Background
The application before this court is the proposed 6th Defendant’s application for joinder dated 26th June 2026 seeking the following orders;
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The application before this court is the proposed 6th Defendant’s application for joinder dated 26th June 2026 seeking the following orders;
Paragraph 1 →I have reviewed the application filed by the 6th intended Defendant dated 26th June 2026 seeking to be enjoined in the matter. The sole issue for determination is whether the application is merited.
Paragraph 8 →I therefore reiterate that a party may be joined in a suit because the party’s presence is necessary in order to enable the court effectually and completely adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the cause or matter. For these reasons, I find merit in notice of motion application dated 26th June 2026.
Paragraph 17 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MILIMANI
ELC CASE E561 OF 2025
IN THE COUNTERCLAIM
JANE WANJIRU KUNGU (Sued as Administrator
of Estate of Bedan Kungu Njenga)……………………………………...1ST DEFENDANT
SAMUEL NJENGA AND NJUGUNA NJENGA (Sued as the
Administrator of the Estate of Joseph Njuguna Njenga)………….…2ND DEFENDANT
JOSEPH WANJIRU NGATA, SALOME WAMBUI NGATA
AND PETER NJUGUNA NGATA(Sued as Administrators
of Estate of Ngata Ikonya Deceased).................................................3RD DEFENDANT
-VERSUS-
BERNARD MIOHE NJAU AND SIMON MIGICI NJAU (Suing as
Administrator of Estate of Njau Gitambi alias Njau Kitumbe) ……….….1ST PLAINTIFF MINNIE NJERI KAMAU, KENNETH CHEGE KAMAU,
JOHN NJUGUNA GAICINGA (Suing as administrator
of Estate Jackson Kamau Gaichinga alias Jackson Kamau)….…………..2ND PLAINTIFF JAMES MWAI KIHARA, MARY NJOKI KIHARA (Suing as
Administrators of the Estate of Kihara Muthiora Kinyungu
Alias Kihara Muthiora)….……………………………………….…………..3RD PLAINTIFF
FLORENCE NYAMBURA MBUGUA AND MARY NYAMBURA
KARURI(Suing as Administrator of Estate of William Mutura)…………4TH PLAINTIFF
RABAT PROPERTIES LIMITED…………………………..………………5TH DEFENDANT
T&R BUSINESS CENTRE LIMITED………..6TH INTENDED DEFENDANT/APPLICANT
RULING
Introduction
1. The application before this court is the proposed 6th Defendant’s application for joinder dated 26th June 2026 seeking the following orders;
i. Pending the hearing and determination of this Application ex- parte this Honourable Court be pleased to arrest it’s impeding Ruling in relation to the Plaintiff’s application dated 10th March 2026 slated for 14th July 2026 pending the hearing and determination of this application inter-partes;
ii. Pending the hearing and determination of this Application inter- partes this Honourable Court be pleased to arrest it’s impeding Ruling in relation to the Application dated 10th March 2026 slated for 14th July 2026 pending the hearing and determination of the application herein.
iii. This Honorable Court be pleased to order that the Applicant be enjoined in this suit as the 6th Defendant;
iv. The Honorable Court be pleased to grant leave to the Applicant to fully participate in the proceedings herein and file such pleadings, submissions and other documents subsequent to the joinder;
v. The Honourable Court be pleased to grant leave to enjoin T & R BUSINESS CENTER LIMITED into this proceeding as the 6th Defendant;
vi. The Honourable Court be pleased to make any further Orders that it may deem fit to grant;
vii. Costs of the application.
2. The intended interested party’s application was premised on grounds as in the supporting affidavit sworn by Abdirahman Mohamed being that the 6th Intended Defendant/Applicant herein had entered into an Investment Agreement (Joint Venture) dated 19th March 2025, with the 5th Defendant, Rabat Properties Limited, over Land Reference Number 36/1/885.That the said agreement was that the intended 6th Defendant contributed to development of a business mall as an investor by channelling substantial amount of funds to the said project.
3. He further deponed that the 6th Defendant is innocent third-party investor for value together with the 5th Defendant, and is not privy to the Plaintiff/Applicant’s purported claim over the suit property and any dealings related to the suit property will affect the Applicant as to his proprietary rights over the suit property hence need to be enjoined and allowed to participate in these proceedings.
Reply
4. The 1st, 2nd and 3rd Defendants in the suit and Plaintiffs in the counterclaim responded by filing grounds of objection to the said application. The grounds raised was that the proposed 6th Defendant had no claim ss against the Plaintiffs neither did the Plaintiff sin the counterclaim have any claim against the intended 6th Defendant.
5. That the issue raised is that he had invested in development on LR NO 36/1/119 and 36/1/885 together with the 5th Defendant which matters do not touch on the issues as between the Plaintiffs and the 5th Defendant and as such any claim over the alleged investment should be charged on the 5th Defendant in a separate suit.
6. That being that the proposed 6th Defendant is not seeking any reliefs as against the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Defendants or Plaintiffs in the counterclaim, he has not demonstrated how his involvement in this suit will be necessary.
Intended 6th Defendant/Applicant’s submissions
7. The Applicant reiterated the content in their supporting affidavit supporting affidavit that it demonstrated an identifiable legal right that ought to be protected by the court hence the need to be enjoined as a party its presence would enable the court effectively adjudicate on the issues raised relying on the provisions of Order 1 Rule 10 (2) and (3) of the Civil Procedure Rules and in the case of Meme Vs Republic (2004) KLR 637 and the case of Civicon Limited Vs Kivuwatt Limited & 2 others [2015] KECA 588 (KLR).
Analysis and determination
8. I have reviewed the application filed by the 6th intended Defendant dated 26th June 2026 seeking to be enjoined in the matter. The sole issue for determination is whether the application is merited.
Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules provides as follows:- “The Court may at any stage of the proceedings, either upon or without Application to either party and on such terms as may appear to the Court to be just, order that the name of any party improperly joined, whether as Plaintif or Defendant, be struck out, and that the name of any person who ought to be joined whether as Plaintiff or Defendant, or whose presence before Court may be necessary in order to enable Court effectually and completely to adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the suit, be added”. It is therefore evident that a party seeking joinder must demonstrate how the suit would affect his interests.
In the case of Direct Line Assurance Co. Ltd v Attorney General [2011] eKLR the Court pronounced itself as follows: - “The law is that only those who are entitled to a claim or be affected by the outcome can legitimately seek protection from the Court. The Applicant has not demonstrated how the legal notice would affect its interests and that of the public it purports to represent. It is not every person who can approach the Court for redress of his grievances but persons with legitimate interests and stake in the outcome and the effects of the decision complained against.”
Further the Supreme Court in Francis K.Muruateru & Ano Vs Republic & 5Others [2016] eKLR set out the key elements for consideration in an Application for joinder as an Interested Party as follows:-
i. Joinder of a person because his presence will result in the complete settlement of all the question involved in the proceedings;
ii. Joinder to provide protection for the rights of a party who would otherwise be adversely affected in law.
iii. Joinder to prevent a likely course of proliferated litigation.
9. But joinder of parties may be refused where such joinder would lead into practical problems of handling the existing cause of action together with the one of the party being joined, is unnecessary or will just occasion unnecessary costs on the parties in the suits – or just being a nuisance on rocking the boat from the bottom. In other words, joinder of parties would be declined where the cause of action being proposed or the relief sought is incompatible to or totally different from the existing cause of action or the relief. The determining factor in joinder of parties would be a common question of fact or law would arise between the existing and the intended parties.
10. The above illustrated legal litmus test on joinder is what I shall apply to the instant case. In consideration and application of all the facts stated here, this Court strongly holds that the Proposed 6th Defendant has not made a strong demonstration to be joined in the instant case. The Court has not seen that need for them to be added as a party to the suit is necessary for the determination of the real matter in dispute or whose presence is necessary in order to enable the court to effectively and completely adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the suit.
11. In the case before this Court the Plaintiffs in the plaint have sued the 1st 2nd and 3rd Defendants on the basis they are not entitled to the suit property as administrators of the estates they represent. That the estate extinguished its title to the suit property and now seek to have their names removed from the register.
12. The 1st, 2nd and 3rd Defendant in the plaint and Plaintiffs in the counterclaim went ahead to sue the Plaintiffs in the plaint/Defendants in the counterclaim indicating that they purportedly sold the property to the 5th Defendant without the consent of the Plaintiffs in the counterclaim. That the suit property in question was jointly owned with the deceased fathers of the Plaintiffs and the deceased fathers of 1st, 2nd and 3rd Defendants in the counterclaim.
13. They therefore sough for orders among others, to have the sale to the 5th Defendant declared as unprocedural as it had been marred with fraud and have the 5th Defendant evicted from the premises and the developments made thereon be demolished
14. From the Court of Appeal authority, the case of 'Pravin Bowry Vs John Ward & Another [2015] eKLR it considered the applicable principles, or test in an application for joinder. The court adopted with approval the holding by the Uganda Supreme Court in the case of: - 'Deported Asians Property Custodian Board Vs Jaffer Brothers Limited [199] 1 EA 55 (SCU) where the court stated: -
' A clear distinction is called for between joining a party who ought to have been joined as a Defendant and one whose presence before the court is necessary in order to enable the court effectually and completely adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the suit. A party may be joined in a suit because the party’s presence is necessary in order to enable the court effectually and completely adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the cause or matter. For a person to be joined on the ground that his presence in the suit is necessary for effectual and complete settlement of all questions in the suit one of two things has to be shown. Either it has to be shown that the orders which the Plaintiff seeks in the suit, would legally affect the interests of that person, and that it is desirable, for avoidance of multiplicity of suits, to have such person joined so that he is bound by the decision of the court in that suit. Alternatively, a person qualifies (on an application of a Defendant) to be joined as a co-Defendant, where it is shown that the Defendant cannot effectually set a defence he desires to set up unless that person is joined in it, or unless the order to be made is to bind that person.
15. The Court further in the Bowry case (supra) also referred to the court’s decision in the case of Civicon Limited Vs Kivuwatt Limited & 2 Others [2015] eKLR which case has been relied on by the Applicant. It stated thus:-
' Again the power given under the rules is discretionary which discretion must of necessity be exercised judicially. The objective of these rules is to bring on record all the persons who are parties to the dispute relating to the subject matter, so that the dispute may be determined in their presence at the time without any protraction, inconvenience and to avoid multiplicity of proceedings. Thus, any party reasonably affected by the pending litigation is a necessary and proper party and should be enjoined. From the foregoing, it may be concluded that being a discretionary order, the court may allow the joinder of a party as a Defendant in a suit based on the general principles set out in Order 1 Rule 10 (2) bearing in mind the unique circumstances of each case with regard to the necessity of the party, in the determination of the subject matter of the suit, any direct prejudice likely to be suffered by the party and the practicability of the execution of the order sought in the suit, in the event that the Plaintiff should succeed. We may add that all that a party needs to do is to demonstrate sufficient interest in the suit, and the interest need not be the kind that must succeed at the end of the trial.'
16. From the facts in the instant case, I am persuaded that the application by the Applicant to have it joined as 6th Defendant and its presence before the court is necessary in order to enable the court effectually and completely adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the suit. Indeed, the Court has taken cognizance of the view held by Learned Counsel for the Plaintiffs in the counterclaim that there exists no cause of action against the intended 6th Defendant and therefore his proposal as the only remedy left for the Applicants is to institute a separate and distinct suit against the 5th Defendant, would tantamount to multiplicity of suits over the same subject matter. Definitely, the proposal defeats logic as this is what this provision of the law attempts to avoid having multiplicity of suits.
17. I therefore reiterate that a party may be joined in a suit because the party’s presence is necessary in order to enable the court effectually and completely adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the cause or matter. For these reasons, I find merit in notice of motion application dated 26th June 2026.
Final disposition
The upshot of the above is that I hold as below;
i. That the Intended Applicant be joined in the suit as the 6th Defendant
ii. That leave is hereby granted to the Applicant to fully participate in the proceedings herein and file such pleadings, submissions and other documents subsequent to the joinder.
iii. That each party to bear their own Costs of the application.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 19th day of October 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
Mr. M. Chege for the Plaintiff
Ms. Nkatha holding brief for Aiden for the Proposed 6th Respondent/Applicant
Ms. Agafwa Holding brief for Mohamed for the 5th Respondent
Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant