REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC NO. E046 OF 2023
__________________________________________________________
HENRY MASI ONDIEKI - PLAINTIFF
VS
ROBERT ASATI OUKO t/a
NDEGE VIEW RESORT - 1ST DEFENDANT
PAUL OWINO OBUONG t/a
WARRETS BAR AND RESTAURANT - 2ND DEFENDANT
EMBAKASI RANCHING CO. LTD. - 3RD DEFENDANT
KENYA DIRECTOR INSTITUTE OF
SURVEYING AND MAPPING - 4TH DEFENDANT
RULING
(In respect of the 2nd Defendant’s application dated 9/6/2025)
1. This matter is slated for Judgment, along with the 2nd Defendant’s application dated 9/6/2025. For context, a brief summary of the chronology of events will suffice. The suit was instituted by the Plaint dated 2/2/2023. The main suit was first slated for hearing on 13/3/2024 but did not proceed in view of the 2nd Defendant’s application dated 12/3/2024 seeking joinder of the 3rd and 4th Defendants. The Court determined the application by the Ruling delivered on 16/5/2024. After joinder and service on the 3rd and 4th Defendants, the matter was listed for pre-trial conference on 27/2/2025. The Court issued pre-trial directions, and the matter was fixed for hearing on 10/6/2025. On the day of the hearing, the Plaintiff’s case was heard, but the Defendants’ case was closed in their absence. When the matter came up on 13/10/2025, counsel for the Plaintiff confirmed the filing of submissions, while counsel for the 1st Defendant informed the Court that a pending application dated 9/6/2025 remained. The Court directed that the application be determined alongside the Judgment.
2. In his application, the 2nd Defendant seeks that his name, PAUL OWINO OBUONG t/a WARRETS BAR AND RESTAURANT, be struck out of this suit. He also prays for costs of the suit.
3. The 2nd Defendant, in his supporting affidavit of even date, contends that he was wrongly joined in the proceedings, as he is merely a tenant rather than the registered lessee of the suit property. He avers that he was not a party to the previous boundary determination in ELC Case No. E062 of 2022, and that he has no direct relationship with the Plaintiff. He further argues that the application is timely, made in good faith, and will not prejudice the Respondent.
The Plaintiff’s Replying Affidavit
4. In his undated Reply Affidavit, the Plaintiff argues that the application is misconceived, frivolous, and an abuse of Court process. He asserts that he is the owner and operator of the suit premises, that he failed to raise this preliminary objection at the earliest opportunity, and that he actively participated in proceedings for over two years without complaint. He contends that raising the issue of misjoinder after the close of pleadings and submissions is procedurally irregular and intended solely to delay justice. He further asserts that the 1st Defendant, being a lessee, shares a joint interest in the subject matter with the lessor. The Respondent further avers that this issue was maliciously raised as an afterthought. Consequently, the Plaintiff urges the Court to dismiss the application on the basis that it is a malicious afterthought and that its disposal will greatly prejudice him.
5. The application was heard orally, and the parties submitted in support of their respective cases.
Analysis and determination
6. The Court has considered the application, the Affidavit in support, the Replying Affidavit, and the oral submissions, and finds that the sole issue for determination is whether the 2nd Defendant is a necessary party to this suit.
7. Order 2 Rule 15 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010 permits a party to apply for striking out of pleadings and provides as follows: -
“At any stage of the proceedings the Court may order to be struck out or amended any pleading on the ground that—
a. It discloses no reasonable cause of action or defence in law; or
b. It is scandalous, frivolous or vexatious; or
c. It may prejudice, embarrass or delay the fair trial of the action; or
d. It is otherwise an abuse of the process of the Court, and may order the suit to be stayed or dismissed or judgment to be entered accordingly, as the case may be.”
8. On this issue, the Court is guided by Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules which states:
“The Court may at any stage of the proceedings, either upon or without the application of either party, and on such terms as may appear to the Court to be just, order that the name of any party improperly joined, whether as Plaintiff or Defendant, be struck out, and that the name of any person who ought to have been joined, whether as Plaintiff or Defendant, or whose presence before the Court may be necessary in order to enable the Court effectually and completely to adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the suit, be added.”
9. The jurisdiction to strike out is discretionary and must be exercised with care. The applicable test is whether the pleading discloses a bona fide triable issue that merits being ventilated at trial. An applicant seeking to strike out pleadings must show that they are scandalous, frivolous, or vexatious; disclose no reasonable cause of action in law; or constitute an abuse of the Court's process and are likely to prejudice, embarrass, or delay the fair trial of the suit.
10. Prior to proceeding with the first issue, it is imperative that the Court briefly set out the background to this matter. For relevance, the suit before the Court was initiated by a Plaint dated 14/12/2020. In summary, the Plaintiff avers that he is the registered Lessee (owner) of all that property known as NAIROBI/BLOCK 105/4348, the suit property. He further avers that the Defendants have jointly and severally unlawfully trespassed on his land since March 2016, thereby depriving him of quiet possession of the suit property.
11. The 2nd Defendant seeks this Court to strike out its name from this suit for the reason that he is a mere tenant and not the registered lessee of the suit property. He asserts that he has no direct relationship with the Plaintiff whatsoever; hence, his name should be struck out from the proceedings.
12. The Plaintiff, on the other hand, maintains that the 2nd Defendant, being a lessee, shares a joint interest in the subject matter with the lessor. Furthermore, the Respondent avers that this issue was maliciously raised as an afterthought.
13. Black’s Law Dictionary, 10th Edition, at page 1642, defines trespass as unlawful acts committed against the person or property of another, especially wrongful entry onto another's land.
14. The provision of Section 3 (1) of the Trespass Act, Cap. 294 provides that:
“Any person who without reasonable excuse enters, is or remains upon or erects any structure on, or cultivates or tills or grazes stock or permits stock to be on, private land without the consent of the occupier thereof shall be guilty of an offence.”
15. The Plaintiff’s right is to take cognisance of the provisions of Sections 24(b), 25 and 26 of the Land Registration Act, 2012. The rights, interests and privileges set out in those provisions are accorded to a registered proprietor of land and apply to the Plaintiff in this case, having established that he is the proprietor of the suit property.
16. The Court of Appeal in the case Jamal Salim vs Yusuf Abdulahi Abdi & another (2018) eKLR and stated that;
“In the text Clerk & Lindsell on Torts, Sweet & Maxwell, 18th Edition, at page 923, trespass to land is defined as follows:- "Trespass to land consists of any unjustifiable intrusion by one person upon land in the possession of another. At page 927 of the same text discusses who may sue for trespass and it states as follows: - “Trespass is actionable at the suit of the person in possession of land, who can claim damages or injunction, or both... Similarly, a person in possession can sue although he is neither owner nor derives title from the owner, and indeed may be in possession adverse to the owner.” It is therefore not necessary for one to establish ownership of land to sustain a claim for trespass. It is enough that the person suing is in possession.”
17. I have reviewed the 2nd Defendant’s Statement of Defence dated 12/4/2023. He avers that the boundary dispute arose from confusing maps provided by the initial Landlord, Embakasi Ranching Co Limited, and asserts that all landowners, except the Plaintiff, have agreed on the boundaries and access roads. He denies obstructing the Plaintiff’s plot, which is adjacent to the main road and has direct access, and contends that the Plaintiff refused an alternative access route negotiated by the residents’ association.
18. From the pleadings herein, it is clear that the Plaintiff has a cause of action against the 2nd Defendant. Whether the Plaintiff will ultimately prove trespass against the 2nd Defendant, who is the 1st Defendant’s tenant, is immaterial at this stage. The test is not whether the Plaintiff will succeed, but whether he is entitled to be heard.
19. The power under Order 1 Rule 10(2) to strike out a party must be exercised judiciously and only where it is clear that the party has been improperly joined and that no relief can possibly lie against them. That threshold has not been met. Striking out the 2nd Defendant at this stage would prematurely deprive the Plaintiff of the opportunity to ventilate his grievance.
20. In view of the 1st Defendant’s application dated 2/7/2026, seeking to arrest the judgment and to be permitted to defend himself, the Court shall not proceed to write the judgment until that application has been heard and determined.
21. Accordingly, I find as follows:
a. The Notice of Motion dated 9/6/2025 is bereft of merit, and the same is hereby dismissed.
b. The 2nd Defendant shall remain a party to the suit.
c. Costs of the application shall be in the cause.
22. It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026 THROUGH MICROSOFT TEAMS.
J G KEMEI
JUDGE
Delivered in the presence of;
1. N/A for the Plaintiff
2. Mr. Getanda for the 1st Defendant
3. N/A for the 1st - 3rd Defendants
4. C/A – Mr Eglon