Background
By a Petition dated 5th February 2026, the Petitioner seeks the following orders:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
By a Petition dated 5th February 2026, the Petitioner seeks the following orders:
Paragraph 1 →Regarding jurisdiction, it is trite that it is everything, and without it the Court cannot take one more step in the proceedings. The record shows that this Court considered and determined the issue of jurisdiction in its ruling dated 17th April 2026. That ruling has neither been challenged nor set aside. In light of the foregoing, I see no basis to reopen that determination. Accordingly, this Court has jurisdiction to hear and…
Paragraph 125 →In the matter at hand, the Petitioner contends that it represents residents and property owners whose properties are adjacent to the proposed development and who allege environmental and planning impacts on neighbouring properties. The Petitioners' complaint concerns an alleged threat to the environmental conditions of a neighbourhood and the legality of decisions regarding the proposed development adjacent to its members' properties.…
Paragraph 119 →Whether the petitioner had standing and pleaded constitutional violations with sufficient precision; whether the twenty-storey project complied with the operative planning framework; whether planning and EIA public participation was adequate; whether the EIA…
Oak Valley Management Limited, representing neighbouring Oak Valley Estate residents and owners, challenged approvals for Calla Residency Ventures Kenya Company Limited’s proposed 316-unit, twenty-storey residential development with basement levels on L.R.…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC. EP PETITION NO. E004 OF 2026
OAK VALLEY MANAGEMENT LIMITED ................................. PETITIONER
=VERSUS=
COUNTY EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEMBER (CECM) BUILT
ENVIRONMENT AND URBAN PLANNING,
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY…………………………………….1ST RESPONDENT
THE NAIROBI CITY COUNTY GOVERNMENT……….....2ND RESPONDENT
DIRECTOR GENERAL, NATIONAL ENVIRONMENT
MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY……………………………..3RD RESPONDENT
NATIONAL ENVIRONMENT
MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY………………………………4TH RESPONDENT
THE HONOURABLE ATTORNEY GENERAL………………5TH RESPONDENT
CALLA RESIDENCY VENTURES
KENYA COMPANY LIMITED ………………………………6TH RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. By a Petition dated 5th February 2026, the Petitioner seeks the following orders:
a) A declaration that the development approvals issued by the 1st and 2nd Respondents to the 6th Respondents in respect of L.R. No. Nairobi/Block 4/151 are unconstitutional, unlawful, irregular, null and void for violating Articles 10, 42, 60(1), 66, 69 and 70 of the Constitution, the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, the Environmental Management and Coordination Act and all the applicable regulations.
b) A declaration that the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Licence issued by the 3rd and 4th Respondents to the 6th Respondent is unlawful, irregular, null and void for non-compliance with Sections 57A, 58 and 69 of EMCA and Regulations 7, 16, 17, 18 and 21 of the Environmental (Impact Assessment and Audit) Regulations 2003.
c) A declaration that the Respondents violated the Petitioner’s constitutional rights under Articles 10, 42, 69 and 70 and breached their statutory obligations under PLUPA, EMCA and the Building Regulations.
d) A declaration that the 1st and 2nd Respondents acted ultra vires, irrationally, unreasonably and in abuse of power by issuing development approvals contrary to NIUPLAN 2016, the controlling planning instrument for Nairobi County.
e) A conservatory order restraining the 6th Respondent, its agents, servants, employees, contractors or any persons acting under its authority from undertaking any evacuation, construction, development or related activities on L.R No. Nairobi/Block 4/151 pending the hearing and determination of this petition.
f) A permanent injunction restraining the 1st to 4th Respondents from issuing, renewing, varying or reinstating any development approvals, EIA Licences, construction permits or related authorisation in respect of the said property unless and until full compliance with the Constitution, NIUPLAN 2016, PLUPA, EMCA and all applicable regulations is demonstrated.
g) An order compelling the 3rd and 4th Respondents to require the 6th Respondent to undertake a fresh, complete and compliant Environmental and Social Impact Assessment incorporating a Traffic Impact Assessment, a geotechnical investigation report, a hydrological and storm water management study, a cumulative impact assessment, an infrastructure capacity assessment for water, sewer, drainage and roads and zoning compliance analysis under NIUPLAN 2016.
h) An order compelling the 1st and 2nd Respondents to conduct a lawful, transparent and document-based public participation process in accordance with Article 10 of the Constitution and the Physical and Land Use Planning Act.
i) An order directing the 6th Respondent to restore the site to its original condition should any construction or excavation have commenced unlawfully.
j) An order for general damages.
k) An order that the Respondents bear the costs of this Petition jointly and severally.
l) Such further orders as the Court may deem just and expedient be issued.’
2. The Petition is based on the facts set out therein and is supported by the affidavit of Professor Daniel N. Mugendi, sworn on the same date.
THE PETITIONER’S CASE
3. The deponent averred that he is a director of the Petitioner, which represents residents and property owners in Oak Valley Estate, a predominantly low-density residential neighbourhood. He further averred that their properties are adjacent to the 6th Respondent’s proposed development on L.R. No. Nairobi/Block 4/151 (Original No. 1870/VI/113), the suit property herein.
4. He further averred that the 6th Respondent intends to construct a 20-storey residential tower on the suit property, comprising 316 units and three basement levels. He also averred that the ESIA Study Report submitted by the 6th Respondent is grossly inconsistent with the area’s zoning and planning framework, which designates the property as Zone 4 under the Nairobi Integrated Urban Development Master Plan (NIUPLAN) 2016.
5. He stated that Zone 4 comprises Upper Spring Valley, Kileleshwa, Kilimani, Thompson, Woodley, Kyuna, and parts of Westlands, including Mvuli Road.
6. He further argued that NIUPLAN 2016, Nairobi City County’s approved planning instrument, limits development in Zone 4 to a maximum of four storeys. He maintained that NIUPLAN 2016 remains the County’s latest approved planning instrument and has neither been replaced nor amended. Accordingly, he contended that the 6th Respondent’s proposed 20-storey development is unlawful and in breach of NIUPLAN 2016.
7. He further asserted that the area experiences chronic water shortages, an overloaded sewer system, inadequate drainage, narrow access roads, insufficient parking, inadequate street lighting, and a lack of pedestrian infrastructure. To support this assertion, he submitted a copy of the Nairobi Water and Sewerage Company’s Equitable Water Distribution Programme as evidence of water rationing. He further stated that no infrastructure upgrades had been undertaken since NIUPLAN 2016.
8. He further averred that the Petitioner’s representatives attended public participation meetings convened by the 6th Respondent and its ESIA consultant, during which the residents requested disclosure of the approved architectural plans, the Traffic Impact Assessment, the geotechnical report, the hydrological report, the zoning compliance documentation, and the ESIA Study Report, but the 6th Respondent failed to disclose them.
9. He argued that the ESIA report cannot support a lawful licence because it is generic, incomplete, and non-compliant with the Environmental (Impact Assessment and Audit) Regulations 2003. It also lacks a Traffic Impact Assessment, a geotechnical investigation report, a hydrological or stormwater management study, a cumulative impact assessment, and an infrastructure capacity assessment.
10. He maintained that the proposed excavation for three basement levels poses significant geotechnical and structural risks to neighbouring properties and that no geotechnical report had been disclosed to date.
11. The deponent contends that the Respondents’ actions violated the Petitioner’s rights under Articles 10, 42, 60(1), 66, 69 and 70 of the Constitution. He further contends that the Respondents breached their statutory obligations under the Physical Land Use Planning Act, EMCA and the Building Regulations. In conclusion, he urged the Court to allow the Petition as prayed.
THE 1ST AND 2ND RESPONDENTS CASE
12. The 1st and 2nd Respondents filed a joint response to the Petitioner’s application and Petition.
13. In a replying affidavit sworn on 22nd April 2026 by Wilfred Masinde, the Deputy Director, Inspection and Planning, the deponent averred that the Respondent submitted a development application on 6th August, which was evaluated and approved in accordance with the applicable planning and development control laws. He further averred that the 6th Respondent later resubmitted an application seeking proposed amendments to add 48 units to the approved 253 units, 20 levels.
14. He maintained that the approvals were granted in accordance with the prevailing position issued by the Court of Appeal. He further maintained that the suit property is situated along Rhapta Road, which permits up to 20 floors, and that the Petitioner has failed to show any illegality on the part of the 1st and 2nd Respondents.
THE 3RD AND 4TH RESPONDENTS CASE
15. The 3rd and 4th Respondents filed a replying affidavit sworn on 30th June 2026 by David On’gare, the 4th Respondent’s Director of Environmental Compliance, in opposition to the Petition.
16. The deponent averred that the 4th Respondent is responsible for issuing EIA licences for development projects after reviewing the Reports. The deponent contends that the purpose of conducting an Environmental Impact Assessment before undertaking any project is to identify the potential environmental and social effects of a proposed activity and to demonstrate how adverse impacts can be mitigated.
17. He asserted that the 6th Respondent’s proposed project is classified as a high-risk project under paragraph 3(3)(g) of the Second Schedule to EMCA, which classifies new housing developments as high-risk when they exceed one hundred units. Accordingly, he explained that the project must undergo an Environmental Impact Assessment Study in accordance with Part 3 (Regulations 11 to 17) of the Environmental (Impact Assessment and Audit) Regulations 2003.
18. He averred that on 4th November 2025, the 6th Respondent, through a registered lead expert, submitted the Terms of Reference for an Environmental Impact Assessment of the proposed residential development to the 4th Respondent, in compliance with EMCA and the Regulations made thereunder. Copies of the report were also sent to the relevant lead agencies for comment on the project.
19. He stated that on 14th November 2025 the Authority issued a notice to the 6th Respondent inviting the public to submit oral or written comments on the report and directed the 6th Respondent to publish it.
20. He explained that, in a letter dated 27th November 2025, the 6th Respondent’s lead expert submitted evidence to the Authority confirming that the notice had been published in The People Daily Newspaper on 20th November 2025, in The Star on 19th November 2025, and in the Kenya Gazette on 21st November 2025, and that it had been advertised on Ghetto Radio for three days.
21. He asserted that an ESIA Study Report contains information on the project's environmental effects, as well as an environmental management plan outlining measures to eliminate, minimise and/or mitigate adverse environmental impacts.
22. He asserted that, after duly reviewing the 6th Respondent’s EIA Study Report in accordance with EMCA and its subsidiary legislation, the 4th Respondent issued the 6th Respondent's EIA Licence No. MEMA/ENVIS/SR/LIC-0022 on 23rd December 2025. He maintained that the licence was subject to mandatory conditions to safeguard the environment and ensure compliance monitoring.
23. He asserted that Chapter 8 of the EIA Study Report identified potential adverse impacts and proposed mitigation measures, while Chapter 10 set out the Environmental Management and Monitoring Plans, which outlined measures to eliminate, minimise and/or mitigate environmental impacts. He contended that the Authority was satisfied that these measures were sufficient and therefore issued the EIA Licence.
24. He further stated that the licence issued by the Authority sets out the conditions the project [proponent] must meet during construction, operation, and decommissioning to promote environmentally sustainable development.
25. Regarding public participation, the deponent asserted that, upon reviewing the 6th Respondent's Study Report, the Authority was satisfied that adequate public participation had taken place before the ESIA report was submitted. This was evidenced by questionnaires, three public meetings, notices published in the Kenya Gazette, a radio advertisement, and publications in two newspapers. The deponent further argued that the Petitioner acknowledged that its members attended the three public participation meetings convened by the 6th Respondent and its ESIA consultant.
26. He argued that zoning and development approvals fall within the County Government's purview and, by extension, that of the County Physical and Liaison Committee. He maintained that the Petitioners' concerns about infrastructure deficits were addressed by conditions 20 and 45, as well as operational conditions 4, 6 and 16, of the EIA Licence.
27. Regarding unsafe excavation, attention was drawn to condition 16 of the EIA Licence, which requires the proponent to undertake a geotechnical investigation, submit a report detailing the effects of slope stability on adjacent structures and on monitoring programmes, and provide a statement on the method of excavation, to be approved by the project's structural engineer and submitted to the National Construction Authority prior to the commencement of works.
28. He further averred that conditions 23 and 24 of the EIA License required the proponent to engage a Geo Survey or structural engineer to undertake a geotechnical site investigation and to use environmentally friendly excavation and rock fragmentation methods to safeguard the structural integrity of the surrounding developments
29. He denied that the 4th Respondent granted EIA approval in breach of the Petitioner's constitutional rights and its constitutional and statutory duties, and asserted that due process had been followed in reviewing the 6th Respondent’s ESIA report. He also denied that the 3rd and 4th Respondents had violated the Petitioner's constitutional rights, or that the public participation process was uninformed, opaque, or procedurally defective.
THE 6TH RESPONDENT’S CASE
30. The 6th Respondent relied on several affidavits in opposition to the Petition.
31. In the replying affidavit sworn by its sales manager, Yan Ruting, on 20th February 2026, the deponent averred that the 6th Respondent is the registered proprietor of the suit property. He further averred that, on 21st June 2025, the then owner applied to the 2nd Respondent to change the property’s use from a single dwelling unit to commercial and residential use, and that the 2nd Respondent approved the application on 16th September 2025.
32. He further averred that the 6th Respondent submitted structural and technical drawings to the 2nd Respondent for review and approval. The 2nd Respondent considered the application and granted approval on 21st October 2025. In addition, the 2nd Respondent issued the 6th Respondent a hoarding/scaffolding licence dated 6 February 2026.
33. The deponent contends that the 6th Respondent submitted an Environmental and Social Impact Assessment Study Report to the 3rd and 4th Respondents, outlining the project's environmental and surrounding-area impacts. He further contends that the 6th Respondent invited the public to various participation meetings, advertised the project in public media, newspapers, and the Kenya Gazette and obtained feedback by way of questionaires.
34. He stated that the 6th Respondent had obtained a Certificate of Compliance from the National Construction Authority, confirming that the development complied with the law.
35. He contended that, in its applications to the 2nd to 4th Respondents and during the public participation process, the 6th Respondent explained the measures it had taken to ensure the project would not violate the rights of the people living in the area.
36. He contended that the development is located in an area with several mixed-use properties, including properties similar to the 6th Respondent.
37. He further contended that the stoppage of works on the development has had irreparable consequences, including the following: the project cost is Kshs 1,736,369,144, including Kshs 170,000,000 for the purchase of the land, of which the 6th Respondent has spent Kshs 50,000,000 on the project. Loss of rent and utilities, and the costs of idle labour and equipment at Kshs 350,000 per week; 100 employees and workers would lose their source of income should the orders be granted; the 6th Respondent is unable to meet its obligations to various stakeholders, including sub-contractors, who are likely to sue for breach of obligation.
38. Regarding the zoning and NIUPLAN allegation, the deponent averred that the suit property is located along Rhapta Road and is classified as Zone 3C under the Nairobi City County Zoning and Development Policy 2022, which permits high-density, mixed-use development of up to twenty floors, as confirmed by the Court of Appeal in Civil Appeal No. E160 of 2025. He maintained that the 1st and 2nd Respondents granted the development approvals in accordance with the applicable zoning regime and after duly considering the relevant planning parameters.
39. He contended that the allegation that the ESIA Study Report was incomplete was misleading, as it incorporated the requisite technical assessments, including traffic impact considerations, geotechnical and soil investigations, stormwater and drainage management measures, and infrastructure impact mitigation. He further contended that the 3rd and 4th Respondents conducted an independent technical evaluation of the Report before issuing the EIA Licence and were satisfied that it complied with all statutory requirements before approving the project.
40. He further averred that, before approving the project, the 6th Respondent held several public participation meetings and issued notices inviting comments from neighbouring residents and stakeholders. He asserted that the Petitioners acknowledged attending the meetings and contended that the minutes confirmed their concerns were received and discussed, with responses provided by the project consultants and experts present. Accordingly, he argued that the allegation that public participation was uninformed is unfounded and contradicted by the Petitioners' documents filed in Court.
41. Regarding geotechnical safety and excavation risks, the deponent averred that, before construction commenced, the 6th Respondent commissioned geotechnical and soil-stability assessments, which confirmed the site was suitable for basement excavation and multi-development. He explained that the ESIA Study Report and engineering assessments concluded that the proposed excavation and construction methodology would not pose structural or geotechnical risks to neighbouring properties, and that the project design incorporated appropriate mitigation and monitoring measures.
42. He argued that the surrounding Rhapta Road and Westlands area has numerous developments with multi-level basements, some extending to six levels, thereby demonstrating the locality’s geological suitability for such construction. He maintained that qualified engineers were supervising the construction and that the works complied with regulatory approvals issued by the relevant authorities, including the National Construction Authority.
43. He argued that the Petitioner had not exhausted the dispute resolution mechanism provided under PLUPA and that the relief sought was intended to frustrate the 6th Respondent from enjoying its property.
44. In a replying affidavit dated 19th June 2026, the deponent produced the Traffic Impact Assessment Report, the Geotechnical Study Report and the Nairobi City County Development Control Policy 2026.
THE PETITIONER’S SUPPLEMENTARY AFFIDAVIT
45. In a supplementary affidavit dated 29th May 2026, the deponent stated that, after the Petition was filed, the Petitioner instructed a registered planner and a registered structural engineer to conduct a technical assessment of the proposed development site.
46. He further averred that Planner Newton G Karuri advised that the suit property falls within Zone 4, which permits a maximum height of four storeys, a ground coverage of 35% and a maximum plot ratio of 80%. He stated that the proposed development, with a plot ratio of approximately 1,407% and a ground coverage of 7%, constitutes a flagrant departure from the existing Zone 4 controls.
47. On this basis, the deponent contends that the proposed development would place severe and unsustainable pressure on the local water, sewerage, drainage, and road networks serving Mvuli Road and the wider Rhapta Road area. It would also cause localised flooding by eliminating permeable surfaces, deprive surrounding low-rise homes of natural light and solar amenity, and adversely affect privacy, neighbourhood character, and community cohesion in ways that could not be adequately mitigated.
48. He maintained that the public participation conducted by the 6th Respondent and its ESIA consultant was procedurally defective, failed to meet the standards required under Section 3 of PLUPA, and did not result in a lawful, informed, and definitive consensus among the affected community.
49. He further averred that Engineer Kaara Stephen K, a registered professional structural and civil engineer, inspected the suit property and the surrounding neighbourhood on 19th September 2025 and 20th January 2026, reviewed the proposed architectural and structural drawings submitted by the 6th Respondent, and concluded that the proposed four-level basement excavation poses credible geotechnical and structural risks to the adjacent properties.
50. He argued that the documentation submitted by the 6th Respondent and relied upon by the 1st to 4th Respondent in granting the impugned approvals fails to include the minimum geotechnical and structural evidence required to support construction of this scale adjacent to existing occupied structures. It omits: a site-specific borehole investigation; a foundation influence assessment; a neighbour notification protocol; a pre-construction structural dilapidation survey of the neighbouring properties; a pre-construction vibration baseline survey or a vibration management plan; and a documented dewatering management plan. He asserted that the Engineer concluded that the proposed development exceeds both the structural loading capacity of the surrounding shared infrastructure and the planning parameters permitted for Zone 4, with direct and significant structural engineering consequences for neighbouring property owners.
51. He asserted that the ESIA Study Report is inconsistent in its description of the number of basement levels, specifying three basement floors on the pages addressing the project specifications and four basement floors in the section discussing the driveway and parking.
52. He further asserted that the expert reports show that the impugned approvals were issued without the minimum technical justification required by the PLUPA, EMCA, the Environmental (Impact Assessment and Audit) Regulations 2003, and the Physical and Land Use Planning (Building) Regulations. He also argued that allowing the development to proceed in its current form would expose the Petitioner members to foreseeable irreparable and uncompensable harm.
THE 6TH RESPONDENT’S RESPONSE
53. The 6th Respondent filed a further affidavit dated 19th June 2026.
54. He averred that sometime in June 2025, Howard Court, the owner of the suit property at the time, applied to the Nairobi City County Government for development permission and a change of use from single residential to commercial and multi-dwelling use. The Nairobi City County Government considered the application and granted approval on 16th September 2025. He further averred that the change-of-use application underwent public participation, and various notices were pinned to the suit property and advertised in the daily newspapers.
55. He averred that Newton Karuri's opinion that the suit property falls within Zone 4 is erroneous and does not reflect the planning framework applicable to Rhapta Road, Waiyaki Way, and the Westlands Development Corridor, particularly in light of the Court of Appeal Decision in Civil Appeal No. E160 of 2025. He asserted that neither Professor Mugendi nor the two experts annexed any enforcement order or records from Nairobi City County, NEMA, the National Construction Authority, or any other statutory regulator demonstrating that the approvals granted to the 6th Respondent breached any applicable planning or environmental standard. He argued that the experts' conclusions are based on the authors' assumptions, observations, and interpretations rather than a review of the complete approval record held by the relevant regulatory authorities.
56. He contended that, as at the date he swore the affidavit, no neighbouring property owner had reported or demonstrated any structural damage, settlement, subsidence, cracking, vibration, utility interference, or any other engineering failure attributable to the construction works on the suit property. He further contended that the Petitioner had produced no structural assessment report, dilapidation survey, geotechnical investigation, vibration monitoring report, hydrological assessment, or other empirical evidence showing that the ongoing works had caused, or were causing, harm to neighbouring properties or the environment.
57. He further argued that the Petitioner had not presented any decision, enforcement notice, suspension order, stop order, revocation notice, or other determination by a competent authority declaring the approvals granted to the 6th Respondent unlawful, invalid, or incapable of implementation.
58. In a supplementary affidavit dated 19th June 2026, the deponent produced the decisions in Civil Appeal No. E160 of 2025, Claire Kubochi Anami & 2 others (Suing as officials of Rhapta Road Residents Association) v Nairobi City County and 20 others. and Supreme Court Petition No. E044 of 2025 Claire Kubochi Anami & 2 others (Suing as officials of Rhapta Road Residents Association) v Nairobi City County & 20 others.
59. The deponent asserted that the Court of Appeal conclusively determined that the 2004 Zoning Ordinance and other pre-2010 Constitutional zoning laws were obsolete, the NIUPLAN was not a zoning instrument and cannot determine the permissible floor count, the 2021 development control policy, though not gazette, was the operative development control framework applicable to development within Nairobi and that the maximum permissible height for development within Rhapta Road area and Zone 3C was 20 floors.
60. The Petition was canvassed by way of written submissions.
THE PETITIONER’S SUBMISSIONS
61. The Petitioner filed its submissions dated 3rd July 2026.
62. On behalf of the Petitioner, Counsel outlined the following issues for the Court’s determination:
a) Whether the Petition is properly constituted and before the Court having regard to the Petitioner’s locus standi, the justifiability of the dispute and the sufficiency of the pleadings;
b) Whether the public participation conducted prior to the impugned approvals and the EIA Licence met the threshold prescribed by the Constitution, the EMCA and EIA Regulations 2003;
c) Whether the Environmental Impact Assessment Licence No. NEMA/ENVIS/SR/LIC-0022 was lawfully issued, the ESIA Study Report being generic, internally inconsistent and non-compliant with EMCA and the EIA Regulations, 2003;
d) Whether the development approvals issued by the 1st and 2nd Respondents violate the applicable planning framework and the infrastructure-first imperative, the development being of excessive density, plot ratio and ground coverage;
e) Whether the directions of the Court of Appeal in Claire Kubochi Anami & Others v CECM Built Environment & Urban Planning & 20 others (Civil Appeal No. E160 of 2025) avail the Respondents or whether they have lapsed and have not been extended;
f) Whether the impugned decisions violate the Petitioner’s right to a clean and healthy environment and offend the precautionary principle and the State’s environmental obligations under Article 42, 69 and 70 of the Constitution;
g) Whether the impugned decisions were made in breach of Article 47 of the Constitution and the Fair Administrative Action Act 2015 and in frustration of the Petitioner’s legitimate expectation;
h) Whether the Petitioner is entitled to the final reliefs sought in the Petition, conservatory orders having already been granted pending its determination and having regard to the 6th Respondent’s commencement of excavation while the matter is sub judice; and ‘
i) Who should bear the costs.
63. Regarding the first issue, Counsel submitted that the Petitioner is a management company representing the residents and proprietors of Oak Valley Estate, whose properties are adjacent to the suit property. Counsel further submitted that the Petitioner has standing, as Article 70(2) of the Constitution and Sections 3(3) and (4) of the EMCA entitle any person to institute proceedings to protect the environment without demonstrating that any person has suffered loss or injury.
64. On justiciability, Counsel relied on Matemu v Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance and 5 others (2013) KECA 445 (KLR), in which the Court of Appeal held that a party seeking to enforce the Constitution has standing.
65. Regarding the precision of the pleadings, Counsel relied on the standard established in Anarita Karimi Njeru v Republic (1979) KEHC 30 (KLR) and reaffirmed in Mumo Matemu (supra). Counsel submitted that the Petition identifies each impugned decision, each Constitutional provision alleged to have been violated, and each statutory breach.
66. Regarding the second issue, Counsel submitted that public participation is a national value and a principle of governance under Articles 10(2) and 69(1)(d) of the Constitution. Counsel further submitted that Section 58 of the EMCA and Regulations 17 and 18 of the EIA Regulations 2003 give these provisions statutory effect. Counsel submitted that Regulation 17 requires the proponent to give the public a genuine opportunity to make oral and written comments on the ESIA Study, while Regulation 18 requires that the concerns raised be addressed. Counsel relied on the governing test formulated by the three-judge bench in Mui Coal Basin Local Community & 15 others v Permanent Secretary, Ministry of Energy & 17 others (2015) eKLR (Constitutional Petition Nos. 305 of 2012, 34 of 2013 and 12 of 2014 (consolidated)). Counsel also relied on the Supreme Court decision in British American Tobacco Kenya PLC v Cabinet Secretary for the Ministry of Health & 2 others; Kenya Tobacco Control Alliance & another (Interested Parties); Mastermind Tobacco Kenya Ltd (Affected Party)(2019) KESC 15 9(KLR), Save Lamu & 5 others v National Environmental Management Authority (NEMA) & another (2019) KENET 98 (KLR), and Amu Power Company Limited v Save Lamu & 6 others 9Environment and Land Appeal No 6 of 2019)(2025) KEELC 7285 (KLR).
67. Applying these principles, Counsel submitted that the public participation process failed to meet the required threshold because the approved architectural plans, the Traffic Impact Assessment, the geotechnical investigation report, the hydrological studies, the zoning compliance records, and the full ESIA report were not disclosed as requested. Accordingly, Counsel argued that residents were invited to comment on a project whose critical technical parameters were deliberately withheld.
68. Counsel further submitted that the expert report indicates that the statutory gazette and newspaper notices were either obscured or missing from the public registry, and that the developer relied on attendance signatures as a proxy for community consensus while disregarding written objections. Counsel argued that the 6th Respondent's replying affidavit places the suit property on Church Road and Rhpata Road, whereas the property is situated off Wayaki Way, along Mvuli Road. Counsel maintained that the Petitioner was not provided with the necessary information to participate meaningfully. Counsel further argued that the public participation process was cosmetic, uninformed, and constitutionally deficient, and therefore could not support the impugned approvals or the EIA Licence.
69. Regarding the third issue, Counsel submitted that an EIA Licence can only be issued after an ESIA Study Report satisfies the substantive requirements of the EMCA and the EIA Regulations. Counsel further submitted that Section 58 of the EMCA requires the proponent to satisfy the Authority that the project meets the requirements for water supply, roads and related infrastructure, and is compatible with its surroundings. Counsel contended that the ESIA Study Report is deficient for the following reasons. First, it describes a 268-unit project, whereas the licensed project comprises 316 units; the study therefore did not assess the impacts of the licensed project. Second, it contains no Traffic Impact Assessment. Third, it contains no geotechnical investigation report, despite excavating three basement levels, beacon to beacon, in close proximity to neighbouring structures. Fourth, it contains no hydrological or stormwater management modelling, despite converting the parcel to a largely impermeable footprint in an area with known drainage inadequacy. Fifth, it contains no cumulative impact assessment or area-wide infrastructure capacity study, despite the acknowledged strain on the local water, sewer and road networks. In support of this point, Counsel relied on the Petitioner’s expert opinion and on Ken Kasinga v Daniel Kiplagat Kirui & 5 others (2015) KEHC 1181 (KLRR).
70. Counsel argued that the 3rd and 4th Respondents' reliance on post-licensing conditions to address these deficiencies is misconceived, as the statutory scheme requires the impacts to be assessed before the licence is issued, thereby ensuring that the licensing decision is informed. Counsel maintained that the EIA Licence was issued on the basis of a non-compliant study and is therefore unlawful, irregular, null and void.
71. Regarding the fourth issue, Counsel submitted that the approvals for the twenty-storey development are inconsistent with the area's planning character and would strain its infrastructure, which already faces chronic water rationing, as evidenced by the Nairobi Water and Sewerage Company's Equitable Water Distribution programme. Counsel also relied on Waweru v Republic (2006) KEHC 3202 (KLR).
72. Regarding the fifth issue, Counsel submitted that the Court of Appeal held that the 2004 Nairobi City Development Ordinance and Zoning Guidelines are obsolete and have no force of law. The Nairobi Integrated Urban Development Master Plan (NIUPLAN) 2016 remains a valid instrument approved by the County Assembly, but is strategic in nature, providing city-wide direction rather than parcel-specific zoning. Although the Draft 2021 Nairobi City County Development Control Policy has not been gazetted, it may be relied upon and applied only in the interim, consistently and transparently, subject to the procedural safeguards in the PLUPA. The Court held that developments whose principal access is from Rhapta Road fall within Zone 3C, where buildings of up to twenty floors are permitted.
73. Counsel submitted that the decision did not confer an unconditional right to construct twenty-storey towers wherever a developer asserts proximity to Rhapta Road. Rather, it established a conditional, interim dispensation, subject to infrastructure capacity, environmental safeguards, and a transparent process.
74. Counsel argued that the suit property does not front Rhapta Road, as it is located off Waiyaki Way along Mvuli Lane within the Petitioner’s neighbourhood; hence, Zone 3C, which the Court of Appeal attributed to the Rhapta Road corridor, is not applicable to the suit property. Counsel further submitted that the 6th Respondent has not produced a site-specific zoning determination placing the suit property in Zone 3C.
75. Counsel further submitted that the court directed the Nairobi City County Government to complete, adopt through the County Assembly, and gazette local physical and land use development and zoning plans, or, alternatively, a Nairobi City Development Control Policy or an equivalent development control code applicable city-wide, within six months of the date of the judgment. This period has expired without any extension, and the county has not fulfilled the condition.
76. Counsel argued that the Anami judgment makes the twenty-floor ceiling contingent upon demonstrated infrastructure capacity, environmental compliance, and meaningful public participation, none of which the 6th Respondent had met.
77. Regarding the sixth issue, Counsel submitted that, taken cumulatively, the impugned decisions threaten the Petitioner’s members' right to a clean and healthy environment under Article 42, violate the precautionary principle under Article 69 and warrant this Court’s intervention.
78. Regarding the seventh issue, Counsel submitted that the Petitioners' legitimate expectation, grounded in NIUPLAN 2016, the EMCA, the EIA Regulations 2003, and the PLUPA, was that development within their neighbourhood would be assessed in accordance with the applicable planning framework, that public participation would be meaningful, and that the ESIA would include the specialist studies required by law.
79. Counsel argued that this expectation was frustrated by an approval process that was arbitrary, uncoordinated and inconsistent with the established planning and environmental frameworks. To support this point, Counsel relied on the elements of legitimate expectation set out by the Supreme Court in Communications Commission of Kenya & 5 others v Royal Media Services Ltd & 5 others (2014) KESC 53 (KLR).
80. Regarding the 8th issue, Counsel submitted that the Petitioner is entitled to the orders with costs.
THE 3RD AND 4TH RESPONDENTS SUBMISSIONS
81. The 3rd and 4th Respondents filed their submissions dated 20th July 2026
82. On their behalf, Counsel outlined the following issues for the Court’s determination:
a) Whether the 4th Respondent followed due process in issuing the 6th Respondent with the EIA Licence No. NEMA/ENVIS/SR/LIC-0022.
b) Whether the Petitioner has established violation of its rights by the 3rd and 4th Respondents.
c) Whether the Petitioners are entitled to the prayers sought in the Petition.
83. Regarding the first issue, Counsel relied on the replying affidavit sworn by David Ongare in support of his submissions. Counsel cited Regulation 18 of the Environmental (Impact Assessment and Audit) Regulations 2003, which specifies the contents of an Environmental Assessment Study report, and submitted that it does not require a traffic impact assessment, a geotechnical investigation report, or hydrological modelling. Counsel further submitted that licence conditions 16, 23, and 24 address geotechnical site investigations, while condition 25 requires the design and implementation of a traffic management plan, subject to approval by the county engineer and other relevant authorities before work begins. To support this point, Counsel relied on Makau & 3 others (Suing in their own name and on behalf of Syokimau Residents Association) v Amalla & 2 others (ELC Petition No 14 of 2017) (2023) KEELC 20020 (KLR).
84. Counsel submitted that, under Regulation 18(1)(q) of the Regulations, the Authority was entitled to request any information it deemed appropriate from the proponent, in addition to the information already provided in the EIA Study. Counsel argued that the Authority's failure to request further information implied that the report, as submitted, was satisfactory. Counsel further submitted that the 6th Respondent had demonstrated that the studies complained of by the Petitioner were in fact conducted.
85. Regarding the Petitioners' contention that there was no proper public participation before the licence was issued, Counsel submitted that, after reviewing the 6th Respondent’s ESIA report, the 4th Respondent was satisfied that adequate public participation had taken place.
86. Counsel further submitted that the Petitioner acknowledged in its Petition that some of its members attended and participated in the three meetings convened by the 6th Respondent and its ESIA Consultant. Relying on Nairobi Metropolitan PSV Saccos Union Limited & 25 others v County of Nairobi Government & 3 others (2013) eKLR and Communist Party of Kenya v Nairobi Metropolitan Services & 3 others; National Environment Management Authority & another (Interested Parties) (2020) eKLR, Counsel argued that the Petitioner had been afforded an opportunity to express its views. Counsel further submitted that no evidence had been adduced to demonstrate that stakeholder views and concerns were suppressed.
87. Counsel further submitted that public participation does not require universal consensus and that objections do not necessarily warrant the rejection of a proposed project. It was also submitted that the Petitioner's disagreement with the outcome of the licensing process cannot, on its own, invalidate a decision made in accordance with the statutory framework.
88. Counsel submitted that the Petitioners' assertion that the licence was issued arbitrarily is unfounded, as the Authority considered the ESIA Study Report, invited comments from relevant stakeholders, evaluated the environmental concerns raised during the review process, and imposed appropriate conditions before granting approval.
89. Counsel submitted that, in the absence of evidence of illegality, irrationality, procedural unfairness, or a constitutional breach, there is no basis for this Court to interfere with the 4th Respondent's decision to issue the Environmental Impact Assessment Licence.
90. On the second issue, Counsel submitted that the evidence on record shows that NEMA fulfilled its constitutional obligation under Article 42 by ensuring that the proposed development complied with the environmental safeguards established under EMCA. Counsel further submitted that the Petitioner failed to demonstrate that the 3rd and 4th Respondents had abdicated or breached any duty imposed on them by Article 69 of the Constitution.
91. In conclusion, Counsel urged the Court to dismiss the Petition against the 3rd and 4th Respondents with costs.
THE 6TH RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS
92. The 6th Respondent filed its submissions dated 14th July 2026
93. On its behalf, Counsel outlined the following issues for the Court’s determination:
a) Whether the licences, permits and approvals issued to the 6th Respondent were lawfully granted;
b) Whether the Environmental and Social Impact Assessment Report is inadequate;
c) Whether the approvals violate the applicable zoning and planning laws; and
d) Whether the project violates the constitutional right to a clean and healthy environment or any provision of the Constitution.
94. Counsel submitted that the Petitioner cannot raise factual issues in written submissions. Counsel argued that parties are bound by their pleadings and that written submissions are intended to argue the pleaded case, not to serve as evidence or to introduce new factual allegations, causes of action or statutory breaches.
95. Counsel submitted that the Petitioner’s submissions advance numerous factual allegations and technical complaints not set out in the Petition, including alleged failure to undertake neighbour notification protocols; alleged absence of vibration baseline surveys, foundation influence assessments, and dewatering management plans; alleged breach of BS 8004 and BS EN 1997; alleged conflicts with underground utility corridors; groundwater drawdown and borehole depletion; surcharge loading, base heave, and engineering deficiencies founded on technical standards never pleaded in the Petition. Counsel contended that these constitute fresh factual allegations intended to establish new grounds for the Court to invalidate the statutory approvals issued by the relevant regulators.
96. Regarding the first issue, Counsel submitted that the allegations that the approvals granted to the 6th Respondent were unlawful are inconsistent with the documentary evidence and the statutory approval process. Counsel further submitted that the evidence before the court shows that the 6th Respondent’s development underwent all material statutory approval processes required by law.
97. On the change of user, Counsel submitted that the evidence on record shows that, in June 2025, the then registered proprietor, Howard Court Limited, applied to the Nairobi County Government for approval to change the property’s use from single-residential to commercial and multi-dwelling residential development. The County Government granted approval on 16th September 2025. Counsel further submitted that the application was subject to public participation, including site notices and newspaper advertisements inviting comments and objections from members of the public, as required by statute. Counsel also submitted that the Petitioner has produced no evidence that the approval has been revoked, cancelled or quashed.
98. Regarding the development permission, Counsel submitted that the structural drawings were submitted and reviewed by the County Government before the approval for change of user or the development permission was granted. Counsel further submitted that the Petitioner has not produced any evidence showing that the County Government acted outside its statutory mandate in granting the development permission, or that there was any defect in the application for change of user or in the structural plans.
99. Counsel further submitted that the Petitioner failed to show that the 3rd and 4th Respondents acted contrary to the national values and principles of governance. On the contrary, the evidence on record showed that the Authority had exercised its statutory mandate transparently, lawfully, and within the framework established by Parliament. Counsel also submitted that the Petitioner failed to establish any constitutional violation attributable to the 3rd and 4th Respondents and was therefore not entitled to the orders sought. It was further submitted that there was no evidence that the approval had been revoked or cancelled, or that the County Government had acted outside its statutory mandate in granting the development permission.
100. Regarding the EIA Licence, Counsel submitted that Regulation 18 of the Environmental (Impact Assessment and Audit) Regulation 2003 comprehensively sets out what must be considered during the study and included in an Environmental Impact Assessment Report. Counsel argued that the Petitioner claimed the EIA report prepared by the 6th Respondent was inadequate because it lacked the mandatory hydrological, geotechnical, traffic assessment, and cumulative impact reports. Counsel further submitted that Regulation 18 does not make these reports mandatory and that their absence does not invalidate a subsequent licence.
101. Counsel submitted that the evidence before the Court demonstrates that the 6th Respondent complied with the statutory process for obtaining the licence. An ESIA study was undertaken, incorporating requirements beyond the minimum standards; the report was submitted to NEMA; public participation was conducted, and comments from the relevant lead agencies were considered. NEMA evaluated the Study Report in accordance with EMCA and the EIA Regulations and, having determined that the statutory requirements had been met, issued the EIA Licence, which has never been suspended, revoked, or cancelled.
102. Counsel submitted that, contrary to the Petitioner’s allegations, the EIA Study encompassed both the traffic assessment and the geotechnical study, as evidenced by the reports presented to the Court.
103. Regarding public participation, Counsel submitted that it is a constitutional imperative anchored in Articles 10(2)(a), 69(1)(d) and 232(1)(d) of the Constitution and operationalised under PLUPA 2019. EMCA and Regulation 17 of the Environmental (Impact Assessment and Audit) Regulations, 2003. Counsel further submitted that the allegation of inadequate public participation is unsupported by evidence or applicable law. Counsel relied on British American Tobacco Kenya PLC v Cabinet Secretary for the Ministry for Health & 5 others 920190 eklr, Independent Electoral Boundary Commission (IEBC) v National Super Alliance (NASA) Kenya & 6 others (2017) KECA 436 (KLR), Nairobi Metropolitan PSV Saccos Union Lt & 25 others v County Government of Nairobi and Doctors for Life International v Speaker of the National Assembly & others (CCT 12/05) (2006) ZACC 11 to submit on the threshold of public participation.
104. Counsel submitted that the statutory requirements for public participation had been met because the development permission and change of use were subject to the prescribed notification procedures. Notices of the proposed development were displayed on the site and published in newspapers with nationwide circulation, inviting members of the public to submit comments and objections within the prescribed periods. Similarly, in the ESIA process, the ESIA Consultant identified stakeholders and conducted public consultations, questionnaires, interviews, and engagement with neighbouring property owners, public institutions, and relevant agencies. The ESIA Report incorporated the comments received and the mitigation measures.
105. Counsel submitted that neither the Petitioner nor its experts had demonstrated that the Respondent failed to comply with any mandatory statutory procedure under the Constitution, the PLUPA, or the Environmental (Impact Assessment and Audit) Regulations.
106. Counsel submitted that none of the statutory approvals issued by the County Government, NEMA or other statutory regulatory authorities had been challenged through the appellate mechanisms established under PLUPA or EMCA. Counsel further submitted that neither regulator had withdrawn, suspended or cancelled any approval issued to the 6th Respondent. Counsel also submitted that the approvals and permits were lawful, as no evidence had been adduced to displace the legality or validity of the licences, permits and approvals issued by the 1st – 4th Respondents.
107. Regarding the third issue, Counsel relied on Clair Kubochi Anami & 2 others (suing as officials of the Rhapta Road Residents Association) v County Executive Committee Member, Built Environment and Urban Plan, to identify the applicable framework governing development in Nairobi County and the Rhapta Road Planning corridor. Counsel submitted that the Petitioner’s argument—that the applicable planning framework remains the repealed 2004 Nairobi City Council Zoning Ordinance together with NIUPLAN 2016—is inconsistent with the law as pronounced by the Court of Appeal.
108. Counsel submitted that, after reviewing the Constitution, the PLUPA, the Nairobi Integrated Urban Development Master Plan (NIUPLAN) 2016, the Zoning Ordinance, and the Nairobi City County Development Control Policy, the Court of Appeal found that the 2004 Zoning Ordinance is no longer the operative zoning instrument. NIUPLAN is a strategic planning document, not a parcel-specific zoning instrument that can prescribe permissible floor counts for individual developments. The operative planning framework in Nairobi is the Development Control Policy 2021; developments along the Rapha Road Westlands corridor are permissible up to 20 floors; and Nairobi City County shall continue to issue development approvals under the 2021 Development Control Policy, rather than on the basis of the redundant NIUPLAN.
109. Counsel further submitted that approval for the development was granted on 20th December 2025, authorizing the construction of 20 floors in accordance with the limits set by the 2021 Development Control Policy. Counsel also submitted that the Petitioner had not identified any provision of PLUPA, any development plan or zoning regulation, or any statutory instrument that the approving authorities had contravened.
110. On the fourth issue, Counsel submitted that although the Petitioner cited numerous constitutional provisions, it failed to demonstrate, through credible evidence, that the lawfully issued approvals violated those protections. Counsel relied on Communications Commission of Kenya & 5 others v Royal Media Services Limited & 5 others (2013) eKLR and Anarita Karimi Njeru v Republic (1979) KLR 154, in which the Courts held that a party alleging the infringement of a constitutional right must plead, with reasonable precision, the provisions allegedly violated, the nature of the alleged violation, and the manner in which the rights were infringed.
111. In conclusion, Counsel submitted that the Petitioner is not entitled to the orders sought and urged the Court to dismiss the Petition with costs.
112. As at the time of writing this Judgment, the 1st and 2nd Respondents had not filed their submissions as directed.
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION
113. Having considered the Petition, the respective affidavits and the rival submissions, the following issues arise for determination:
a) Whether the Petitioner has locus standi to bring this Petition;
b) Whether the Petition meets the constitutional threshold of precision;
b) Whether the proposed development complies with the applicable zoning and physical Planning Framework;
c) Whether there was adequate public participation in the planning and EIA processes;
d) Whether the Environmental Impact Assessment process was lawfully undertaken and the EIA Licence were lawful;
e) Whether the Respondents violated the Petitioner’s constitutional rights; and
f) Whether the Petitioner is entitled to the orders sought.
WHETHER THE PETITIONER HAS LOCUS STANDI TO BRING THIS PETITION.
114. The Petitioner contends that it is a management company representing residents and property owners in Oak Valley Estate whose properties are adjacent to the proposed development. The Petition is primarily based on alleged violations of the right to a clean and healthy environment and of the statutory obligations imposed on the Respondents.
115. Article 22(1) of the Constitution permits every person to institute court proceedings claiming that a right or fundamental freedom in the Bill of Rights has been denied, violated or infringed, or is threatened. Article 22(2) permits proceedings to be instituted by a person acting in their own interest, on behalf of another person who cannot act in their own name, as a member or in the interest of a group or class of persons in the public interest, or by an association acting in the interest of one or more of its members. Article 258 confers standing in proceedings where the Constitution has been contravened or is threatened with contravention.
116. Article 70(1) of the Constitution provides that if a person alleges that a right to a clean and healthy environment recognised under Article 42 has been, is being, or is likely to be contravened, the person may apply to a court for redress. Article 70(2) expressly provides that an applicant need not demonstrate that any person has incurred loss or suffered injury.
117. Section 3 of the EMCA reinforces this provision by providing that if a person alleges that the right to a clean and healthy environment has been, is being, or is likely to be contravened, that person may apply to the ELC for redress. Section 3(4) further provides that a person who brings an action under that section need not demonstrate that they have incurred loss or suffered injury.
118. In Mumo Matemu v Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance & 5 others (2103) eKLR, the Court of Appeal observed as follows:
“It is to be noted that the promulgation of the 2010 Constitution enlarged the scope of locus standi in Kenya. Articles 22 and 258 have empowered every person, whether corporate or non-incorporated, to move the court contesting any contravention of the Bill of Rights or the Constitution in general”.
119. In the matter at hand, the Petitioner contends that it represents residents and property owners whose properties are adjacent to the proposed development and who allege environmental and planning impacts on neighbouring properties. The Petitioners' complaint concerns an alleged threat to the environmental conditions of a neighbourhood and the legality of decisions regarding the proposed development adjacent to its members' properties. Their interest in the proceedings is not speculative or remote. Accordingly, I find that the Petitioner has the requisite standing to institute these proceedings.
WHETHER THE PETITION MEETS THE CONSTITUTIONAL THRESHOLD ON PRECISION
120. The 6th Respondent challenged the Petition on the ground that it failed to meet the constitutional threshold of precision. It is well established that a Petitioner seeking redress under the Constitution must state their claim with precision, identifying the provisions of the Constitution alleged to have been violated and the manner of the alleged violation. This principle was set out in the case of Anarita Karimi Njeru v Republic (1979) KLR 154, where the Court held that:
“We would, however, again stress that if a person is seeking redress for the High Court on a matter which involves a reference of the Constitution, it is important if only to ensure justice is dome to his case that he should set with reasonable precision, that which he complains, the constitutional provisions said to be infringed and the manner in which they are alleged to be infringed.”
121. The principle was reaffirmed by the Court of Appeal in the case of Mumo Matemu vs Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance & Others (2013) eKLR as follows:
“We cannot but emphasise the importance of precise claims in due substantive justice and the exercise of jurisdiction by a court. In essence, due process, substantive justice and the exercise of jurisdiction are a function of precise legal and factual claims. However, we also note that precision is not conterminous with exactitude. Restated, although precision must remain a requirement as it is important, it demands neither formulaic prescription of the factual claims nor formalistic utterance of the constitutional provisions alleged to have been violated. We speak particularly knowing that the whole function of pleadings, hearings, submissions and the judicial decision is to define issues in the point…Cases cannot be dealt with justly unless the parties and the court know the issues in controversy. Pleadings assist in that regard and are a tenet of substantive justice as they give fair notice to the other party. The principle in Anarita Njeru Karimi (supra) that established the rule that requires reasonable precision in framing of issues in petitions is an extension of this principle.”
122. Further, the Supreme Court of Kenya has articulated this position in the case of Communication Commission of Kenya & 5 Others v. Royal Media Services Limited & 5 Others [2014] eKLR, as follows:
‘Although Article 22 (1) of the Constitution gives every person the right to initiate proceedings claiming that a fundamental right or freedom has been denied, violated or infringed or threatened, a party invoking this Article has to show the rights said to be infringed, as well as the basis of his or her grievance. This principle emerges clearly from the High Court decision in Anarita Karimi Njeru v. Republic [1979] KLR 154; the necessity of a link between the aggrieved party, the provisions of the Constitution alleged to have been contravened, and the manifestation of contravention or infringement. Such a principle plays a positive role, as a foundation of conviction and good faith, in engaging the Constitutional process of dispute settlement…….’
123. The principle in Anarita Karimi Njeru (supra) underscores the need to define the dispute for the Court to determine. A person alleging a violation of constitutional rights must set out, with reasonable precision, the constitutional provision alleged to have been violated, the nature of the alleged violation, and the manner in which the violation occurred.
124. In the matter at hand, the Petitioner contends that its members' rights, enshrined in Articles 10, 42, 60, 66, 69, and 70, have been violated and sets out the factual basis for these alleged violations. Accordingly, I find that the Petition has met the constitutional threshold for precision.
125. Regarding jurisdiction, it is trite that it is everything, and without it the Court cannot take one more step in the proceedings. The record shows that this Court considered and determined the issue of jurisdiction in its ruling dated 17th April 2026. That ruling has neither been challenged nor set aside. In light of the foregoing, I see no basis to reopen that determination. Accordingly, this Court has jurisdiction to hear and determine the Petition.
126. The 6th Respondent contends that the Petitioners' submissions raise technical complaints that were not pleaded in the Petition. It is settled law that submissions cannot take the place of pleadings or evidence. A party is bound by its pleadings and cannot, through submissions, introduce a new cause of action or materially alter the pleaded case.
127. Accordingly, to the extent that the Petitioner's submissions raise new factual or technical allegations that do not arise from the Petition, those matters cannot form an independent basis for determination.
WHETHER THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT COMPLIES WITH THE APPLICABEL ZONING AND PHYSICAL PLANNING FRAMEWORK
128. The Court is called upon to determine whether the approvals granted to the Respondent were made in accordance with the applicable planning framework.
129. The Physical Land Use and Planning Act provides the principal statutory framework for physical and land-use planning and development control. Section 57(1) of PLUPA provides that a person shall not carry out development within a county without development permission granted by the relevant county executive member. Section 61 requires that the county executive committee member be bound by the relevant approved national, county, local, urban and special area plans. The decision-maker must also consider community facilities, environmental and social amenities, and comments from relevant authorities and members of the public.
130. The Petitioner contends that the proposed development does not comply with the area's zoning requirements. It was further contended that the proposed development is a 20-storey tower with three basement levels in a low-density residential area. The Petitioner contends that the suit property falls within Zone 4 under NIUPLAN 2016, which permits a maximum height of four storeys.
131. The 6th Respondent asserts that the property falls within Zone 3C of the Nairobi City County Zoning and Development Policy 2022, which permits development of up to twenty floors.
132. The Court is called upon to identify the planning instrument applicable to the property when the impugned approvals were granted. The Petitioner contends that NIUPLAN 2016 contains planning parameters applicable to the relevant areas of Nairobi. The 6th Respondent relied on the Court of Appeal decision in Claire Kubochu Anami & others v County Executive Committee Member, Built Environment & Urban Planning & 20 others, Civil Appeal No. E160 of 2025. The Petitioner contends that the decision does not confer an unconditional entitlement to erect a 20-storey building anywhere in the broader Rhapta Road area. It further contends that the suit property does not front the Rhapta Road area but is situated off Waiyaki Way along Mvuli Lane.
133. The Court has considered the decisions in Claire Kubochi & others v County Executive Committee Member, Built Environment & Urban Planning, Nairobi City County & 20 others (Civil Appeal No. E10 of 2025) and in Mbaazi Avenue Residents Association 7 Another v Metricon Home Nairobi Company Limited & 2 Others. These decisions are material because they addressed the status of Nairobi’s planning development control framework and held that, pending the formulation and adoption of a lawful framework, the Nairobi City County Development Control Policy 2021 remained the operative planning instrument. Accordingly, this Court finds that the Nairobi City County Development Control Policy 2021 was the operative planning instrument when the approvals were granted.
134. In Claire Kubochi case, the Court of Appeal clarified the zoning issue and considered the legal status of NIUPLAN 2016 and the Nairobi City County Development Control Policy in the context of development along Rhapta Road. The Court of Appeal held that NIUPLAN 2016 remains a valid strategic county-wide planning document but does not, by itself, provide parcel-specific zoning rules. It addressed the status of the 2021 Development Control Policy as an administrative guide, pending the establishment of a comprehensive statutory zoning instrument. The Court of Appeal classified Rhapta Road within Zone 3C under the 2021 Development Control Policy, with a 20-storey height cap, and directed Nairobi City County to prepare and gazette a comprehensive planning instrument. This court is bound by that decision. Accordingly, the Petitioner's proposition that NIUPLAN 2016, by itself, conclusively establishes a four-storey maximum for the suit property cannot be accepted.
135. The 6th Respondent asserts that the property was classified under Zone 3C and that the approval permitted twenty floors. The Petitioner has not produced sufficient evidence to establish that the particular parcel was excluded from the relevant Zone 3C classification or that the County Government applied an impermissible zoning classification.
136. The approval was issued following a change of use application approved on 16th September 2025, and the subsequent approval of the structural and technical drawings. The approvals identified the property as situated in Westlands, Kileleshwa in Dagoretti Noth sub County along Waiyaki way. The approval was done by the Urban Planning technical committee and was subject to the conditions contained therein.
137. In considering whether the 1st Respondents decision was irregular or unlawful, the Court is guided by the presumption of regularity. This is an evidential presumption that, where an official or public authority is shown to have performed an official act, the Court ordinarily presumes the act was lawful and in accordance with the prescribed procedure unless the person challenging it adduces evidence to the contrary.
138. In Export Processing Zone Authority and 10 others (Suing on their own behalf and on behalf of all residents of Owini Uhuru village in Mikindani Changamwe Area Mombasa) v National Environment Management Authority & 3 others (2024) KESC 7 (KLR), the Supreme Court stated as follows with respect to the doctrine of regularity:
In general, the presumption of regularity presupposes that no official or person acting under an oath of office will do anything contrary to their official duty or omit anything which their office requires to be done. The doctrine provides a degree of deference to the actions or decisions made by government officials or institutions. It is grounded in the assumption that these officials act within the bounds of the law, follow established procedures and operate in good faith when performing their duties. This presumption also relieves courts or reviewing bodies from conducting a deep review of every action or decision unless there is specific evidence to suggest wrongdoing, procedural lapses or irrational behaviour (See The Presumption of Regularity in Judicial Review of the Executive Branch, Harvard Law Review pg 2432. The idea is that in the absence of clear evidence to the contrary, administrative actions should be presumed to be regular, lawful and reasonable.
139. The effect of this principle is that the Court must examine the evidence to determine whether the Petitioner has established a specific legal defect or irregularity capable of vitiating the approvals. This conclusion is reinforced by the decision in Claire Kubochi Anami (supra), which the 6th Respondent relied upon, in which the Court held that:
”104. Finally, we reaffirm that remedies must also respect proportionality and legal certainty. Developers who obtained permissions in good faith after multi-agency review should not be retroactively penalised absent demonstrated illegality. At the same time, pending projects remain subject to any new lawful general controls applicable, adopted through due process (subject of course to fair transition provisions embedded in the instruments themselves). This balances investment-backed expectations with environmental stewardship and community rights.
140. The burden of rebutting the presumption of legality, regularity and procedural propriety rests on the party alleging that the official acts were unlawful or irregular. The Court's role is to interrogate the legality of the decision against the applicable law and the evidence tendered. In the matter at hand, the Petitioner has not demonstrated that the County lacked jurisdiction to consider the application for change of user and development permission, or that, in granting the approvals, it breached a specific mandatory statutory requirement, acted fraudulently, illegally, unprocedurally, or committed a procedural impropriety.
141. The evidence shows that the applications were considered and approvals were issued subject to conditions. Importantly, where planning has acted within its jurisdiction, judicial intervention must be founded on a demonstrated error or illegality, which the Petitioner failed to establish.
142. I therefore find that the petitioner has failed to prove that the development approvals issued by the 1st and 2nd Respondents were ultra vires, irrational, unreasonable or otherwise unlawful.
WHETHER THERE WAS ADEQUATE PUBLIC PARTICIPATION IN THE PLANNING AND EIA PROCESS
143. The Petitioner contends that public participation in relation to the proposed project was inadequate and failed to meaningfully address the residents' concerns. The Petitioner relied on Articles 10(2) and 69(1)(d) of the Constitution, and Regulation 17 of the Environmental (Impact Assessment and Audit) Regulations 2003.
144. The Petitioner contends that during the three meetings, the residents specifically requested the disclosure of the approved architectural plans, the Traffic Impact Assessment, the geotechnical report, the hydrological studies, the zoning compliance records and full ESIA Report.
145. Public participation is a constitutional value under Article 10 of the Constitution and an important component of environmental governance.In British American Tobacco Kenya, PLC (formerly British American Tobacco Kenya Limited) v Cabinet Secretary for the Ministry of Health & 2 others; Kenya Tobacco Control Alliance & another (Interested Parties); Mastermind Tobacco Kenya Limited (The Affected Party) [2019] eKLR, the Supreme Court laid down the guiding principles on public participation as follows:
i. As a constitutional principle under Article 10(2) of the Constitution, public participation applies to all aspects of governance.
ii. The public officer and or entity charged with the performance of a particular duty bears the onus of ensuring and facilitating public participation.
iii.The lack of a prescribed legal framework for public participation is no excuse for not conducting public participation; the onus is on the public entity to give effect to this constitutional principle using reasonable means.
iv. Public participation must be real and not illusory. It is not a cosmetic or a public relations act. It is not a mere formality to be undertaken as a matter of course just to ‘fulfill’ a constitutional requirement. There is need for both quantitative and qualitative components in public participation.
v. Public participation is not an abstract notion; it must be purposive and meaningful.
vi. Public participation must be accompanied by reasonable notice and reasonable opportunity. Reasonableness will be determined on a case to case basis.
vii. Public participation is not necessarily a process consisting of oral hearings, written submissions can also be made. The fact that someone was not heard is not enough to annul the process.
viii. Allegation of lack of public participation does not automatically vitiate the process. The allegations must be considered within the peculiar circumstances of each case: the mode, degree, scope and extent of public participation is to be determined on a case-to-case basis.
ix. Components of meaningful public participation include the following:
a. clarity of the subject matter for the public to understand;
b. structures and processes (medium of engagement) of participation that are clear and simple
c. opportunity for balanced influence from the public in general
d. commitment to the process
e. inclusive and effective representation
f. integrity and transparency of the process;
g. capacity to engage on the part of the public, including that the public must be first sensitized on the subject matter.
146. In Kiambu County Government & 3 others v Robert N Gakuru & others (20170 eKLR the Court of Appeal stated as follows:
“The issue of public participation is of immense significance considering the primacy it has been given in the supreme law of this country and in relevant statutes relating to institutions that touch on the lives of people. The Constitution, in Article 10, which binds all state organs, state officers, public officers and all persons in the discharge of public functions, highlights public participation as one of the ideals and aspirations of our democratic nation.”
147. Applying those principles to the present case, the evidence establishes that the Authority issued a notice inviting public comments. The 3rd and 4th Respondents contend that the Authority issued a publication notice on 14th November 2025. In this regard, they produced a publication in the People Daily, The Star, and the Kenya Gazette, and placed advertisements on Ghetto Radio. The Authority further states that the ESIA process involved questionnaires and three public meetings.
148. The 6th Respondent similarly states that it issued public notices and that public participation comprised questionnaires, interviews, and engagement with neighbouring property owners and public institutions. It further states that the concerns raised were discussed and that responses were provided.
149. The Petitioner acknowledged that its representatives attended the public participation meetings. Its complaint is therefore not about a lack of participation, but about the public participation being insufficiently informed because certain technical documents were not disclosed.
150. Meaningful public participation requires that the public be given sufficient information about the subject matter to enable an informed contribution. However, it does not follow that every technical document produced during the development process must be provided to every participant for participation to be valid. The test is whether the process gave the affected public a reasonable opportunity to understand the nature and likely implications of the proposal, to express their views, and to have those views considered before the decision is made.
151. In the matter at hand, the Respondent published the proposal, held meetings, administered questionnaires, and engaged with affected residents and stakeholders. The Petitioner participated in the process and raised its concerns. The Petitioner has not demonstrated, with sufficient evidence, that the process was a sham or that the Authority failed to consider the views and objections.
152. The mere fact that the residents' concerns did not result in rejection of the project does not establish a failure of public participation. I therefore find that the Petitioner has not established that the public participation process, taken as a whole, failed to meet the constitutional and statutory thresholds.
WHETHER THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT PROCESS WAS LAWFULLY UNDERTAKEN AND THE EIA LICENCE WERE LAWFUL
153. Section 58 of EMCA provides that notwithstanding any approval, permit or licence granted under this Act or any other law in force in Kenya, any person, being a proponent of a project, shall, before financing, commencing, proceeding with, carrying out, executing or conducting or causing to be financed, commenced, proceeded with, carried out, executed or conducted by another person, any undertaking specified in the second schedule to this Act submit a project to the Authority in the prescribed form giving the prescribed information and which shall be accompanied by the prescribed fee.
154. The Petitioner contends that the ESIA study Report failed to comply with the Environmental Impact Assessment and Audit) Regulations 2003, including an incomplete project report, failure to assess significant and cumulative impacts, failure to disclose the ESIA to the public, failure to respond to public concerns and licensing based on inadequate information.
155. The Petitioner challenged the ESIA on several grounds. It alleged that the report assessed a 268-unit development, whereas the licence concerns 316 units; that it lacked a traffic impact assessment; that it lacked a geotechnical investigation; that it lacked a hydrological and stormwater analysis; and that it failed to conduct a cumulative and area-wide infrastructure assessment.
156. The 3rd and 4th Respondents state that the ESIA identified potential adverse impacts and mitigation measures in Chapter 8, while Chapter 10 contained environmental management and monitoring plans.
157. The 6th Respondent disputes these allegations and states that the ESIA incorporated traffic, geotechnical, stormwater, drainage and infrastructure considerations. It further states that the technical assessments were carried out and that NEMA subjected the report to technical evaluation before issuing the licence.
158. The EIA Licence contains conditions addressing environmental and structural risks. Condition 16 of the EMCA Licence requires the proponent to undertake a geotechnical investigation and submit a report on slope stability effects on adjacent structures, monitoring programmes, and the excavation method before the works commence. The condition shows that the environmental regulator recognised excavation and structural stability as matters requiring control and imposed a mandatory condition that the works could not proceed until it was satisfied. The petitioner argued that the condition cannot cure the absence of a proper geotechnical assessment at the ESIA stage.
159. A licence should not be issued where an assessment fails to consider obvious and material environmental risks. The Petitioner asserts that the ESIA lacked the relevant assessments, whereas the Respondents assert that the assessments were undertaken or incorporated into the report.
160. The 6th Respondent's evidence shows that geotechnical and soil stability assessments were conducted and that the project design incorporated mitigation measures. The 6th Respondent relied on Regulation 18 of the Environmental (Impact Assessment and Audit) Regulations 2003 to contend that the assessments were not mandatory.
161. The burden remains on the Petitioner to establish the alleged illegality. The mere fact that the Petitioner would have preferred separate technical reports to be incorporated into the ESIA does not, without more, establish statutory non-compliance. The 3rd and 4th Respondents' evidence is that they reviewed the report and were satisfied that the requirements were met. No evidence shows that NEMA issued the EIA Licence without considering the environmental risks identified in the Petition, ignored a mandatory requirement, acted on materially incomplete information, or issued the licence without considering a significant environmental risk.
162. Regarding the alleged discrepancy between 268 and 316 units, the allegation is significant because an environmental assessment must correspond to the project that is actually proposed to be undertaken. However, the Petitioner has not placed before this court evidence demonstrating that the alleged discrepancy rendered the entire environmental assessment irrelevant, or that NEMA issued the licence for a materially different project without knowledge of the discrepancy.
163. The Petitioner has not shown that the 3rd and 4th Respondents acted without jurisdiction, failed to comply with a mandatory statutory requirement, or issued the licence without an environmental assessment. The Petitioner has not shown that the decision was so irrational or procedurally defective as to warrant quashing the licence. The evidence before the Court shows that an EIA was undertaken and that the licence was issued subject to conditions.
164. Based on the foregoing, it is clear that the EIA process was lawfully undertaken and that the EIA Licence was lawfully issued. Accordingly, this Court finds that the Petitioner has failed to prove that the EIA Licence was unlawfully issued.
165. The court notes that environmental licensing is a continuous regulatory process, and, as such, the issuance of the licence does not confer immunity from subsequent enforcement. I therefore find that the Petitioner has not proved that the ESIA was deficient to the point of rendering the EIA Licence unlawful.
WHETHER THE RESPONDENTS VIOLATED THE PETITIONER’S CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS
166. The Petitioner alleges that its members' rights under Articles 42, 69 and 70 of the Constitution were violated.
167. Article 42 of the Constitution of Kenya provides for the right to a clean and healthy environment as follows:
‘Every person has the right to a clean and healthy environment, which includes the right— (a) to have the environment protected for the benefit of present and future generations through legislative and other measures, particularly those contemplated in Article 69; and (b) to have obligations relating to the environment fulfilled under Article 70.’
168. The Petitioner contends that the proposed development violates its right to a clean and healthy environment. In P K. Waweru vs Republic (2006) eKLR, the Court held that:
”The right to a clean and healthy environment is primary to all creatures including man; it is inherent from the act of creation, the reset restatement in the statutes and constitution of the world notwithstanding. This right and the other human rights, including civil, cultural, economic, political and social rights, are universal, interdependent and indivisible.”
169. Regarding the infrastructure concerns, the Petitioner placed considerable emphasis on existing constraints in water supply, the risks involved in excavating the basement and the general infrastructure, which, in my view, are legitimate planning considerations. Section 61 of PLUPA expressly requires consideration of community facilities, environmental and social amenities, and relevant comments when considering development permission. Accordingly, the issue is whether the infrastructure constraints establish that the approval was unlawful.
170. The evidence establishes that the area experiences water rationing. However, without more, it does not establish that the proposed development cannot be served by the available infrastructure, or that the county government failed to consider or undertake the statutory assessment of infrastructure capacity. The Petitioner challenged the existing infrastructure's capacity to support the proposed development.
171. The Petitioner invoked the precautionary principle. The Environmental Management and Coordination Act defines the precautionary principle as the principle that where there are threats of damage to the environment, whether serious or irreversible, a lack of full scientific certainty should not be used as a reason to postpone cost-effective measures to prevent environmental degradation. The precautionary principle permits preventive intervention where a credible threat of serious environmental harm has been demonstrated. However, it does not dispense with the requirement for evidence.
172. The Petitioner argued that the proposed excavation, increased density, and pressure on infrastructure require the Court to intervene before any harm occurs. Although the evidence establishes legitimate concerns about the potential pressure the proposed development may place on the existing infrastructure and environment, the Petitioner has not presented cogent evidence that the proposed development poses a serious or irreversible threat, or that the mitigation measures cannot address the identified risks. The requirement for a geotechnical investigation and an approved excavation methodology before works commence directly addresses concerns about basement excavation and neighbouring structures. I therefore find that, on the evidence before the Court, the precautionary principle does not require the invalidation of the development or environmental approvals. The infrastructure concerns raised by the Petitioner do not warrant the application of the precautionary principle.
173. I find that the evidence, considered as a whole, establishes potential environmental and infrastructural impacts that require ongoing regulatory oversight; however, it does not demonstrate that the development, as currently structured, contravenes Article 42 of the Constitution.
174. The Court must also determine whether the authorities failed to consider those matters or whether the development poses a demonstrable unlawful threat to constitutional and environmental rights.
175. Article 69(1) of the Constitution sets out obligations for the State and non-State actors regarding the environment, while Article 69(2) requires every person and entity to cooperate with the State and other persons to protect the environment. Article 69 of the Constitution provides as follows:
’(1) The State shall— (a) ensure sustainable exploitation, utilisation, management and conservation of the environment and natural resources, and ensure the equitable sharing of the accruing benefits; (b) work to achieve and maintain a tree cover of at least ten per cent of the land area of Kenya; (c) protect and enhance intellectual property in, and indigenous knowledge of, biodiversity and the genetic resources of the communities; (d) encourage public participation in the management, protection and conservation of the environment; establish (e) protect genetic resources and biological diversity; (f) systems of environmental impact assessment, environmental audit and monitoring of the environment; (g) eliminate processes and activities that are likely to endanger the environment; and (h) utilise the environment and natural resources for the benefit of the people of Kenya. (2) Every person has a duty to cooperate with State organs and other persons to protect and conserve the environment and ensure ecologically sustainable development and use of natural resources.’
176. The 4th Respondent is the principal instrument of Government for implementing all policies relating to the environment and also exercises general supervision and coordination of all matters touching on the environment on behalf of the State. Therefore, the State's obligations under Article 69 of the Constitution are principally those of the 4th Respondent, including establishing systems of environmental audit and monitoring and eliminating processes and activities that may endanger the environment.
177. The Petitioner raised legitimate environmental concerns regarding water supply and the overall environmental impact of the proposed development. However, there is no evidence that the 4th Respondent failed to undertake the requisite environmental assessment or acted in disregard of the Constitution.
178. The Court has found that the public participation process was carried out, relevant agencies were consulted, objections were received and considered, and conditions were imposed to mitigate and manage the identified environmental risks. The Court therefore finds that the Petitioner has not demonstrated that the interested parties failed to discharge their obligations under Article 69 of the Constitution.
179. The Petitioner alleged that the approvals granted were procedurally unfair and violated Article 47 of the Constitution. Article 47 (1) of the Constitution provides that: (1) Every person has the right to administrative action that is expeditious, efficient, lawful, reasonable, and procedurally fair.
180. The above provision is echoed in Article 50(1) of the Constitution and Section 4(3)(b) of the Fair Administrative Action Act. These provisions make it clear that the tribunal or authority entrusted with the mandate to make decisions must act fairly. Procedural fairness is a constitutional requirement in administrative actions.
181. The right to fair administrative action cannot be gainsaid. In Judicial Service Commission v Mbalu Mutava & Another (2015) eKLR, the Court of Appeal held that:
182. “Article 47(1) marks an important and transformative development of administrative justice for it not only lays a constitutional foundation for control of the powers of state organs and other administrative bodies, but also entrenches the right to fair administrative action in the Bill of Rights. The right to fair administrative action is a reflection of the national values in Article 10, such as the rule of law, human dignity, social justice, good governance, transparency and accountability. The administrative actions of public officers. State organs and other administrative bodies are now subjected to the principle of constitutionality rather than to the doctrine of ultra vires from which administrative law under common law developed.”
183. The impugned planning and environmental decisions are administrative actions. For the reasons already given. I have found that the county government undertook the planning process and issued relevant approvals, while NEMA undertook an environmental assessment process that involved public participation, review of the ESIA, and the imposition of licence conditions.
184. An administrative decision is not rendered unfair merely because it is adverse to the person who made the representation. The court must determine whether the decision-maker acted within jurisdiction, considered relevant matters, followed the prescribed procedure, and afforded affected persons a reasonable opportunity to participate.
185. The Petitioner has not demonstrated that the decision-makers acted unlawfully, irrationally, unfairly, disproportionately, or in breach of a mandatory procedure. The Court is therefore unable to conclude that the decision-making process lacked procedural fairness. This Court therefore finds that the Petitioner has failed to establish the alleged violation of Article 47 of the Constitution.
186. The Petitioner contends that residents had a legitimate expectation that development in the area would comply with the area's planning framework. In Communications Commission of Kenya & 5 others v Royal Media Services Ltd & 5 others (2014) KESC 53 (KLR), the Supreme Court explained that legitimate expectation may arise from a representation or established practice by a public authority. However, the expectation must be legitimate; it cannot override clear statutory or constitutional provisions.The doctrine cannot be invoked to create a substantive right contrary to statute or to prevent a public authority from exercising a lawful statutory power.
187. In the matter at hand, the Petitioner’s alleged expectation is that development in the neighbourhood would remain within the low-density character residents associate with the area. That may constitute a preference for a low-density neighbourhood or a planning concern, but without clear representation or established lawful practice, it does not amount to an enforceable legitimate expectation that no higher-density development could be approved.
188. The Petitioner has not demonstrated a clear and unambiguous representation by the County Government that no development exceeding four storeys would ever be permitted on the suit property. I therefore find that no enforceable legitimate expectation has been established.
WHETHER THE PETITIONER IS ENTITLED TO THE ORDERS SOUGHT
189. Having found that the Petitioner has not established illegality in the development approvals or the EIA Licence, the declaratory order sought in prayers a, b, c and d cannot be issued.
190. The Petitioner also sought a permanent injunction restraining the Respondents from issuing or varying future approvals. In the absence of a demonstrated violation of the law, the Court cannot grant the injunction. The Court cannot issue a blanket injunction preventing statutory authorities from exercising powers conferred upon them by the law.
191. Similarly, the prayer compelling a fresh ESIA cannot be granted merely because the Petitioner would have preferred additional study. The evidence does not establish that the Authority’s assessment was unlawful or that the licence is incapable of enforcement through its conditions.
192. The prayer for restoration of the site depends on a finding that the construction or excavation undertaken was unlawful. No such basis has been established.
193. The claim for general damages also fails. No sufficient basis has been placed before the court demonstrating an actionable constitutional wrong warranting an award for damages.
194. The upshot of the foregoing is that the Petition is without merit and is hereby dismissed with costs.
RULING DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS THIS 21ST DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.
..............................
T. MURIGI
JUDGE
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
Gitonga for the Petitioner
Ms Muyaayi for the 3rd and 4th Respondents
Andiwo appearing together with Makori for the 6th Respondent
Vena - Court Assistant