REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELCEPCC NO. E015 OF 2026
_____________________________________________________________________________
PAA BROTHERS CO. LTD - APPLICANT
VS
TOGETHER INVESTMENTS LTD - 1ST RESPONDENT
FIRST ARTISTS VENTURES LTD - 2ND RESPONDENT
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY - 3RD RESPONDENT
COUNTY EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
MEMBER- BUILT ENVIRONMENT
AND URBAN PLANNING - 4TH RESPONDENT
PATRICK MBOGO - 5TH RESPONDENT
PATRICK ANALO AKIVAGA - 6TH RESPONDENT
NATIONAL CONSTRUCTION AUTHORITY - 7TH RESPONDENT
NATIONAL ENVIRONMENT
MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY - 8TH RESPONDENT
RULING
(In respect of the Plaintiff’s application dated 14/4/2026)
1. This application is brought pursuant to Articles 26, 28, 40, 42, 66, 69 and 70 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010, Section 3 of the Environmental Management and Co-ordination Act [EMCA], Sections 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act 2010, and Orders 11, 14 and 40, Rules 1, 2, 3 and 4, and Order 51, Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2010. In the main, the Plaintiff prays for orders that:
1) Pending hearing and determination of this suit, this Honourable Court be pleased to issue temporary orders of injunction restraining the 1st and 2nd Defendants/Respondents, their agents, servants, architects, engineers and contractor from undertaking any or any further development or construction works on the property known as L.R. No. 3734/1450-Valley Arcade, Muthangari Road off Gitanga Road, Nairobi City County.
2) An order be and is hereby made compelling the 3rd, 4th, 5th and 6th Respondents jointly and/or severally to ensure compliance with prayers (2) and (3) above.
3) The OCS Muthangari Police Station or any other Station be and is hereby ordered to provide security during the enforcement of the orders granted herein.
4) Pending the hearing and determination of this suit, the 1st and 2nd Defendants/Respondents do produce and hand over to the Plaintiff/Applicant the following copies of documents to wit:
a. The Planning Brief/Report on the proposed development on L.R. No. 3734/1450-Valley Arcade, Muthangari Road (the subject property) prepared by a Registered and Licensed Physical Planner and the date of preparation.
b. Particulars and details on Application for Development Permission (Planning Application) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/1A that was duly submitted to the County Executive Committee Member (hereafter CECM), with clear date of the application.
c. Particulars and details on Application for Development Permission (Change of User) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/1A that was duly submitted to the CECM, with clear date of the application.
d. Particulars and details on Application for Development Permission (Subdivision) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/1A that was duly submitted to the CECM, with clear date of the application.
e. Details and particulars on Application for Development Permission (Demolition) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/1A that was duly submitted to the CECM, with clear date of the application.
f. Details and particulars on Application for Development Permission (Building Plan) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/1B that was duly submitted to the CECM, with clear date of the application.
g. Details and Particulars on Notification for Proposed Subdivision in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/2 received from the CECM.
h. Details and Particulars on Notification for Proposed Change of User/Densification of Use in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/3 received from the CECM.
i. Details and Particulars on Application/s for Development Permission (Building) Plan) in Prescribed Forms PLUPA/DC/5 (Submission Certificate/s) received from the CECM.
j. Details and Particulars on Authority to Issue Development Permission and Other Development Control Instruments in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/1G addressed to the County Director of Physical and Land Use Planning by the CECM, with copies to the National Land Commission, the Land Registrar and the Director of Surveys, requesting them to consider the Application/s for Development Permission/s (Change of User, Subdivision, Demolition and Building).
k. Invoice or invoices, and also receipt/s of payments of revised ground rent of the proposed Change of User and/or Subdivision as determined by the Director of Valuations, National Land Commission and/or the Land Registrar.
l. Copy of Invoice, and copy of receipt of Payment of revised rates of the proposed Change of User and/or Subdivision as determined by the Director of Valuations- County Government of Nairobi.
m. Copy of the title issued by the Land Registrar upon approval of the application for Change of User together with the new Deed Plan.
n. Letter/Licence from NEMA to the CECM, approving and/or giving conditions on demolition on the existing buildings and Structures on the subject property.
o. Copy of clear and legible Building Plan submitted in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/1B to the CECM.
p. Copy of clear and legible Site Plan submitted to the CECM.
q. Copy of clear and legible Structural/Civil/Engineering Drawings submitted in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/1C to the CECM with clear date of submission.
r. Copy of clear and legible Electrical Engineer’s drawings and specifications of the proposed development submitted to the CECM, with clear date of submission.
s. Copy of clear and legible Mechanical and Plumbing drawings and specifications of the proposed development submitted to the CECM.
t. Copy of clear and legible Architectural Drawings and Specifications of the proposed development/diversification of the Property submitted to the CECM.
u. Copy of clear and legible Sectional Plan of the proposed development/diversification contained in the Architectural drawings, with the duly approved and registered Sectional Units with their various Land Reference Numbers submitted to the CECM.
v. Legible Civil and Structural Engineer’s drawings and specifications of the proposed development/diversification submitted to the CECM.
w. Copies of titles of all the units of the Proposed Residential Apartment issued by the Lands Registrar and approved by the CECM.
x. Copy of approval/permit to demolish the existing buildings and other Structures on the Subject property in the Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/8 issued by the CECM, with clear date of approval.
y. Copy of Notification of Approval of Application (Building) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/8 from the CECM.
z. Copy of Commencement Notice for Development in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/14 issued by the CECM with copies to the National Construction Authority, Architectural Association of Kenya, Kenya Institute of Planners and the Institution of Surveyors of Kenya.
5) Pending the hearing and determination of this suit, the 3rd, 4th, 5th and 6th Defendants/Respondents produce and hand over to the Plaintiff/Applicant copies of the following documents to wit:
a. Copy of Application for Development Permission (Planning) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/1A that was duly submitted to the County Executive Committee Member (hereafter CECM) by the owner of the subject property, with clear date of submission stating the aspect of the proposed development (Subdivision, Extension of Lease or Use or Change of User, Densification, Demolition or Easements and Wayleaves), together with a Planning Brief prepared by a registered and licensed Physical Planner.
b. Copy of Application for Development Permission) (Building Plan) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/1B submitted by the owner, together with copy of title and copy of the Gazette Notice/Public Notice on the proposed development.
c. Copy of Gazette Notice and/or any other Notice on the proposed development (Sub-division, Densification Demolition and Building) circulated by the owner/developer of the suit property, informing and seeking public opinion on the proposed development.
d. Minutes of meeting/s held by the owner/developer of the suit property, with names of members of the public who attended the meeting/s, and the resolutions made on the Application for Development Permission.
e. Legible Architectural Drawings and specifications of the proposed development/diversification.
f. Legible Civil and Structural Engineer's drawings and specifications of the proposed development.
g. Legible Electrical Engineer's drawings and specifications of the proposed development.
h. Legible Mechanical and Plumbing drawings and specifications of the proposed development.
i. Copy of Notification for Proposed Subdivision in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/2 by owner or Registered Physical Planner, with dates of the first and second advertisements, together with records on inspections of the plan and/or submissions of representations and objections to the proposed Subdivision.
j. Copy of Notification for Proposed Subdivision, Demolition and Densification in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/3 issued by the CECM.
k. Copy of Public Notice on Notification of Densification and Subdivision in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/4, and details/particulars of its publication, including in the Kenya Gazette.
l. Copy of Submission Certificate in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/5 issued by the Department/Section of Physical and Land Use Planning, together with details and particulars of the Applicant.
m. Copy of Circulation Sheet in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/6A duly circulated to the various departments and agencies, with or without their comments/views.
n. Copy of Circulation Sheet (Building Plan) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/6B duly circulated to the various departments, with or without their comments/views.
o. Copy of General Circulation Register in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/7A, duly circulated to the various departments and County Government Sections.
p. Copy of Building Plans (Circulation Register) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/7B duly circulated amongst the various departments, with or without their comments.
q. Copy of Application for a Sectional Plan of the proposed Building prepared by a Surveyor, and also particulars on dates when the Sectional Plan was submitted to the County Government by the Land Registrar.
r. Details and particulars on registration of the Sectional Plan by the Lands Registrar.
s. Details and particulars on the separate register opened for each Unit in the Sectional Plan, and also details and particulars of certificates of title issued in respect of each Unit, and of the Common Areas, of the Sectional Property.
t. Letter/s or comments from (i) County Director of Physical and Land Use Planning, (ii) National Land Commission (iii) Land Registrar and (iv) Director of Surveys on the review or comments on the Application for Development Permission (Densification and/or Subdivision).
u. Document/s or Letter/s from the National Land Commission with comments and/or approval on the Application for Development Permission on Densification and/or Application for Development Permission on Subdivision of the suit property.
v. Document/s or Letter/s from the Director of Survey with comments and/or approval on the Application for Development Permission on Densification and/or Application for Development Permission on Subdivision of the suit property.
w. Document/s or Letter/s from the Land Registrar, Nairobi with comments and/or approvals on the Application for Development Permission (Densification) and/or Application for Development Permission (Subdivision) of the suit property.
x. Document on Valuation of the suit property before, and after consideration by the National Land Commission and the Land Registrar on the proposed Densification and/or Subdivision.
y. Invoice or invoices, and also receipt/s of payment of revised ground rent of the proposed Densification and/or Subdivision as determined by the Director of Valuations, National Land Commission and/or the Land Registrar.
z. Copy of invoice, and copy of receipt of payment of revised rates of the proposed Densification and/or Subdivision as determined by the Director of Valuations- County Government of Nairobi.
aa. Copy of the title issued by the Land Registrar upon approval of the Application for Development Permission (Densification and or Subdivision) together with the new Deed Plan.
ab. Letter by CECM to the National Environment Management Authority (NEMA) requesting them to review or comment on the Application for Development Permission (Demolition) of the suit property.
ac. Letter/Licence from NEMA to CECM, approving and/or giving conditions on Demolition on the existing buildings and structures on the subject property.
ad. Copy of Notification of Approval of Development Permission (Demolition) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/8 issued to the owner of the suit property.
ae. Copy of Notification of Approval of Development Permission (Densification) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/8 issued to the owner of the suit property.
af. Copy of Notification of Approval of Development Permission (Subdivision) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/8 issued to the owner of the suit property.
ag. Copy of Notification of Approval of Development Permission (Building) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/8 issued to the owner of the suit property.
ah. Copy of Commencement Notice for Development) (Demolition) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/14 issued to the owner/developer/contractor of the approved proposed development on the suit property.
ai. Copy of Commencement Notice for Development) (Building) in Prescribed Form PLUPA/DC/14 issued to the owner/developer/contractor of the approved proposed development on the suit property.
6) Costs of this application be provided for.
2. The application is premised on the face of it and supported by the affidavit of Schon Noorani, the Chairman and one of the Directors of the Plaintiff/Applicant. The deponent avers that the Plaintiff is a lessee of L.R. No. 3734/22, situated along Muthangari Road in Lavington, and that flats have been developed thereon. He further deposes that the adjacent suit property, L.R. No. 3734/1450, is registered to the 1st Defendant. He further states that the two parcels fall within a historically low-density residential zone governed by the Nairobi City County Development Control Policy 2021. Notwithstanding this zoning framework, the Plaintiff contends that in June 2024 the existing five-bedroom maisonnette on the suit property was demolished and excavation commenced for a proposed high-density development comprising 44 three-bedroom and 22 two-bedroom apartments, a community hall, a gym, and a children’s playground, purportedly approved by the 3rd Defendant. The Plaintiff asserts that these actions contravene the applicable zoning regulations and development control policies.
3. The deponent states that upon learning in late February 2026 of ongoing construction at level 16 on the suit property, he conducted investigations that revealed the 1st and 2nd Respondents failed to apply for or obtain the mandatory development permissions, demolition approvals, and environmental impact assessments required under the Physical and Land Use Planning Act (PLUPA) 2019 and EMCA. Despite purported approvals from the 3rd to 8th Respondents, no public participation was conducted and no stakeholder comments were sought. He asserts that the approvals were issued in total breach of the law and the express requirements of the Ministry for Lands, Public Works, Housing and Urban Development.
4. It is argued that the ongoing construction by the 1st and 2nd Respondents is illegal, unprocedural, and in violation of the proposed Nairobi City Development Control Policy 2021 regarding plot ratio, coverage, and skyline. The deponent avows that, despite bringing this to the attention of the 3rd to 8th Respondents, no action has been taken to halt the development. Requests for relevant documentation have likewise been unsuccessful. The Applicant avers that the construction has caused irreparable damage to their property, including blocked natural light and air, destroyed solar systems and water tanks, and permanent environmental degradation. Consequently, he asserts that their fundamental rights to life, human dignity, and a clean and healthy environment have been infringed, turning their lives upside down, causing immeasurable emotional distress to their families, and necessitating restoration costs.
1st and 2nd Defendants’ Replying Affidavit
5. In the Reply Affidavit sworn by Leonard Limo on 5/5/2026, on behalf of the 1st and 2nd Defendants, it is averred that the 1st Defendant, the previous registered owner of the suit property in Kilimani, transferred title to Arcade Haven Apartments Limited. Subsequently, in 2014, the 1st Defendant initiated a residential development and, in compliance with the Physical and Land Use Planning Act [PLUPA] , successfully applied for a change of use from a single to a multi-dwelling unit, which was approved on 7/6/2024. It is deposed that, following this, the 1st Defendant secured the necessary approvals for a 13-level building, completed an Environmental Impact Assessment, and obtained both an EIA Licence and a Certificate of Compliance from the relevant statutory bodies. Construction proceeded lawfully, and later alterations to add two levels were also approved, resulting in a 15-level building that remains within the permissible zoning limits for the area.
6. The deponent avers that the ongoing development fully complies with all applicable legal frameworks, including the National Construction Authority Act and the Nairobi City Development Control Policy. It is contended that the Plaintiff's application lacks merit, as there is no evidence of illegality, injury, or a prima facie case warranting injunctive relief. The deponent asserts that the Plaintiff has approached the Court with unclean hands, having delayed complaints until the project is nearly complete, thereby threatening the 1st and 2nd Defendants with substantial financial prejudice exceeding Kshs. 409 Million. Consequently, it is prayed that the Court dismiss the application with costs.
3rd and 4th Defendants’ Replying Affidavit
7. The 3rd and 4th Defendants opposed the application by the Replying Affidavit of Wilfred Wanyonyi Masinde, the Deputy Director, Development Inspection and Planning Litigation of Nairobi City County, the 3rd Defendant herein, dated 10/7/2026. The 3rd and 4th Defendants assert that the impugned development on L.R. No. 3734/1450 was constructed with all necessary legal approvals, including a change of use, building plan approval, and subsequent approval for alterations, all issued by Nairobi City County and other relevant authorities. They further assert that these approvals were processed in strict compliance with the Physical and Land Use Planning Act (PLUPA), with public notices, circulation to technical departments, and statutory scrutiny. The project site board prominently displayed these approval particulars, and the development's height of 15 levels falls within the 16-level limit prescribed for the applicable Zone 4B (Muthangari). They argue that the Plaintiff's claim of illegality is unsupported by any evidence of fraud, malice, or official revocation of the approvals, and that the approvals remain legally valid under the presumption of validity.
8. The 2nd and 3rd Defendants further argue that the Plaintiff's assertions, such as excessive plot ratio, obstruction of light, and damage to property, are bare conclusions unsupported by any technical evidence, such as structural engineer reports, valuation assessments, or expert opinions. They note that the Plaintiff relies on a photograph of a site board obtained from a casual worker and on subjective visual impressions of the building's height, which cannot displace the official statutory records. Additionally, the Defendants point out that the Plaintiff waited nearly two years after construction commenced to file the present Notice of Motion in April 2026, offering no satisfactory explanation for this considerable delay.
9. The deponent reiterates that the 1st Defendant has transferred all rights, title, and interest in the suit property to Arcade Haven Apartments Limited, the Management Company, which is now the registered proprietor. This entity, along with the purchasers of individual units, stands to be directly and substantially affected by the orders sought, yet the Plaintiff has neither joined them as parties to the proceedings nor served them with the Court documents. It is argued that granting the injunctive relief in their absence would violate the rules of natural justice and the cardinal principle that no person should be condemned unheard.
10. The deponent asserts that the Plaintiff has failed to establish a prima facie case with a probability of success or to demonstrate irreparable injury, as the application invites the Court to restrain statutory power without proof of any wrongdoing. They argue that the orders sought would effectively determine the substantive dispute at an interlocutory stage, exposing public officers to enforcement actions and potential compensation claims before a full hearing. Emphasising that the Plaintiff's dissatisfaction as a neighbouring proprietor does not render a lawful approval illegal, they urge the Court to dismiss the application with costs, as it is bereft of factual and legal merit.
The Submissions
11. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions, as directed by the Court. The Plaintiff’s submissions are dated 10/7/2026, whereas the 1st and 2nd Defendants’ submissions are dated 11/7/2026. By contrast, the 3rd and 4th Defendants’ submissions are dated 13/7/2026. The Court has read and considered both the written submissions and the highlights.
Analysis and determination
12. I have carefully read and considered all the filed pleadings, the written submissions, the cited authorities relied on, and the relevant provisions of the appropriate and enabling laws with regard to the instant application. I have framed the following salient issues for determination;
a. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the orders sought in the application.
b. Who shall bear the costs of the application?
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the orders sought in the application
13. The Plaintiff has sought numerous prayers. I will address each order sequentially.
14. The first substantive prayer is for an order of temporary injunction. Has Plaintiff/Applicant met the criteria for the grant of an order of temporary injunction pending the hearing and determination of this suit?
15. The guiding principles for the grant of orders of temporary injunction are well settled and are set out in the judicial decision of Giella versus Cassman Brown (1973) EA 358. This position has been reiterated in numerous decisions of Kenyan Courts, particularly in the case of Nguruman Limited versus Jan Bonde Nielsen & 2 others, CA No. 77 of 2012 (2014) eKLR, where the Court of Appeal held that;
“in an interlocutory injunction application, the Applicant has to satisfy the triple requirements to a, establishes his case only at a prima facie level, b, demonstrates irreparable injury if a temporary injunction is not granted and c, ally any doubts as to b, by showing that the balance of convenience is in his favour.
These are the three pillars on which rest the foundation of any order of injunction interlocutory or permanent. It is established that all the above three conditions and states are to be applied as separate distinct and logical hurdles which the Applicant is expected to surmount sequentially”.
16. Consequently, the Plaintiff ought first to establish a prima facie case. The Plaintiff/Applicant submitted that they have established a prima facie case and relied on the judicial decision of Mrao Ltd versus First American Bank of Kenya Ltd (2003) EKLR, in which the Court of Appeal addressed the issue of a prima facie case. The Court stated that:
“... in civil cases, it is a case in which, on the material presented to the Court a tribunal properly directing itself will conclude that there exists a legal right which has apparently been infringed by the opposite party as to call for an explanation or rebuttal from the latter.”
17. Secondly, the Petitioner has to demonstrate that irreparable injury will be occasioned to them if an order of temporary injunction is not granted. The judicial decision of Pius Kipchirchir Kogo Vs Frank Kimeli Tenai (2018) eKLR provides an explanation for what is meant by irreparable injury and it states;
“Irreparable injury means that the injury must be one that cannot be adequately compensated for in damages and that the existence of a prima facie case is not itself sufficient. The Applicant should further show that irreparable injury will occur to him if the injunction is not granted and there is no other remedy open to him by which he will protect himself from the consequences of the apprehended injury.”
18. Thirdly, the Petitioner has to demonstrate that the balance of convenience tilts in their favour. In the case of Pius Kipchirchir Kogo vs Frank Kimeli Tenai (2018) EKLR which defined the concept of balance of convenience as:
‘The meaning of balance of convenience will favour of the Plaintiff' is that if an injunction is not granted and the Suit is ultimately decided in favour of the Plaintiffs, the inconvenience caused to the Plaintiff would be greater than that which would be caused to the Defendants if an injunction is granted but the suit is ultimately dismissed. Although it is called balance of convenience it is really the balance of inconvenience and it is for the Plaintiffs to show that the inconvenience caused to them will be greater than that which may be caused to the Defendants. If inconvenience be equal, it is the Plaintiff who will suffer.
In other words, the Plaintiff has to show that the comparative mischief from the inconvenience which is likely to arise from withholding the injunction will be greater than that which is likely to arise from granting”.
19. In the case of Paul Gitonga Wanjau Vs Gathuthi Tea Factory Company Ltd & 2 others (2016) eKLR, the Court dealing with the issue of balance of convenience expressed itself thus:-
" Where any doubt exists as to the Applicants’ right, or if the right is not disputed, but its violation is denied, the Court, in determining whether an interlocutory injunction should be granted, takes into consideration the balance of convenience to the parties and the nature of the injury which the Respondent on the other hand, would suffer if the injunction was granted and he should ultimately turn out to be right and that which the Applicant, on the other hand, might sustain if the injunction was refused and he should ultimately turn out to be right... Thus, the Court makes a determination as to which party will suffer the greater harm with the outcome of the motion. If Applicant has a strong case on the merits or there is significant irreparable harm, it may influence the balance in favour of granting an injunction. The Court will seek to maintain the status quo in determining where the balance of convenience lies.”
20. The Plaintiff/Applicant’s case is that it learnt in late February 2026 of ongoing construction at level 16 on the suit property. It states that its investigations revealed that the 1st and 2nd Respondents failed to apply for or obtain the mandatory development permissions, demolition approvals, and environmental impact assessments required under the Physical and Land Use Planning Act (PLUPA) 2019 and EMCA. Despite purported approvals from the 3rd to 8th Respondents, no public participation was conducted and stakeholder comments were not sought. He asserts that the approvals were issued in total breach of the law and the express requirements of the Ministry for Lands, Public Works, Housing and Urban Development.
21. In response, the 1st to 4th Defendants aver that the construction was carried out with all necessary legal approvals and licences, including a change of user, building plan approval, and subsequent approval for alterations, all issued by the Nairobi City County and other relevant authorities. The approvals were processed in strict compliance with the law, including public notices, circulation to technical departments, and statutory scrutiny. They further aver that the project site board prominently displayed these approval particulars, and that the development's height of 15 levels falls within the 16-level limit prescribed for the applicable Zone 4B (Muthangari). They argue that the Plaintiff's claim of illegality is unsupported by any evidence of fraud, malice, or official revocation of the approvals, and that the approvals remain legally valid under the presumption of validity. They further aver that, in any case, the subject property has since been transferred to the Management Company and some units sold.
22. Based on the material presented before me, I find that the Applicant has not established a prima facie case with a likelihood of success. It is not in doubt that the subject property has already been developed and even sold to third parties. Evidently, the Plaintiff’s claim is overtaken by events.
23. The Plaintiff has also argued that the approvals and licences issued by the 3rd, 7th and 8th Defendants, if any, were unlawful and irregular. The law governing such approvals and licences is very clear on the procedure for their issuance. For instance, the Physical Land Use Planning Act is very clear on how an aggrieved party should challenge the issuance of building approvals by a County Government. The Plaintiff has not explained why it has not followed that laid-down statutory process.
24. Further, as an injunction is an equitable remedy, the principles of equity apply. In the present case, construction works on the suit property began in 2024. The instant application has been brought after more than 2 years. Equity aids the vigilant and not the indolent. The Plaintiff has not explained why it did not move the Court earlier, but instead waited for the project to be developed and almost completed before arising from slumber to seek the orders it now seeks.
25. Since a prima facie case has not been established against the Respondents, it is unnecessary to consider whether the Applicant will suffer irreparable harm unless the orders sought are granted against them.
26. Regarding the other prayers sought against the 1st to 6th Defendants for the handing over and production of documents, it is my view that the orders are premature at this stage. The Plaintiff has not exhausted the provisions of the Civil Procedure Act, the Evidence Act, and the Access to Information Act regarding pre-trial directions, production, impounding, and discovery of documents. The prayers are dismissed.
27. The upshot is that the Plaintiff’s application dated 14/4/2026 is dismissed in its entirety. The costs of the application shall be in the cause.
28. It is so ordered
DELIVERED, DATED AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026 VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS.
J. G. KEMEI
JUDGE
Delivered Online in the Presence of:
1. Mr. Ndambiri for the Applicant n
2. Mr. Dachi for the 1st and 2nd Respondents
3. Mr. Karenju for the 3rd and 4th Respondents
4. N/A for the 5th -8th Respondents
5. CA- Mr Eglon