Background
ELEGANT GEMS LTD ……………………………………………….…1ST RESPONDENT
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The application succeeded in part: execution and implementation of the 18 September 2025 judgment in MCELC E376 of 2024 (consolidated with MCELC E296 of 2024), including consequential orders, were stayed pending determination of the appeal. Costs of the application were ordered to abide the appeal’s outcome. The request to set aside the 27 October 2025 consent was not decided in the application and was directed to be canvassed in the main appeal.
i. That Judgement delivered on 18th September 2025 in MCELC No. E376 of 2024 (as consolidated with MCELC No. E296 of 2024), together with all consequential orders arising therefrom is hereby stayed pending hearing and determination of this appeal.
Passage 54 →
ii. The costs of this application abide the outcome of the appeal.
Passage 55 →
21. In regards to prayer no 6 on the setting aside of the consent judgement dated 27th October 2025, I do hold that same should be canvassed in the main appeal.
Paragraph 21 →
Held. Decided. A stay of the 18 September 2025 judgment in MCELC E376 of 2024, as consolidated with MCELC E296 of 2024, and all consequential orders was granted pending hearing and determination of the appeal. The court found that the applicant demonstrated substantial loss because disposal and sale of the suit property to third parties could irreparably affect it and render the appeal nugatory. Costs were to abide the appeal’s outcome. The separate request to set aside the consent was left for determination in the main appeal.
Ratio. An appeal does not automatically stay execution. Under Order 42 rule 6(2), stay requires satisfaction that substantial loss may result, that the application was made without unreasonable delay, and that ordered security for due performance is given. Substantial loss is not established merely by execution; the applicant must show execution would irreparably affect it or negate the appeal’s essential benefit. In exercising discretion, the court must balance the appellant’s right to pursue the appeal against the successful party’s right to enjoy the judgment.
Issue
16. Having looked at the application, the responses thereto, the submissions and cited authorities, the issues for determination are whether orders of stay should be issued pending hearing and determination of this appeal.
Paragraph 16 →
Held
19. The Applicant argues that he is apprehensive that the Respondent shall proceed with execution of judgment at any time rendering the appeal nugatory which execution is that the suit property might be disposed off and sold to other third parties and recovery of the same will not be possible. It is my view that the Applicant has shown that execution shall irreparably affect him and render the appeal nugatory. It is, therefore, my considered view that the Applicant has demonstrated what substantial loss it stands to suffer.
Paragraph 19 →
i. That Judgement delivered on 18th September 2025 in MCELC No. E376 of 2024 (as consolidated with MCELC No. E296 of 2024), together with all consequential orders arising therefrom is hereby stayed pending hearing and determination of this appeal.
Passage 54 →
ii. The costs of this application abide the outcome of the appeal.
Passage 55 →
Ratio
17. It is trite law that an appeal does not operate as an automatic stay of execution. The conditions which a party must establish in order for the court to order stay of execution are provided for under Order 42 Rule 6(2) Civil Procedure Rules. Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules stipulates: -
Paragraph 17 →
a) The Court is satisfied that substantial loss may result to the 1st Applicant unless the order is made and that the application has been made without unreasonable delay; and
Passage 47 →
b) Such security as the Court orders for the due performance of such decree or order as may ultimately be binding on him has been given by the Applicant
Passage 48 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
ELEGANT GEMS LTD ……………………………………………….…1ST RESPONDENT
Paragraph 1 →Having looked at the application, the responses thereto, the submissions and cited authorities, the issues for determination are whether orders of stay should be issued pending hearing and determination of this appeal.
Paragraph 16 →Whether a stay of execution should issue pending the hearing and determination of the appeal from the magistrate’s judgment delivered on 18 September 2025. Although the motion also sought to set aside a consent dated 27 October 2025, the court held that…
Following judgment in MCELC No. E376 of 2024, consolidated with MCELC No. E296 of 2024, former advocates filed a stay application that was compromised by a 27 October 2025 consent. The consent made stay conditional upon the appellant depositing Ksh 14,250,000…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI
ELC APPEAL NO E213 OF 2025
MAXITIZE KENYA LIMITED ……………………………………APPELLANT/APPLICANT
-VERSUS-
1. ELEGANT GEMS LTD ……………………………………………….…1ST RESPONDENT
2. LUCY RAHAB & VERONICA WANJIRU suing as personal
representatives of the estate of Ruth Waithera Gitau……….…….…2ND RESPONDENT
3. KARAGITA E. A LTD. ………………………………………..……... 3RD RESPONDENT
4. CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR…………………………………..……… 4TH RESPONDENT
(Being an appeal from the Judgment of the magistrate Court of Hon delivered on the 18th September, 2025 in MCELC E376 of 2024)
RULING
Introduction
1. The matter is coming up for determination of the Applicant/Appellant’s Notice of Motion application dated 30th September 2026 seeking the following orders;
a) Spent
b) THAT upon hearing of this Application ex-parte, there be a stay of all execution proceedings, enforcement proceedings, corporate veil piercing proceedings and/or any other proceedings commenced in the subordinate court MCELC No. E376 of 2024 (as consolidated with MCELC No. E296 of 2024) or elsewhere for purposes of enforcing the Judgment delivered on 18th September 2025.
c) THAT pending the hearing and determination of this Application, there be an order maintaining the status quo in respect of the suit property, NAIROBI BLOCK 115/268 and the Land Registry records relating thereto, and that no further dealings, transfers, registrations or alterations affecting the title to the suit property be effected until further orders of this Honourable Court, so as to preserve the subject matter of the Appeal and prevent the Appeal from being rendered nugatory.
d) THAT pending the hearing of this Application, there be a stay of execution, enforcement and/or implementation of the Judgment delivered on 18th September 2025 in MCELC No. E376 of 2024 (as consolidated with MCELC No. E296 of 2024), together with all consequential orders arising therefrom.
e) THAT pending the hearing and determination of the Appeal herein, there be a stay of execution, enforcement and/or implementation of the Judgment delivered on 18th September 2025 in MCELC No. E376 of 2024 (as consolidated with MCELC No. E296 of 2024), together with all consequential orders arising therefrom.
f) THAT the consent dated 27th October, 2025 be set aside.
g) THAT the costs of the application be provided for.
2. The application was premised on grounds as in the supporting affidavit of Michael Mutembei Kibutha. He deponed that the after judgement was entered into in MCELC No E376 of 2024, the firm of Mosi & Company advocates filed an application for stay dated 8th October 2025 but compromised the same by entering entered into a consent on the 27th October 2025 which consent allowed for the stay conditional on the Appellant deposit Ksh.14, 250,000/= within 45 days of the said consent.
3. He deponed that the Appellant herein had not instructed the said firm and that the consent was entered into without their knowledge hence this application to set it aside as the suit property is at the danger of being disposed of by the 2nd Respondents.
4. The 1st Respondent in opposing the application filed grounds of opposition and a relying affidavit sworn on the 7th October 2026 by one Amos Gitau. He deponed that the application is res judicata as the application of 8th October 2025 was compromised by the consent dated 27th October 2025.
5. That further the Appellant is guilty of laches. That the Appellant had failed to adhere to the terms of the consent and the stay orders lapsed which orders he did not seek an extension of making this application much later when directions for the appeal have already been given indicating the application to be an afterthought aimed at delaying the appeal process.
6. Counsel further submitted that the excuse given of counsel acting on his own instructions had not been substantiated for this court to allow the setting aside of the consent an issue stay of execution orders.
7. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions with the Appellant1st Respondent and 2nd Respondent putting in their submissions
Applicant/Appellant’s submissions
8. Counsel for the Applicant submitted on whether the consent should be set aside and insisted that in this case valid grounds had been given being that the firm that entered into the consent was not instructed by the Applicant relying in Maina (Suing on Behalf of 127 others) Vs County Government of Nairobi Executive Committee and 5 other[2026] KEELC 5495(KLR) the court relied In Flora N. Wasike -Vs- Destimo Wamboko [1985] KECA 149 (KLR)
9. Counsel further submitted that they had met the requirements for issuance of stay of execution orders as per Order 42 rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules
He submitted that substantial loss had been proved by the fact that the 2nd Respondent was seeking to execute the judgment that may lead the suit property in the hands of third parties, that three was no unreasonable delay in filing the application being that the delay was not deliberate. That the failure to be able to meet security for due performance of a decree had been hindered by the impugned consent that gave an exorbitant figure.
10. The Appellant submitted that the orders of stay should issue to preserve the substratum of the appeal.
1st Respondents ‘submissions
11. Counsel reiterated the grounds raised in their grounds of objection and replying affidavit that the application was res judicata to the application of 8th October 2025.
That the Applicant had not demonstrated why consent should be set aside as they had not proven fraud, duress, misrepresentation tor non-disclosure of material facts. That the argument advance that their advocates acted on their own instructions in entering the consent had not been backed up by any proof relying in the court of appeal case Rop & 2 others Vs Kipruto & Another (2025)KECA 1610 (KLR)
12. Counsel further submitted the appellant/Applicant had not met the conditions for issuance of stay of execution orders. That no substantial loss had been demonstrated on their part if they were to pay the decretal sum as in the consent. That the application had been brought after an unreasonable time lapse of one year since the consent was entered into and lastly no security for due performance of a decree was offered.
2nd Respondent’s submissions
13. Counsel submitted that the Applicant had not given valid grounds for setting aside of the consent. That it had not been proved that the firm on record for the Applicant then acted on their own instructions being that the said firm filed the instant appeal that the Applicant is prosecuting
14. It was submitted that the Applicant cannot seek for fresh stay orders while a consent order that has not been set aside is still in effect relying on the doctrine of res judicata
15. On whether stay orders should issue counsel indicated the requirements as per Order 42 Rule 6(2) had not been met.
Analysis and determination
16. Having looked at the application, the responses thereto, the submissions and cited authorities, the issues for determination are whether orders of stay should be issued pending hearing and determination of this appeal.
17. It is trite law that an appeal does not operate as an automatic stay of execution. The conditions which a party must establish in order for the court to order stay of execution are provided for under Order 42 Rule 6(2) Civil Procedure Rules. Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules stipulates: -
1. “No appeal or second appeal shall operate as a stay of execution or proceedings under a decree or order appealed from except in so far as the court appealed from may order but the court appealed from may for sufficient cause order stay of execution of such decree or order and whether the application for such stay shall have been granted or refused by the court appealed from the court to which such appeal is preferred shall be at liberty on application being made to consider such application and to make such order thereon as may to it seem just and any person aggrieved by an order of stay made by the court from whose decision the Appeal is preferred may apply to the appellate court to have such orders set aside.
2. No order for stay of execution shall be made under sub rule 1 unless:
a) The Court is satisfied that substantial loss may result to the 1st Applicant unless the order is made and that the application has been made without unreasonable delay; and
b) Such security as the Court orders for the due performance of such decree or order as may ultimately be binding on him has been given by the Applicant
18. Substantial loss was clearly explained in the case of James Wangalwa & Another Vs Agnes Naliaka Cheseto [2012] eKLR: -“No doubt in law, the fact that the process of execution has been put in motion, or is likely to be put in motion, by itself, does not amount to substantial loss. Even when execution has been levied and completed, that is to say, the attached properties have been sold, as is the case here does not in itself amount to substantial loss under Order 42 Rule 6 of the CPR. This is so because execution is a lawful process. The Applicant must establish other factors which show that the execution will create a state of affairs that will irreparably affect or negate the very essential core of the Applicant as the successful party in the appeal…the issue of substantial loss is the cornerstone of both jurisdictions. Substantial loss is what has to be prevented by preserving the status quo because such loss would render the appeal nugatory’’
19. The Applicant argues that he is apprehensive that the Respondent shall proceed with execution of judgment at any time rendering the appeal nugatory which execution is that the suit property might be disposed off and sold to other third parties and recovery of the same will not be possible. It is my view that the Applicant has shown that execution shall irreparably affect him and render the appeal nugatory. It is, therefore, my considered view that the Applicant has demonstrated what substantial loss it stands to suffer.
20. Grant of stay being a discretionary order, the court is expected to balance out the interests of the successful litigant and the Applicant’s unfettered right to file an appeal to fully ventilate his grievances. This was well stated in the case of M/s Porteitz Maternity Vs James Karanga Kabia Civil Appeal No. 63 of 1997 where the court held:- That the right of appeal must be balanced against an equally weighty right, that of the Plaintiff to enjoy the fruits of the judgment delivered in his favour. There must be a just cause for depriving the Plaintiff of that right.
21. In regards to prayer no 6 on the setting aside of the consent judgement dated 27th October 2025, I do hold that same should be canvassed in the main appeal.
22. In the foregoing I make the following orders;
i. That Judgement delivered on 18th September 2025 in MCELC No. E376 of 2024 (as consolidated with MCELC No. E296 of 2024), together with all consequential orders arising therefrom is hereby stayed pending hearing and determination of this appeal.
ii. The costs of this application abide the outcome of the appeal.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 15th day of
October 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
Mr. Ngarega for the Plaintiff/Applicant
Mr. Nakhone for the 1st Respondent
Ms. Munguti for the 2nd Respondent
N/A for the 3rd and 4th Respondents
Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant