Background
The plaintiffs, by an application dated 6.7.2026, seek:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The plaintiffs, by an application dated 6.7.2026, seek:
Paragraph 1 →Applying the foregoing, the first issue for determination is whether the Plaintiffs have established a prima facie case with a probability of success. The Plaintiffs’ claim to the suit property is premised on their alleged membership in Ngumbu Farmers Co-operative Society Limited, the allocation of the land to them by the society, and the subsequent processing of title documents through the relevant land registration authorities.
Paragraph 23 →The application is dismissed with no order as to costs.
Paragraph 46 →In view of the foregoing, the court finds that the plaintiffs have, for purposes of this application, established a prima facie case with a probability of success.
Paragraph 31 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
MILIMANI LAW COURTS
ELC L CASE NUMBER E306 OF 2026
PETER N. TUMBO…………...………………………..…………..1ST PLAINTIFF
JAMES NJOROGE MUTHONI……………………….…………2ND PLAINTIFF
-VERSUS-
MARY WARIARA KERUOYA...…………….………….……..1ST DEFENDANT
NAOMI WANGUI KAMOCHE……………………………….2ND DEFENDANT
RULING
1. The plaintiffs, by an application dated 6.7.2026, seek:
a) Spent
a) That pending the hearing and final determination of this application inter partes, or until further orders, an interim order and injunction be and is hereby issued restraining the 1st and 2nd defendants, either by themselves, their agents, servants or anyone else claiming through them, or on their behalf or anyone else for that matter including investigating officers, from laying any claim, occupying or attempting to occupy, trespassing upon, developing or continuing to develop in any manner whatsoever, investigating or continuing to investigate, summoning the Plaintiffs, alienating or in any other manner interfering with all that property known as LR No. NAIROBI/BLOCK 126/618.
b) That pending the hearing and final determination of this suit, a permanent order of injunction be and is hereby issued restraining the 1st and 2nd defendants, either by themselves, their agents, servants or anyone else claiming through them, or on their behalf or anyone else for that matter including investigating officers, from laying any claim, occupying or attempting to occupy, trespassing upon, developing or continuing to develop in any manner whatsoever, investigating or continuing to investigate, summoning the Plaintiffs, alienating or in any other manner interfering with all that property known as LR No. NAIROBI/BLOCK 126/618.
c) That OCS Ruai Police Station do ensure compliance with the ensuing court orders.
1. The application is supported by the grounds on the face of the application and the supporting affidavit of Peter N. Tumbo sworn on 5.7.2026.
2. It is deposed that the 1st Plaintiff and the co-Plaintiff, as members of Ngumbu Farmers Co-operative Society Limited, were jointly issued with a valid share certificate by the said Society. A copy of the share certificate is annexed hereto and marked PNT1.
3. It is deposed that the said society was the original registered proprietor of a large tract of land situated in the Kamulu area of Nairobi.
4. It is deposed that the society subsequently subdivided and allocated portions thereof to its members, including the plaintiff and the co-Plaintiff, who were allocated a parcel measuring approximately five (5) acres.
5. It is deposed that, upon following the requisite procedures and obtaining the necessary documentation from the society, the plaintiffs successfully processed their title documents through the Ministry of Lands and the relevant Land Registry. A copy of the title document is annexed hereto and marked PNT2.
6. It is deposed that the 1st plaintiff and the co-Plaintiff are the duly registered proprietors of the suit property possessing the original title documents, which they intend to produce and rely upon at the hearing of this matter for their full tenor and effect.
7. It is deposed that the plaintiffs were shocked to discover that the defendants and other persons claiming through them had emerged and purported to occupy the suit property without any lawful justification or supporting ownership documents.
8. It is further deposed that the said persons had commenced clearing the land and demarcating its boundaries without the plaintiffs’ knowledge or consent.
9. It is deposed that, at the time of filing the present suit, the defendants and/or their agents had commenced erecting structures on the suit property, much to the dismay of the plaintiffs. Photographs evidencing the said activities are annexed hereto and marked PNT3.
10. It is deposed that the suit property measures approximately five (5) acres and that, unless the defendants and their agents are restrained, they may proceed to occupy the property, subdivide it, and possibly dispose of the resulting subdivisions to third parties, thereby rendering it difficult, if not impossible, for the Plaintiffs to recover possession and regain control of their property.
11. It is deposed that the defendants have continued with the aforesaid activities with impunity, allegedly taking advantage of the Plaintiffs’ limited financial means and seeking to exploit their superior financial resources to unlawfully dispossess the Plaintiffs of their property by force.
12. It is therefore deposed that the intervention of this honourable court is necessary to restrain the defendants from continuing with the said activities and to preserve the suit property pending the determination of the present application.
13. The respondents did not file any response to the application despite being served.
14. The plaintiffs rely on written submissions dated 23.7. 2026 stating that the application has met the tests in Giella v Cassman Brown & Co. Ltd (1973) EA 358.
15. This court derives its jurisdiction to grant temporary injunctive reliefs from section 63 (e) of the Civil Procedure Act, as read with Order 40 Rules 1 and 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010.
16. Order 40 Rule 1 empowers the court to issue a temporary injunction where it is established that the property in dispute is at risk of being wasted, damaged or alienated by any party to the suit. The provision also applies where a defendant threatens or intends to dispose of or remove the property in circumstances likely to obstruct or delay the execution of a decree that may ultimately be issued by the court.
17. The principles applicable to the grant of interlocutory injunctions were discussed in Giella v Cassman Brown & Co. Ltd [1973] EA 358. The court held that an applicant must demonstrate a prima facie case with a probability of success, establish that they are likely to suffer irreparable harm that cannot adequately be compensated by an award of damages, and, where the Court is in doubt, show that the balance of convenience favours the grant of the injunction.
18. These principles were reaffirmed and further elucidated by the Court of Appeal in Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielsen & 2 Others [2014] eKLR.
19. The court highlighted that these three requirements are separate, standalone, and must be addressed in a specific order. An applicant is required to establish a prima facie case as a prerequisite before the court will assess the likelihood of irreparable harm. The balance of convenience is only evaluated if ambiguity remains after checking the first two conditions. Consequently, the court must weigh each individual criterion against the submitted evidence.
20. In determining whether a prima facie case has been established, this Court is guided by the decision in Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 Others [2003] eKLR. The Court of Appeal defined a prima facie case as one in which the material presented would lead a reasonable tribunal to conclude that a right has apparently been infringed by the opposing party, thereby calling for an explanation or rebuttal. At the interlocutory stage, an applicant need not establish the entire case but must demonstrate an apparent right that warrants protection against threatened infringement.
21. In considering an application for an interlocutory injunction, the Court must exercise restraint and avoid making final determinations on the substantive issues in dispute.
22. In Mbuthia v Jimba Credit Finance Corporation & Another [1988] KLR 1, the Court of Appeal observed that the determination of an interlocutory application does not require final findings on contested questions of fact and law. Rather, the court is required to assess the relative strength of the parties’ respective cases.
23. Applying the foregoing, the first issue for determination is whether the Plaintiffs have established a prima facie case with a probability of success. The Plaintiffs’ claim to the suit property is premised on their alleged membership in Ngumbu Farmers Co-operative Society Limited, the allocation of the land to them by the society, and the subsequent processing of title documents through the relevant land registration authorities.
24. The Plaintiffs have annexed a share certificate marked PNT1 and a title document marked PNT2. They have also produced photographs marked PNT3, as evidence of the clearing of the land, demarcation of boundaries and erection of structures by the defendants or persons acting through them.
25. Article 40 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010, safeguards the right to acquire and own property, subject to the limitations imposed by the Constitution or statute. Sections 24 and 25 of the Land Registration Act, 2012, set out the rights and interests conferred upon a registered proprietor, while Section 26 provides for the evidential status of a certificate of title and the circumstances under which its validity may be challenged.
26. At this preliminary stage, the court is not expected to definitively rule on the validity or origin of the plaintiffs’ property title. That specific issue must be reserved for the trial, where both sides can present evidence and cross-examine the disputed documents.
27. Looking at the title displayed alongside the plaintiffs' historical description of how the property was allocated and the accompanying share certificate provides sufficient initial evidence of a property interest that deserves protection until the final trial.
28. The plaintiffs additionally contend that the defendants trespassed onto the disputed property without permission, cleared sections of the land, established boundaries, and began building structures. In support of these assertions, the plaintiffs rely on the photographic evidence attached to the accompanying supporting affidavit.
29. Though the defendants have not rebutted the allegations made by the plaintiffs, the failure to file a response does not automatically entitle the plaintiffs to the reliefs sought.
30. The court is nonetheless obligated to consider the application on the basis of the evidence presented before it. In the instant case, the plaintiffs have placed before the court evidence in support of their alleged interest in the suit property and their apprehension that the same is being interfered with.
31. In view of the foregoing, the court finds that the plaintiffs have, for purposes of this application, established a prima facie case with a probability of success.
32. The second issue is whether the plaintiffs are likely to suffer irreparable injury that cannot adequately be compensated by damages if the injunction is refused. In Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielsen & 2 Others [2014] eKLR (supra), the Court of Appeal underscored that irreparable injury refers to harm that cannot adequately be remedied through an award of damages, or in respect of which damages would not constitute an adequate remedy.
33. The plaintiffs claim that the defendants are actively working on the disputed land by clearing it, marking boundaries, and building structures. Additionally, they worry that the property could be subdivided and sold or transferred to other buyers before the court reaches a final decision. Delay defeats equity. Non-dislosure of all facts may be detrimental at the ex parte stage.
34. Other than mere allegations of threat and unauthenticated photographs, the plaintiffs do not say when the alleged entry took place, if they reported to the police or sent a demand letter.
35. The court is not satisfied that the Plaintiffs have demonstrated a sufficient risk of injury for which an award of damages may not be an adequate remedy.
36. The third principle requires the court, where doubt persists, to determine the application on the basis of the balance of convenience.
37. The suit property constitutes the subject matter of the pending proceedings. The plaintiffs have presented documentary evidence in support of their claim and allege that the defendants are undertaking activities likely to alter the status of the property before the dispute is resolved. The applicant has to substantiate the likely inconvenience vis-à-vis that of the respondents. The court finds none.
38. The Plaintiffs have additionally sought orders restraining the defendants and persons described as investigating officers from conducting investigations into the dispute or summoning the plaintiffs. This specific prayer requires its own evaluation, distinct from the application to stop trespassing, building, or selling the property in question. Just because a title dispute is ongoing in court, law enforcement is not barred from conducting related criminal investigations, nor can the police be stripped of their legal power to investigate.
39. Article 245 of the Constitution establishes the constitutional framework governing the National Police Service and safeguards its operational independence in the performance of its functions, subject to the Constitution and applicable law. The National Police Service Act, 2011, further provides the statutory framework governing the functions and operations of the service.
40. Judicial intervention is permitted only if clear evidence that proves that investigative authorities are acting illegally, maliciously, for unauthorised reasons, or in violation of constitutional rights. Nevertheless, any such court action must be strictly warranted by the specific facts of the case and narrowly tailored to correct only the proven violation.
41. In the present case, the Plaintiffs have not provided sufficient particulars or evidence to establish that the investigations or summons complained of are unlawful, malicious or otherwise constitute an abuse of statutory powers.
42. The existence of a civil dispute concerning land ownership, without more, does not provide a sufficient basis for restraining lawful investigations. Accordingly, the court declines to grant the blanket orders sought to prohibit investigations or the summoning of the plaintiffs.
43. The plaintiffs have also sought a permanent injunction restraining the Defendants from interfering with the suit property pending the hearing and determination of the suit. A permanent injunction is ordinarily a final remedy granted after the court has heard and determined the substantive dispute and established the respective rights of the parties.
44. The present proceedings concern an interlocutory application, and the court has not yet received and evaluated the evidence necessary to conclusively determine ownership of the suit property. It would therefore be premature to grant a permanent injunction at this stage. The prayer for a permanent injunction shall accordingly be reserved for determination at the hearing of the suit.
45. Flowing from the foregoing, the court finds that the plaintiffs have not met all the tests to be entitled to the prayers sought.
46. The application is dismissed with no order as to costs.
SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 21st DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
HON. JUSTICE C.K NZILI
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Mr. Njeru for the defendants
Court Assistant: Julius
Legal Researcher: Bevalyn Nyakwana