Background
The Claimant sued the Respondent vide a Memorandum of Claim dated 25th June, 2025 and pleaded:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The claimant union’s suit was dismissed. Each party was ordered to bear its own costs.
19. In the upshot, and having considered written submissions filed by both parties herein, the Claimant’s suit herein is hereby dismissed.
Paragraph 19 →
20. Each party shall bear its own costs of the suit.
Paragraph 20 →
Held. No. The claimant was non-suited and its suit was an abuse of the court process. The respondent operated in the plastic, paper and chemical manufacturing sector, which was outside the sectors covered by the claimant’s constitution. The claimant therefore could not lawfully recruit the respondent’s employees; the purported recruitment was unlawful, null and void. Consequently, the respondent’s refusal to deduct and remit union dues was not faultable and gave the claimant no cause of action.
Ratio. Under section 14(e) of the Labour Relations Act, only persons in a sector specified in a trade union’s constitution qualify for membership. Parties are bound by their pleadings. A union cannot lawfully recruit employees from a sector outside its registered constitutional mandate, and an employer incurs no actionable obligation to deduct and remit dues based on such invalid recruitment.
Issue
(a) Whether the Claimant is properly suited in the present suit.
Passage 35 →
Held
15. The Claimant’s said constitution, whose authenticity the Claimant did not question, does not mention/include plastic, paper and chemical manufacturing, which is shown to be the Respondent’s Sector. The Claimant could not, therefore, claim to have lawfully and validly recruited members from a Sector which it is not mandated to cover. Any purported recruitment of “members” outside its lawfully mandated sector was unlawful, null and void.
Paragraph 15 →
16. The Respondent’s refusal to deduct union dues in favour of the Claimant and to remit them to the Claimant cannot be faulted, and no cause of action accrued to the Claimant from such refusal.
Paragraph 16 →
17. Further, the Claimant is non-suited, in view of the foregoing; and the suit herein is an abuse of this Court’s process.
Paragraph 17 →
Ratio
10. In view of the foregoing pleadings by both parties, there is a clear agreement on the fact that the Respondent does not fall within the sector for which the Claimant Trade Union is registered. It is trite that parties are always bound by their pleadings as presented by them to a Court of law.
Paragraph 10 →
“(e) Subject to sub-section (2), only members in a sector specified in the Constitution qualify for membership of the trade union”.
Passage 44 →
15. The Claimant’s said constitution, whose authenticity the Claimant did not question, does not mention/include plastic, paper and chemical manufacturing, which is shown to be the Respondent’s Sector. The Claimant could not, therefore, claim to have lawfully and validly recruited members from a Sector which it is not mandated to cover. Any purported recruitment of “members” outside its lawfully mandated sector was unlawful, null and void.
Paragraph 15 →
Not reached
Held. Not reached. Having found that the claimant was non-suited, the court declined to consider whether the requested recognition agreement, deduction and remittance of union dues, accumulated dues, or other reliefs were available, because that would be academic.
Ratio. This issue was not decided. The court expressly declined to determine this issue after resolving the claimant’s standing/suitability against it.
Issue
(b) Whether the reliefs sought are available to the Claimant.
Passage 36 →
Held
18. Having made the foregoing finding, I will not delve into the second issue, as doing so will be a mere academic exercise.
Paragraph 18 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The Claimant sued the Respondent vide a Memorandum of Claim dated 25th June, 2025 and pleaded:-
Paragraph 1 →The court considered whether the Claimant union was properly suited to bring the claim against the Respondent, and, if so, whether the requested orders for recognition, deduction and remittance of union dues, accumulated dues, and costs were available.
The Amalgamated Union of Kenya Metal Workers pleaded that it represents employees in the metal and motor trades sectors and had recruited 43 of Arihant Industries Limited’s employees. It served check-off documents on 7 March 2025 and a proposed recognition…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E602 OF 2025
(Before Hon. Lady Justice Agnes Kitiku Nzei)
AMALGAMATED UNION OF KENYA
METAL WORKERS CLAIMANT
VERSUS
ARIHANT INDUSTRIES LIMITED ..RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. The Claimant sued the Respondent vide a Memorandum of Claim dated 25th June, 2025 and pleaded:-
(a) that the Claimant is a Trade Union registered under Section 19 of the Labour Relations Act, with mandate to represent employees in the Metal and Motor Trades Sectors.
(b) that the Respondent is a duly registered manufacturer of polythene bags.
(c) that pursuant to Articles 36(1) and 41(2)(c) of the Constitution of Kenya 2010 and Clause 4(1) of the Labour Relations Act 2007, the Respondent organized and recruited 43 employees of the Respondent into its membership; and subsequently served a check off- system (documents) on the Respondent vide a letter dated 7th March, 2025, instructing the Respondent to deduct and remit Trade Union dues to the Claimant pursuant to Section 48 (1) & (2) of the Labour Relations Act.
(d) that despite service of the check off system documents as afore-stated, the Respondent remained defiant, and never executed the instructions on deduction and remittance of union dues.
(e) that under cover of a letter dated 24th March, 2025, the Claimant sent to the Respondent a standard formal Recognition Agreement for joint signing on 2nd April, 2025, but the Respondent declined to sign the same.
(f) that subsequently, the Claimant forwarded a Trade Dispute to the Labour Cabinet Secretary for conciliation.
(g) that there were reasonable grounds to confirm that employees were being threatened, harassed, intimidated and coerced against union membership.
2. The Claimant sought the following reliefs:-
(a) that a finding be made that the Respondent’s refusal to sign a Recognition Agreement contravened Section 54(1) of the Labour Relations Act, and that an order be made that the Respondent signs a Recognition Agreement with the Claimant Union within 14 das of the Court’s Judgment.
(b) that a finding be made that the Respondent’s refusal to deduct union dues contravened Section 48 of the Labour Relations Act, and that an order be made that the Respondent deducts and remits union dues within a month of the date of Judgment.
(c) An order that the Respondent pays the Claimant accumulated trade union dues that ought to have been paid from its own money.
(d) An order that costs of the suit be in favour of the Claimant.
(e) Any other relief that the Court may deem fit.
3. Documents filed alongside the Memorandum of Claim included an affidavit in verification of the claim and a list of documents dated 25th June, 2025, listing 4 documents. The listed documents included check-off system documents and a covering letter, a standard draft recognition agreement and a covering letter, and letters by the conciliator.
4. The suit was filed contemporaneously with an urgent Notice of Motion dated 25th June, 2025, but which the Claimant subsequently withdrew on 3rd December, 2025.
5. The Respondent filed a Statement of Response and pleaded:-
(a) that the Claimant Trade Union is registered to represent employees in the motor sector, metal workers and auto ancillaries as stated in their letter to the Respondent dated 24th March, 2025, which forms part of the Claimant’s documents/exhibits filed herein.
(b) that the Respondent operates in the Plastic and Chemical Manufacturing Sector; which falls outside the scope of the Claimant’s mandate.
(c) that under Section 54(1) of the Labour Relations Act, a Union can only be recognised for purposes of collective bargaining where it represents a simple majority of unionisable employees within the sector for which it is registered. That the Claimant does not fall within the Respondent’s sector.
(d) that pursuant to Section 48(2) of the Labour Relations Act, an employer is only obligated to deduct and remit trade union dues upon receipt of valid check-off forms from a properly mandated Trade Union. That since the Claimant does not cover the Respondent’s sector, any such deduction would be contrary to the law, and therefore unlawful.
(e) that the Respondent denied harassing, intimidating or coercion of employees; and that it respected employees’ constitutional right and freedom of association under Articles 36 and 41 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010.
(f) that the Claimant’s suit be dismissed in its entirety, with costs.
6. On 3rd December, 2025, the Court directed that the suit herein determined pursuant to Rule 59 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules 2024; and ordered both parties to file and serve their respective witness affidavits and written submissions.
7. Having perused the pleadings, documents and witness affidavits filed herein, issues that fall for determination, in my view, are as follows:-
(a) Whether the Claimant is properly suited in the present suit.
(b) Whether the reliefs sought are available to the Claimant.
8. On the first issue, the Claimant pleaded at paragraph 1 of its Memorandum of Claim that “its mandate is to represent employees in the Metal and Motor Trades Sectors”; while the Respondent “is a manufacturer of polythene and bags”.
9. On its part, the Respondent pleaded that the Claimant Trade Union is registered to represent employees in the motor sector, metal workers and auto ancillaries, according to documents filed by the Claimant. That the Respondent operates in the plastic and chemical sector which falls outside the scope of the Claimant’s registered mandate; and that any deduction of union dues in favour of the Claimant, under the circumstances, would be contrary to the law and therefore unlawful.
10. In view of the foregoing pleadings by both parties, there is a clear agreement on the fact that the Respondent does not fall within the sector for which the Claimant Trade Union is registered. It is trite that parties are always bound by their pleadings as presented by them to a Court of law.
11. It was stated as follows in the case of Daniel Otieno Migore – vs – South Nyanza Sugar Company Limited [2018] eKLR:-
“It is now well settled by precedent that parties are bound by their pleadings and that evidence which tends to be at variance with the pleadings is for rejection. Pleadings are the bedrock upon which all the proceedings derive from. It hence follows that any evidence adduced in a matter must be in consonance with the pleadings. Any evidence, however strong, that tends to be at variance with the pleadings must be disregarded. That settled position was re-affirmed by the Court of Appeal in the case of Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & Another – vs – Stephen Mutinda Mule & 3 Others [2014] eKLR, which cited with approval the decision of the Supreme Court of Nigeria in Adetoun Oladeji [NIG] – vs – Nigeria Breweries PLC SC 91/2002 where Adereji, JSC expressed himself thus on the importance of pleadings:-
“. . . it is now a trite principle in law that parties are bound by their own pleadings and that any evidence led by any of the parties which does not support the averments in the pleadings, or put in another way, which is at variance with the averments of the pleadings goes to no issue and must be disregarded . . .”
12. Under Section 14 of the Labour Relations Act, one of the mandatory requirements for registration of a trade union is a constitution that has been adopted by the trade union, and which complies with the Act. Section 14(e) of the Act provides as follows:-
“(e) Subject to sub-section (2), only members in a sector specified in the Constitution qualify for membership of the trade union”.
13. Among the documents annexed to the Respondent’s witness affidavit is a copy of the Claimant’s constitution as presented to the Registrar of Trade Unions at the time of the Claimant’s registration.
14. Clause 2 of the Claimant’s said Constitution provides as follows:-
“(i) Membership of the Union shall be drawn from persons employed in any undertaking or part of an undertaking which consists in the carrying on for gain of one or more of the following activities:-
• Motor Trade Group.
• Electrical and Electronic Trades.
• Tyre Manufacturers or Retreading Group.
• Battery Manufacturing group.
• Allied industries to the Metal Trade.”
15. The Claimant’s said constitution, whose authenticity the Claimant did not question, does not mention/include plastic, paper and chemical manufacturing, which is shown to be the Respondent’s Sector. The Claimant could not, therefore, claim to have lawfully and validly recruited members from a Sector which it is not mandated to cover. Any purported recruitment of “members” outside its lawfully mandated sector was unlawful, null and void.
16. The Respondent’s refusal to deduct union dues in favour of the Claimant and to remit them to the Claimant cannot be faulted, and no cause of action accrued to the Claimant from such refusal.
17. Further, the Claimant is non-suited, in view of the foregoing; and the suit herein is an abuse of this Court’s process.
18. Having made the foregoing finding, I will not delve into the second issue, as doing so will be a mere academic exercise.
19. In the upshot, and having considered written submissions filed by both parties herein, the Claimant’s suit herein is hereby dismissed.
20. Each party shall bear its own costs of the suit.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS
25TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
AGNES KITIKU NZEI
JUDGE
ORDER
This Judgment has been delivered via Microsoft Teams Online Platform. A signed copy will be availed to each party upon payment of the applicable Court fees.
AGNES KITIKU NZEI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Mr. Ondiege for the Claimant
Mr. Sumaria for the Respondent