Land law

Law Society of Kenya & 2 others v Attorney General & 6 others [2026] KEELC 6815 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Petition E041 of 2026
Judgment date
15 October 2026
Judge(s)
J G Kemei

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is coming up for determination is the Petitioners’ application dated 13/7/2026. The application is brought under Articles 10, 22, 23, 42, 70 and 258 of the Constitution of Kenya; Sections 3, 3A and 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act, No. 19 of 2011; and Orders 40 and 51 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The Petitioners substantially pray for orders that;

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have considered the pleadings, the applications, the rival affidavits thereto, the submissions thereof as well as the Court record. I distil the following issues for determination:

Paragraph 60 →

Decision / orders

In the end, the Court finds no evidence of willful or deliberate disobedience, and the deponents' affidavits show compliance with the orders. It is therefore my finding that the application is not merited. Accordingly, it is dismissed.

Paragraph 114 →

Reasoning passage

Given the nature of the projects and the irreversible environmental harm likely to be caused, the Court finds that the Petition is likely to be rendered nugatory if conservatory orders are not issued.

Paragraph 85 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT MILIMANI

ELC PETITION NO. E041 OF 2026

LAW SOCIETY OF KENYA - 1ST PETITIONER/APPLICANT

GREEN BELT MOVEMENT - 2ND PETITIONER/APPLICANT

JUSTACT - 3RD PETITIONER/APPLICANT

AND

HON. ATTORNEY GENERAL - 1ST RESPONDENT

KENYA FOREST SERVICE - 2ND RESPONDENT

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENT

MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY - 3RD RESPONDENT

KENYA URBAN ROADS AUTHORITY - 4TH RESPONDENT

KENYA RAILWAYS CORPORATION - 5TH RESPONDENT

KONYON COMPANY LIMITED - 6TH RESPONDENT

AND

NGONG ROAD FOREST ASSOCIATION - INTERESTED PARTY

RULING

(In respect of the Petitioners’ applications dated 13/7/2026 and 6/8/2026 and the 5th Respondent’s application dated 14/9/2026)

1. What is coming up for determination is the Petitioners’ application dated 13/7/2026. The application is brought under Articles 10, 22, 23, 42, 70 and 258 of the Constitution of Kenya; Sections 3, 3A and 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act, No. 19 of 2011; and Orders 40 and 51 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The Petitioners substantially pray for orders that;

a. Pending the hearing of the Petition, a conservatory order be issued staying and restraining the 2nd, 4th and 6th Respondents, whether by themselves, their servants, agents, employees, contractors or any person acting under their authority, from any further excavation, tree-felling, land clearance, or construction works of any kind at the eco-lodge site operated by the 6th Respondent within the Sanctuary Block of Ngong Road Forest, and the Bomas-Talanta road corridor within Ngong Road Forest, including any removal of the Sanctuary Block electric fence.

b. Pending the hearing of the Petition, a conservatory order be issued restraining the 5th Respondent, whether by itself, its servants, agents or any contractor, from commencing any construction, survey, ground-preparation, or land-clearance works for the proposed Riruta-Ngong Town Meter Gauge Railway line within Ngong Road Forest

c. Pending the hearing and determination of the Petition, a conservatory order be issued restraining the 2nd, 3rd, 4th and 5th Respondents, whether by themselves, their servants, agents, officers or any person acting under their direction, from implementing, enforcing, granting, processing, issuing, or taking any further step in furtherance of any permit, licence, way-leave or approval - including, without limitation, any Environmental Impact Assessment licence, Special Use Licence, or any instrument purportedly issued or to be issued under sections 56(2)(da) or 56(2)(db) of the Forest Conservation and Management Act, 2016 - in respect of the eco-lodge, the Bomas-Talanta road, or the proposed railway.

d. This Honourable Court be pleased to order the 2nd, 3rd, 4th and 5th Respondents to supply to the Court and to the Petitioners, within ten (10) days of this Order, complete discovery of: the Environmental Impact Assessment report(s), licence(s) and correspondence; records of community consultation and public participation; all permits, leases, licences, way-leaves and Forest Management Agreements; and, in respect of the 4th Respondent in each case relating to the eco-lodge, the road, and the proposed railway.

e. This Honourable Court be pleased to direct the Deputy Registrar of this Court, accompanied by representatives of the parties, to conduct a site visit to Ngong Road Forest within seven (7) days of this Order, and to file a report before this Court recording an independent account of the condition of the forest and the nature and extent of the works undertaken, so as to place before the Court an accurate record ahead of the inter partes hearing.

f. The costs of this application be provided for.

2. The application is founded on the grounds set out on its face and is supported by the affidavit of Akshay Vishwanath, a director of the 3rd Petitioner. The deponent states that Ngong Road Forest, originally gazetted at approximately 2,850 hectares in 1932 and re-gazetted in 1964, was reduced through seventeen successive excisions to 1,224.4 hectares by 1978, representing a loss of more than 57% of its original area. Although no formal excision has been recorded since 1978, the deponent asserts that approximately 71 hectares of the forest have, within the past two years, been occupied or designated for the construction of the Talanta Sports City Stadium (approximately 56 hectares), the Bomas-Talanta road (approximately 10 hectares), the 6th Respondent's eco-lodge (approximately 2 hectares), a contractor's construction camp (approximately 2 hectares), and the proposed Riruta-Ngong Town Meter Gauge Railway (approximately 1 hectare). None of these projects appears in the Participatory Forest Management Plan 2024-2029, the excision register, or the Kenya Gazette.

3. The deponent further states that, on 21/1/2025, the 2nd Respondent approved a Special Use Licence for the construction of a commercial eco-lodge within the Sanctuary Block. The 3rd Respondent also issued a conditional licence in or around February 2025, together with an early-entry authorisation permitting construction before full regulatory clearance had been obtained.

4. The deponent avers that their efforts to obtain information about the eco-lodge from the 3rd Respondent have been unsuccessful. Attempts to obtain the same information from the Commission on Administrative Justice did not bear fruit, as the 3rd Respondent, in its letter dated 7/8/2025, failed to address the specific concerns raised by the Petitioners, thereby forcing the Petitioners to file an application for review with the Commission.

5. Subsequently, on 10/7/2026, the Petitioners wrote to the 3rd Respondent, requesting that the bearer of the letter be permitted to inspect and obtain copies of the licence and related documents, and undertaking to meet any costs incurred. However, when the Petitioners’ representative attended the 3rd Respondent's offices, the 3rd Respondent declined to permit the inspection and copying of the documents, without providing written reasons or citing any ground for exemption under the Access to Information Act, 2016.

6. The deponent avers that excavation works and the felling of mature trees for the said road works commenced on 8/7/2026, without notice to the Petitioners, in the absence of any published Environmental Impact Assessment licence, Special Use Licence, or way-leave, and without any public participation exercise having been conducted. The deponent further deposes that the 4th Respondent awarded a contract of approximately Kshs. 3.9 Billion for road works procured through the Specially Permitted Procurement Procedure, without published justification for departing from open competitive tender, and that the 5th Respondent proposes to construct a railway line requiring approximately 2.5 acres of the forest.

7. The deponent states that he has reviewed the photographic evidence dated on or about 9/7/2026 and has been informed by the 2nd Petitioner’s officers who visited the site that, as of 8/7/2026, excavation works had commenced and mature trees had been felled. He avers that the conservatory orders sought are necessary to prevent the substantial completion of the works, which would otherwise render the Petition nugatory. The Petitioners rely on the principle set out in Okiya Omtatah Okoiti v Ministry of Lands, Public Works, Housing and Urban Development & 11 others (ELC LC Petition E052 of 2025), namely, that an Environmental Impact Assessment licence obtained after implementation cannot retrospectively sanitize an unlawful commencement.

The 1st, 2nd and 4th Respondents’ Replying Affidavit

8. Engineer Silas M. Kinoti, the Director General of the 4th Respondent, swore the affidavit dated 20/7/2026 on behalf of the 1st, 2nd, and 4th Respondents.

9. The deponent contends that the Petition is based on incomplete facts, erroneous assumptions, and a selective presentation of the circumstances surrounding the impugned Traffic Circulation and Capacity Enhancement Project serving Talanta Sports City Stadium and the Bomas International Convention Centre (BICC), undertaken pursuant to Contract No. KURA/DEV/HQ/194/2025–2026. The deponent states that, in discharging its statutory mandate, KURA conceived the Project as critical national infrastructure intended to enhance transport connectivity, traffic circulation, public safety, and emergency evacuation, particularly in anticipation of major international sporting events. KURA avers that before the Project’s commencement, technical traffic, evacuation, and road-capacity studies were undertaken, which established that the existing road network, including reliance on Ngong Road, would be inadequate to meet the required evacuation timelines. A Multi-Agency Technical Committee thereafter considered various alternatives, including a viaduct and alternative road alignments, and adopted the current route following technical and inter-agency consultations and advice from the Kenya Forest Service that the selected option would cause comparatively lower environmental impacts.

10. The 4th Respondent further avers that the Project complied with the applicable constitutional and statutory requirements concerning environmental protection, planning, and infrastructure development. In particular, KURA asserts that it commissioned a comprehensive Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (ESIA) in accordance with the Environmental Management and Co-ordination Act (EMCA) and the applicable Environmental (Impact Assessment and Audit) Regulations. The Deponent avers that the ESIA commenced in February 2026, was completed in June 2026, and was submitted to the National Environment Management Authority (NEMA) on 24/6/2026 for consideration and licensing. According to the Respondent, the assessment incorporated baseline environmental studies, specialist investigations, consideration of alternative designs, assessment of direct, indirect, and cumulative impacts, climate-change considerations, stakeholder engagement, mitigation measures, environmental management plans, and grievance-redress mechanisms.

11. The deponent further states that KURA obtained Early Entry permission from the Kenya Forest Service on 4/2/2026 to undertake preliminary works, including surveys, geotechnical investigations, and limited site clearance, and subsequently applied for the requisite Special Use Licence. The 4th Respondent denies that the limited vegetation clearance amounted to unlawful or irreversible environmental degradation.

12. It is further stated that extensive stakeholder engagement was undertaken through consultations, focus groups, and questionnaires, involving 446 participants and 110 questionnaires whose views informed the mitigation measures. It also denies any irregularity in the procurement process, stating that the Specially Permitted Procurement (SPP) method was approved by the National Treasury and the parent Ministry pursuant to the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015.

13. The deponent avers that the Petitioners have not adduced any contradictory engineering or environmental report demonstrating that a better alternative exists. He further asserts that the project will not cause the catastrophic environmental consequences alleged, as the anticipated impacts on the ecology and surrounding communities have informed the proposed detailed mitigation measures. Furthermore, after construction is complete, the project will remain subject to oversight and accountability by other statutory bodies, including the 3rd Respondent, in relation to any activity likely to degrade the environment. The deponent maintains that KURA is committed to adhering to the principle of sustainable development, as envisioned in Article 69(1) of the Constitution.

14. The deponent further avers that the law permits certain project activities to commence before the formal issuance of an environmental licence, particularly where the ESIA process has been substantially completed and the Applicant is awaiting NEMA’s final licensing decision. He further contends that the preliminary activities undertaken to date in Ngong Road Forest, namely topographical surveys, geotechnical investigations, and limited vegetation clearance, constitute legally permissible preparatory works under Regulation 27 of the Environmental (Impact Assessment and Audit) Regulations, 2003.

15. The 4th Respondent submits that the Petition is based on the erroneous assumption that environmental rights invariably override all other constitutional considerations, whereas the Constitution requires a holistic balancing of environmental protection with public safety, economic development, and the national interest. The 4th Respondent further asserts that the project is of national significance, as it is intended to facilitate upcoming international sporting events and enhance Nairobi's transport network. It contends that technical traffic modelling confirms that the existing road network cannot safely accommodate projected demand or satisfy emergency evacuation requirements for users expected to attend international sporting events at Talanta Sports City Stadium. It further submits that granting the orders sought would cause substantial public prejudice and disrupt government infrastructure programmes.

The 3rd Respondent’s Replying Affidavit

16. The 3rd Respondent opposed the application by way of the Affidavit of Dr. Leonard Tampushi, sworn on 4/8/2026. The deponent avers that the Petitioners’ assertion that the 3rd Respondent unlawfully authorised the impugned road project without an Environmental Impact Assessment Licence fundamentally misapprehends the statutory processes under the EMCA and the Regulations thereunder. The absence of a licence during an ongoing statutory evaluation does not, in itself, constitute evidence of illegality on the part of the Authority.

17. He states that the Authority received an application from the 4th Respondent for the proposed Talanta Sports City Stadium and Bomas International Convention Centre road project. The Authority registered the application under Reference Number NEMA/ENVIS/SR/00619 on 17/7/2026, following payment of the prescribed statutory fees. The application currently before the Authority is a Study Report and does not constitute an EIA Licence.

18. He avers that, before the Study Report was submitted, the Authority approved the Terms of Reference under Approval Number NEMA/ENVIS/EIA/TOR/Approval0169. The project proponent subsequently submitted the requisite Environmental and Social Impact Assessment study report. The Authority confirms that this submission merely initiates the statutory evaluation process and does not automatically result in the issuance of a licence. In addition, the Authority received numerous supporting documents, including Bills of Quantities, a Stakeholder Engagement Plan, signed minutes of engagement meetings, administered questionnaires, and other technical and statutory documents required to evaluate the application. The statutory review process prescribed under EMCA and the applicable Regulations is therefore ongoing. He further states that the Authority has neither completed its technical evaluation nor made a final decision on whether to issue a licence.

19. He deposes that the Petitioners have failed to identify any specific unlawful act, omission or constitutional violation by the Authority. The conservatory orders sought would prematurely halt an ongoing statutory process and undermine the regulatory framework underpinning the Authority’s mandate. He avers that it is in the public interest for the Authority to complete its evaluation without unwarranted interference.

The 5th Respondent’s Replying Affidavit

20. In its Replying Affidavit, sworn by Stanley Gitari on 23/9/2026, the 5th Respondent states that the Petitioners’ grievance primarily concerns the Bomas–Talanta Road Project, undertaken by the 4th Respondent. The deponent denies any involvement in the project’s financing, procurement, supervision, authorisation, or implementation, and states that the Petitioners have adduced no evidence linking it to the construction of a railway at the site in question.

21. The deponent further distinguishes the Bomas–Talanta Road Project from the separate Ngong–Riruta Meter Gauge Railway Project. He states that the allegation that the 5th Respondent proposes, or has been directed, to construct a railway serving Talanta Stadium is based solely on unsubstantiated apprehension and is unsupported by any project documents, approvals, contracts, designs, or construction programme. He avers that the road works cannot properly be regarded as evidence of railway construction.

22. The deponent further avers and refers to prior proceedings relating to the Ngong–Riruta Meter Gauge Railway Project, including Petition E028 of 2024 and Petition E843 of 2025. He states that the Courts have previously considered the legality and implementation of the railway project and issued consequential directions, including requirements for further public participation and compliance measures. He asserts that the 5th Respondent is complying with these directions and contends that the present application should not reopen or restrain matters the Court has already addressed.

The 6th Respondent’s Replying Affidavit

23. The 6th Respondent opposed the application through the Replying Affidavit of Erick Kipngetich Bii sworn on 24/9/2026.

24. He avers that the application improperly groups its licensed ecotourism project with unrelated road, railway, and stadium projects undertaken by separate proponents. The deponent further states that the 6th Respondent has no control over the 4th and 5th Respondents, and that the Petitioners' evidence, comprising photographs not specific to the project and allegations of excavation, relates exclusively to road works allegedly carried out on 8 and 9 July 2026 by unrelated parties.

25. The 6th Respondent contends that the Petitioners’ assertion that no licences existed is demonstrably incorrect and misleading. It is averred that the 2nd Respondent approved the project and issued Special Use Licence No. LIC/18/2024 on 12/2/2025, expressly recording that no trees would be affected. It is stated that the 3rd Respondent subsequently issued EIA Licence No. NEMA/EIA/PSL/42385 on 2/9/2025 for an eleven-unit ecotourism facility, and that the Kenya Wildlife Service confirmed compliance on 22/10/2025. It is further averred that the Water Resources Authority also authorised effluent works on 2/12/2025.

26. The 6th Respondent denies felling mature trees, asserting that the design has a low environmental impact and is situated around existing vegetation. It contends that the Petitioners failed to identify specific unauthorised structures or provide competing, site-specific ecological evidence to support their allegations. Furthermore, the 6th Respondent denies that construction continued unabated, stating that it complied with all suspension directives pending completion of the regulatory process.

27. The Petitioners are further accused of failing to exhaust the statutory appeal mechanism under section 129 of EMCA in relation to the EIA licence. The NEMA licence remains valid and in force. The 6th Respondent contends that the blanket conservatory orders sought are excessive, as they will restrain lawful mitigation and compliance works and would prematurely grant final relief. Accordingly, the 6th Respondent prays that prayers 2, 4, and 5 of the Notice of Motion be dismissed with costs.

The Petitioner’s Further Affidavit

28. The Petitioners filed a Further Affidavit, sworn by Akshay Vishwanath on 27/7/2026, in response to the 1st, 2nd and 4th Respondents’ Replying Affidavit.

29. The deponent avers that the 1st, 2nd, and 4th Respondents’ reply addresses only the Bomas-Talanta road and is silent on the Petitioners’ case against the 6th Respondent regarding the eco-lodge, as well as on their case against the 3rd and 5th Respondents.

30. The deponent further reiterates the Petitioners’ assertions that the stakeholder engagements relied upon by the 4th Respondent did not constitute meaningful public participation. In particular, the meeting held on 13/2/2026 took place before completion of the ESIA study, which, according to Eng. Kinoti’s affidavit, commenced in February 2026, was completed in June 2026, and was submitted to NEMA on 24/6/2026. The deponent argues that the engagements could not have addressed the completed ESIA report, its findings, or the proposed mitigation measures. The Petitioners further contend that the meetings were restricted to invited institutional stakeholders, were convened at short notice, and were not supported by evidence of adequate public notification or participation as contemplated by the applicable Regulations and the Constitution.

31. The Petitioners further challenge the evidentiary basis for the alleged stakeholder consultations. They contend that the invitee list marked “SMK-1” was closed and that insufficient evidence shows that the Ngong Road Forest Association was afforded a genuine opportunity to be heard. They also note the absence of evidence of Gazette notices, newspaper publications, radio announcements, or a public hearing convened by NEMA under Regulation 22. Accordingly, the Petitioners maintain that the Respondents’ materials fail to demonstrate compliance with the statutory requirements for public participation.

32. Regarding the alleged Early Entry permission granted by the Kenya Forest Service (KFS) on 4/2/2026, the Petitioners contend that neither the Forest Conservation and Management Act, 2016, nor the regulations made thereunder authorise site clearance, fence relocation, or other preparatory works in a public forest without the requisite statutory licences. Section 56 of the Act limits KFS’s licensing authority to a defined Special Use Licence. Citing sections 58 and 59 of EMCA, the Petitioners further contend that the Early Entry permission was granted before the requisite Special Use Licence and ESIA licence had been issued. They also question whether Regulation 27 permits preparatory works of this nature and assert that the Respondents have not produced the relevant licences.

33. The Petitioners also challenge the alleged chronology of events, calling into question the legality and independence of the environmental assessment process; that procurement activities commenced in September 2025, qualified contractors were identified by October 2025, Early Entry permission was granted in February 2026, and the ESIA study is alleged to have commenced only in February 2026. The ESIA report was submitted to NEMA on 24/6/2026, while licensing fees were paid on 17/7/2026, after the present proceedings had been filed and excavation and tree-felling activities had commenced. The Petitioners contend that this sequence raises questions as to whether the environmental assessment and analysis of alternatives preceded the operational commitment to the road, and whether the licensing process was undertaken only after implementation had begun.

34. The Petitioners further contend that the Replying Affidavit leaves material matters unanswered, including the alleged construction of a concrete wall, the removal of fencing and felling of mature trees, the absence of an exhibited ESIA licence, and the failure to disclose engineering drawings, procurement dates, and other documents sought in the Petition. They further assert that the Respondents have not demonstrated any amendment to the Participatory Forest Management Plan or the required consultation with the Ngong Road Forest Association under applicable law. They rely on the decisions of the Court in; Green Belt Movement v Kenya Forest Service & Others, ELC Petition No. E042 of 2024, and Okiya Omtatah Okoiti v Ministry of Lands, Public Works, Housing and Urban Development & 11 Others, ELC Petition No. E052 of 2025 (the Southlands judgment), to support their contention that environmental licensing and forest-management processes cannot retrospectively regularise works commenced before the requisite statutory processes are completed.

35. Furthermore, the deponent avers that the KFS failed to discharge its statutory co-management duty with the Kenya Forest Research Institute, as KFS filed no affidavit explaining its engagement with the 1st Interested Party. Consequently, the deponent maintains that the Replying Affidavit corroborates, rather than rebuts, the Petitioners' case. The deponent reiterates that the prayer for conservatory orders is meritorious.

The 1st, 2nd and 4th Respondents’ Supplementary Affidavit

36. The 4th Respondent filed a Supplementary Affidavit, sworn by Eng. Silas M. Kinoti and dated 28/7/2026, in response to the issues raised in the Petitioners’ Further Affidavit.

37. The deponent asserts that the Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (ESIA) process for the Talanta Sports City Stadium and BICC Phase I Project has neither been circumvented nor left incomplete. He reiterates that the ESIA Report was submitted to the 3rd Respondent on 24/6/2026, before these proceedings were filed.

38. Regarding site activities, the deponent maintains that only preparatory works, authorised by the KFS under an Early Entry permission granted on 4/2/2026, have been carried out. The deponent avers that this permission is a standard administrative practice, consistent with the Forest Conservation and Management Act, 2016 (FCMA), and is not extra-statutory, as alleged.

39. The deponent further reiterated that the consultations, including the meeting held on 13/2/2026, were iterative and informed the project design and mitigation measures. The deponent maintains that the invitee list was a considered selection of affected parties, including the 1st Interested Party through the Community Forest Association, and that the constitutional requirement for public participation does not necessarily require unanimity.

40. Finally, the deponent categorically denies the allegations of unlawful destruction, including the felling of mature trees or the dismantling of fences, and states that any vegetation clearance was minimal and undertaken solely for topographical surveys. He adds that NEMA retains the power to impose conditions or deny the licence if the ESIA Report is found to be deficient.

The Petitioners’ application dated 6/8/2026

41. The Petitioner's application dated 6/8/2026 is brought under the provisions of Section of the Environment and Land Court Act, Section 5(1) of the Judicature Act, Cap 8, Section 3, 3A, 3B and 63(c) and (e) of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 40 Rule 3; Order 51 Rules 1, 3 and 4 of the Civil Procedure Rules, and Rules 2, 20 and 24 of the Environment and Land Court (Practice and Procedure) Rules, 2014. The Petitioner prays for orders that;

a. The Director General, Kenya Urban Roads Authority, Eng. Silas Kinoti of the 4th Respondent be, and is hereby, summoned to appear in person before this Honourable Court to show cause why he should not be cited, committed to civil jail, fined, and/or otherwise punished for contempt of the conservatory Order of this Honourable Court issued on 30/7/26 in this suit.

b. The Chief Conservator of Forests, Kenya Forest Service, Mr. Alexander Lemarkoko, of the 2nd Respondent, be, and is hereby, summoned to appear in person before this Honourable Court to show cause why he should not be cited, committed to civil jail, fined, and/or otherwise punished for contempt of the said conservatory Order of 30/7/26.

c. Upon the said Director General, KURA and the said Chief Conservator of Forests, KFS failing to show sufficient cause, they be each committed to civil jail for a term not exceeding six (6) months, or fined, or both, and/or such other punishment as this Honourable Court may deem fit, for contempt of the Order of this Honourable Court dated 30/7/26.

d. The Officer Commanding Station Jamhuri Police Station, having jurisdiction over Ngong Road Forest, be, and is hereby, directed to enforce compliance with the Order of this Honourable Court dated 30/7/26 and any further orders made herein, and to provide such assistance to the Petitioners/Applicants and the Deputy Registrar of this Court as may be necessary to give effect to the same.

e. The costs of this Application be borne personally by the Director General, Kenya Urban Roads Authority and the Chief Conservator of Forests, Kenya Forest Service, in any event.

42. The application is based on the grounds set out on its face and is further supported by the affidavit of Akshay Vishwanath, dated the same day.

43. The deponent avers that the conservatory order of 30/7/2026 was issued in the presence of Counsel for the Respondents, and that the Respondents were therefore aware of its terms and legal consequences.

44. It is deposed that, notwithstanding the Order and the penal notice, the 2nd and 4th Respondents continued tree-felling, earthworks and excavation, and interfered with the electric fence. The deponent annexes photographs, allegedly taken on 3/8/2026, showing an excavator and workers carrying out ground-clearing and excavation alongside the fence. Further, photographs taken on 5/8/2026 show freshly felled trees, cut branches, cleared vegetation and tree stumps.

45. The Deponent avers that the Director General of the 4th Respondent, Eng. Silas Kinoti, and the Chief Conservator of Forests of the 2nd Respondent, Mr. Alexander Lemarkoko, are responsible for ensuring the 2nd and 4th Respondents’ compliance with the Court’s Orders.

46. He contends that the disobedience of the impugned orders is deliberate, willful and contumacious. It is further averred that unless the Court intervenes urgently, continued excavation and tree-felling will cause irreversible damage to the mature forest cover, a vital urban water catchment, biodiversity and a public trust resource.

The Replying Affidavit filed by Mr Alex Lemarkoko

47. The Chief Conservator of Forests of the 2nd Respondent, Mr. Alexander Lemarkoko, filed a Replying Affidavit dated 18/9/2026.

48. From the outset, he contends that he was never personally served with the Court order dated 30/7/2026 or the contempt application dated 6/8/2026, as required by law. He avers that he learnt of the Order and the Contempt application only through their Counsel. He further argues that he was never formally joined as a party to the proceedings. The deponent avers that his rights to a fair hearing and liberty have been prejudicially curtailed, as he was denied the opportunity to elect his own representation.

49. Regarding the substance of the application, the deponent asserts that, prior to the Court order, the 2nd Respondent had issued an Early Entry Permit authorising preliminary project activities in the Ngong Road Forest. He confirms that, upon learning of the conservatory orders on 30/7/2026, the 2nd Respondent immediately instructed the cessation of all activities. He deposes that active preliminary works ceased on 31/7/2026, with only the demobilisation of machinery continuing until 3/8/2026. He maintains that no excavation, tree-felling, or construction is currently underway and that the 2nd Respondent has fully complied with the Court orders.

50. The deponent further argues that the contempt application lacks merit because it relies on hearsay and unverified photographic evidence. He points out that the supporting affidavit fails to disclose the identities of the persons who took the photographs, no affidavit was sworn to verify the images, and no certificate of electronic evidence, as required by the Evidence Act, has been adduced. He contends that the Applicants have not met the higher standard of proof required for quasi-criminal contempt proceedings, and he asserts that the allegations are spurious and made in bad faith.

The Replying Affidavit filed by Eng. Silas M Kinoti

51. The 4th Respondent opposed the application by the Replying Affidavit of Eng. Silas Murira Kinoti, dated 22/9/2026.

52. The deponent states that the 4th Respondent learnt of the contempt application only from the State Counsel. He asserts that contempt proceedings are personal and that the alleged contemnor must be personally served and afforded the opportunity to choose legal representation. The deponent claims they were not served with the order violated or with the contempt application, which they argue prejudices their right to a fair hearing.

53. The deponent notes that the conservatory order was issued on 30/7/2026 and extracted on 31/7/2026. He avers that, upon the order being brought to the 4th Respondent's attention on 30/7/2026, he instructed officials and agents to cease all activities in the forest immediately and to comply fully with the order. He states that there was thereafter no further excavation, tree-felling or interference with the electric fence, and that although active works stopped on 31/7/2026, demobilisation of machinery continued until 3/8/2026 because of the intervening weekend.

54. He denies the Petitioners’ allegations that preliminary works continued after the order and contends that these allegations are an attempt to mislead the Court. The deponent argues that the contempt application is based on hearsay from undisclosed Petitioner representatives and on photographic material whose authenticity cannot be vouched for, rendering it without probative value.

The 5th Respondent’s Replying Affidavit

55. In the Replying Affidavit sworn by Stanley Gitari on 23/9/2026, the 5th Respondent asserts that the conservatory orders issued on 30/7/2026 were directed only at the 2nd, 4thand 6th Respondents and imposed no obligation on it, that the contempt application is directed solely at the 2nd and 4th Respondents and their officers, and that there is no factual or legal basis for any order against the 5th Respondent.

The 5th Respondent’s application dated 14/9/26

56. The 5th Respondent in its application dated 14/9/2026 seeks for orders that;

a. The Petition as against the 5th Respondent be struck out for failure to disclose a reasonable cause of action.

b. The name of the 5th Respondent be struck out from these proceedings for improper joinder.

c. The costs of this Application be awarded to the 5th Respondent.

57. The application is premised on the face of it and on the affidavit of Stanley Gitari, of even date. The deponent avers that the joinder of the 5th Respondent is based on allegations concerning a proposed railway project and its alleged impact on the environment and the Ngong Road Forest. He contends that the Petition does not identify any specific decision, approval, licence, instrument, act or omission attributable to the Applicant that is being challenged.

58. The Applicant further states that the excavation, tree-felling, land clearance and construction activities complained of in the Petition relate to separate Bomas–Talanta road and eco-lodge projects involving other Respondents. He argues that the reliefs sought do not disclose any specific claim or relief against it, and that no material facts show that it has violated, or threatens to violate, any constitutional or statutory right of the Petitioners.

The Court’s direction on written submissions in respect to the applications dated 13/7/26, 6/8/26 and 14/9/26

59. Pursuant to directions issued on 16/9/2026, the Court directed that the applications be dispensed with by way of written submissions. The parties complied. The Court has read and considered all the written submissions, which now form part of the Court record. The Court is grateful to the respective counsel for their industry and highlights.

Analysis and determination

60. I have considered the pleadings, the applications, the rival affidavits thereto, the submissions thereof as well as the Court record. I distil the following issues for determination:

a. Whether the Petitioners have satisfied the principles applicable in applications for conservatory orders;

(i) Whether the prayer for discovery is merited;

(ii) Whether the Court should conduct a site visit;

b. Whether the Petitioners’ application for contempt of Court is merited;

c. Whether the 5th Respondent should be struck out of the Petition

d. Who should bear the costs of the applications.

Whether the Petitioner has satisfied the principles applicable in applications for conservatory orders;

61. A conservatory order was defined in the case of Invesco Assurance Co. Ltd vs. MW (Minor suing thro' next friend and mother (HW) [2016] eKLR as follows: -

“A conservatory order is a judicial remedy granted by the Court by way of an undertaking that no action of any kind is taken to preserve the subject until the motion of the suit is heard. It is an order of status quo for the preservation of the subject matter.”

62. The primary constitutional basis for granting conservatory orders is Article 23(3)(c), which expressly authorises such orders in proceedings brought under Article 22. Article 22 is deliberately broad, covering threatened violations and conferring standing on persons acting in the interests of groups, classes, associations and the public interest.

63. Courts have repeatedly held that caution is necessary when dealing with applications for conservatory orders, so as not to venture into the arena of the main Petition. Ibrahim, J (as he then was) in Muslim for Human Rights (Milimani) & 2 Others vs Attorney General & 2 Others (2011) eKLR rightly so rendered himself as follows: -

“The Court must be careful for it not to reach final conclusion and to make final findings. By the time the application is decided; all the parties must still have the ability and flexibility to prosecute their cases or present their defences without prejudice. There must be no conclusivity or finality arising that will or may operate adversely vis-a vis the case of either parties. The principle is similar to that in temporary or interlocutory injunctive in civil matters. This is a cardinal principle and happily makes my functions and work here much easier despite walking a tight legal rope that I could easily lose balance with the slightest slip due to any laxity or being carried away by the passion or zeal of persuasion of any one side.”

Also see the case of Speedex Logistics Limited & 2 Others v Director of Criminal Investigations & 3 Others [2018] eKLR .

64. The principles for considering whether to grant conservatory orders have been developed by the Courts over time. The locus classicus is the Supreme Court decision in Gatirau Peter Munya -v- Dickson Mwenda Kithinji & 2 Others (2014) eKLR. At paragraph 86, the Court stated as follows: -

[86] Conservatory orders” bear a more decided public-law connotation: for these are orders to facilitate ordered functioning within public agencies, as well as to uphold the adjudicatory authority of the Court, in the public interest. Conservatory orders, therefore, are not, unlike interlocutory injunctions, linked to such private-party issues as “the prospects of irreparable harm” occurring during the pendency of a case; or “high probability of success” in the Applicant’s case for orders of stay. Conservatory orders, consequently, should be granted on the inherent merit of a case, bearing in mind the public interest, the constitutional values, and the proportionate magnitudes, and priority levels attributable to the relevant courses.

65. In Wilson Kaberia Nkunja vs. The Magistrate and Judges Vetting Board and Other [2016] eKLR the Court summarized the three principles for consideration as follows:

a. An Applicant must demonstrate that he has a prima facie case with a likelihood of success and that unless the Court grants the conservatory order, there is a real danger that he will suffer prejudice as a result of the violation or threatened violation of the Constitution.

b. Whether, if a conservatory order is not granted, the Petition alleging violation of, or threat of violation of rights will be rendered nugatory; and

c. The public interest must be considered before grant of a conservatory order. See the case of Board of Management of Uhuru Secondary School versus City County Director of Education & 2 Others [2015] e KLR.

Whether a prima-facie case was established

66. Courts have settled the definition of a prima facie case in respect of civil applications. For instance, in Mrao vs. First American Bank of Kenya Limited & 2 Others (2003) KLR 125 the Court defined a prima facie case to mean: -

“…. In a civil application includes but is not confined to a ‘genuine and arguable case’. It is a case which, on the material presented to the Court, a tribunal properly directing itself will conclude that there exists a right which has apparently been infringed by the opposite party as to call for an explanation or rebuttal from the later.

67. It is trite law that the burden of proof rests upon the party who asserts the particulars of the claim to adduce evidence to support the prima facie case.

68. Has the Applicant established a prima facie case? To begin with, the Petitioners have contended that the impugned projects were commenced without the requisite licences or approvals from the 3rd Respondent, as required by law. Article 69(f) of the Constitution requires the State to establish systems for environmental impact assessment, environmental audit and environmental monitoring.

69. Section 58 of the EMCA stipulates the procedure to be followed when applying for an EIA license. It provides as follows:

“58(1). Notwithstanding any approval, permit or license granted under this Act or any other law in force in Kenya, any person, being a proponent of a project, shall before for financing, commencing, proceeding with, carrying out, executing or conducting or causing to be financed, commenced, proceeded with, carried out, executed or conducted by another person any undertaking specified in the Second Schedule to this Act, submit a project report to the Authority, in the prescribed form, giving the prescribed information and which shall be accompanied by the prescribed fee.

(2) The proponent of any project specified in the second schedule shall undertake a full environmental impact assessment study and submit an environmental impact assessment study report to the Authority prior to being issued with any licence by the Authority:

Provided that the Authority may direct that the proponent forego the submission of the environmental impact assessment study report in certain cases.”

70. The 4th Respondent, the proponent of the proposed Talanta Sports City Stadium and Bomas International Convention Centre road project, confirms that, at the time of filing the instant Petition, the 3rd Respondent had not issued the requisite licence. However, it is averred that the KFS granted the 4th Respondent Early Entry Permission vide the Letter dated 4/2/2026. The 1st, 2nd and 4th Respondents argue that the Early Entry Permission permitted the 4th Respondent to carry out preliminary works, including surveys, geotechnical investigations and limited site clearance, and that the 4th Respondent subsequently applied for the requisite Special Use Licence.

71. I have perused the Early Entry Permission granted vide Letter dated 4/2/2026. It reads in part;

‘Your request for early access to the affected portion of Ngong Road Forest to commence implementation of the proposed works is noted, and is hereby granted.

Please note that a Special Use License will be processed as soon as the approval by the Board is granted and the negotiations made for full compliance with the conditions therein…

i. Adherence to the conditions of the NEMA license with regard to the project

ii. Submission of technical designs of the project

iii. Payment of the requisite fees payable to the Service prior to issuance of the Special Use License

iv. Cooperation with Kenya Forest Service to enhance seamless Service delivery, among others.’

72. In their submissions, the 1st, 2nd and 4th Respondents submit that the Early Entry Permission, granted pursuant to Section 56 of the Forest Conservation and Management Act, allows them to undertake the activities complained of. Section 56(2) of the Forest Conservation and Management Act provides;

“(2) The Service may issue authorizations for forestry activities in form of—

a) a permit;

b) a timber licence;

c) a special use licence;

d) a contract;

e) a joint management agreement; or

f) a concession agreement.”

73. Considering the provisions of Section 56 of the Forest Conservation and Management Act, the permission granted by KFS, and the extent of the activities undertaken by KURA to date without the requisite approval from the 3rd Respondent, I am of the considered view that the Petitioners have raised a prima facie or arguable case. Although the 4th Respondent contends that the Early Entry Permission authorised it to undertake preliminary activities, whether those activities constitute preliminary works or not shall be determined at trial.

74. There is also contestation over the quality of public participation. Under Article 10 of the Constitution, public participation is a fundamental principle of governance. Article 69 of the Constitution specifically addresses public participation in environmental management, requiring the state to encourage it in the management, protection and conservation of the environment.

75. The Petitioners argue that the impugned project is being undertaken without public participation and the involvement of key stakeholders. It has been contended that, without public participation, the impugned project is unconstitutional. The 1st, 2nd and 4th Respondents have maintained that they undertook public participation and, to this end, they attached questionnaires purporting to demonstrate such participation.

76. The question that arises and which the Court will have to interrogate concerns the quality of public participation; whether there was prior public awareness; and whether the key stakeholders were involved. This issue cannot be determined at the interlocutory stage. It will require examination of the evidence at trial.

77. As for the eco-lodge, the 6th Respondent has, as set out above, deposed that it holds Special Use Licence No. LIC/18/2024 issued by the 2nd Respondent on 12/2/2025 and EIA Licence No. NEMA/EIA/PSL/42385 issued by the 3rd Respondent on 2/9/2025, and that the Kenya Wildlife Service confirmed compliance on 22/10/2025. It has also denied felling mature trees.

78. I note that the Petitioners did not file any response to the 6th Respondent’s assertion. The 6th Respondent's affidavit evidence has therefore not been rebutted. In the absence of evidence challenging the approvals granted in respect of the eco-lodge, the Petitioners have failed to establish a prima facie case in respect of the eco-lodge. Conservatory orders cannot therefore be issued in respect of it.

Whether the violations of rights would render the Petition nugatory

79. Next is the issue of whether the failure to grant conservatory orders will defeat the Petition's foundation. To begin with, the crux of the Petition is the preservation and conservation of Ngong Forest and the general conservation of the environment in accordance with Article 42 of the Constitution.

80. Without venturing into the merits of the Petition, NEMA plays a central role in the preservation and protection of the environment, including ecologically sensitive habitats. It is the watchdog for environmental well-being in our Country, as evidenced by Section 9 of EMCA.

81. The principle of sustainable development holds that developments, such as the one in question, ought to take into account ecological and environmental considerations. The environment must be utilised and exploited in a manner that protects future generations. The Court will be called upon to interrogate whether the principle of ecological sustainable development has been considered.

82. Article 69(1) of the Constitution obliges the State, among other things, to ensure the sustainable exploitation, utilisation, management and conservation of the environment and natural resources, to work to achieve and maintain a tree cover of at least ten per cent of the land area of Kenya, and to eliminate processes and activities that are likely to endanger the environment. Under Article 69(2), every person has a duty to cooperate with State organs and other persons to protect and conserve the environment and ensure ecologically sustainable development and use of natural resources.

83. There is also the Precautionary principle, a doctrine that when there are threats of serious and irreversible damage to the environment, a lack of full scientific certainty is not a reason for postponing measures to prevent the damage. A proponent is to take measures or precautions to ensure that there is no damage to the environment even as it actualises its project.

84. It is not in dispute that the 4th Respondent has undertaken vegetation clearance and some excavation before obtaining the requisite licence from the 3rd Respondent. These activities will inevitably remove part of Ngong Forest and have ripple effects on the environment. Therefore, continuing them before the subject Petition is heard and determined will no doubt defeat it.

85. Given the nature of the projects and the irreversible environmental harm likely to be caused, the Court finds that the Petition is likely to be rendered nugatory if conservatory orders are not issued.

The public interest aspect

86. Finally, it is important to address where the public interest and proportionality lie. The 4th Respondent argues that the Project forms part of critical national infrastructure, designed to enhance transport connectivity, public safety, emergency response, and traffic circulation, while further supporting international sporting events at the Talanta Sports City Stadium and establishing connectivity to the Bomas International Convention Complex (BICC) and the broader road network, including Magadi Road and Lang’ata Road. The 4th Respondent further argues that, given the FIFA timelines for approval to host the upcoming Africa Cup of Nations (AFCON) tournaments, preliminary preparations need to commence.

87. The Petitioners rely on the rule of law, constitutional fidelity, public participation, the principle of sustainable development, and the precautionary principle. In their submissions, they argue that any inconvenience or cost to the Respondents arising from a short pause in works pending an expedited hearing is both compensable and reversible. However, the loss of mature forest cannot be reversed. They contend that where the harm on one side is reversible and the harm on the other is not, the balance of convenience favours granting the conservatory orders.

88. Public interest is therefore the most delicate element of the balance. In light of the competing public interest and constitutional proportionality, and pursuant to Section 13(7)(a) of the Environment and Land Court Act, 2011, which sets out this Court’s mandate to grant interim preservation orders, it is in the interests of justice to issue status quo orders to preserve the subject property pending the hearing and determination of the Petition.

89. Noting the averments in their respective responses by the 1st, 2nd and 4th Respondents that they ceased all activities on the site pursuant to the interim orders dated 30/7/2026, the Court directs that the status quo as at 30/7/2026 be maintained pending the hearing and determination of the Petition.

90. Prayer (b) is directed against the 5th Respondent in respect of the proposed Riruta-Ngong Town Meter Gauge Railway line. From the description of parties in the Petition, the Petitioners stated the mandate of the 5th Respondent and averred that the 5th Respondent has been joined in the Petition herein because it is the agency responsible, or which will be responsible, for the proposed Riruta-Ngong Town Meter Gauge Railway line, which the Petitioners are informed and verily believe is proposed to traverse a portion of Ngong Road Forest en route to Talanta Sports City.

91. Other than the description, the 5th Respondent is not mentioned elsewhere in the Petition or in relation to the alleged proposed construction of the railway line. In the absence of a substantive prayer in the Petition, a conservatory order cannot issue against the 5th Respondent and/or the speculative railway line.

92. Prayer (c) seeks to restrain the 2nd, 3rd, 4th and 5th Respondents from taking any further step in respect of any permit, licence, way-leave or approval for the eco-lodge, the road or the railway. The Court notes that these are statutory bodies with mandates set out in their respective establishing statutes. On the evidence before the Court, the Court finds no justifiable reason to restrain them from carrying out their duties, particularly at an interim stage, without affording them an opportunity to be heard and to adduce evidence. Prayer (c) is therefore declined.

Whether the prayer for discovery is merited;

93. Prayer (d) seeks an order compelling the 2nd, 3rd, 4th and 5th Respondents to make discovery, within ten (10) days, of the environmental, licensing and public participation documents relating to the eco-lodge, the road and the proposed railway.

94. According to Black’s Law Dictionary, 7th Edition, discovery is defined as:

“the disclosure by the defendant of facts, titles, documents, or other things which are in his exclusive knowledge or possession, and which are necessary to the party seeking the discovery as a party of a cause or action pending or to be brought in another Court, or as evidence of his rights or title in such proceeding.”

95. The purpose of discovery is to ensure a level playing field in which all parties are fully aware of their opponent’s case and have the relevant materials to support their case. See the case of ABN Amro Bank N.V. –vs- Kenya Pipeline Company Limited [2014] eKLR, where it was stated that;

“Discovery as a compulsory disclosure, at the request of a party, of information that relates to the litigation in a civil suit is provided for in section 22 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 11 rule 3(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules, and given the nature of discovery, I would class it as a means of access to information in the sense of Article 35(2) (b) of the Constitution. And as Justice Kimondo J stated in the Oracle productions case, I too conclude that “the true purpose of discovery is to level the litigation field, to expedite hearing, reduce costs and allow parties to gauge the case they will face at trial.” It, therefore, serves a higher objective as the enabler of fair hearing.”

96. As the present proceedings are a Constitutional Petition, they are governed by the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, also known as ‘the Mutunga Rules’. The Civil Procedure Rules therefore do not apply. The Mutunga Rules are silent on document discovery.

97. I note that some of the information and documents sought by the Petitioners have been disclosed by the Respondents in their Replying and Supplementary Affidavits and the exhibits thereto. I therefore see no justification for granting the prayer for discovery. In any case, discovery of documents is a case-management tool, and since directions for the hearings of the Petition are yet to be issued, an order of discovery would be premature at this stage.

Whether the Court should conduct a site visit;

98. The Petitioners argue that the Court must visit the site to establish the position on the ground. The 1st, 2nd and 4th Respondents argued in their submissions that site visits should not be used to assist the Petitioners in collecting evidence to build a case.

99. It is a settled principle of law that parties are bound by their pleadings and that submissions are a marketing tool which cannot replace pleadings. The prayer for a site visit was pending the inter partes hearing of the application, not the Petition. The prayer for a site visit is evidently spent. That said, nothing bars the parties from seeking leave to conduct a site visit if and when it becomes necessary and in the interests of justice.

Whether the Petitioners’ application for contempt of Court is merited;

100. Section 29 of the Environment and Land Court Act provides that any person who refuses, fails or neglects to obey an order or direction of the Court given under this Act, commits an offence, and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding twenty million shillings or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years, or to both.

101. In the case of Martin Nyaga Wambora & 4 Others vs. Speaker of the Senate & Others (2014 eKLR it was rightly observed that:

“……. the disobedience of a Court order is a grave issue as it undermines the rule of law. Article 10 of the Constitution identified the rule of law as one of the guiding principles of governance. Article 3 of the Constitution is very clear that every person has an obligation to respect and defend the Constitution. So that any person who disobeys a Court order violates the Constitution.”

102. It is therefore a fundamental rule of law that Court orders be obeyed, and where a Court order enjoins an individual from doing, or refraining from doing, a particular act, he has a duty to comply. The Court has a duty to commit that individual for contempt of its orders if he deliberately fails to comply.

103. In this case, the Court issued the following orders on 30/7/2026;

‘THAT pending the hearing and determination of this application, a conservatory order be and is hereby issued staying and restraining the 2nd, 4th and 6th Respondents, whether by themselves, their servants, agents, employees, contractors or any person acting under their authority, from any further excavation, tree-felling, land clearance, or construction works of any kind at the eco-lodge site operated by the 6th Respondent within the Sanctuary Block of Ngong Road Forest, and the Bomas-Talanta road corridor within Ngong Road Forest, including any removal of the Sanctuary Block electric fence.’

104. The Petitioners have averred that the above orders have been disobeyed by the 2nd and 4th Respondents; hence the need to find the Chief Conservator of Forests of the 2nd Respondent, Mr. Alexander Lemarkoko, and the Director General of the 4th Respondent, Eng. Silas Kinoti, guilty of contempt and to punish them accordingly. That, notwithstanding the Court orders, the 2nd and 4th Respondents have continued with excavation, tree-felling, land clearance, or construction works within Ngong Road Forest. The elements of civil contempt, as set out in the book “Contempt in Modern New Zealand”, are as follows:

a) The terms of the order (or injunction or undertaking) were clear and unambiguous and were binding on the defendant.

b) The defendant had knowledge of or proper notice of the terms of the order.

c) The defendant has acted in breach of the terms of the order.

d) The defendant's conduct was deliberate.

105. These four elements must be proved to establish a case of Civil Contempt. Although the proceedings are civil in nature, the standard of proof is well established as almost beyond reasonable doubt, and is definitely higher than on the balance of probabilities.

106. Considering the four elements set out above, I find that the terms of the order were clear and that the Respondents were aware of it, as they were represented by counsel in Court when the orders were issued. Personal service is no longer mandatory where a party is represented.

107. The crux of the matter before the Court is whether the Respondents breached the terms of the orders, wilfully disobeyed the Court's orders, or committed contempt of Court.

108. The Respondents deny disobedience of the impugned orders and maintain that all project activities ceased the evening the orders were issued, after they became aware of them. They argue that only the demobilisation of machinery to ensure its safety continued until 3/8/2026, due to the intervening weekend. They further contend that the Petitioners have not proved disobedience of the orders, as the Supporting Affidavit is based on hearsay and fails to disclose the source of the information. They also argue that the attached photographs do not identify the person who took them.

109. In the Affidavit in support of the application, the deponent, at paragraph one, avers that he relies on documents in his custody and on information supplied to him by officers of the 1st and 2nd Petitioners and by the Petitioners' representatives who visited the site. At paragraph 5, he avers that he was informed by the Petitioners' representatives that the 2nd and 4th Respondents have continued to excise, clear and fell trees within Ngong Road Forest, to carry out earthworks and excavation, and to interfere with the electric fence of the Sanctuary Block, in flagrant and continuing disregard of the Order of this Honourable Court.

110. He further deposed in Paragraphs 6 and 7 that on 3/8/2026, between approximately 2.58 p.m. and 3.01 p.m., the Petitioners' representatives attended the site and took photographs, geo-tagged and time-stamped, depicting an excavator and workers actively engaged in ground-clearing and excavation works immediately alongside the Sanctuary Block electric fence, and further depicting the fence itself as compromised, with works ongoing along the fence line. That, again on 5/8/2026, the Petitioners' representatives attended the site and took further photographs depicting freshly felled trees, large piles of cut branches and cleared vegetation stacked along the forest paths, and cut tree stumps consistent with recent, ongoing tree-felling within the forest after the date of the Order. The said photographs are annexed hereto and marked "AV-3".

111. The Deponent has not disclosed the names of the persons who informed him, nor has he attached an Affidavit from the said representatives confirming his depositions. The photographers have not deposed, and there is no proof of the date, place, and time, or of the chain of custody. This constitutes hearsay. Further, in the absence of a Certificate of Electronic Evidence under Sections 78A, 106A and 106B of the Evidence Act confirming the authenticity of the photographs, the Court cannot ascertain the veracity of the deponent’s assertions.

112. It is therefore my finding that the Supporting Affidavit contravenes the provisions of Order 19, rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which provides as follows:

“Affidavits shall be confined to such facts as the deponent is able, of his knowledge, to prove.”

113. As the deponent is not privy to the information set out in the Supporting Affidavit, the Court cannot ascertain that its orders were disobeyed. The Court cannot cite a party on the basis of hearsay evidence, particularly given the standard of proof for contempt of Court.

114. In the end, the Court finds no evidence of willful or deliberate disobedience, and the deponents' affidavits show compliance with the orders. It is therefore my finding that the application is not merited. Accordingly, it is dismissed.

Whether the 5th Respondent should be struck out of the Petition

115. Rule 5 of the Mutunga Rules provides for addition, joinder, substitution and striking out of Parties. Sub rule (d) provides that;

“The Court may at any stage of the proceedings, either upon or without the application of either party, and on such terms as may appear just—

(i) order that the name of any party improperly joined, be struck out; and

116. I have perused the Petition. As previously stated, the 5th Respondent has been sued on allegations concerning a proposed railway project and its alleged impact on the environment and the Ngong Road Forest. Apart from mentioning it in the descriptive part, the Petition does not accuse the 5th Respondent of anything. The Petitioners also do not seek any order against the 5th Respondent. As the 5th Respondent states, the Petition does not identify any specific decision, approval, licence, instrument, act or omission attributable to the 5th Respondent that is being challenged. The claim against the 5th Respondent is speculative.

117. In Amon v Raphael Tuck & Sons Ltd [1956] 1 All ER 273, cited in Sakwa & 3 others -vs- County Government of Vihiga & 3 Others [2025] KEELC 4560 (KLR), it was held that the only reason for making a person a party to an action is to bind him by the result of the action and the question to be settled. Therefore, the question must be one that cannot be effectively and completely settled unless he is a party.

118. In the absence of a cause of action against the 5th Respondent, the 5th Respondent was improperly joined in the Petition. Accordingly, the 5th Respondent's name is hereby struck out of the Petition.

119. Final orders for disposal

Based on the foregoing, the three applications are determined as follows;

a. An order for status quo is hereby issued and for clarity, I direct that the status of the site as of 30/7/2026 shall be maintained pending the hearing and determination of the Petition. For the avoidance of doubt, no activities, excavation, tree-felling, land clearance, or construction works whatsoever shall take place at the site pending the hearing and determination of the Petition herein.

b. The application dated 6/8/2026 for contempt of Court is not merited and is hereby dismissed.

c. The application dated 14/9/2026 is meritorious, and consequently the name of the 5th Respondent be and is hereby struck out of these proceedings.

d. As the proceedings herein are public interest litigation, each party shall bear its own costs.

120. It is so ordered.

DELIVERED, DATED AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026 VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS.

J G KEMEI

JUDGE

Delivered online in the presence of:

1. Messrs Gichohi/Mbetera for the Petitioners

2. Mr Odongo for the 1st, 2nd and 4th Respondents

3. N/A for the 3rd Respondent

4. Ms Mugi H/B for Mr. Muturi for the 5th Respondent

5. N/A for the 6th Respondent

6. N/A for the Interested Party

7. CA – Mr. Eglon

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder