'A

7. SHARON WAHITO WACHIRA

8. LYNN NKATHA GITONGA

9. DOLLY KARENDI MIRITI

10. YVONNE GATWIRI GITONGA

11. KENNETH MUTWIRI MUGAMBI

12. DAMARIS KATHAMBI SAMUEL

13. BENSON MUTHENGI MUTISYA

14. ERIC MWENDA GITONGA

15. FRIDAH GAKII

16. JANET K KABIRA

17. MERCY MUTHONI MUTEGI

18. PETER MUTEMI NJOKA

19. SARAH KAGENDO MUNYUA

20. SILAS MWANIKI GITARI

21. STEPHEN MUTHURE MICHENI

22. ZACHARY GITONGA KATHUNI

23. VIOLET GATWIRI MBAKA

KAKAMEGA COUNTY

1. HAJI WASICHE OMULAHA

2. DANIEL KASAMANI WANGULU

3. ADAM KAULA KANDAWALA

4. LUCY ESHUCHI ALWANG'A

5. MAUREEN NDAKALA WERE

6. GEORGE ISIAHO ROBERT

7. BRENDA KHABWANDISA ANAMI

8. PHEOBE AKOYI

9. CHRISTINE TIMINA ONGOCHE

10. LINDAH NASIMIYU OKAVA

11. ISAIAH BAINITO

12. ROSE MAKOKHA KWEYU

13. LINUS ASHIOYA

14. JANE OTIENO ORWA

15. COLLINS AVEMBE AZENGA

TURKANA COUNTY

1. FLORENCE STEPHANY AKOTH OLOO.

2. DENNIS KIPCHUMBA KIPROTICH

3. OPURA VINCENT LIKUYI

4. VINCENT KIPKEMOI SIGEI

5. CHEPKEMBOI JANIFFER

6. JOSEPHAT ORIEKO.

7. DORIS NANYAMA

8. OSCAR ADEGO.

9. WILFRED OMBUI.

10. LEAH KERUBO ONTOBO

11. BEATRICE MWALE MACHANJA

12. SHEILA KAIBEI

13. SHEILA JERONO.

14. JOYCE AKHARAN BENDERA

NYAMIRA COUNTY

1. LOYCE KEMUNTOH ONYANCHA

2. RHODAH NYABOKE AMWOMA

3. DOROTHY MORAA NYAMWEYA

4. BENARD OSORO ABUYA

5. GEOFFREY O. OSORO

6. BENSON NYAMWEYA

7. KEN MASARA

8. JUSTINE MARIITA GEKE

9. JANET MORAA

10. EDNA OCHOKI

11. HARRISON OBWOCHA

12. BRENDON BUKO

13. GEORGE GWAKO

14. DOLYPHINE MON'GINA MOMANYI

15. PETER ORINA

16. RATUMO CAROLINE

17. VICTOR GESORA MAGABI

18. ALBERT MIGIRO

19. KEVIN NYABUTO

20. VICTOR MAGABI

KISII COUNTY

1. NYANUSI DENFORD NYANUSI

2. KELVIN RICHARD

3. MOMANYI CALVIN

4. KENYORU PACIFICAH NYANCHOKA

5. NYAIRO ELLA NYANG'ARA

6. OMWENGA FAITH BOSIBORI

7. MANDO NATHAN ONGERI

8. KEROSI IGNATIUS MARIITA

9. KAYAGO MILLICENT MORAA

10. OMBATI ERICK M

11. MOTURI DOUGLAS ABERR

12. MOGEKE DORCAS NYARINDA

13. MOSE EDWIN OMBUI

14. OMAMBIA BONFACE BICHANG'A

15. MACHUKA VANE MOIGE "RESIGNED"

16. OMBONGI ERIC MAMWANCHA

17. OMARI ANDREW MANDERE "RESIGNED"

SAMBURU COUNTY

1. LINDA LIMO

2. RONALD MURWANI

3. EBISIBA MOKEIRA

4. ELIJAH KIPTOO KIMELI

5. KIPKORIR KIRUI

6. CHERUTICH CHIRCHIR NGETUNY

7. ZAKAYO MOMANYI ONDIEKI

8. THOMAS LENANGARIMA

9. PATRICIA NYAWIRA

10. LEMETEKI JAMES

11. BRUNO SAMMY KAIMENYI

12. PETER WASWA

13. SYLVESTER MUREI

BOMET COUNTY

1. BENINA CHEPKOECH

2. BII SIMION KIBET

3. ABRAHAM KIPRONO BENGAT

4. KOECH KIPKORIR

5. ECITY CHEPKOECH

6. CHEPKOECH KORIR

7. MISPER CHERONO

8. CHEPNGENO LILIAN KOECH

9. MUTAI KIPKEMOI GEOFFREY

10. PERIS CHEPKEMOI

11. WALTER CHERUIYOT

12. CHEPKOECH MERCY

13. CHARLES KIPNGETICH BETT

14. JESSICA CHEPKEMOI

15. DORIS CHEROTICH

16. BETTY CHEPKORIR MITEI

MIGORI COUNTY

1. MAROA JOSHUA MOSETI

2. PRESTOLINE ANYANGO OTIENO

3. PAMELA NYAGA

4. EVERLYNE AWUOR

5. EMILY WAFULA

6. ORAGO VICTOR

7. KENNEDY OCHIENG

8. JOSEPH OBIMBO

9. WAMBURA CALEB PAUL

10. RUTH MADO

11. CHARLES MATIKO MASAITE.

12. KEVIN NDISIO

13. ROBERT CHACHA

14. ALLAN ODHIAMBO

15. HANINGTON OGALO

16. WYCLIFFE OMONDI

17. GEOFREY MBOGO

KERICHO COUNTY

1. KEMBOI HILLARY

2. LOICE CHEBET

3. FANCY CHELANGAT

4. GEOFFREY KIPKEMOI

5. HOSEA MUTAI

6. MIKE KIPKORIR KIRUI

7. DENIS RUTO

8. HAWKINS ALINGO

9. RONALD KIMUTAI

ELGEYO MARAKWET COUNTY

1. FELIX NGETICH

2. JUSTUS KEMBOI

3. DAVID KIBOR

4. KORIR BENARD

5. PATRICK KIGEN

6. HENRY CHEBII

7. SILAS KIRWA

8. MAURINE CHESIR

9. LYDIA J KULEI

10. TIMOTHY KIMAIYO

11. NANCY KIPTOO

12. ROBERT KIPROP

13. LILIAN BIWOTT

14. EVANS RUTO

15. ERUSTUS KOECH

16. GILBERT KIPRONO

17. ANNALYNE KIBET

18. MATHEW KOSGEI

KISUMU COUNTY

1. SHARON AKINYI NYAORO

2. BRIAN ONYANGO MBOYA

3. PETER OUMA ABUTO

4. ADRIANNE WINNIE

5. JACK OWUOR OTIENO

6. JESCA AKINYI OWINO

7. SYLVIA ATIENO OTIENO

8. TEREZAH OTIENO

9. DIANA OKETCH

10. ABWAO WICKLIFFE

11. VICTOR OKUL

12. OKELLO DENNIS OUMA

13. CORRINE OPOT AKOTH

14. GEOFREY ODIYO AGIE

15. VINCENT OTIENO OUKO

16. DIBORAH ANYANGO OYOO

17. NGESA GEORGE MICHAEL

18. OCHINGA GODFREY OCHIENG

19. EMMANUEL IMANY OKUTA

20. KELVIN ONGINJO OCHIENG

21. BEATRICE AUMA OCHIENG

NYERI COUNTY

1. ZIPPORAH WANGUI THUA.

2. BEVERLYN NDUTA VERAH

3. PETER MARUNGO MAINA

4. ELIZABETH WANJIRU NDIRANGU

5. CAROLINE WANJIRU GIKUNJU

6. JOYCE WANGECI GITONGA

7. MARY WANJIKU MUTURI

8. JAMES WACHIHI NDIRANGU

9. PAUL WAHOME MWANGI

10. CATHERINE WANGARI WATURU

11. JACQUELINE WAWIRA GICHOVI

12. REBECCA WANGUI MUTHUI

13. CHRISTINE WANJIRU NDIRANGU

14. NEWTON MUTIGA GIKIRI

15. ROSE WANJIRU NJOROGE

16. JOYCE WANGUI MAINA

17. ANNE WANGECI GATHONGO

18. MORIS WERU KAGIA

BARINGO COUNTY

1. JOHN KIPTOO

2. ELIJAH SIRMA

3. FRIDAH SORNO

4. ALEX NGENY

5. HOSEA BARASEL

6. WILSON MABATUK

7. BETHWEL KIBET

8. SAMWEL KIPROP

9. JAMES KOECH

10. METRINE KIMOSOP

11. PATZI CHEPKETE

12. DEBORA TANUI

13. JONES LEMARKOKO

14. MARY MOROGO

15. VALENTINE YATOR

16. ROSE KORIR

17. JULIA KIPROP

LAIKIPIA COUNTY

1. OBONGO EVELYN

2. GIVONDO SAMUEL

3. GITHONGO PATRICIA

4. MUTHEE RACHEL

5. EUNICE KIRWA

6. MWONGERA JACKLINE

7. BUNDOTICH KIPROTICH

8. MACHARIA PETER

9. RITA MUTHIORA

10. MBURU ERASTUS

11. KIBE PATRICK

12. MWANU PURITY

13. NJERI DAMARIS

14. KIMANI EARNEST

15. GUYO SALAD

16. GACUGA ANTHONY

17. ELAMAN EMANUEL

TRANS-NZOIA COUNTY

1. FRED SIMIYU WAFULA

2. DIANA MUTHONI KITIYO

3. ERIC NGEYWO

4. EDWIN MARANGO

5. EZEKIEL MASIKA WESONGA

6. SAMUEL WANYOIKE

7. ANDREW WANJEKEJE WANYONYI

8. EVELYNE ACHIENG

9. VIVIANNE W WAMBOI

10. TIMOTHY DALIZU MULWEYE

11. COLLINS SIMIYU WANYONYI

KAJIADO COUNTY\

1. DAVID NJOROGE WAINAINA

2. PATRICK MWANGI WANGECI

3. DAVID MWENDA MUTHAMIA

5. It is averred that the recruited UHC Clinical Officers were seconded by the Public Service Board and the Ministry of Health to various counties to work alongside the county clinical officers employed under the various county public service boards, while some were posted to national health facilities. Once the contracts expired in May and June 2023, the Ministry of Health renewed the UHC clinical officers’ contracts for a further one year upon the advisory by the Public Service Board, and with the understanding that after the same expired in May and June 2024, the clinical officers would be absorbed at by the county public service boards on permanent and pensionable basis.

6. It is stated that on 10th-12th February 2023, the 112th Ordinary Session of the National and County Government Coordination Summit sitting in Naivasha passed Resolution 23 for the Ministry of Health to extend the contracts of UHC staff for a further period of three years under the same terms and conditions, and issued a press release to that effect. The staff are aggrieved by this development as they had a legitimate expectation that their contract employment would be converted to employment on permanent and pensionable terms, or their remuneration adjusted to the same rate as their peers who work under the same conditions. Notably, the UHC clinical officers earn less than half of what their peers earn working in the same environment. The Grievants categorise the Resolution of the Inter-Governmental Summit as not only unfair by dint of law but also unethical.

7. Since then, various stakeholders in the health sector have held talks to ensure that there would be smooth uptake of the UHC clinical officers by the county public service boards upon the expiration of the 1-year contract in May and June 2024 as follows:

a) On 12th October 2023 the Senate standing committee on labour and social Welfare issued a report to recommend the absorption of UHC Clinical Officers into permanent and pensionable terms.

b) On 18th October 2023, the Ministry of Health and the Council of Governors (CoG) signed the Kericho Declaration where by it was agreed that the CoG and the Ministry of Health would facilitate absorption and mainstreaming of the national government contract staff (including the UHC Clinical Officers) and CoG to develop a clear plan for absorbing other contract staff.

c) The Ministry of Health drafted a circular Ref No. SDPH&PS.1/1/170 dated 2nd April 2024 requesting for the approval of the Public Service Commission to transition the UHC Clinical Officers to permanent terms in their respective counties.

d) That the Council of governors in a circular Ref: COG/6/40/3A Vol. 3(27) dated 4th April 2024 instructed all governors and their respective county public service boards to submit data of all the UHC Clinical Officers in the County Governments health facilities, a task which was done.

e) The UHC clinical officers signed physical contract letters with their respective county public service boards specifying that their contracts extend to May and June 2026.

8. Unfortunately, in May and June 2024, the UHC clinical officers learned that the county governments had failed to absorb them as county clinical officers with the various county public service boards under permanent and pensionable terms. In the government's Human Resource Information System, the Ministry of Health is listed as the UHC clinical officers’ employer and the ROD reads May and June 2024. The contracts that the UHC clinical officers had signed with the county public service boards during the negotiations by stakeholders were withheld by some counties without explanation with the physical copies of their contracts failing to be provided.

9. The Petitioner argues that while the UHC clinical officers have been employed on contractual terms under the PSC and the Ministry of Health, they have been delivering critical healthcare services countrywide for their entire contractual period. Further, they have the same qualifications, work in the same conditions and take up similar roles as their county counterparts but are still paid less and have fewer allowances owing to the fact that they are yet to be placed under permanent and pensionable terms by the county public service boards. To aggravate matters further, some of the UHC clinical officers have had to take on extra responsibilities, including overseeing health facilities, particularly in counties that are understaffed. Throughout the four years under the UHC contracts, the salaries of UHC clinical officers have consistently been subjected to all salary deductions without any increase or additional allowances, including for those working in hardship areas.

10. It is stated that the actions of the Respondents are not warranted as the Ministry of Health has already initiated the process for this transition, and it is essential for promoting fairness, equality, and employee welfare. There have also been advertisements published by the Respondents for health jobs on permanent terms while deliberately failing to consider the UHC clinical officers who had legitimate expectations that their employment terms would be converted to permanent and pensionable, or their remuneration increased to match their peers.

11. The Petitioner’s case is that the failure of county public service boards to absorb the UHC

clinical officers into their labour force is an infringement of their right to fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution, has violated the principle of “equal work equal pay’’, has been discriminatory contrary to Article 27 of the Constitution, and amounts to an illegality as it predisposes the UHC clinical officers to successive employment contracts for the last 4 years which is against Kenyan employment law. Additionally, it violates the Public Service Commission (PSC) Act which outlines requirements for the engagement and renewal of contracts, emphasizing equal treatment and non-discrimination.

12. In a joint sitting with the departmental committee on Health of the National Assembly and the Senate to deliberate on the nationwide strike that was convened on 2nd of May 2024, the chairman to the Public Service Commission announced that there shall be a further extension of contract for the UHC staff for further two years, making it six years under same terms and conditions.

Respondents’ case in brief

12th Respondent

13. The 12th Respondent opposes the Amended Petition on the premise that the Petitioner has failed to prove the existence of an employer-employee relationship between it and the Grievants. They aver that the initial engagement, recruitment, contracting and secondment were carried out by the Public Service Commission and the Ministry of Health on behalf of the National Government, not by Kiambu County Government. They point out that the contracts referred to by the Petitioner were entered into between the UHC Clinical Officers and the Public Service Commission, with the Ministry of Health as the executing agency, and Kiambu County Government was never a party to those contracts. They emphasize that the Petitioner has not produced any subsequent physical contracts entered into by the Grievants and the Kiambu County Public Service Board and the Petitioner, and any such contracts, even if they existed would have exceeded the Board's mandate and lacked the requisite budgetary allocation and approval by Kiambu County Assembly.

14. The 12th Respondent denies that they have violated any of the Grievants Constitutional rights as alleged and complain that the allegations of contravention of rights are generalized without unique factual basis attributable to the 12th Respondent. They, in particular, deny discriminating against any clinical officer, and explain that the terms of engagement for county-employed clinical officers on permanent and pensionable terms are governed by the Kiambu County Public Service Board Human Resource Policies, SRC guidelines and available budgetary resources all of which differ fundamentally from the National Government’s contractual terms. It is stated that the principle of "equal pay for equal work" does not apply between employees of different employers (National Government vs. County Government) working under different legal and remuneration frameworks approved by SRC.

15. Further, the 12th Respondent denies that the Grievants hold any legitimate expectation in relation to employment by them as no express promise, representation or statutory provision binds Kiambu County Government to absorb National Government’s contract staff. They categorize the Kericho Declaration, Senate Committee report, Ministry of Health circular and COG circulars, which are referred to by the Petitioner, as policy recommendations and non-binding instruments which do not create enforceable legal rights or legitimate expectations against an individual county government. Additionally, they clarify that the Intergovernmental Summit resolution of February 2023 recommended a three-year extension of contracts and not permanent absorption as purported by the Petitioner.

16. According to the 12th Respondent, some challenges which would face it in respect of absorption of UHC Clinical Officers onto permanent and pensionable terms are that: such absorption would require budgetary allocation and approval by the Kiambu County Assembly under Article 174 and 176 of the Constitution and the Public Finance Management Act; the estimated cost of absorption (Kshs. 10.3 Billion annually) would impose an unbudgeted, unfunded mandate upon Kiambu County Government, contravening Article 6(2) which requires intergovernmental consultation and financial sustainability; and any transition of contract staff to permanent terms must comply with the Public Service Commission (PSC) approval and County Public Service Board Rules and Regulations, which have not been exhausted or satisfied in this case. It is averred that the Court cannot compel the 47 County Governments to appropriate funds without violating the principle of separation of powers.

17. The 12th Respondent objects to the Petitioner’s failure to exhaust administrative remedies under the Fair Administrative Actions Act or Employment Act prior to filing the instant Petition; and states that they have framed ordinary employment claims (absorption, conversion to permanent terms, gratuity, allowances et al) as constitutional violations. The 12th Respondent denies having withheld physical copies of any signed employment contracts between it and the Grievants from them and categorically states that no valid, approved and budgeted contracts for permanent absorption were ever executed by the Kiambu County Public Service Board in favour of the named individuals.

18. The 12th Respondent, in conclusion, prays for dismissal of the Amended Petition against it stating that it is an abuse of the constitutional court process that seeks to compel 47 diverse County Governments to take uniform action without regard to their individual fiscal positions, staffing norms and legal obligations.

22nd Respondent

19. The 22nd Respondent takes a similar stance to the 12th Respondent, and states that the Universal Health Coverage (UHC) Programme was conceived, initiated, financed and coordinated by the National Government through the Ministry of Health and the Public Service Commission and not by it or the Makueni County Public Service Board. The recruitment process for the UHC staff was centrally undertaken by the Public Service Commission under the Ministry of Health as evidenced by the public advertisements inviting applications for various positions under the UHC Programme, and the terms and conditions of engagement, remuneration, deployment and renewal of contracts for the UHC staff were similarly determined by the National Government and communicated to County Governments and County Public Service Boards for implementation and administrative coordination. They therefore argue that their role was limited to facilitating administrative implementation and coordination at the County level upon deployment of the UHC staff to health facilities within Makueni County.

20. Subsequently, after expiry of the initial contracts, the Council of Governors and the Ministry of Health advised County Public Service Boards to commence the process of renewal of the UHC contracts for a further period of three (3) years. Pursuant to the said communication and directives, the Makueni County Public Service Board processed and facilitated renewal of contracts for the affected UHC staff stationed within Makueni County. Vide a letter dated 26th July 2023, the Board forwarded renewed UHC contracts and issued a status report regarding the affected officers including those with disciplinary and licensing concerns. Thereafter, through another letter dated 16th August 2025 addressed to the Principal Secretary, State Department for Medical Services, the Makueni County Public Service Board expressly supported the conversion of UHC staff on contractual terms to permanent and pensionable terms, due to the need for competitive human resource management. They requested an update on progress on the Ministry of Health side regarding the transition of the affected UHC staff into permanent and pensionable terms.

21. It is therefore the 22nd Respondent’s case that they and the Makueni County Public Service Board have lawfully in relation to the officers serving under the UHC Programme within Makueni County. They state that no violation of constitutional rights attributable solely and directly to the 22nd Respondent and the Makueni County Public Service Board has been demonstrated. It is averred that the issues raised in the Petition regarding remuneration, contractual terms, budgetary allocation and policy direction concerning the UHC Programme substantially fall within the mandate of the National Government, Ministry of Health, Public Service Commission and other intergovernmental bodies involved in the Programme.

1st Interested Party

22. The 1st Interested Party avers that there is no employer employee relationship between it and the Petitioner's members, hence the issue of discrimination by the employer is denied. The 1st Interested Party also opposes the claim of discrimination against the Petitioner’s members on the premise that no evidence has been adduced showing that a different group of health workers were treated differentially and favourably. They also deny that the Petitioner’s members were seconded from one level of government to the other.

23. The 1st Interested Party explains that the Petitioners members were employees of various County Governments having been interviewed by the respective County Public Service Boards and issued with appointment letters initially under fixed term contracts of three years, as admitted in the Petition. They argue that at the time of employment of the clinical officers, they were aware of the duration and the remuneration attached to their contracts, and elected to accept them. They cannot turn around and demand alteration of the terms of the contract during the subsistence thereof.

24. On the alleged failure by the 1st Interested Party to factor in the Scheme of Service for health workers as approved by the Commission itself, in determining the Grievants’ terms of employment, the 1st Interested Party states that although the advertisement was published centrally by the Commission, the applicants were intended to be employed by the county governments, who are not obligated to adopt the policies issued by the Commission in respect of the national government institutions falling under its mandate. The legislation that applies to county government employees is the County Governments Act 2012 and not the Public Service Commission Act 2017.

25. On the purported legitimate expectation held by the Grievants that their employment would be converted to permanent and pensionable and/or their remuneration enhanced, the 1st Interested Party avers that there is no basis giving rise to such legitimate expectation, as the legal threshold for a finding of legitimate expectation has not been met. Specifically, since the Petitioner's members are employees of the various county governments, the respective County Public Service Boards, and not the 1st Interested Party, are competent to make a promise capable of being interpreted as creating legitimate expectation.

26. The 1st Interested Party emphasizes that they are responsible for making appointments at the national government level and any attempt to make pronouncements relating to appointments at the county level would be unconstitutional. Further, the Interested Parties cannot direct the translation of terms of officers in the County Government Public Service. For absorption to happen, the respective county governments, through their County Public Service Boards must agree after assessing the employees’ capacity. Notably, health is a devolved function, with Universal Health Care nurses serving in county health facilities.

27. On the prayers sought, the 1st Interested Party opposes the grant of the prayer for payment of the underpaid salaries and allowances as per gazette notice number 8091 dated 12th October 2020, as the specific amounts due have not been computed. They also oppose the prayer for payment of gratuity as the same is not supported by documentation.

28. In support of its case, the 1st Interested Party relies on Article 2(2) of the Constitution which provides that no person may claim or exercise statutory authority except as authorized under the Constitution; Article 6(2) which provides that the governments at the national and county levels are distinct and interdependent; Article 189 on Government at either level performing its functions and exercising its powers in a manner that respects the functional and institutional integrity of government at the other level; Article 233 which establishes the Public Service Commission and Article 234 which sets out its mandate; Article 235 of the constitution which sets out the mandate of County Governments, including to establish and abolish offices in its public service and appoint persons to hold or act in those offices; and Paragraphs 23 and 28 of part one of the Fourth Schedule which provide that the national government will be responsible for the national referral facilities and the health policy respectively, and paragraph 2 of part two which provides that the county governments are responsible for the county health facilities. They also rely on Sections 7 and 8 of the Intergovernmental Technical Relations Act which provides for establishment of a National and County Government Co-ordinating Summit and its functions; as well as Sections 57 and 58 of the County Governments Act 2012 which establish the County Public Service Board and set out its powers and functions.

The 3rd Interested Party

29. The 3rd Interested Party filed a replying affidavit through its Chief Executive Officer, Mary Mwiti, sworn on the 10th December 2024. Its response was as follows-

30. The 3rd interested party is an Intergovernmental Relations Body established under Section 19 of the Intergovernmental Relations Act No. 2 of 2012. It comprises of the 47 County Governors whose functions as set out under Section 20 of the Act are to inter-alia provide a forum for, among others: consultation amongst County Governments; and considering matters of common interest to the County Governments.

31. Pursuant to its mandate hereinabove, the 3rd interested party coordinates the 47 County Governments on matters of common interest with regard to implementation of devolution. The Council also provides the linkage and synergy between the Counties and National Government, development partners and International organizations on matters of common interest.

32. The 3rd Respondent is not an employer to the Petitioner/Applicant's members in line with the provisions of the Employment Act or any other law. The prayers as framed cannot issue as against the 3rd interested party in light of the following:

a) There exists no employment relationship between the Petitioner/Applicant and the 3rd Respondent.

b) The 3rd interested party does not have a County Public Service Board that is mandated in law to appoint members of the applicant.

c) There exists no contractual relationship between members of the Petitioner/Applicant and 3rd interested party to warrant issuance of the orders sought in the Application

33. Ms Mwiti averred on without prejudice basis as follows-

34. That with the promulgation of the 2010 Constitution, devolution was introduced in a bid to promote good governance and enhance effective exercise of the people's sovereign power at both the County and National levels of the government. Article 174 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010 provides inter alia for the objects of devolution.

35. Under Article 186(1) as read together with section 2 Part 2 of the Fourth Schedule of the Constitution, the function of provision of healthcare services is devolved to County Governments. The National Government is assigned the role of health policy and providing services at national referral health facilities.

36. The above notwithstanding, at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, the 1st Respondent (1st interested party under amended petition) advertised health worker positions as part of the efforts to complement the workforce on the battlefront against coronavirus. Consequently, the qualified candidates were asked in the advertisement to make their applications online through the 1st interested party website, indicating the counties where they wish to serve.

37. The applicant's members engaged under the 2nd Respondent's (2nd interested party under amended petition) Universal Health Coverage Programme were appointed for a three-year fixed term contract which was to automatically expire by effluxion of time in May 2023. That it was a term at the inception of the programme that the applicant's members be supervised and managed by the respective county governments but their payroll be managed by the 2nd Respondent (2nd interested party under amended petition) , subject to statutory deductions, a fact that initially did not sit well with the 3rd Respondent(3rd interested party under amended petition) as this offends the functional and institutional integrity of county governments.

38. Article 235 of the Constitution provides that a county government is responsible for establishing and staffing its public service. To operationalise Article 235 of the Constitution, Section 57 of the County Governments Act, Cap 265, establishes a county public service board for every county government, which is responsible for managing human resources, including appointing the members of the board. In order for the programme to be effectively conducted, the County Governments ought to have been given the resources to effectively undertake the function.

39. That fixed-term contracts, which the applicant's members voluntarily agreed to carry, carry no rights, obligations or expectation beyond the date of expiry of the contract. Article 6(2) of the Constitution provides that the governments at the national and county levels are distinct and interdependent and shall conduct their mutual relations on the basis of consultation and cooperation. It is on this basis that the Intergovernmental Relations Act, Cap 265F of the laws of Kenya, established the National and County Government Co-ordinating Summit as the apex body for intergovernmental relations. The Summit comprises the President, the Deputy President and the governors of the forty-seven counties.

40. Section 8 of the Intergovernmental Relations Act, Cap 265F of the Laws of Kenya, provides that the Summit shall, among other things, provide a forum for consultation and co-operation between the national and county governments.

41. That aware that the contracts of the Ministry of Health Universal Health Coverage staff were coming to an end, the Summit convened on 12th February 2023 to discuss inter alia issues pertaining to the applicant's members engaged under the Ministry of Health Universal Health Coverage programme. Consequently, the summit resolved that all contracts of clinical officers under the programme be extended for another three years under same terms and conditions.

42. In light of the Summit resolution dated 12th February 2023, the 3rd Respondent (3rd interested party under amended petition) conveyed the resolution of the summit held on 12th February 2023 to the 2nd Respondent (2nd interested party under amended petition) and the National Treasury, urging the aforesaid stakeholders to extend the contracts of the claimant's members for another three years under the same terms and conditions and to allocate adequate budget for the same.

43. However, the 1st Respondent (1st interested party under amended petition) renewed the contracts of members of the applicant for one year. The county governments are cognizant of the essential role that clinical officers employed under Ministry of Health Coverage play in promoting healthcare services in county facilities and have progressively employed the said staff within their staffing establishments whenever vacancies arise. Further, the advertisements issued by the counties do not bar the members of the applicant from applying the advertised positions. As a matter of fact, some members of the applicant have successfully applied and secured the positions advertised by the County Public Service Board.

DETERMINATION

44. Following directions by the court that it would determine the Petition through written submissions, the Petitioner, 12th Respondent, and 1st and 3rd Interested Parties filed their respective submissions.

Issues for determination

45. The Petitioner distilled the following issues for determination in their submissions dated 12th January 2026:

i. Whether the Respondents violated the right to fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution and national labour standards.

ii. Whether the Respondents’ actions violated the principle of equality and non-discrimination under Article 27 of the Constitution.

iii. Whether the Respondents’ actions breached the Petitioner’s right to fair administrative action under Article 47 of the Constitution.

iv. Whether the Petitioner is entitled to the reliefs sought.

v. Whether the Respondents violated the right to fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution and national labour standards.

46. The 12th Respondent filed submissions dated 13th April 2026, where they submitted generally on the Petition.

47. On their part, the 1st Interested Party also submitted generally on the Petition in their submissions dated 12th February 2026.

48. The 3rd Interested Party, in their submissions dated 17th July 2026, identified the following issues for determination, namely:

i. Whether the recruitment process of the members of the Petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Universal Coverage was constitutionally flawed.

ii. Whether there exists an employer-employee relationship between members of the Petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Universal Health Coverage Programme and the Respondents.

iii. Whether the Honourable Court can rewrite the fixed term contracts of the members of the Petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Coverage Programme.

49. The court finds that the parties are in agreement on issues for determination which the court concluded were as follows-

a. Whether there exists an employer-employee relationship between members of the Petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Universal Health Coverage Programme and the Respondents.

b. Whether the Honourable Court can rewrite the fixed term contracts of the members of the Petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Coverage Programme.

c. Whether the Respondents violated the right to fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution and national labour standards.

d. Whether the Respondents’ actions violated the principle of equality and non-discrimination under Article 27 of the Constitution.

e. Whether the Respondents/interested parties’ actions breached the Petitioner’s right to fair administrative action under Article 47 of the Constitution.

f. Whether the Petitioner is entitled to the relief sought.

Whether there exists an employer-employee relationship between members of the Petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Universal Health Coverage Programme and the Respondents.

50. The court finds that the facts of the case are not in dispute. What is in dispute is who is responsible for the terms of employment and engagement of the members of the Petitioner.

51. It was apparent from the facts before the court that the 1st interested party recruited the members of the petitioner under the Ministry of Health Universal Health Coverage Programme, and the members were deployed to serve in the counties under terms stipulated by the 1st and 2nd interested parties. The petitioner admitted in the pleadings that, in the Government Human Resource Information System, the Ministry of Health is listed as the UHC clinical officer’s employer. The 1st interested party's attempt to evade responsibility for employing the clinical officers is unacceptable, given that the facts clearly show it recruited the officers at behest of the 2nd respondent.

52. The court established that the 1st and 2nd interested parties control the fate of the said workers, having been under the Ministry health programme. This position is supported by the replying affidavit of Redempta Kavindu, of Makueni County Government (the 22nd Respondent), sworn on 22nd May 2026, who annexed the recruitment advert by the 1st interested party dated 8th May 2020 titled- 'Vacant positions in the public service -Ministry of Health(Universal Health Coverage Programme)’. Kavindu stated that the Universal Health Coverage Programme was conceived, initiated, financed and coordinated by the national government through the Ministry of Health and the Public Service Commission and not by the 22nd Respondent. Kavindu stated that implementation control for the officers under the programme remains with the 1st and 2nd interested parties and the relevant intergovernmental entities.

53. I find that from the facts by the petitioner, it was evident that the employer of the clinical officers under the programme is the Ministry of Health supported by the Public Service Commission in the recruitment. The counties received the workers and issued contracts as directed by the 1st and 2nd interested parties. This was a tripartite employment relationship for which both national and county governments must be held jointly and severally responsible. Indeed, it is evident from the affidavit of Makueni County Government that it is the national government, through the 1st and 2nd interested parties, that holds the key to the fate of the long-term employment of the members of the Petitioner. I say no more.

Whether the Honourable Court can rewrite the fixed-term contracts of the members of the Petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Coverage Programme.

54. The court agreed that it cannot rewrite contracts of members of the petitioner engaged under the Ministry of Health Coverage Programme. The court’s judicial authority is not fettered by the said contracts. The petitioner raised an issue of equal pay for equal work and discrimination as against clinical officers employed by the county public service boards. Unfortunately, no evidence was placed before the court to support the assertions.

55. The 1st interested party in the affidavit of Mr. Pamba dated 6th November 2024 stated that it could not interfere with the employment of the members of the petitioner and the absorption can only be dealt with at the highest decision-making organ, the Summit. That health is a devolved service, and only the county public service boards can absorb the petitioner's members.

56. The court held that the Ministry of Health is the actual employer of the members of the petitioner under the program and dictates the terms of their service at the deployed counties in conjunction with the 1st interested party. The Makueni County Public Service Board, in a letter dated 26th August 2025 addressed to the PS, State Department of Medical Services, expressly supported the conversion of UHC staff to permanent and pensionable terms. The response was not annexed, and the court reasonably assumed that none existed.

57. The court finds the continued limbo of the fate of the said UHC staff employed under the programme amounts to unfair labour practice. The Ministry of Health and the Public Service Commission owe the said workers a duty of care to direct on their fate in the same way they directed on their recruitment and deployment.

58. Recently, the Court of Appeal had opportunity to determine fate of workers placed on continuous short term of contracts in Kenya County Government Workers' Union v Embu County Government & another [2026] KECA 1481 (KLR) where the facts are similar to the cause of action as summarised by the court in paragraph 36 as follows-

‘On the status of the appellant’s members, we need to interrogate what the actual status of the employees was, vis-à- vis the documents presented and the reality on the ground. The evidence on record shows that the appellant’s members were initially employed for periods ranging from 3 months to 6 months and for some 1 year. Meaning that, at the initial stage, some engagements were on short-term fixed contracts, and others were specific to the members involved, who were employed on temporary/casual terms. Evident also is that some contracts were renewed for similar periods, and thereafter members worked continuously for long periods, several years, performing duties of a permanent nature. When the contracts lapsed, they lacked clarity about the nature of their employment, leaving them in a state of anxiety and confusion.’’

59. The Court of Appeal (above) held as follows-

‘We therefore find that the appellant’s members were not casual employees, nor were they on fixed contract as assumed by the respondent, who engaged them for a long period of time and extended the contracts at its whim. We firmly find that the long and continuous service entitled the appellant’s members to statutory protection. The Act was precisely put in place to protect employees who often have no voice against the ‘big brother’ from unfair and poor labour practices that dogged the public and private service for decades.

44.Article 41 of the Constitution stipulates as follows on labour relations: 1.Every person has the right to fair labour practices. 2.Every worker has the right—a.to fair remuneration; b.to reasonable working conditions

45.On whether there was a violation of fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution, and the law which guarantees every worker the right to fair labour practices, including fair remuneration, reasonable working conditions, and generally job security. A reading of the record demonstrates a lack of clarity in the employment terms of the appellant’s members; repeated short-term engagements spanning years; unrenewed for long periods; absence of benefits such as leave, benefits, and pension; and continued uncertainty despite long service.

46. In Kenyatta University vs. Maina (supra), this Court squarely addressed the problem of keeping employees in prolonged casual or insecure arrangements, and held that: an employer cannot retain an employee under casual or rolling short-term arrangements for long periods as such conduct is a deliberate circumvention of labour protections; and it violates the right to fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution. The Court firmly stated: “By being retained to what in essence was casual employment, we are further in agreement with the learned judge’s summation that the respondent’s constitutional rights were infringed. She was treated as a non-permanent employee and this is tantamount to unfair labour practices and thus denying her all the rights of a permanent employee.”

47.We agree with the finding in the case above, which encapsulates very well the situation in this case. The respondent's action cannot but be condemned in the strongest terms, particularly because the appellant’s members were in the employ of the government, which is expected to protect its citizens and to work within the law.’’

60. I upheld the above Court of Appeal decision to apply in the instant case. The court condemns the 1st interested party's act of recommending short-term contracts for workers under the Ministry of Health UHC programme, thereby circumventing the said workers' right to fair labour practices. The 1st interested party is responsible for ensuring fair labour practices across the public service. The 2nd interested party had a duty to issue the relevant directions sought in the letter of the Makueni County Government dated 26th August 2025 regarding the employment of workers under its programme.

61. I hold that the short-term arrangements for a continued long period for the UHC workers are a deliberate circumvention of labour protections; and it violates the right to fair labour practices under Article 41 of the Constitution. The Ministry of Health, as the initial employer, has failed to provide directions on the employment terms of the said UHC programme workers, and thus cannot escape responsibility.

On whether there was evidence of discrimination against the petitioner by the respondents.

62. I found no evidence to prove the allegation of less pay to the members of the petitioner than their peers employed by the respondents. The petitioner had the burden of proving discrimination. I upheld the instant case the above decision of the Court of Appeal (Embu County Government) where it was held-

'On whether there was discrimination contrary to Article 27 of the Constitution and section 5 of the Act, the appellant alleged that its members performed similar duties as permanent employees, were paid less, denied benefits and were overlooked during absorption despite experience. The appellant failed to provide evidence to support this allegation. Inasmuch as it would have been difficult to obtain such evidence from persons who appeared to be competing with them in the space, the allegations and assertions must be backed by evidence, which was lacking, making it impossible for the court to make a finding on this ground.’

Whether the petitioner is entitled to relief sought.

63. The court held that the short-term contracts of 3 years to 1 year, as directed by the 1st interested party, were a deliberate action of circumventing fair labour rights of the petitioners under Article 41 of the Constitution. I did not find proof of the discrimination claims.

64. The petitioner sought for various reliefs which I proceed to consider-

a) An order of MANDAMUS be issued directing the Ministry of Health, Council of Governors, Public Service Commission, Salaries and Remuneration Commission, and the National Treasury to immediately initiate the process of transitioning all the clinical officers currently under the UHC programme as per the circular issued by the Ministry of Health, Ref No. SDPH&PS.1/1/170 dated 2nd of April 2024 and remunerate them as per the SRC guidelines without discrimination.

65. I return this order in the positive, having held that the continued engagement of workers on short-term contracts violates their fair labour rights under Article 41 of the Constitution. The Court of Appeal in the Kenya County Government Workers' Union v Embu County Government & another [2026] KECA 1481 (KLR) granted the following order in similar cause of action –

‘We direct and order the respondents to regularize the appellant’s members’ employment terms and conditions of service to accord with fair labour practices in accordance with the Constitution and the Employment Act forthwith.‘

66. The 12th respondent on the order of Mandamus sought submitted that the Court cannot compel budgetary appropriation without violating the principle of separation of powers. It relied on Kenya National Examination Council v Republic ex parte Geoffrey Gathenji Njoroge [1997] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal held that an order of mandamus cannot compel a public body to perform a duty in a specific way where the law leaves discretion as to the mode of performance. I agreed with the submission.

67. It is my finding that the law places an obligation on 1st interested party to deal with grievances on employment of all public officers under their jurisdiction. The Ministry of Health is the owner of the programme in which the petitioner's members are employed. The court noted that it was undisputed that the Ministry of Health circular dated 2nd April 2024 requested approval from the Public Service Commission on transition UHC Clinical Officers. I adopt the order by the Court of Appeal in Kenya County Government Workers' Union v Embu County Government & another [2026] KECA 1481 (KLR) as a relief to the grievance on the employment status of the workers under the UHC programme and order as follows- I direct and order the interested parties to regularize the petitioner’s members’ employment terms and conditions of service to accord with fair labour practices in accordance with the Constitution and the Employment Act forthwith and within 3 months file a report of the court on the progress.

b. An order of MANDAMUS be issued directing the 47 Respondents and the Ministry of Health to pay gratuities for all the four years served by the clinical officers under the Universal Health programme contract as per the Gazette Notice No. 8091 dated 12th October 2020.

68. I did not find the Gazette Notice in the annexures to the petition. I decline to make the order as the members of the petitioner hold contracts of employment, and the respondents had been guided on how to remunerate them. The contracts had terms of service and are complete on their own.

c. Order of DECLARATION sought that the deliberations made in the Intergovernmental Relations Technical Committee (IGRTC) summit on 24th of March 2023 are unconstitutional and unlawful as they violate the principle of “equal pay for equal work” and have prevented the transitioning of terms of UHC clinical officers to permanent and pensionable terms-

69. I did not find the record of the deliberations made in the Intergovernmental Relations Technical Committee (IGRTC) summit on 24th of March 2023 thus was unable to make any decision on the same.

d. Order of MANDAMUS compelling the 47 Respondents and the Ministry of Health to remit all the already deducted NSSF contribution for the UHC clinical officers.

70. The court finds that the employer had a duty to comply with deductions and to remit them as required. The court need not make such an order as it is a statutory duty and there is no evidence before the court of non-compliance.

71. On the costs of the petition, the court, taking into account the need to promote industrial harmony, makes no order as to costs in the petition. Each party to bear its own costs.

Disposition

72. In the upshot, the court held that the short-term contracts of 3 years to 1 year given to the members of the petitioner, as directed by the 1st interested party, were a deliberate conduct by the interested parties of circumventing fair labour rights under Article 41 of the Constitution.

73. I direct and order the interested parties to regularise the petitioner’s members’ employment terms and conditions of service to accord with fair labour practices in accordance with the Constitution and the Employment Act forthwith and, within 3 months, file a report with the court on the progress/compliance.

74. Each party to bear its own costs in the petition.

75. It is so Ordered.

DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI THIS 25TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026.

JEMIMAH KELI

JUDGE

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Court Assistant: Otieno

Petitioner: Ms Ochieng h/b Ataka

1st respondent – Mrs Iseme

12th Respondent:- Mararo

22nd Respondent: absent

1st Interested Party: SRC- Njuguna

3rd Interested Party: absent

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder