REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELCPET NO. E048 OF 2021 AS CONSOLIDATED WITH
ELC PETITION NO. E050 OF 2021
NELSON OCHIENG...................................................................1ST PETITIONER
ROSE ANYANGO……………………….......................………………….2ND PETITIONER
CHRISTOPHER OTIENO……………….......................……………….3RD PETITIONER
JOSHUA MUTHEGI………………………….......................……………4TH PETITIONER
MUKURU VUMILIA COMMUNITY
BASED ORGANISATION…………...........………………………………..5TH PETITIONER
(Suing on their own behalf and on behalf of their
families and all the members of the over 2000 residents
of Mukuru Kwa Njenga Residential Area)
VERSUS
THE NAIROBI METROPOLITAN SERVICE..............................1ST RESPONDENT
COUNTY GOVERNMENT OF NAIROBI..................................2ND RESPONDENT
MINISTRY OF INTERIOR & COORDINATION
OF NATIONAL GOVERNMENT………................…………………..3RD RESPONDENT
KENYA URBAN ROADS AUTHORITY…..…......................…….4TH RESPONDENT
MINISTRY OF LANDS &
PHYSICAL PLANNING……………………….....………………………..5TH RESPONDENT
NATIONAL LAND COMMISSION……………....................………6TH RESPONDENT
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL…………………......................……….7TH RESPONDENT
ORBIT CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES LIMITED…...................……8TH RESPONDENT
DOMINIC NJUGUNA NDUNG’U & 206 OTHERS…...................…RESPONDENTS
AND
ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL
RIGHTS CENTRE (HAKIJAMII)………......…………………1ST INTERESTED PARTY
KATIBA INSTITUTE………………………......................…..2ND INTERESTED PARTY
LEGAL ADVICE CENTRE T/A
KITUO CHA SHERIA……………......................…………….3RD INTERESTED PARTY
JANE WERU………………………….......................………….4TH INTERESTED PARTY
AND
EDITH VUSHA USIDE…………………………......................………..1ST CONTEMNOR
ANTHONY MWANGI MAINA…………………...................………..2ND CONTEMNOR
ADEN BALLA……………………………………….......................……..3RD CONTEMNOR
RULING
1. Before me is the notice of motion dated 3rd July, 2026 filed by the petitioners/applicants, and it is expressed to be brought under Section 5 of the Judicature Act, Sections 1A,1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules seeking the following orders:-
1. Spent.
2. This honourable court be pleased to find and cite Edith Vusha Uside (the 10th respondent), Antony Mwangi Maina (the 200th respondent) and Aden Balla for being in contempt of the orders of this honourable court issued on 14th February 2022, by knowingly and willfully undertaking and/or continuing with developments and construction on the suit property in contravention of the said orders.
3. This honourable court be pleased to commit Edith Vusha Uside (the 10th respondent), Antony Mwangi Maina (the 200th respondent) and Aden Balla to civil jail for a period of six (6) months, or for such other period as this honourable court may deem just and appropriate or fine them Kshs.200,000 each and/or impose such punitive sanctions as the court may consider necessary to uphold the dignity and authority of the court.
4. The costs of this application be borne by Edith Vusha Uside (the 10th respondent), Antony Mwangi Maina(the 200th respondent) and Aden Balla.
2. The application is premised on the grounds on its face. It is supported by the affidavit of the 1st petitioner/applicant sworn on even date on his behalf and on behalf of the petitioners/applicants. He deposed that on 14th February 2022 this court issued binding conservatory orders preserving the prevailing status quo of the suit property and expressly prohibited further developments, constructions and settlement thereon. These orders remain subsisting and have neither been reviewed or set aside. He deposed that notwithstanding the existence of these orders, the 10th, 200th respondent, and Aden Balla have deliberately entered into the suit property and erected permanent structures thereon in flagrant and calculated violation of the court’s orders.
3. The 1st petitioner/applicant deposed that the contemnors are not strangers to these proceedings as they have actively participated in this matter and are fully aware of the scope of the conservatory orders in place. Despite protests by the petitioners/applicants, the contemnors have persisted with the illegal developments including mobilizing goons to attack residents who attempted to stop the illegal developments. Further, and as a result several residents sustained injuries, and they reported the assault at Mukuru police post.
4. It was deposed that if such blatant disobedience is permitted to continue, it will undermine the public confidence in the administration of justice and alter the character and substratum of the dispute.
5. The 10th respondent/1st contemnor filed the replying affidavit sworn on 9th July, 2026 on her behalf and on behalf of the 2nd and 3rd contemnors. She deposed that the orders issued on 14th February, 2022 directed that status quo be maintained with regard to their occupation and access to the suit property, and that they cannot be guilty of disobeying court orders which granted them the right to the title, occupation and use of the suit property. She further deposed that the interim orders issued on the said date in their favour barred the petitioners/applicants from encroaching, settling or interfering in any manner with their property.
6. The 10th respondent/1st contemnor equally accused the petitioners/applicants of disobeying the same orders and the orders issued on 8th December, 2021 by denying them access and hiring goons to harass them. Despite numerous reports, to the 5th, 6th, 7th and 8th respondents no action has been taken against the petitioners/applicants. She maintained that they are law abiding citizens and have not disobeyed court orders as alleged.
7. The court directed that the application be canvassed through written submissions. None of the respective parties filed their written submissions. Be that as it may, I have considered the application and the reply thereof. The issue for determination is whether the cited parties are in contempt of the court orders issued on 14th April 2022.
8. Section 5(1) of the Judicature Act provides as follows:-
“The High Court and Court of Appeal shall have the same power to punish for contempt of court as is for the time being possessed by the High Court of justice in England and such power shall extend to upholding the authority and dignity of subordinate courts.”
9. From the above, the law is clear that this court has jurisdiction to punish for contempt of court orders where it has been established. In the case of North Tetu Farmers Co. Ltd v Joseph Nderitu Wanjohi [2016] KEHC 7193 (KLR), the court stated that:-
“Writing on proving the elements of civil contempt, learned authors of the book Contempt in Modern New Zealand have authoritatively stated as follows:-
"There are essentially four elements that must be proved to make the case for civil contempt. The applicant must prove to the required standard (in civil contempt cases which is higher than civil cases) that:-
a. the terms of the order (or injunction or undertaking) were clear and unambiguous and were binding on the defendant;
b. the defendant had knowledge of or proper notice of the terms of the order;
c. the defendant has acted in breach of the terms of the order; and
d. the defendant's conduct was deliberate.
Although the proceedings are civil in nature, it is well established that an applicant must prove the elements beyond reasonable doubt, at least higher than the standard in civil cases, the fact that the liberty of the defendant could be affected means that the standard of prove is higher than the standard in civil cases. It is incumbent on the applicant to prove that the defendant's conduct was deliberate in the sense that he or she deliberately or willfully acted in a manner that breached the order.”
10. It is without doubt that the parties in this case particularly the cited contemnors have knowledge of existence of the court orders issued on 14th February, 2022. Order no. 8, 9 and 10 are instructive in this application to the extent that it provides as follows:-
“8. To avoid further conflicts and avert several applications and counter-applications in the matter, there be and is hereby granted an order of status quo over and in respect of the suit property or properties and in particular pertaining to the title, occupation, possession and use of the suit property as at today (14/02/22).
9. For the avoidance of doubt, there shall be no further developments and/or constructions to be carried out on the suit property save for what is already constructed thereon.
10. There shall similarly be no further settlement of people of whatever name on the suit property, save for the once who are currently in occupation and possession thereof and the import and tenor of the court orders herein to be respected by all the parties.”
11. It is necessary to note that this file was consolidated with petition no. E048 of 2021 which is the lead file and the subject of the instant petition deemed as a cross petition. More importantly, the petitioners herein are the respondents in Petition no. E048 of 2021. Having said this, and from a reading of these orders, the said orders were to subsist until the petition is heard and determined. It therefore beats logic for the cited contemnors whom I note have not disputed erecting permanent structures to aver that the orders granted them use of the suit property as at the said date. I say this because the orders were clear that there shall be no further developments/or construction on the suit property save what is already constructed.
12. In my view, there is utter display of disobedience of court orders which is an expression of mockery of the court process. If the cited contemnors equally found the petitioners/ applicants in contempt of the same orders, nothing stopped them from coming to court when they noted the interference of the suit property. Their allegations have come to court late in the day while they seem to have been reported sometime in September 2025 and December 2025. This appears as an afterthought and an attempt to neutralize their actions.
13. Court orders are not issued in vain, and for this reason, they must be respected at all costs. Otherwise, public confidence in the administration of justice will be eroded. In my view, I find that the cited contemnors had knowledge of the existence of these orders which are express in their terms, and they deliberately chose to breach the terms of the orders through disobedience of the same by erecting structures on the suit property. I find there is sufficient reason for the cited contemnors to show cause why they should not be punished for being in contempt of the orders of this court.
14. From the above, I find merit in the notice of motion dated 3rd July 2026, and I grant the following orders:-
i. This court hereby cites Edith Vusha Uside (the 10th respondent), Antony Mwangi Maina (the 200th respondent) and Aden Balla for being in contempt of the orders of this court issued on 14th February 2022.
ii. A notice to show cause is hereby issued to Edith Vusha Uside (the 10th respondent),Antony Mwangi Maina (the 200th respondent) and Aden Balla to explain why they should not be punished.
iii. The said contemnors Edith Vusha Uside (the 10th respondent),Antony Mwangi Maina (the 200th respondent) and Aden Balla to appear in court on 6th November, 2026 failure to which warrants of arrest shall issue.
iv. The costs of this application to be borne by the cited contemnors Edith Vusha Uside (the 10th respondent), Antony Mwangi Maina (the 200th respondent) and Aden Balla.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED VIRTUALLY
THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
HON. MBOGO C.G.
JUDGE
15/10/2026.
In the presence of:
Mr. Benson Agunga - Court assistant
Ms. Otimbo holding brief for Mr. Wanyama for the Applicant
Mr. Okul for the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Contemnors
Mr. Ojuok holding brief for Modi for the 1st Respondent