REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING PETITION NO. E032 OF 2024
BETWEEN
DANIEL NGOLI MAVISI ….……………………...........1ST PETITIONER
CATHOLIC DIOCESE OF TORIT………………........2ND PETITIONER
SATIENDER SINGH SEHMI…………………………...3RD PETITIONER
JAGS KAUR (FOR AND ON BEHALF OF PARKLANDS RESIDENTS ASSOCIATION…………………………...4TH PETITIONER
TEDDY OBIERO (For and on Behalf of Alliance of
NAIROBI METRO RESIDENTS - EMBAKASI……5TH PETITIONER
VERSUS
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY GOVERNMENT …..…..1ST RESPONDENT
GODEFREY AKUMALI………………………………...2ND RESPONDENT
PATRICK ANALO AKIVAGA………………………...3RD RESPONDENT
PATRICK MBOGO…………………………………….…4TH RESPONDENT
NATIONAL ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT
AUTHORITY …………………………………………….. 5TH RESPONDENT
NATIONAL CONSTRUCTION AUTHORITY.…..6TH RESPONDENT
KENYA URBAN ROADS AUTHORITY……….……7TH RESPONDENT
HUGHRIDGE AUTO BAZAR LIMITED…….…….8TH RESPONDENT
MINHAAJ HOMES LIMITED ……………….……...9TH RESPONDENT
AND
THE LAND REGISTRAR…………..…..…….1ST INTERESTED PARTY
MINISTRY OF LANDS, PUBLIC WORKS, HOUSING
AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT…….…...…2ND INTERESTED PARTY
NAIROBI CITY WATER & SEWERAGE
COMPANY LIMITED …………………….…..3RD INTERESTED PARTY
RULING
1. Vide the Motion dated 10th February, 2026, brought pursuant to the provisions of Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act 2010, Rule 3 of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (Practice and Procedure Rules) 2013, and Order 16 Rule 1 and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2020, the Petitioners/Applicants seek the following reliefs:
i. That this Honourable Court be pleased to issue witness summonses to (i) Eng Maurice Akech (Chief Officer of the National Construction Authority, the 6th Respondent), (ii) Eng. Silas M. Kinoti (Director General of the 7th Respondent), (iii) Patrick Analo Akivaga (Chief Officer, Urban Development and Planning of the 1st Respondent) and (iv) Geoffrey Mosiria (an officer in the 1st Respondent's County Government) to attend court and give evidence on matters relating to the Petition filed herein on a day and time to be fixed by the Court.
ii. That this Honourable Court do suspend the hearing date for Petition to a date when the said (i) Eng. Maurice Akech (Chief Officer of the National Construction Authority, the 6th Respondent), (ii) Eng. Silas M. Kinoti (Director General of the 7th Respondent), (iii) Patrick Analo Akivaga (3rd Respondent/Chief Officer, Urban Development and Planning of the 1st Respondent) and (iv) Geoffrey Mosiria (an officer in the 1st Respondent's County Government) shall attend court, give evidence and be cross-examined by the Petitioner's/Applicants.
iii. That the Court do issue any other consequential orders it deems just and fair in the circumstances.
iv. That the costs of this application abide the Petition.
2. The Motion is supported by the affidavit of Daniel Ngoli Mavisi, the 1st Petitioner, sworn on an even date. He deponed that the Amended Petition concerns breaches, denials, violations and infringements of various constitutional rights and fundamental freedoms, as well as contraventions of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, the Environmental Management and Co-ordination Act, the National Construction Authority Act, the Public Officer Ethics Act and other applicable laws and regulations.
3. He stated that the Petitioners have always intended to call Eng. Maurice Akech, Chief Officer of the National Construction Authority; Eng. Silas M. Kinoti, Director General of the 7th Respondent; Patrick Analo Akivaga, the 3rd Respondent and Chief Officer for Urban Development and Planning of the 1st Respondent; and Geoffrey Mosiria, an officer of the 1st Respondent, to testify on matters arising from the Amended Petition.
4. With regard to Eng. Maurice Akech, he deponed that his attendance is necessary because the 6th Respondent issued the 8th Respondent with a Certificate of Compliance Registration No. 53127415710892 authorizing the proposed development on Nairobi/Block 37/283, formerly L.R. No. 209/22334, allegedly on the strength of approvals granted by the 1st to 5th Respondents and that Eng. Akech is also required to produce the geotechnical investigation report and construction method statement submitted by the 8th Respondent and to testify on the nature, extent and progress of the development.
5. On several occasions, it was noted, Eng. Akech had been requested to visit the construction site and ascertain whether the works complied with the National Construction Authority Act, the applicable building regulations and the National Building Code, 2024.
6. As regards Eng. Silas M. Kinoti, he deponed that his testimony is required in relation to the design and base maps bearing Universal Transverse Mercator coordinates and showing the boundaries of Ring Road Parklands (City Park Drive) and Limuru Road, between the City Park Drive and Mwambao Lane junctions, insofar as those roads border Nairobi/Block 37/283 and that Eng. Kinoti is also required to produce the additional documents specified in the notice to produce dated 17th December 2024.
7. The 1st Petitioner further stated that the attendance of Patrick Analo Akivaga is necessary to enable him to testify on the alleged illegality and irregularity of the development, including the notification of approval annexed as “WM-1” to the affidavit of Wilfred Masinde sworn on 24th October 2025 and that his testimony is also required to clarify the circumstances surrounding the issuance and enforcement, if any, of the enforcement notice dated 27th December 2024, annexed as “DNM-23” to the affidavit sworn on 21st January 2025.
8. The attendance of Geoffrey Mosiria, he explained, is necessary to enable him to testify on the various visits made to the development site and the measures taken against the 8th and 9th Respondents, their servants, agents, proponents or developers and that he is also required to produce the TikTok video referenced in the further affidavit sworn on 31st October 2024, which depicts a site visit undertaken in October 2024.
9. In view of the foregoing, he urged, the evidence of the aforesaid persons is material to the fair and effectual determination of the issues raised given the official positions they hold within the National Construction Authority, the Kenya Urban Roads Authority and the Nairobi City County Government, respectively, and their knowledge of or authority over the matters in dispute.
10. In response to the Motion, the 1st-4th Respondents filed a replying affidavit sworn on 27th March 2026, by Wilfred Masinde, the Deputy Director of Development Inspection and Planning Dedication in the department of Planning, Compliance and Enforcement of the Nairobi City County Government.
11. Mr. Masinde deponed that the application is misconceived, frivolous, vexatious and an abuse of the court process. He asserted that the multifaceted nature of a petition or suit cannot not confer jurisdiction upon a court where none exists. In his view, holding otherwise will permit litigants to circumvent the jurisdiction of specialized statutory bodies by framing their pleadings to incorporate multiple causes of action, thereby encouraging forum shopping.
12. According to him, the issues upon which the proposed witnesses are to testify ought first to have been presented to the County Liaison Committee pursuant to Sections 61, 78, 79 and 80 of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, 2019 and that although the court exercises both original and appellate jurisdiction in planning matters, judicial deference requires it to permit the statutory body established by law to determine the dispute in the first instance.
13. With regard to the TikTok video which the Petitioners sought to have produced through Geoffrey Mosiria, he described it as a fishing expedition devoid of probative value and maintained that the court lacks jurisdiction to entertain it.
14. He similarly contended that summoning Mr. Mosiria and Mr. Analo Akivaga to testify on the alleged illegality or irregularity of the approval relating to Nairobi/Block 37/283 will amount to a usurpation of the powers of the County Liaison Committee.
15. He pointed out that, under regulations 47, 49 and 50 of the Physical and Land Use Planning (Liaison Committees) Regulations, the Committee is empowered to summon witnesses, receive evidence, conduct site visits and issue interim orders in disputes concerning offensive developments, development permissions and planning matters.
16. Without prejudice to those objections, he deponed that the Petitioners have not challenged his competence or authority to respond to the allegations raised in the Amended Petition and the application. He maintained that, by virtue of his position within the 1st Respondent, he possesses the requisite authority and competence to depone to or be examined on any matter on behalf of the 1st to 4th Respondents.
17. He further contended that the court is required to remain an impartial adjudicator and ought not to descend into the arena of the dispute by assisting either party to supplement or prove its case. Summoning a witness as a witness of the court risks transforming the court from an adjudicator into an investigator, contrary to the rule of law. He also invoked Sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act for the proposition that each party bears the burden of proving its own case and cannot rely upon the court to discharge that burden.
18. The 6th Respondent filed grounds of opposition dated 29th May 2026, premised on the grounds that:
i. The application is misconceived, frivolous and amounts to an abuse of the court process.
ii. The application seeking witness summonses against Eng. Maurice Akech, the Executive Director of the 6th Respondent, is premature and misconceived in law.
iii. Under Order 16 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2020, witness summons are ordinarily issued where a party demonstrates that the witness has relevant evidence that cannot otherwise be obtained, and that the witness has refused or is likely to refuse to attend voluntarily. The Applicants have not demonstrated either condition.
iv. The 6th Respondent, as a party to these proceedings, has already filed pleadings and a replying affidavit sworn on 27th October 2025, annexing evidence, all of which is part of the record before the court.
v. The 6th Respondent, through its replying affidavit sworn on 27th October 2025, comprehensively addressed the Petitioners' allegations. The said replying affidavit exhibits the Certificate of Compliance Registration Number 53127415710892. The Petitioners attempt to compel Eng. Maurice Akech's attendance through witness summons is therefore unnecessary, duplicative and an attempt to relitigate matters already on record.
vi. The Petitioners have not laid a proper legal foundation for the issuance of a witness summons against Eng. Maurice Akech. The applicable provision, Order 16 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2020, requires that the applicant demonstrate: (a) that the proposed witness has evidence relevant to the issues in dispute; and (b) that the witness will not attend voluntarily.
vii. The Petitioners have not demonstrated that any prior request was made to Eng. Maurice Akech was required to attend court voluntarily, but the request was declined. A mere assertion that his attendance is "indispensable" does not satisfy the legal threshold.
viii. The 6th Respondent discharged its statutory mandate under the National Construction Authority Act, CAP 118 by issuing the Certificate of Compliance Registration Number 53127415710892 upon being satisfied that all requisite approvals and conditions had been met. The Certificate of Compliance is a statutory document that speaks for itself. Compelling Eng. Maurice Akech to attend court to testify about the issuance of a statutory certificate amounts to improperly subjecting regulatory decision-making to collateral challenge through testimony rather than the proper judicial review process.
ix. The Petitioners claim that the geotechnical investigation report and construction method statement need to be produced through Eng. Maurice Akech is misconceived. These are documents in the possession of the developer, the 8th Respondent herein, that were submitted to the 6th Respondent in the course of the regulatory process. If the Petitioners required these documents, the appropriate mechanism was a Notice to Produce directed at the proper custodian, or an application for discovery and inspection under Order 10 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2020, not a witness summons against the 6th Respondent.
x. That contrary to the Petitioners assertion at ground (n) of the Notice of Motion, granting the orders sought would occasion serious prejudice to the 6th Respondent, who has been ready and willing to proceed with the hearing of the Petition.
xi. The Petitioners application undermines the overriding objectives under Sections 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act, which require facilitation of just, expeditious, proportionate and affordable resolution of disputes.
Submissions
19. The Applicant’s counsel filed written submissions dated 6th May 2026. Counsel acknowledged the settled principle that jurisdiction is everything and that a court must down its tools once it finds that it lacks jurisdiction, as held in Owners of the Motor Vessel “Lillian S” vs Caltex Oil (Kenya) Limited [1989] KLR 1. Reference was also made to Samuel Kamau Macharia & Another vs Kenya Commercial Bank Ltd & 2 Others (Application No. 2 of 2011) [2012] KESC 8 (KLR), where the Supreme Court held that a court’s jurisdiction flows from the Constitution or legislation and cannot be expanded beyond that conferred by law.
20. It was nevertheless submitted that the question of this court’s jurisdiction was conclusively determined in the court’s ruling delivered on 26th June 2025 which has not been reviewed nor appealed against.
21. On the merits of the application, counsel submitted that Rule 3 of the Mutunga Rules, Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 16 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules empower the court to summon any person whose testimony or production of documents is necessary for the just and expeditious determination of a dispute.
22. On that basis, counsel argued that Patrick Analo Akivaga and Geoffrey Mosiria were directly involved in the development approval and control processes undertaken by the 1st Respondent in its capacity as the planning authority under Section 2 of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, 2019.
23. According to counsel, the attendance of Eng. Maurice Akech and Eng. Silas M. Kinoti was similarly said to be necessary by virtue of their positions as heads of the relevant agencies or authorities contemplated under Section 60 of the Act, which required them to review and comment on the applications for development permission.
24. Reliance was placed on Dahir Sadik Ausaad vs Modogashe Construction Ltd & 3 Others [2016] KEHC 3994 (KLR) and Central Bank of Kenya vs Pontrillas Investment Limited & Attorney General, Civil Appeal No. 3 of 2020 (EACJ), which affirmed the court’s discretion to summon essential witnesses or require the production of documents.
25. The 1st to 4th Respondents advocate filed written submissions dated 9th May 2026. Counsel submitted that the Amended Petition essentially challenges development approvals issued by the planning authority and, pursuant to Sections 61(3) and (4) and 78(a) and (b) of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, 2019, ought first to have been presented before the County Physical and Land Use Planning Liaison Committee.
26. Counsel further contended that Regulations 47, 49 and 50 of the Physical and Land Use Planning (Liaison Committees) Regulations empower the Liaison Committee to summon witnesses, receive evidence, conduct site visits and issue interim orders in disputes relating to offensive developments and contested development permissions, licenses or approvals.
27. Without prejudice to that jurisdictional objection, counsel argued that the court, as an impartial adjudicator in an adversarial system, should not descend into the arena of the dispute by assisting either party to assemble or prove its case. Reliance was placed on Mureithi & another vs Mwangi & 3 others (Environment and Land Case No. 298 of 2019) [2024] KEELC 6230 (KLR), where the court held that Sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act place the burden of proof upon the parties and do not permit the court to intervene in order to supplement a party’s case.
28. Counsel argued that summoning the proposed witnesses would improperly transform the court from an impartial adjudicator into an investigator. It was submitted that the 1st to 4th Respondents, who had authorized Wilfred Masinde to testify on their behalf, were entitled under Article 50 of the Constitution to determine how to present their case and which witnesses to call.
29. The court cannot therefore, compel the 3rd Respondent or Geoffrey Mosiria to testify against their wishes and that where a party unjustifiably fails to call a material witness, the appropriate recourse is for the court to draw an adverse inference. Reference was made to Stanley Mombo Amuti v Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission [2019] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal affirmed that a party is ordinarily responsible for determining how to present its case and which witnesses to call.
Analysis and Determination
30. Having considered the application, the responses and the parties’ submissions, the sole issue for determination is whether the Petitioners have established sufficient grounds for the issuance of witness summonses against Eng. Maurice Akech, Eng. Silas M. Kinoti, Patrick Analo Akivaga and Geoffrey Mosiria.
31. At the outset, the court notes that the 1st to 4th Respondents have challenged its jurisdiction on the ground that the dispute ought first to have been presented before the County Physical and Land Use Planning Liaison Committee, which has the power to summon witnesses. The record, however, shows that the court considered and determined an objection to its jurisdiction, founded on the doctrine of exhaustion, in its ruling delivered on 26th June 2025. That ruling has neither been reviewed, set aside nor overturned on appeal and therefore remains binding. The jurisdictional question cannot, therefore, be reopened through the present application.
32. Moving on to the merits, Section 22 of the Civil Procedure Act provides:
“Subject to such conditions and limitations as may be prescribed, the court may, at any time, either of its own motion or on the application of any party—(a)make such orders as may be necessary or reasonable in all matters relating to the delivery and answering of interrogatories, the admission of documents and facts, and the discovery, inspection, production, impounding and return of documents or other material objects producible as evidence;(b) issue summonses to persons whose attendance is required either to give evidence or to produce documents or such other objects as aforesaid;(c) order any fact to be proved by affidavit.”
33. Order 16 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules similarly provides:
“At any time before the trial conference under Order 11 the parties may obtain, on application to the court or to such officer as it appoints in this behalf, summonses to persons whose attendance is required either to give evidence or to produce documents.”
34. The court’s power to obtain evidence necessary for the proper determination of a dispute is further reinforced by Section 173(1) of the Evidence Act, which provides:
“(1)A judge or magistrate may, in order to discover or to obtain proper evidence, ask any question he pleases, in any form, at any time, of any witness, or of the parties about any fact whether or not it is otherwise admissible; and may order the production of any document or thing; and neither the parties nor their agents shall be entitled to object to any such question or order, nor, without leave of the court, to cross-examine the witness upon any answer given in reply to any such question:
Provided that judgment shall be based only upon facts which are otherwise admissible and which have been duly proved.”
29. These provisions confer discretion upon the court to compel the attendance of a person whose testimony or documents are necessary for the determination of a dispute. Speaking to the same, the Court of Appeal in Ogot vs Keroka Highway Service Station (Civil Appeal E712 of 2023) [2024] KECA 1499 (KLR) (25 October 2024) (Judgment) stated:
“It is true that sections 22(b) and 23 of the Civil Procedure Act and section 173 of the Evidence Act give power to a Judge or magistrate to ask questions of witnesses, summon a witness or call for additional evidence. Section 22 of the said Act is on “Power to order discovery and the like” while section 23 is on “Summons to witness.” The heading to section 173 of the Evidence Act is “Extended powers of court for purpose of obtaining proper evidence.”
Those provisions of the law allow the trial court to seek evidence that will enable it to make a more informed judgment but this does not take away the fundamental principle that the Judge or magistrate is and must remain an impartial arbiter in the proceedings, more so in civil proceedings which involve resolution of disputes between parties. The court cannot go into a fishing expedition looking for evidence, the court should not be seen to be assisting either side in the dispute. Disputes in civil proceedings should be determined based on the pleadings and evidence. As was observed by Sir Barclay Nihil, P in Jashbhai C Patel vs. BD Joshi [1952], 19 EACA 42:“A trial judge should not descend into the arena where his vision may become clouded by the dust of the conflict… Where the parties are represented by counsel, it is preferable that ordinarily the conduct of the case should remain in their hands. Not to do so might indeed lead to error of descending into the arena.”
The trial court must be cautious of how it exercises the said powers under the Civil Procedure Act and Evidence Act so that the exercise does not negatively affect the perception of a fair trial. This Court in Accredo AG & 3 others vs. Steffano Ucceli & Another [2018] eKLR had this to say on fair trial: “The right to have a dispute adjudicated before an impartial court is a subset of the right to a fair hearing as enshrined under Article 150 of the Constitution. Together they advance the rule of law in that, on one hand, litigants are afforded an opportunity to present their respective cases and on the other, the court seized of the matter resolves the issues that arise therein as an impartial arbiter and within the confines of the law.”
30. The court is so guided.
31. Vide the present Motion, the Petitioners seek to have this court summon Eng. Maurice Akech, Eng. Silas M. Kinoti, Patrick Analo Akivaga and Geoffrey Mosiria to attend court, testify and produce documents relating to the approval, construction, inspection and enforcement processes concerning the development on Nairobi/Block 37/283.
32. The Respondents oppose the application on the ground that the relevant public institutions are already parties to the Petition and have filed their respective responses through authorized officers. The 1st to 4th Respondents particularly contend that Wilfred Masinde is authorized and competent to testify on behalf of the Nairobi City County Government whereas the 6th Respondent notes that its officer has similarly responded to the same. They assert that the Petitioners cannot use witness summons to dictate how the Respondents should present their cases.
33. The court has considered the application, the responses and the parties’ submissions. The allegations in the Amended Petition principally concern the official acts and omissions of the Nairobi City County Government, the National Construction Authority and the Kenya Urban Roads Authority. They include the alleged failure to prepare the requisite development plans, provide information concerning the development, issue or enforce the necessary approvals and prevent the unauthorised use of pedestrian walkways and sections of City Park Drive and Limuru Road.
34. The power to issue witness summons exists to secure identified evidence necessary for the just determination of a dispute. It does not relieve the Petitioners of their burden under Sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act or permit them to summon public officers merely to investigate whether those officers might provide evidence supporting the Petition.
35. Where the relevant evidence can be obtained from authorised institutional witnesses, proper records’ custodians or through the procedures for discovery and production, compelling the attendance of particular senior officers would be unnecessary and disproportionate.
36. Patrick Analo Akivaga is required to testify on the alleged illegality of the development, the circumstances surrounding the Notification of Approval and the issuance and enforcement of the Enforcement Notice dated 27th December 2024. Although he is sued in both his personal and official capacities, the matters upon which his evidence is sought concern the County’s planning and enforcement functions.
37. The County has responded through Wilfred Masinde, who has stated that he is authorised and competent to testify for the 1st to 4th Respondents. His competence has not been challenged, and it has not been demonstrated that the relevant evidence lies exclusively within Mr. Akivaga’s personal knowledge. There is therefore no sufficient basis for compelling his attendance.
38. Geoffrey Mosiria is sought to testify on the site visits undertaken and the measures if any taken against the 8th and 9th Respondents. Any official site visits, together with the resulting reports and enforcement records, are records of the Nairobi City County Government and may be produced and explained by Mr. Masinde or another authorised County officer. The fact that a video posted on Mr. Mosiria’s personal TikTok account depicts those visits does not convert it into an official County record.
39. In any event, the TikTok video has already been adduced in evidence. Being electronic evidence, its admissibility and probative value fall to be determined under Sections 78A and 106B of the Evidence Act. Accordingly, Mr. Mosiria’s attendance is unnecessary.
40. Eng. Maurice Akech is required to testify on the issuance of Certificate of Compliance Registration No. 53127415710892, produce the geotechnical investigation report and construction method statement submitted by the 8th Respondent, and explain the nature, extent and progress of the development and its compliance with the applicable construction laws.
41. The 6th Respondent has, however, filed a response addressing its role in the development and produced the certificate of compliance. The other documents sought are institutional records submitted by the developer and may be obtained from the developer or the appropriate records custodian through discovery, inspection or a notice to produce. It has not been shown that Eng. Akech possesses evidence unavailable from another authorized officer of the 6th Respondent. His personal attendance is therefore unnecessary.
42. Eng. Silas M. Kinoti is sought to produce design and base maps bearing Universal Transverse Mercator coordinates and depicting the boundaries of City Park Drive and Limuru Road adjoining Nairobi/Block 37/283. The Petitioners also seek his testimony and the production of the additional documents identified in the Notice to Produce dated 17th December 2024. While that notice may justify requiring the 7th Respondent to produce the specified documents, it does not warrant the personal attendance of its Director General.
43. The Petitioners have consequently failed to demonstrate that the personal attendance of Eng. Maurice Akech, Eng. Silas M. Kinoti, Patrick Analo Akivaga or Geoffrey Mosiria is necessary for the fair determination of the Petition.
44. In the end, the court finds the Notice of Motion dated 10th February, 2026 to be unmerited. The same is dismissed with costs.
Dated, signed and delivered virtually in Nairobi this 15th day of October, 2026.
O. A. Angote
Judge
In the presence of;
Ms. Anjiko for Abdulaziz for 8th and 9th Respondents
Mr. Ndambiri for petitioners
Mr. Nderitu for 1st – 4th Respondents
Ms Ogolla for 6th Respondent
Court Assistant: Tracy