Land law

Mwafa Court Ltd v National Land Commission & 2 others [2026] KEELC 6972 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Judicial Review Application 36 of 2017
Judgment date
21 October 2026
Judge(s)
C.K. Nzili

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The applicant, following leave to commence judicial review proceedings granted on 18th August 2017, filed an application dated 29/9/2017, and asks the court to;

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The issues calling for my determination are:

Paragraph 30 →

Reasoning passage

The court finds that the applicant's claim falls short of demonstrating that the requirement of Article 47 of the Constitution, as read together with section 4 of the Fair Administrative Actions Act, was not met.

Paragraph 110 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATION NO.36 OF 2017

(FORMERLY HIGH COURT J.R. MISC APPLICATION NO. 500 OF 2017)

MWAFA COURT LIMITED ………………..……………………… APPLICANT

VERSUS

THE NATIONAL LAND COMMISSION ………………..…. 1ST RESPONDENT

THE CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR …………………..……….. 2ND RESPONDENT

THE HONOURABLE ATTORNEY GENERAL

……….………………………………………………….…. 3RD RESPONDENT

JUDGEMENT

A. INTRODUCTION

1. The applicant, following leave to commence judicial review proceedings granted on 18th August 2017, filed an application dated 29/9/2017, and asks the court to;

i. Issue an order of certiorari to quash the 1st respondent's decision in the gazette notice dated 17/7/2017 revoking the applicant's land title LR No.209/11629 situated within Langata area, Nairobi County.

ii. Issue an order of prohibition stopping the 2nd respondent from acting on the recommendation of the 1st respondent to revoke the title to LR No.209/11629

iii. Issue an order of prohibition stopping the 2nd respondent from revoking title No.209/11629.

iv. An order of prohibition restraining the 2nd respondent, its servants, agents, employees, associates or other person or entity whatsoever from acquiring, taking over, nullifying or otherwise dealing with the suit property except by way of recognised legal procedures and mechanisms set out under the relevant laws.

B. FACTS

2. The facts are set out in the statutory statement of facts dated 4.8.2017 and supporting affidavit of Johnson Ngarari Mwaura, a director of the ex parte applicant, accompanying the application for leave sworn on 4.8.2017.

i. The Applicant is a limited liability company duly incorporated in the Republic of Kenya and for purpose of these proceedings its postal address is care of Gichuru & Gichuru Advocates, Shankardass House, 4th Floor, penthouse, New Wing, Moi Avenue and of Post Office Box Number 6342-00100, Nairobi.

ii. The Applicant is the registered proprietor of the parcel of land bearing L. R. No.209/11629 located within the Langata area of Nairobi County.

iii. Applicant stands directly affected and is aggrieved by the decision of the 1 st respondent herein who purported to revoke duly issued Title to the said parcel of land on unsubstantiated allegations that the said parcel of land is on the Nairobi Southern Bypass and had been reserved for use as the Mombasa road interchange section

iv. The applicant has erected on the said parcel of land, at great cost, 60 apartments comprising of 42 (Fourty Two) 3 (three) bedroom apartments, 12 (Twelve) 2 (two) bedroom apartments and 6 (Six) 2 bedroom apartments with dining in an estate known as "Park Gardens Court".

v. The Applicant had in 2010 instituted a suit being ELC No. 537 of 2010 against the Kenya National Highway Authority (KeNHA) in relation to the same suit land in which matter the Honourable Court granted an interim injunction pending hearing and determination of the suit.

vi. The said suit is yet to be heard and determined by the High Court and the interim injunctive orders are still in place,

vii. The first Respondent despite being aware of the said orders and in utter contempt decision of the same, purported to take up the hearing of the matter and made a decision to revoke the applicant's title to the said parcel of land.

viii. The southern bypass was commissioned and Officially opened in November, 2016 and is now fully functional.

ix. The said Kenya Gazette of 17th July, 2017 was not released to the general public until 10 days later on 27th July, 2017 with intent to conceal the first Respondent's illegal, and discriminative decision.

x. The first Respondent's said decision is illegal, discriminative and done out of malice and meant to intimidate the Applicant and force them to give up possession of the said parcel of land which the applicant purchased for value from a previous owner.

xi. The first respondent's decision is meant to short circuit and curtail the proceedings currently pending before the High Court ELC division in ELC CaseNo. 537 of 2010.

xii. The Applicant's buildings are under threat of demolition notwithstanding the existence of injunctive orders issued by the High Court of Kenya in Nairobi in ELC No. 537 of 2010.

xiii. The applicant has invested heavily in its buildings and no proceedings for the compulsory acquisition of the said parcel of land has been commenced and/or is intended to be commenced.

THE GROUNDS

1) The decision of the 1 st Respondent to revoke the Applicant's lawful proprietorship of the said parcel of land despite the existence of a lawful injunctive order is contemptuous of the authority of the Court.

2) The decision of the 1 st Respondent to revoke the Applicant's lawful proprietorship of the said parcel of land while the matter is pending hearing and determination before the High Court of Kenya amounts to usurping the lawful powers of the Court and to pre-empt any decision that the Court legally seized of the matter may make on full determination of the same.

3) The decision of the 1st respondent to revoke the applicant's proprietorship of the said parcel of land is ultra vires and the 1st Respondent has no powers under the law to revoke properly and duly issued titles to land which exercise is the sole preserve of the High Court of Kenya.

4) The Applicant in acquiring the said parcel of land followed the due process of law and indeed is an innocent and lawful purchaser for value.

5) The Applicant being a national of this country has a constitutional right to acquire and hold property and the decision by the 1st Respondent to harass and illegally malign the applicant and also deprive it of its property is a gross infringement of its proprietary rights.

6) The Applicant has not committed any offence recognized under Kenyan law and has also not been party to any illegal acts concerning the said parcel of land is a bonafide purchaser for value and is entitled to be deprived of its property, if at all, in line with the duly recognized process of law.

ABUSE OF OFFICE /POWER

1) The decisions by the 1st Respondent to revoke legal Title to land is capricious and ultra vires the statutory powers granted to the 1st Respondent.

2) The 2nd respondent , acting on the findings , directions and/or recommendations of the 1st Respondent may proceed to revoke the applicant’s legal title the net effect of which is to infringe on the right to property of the applicant.

C. SUPPORTING AFFIDAVIT AND ANNEXURES

3. It is pleaded and deposed by the director that the applicant is the registered owner of the suit land as per the copy of title annexed as JNM (1), previously owned by Talent Academy Limited.

4. It is pleaded and deposed that the exparte applicant bought the subject land for Ksh. 8 million but paid a deposit by way of banker's cheque of Ksh. 800,000 on 14/6/2007, followed by payment of stamp duty assessed at Ksh. 400,000 leading to a transfer that was effected on 7/8/2008 as per annexures marked JNM No. 2 and 3.

5. The applicant pleads and deposes that upon registration of the transfer, it paid the balance of Ksh. 7.2 million by banker's cheque dated 28/8/2007, a copy attached hereto as JNM(4). The applicant deposes that it later applied for change of user permission from the Nairobi City Council through Pieng(K) Limited, as per copies of the brief and payment receipts marked JNM 5a, b and c,

6. The applicant avers that it also obtained a notification of approval PPA (2), leading to the drawing up of a building plan annexed as JNM (6).

7. The applicant deposes that after considering its application, a change of use was approved by letters dated 29/7/2009 and 31st March 2010 annexed as JNM (7).

8. The applicant deposes that upon approval of the plans, it commenced and completed construction of several housing units which were sold to purchasers for valuable consideration and as of 15/10/2013 the development is valued at Ksh. 503 million as per valuation report annexed JNM (8).

9. The applicant states that on 8/10/2010, officers from KenHA, in the company of armed police officers, descended on the property marked letter "X” thereon and directed that the development on the land be demolished, purporting that the buildings were on a road reserve earmarked for the Southern bypass.

10. The applicant states that it then moved to court on 11/11/2010 in ELC No.537 of 2010, where it sought and obtained temporary injunctive orders pending hearing and detention of the suit, on 27/9/2022 as per annexures marked JNM (9) and (10).

11. The applicant deposes that in March 2017, the 1st respondent published a notice to the effect that it would proceed to hear and determine the dispute over the suit property despite the pending suit in court.

12. The applicant states that its advocates then wrote a letter dated 24/3/2017 to the 1st respondent stating that there was a pending suit over the matter, as per Annexure JNM (11), which letter unfortunately was ignored, and the 1st respondent proceeded to hear, determine and revoke its title as per the published decision in the Special Gazette dated 27/7/2017, later published to the public on 21/7/2017, a copy annexed as JNM (12).

13. The applicant terms the gazette notice illegal, which was also in contempt of a pending court order and a suit. It terms the said action as contemptuous, capricious, illegal and ultra vires.

14. The applicant pleads that it lawfully acquired the land, which in law can only be taken away under the provisions of the law. The applicant pleads that the applicable law was never followed by the 1st applicant.

15. It is stated that, in view of the foregoing, the applicant risks suffering loss and damage after making substantial development on the land.

16. The respondents were served with the application and were given up to 15/8/2016 to file their responses. Strangely and for unknown reasons, the respondents for the last eight years have not complied with the directives of the court, including the filing of written submissions.

D. WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS

17. The applicant relies on a written submission dated 16/9/2026 isolating five issues for the court's determination. On jurisdiction, under the National Land Commission Act 20 after 2/5/2017, it is submitted that Section 14(1) of the National Land Commission Act set a five-year deadline for hearing and determination of review on grants and determination over public land.

18. It is submitted that after 2/5/2017, the National Land Commission lacked jurisdiction to do so; hence, the gazette notice herein was irregular for being published outside the five-year period by two months. Reliance is placed on Likizo Limited vs. Nasib Kashuru Limited and 5 Others Civil Appeal E005 of 2020 [2023] KECA 1314 (KLR), Samuel Kamau Macharia and Another vs. Kenya Commercial Bank Limited and 2 Others [2012] KESC 8 (KLR).

19. The applicant submits that at the 1st respondent's hearing and determination, there was a live suit and therefore the 1st respondent should not have established parallel proceedings or purported to determine the very dispute before a court of law.

Reliance is placed on Republic v National Land Commission; Ex Parte Holborn Properties Limited (2016) eKLR.

20. In this case, the applicant submits that in a judgment dated 19/3/2026, the court found that the land does not encroach on a road reserve of the Southern Bypass. The ex parte applicant submits that by this submission it does not invite the court to read this judgment as retrospectively conferring jurisdiction upon or removing jurisdiction from the 1st respondent.

21. Rather, it is submitted that the significance of the said judgment is that the issue which the National Land Commission sought to determine administratively has now been determined after a full hearing and therefore it would produce an obvious contradiction in the administration of justice to leave standing an administrative determination demanding the revocation of its title based on an alleged interference with the southern bypass while a superior court has, after a trial, expressly found that the said land does not encroach upon that corridor.

22. The applicant submits that the continued existence of the Gazette Notice over the determination by the 1st respondent therefore serves no lawful purpose and creates an uncertainty over a title which has been protected by a final judgment of this court.

23. The ex parte applicant relies on and invokes Article 47 of the Constitution, Judicial Service Commission vs. Mbalu Mutava & Another, Civil Appeal No. 52 of 2014[2015] eKLR, Suchan Investment Limited vs. Ministry of National Heritage and Culture and 3 others [2016] eKLR. and in David Oloo Onyango vs. Attorney General (1987)KECA 56 (KLR).

24. The ex parte applicant submits that though subsequent jurisprudence on the scope of Section 14 of the National Land Commission Act is that land initially consisting of public land is not immune from review, as held in Yako Supermarket (K) Limited & another vs. National Land Commission and 4 others [2023] KECA 602 (KLR), in this case it distinguishes the said case since the National Land Commission mandate had expired, there was a pending ELC suit, and government agencies had approved the change of user and developments on the subject land.

25. The applicant submits that it lawfully acquired the land for valuable consideration, substantial resources were used to erect and develop the land, 3rd parties were transferred the land, and the ELC has now affirmed the legality of the title.

26. The ex parte applicant submits that the Dina management case does not prejudice its case, for it does not solely rely on possession alone, given the chain and acquisition, transfer, government approvals, development process and alleged encroachment were subjected to scrutiny in ELC No.537 of 2010, which rejected the KenHA assertion on encroachment and dismissed a counterclaim seeking cancellation of title.

27. The ex parte applicant submits that section 14(7) of the National Land Commission Act itself prohibits revocation against a bona fide purchaser for value without notice of defect in title.

28. In this case, the applicant submits the respondents have filed no response to impeach its title or called evidence demonstrating fraud or illegality attributable to it.

29. In the circumstances, the applicant urges the court to grant the reliefs of certiorari and prohibition, guided by the case law of Kenya National Examinations Council Versus Republic ex parte Geoffrey Gathenji Njoroge & 9 others, Civil Appeal No. 266 of 1996 [1997] KECA 58 (KLR), Republic Vs National Land Commission ex parte Joseph Miring’u Ng’anga’a [ 2021] KEELC 2614 KLR.

E. ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

30. The issues calling for my determination are:

i. Whether the pendency of ELC No.537 of 2010 was a bar to the 1st respondent exercising its constitutional mandate;

ii. If the ex parte applicant exhausted internal dispute resolution outside court before invoking the jurisdiction of this court by filing the matter;

iii. Whether the application is merited;

iv. What is the order as to costs?

F. JURISDICTION

31. Jurisdiction is everything. It is a creature of the Constitution, statute, or both. It cannot be conferred by parties' consent, judicial innovation, craftsmanship, or parties' draftsmanship. Without it, anything done is a nullity.

32. There is no evidence that the ex parte applicant took remedial action immediately after the letter was not acted upon by the 1st respondent.

33. Jurisdiction is everything. It is conferred by statute, constitution, or both. It is not a mere procedural technicality. It is a fundamental prerequisite to exercise judicial authority. As held in Macharia and Another versus Kenya Commercial Bank Limited and Others [2012] KESC 8 (KLR), it is not an open-ended discretion. A court cannot arrogate itself jurisdiction exceeding its boundaries. A court without jurisdiction cannot even grant the reliefs sought.

34. A litigant is under a forensic obligation to categorise his or her case, indicating the constitution or legal category under which he moves the court, as held in Towaha versus Abdalla and Others (2015)KESC 20 (KLR).

35. The jurisdiction of this court is both original and appellate under Section 13(4) of the ELC Act. In this particular matter, this court can only exercise appellate jurisdiction under Section 13(4) of the ELC Act in view of Section 14 of the National Land Commission Act.

36. Article 67 of the Constitution establishes the National Land Commission, whose constitutional mandate under Article 67(2)(e) includes initiating investigations on its own motion or on a complaint into present or historical injustice, and recommending appropriate authorities. The mandate also includes performing any other function as may be prescribed by a statute.

37. Article 68(C)(v) of the Constitution mandates Parliament to legislate on a law to review all grants or dispositions of public land to establish their propriety or legality.

38. Section 14 of the National Land Commission Act provides the procedure, powers, and obligations which the National Land Commission can follow in undertaking the review exercise over grants and dispositions subject to the provisions of Articles 40, 47, and 60 of the Constitution. Publication on gazettement of the decision is also covered by the section.

39. To comply with the law, the National Land Commission published the Review of Grants and Disposition of Public Land Regulations 2017. Rule 29 relates to the decision of the Commission.

40. Rule 30 relates to appeal. An aggrieved party by any decision of the Commission has 14 days to file an appeal to this court. Publication of the decision is covered by Rule 32.

41. In this matter, the applicant opted to move court through judicial review instead of an appeal. The ex parte applicant admits that, after notification of the impending proceedings and exercise of constitutional mandate by the 1st respondent over the subject title by a letter dated 24/3/2017, it confirmed to the 1st respondent that it had received the notification from the National Land Commission before the hearing commenced. That notice was published in line with Rule 8 (2) of the Regulations.

42. Rule 9 thereof required the ex parte applicant to attend and inspect the relevant form in Form No. NLC 02 set out in the first schedule. Rules 14, 16, 17, 19, and 25 of the Regulations required the applicant to fully participate in the proceedings to protect its interest by making presentations, cross-examining the complainant and offering evidence in rebuttal.

43. Rule 28 required the NLC to consider the lawfulness of the grant or disposition. Rule 29 required the National Land Commission to render the decision within a reasonable time and to publish the decision. The ex parte applicant has faulted the jurisdiction, legality of the proceedings, and the decision of the 1st respondent as being in breach of its constitutional rights and freedoms. The burden in law is on he who alleges the existence of certain facts to be entitled to the reliefs sought.

44. The next issue is whether the applicant has correctly invoked the jurisdiction of this court. In Simon Kirori Kabuagi & another Vs National Land Commission and 4 Others [2026] KEELC 1462 (KLR), 11th March 2016, a ruling, decision had been made by the National Land Commission under its mandate provided by Section 14 of the National Land Commission Act, concluding that the petitioner's titles were obtained unprocedurally.

45. The court held that since the applicant had written to the National Land Commission through a lawyer, it was accorded adequate notice to respond, answer, attend, appear or participate in the hearing and determination of the complaint. The court cited with approval Republic v. National Land Commission and Other ex parte Rono Kitaa ELC JR No.14 of 2019 and Speaker of National Assembly v. James Njenga Karume (1992) eKLR that where there is a clear procedure for redress of any particular grievance prescribed by the Constitution or statute, that procedure must strictly be followed.

46. The court cited Malindi Musketeers Limited V. National Land Commission and 5 Others [2021] KEELC 3125 (KLR) that failure to file an appeal within 14 days of the decision made,left the decision final and valid.

47. In Tom Dola and others versus Chairman, (National Land Commission) and 5 others [2018] eKLR, the court said that the power to review grants and dispositions in public land is a jurisdiction specific to the National Land Commission and cannot be usurped by any other body or agency.

48. In Republic versus National Land Commission ex parte Holborn Properties Limited [2016] eKLR, the court said that under Section 14(1) of the National Land Commission Act, Judicial review can cover land that has been converted from public to private land.

49. In Almer Farm Limited versus National Land Commission and others [2021] KEELC 456 (KLR), the court ruled that under Regulation 29 of 2021 Regulations, it is an appeal which ought to be filed.

50. In Almer Farm Limited versus National Land Commission [2021] KECA 469 KLR, the court said that the applicant should have followed the procedure laid out in the said law if it desired to file an appeal. Guided by the foregoing case law, my finding is that the applicant should have filed an appeal and not an application for judicial review.

51. As to whether the applicant has proved illegality, unreasonableness or breach of rules of natural justice against the 1st respondent, a party seeking to impeach the procedure, decision or process as to its legality must substantiate the actual sins of a tribunal to be entitled to judgment or redress as held in Republic versus Kenya Power & Lighting Company Ltd and another Exparte Fleet Tracking Solutions Africa Ltd. (2013) eKLR, Republic versus Business Premises Rent Tribunal and Attorney General another ex parte Albert Kigera Karume (2015) eKLR, Republic versus Public Procurement Administrative Review Board and others; ex parte Rongo University [2018] eKLR.

52. To succeed, the ex parte applicant had to show that the process and the decision were tainted with illegality, irrationality and procedural impropriety or were ultra vires or were made in error of law, as held in Pastoli vs Kabale District Local Government Council and others [2008] 2 EA 300.

53. In Tinek Limited and another versus National Land Commission and 7 others, Civil Appeal 257 of 2020 (2026) KECA 558 (KLR) (13th March 2026) (judgment), the court cited with approval David Oloo Onyango versus Attorney General (1987) KECA 56 ( KLR), that a decision in breach of the rules of natural justice is not cured by holding the decision would otherwise have been made right. The court said that if the principle of natural justice is violated, it matters not that the same decision would have been arrived at.

54. The court cited Sceneries Limited vs National Land Commission & 2 others [2017] eKLR, holding that a man cannot incur loss for an offence by judicial proceedings until he has a fair opportunity of answering the case against him.

55. In this matter, the Applicant argues that the National Land Commission acted outside its constitutional timelines of five years; hence the decision is a nullity. This erroneous view, however, has since been overtaken by events, as the court has, in Okoiti vs Attorney General and 2 others; National Land Commission & 3 others (IP) [2025] KEHC 17900 KLR, held that Section 14(5) of the National Land Commission Act, now amended, had unlawfully curtailed the National Land Commission's powers.

56. The court said that the Constitution does not prescribe timelines for the execution of National Land Commission functions, and therefore it was not open to Parliament to manufacture them; otherwise it would amount to undermining the independence of the operational space and foundation of the Commission.

57. The court observed that a constitutional provision must be read as a whole and holistically such that the National Land Commission Review and Redress functions under Article 67(e) cannot be narrowed or restricted through ordinary legislation.

58. The court held that imposing a five-year window was inconsistent with the spirit and letter of the Constitution, which the Parliament had attempted to dilute or restrict.

59. The NLC Act as amended in 4.11.2025 now opens up the NLC to continue review of grant & disposition over public land issued before 27.8.2010.

60. In Rep Vs Secretary of State for Health, ex parte Furneaux [1994]2 ALL ER 652, the court said that certiorari is an extraordinary discretionary remedy, and not a right of an applicant. The court said that coming late to court itself was a reason for the court to withhold such a remedy.

61. In Catherine C.Kittony Vs Jonathan Muindi Dome & 2 others [2019] KECA 84 (KLR), the court held that a party who fails to challenge the court judgment through the mechanism provided under statute forecloses any further avenue of challenge, regardless of the jurisdictional complaints directed at the underlying award.

62. In Mathenge Vs Gatua & Another [2024]KECA 341 (KLR), the court held that jurisdiction cannot be granted to the court or tribunal by agreement between the parties if there is no such jurisdiction granted by law.

63. The National Land Commission mandate under section 14(1) of the National Land Commission Act is sanctioned by the Constitution. The Commission, in my view, has an exclusive mandate to review all grants or dispositions of public land, which includes establishing a title’s propriety or legality.Courts only intervene at the appellate level and only if the 1st respondent failed to do that, which is demanded of it by the Constitution, as held in Diana Kethi Kilonzo and another versus IEBC and others [2013]eKLR.

64. Decision-making bodies are masters of their own procedures and are only required to achieve some degree of fairness appropriate to their task, as held in Kenya Revenue Authority Vs Menginya Salim Murgani[2010]. The rights to fair administrative action and the right to be heard should not be interpreted to mean something else, as held in Simon Gakuo v. Kenyatta University & Others (Misc Application No.34 of 2019). The right to a fair hearing includes the right to be informed of the hearing or to present the case, as held in Judicial Service Commission Vs Gladys Boss Shollei & Another [2014] KECA 334 (KLR).

65. In my view, the 1st respondent was undertaking a constitutional and statutory mandate governed by its Regulations 2017 made under Section 14(2) of the Act. The National Land Commission Act is a creature of Article 68(c)(v) of the Constitution. Under Article 50 of the Constitution, the applicant had the right to have its dispute or complaint, and defence to dispute, resolved by application of law decided by the 1st respondent.

66. It is not the law that the issue or complaint could only be heard before the court. It is the National Land Commission which had the constitutional mandate at the time, and not the court, to hear and determine the complaint. The fact that there was a pending suit did not, of its own, deter the National Land Commission from undertaking its constitutional mandate.

67. In Musila v. Thengi and Others, Civil Appeal 607 of 2019 [2025] KECA 750 (KLR), the petitioners had alleged breach of Article 47(1) and 50 (1) of the Constitution in the hearing of their matter at the Minister's appeal. Reliance was placed on Onyango Oloo Vs. Attorney General (1986-89) EA 456.

68. The court said that a cardinal rule of natural justice is that no party should be condemned unheard. The court said that statutory timelines are put in place to ensure that the right is neither abused nor used to the detriment of the other party.

69. The court said that Article 47 of the Constitution addresses the fair administration of services and that every person is entitled to an administrative action that is expeditious, efficient, reasonable and procedurally fair.

70. The court cited with approval Union Insurance Company of Kenya Limited vs. Ramzan Abdul Dhanji, Civil Application No.179 of 1998, [1998] eKLR, that whereas the right to be heard is a basic natural justice concept and ought not to be taken away legally, an applicant who was notified of every step of the litigation but failed to attend, the law is not that a party must be heard in every litigation, so long as it is given a reasonable opportunity of being heard.

71. The court said that once that opportunity is given and it is not utilised, then the only point on which the party not utilising the opportunity can be heard is why it did not utilise the opportunity. In this matter, the ex parte applicant, instead of submitting to the jurisdiction of the 1st respondent, chose to write a letter to inform the National Land Commission of the pending ELC matter and nothing else.

72. There is no evidence that the ex parte applicant asked and was denied an opportunity to be heard or to file or make a presentation in line with the Constitution and the statutes and the Regulations. There is also no evidence that, other than the letter, the ex parte applicant went to the tribunal and raised a preliminary objection to jurisdiction or asked it to stay its proceedings.

73. In Republic vs. National Land Commission & 2 others, Gregory Kavinya Muvevi (Interested Party) Ex parte, Gideon Muli Musembi [2021] eKLR, the court said that one of the cardinal principles of natural justice is that a person must be accorded an opportunity before a decision is made. The court cited with approval Fahim Yasin Twaha & another Vs District Land Registrar -Lamu [2011] eKLR: that a decision affecting the legal rights of an individual, which is arrived at by a procedure offending principles of natural justice, is outside the jurisdiction of the decision-making authority.

74. In Eastern Produce (K) Limited v National Land Commission & another (Civil Appeal No. E835 of 2023, a decision of 9.10.206, the court said that there is a difference between a party who has been furnished with the case against it, given reasonable time to respond, and simply elects not to do so, and a party who expressly informs the decision maker that it does not have material upon which it is expected to respond and then assures that the material will be availed. In the first case, the court said that the failure to utilise the opportunity may be attributed to the party.

75. In Dola & others vs Chairman, National Land Commission & others [2020] KECA 432(KLR), the court held that section 14(3) of the National Land Commission Act requires participation upon invitation of every person who appears to have an interest in the grant or disposition of public land to be notified.

76. In Cortec Mining of Kenya Limited vs. Cabinet Secretary, Ministry of Mining and Others, Civil Appeal No.105 of 2015, the Court of Appeal held that an appeal process, unlike judicial review, would allow parties to explore the merits of the decision.

77. Judicial review is not the most efficacious remedy where the title is disputed, as held in Republic vs Registrar of Titles and Another ex parte David Gachina Muriithi (2014) eKLR and Livingstone Kunini Ntutu vs Minister for Land and Others (2014) eKLR.

78. In Speaker of the National Assembly versus Njenga Karume (1992) eKLR, the doctrine of exhaustion was emphasised. The Court has held that it must guard against outcomes that compel parties to pursue fragmented litigation in multiple forums. In Abidha Nicholus versus Attorney General & Others [2023] KESCC 113 (KLR), the court held that alternative mechanisms should be given deference unless they are not adequate or effective. In Keroche Industries Limited vs KRA and Others (2007) eKLR 240, the court said that a public authority has to act reasonably and in good faith and upon lawful and relevant grounds in the public interest or in the public good. The court said that a public body has no inherent legal right which it enjoys for its own sake. The court said that it is the constitutional separation and balance of power that separates democracies from dictatorship, and that the court should never abandon its role in maintaining the balance.

79. In this matter, the applicant was accorded an opportunity to be heard. It chose not to subject itself to a constitutionally sanctioned process for no reason. It cannot therefore turn around and allege breach of the right to fair hearing or fair administrative action.

80. In my view, Article 47 of the Constitution was adhered to by the National Land Commission. It notified the ex parte applicant of the complaint; that is why the ex parte applicant wrote to the National Land Commission. The ex parte applicant cannot therefore be heard to say that the resultant decision was ultra vires or against the rules of natural justice and therefore should be quashed.

81. As to whether the applicant was a bona fide purchaser for value without notice, Article 40(6) of the Constitution does not protect unlawfully acquired property.

82. Due process of law must indeed be followed in revoking title to land, as held in Kuria Green Ltd Vs Registrar of Titles & Another [2011] eKLR .

83. Courts must exercise restraint and give deference to relevant competent bodies or state organs mandated to handle such disputes, as held in Geoffrey Muthinja Vs Samuel Munga Henry & others [2015]. Alienation of land reserved for public purpose and issuance of title is a nullity ab initio, as held in Adan Abdirahani Hassan & 2 Others V. Registrar of Titles, Ministry of Lands & 2 others [2013]eKLR, Dina Management Limited Vs County Government of Mombasa (supra).

84. Unlawful acquisition of title under Article 40(6) of the Constitution has to be established through a legally established process, as held in Evelyn College of Design Limited vs. Director of Children’s Department & another [2013]eKLR.One such process is through section 14 of the National Land Commission Act.

85. The applicant has failed to substantiate how the 1st respondent lacked, jurisdiction or had no mandate to make the decision acted ultra vires or breached it and natural justice. The failure to place before the court reasons or the ills of the decision maker may cause the court not to grant the relief of certiorari.

86. The other ground is that the National Land Commission purported to determine the status of the LR No. 209/11629 while ELC No. 537 of 2010 was pending. The sub judice rule was discussed in Kenya National Commission on Human Rights vs. Attorney General and 17 Others (2020) eKLR. The court said that the purpose of the sub judice rule is to stop the filing of a multiplicity of suits between the same parties over the same subject matter so as to avoid abuse of the court process and diminish chances of courts with competent jurisdiction issuing conflicting decisions over the same subject matter.

87. The ex parte applicant has the burden to show that the constitutional mandate of the National Land Commission could be stopped or should have been stayed pending hearing and determination of the pending suit.

88. There is no evidence that the ex parte applicant, other than writing a letter to the National Land Commission, formally applied for stay of either its suit or the National Land Commission complaint if both of them were on the same factual matrix and sought in substance to relitigate the ownership dispute.

89. The basis of saying that there were parallel processes anchored on the same disputes between the same parties, thereby rendering the matter at the National Land Commission sub judice, has to be substantiated.

90. The court record does not show that the ex parte applicant did anything to forestall the National Land Commission proceedings or challenge the jurisdiction of the 1st respondent.

91. It was up to the ex parte applicant to choose to follow the law and the procedure governing review of grant and disposition of public land.

92. The National Land Commission was merely exercising a constitutional mandate. Section 14 of the National Land Commission Act did not give the applicant multiple pathways. The applicant did not challenge the constitutionality of the process of the National Land Commission. In Advisory Reference No.001 of 2024, the Supreme Court of Kenya said that the National Land Commission is a constitutional commission insulated from execution proceedings under Sections 21 and 25 of the Government Proceedings Act.

93. As to whether the applicant is entitled to the reliefs of certiorari and prohibition, the writs of prohibition, certiorari and Mandamus are discretionary in nature. In Halsbury's Laws of England, Volume 4th Edition, Volume T(1), Paragraph 12, Page 270, it is stated that whether or not to grant the orders, the court will consider the conduct of the party applying, undue delay, unreasonable or unmeritorious conduct, acquiescence in the irregularity or waiver of the right to object.

94. Judicial review, as held in Biren Amritlal Shah and Another vs Republic and 3 Others (2013) eKLR, is concerned with whether the applicant was accorded fair treatment by the concerned public body.

95. In Republic vs National Environment Management Authority and Civil Appeal No.84 of 2010, the court said that only in exceptional circumstances, if there exists an alternative remedy law, the court intervenes in judicial review.

96. The applicant has not shown that the Judicial Review was a better mode of redress than an appeal to the court. Failure to disclose the existence of an alternative remedy and to show its ineffectiveness led to denial of the relief in Republic vs. Nema, Ex parte Sound Equipment Limited, Miscellaneous Application No.7 of 2000.

97. In Kenya Hotel Properties Limited vs. Honourable AG and Others, Petition No.16 of 2020, it was held that a High Court has no supervisory power over other superior courts.

98. The applicant has submitted that the gazette notice at the moment serves no useful purpose given the decision of this court on the legality of its title, and therefore this court should abide by its decision. The powers of the National Land Commission is donated by the Constitution. If the framers of the Constitution wanted the courts to exercise that power, they would have expressly stated so and given the courts express powers to review grants and disposition of public land.

99. The ELC court could not set out to exercise a power not expressly donated to it by the Constitution to review grants and disposition of public land under Article 67 of the Constitution. Jurisdiction cannot be procured, conferred, or assumed by consent, judicial craftsmanship, or draftsmanship, as held in James Imparut Kenya Limited and Another vs. National Land Commission and Others [2023] KECA 602 (KLR).

100. Land initially constituting public land is not immune from Section 14 of the National Land Commission Act. Similarly, as held in Dina Management Limited vs. County Government of Mombasa, Petition 010 of 2021, and in Torino Enterprises vs Attorney General[2002] KECA 78 (KLR), Article 46 of the Constitution does not protect illegally or irregularly acquired title to land.

101. As held in Yako Supermarkets Kenya Limited and Another vs The National Land Commission, had Capacity to undertake a Review of the Suit Properties, consider the legality and propriety of the conversion from public into private property.

102. There is evidence that the 1st respondent complied with Article 47 of the Constitution, its stature and the regulations made thereunder, by issuing, gazetting and publicly publishing adequate and reasonable notices of the intended review, hearing of the complaints publicly, publicly publishing and gazetting the outcomes and an opportunity to appeal.

103. It is not disputed by the ex parte applicant that it failed to subject itself to the process. The reasons for not doing so are not explained.

104. An effective trial advocate, as held in Leitich vs Mwanji, Civil Appeal DPPL e147 of 2023(2025) KECA 1279 (KLR), must understand the rules of procedure and the consequences of not adhering to the rites governing the proceedings.

105. Procedural rules are a vital mechanism for upholding the rule of law, ensuring fairness and promoting efficient and just outcomes in civil litigation. The appeal process set out under the National Land Commission Act is not a mere technicality but serves as a foundation for a sound and predictable legal system. A jurisdictional objection was not taken to the doorstep of the National Land Commission, followed by a court action.

106. The decision made by this court did not insulate the applicant from its own act of negligence, waiver, or refusal to participate in the review of grant and disposition on public land, which had been lawfully initiated under the Constitution by the 1st respondent. The decision of this court, which was not based on section 14 of the National Land Commission Act, cannot be invoked to retrospectively undo the process and the outcome of a constitutionally sanctioned process. This court, just like the commission, is a creature of the Constitution.

107. In this matter, the applicant and his advocate, while aware that the process was on or underway, remained silent or declined to participate in a constitutional process. It never attended the proceedings, objected to the jurisdiction, or raised the complaint or made written submissions to oppose the complaint.

108. The applicant, in the circumstances, has not substantiated the grounds to challenge the process and its outcome by the 1st respondent under section 4 (3) & (4) of the Fair Administrative Actions. The applicant was accorded and placed in a position to make an informed representation before an adverse decision was taken.

109. The applicant was notified of the complaint, the proceedings and responded in writing through counsel. It cannot turn around and say that it was not afforded a meaningful opportunity to be heard before the impugned determination was made. The proceedings cannot be said to be illegal or unconstitutional or a nullity simply because the applicant opted to follow its case in court and not participate in the impugned process and the proceedings.

110. The court finds that the applicant's claim falls short of demonstrating that the requirement of Article 47 of the Constitution, as read together with section 4 of the Fair Administrative Actions Act, was not met.

111. It has been submitted that the notice of motion is unopposed and therefore the court should allow the same. Failure to respond to the notice of motion by the respondents, which is regrettable, did not mean that the ex parte applicant was relieved of the evidentiary role or the duty to discharge the burden of proof to substantiate its assertions.

112. Even if the notice of motion was not opposed, the burden is as held in Charterhouse Bank Limited (under statutory Management) Vs Frank N.Kamau [2016] eKLR. The applicant must prove on a balance of probabilities that it has credible and believable evidence which can stand in the absence of rebuttable evidence by the respondent.

113. The upshot is that I find the applicant has not met the conditions set in KNEC VS Republic; Ex parte Gathenji (Supra) to be entitled to the reliefs sought.

114. Orders accordingly.

Dated, signed, and delivered on this 21st day of October in Milimani, Nairobi.

Hon. Justice C.K. Nzili

Judge

In the presence of;

Mr Gichiru D.N. for the applicant

Court assistant: Julius

Legal researcher: Beverly N.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder