Background
The petitioners filed the petition dated 2nd June, 2021 seeking the following orders:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The petitioners filed the petition dated 2nd June, 2021 seeking the following orders:-
Paragraph 1 →I find it necessary to point out certain issues. First, the petitioners have not shown that the people who had their structures on Legio Maria ward were specifically from the Nubian community. This paints the image that the orders sought are strictly for the Nubian community which is discriminatory in my view and excludes other communities who live within the trust land and are victims of the demolitions. Secondly, it was necessary to…
Paragraph 26 →The court identified whether public participation preceded the special-planning-area designation and road project; whether demolitions and evictions were lawful and affected Nubian Trust land; whether the 1st and 3rd respondents breached access to information…
The petitioners alleged that 288 acres in Kibra were allocated to the Nubian community in 2017 under grant IR 149108 and managed by the 1st petitioner. They challenged the 2020 special-planning-area declaration and 2021 roadworks and demolitions along Legio…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELCPET NO. E022 OF 2021
IN THE MATTER OF: ARTICLES 2,3(1),10,22(1),23(1) & (3),26,27(1) &(2),28,29,35,40(1)-(3),42(b),43(1),47(1) &(2),48,50(1),56(d) &(e),60(1)(b),63,69(1)(a) &(d),165(3)(b) & (6),232(1) & (2) AND258(1) &(2)(b) OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA
AND
IN THE MATTER OF: RULES 4(1), 10, 13 AND 23(1) OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA (PROTECTION OF RIGHTS AND FUNDAMENTAL FREEDOMS PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE RULES, 2013
AND
IN THE MATTER OF: PHYSICAL AND LAND USE PLANNING ACT, AND THE REGULATIONS MADE THEREUNDER
AND
IN THE MATTER OF: THE ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT AND CO-ORDINATION ACT, 1999 AND THE REGULATIONS MADE THEREUNDER
AND
IN THE MATTER OF: THE URBAN AREAS AND CITIES ACT
AND
IN THE MATTER OF : ACCESS TO INFORMATION ACT
AND
IN THE MATTER OF: PUBLIC SERVICE (VALUES AND PRINCIPLES ACT
AND
IN THE MATTER OF: FAIR ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION ACT
BETWEEN
NUBIAN RIGHTS FORUM..…………….....................………………..1ST PETITIONER
KIBRA NUBIAN COMMUNITY LAND TRUST……..................…2ND PETITIONER
SHAFI ALI HUSSEIN…………………………….....................……….3RD PETITIONER
YASIN MOHAMED BADR, ON HIS OWN BEHALF
AND AS A TRUSTEE OF THE KIBRA NUBIAN
COMMUNITY LAND TRUST……………......................………………4TH PETITIONER
ISMAIL KHAMIS, ON HIS OWN BEHALF
AND AS A TRUSTEE OF THE KIBRA NUBIAN
COMMUNITY LAND TRUST………......................……………………5TH PETITIONER
VERSUS
NAIROBI METROPOLITAN SERVICES..…….....................….…1ST RESPONDENT
COUNTY GOVERNMENT OF
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY………….......………………………………...2ND RESPONDENT
KENYA URBAN ROADS AUTHORITY……....................………..3RD RESPONDENT
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL……………………......................…….4TH RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioners filed the petition dated 2nd June, 2021 seeking the following orders:-
a. A declaration that the actual and intended construction and improvement of roads within the Nubian Trust land and within the special planning area and established pursuant to gazette notice 3432, published on 8 May 2020, is unlawful and occurred in violation of Articles 10, 26, 27, 28, 29, 32, 40, 43, 47, 53, 54, 57, 62 and 67 of the Constitution and Sections 152C, 152F and 152G of the Land Act and Regulations 63,66 and 67 and 70 of the Land Regulations (Legal notice no. 280 of 2017).
b. A declaration that the actual and intended demolitions and evictions within the special planning area violate section 4(1) and 5 of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act.
c. A declaration that the actual and intended demolitions and evictions on Nubian Trust land and within the special planning area violates Section 3(f) & (h) of the County Governments Act, Sections 6 and 11 of the Urban Areas and Cities Act, Section 3(b) of the Public Service (Values and Principles) Act, and Section 4-6 of the Fair Administrative Action Act.
d. A declaration that the respondents have failed to protect the rights of the petitioners and the Nubian community, which is a marginalized community contrary to Article 21(3) of the Constitution, Sections 97, 102 and 103 of the County Governments Act and Section 5 of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act.
e. A declaration that the respondents have violated Article 232 of the Constitution and Sections 3 and 5(2) of the Public Service (Values and Principals) Act.
f. A declaration that the 1st and 3rd respondents violated Article 35 of the Constitution and Sections 4 and 5 of the Access to Information Act by failing to respond to the 3rd,4th and 5th petitioners request for access to information.
g. An order compelling the 1st and 3rd respondents to provide the 3rd,4th and 5th petitioners with the following information:-
1. Information regarding whether any planned roads in Kibra are intended to pass through the 288 acres owned by the Nubian community.
2. A list of all existing or anticipated road projects through areas of Kibra that involve construction or improvement of more than 1km roadway.
3. The names and identifying numbers of any EIA or SEA reports conducted as part of any road works to be conducted in Kibra.
4. Copies of any EIA or SEA reports submitted to the National Environmental Management Authority.
5. Copies of NEMA licenses for any roadworks within Kibra.
6. Copies of any agreement or memoranda of understanding entered into between Nairobi Metropolitan Services or Nairobi City County and the Kenya Urban Roads Authority regarding the construction of roadworks in the Kibra community.
7. Copies of any maps or other documents that identify the location of construction or road upgrades in Kibra.
h. An order prohibiting the respondents either by themselves, assigns, representatives, employees or agents from engaging in any further demolitions and evictions in either the special planning area or on Nubian trust land until the respondents have complied with the requirements for public participation, citizen engagement, and access to information set forth in the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, Urban Areas and Cities Act, County Governments Act and the Access to Information Act, and the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.
i. An order prohibiting the respondents either by themselves, assigns, representatives, employees or agents from any further construction or demolition either the special planning are or on Nubian trust land until the respondents have demonstrated that they have complied with all environmental licensing and planning requirements under the National Environmental Management Act and its accompanying regulations.
j. General damages at a quantum assessed by the court, in compensation for the violation of the 2nd petitioners’ fundamental freedoms under Article 26, 28, 29, 43, 47, 54, 55, 56 and 57 of the Constitution.
k. Exemplary damages against the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents for violating fundamental rights and freedoms and disregarding the guiding principles on leadership and integrity under Article 73(2) of the Constitution as well as the national values and principles under Article 10 of the Constitution.
l. Costs of and incidental to this petition.
m. Any other order that this honourable court deems fit and just to grant in the circumstances.
2. The facts giving rise to this petition is that in 2017, the ministry of lands allocated the Nubian community 288 acres of land in Kibra under grant no. IR 149108 which is managed by the 1st petitioner on behalf of the community, and on 23rd April, 2020 the general director of the 1st respondent declared the informal settlements of Sarang’ombe, Lindi, Makina and Laini Saba as a special planning area vide gazette notice no. 3432 published on 8th May, 2020. Further, that the special planning area includes 288 acres that have been allocated to the Nubian community and that neither the county government or Nairobi metropolitan services engaged in public participation before making the designation.
3. The petitioners contend that the announcement made on 23rd February, 2021 by the director general of Nairobi Metropolitan Services (NMS) was not preceded by public participation, consultative forums, dissemination of information or citizen engagement with persons that would be affected. It followed thereafter that on 1st March 2021, the homes of several members of the Nubian community in Sarang’ombe ward in Soweto west were demolished as part of the road construction and improvement plan. Although these individuals did not live within the Nubian trust land, concerns within the Nubian community was that demolitions may occur within their land. As a result, they wrote letters dated 3rd March, 2021 to the Director General of NMS and to Kenya Urban Roads Authority (KURA) seeking more information but there was no response from them.
4. The petitioners further stated that on 21st May 2021, individuals placed notices in Lindi ward announcing that demolitions would occur, and that the following day, houses were marked for demolition. On 25th May 2020, structures on Legio Maria road were pulled down and by 27th May, significant damage had been done on numerous structures. Thus, they challenge the decision of the 1st respondent to evict the petitioners’ beneficiaries to pave way for the construction of a road that traverses through Lindi, Makina and Laini Saba wards without consultation, and without adhering to procedures laid down under Section 152 G of the Land Act.
5. The petitioners allege violation of Articles 21,10,60(1),27(1) & (2), 28, 35(1) & (3), 40, 42, 41(1)(b) & (d),47, 50, 53(1), 56,69(1) and 232(1) of the Constitution. They also allege violation of Sections 152B,152C,152F and 152G of the Land Act and Regulations 63, 66, 67 and 70 of the Land Regulations 2017, Section 3 of the County Government Acts and Sections 3, 5, 7, 8 and 11 of the Public Service (Values and Principles) Act.
6. In support thereof, the Christopher James Kerkering filed his supporting affidavit sworn on even date. He reiterated the facts of the petition and annexed a copy of the articles following the 1st respondent’s announcement, a copy of the map, and images showing the demolitions and evictions that took place. The 4th petitioner filed two supporting affidavits, one sworn on even date and 27th October, 2022 respectively. He reiterated the facts of the petition. The 3rd petitioner filed his supporting affidavit sworn on even date. He reiterated the facts as presented in the petition. Adei Adam Abdulrahman filed his supporting affidavit sworn on even date. He deposed that on 24th May, he received a phone call from his brother informing him that unknown men had gone to take measurements on Legio Maria road. He confirmed that the structures he owned on the said road were identified as part of the property that would be demolished. According to him, there was no prior notice of the evictions and demolitions.
7. The petition was opposed vide the affidavit of Eng. Thomas Rukenya Karatai, on behalf of the 1st respondent sworn on 23rd June, 2021. He deposed that the petitioners are aggrieved by the proposed road construction along Legio Maria road in Lindi ward under contract no. NCC/WDP/T/362/2019-2020 which was prioritized during stakeholder forum held on 30th August, 2017 for the preparation of FY 2018-2022 county integrated development plan (CIDP) attended by 55 representatives from Lindi ward.
8. The 1st respondent further deposed that the road construction along Legio Maria road in Lindi ward was planned and budgeted under ward development programme for financial year 2020/2021 having been identified and selected by the members of the public residing in that ward. The said process was participatory as it included Nairobi city county, residents of Lindi ward, and their leaders. The 1st respondent deposed that the proposed construction was initiated through a contract between Nairobi city county government and M/s Naskel Africa Ltd long before it was established and before the gazettement of the special planning area. The said construction is part of a larger initiative to improve accessibility in all informal settlements within Nairobi and prevent inaccessibility of emergency services during disaster management. Further, that in a site meeting held on 24th April 2021, it was noted that sections of the road had been encroached by the residents and it was agreed that the contractor would mark the extent of the road reserve and display notice to give way to enforcement.
9. The 1st respondent deposed that since the project was an initiative by local residents, majority of the residents voluntarily removed their structures to pave way for the road. Further, that the road under construction covers 520 metres across Lindi ward and those affected are people who had constructed their houses or structures within the road reserve. In any case, it was deposed, the residents of Lindi ward are supportive of the project, and a private interest cannot override public interest.
10. The petition was further opposed vide the affidavit of Abwao Erick Odhiambo, the county solicitor of the 2nd respondent sworn on 26th July, 2021. The 2nd respondent deposed that construction of Legio Maria road was prioritized on 30th August, 2017 and included in the 2018 to 2022 county integrated development plan “CIDP” a public document within reach of the petitioners and the public. That during the preparation of the CIDP, 55 representatives from Lindi ward attended the public participation and proposed the specific project. The 2nd respondent deposed that the petitioners and all the residents of Lindi ward have been aware of the project which was planned in a public participation forum.
11. The 2nd respondent deposed that the structures on the road were illegal and the access road which presumably functions as a foot path could only have been caused by illegal encroachments on the road. It was further deposed that the impugned development was approved way back in 2017 and falls within the more than 6 months exception window contemplated under Section 52 (1) & (2) of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act.
12. On alleged violations of the law and the Constitution, the 2nd respondent deposed that the objective of the development is to create access of emergency response in times of disaster for the people of Kibra and to connect the area to the southern bypass to ease traffic for all the residents of Nairobi. Further, that this petition has been brought by the private owners of community land and does not represent the sentiments of other residents of Kibra or members of the public. That if there are genuine occupants in the development area, there are mechanisms for their compensation.
13. The petition was canvassed through written submissions. The petitioners filed their written submissions dated 28th September, 2022. The 2nd respondent filed its written submissions dated 14th November, 2025. I have considered the petition, the replies thereof, the affidavit evidence and the written submissions as well as the authorities cited. The issues for determination are as follows:-
i. Whether the designation of the special planning area and the road project were preceded by public participation;
ii. Whether the demolitions and evictions were lawful.
iii. Whether they affected Nubian trust land.
iv. Whether the 1st and 3rd respondents violated the right of access to information;
v. Whether the roadworks complied with environmental licensing requirements.
vi. Whether Articles 10, 21(3), 56 and 232 were breached.
vii. What reliefs and costs should be awarded.
14. It is not in dispute that vide gazette notice dated 8th May 2020, the 1st respondent declared the informal settlements of Sarang’ombe, Lindi, Makina and Laini Saba within Kibra constituency as a special planning area. The gazette notice reads that the purpose of this declaration is to among others enable preparation of a participatory, economically feasible, socially and environmentally sustainable physical development plan in accordance with the provisions of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act. As a result of this declaration, the notice directed that there would be no more developments in the mentioned areas as suspended for a period of not more than two years, save that it does not affect development permission granted six months prior to the said declaration. While the petitioners contend that in 2017, the ministry of lands allocated approximately 288 acres of land in Kibra to the Nubian community under grant no. IR 149108, to be held in trust and managed for the community by the Kibra Nubian community land trust, annexure YM-1 does not provide or support this averment, to the extent that the copy of the title contains two pages only and the court cannot ascertain the acreage.
15. The petitioners contend that neither the county government nor the 1st respondent undertook adequate public participation before the declaration of the special planning area and before decisions were taken concerning road construction and demolitions. The petitioners further contend that on 23rd February, 2021 the Director-General of the 1st respondent announced plans to construct or improve roads in Kibra, including roads passing through areas occupied by members of the Nubian community. It is alleged that the announcement was not preceded by adequate consultation, dissemination of information or meaningful engagement with persons likely to be affected. It is further alleged that on 1st March 2021 demolitions were undertaken in Sarang’ombe ward, and that on or about 21st May, 2021 notices were placed in Lindi ward indicating that demolitions would occur. Structures were subsequently marked and, from 25th May 2021, structures along Legio Maria road were demolished.
16. The respondents, on the other hand, maintained that the construction of Legio Maria road was not a new or secret project. They stated that the project was identified during a stakeholder forum held on 30th August, 2017 in preparation of the 2018 to 2022 CIDP, attended by 55 representatives from Lindi ward. Further, that the project was subsequently budgeted for under the ward development programme for the financial year 2020/2021 and was therefore the product of a participatory process involving the county government, residents and local leaders.
17. According to the 1st respondent, the project was initially undertaken pursuant to a contract between the county government and M/s Naskel Africa Limited and was subsequently taken over by the 1st respondent following the transfer of functions between the county government and the national government. The respondents contend that during a site meeting held on 24th April 2021, it was established that portions of the road had been encroached upon by structures erected within the road reserve. It was agreed that the contractor would mark the extent of the road reserve and display notices to facilitate enforcement. The respondents strongly urged that the affected structures were illegal structures within the road reserve and that most occupants voluntarily removed them. They further contend that the road was approximately 520 metres in length and that the project was intended to improve accessibility and facilitate emergency response. More importantly, is that the project had been approved before the declaration of the special planning area and was therefore protected by the exception contained in Section 52(3) of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act.
18. On the first issue, public participation is a national value under Article 10 of the Constitution and a constitutional requirement in county planning and development. The supreme court has explained that it must be meaningful, informed and reasonable. In the case of British American Tobacco Kenya, PLC (formerly British American Tobacco Kenya Limited) vs Cabinet Secretary for the Ministry of Health &; 2 Others; Kenya Tobacco Control Alliance & another (Interested Parties); Mastermind Tobacco Kenya Limited (The Affected Party) [2019] eKLR, the court stated:-
“We would like to underscore that public participation and consultation is a living constitutional principle that goes to the constitutional tenet of the sovereignty of the people. It is through public participation that the people continue to find their sovereign place in the governance they have delegated to both the National and County Governments.... Components of meaningful public participation include the following; a) clarity of the subject matter for the public to understand; b). structures and processes (medium of engagement) of participation that are clear and simple; c). opportunity for balance influence from the public in general; d). commitment to the process; e). inclusive and effective representation; f). integrity and transparency of the process; g). capacity to engage on the part of the public, including that the public must be first sensitized on the subject matter.”
19. As stated earlier, the petitioners argued that neither the 2nd respondent nor the 1st respondent engaged the community before the designation of the special planning area, which includes the 288 acres granted under grant no. IR 149108. This allegation is not specifically answered in the replying affidavits. The respondents’ affidavits instead rely on the 2017 stakeholder forum for CIDP 2018 to 2022, where 55 representatives from Lindi ward proposed the Legio Maria road project. In my view, that forum cannot cure the absence of engagement on the 2020 designation. The 2017 forum approved a project in the CIPD. The 2020 declaration was a separate decision made three years later. These are two distinct activities. The respondents are in effect relying on a participation exercise that predates the decision under challenge. It concerned a different decision, a county-wide development plan, and a different step in the planning process. It also involved representatives of one ward, whereas the special planning area covers four settlements and land held in trust for the Nubian community.
20. However, Section 52 (5) of the Act does not itself require public participation. It provides as follows: “A county planning authority may publish regulations to promote public participation during the process of declaring an area a special planning area.” The word “may” means the Act leaves the participation exercise to regulations rather than prescribing it. By virtue of this provision, I cannot fault the 1st respondent for failing to publish regulations as the same was not mandatory.
21. On the second issue, Article 40 of the Constitution gives every person the right to acquire and own property. Article 43(1) (b) protects the right to accessible and adequate housing, and Article 47 requires fair administrative action. In the case of Mitu-Bell Welfare Society v Kenya Airports Authority & 3 others [2021] KESC 34 (KLR), the supreme court held as follows:-
“The protection, need not necessarily be in the form of an order restraining the state agency from evicting the occupants, given the fact that, the eviction may be entirely justifiable in the public interest. But, under article 23(3) of the Constitution, the court may craft orders aimed at protecting that right, such as compensation, the requirement of adequate notice before eviction, the observance of humane conditions during eviction (UN Guidelines), the provision of alternative land for settlement, etc.”
22. In addition, Sections 152B to 152G of the Land Act provide the notice and procedure to be followed in evictions from public land. The petitioners contend that there was no notice served upon for the demolitions and evictions and therefore the same was unlawful. On the other hand, the 1st and 2nd respondents’ argued that the structures were within the road reserve and majority of the residents voluntarily removed their structures because the project was community-driven. While I do not condone the construction of structures on road reserve, the respondents needed to demonstrate that the structures had encroached on the roads. There was no survey,road reserve map or boundary determination annexed showing that the demolished structures stood within the reserve.
23. Even if the structures stood in the reserve, the respondents have not shown compliance with the notice and procedure that the law requires. The only step shown is the site meeting held on 24th April 2021, where it was agreed that the contractor would mark the road reserve and display notices. That meeting was attended by the contractor and officials. Nothing indicates that affected owners were present or heard. The petitioners’ evidence, which was not controverted, is that notices were posted on 21st May 2021, houses were marked on 22nd May, and demolitions began by 25th May. That is a matter of days. The respondents’ claim that residents ‘voluntarily’ removed their structures does not remove the obligation to give notice. Compliance under threat of imminent demolition is not consent. I find that the demolitions and evictions on Legio Maria road in Lindi ward violated Articles 40, 43(1)(b) and 47 of the Constitution, the Fair Administrative Action Act and the eviction procedure in the Land Act.
24. On access to information, which is the fourth issue, Article 35(1)(a) of the Constitution gives every citizen the right of access to information held by the state, and the Access to Information Act requires a response within twenty-one days. The petitioners wrote two letters, both 3rd March, 2021 to the 1st and 3rd respondents seeking information on the planned roads, EIA reports, NEMA licences, inter-agency agreements and maps. The petition alleges that neither responded, and no reply or refusal has been produced. The respondents’ have not addressed these letters. This evidence has not be controverted. The information sought in both letters are quite specific and detailed. I find the 1st and 3rd respondents in violation of Article 35 of the Constitution.
25. On violations of Articles 10, 21(3), 56 and 232 of the Constitution, the petitioners asserted that the respondents failed to protect a marginalized community and breached the values and principles of public service in Article 232. Having evaluated the evidence tendered, none supports the broader findings that the rights of the Nubian community as a whole were violated.
26. I find it necessary to point out certain issues. First, the petitioners have not shown that the people who had their structures on Legio Maria ward were specifically from the Nubian community. This paints the image that the orders sought are strictly for the Nubian community which is discriminatory in my view and excludes other communities who live within the trust land and are victims of the demolitions. Secondly, it was necessary to have the identities of the people affected by the demolitions and evictions and the specific loss suffered. This would have enabled the court assess the damage and appropriate remedy for such victims. Third, I take judicial notice that the functions previously transferred to the 1st respondent have reverted to the 2nd respondent. Therefore, the court cannot issue orders against the 1st respondent. Fourth, it is not practical and in the interest of justice for the court to issue a blanket prohibitory order against any future county projects within the trust land as sought by the petitioners. The 2nd respondent has mandate to plan, construct and improve roads and other public infrastructure. Save that the same must be within the confines of the law.
27. Having said the above, the petition dated 2nd June 2021 partially succeeds in the following terms:-
1) A declaration is hereby issued that the demolitions and evictions along Legio Maria road were in violation of Section 152G of the Land Act.
2) A declaration is hereby issued that the 1st and 3rd respondents violated Article 35 of the Constitution and Sections 4 and 5 of the Access to Information Act by failing to respond to the 3rd, 4th and 5th petitioners request for access to information.
3) The 1st and 3rd respondents are hereby ordered to respond to the letters dated 3rd March 2021 within 21 days from the date hereof.
4) The prayers for general and exemplary damages are hereby declined.
5) In view that the petition has been filed on behalf of a community and partially succeeds, each party shall be its own costs.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED VIRTUALLY
THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
HON. MBOGO C.G.
JUDGE
15/10/2026.
In the presence of:
Mr. Benson Agunga - Court assistant
Ms. Mokku for the Petitioner
Ms. Wangari for the 1st Respondent
Mr. Allan Kamau for the 4th Respondent