Land law

Bari & 10 others v Gachega & 78 others [2026] KEELC 6592 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
ELC CASE NO. 2363 OF 2007
Judgment date
14 October 2026
Judge(s)
C.K. Nzili

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

By an application dated 27.10.2025, the court is asked to consolidate this suit with

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

The upshot is that I find the applicant has not met the threshold for consolidation. The application is dismissed with costs.

Paragraph 14 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MILIMANI

ELC CASE NO. 2363 OF 2007

BETH WAIRIMU BARI ………………………………………….. 1ST PLAINTIFF

CHARLES WESONGA……………….………………….……….. 2ND PLAINTIFF

NICHOLAS O.ORIGI……………………………..…….……….. 3RD PLAINTIFF

THOMAS ALUKE…………………………………………….….. 4TH PLAINTIFF

MOSES ONYANGO …………………………………………….. 5TH PLAINTIFF

FRANCIS KIRIMA M’IKUNYUA……………………………….. 6TH PLAINTIFF

PETER NDUNG’U MUTIGA………………………………...….. 7TH PLAINTIFF

GEORGE OLUOCH OMONDI…………………………………..8TH PLAINTIFF

JOSEPH MUSYOKA WAMBUA………………………….…….. 9TH PLAINTIFF

KENNEDY OCHIENG ONDORO………………………….…. 10TH PLAINTIFF

ANTHONY MAINA WAIHUNI……………………………….. 11TH PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

JOHN KIMUHU GACHEGA ………………………………… 1ST DEFENDANT

JOHNSON WAIGANJO KAMANDA……………….……… 2ND DEFENDANT

MWANGI KIMANGA………………………………………… 3RD DEFENDANT

GICHUHI MACHARIA………………………..……………… 4TH DEFENDANT

JANET WANJIRU KABUI………………….………………… 5TH DEFENDANT

CHARLES KIGE KARANJA…………………………………… 6TH DEFENDANT

CHARLES KIRI KOBE…………………………………………. 7TH DEFENDANT

PATRICK GITHINJI MWANGI……………………………… 8TH DEFENDANT

ROBERT WAMITHI MUTAHI……………………….……… 9TH DEFENDANT

GRACE WANJIKU KABUI……………………………………10TH DEFENDANT

DOMINIC THUITA GATHEGE………………………..…… 11TH DEFENDANT

ABDUL RAHMAN MOHAMED…………………………… 12TH DEFENDANT

LUCY NJOKI KABUI………………………………………… 13TH DEFENDANT

SAMUEL NJENGA NGARUIYA…………,….……………… 14TH DEFENDANT

JAMES WAIGANJO GITONGO……….…………………… 15TH DEFENDANT

MUCHIRI MATHENGE………………………..…………… 16TH DEFENDANT

DANEVER LIMITED……………………………………….… 17TH DEFENDANT

PAUL KIMARI MWANGI…………………………………… 18TH DEFENDANT

THIKIRIKA TEA FARM …………………………………..… 19TH DEFENDANT

ROBERT WAMITHI………………………………………… 20TH DEFENDANT

PETER KIMANGA WAIGANJO……………………..……… 21ST DEFENDANT

JACKSON MUCHOKI MWANGI…………………….…… 22ND DEFENDANT

MONICA MUTHONI MWANGI……………………..…… 23RD DEFENDANT

JULIUS NG’ANG’A KINUTHIA …………………………… 24TH DEFENDANT

COMMISSIONER OF LANDS ……………………………… 25TH DEFENDANT

MALRAJI KANJI PATEL………………………………..…… 26TH DEFENDANT

PUR KANJI PATEL………………………………………...… 27TH DEFENDANT

MARY WNAJIKU KIMARU………………………………… 28TH DEFENDANT

JUDY WNAJIKU KIMARU……………………………….… 29TH DEFENDANT

WAKIMAR LIMITED………………………………….…..… 30TH DEFENDANT

TITAS RUBIA KARANJA……………………………….….… 31ST DEFENDANT

MORRIS KINUTHIA MUNDIA………………………….… 32ND DEFENDANT

PETERCON MWANGI GITHINJI……………………….… 33RD DEFENDANT

GEORGE KARIUKI GITHINJI…………………………..… 34TH DEFENDANT

BENSON MWANGI GITHINJI………………………….… 35TH DEFENDANT

JOHN IRUNGU GITHINJI………………………………… 36TH DEFENDANT

JORAM GITHINJI KIMANGA…………………………..… 37TH DEFENDANT

JOSEPH GITHIGO KIMANGA………………………..…… 38TH DEFENDANT

JACKSON MUCHOKI MWANGI…………………….…… 39TH DEFENDANT

PAUL KIMARI MWANGI………………………………..… 40TH DEFENDANT

PETER KIMANGA WAIGANJO…………………………..… 41ST DEFENDANT

WANJIRU KABAGE………………………………………… 42ND DEFENDANT

GEOFFREY MWANGI…………………………………...…. 43RD DEFENDANT

KABAGE MURUGAMI…………………………………...… 44TH DEFENDANT

EUNICE WANJIRU MWANGI…………………………..… 45TH DEFENDANT

HANNAH NJERI MWANGI……………………………..… 46TH DEFENDANT

GICHUHI MACHARIA……………………………..….…… 47TH DEFENDANT

GLADYS MUGAMBI………………………………………… 48TH DEFENDANT

ANN NJERI & VICTOR MUIRU…………………………… 49TH DEFENDANT

LUCY WAIRIMU KAHAGA………………………………… 50TH DEFENDANT

PHARES NGAHU NDUNGU…………………………...…… 51ST DEFENDANT

ANNASTACIA NDUTA NGAHU……………………..…… 52ND DEFENDANT

JOHN KINUTHIA MAKUMI…………………………….… 53RD DEFENDANT

AGNES WARINGA KINUTHIA …………………………… 54TH DEFENDANT

NANCY NJOKI GITHERE………………………………..… 55TH DEFENDANT

GRACE WANJIKU NDEGWA……………………………… 56TH DEFENDANT

ZIPPORAH WAIRIMU WAMITHI………………………… 57TH DEFENDANT

FREDRICK NGUGI MUIRURI……………………………… 58TH DEFENDANT

HELKINAH WANGARI MWANGI …………………..…… 59TH DEFENDANT

MATHEW KIMANI KIMANGA……………………….…… 60TH DEFENDANT

MORRIS KINUTHIA MUNDIA………………………..….… 61ST DEFENDANT

DANIEL KARANJA KAIMANGA……………………...…… 62ND DEFENDANT

MWANGI WAITHATTU MWANGI……………….……… 63RD DEFENDANT

MATHEW NDEGWA MATHIA…………………….……… 64TH DEFENDANT

MONICA MUTHONI MWANGI……………………..……65TH DEFENDANT

FREDRICK NJORA MWANGI………………………...…… 66TH DEFENDANT

MWANGI KIMANGA…………………………………...….. 67TH DEFENDANT

LUCY MUKAMI NDUNGU ……………………………..… 68TH DEFENDANT

HARRISON GACHUKA KIMANGA………………….….… 69TH DEFENDANT

STEPHEN MAINA KIMANGA……………………………… 70TH DEFENDANT

ARMSTRONG KAMAU CHEGGEH………………………… 71ST DEFENDANT

ERIC MUREITHI KIMARU…………………………….…… 72ND DEFENDANT

PETER WANGOMBE MACHAGI……………………..…… 73RD DEFENDANT

LUCY WANJIRU WANGOMBE…………………………… 74TH DEFENDANT

FRANCIS NGATIA KINYORI……………………….……… 75TH DEFENDANT

TITUS THUO MACHARIA ………………………………… 76TH DEFENDANT

SAMMY ANLIO……………………………………………… 77TH DEFENDANT

JOSIAH NJONJO GACHUMI……………………………… 78TH DEFENDANT

JANE NYAWERU CHEGE………………………..………… 79TH DEFENDANT

RULING

1. By an application dated 27.10.2025, the court is asked to consolidate this suit with

i. ELC Nos. E219 of 2023 ( Ndiritu Gikaria Vs Zimman Settlement Scheme Society),

ii. ELC No. E438 of 2025 ( Taitas Rubia Kariuki vs Robert Muichua & Another),

iii. ELC No 194 of 2009(Mohamed Iqbal vs Francis Kirima M’ikunyua & 3 Others,

iv. ELC No. 725 of 2014 (Monicah Muthoni Mwangi Vs Nzau Mwallimu Nzau & Others) and

v. ELC No. E068 of 2022 ( Raphael Mbugua Mbogo & Another Vs Zimman Settlement Scheme Society & 6 Others

2. The reasons are contained on the face of the application and in a supporting affidavit of Peter Ndungu Mutiga sworn on 27.10.2025. The deponent says that he is a member of the special committee of the Zimman Settlement Scheme Society, which represents all the squatters on LR No. Nairobi Block 123/1-255, the suit properties herein, which suit properties are also the subject of the written in the referenced suit as per attached pleadings marked PNM 2 (A) to (C).

3. The applicant depose that the listed files and this suit involve the same parties who share the same subject matter, making them ripe for consolidation to prevent the potential situation where a court of equal and concurrent jurisdiction might deliver conflicting decisions on the same issues.

4. Order II Rule 3(1) (9) of the Civil Procedure Acts and section 1A & 1B of the Civil Procedure Rules are the basis upon which a court may consolidate suits for just, expeditious, and proportionate resolution of disputes and to avoid multiplicity of proceedings, duplication of evidence and the risk of conflicting judgments.

5. In the Law Society of Kenya Vs Centre for Human Rights & Democracy & Others [2014] EKLR, the court held that the essence of consolidation is to facilitate the efficient and expeditious disposal of disputes, and to provide a framework for a fair and impartial dispensation of justice to the parties.

6. The court said that consolidation was never meant to confer any undue advantage upon the party that seeks it, nor was it intended to occasion a disadvantage to the party that opposes it; otherwise, the court must be satisfied that no injustice would be occasioned to the respondent by an order of consolidation.

7. In Nyati Security Guard Services Limited Vs Municipal Council of Mombasa 2004 KEHC 1896 (KLR), the court said that there are situations where consolidation is undesirable, such as where in two actions, or a plaintiff in two or more actions, are represented by different advocates, meaning the hearing will be longer and the purpose of saving time will be defeated.

8. In Stumberg & Another Vs Potgieter [1970] EA 323, the court said that where there are common questions of law or facts, in an action having sufficient importance in proportion to the rest of each action to render it desirable that the whole of the matters should be disposed of at the same time, consolidation should be ordered.

9. Sameness of parties alone is not sufficient ground for consolidation; the court said that consolidation of suits saves costs, time, effort and makes the conduct of several actions more convenient by treating them as one action. The court said that the rationale behind consolidation is to avoid competing judgments, save time and money by clubbing together matters involving a common question of fact and law, which helps or assists the court in achieving the overriding objective of expeditious and proportionate disposal of cases.

10. In this application, other than attaching various pleadings in the referenced suits, the applicant has not told the court the current status of the hearing, or advancement of each of the individual files and before which courts of equal status the files are at and the nature of the claims.

11. The lawyers or parties in those files have also not been specified or notified of the proposal or intention to consolidate their matters.

12. The applicant has also not sought for the court to give notice to the owners of those files as a condition precedent for allowing the application. Even after the applicant was directed to serve the application for interparty hearing or for directions, there is no evidence that the parties and respective lawyers in those matters were served, or notified and/or are consenting to the proposal to consolidate their matters with the instant suit.

13. As much as the applicant intends or seeks consolidation, such an order or proposal may not be made ex parte without notice to the affected parties.

14. The upshot is that I find the applicant has not met the threshold for consolidation. The application is dismissed with costs.

15. Orders accordingly.

Signed, dated and delivered on this 14TH day of October, 2026 at Milimani – Nairobi.

……………………

Hon Justice C.K. Nzili

Judge

In the presence of ;

Okul for Kenyatta for plaintiff

Ngaga for kimani for 1st defendant

Theuri for 4th defendant

Court assistant: Julius

Legal researcher: Bevalyn N.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder