Land law

Chege & another v Gichimu & another [2026] KEELC 7437 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
ELCLA/E141/2025
Judgment date
21 October 2026
Judge(s)
J. Orwa

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The dispute before this Honourable Court concerns a parcel of land situated at Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton, Nairobi County, whose identity and ownership remain at the heart of this appeal.

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

In the circumstances this court finds that the Learned trial magistrate erred in both law and fact in holding that 2nd respondent established her claim over

Paragraph 53 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT OF KENYA AT NAIROBI COUNTY COURT NAME: MILIMANI ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

CASE NUMBER: ELCLA/E141/2025

BONIFACE CHEGE AND JOSEPH NJOROGE VS HENRY WANYORO GICHIMU AND JOYCE NDUTA MUNGAI

JUDGMENT

1. (An appeal against the Judgment and Decree of Honourable A. Mukenga [P.M] in Milimani Commercial Court MCCC No. 1642 of 2018 consolidated with MCELC No. E473 of 2023 delivered on the 23rd of July 2025)

1. The dispute before this Honourable Court concerns a parcel of land situated at Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton, Nairobi County, whose identity and ownership remain at the heart of this appeal.

2. The Appellants maintain that they occupy Plot No. 26 allocated to their late sister, Nancy Wambui Mweru. The 1st Respondent, however, claimed ownership of Plot No. 624, which he subsequently sold to the 2nd Respondent, Joyce Nduta Mungai, for Kshs. 600,000 under a Sale Agreement dated 29th November 2016.

3. Consequently, the 1st Respondent instituted Milimani Commercial Court (“the trial court”) Civil Case No. 1642 of 2018, where he sought the following orders: -

“i. An Order of eviction of the defendants from plot No. 624 Buruburu Riverside estate [City Carton

ii. Costs of the Suit.

iii. Interest on [b] above.

iv. Any other relief as is just to grant.

4. After a lapse of approximately five years, the 2nd Respondent instituted Milimani Chief Magistrate’s Environment and Land Court Case No. E473 of 2023, where she sought the following reliefs: -

“i. A Declaration that the plaintiff is the lawful and Bonafide owner of plot No. 624 located at city Carton, Buru, Buru Riverside Estate Nairobi County and the Honourable Court to issue a permanent injunction against the 1st and 2nd defendants restraining them from accessing, selling, trespassing onto or dealing with the suit property in any manner.

ii. An Order for eviction against the defendants to allow the plaintiff to take and enjoy quiet possession of the suit;

iii. Costs and interest of this suit;

iv. Any other or further relief which this Honourable Court deems fit and just to grant.”

5. On 28.3.2024 the trial court ordered the consolidation of both files, the matter was heard and determined. In a judgment delivered on 25th July 2025, Hon. A. Mukenga, Principal Magistrate (“learned trial magistrate”), declared: -

“ In the end, I issue the following orders;

i) A declaration be and is hereby issued that the 2nd Plaintiff, Joyce Nduta Mungai is the lawful and Bonafide owner of PLOT NO. 624 located at City Carton, Buruburu Riverside Estate in Nairobi County.

ii) The Defendants are hereby ordered to render vacant possession of the suit property within ninety (90) days from the date hereof failure to which an eviction order shall issue forthwith.

iii) The 2nd Plaintiff is awarded costs of the suit and interest thereon.”

6. Aggrieved by the said determination, the Appellants lodged the instant appeal on 30th July 2025. The appeal is anchored on four (4) grounds of appeal whereby the appellant ultimately prays for the following reliefs:

(a) The Appeal be allowed.

(b) The Plaintiffs suit number MCCC No. 1642 of 2018 filed on 7th July, 2017 [2018] and MCELC No. E473 of 2013 [2023] filed on the 9th November, 2023 be dismissed.

(c) the costs of this appeal and costs [in the trial court] be borne by the Respondents.”

7. On the 07.07.2026 the appeal was admitted for hearing. With the consent of the parties the court directed that the same be canvassed by written submission.

8. Appellants filed their written submissions dated 28.8.2026 while the Respondents filed theirs dated 15.10.2026 on the 18.10.2026

9. The Appellant invoked the foundational principles of a first appeal in prosecuting the appeal. They urged the court to discharge its duty to re-evaluate, re-assess and analyze the entire evidence to arrive at its own independent findings of fact and law as established in the landmark case of Selle & Another v. Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd & Others [1968] EA 123 and reinforced in Gakii v. Gerald [2026] KEELC 1180 (KLR). The Appellants contended that the learned trial magistrate committed fundamental errors of both law and fact by misapprehending evidence, shifting the burden of proof, and relying on judicial speculation.

10. The Appellants submission that the core gravamen of the Respondents’ case was that the Appellants were illegally in occupation of plot No. 624. However, The Respondents failed to establish the foundational identity, precise location, and boundaries of the suit plot through cogent technical evidence. The Appellants asserted that they occupy Plot No. 26, property allocated to their late sister, Nancy Mweru, by the Nairobi City Council on October 14, 2002. It is the appellants submission that by virtue of sections 107, 108, and 109 of the Evidence Act (Cap 80), the legal burden and evidential burden rested entirely on the Respondents to establish, on a balance of probabilities, encroachment and unlawful occupation concerning plot no 624, a legal position underscored in Adina

v. Otiato & 2 Others [2024] KEELC 1218 (KLR), Palace Investments Limited v. Geoffrey Kariuki Mwenda & Another [2015] eKLR among other cited precedents. The appellants contended that the learned magistrate gravely erred in law by shifting the burden of proof onto the Appellants requiring them to defend their title against unproven claim. furthermore, the trial court misdirected itself by validating competing allotment letters that bore identical dates and reference

numbers notwithstanding the absence of any lawful basis or verifiable chain of transfer.

11. The Appellant submitted that the trial magistrate engaged in impermissible judicial conjecture by holding that the 1st Respondent’s payment of survey fees was synonymous with a physical survey and definitive establishment of boundary. This finding the appellants point out was arrived at despite a total lack of evidence demonstrating that a licensed surveyor visited the suit plot or fixed any boundary beacons. To enforce this, point the appellants cited that the decision in Munguti v. Ndonye [2025] KECA 2114 (KLR), which affirms the established principle that boundary uncertainty or dispute can only be conclusively cured through identification and verification on the ground by professional, licensed surveyor. Consequently, it was urged that the trial magistrate reliance on mere payment receipts to determine a boundary line was a misdirection that fundamentally prejudiced the appellant’s case.

12. The Appellants faulted the learned Trial Magistrate for dismissing this material contradiction as a mere obvious inconsistency. The Appellants contended that this discrepancy goes to the very root of the respondent’s credibility, fundamentally undermining and exposing their narrative as a fabrication.

13. Furthermore, the Appellant contended that the Respondents failed to discharge their mandatory burden of proof required in land disputes. citing the persuasive authority of Mbuthi v. Osman & Another [2024] KEELC 387, the appellants urged that the respondents failed to establish the identity of the land, proof of ownership roots and continuous physical possession. Consequently, the Appellants maintained that the trial courts judgment was in its entirety, set aside the trial court's judgment was flawed, unsafe and unsustainable in law.

14. Ultimately the Appellants pray that this appeal be allowed in its entirety, the judgment and orders of the trial court to be set aside, the respondents suits in the lower court (Milimani Commercial Court Case No. 1642 of 2018 (consolidated with MCELC No. E473 of 2023) be dismissed and costs of both this appeal and the trial court proceedings be awarded to the Appellants.

15. The Respondents submitted that the appeal lacks merit and the decision of the trial court should be upheld. The respondents reminded this court that while the first appellate is under a legal duty-to reevaluate the evidence on record while bearing in mind that the trial court observed the demeanor of witnesses as established in Kenya Breweries Ltd v Godfrey Odoyo [2010] eKLR, Selle v

Associated Motor Boat Company Limited [1968] EA 123, and Samuel Kariuki Nyangoti v Johaan Distelberger [2017] eKLR.

16. The 1st Respondent asserted that the late Nancy Mweru served as his caretaker between the years 2014 and 2016 during which period she allegedly resided on the plot and invited the appellants to occupy it. However, the Death Certificate Serial No. 54010 conclusively establishes that the late Nancy Mweru died on 26.2.2011.

17. The Respondents further argued that the appellants failed to prove their own claim of ownership or establish the nexus between themselves and the alleged original allottee (Nancy Wambui Mweru), of the suit plot.it was the respondents’ case that that the documents produced by appellants related to an entirely different plot (plot number 26) instead of (plot number 624).The Respondents contended that the Appellants omitted to file a counter-claim to substantiate any claim for adverse possession.

18. Ultimately, applying the principle that ownership is determined by tracing title to a solid foundation without a break in the chain as held in Kaggs Investment Limited v Nyakwara & 2 others [2025] KEELC 514 (KLR), the Respondents maintained they possess the superior title.

19. Having considered the grounds of appeal, record of appeal, the trial court’s records and the rival written submissions filed by the respective as evidence, the following issues crystalize for determination: -

a) Whether the Respondents discharged the burden of proof regarding land identity and physical boundaries of plot number 624 and 26.

b) Whether the root of ownership and validity of the underlying allocations were legally established by respondents /appellants.

c) Whether the 2nd respondent was a Bonafide purchaser for value without notice of p suit plot(No 624).

d) Who should bear the costs of the Appeal?

20. This court, sitting as a first appellate court, is mandated to re-examine, re-evaluate and analyze the evidence adduced before the trial court to draw its own independent conclusions. We do so with the necessary caution that the court neither heard the witnesses testify nor observed their demeanor firsthand. This principle was restated in Selle and Another vs. Associated Motorboat Company Ltd & Others, [1968] EA 123.

21. To the extent that the appeal challenges the trial court’s exercise of discretion, this court takes guidance from Mbogo & Another vs Shah (1968)93 which dictates that an appellate court will not interfere with the exercise of trial

court’s discretion unless it is satisfied that the trial court misdirected itself on the law, misapprehended the facts, or arrived at a decision that is plainly wrong.

i) Issue of Proof of land identity and physical boundaries of plot no 624 and 26 situate at Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton, Nairobi County.

22. The Respondents’ case at the trial court was anchored on the allegation that the Appellants unlawfully entered and occupied Plot No. 624. Conversely The Appellants categorically denied any occupation and possession of the suit plot. (624). The Appellants maintained that they occupy /reside on plot no 26 situated at Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton, Nairobi County They contended that plot no 26 had been allocated to their late sister, Nancy Wambui Mweru, by the then Nairobi City Council on 14th October 2002.

23. The central question therefore is whether the land/plot no 26 the Appellants occupy on the ground is, in fact, Plot No. Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton, 624, Nairobi County as alleged by the Respondents and /or plot no 26 situated at Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton, Nairobi County as asserted by the Appellants. Sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act, (cap 80) dictates that the legal burden of proving a fact rest upon the party asserting it while the evidentiary burden is dynamic. In civil proceedings, that burden is discharged on a balance of probabilities. As stated in Githaiga vs Mwangi (Civil appeal E064 of 2022) [2024] that the legal burden remains fixed whereas the evidential burden may shift during proceedings based on the circumstances of evidence adduced by each party to the proceedings.

24. It is trite that he who asserts must prove. In matters to do with land the burden of proof rests with the Plaintiff, in this case the Respondents, on a balance of probabilities. The Court of Appeal in Maina v Maina [2013] KECA 94 (KLR) stated as follows:-

“We state that when a registered proprietor’s root of title is under challenge, it is not sufficient to dangle the instrument of title as proof of ownership .it is this instrument of title that is in challenge and the registered owner must go beyond the instrument and prove the legality of how he acquired the title.”

25. In Adina v Otiato & 2 others environment & Land Case 81 of 2018) [2024] KEELC 1218 (KLR) the Court held: -

"As I have already stated above, the onus was on the Plaintiff, not on the Defendants, to prove what they alleged in their plaint. It was never the duty of the Defendants to prove that they "are in occupation of their portion of land" as suggested by counsel for the Plaintiff. It was the Plaintiff to prove that in fact the Defendants are the ones encroaching on his land and should be evicted therefrom.”

26. From the established Judicial precedents, where a particular fact is within the knowledge of a party, the onus of proof shifts upon that party to prove. Consequently, the evidentiary burden lay upon the Respondents to demonstrate on a balance of probability how they acquired plot No 624situtated at Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton, Nairobi County, a fact within the personal knowledge of the 1st Respondent. It was incumbent upon the 1st respondent to discharge the burden. The 1st Respondent relied on an allotment letter dated 12th February 2014, reference number LS/02/SGM/JWK/2338, purporting to allocate Plot No. 624, Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton, Nairobi County to him. He produced payment receipts and an acceptance letter dated 13.05.2015 addressed to the Nairobi City County. During his testimony, he stated that he employed Nancy Wambui Mweru as a caretaker of his plot (plot No 624) in 2014 who permitted her brothers, the Appellants herein, to occupy the property until 2016, when she died.

27. The court in Total Kenya Ltd v Dakawou Transport Ltd [2026] KEHC 663 (KLR) stipulated that: -

“It is imperative to distinguish between the legal burden (persuasive burden) and the evidential burden. Legal burden is the obligation to prove the case to the required standard (balance of probabilities). It generally remains with the plaintiff throughout the trial. Evidential burden is the burden of adducing evidence to support a specific assertion. This burden shifts like a pendulum during the trial. This distinction was eloquently clarified by the Supreme Court in Raila Amolo Odinga & Another vs. IEBC & 2 Others eKLR .

“Though the legal and evidential burden of establishing the facts and contentions which will support a party's case is static and remains constant through a trial with the plaintiff, however, depending on the effectiveness with which he or she discharges this, the evidential burden keeps shifting and its position at any time is determined by answering the question as to who would lose if no further evidence were introduced.”

28. It is trite that while the legal burden remains constant and rests on the party asserting a fact . evidential burden is dyanamic.it shifts at any given stage of proceedings depending on the evidence already adduced and the party who would stand to lose if no further evidence were introduced.

29. During cross-examination, the 1st Respondent stated that Nancy passed away in 2016 and denied the suggestion that she had passed on in 2011.However, The Appellants produced a death certificate of serial number 540107 demonstrating that Nancy Mweru passed away on 26.2. 2011.This crucial document was not challenged by the Respondents, hence remained uncontroverted evidence. This piece of documentary evidence materially casts doubt on the credibility of the 1stRespondent’s evidence that the late Nancy Mweru remained associated with the property (624), as his caretaker between 2014 and 2016. Further, this contradiction is relevant to the credibility of the 1st respondent account of the circumstances under which the Appellants came into possession and/or occupation of the suit plot (624), Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton, Nairobi County).

30. Consequently, the core issue for scrutiny is whether plot 624 and plot 26 Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton, Nairobi County are same plot. In Munguti v Ndonye (Civil Appeal 454 of 2019) [2025] KECA 2114 (KLR) the Court of Appeal stated as follows -

"The main problem, however, still remains the uncertainty of the actual portion on the ground that was sold. This is a problem that can only be cured by a surveyor identifying on the ground the portion of the suit property that was identified by the appellant and accepted by the ELC.”

31. The 1st Respondent produced a receipt indicating a payment of Kshs. 23,500 as survey fees. However, the record, as presented does not indicate that he produced a survey map, Registry Index Map, Part Development Plan, beacon certificate, or surveyor’s or county inspection report identifying the physical location of Plot No. 624 ,Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton, and establishing that the premises occupied by the Appellants formed part of the suit plot. (plot 624).

32. The mere payment of survey fees, without corresponding evidence identifying plot no 624 (suit plot) on the ground, does not by itself establish that Plot No. 624 and Plot No. 26 refer to the same property, nor does it prove that the e appellants were in occupation of plot no 624, not 26 Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton,

Nairobi County. In the absence of sufficient evidence establishing that nexus the finding of trespass by Appellants on plot number 624 Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton, Nairobi city council lacks proof of an essential factual element of the Respondents’ claim. The burden could not be properly shifted to the Appellants merely because they were in occupation of the premises and did not file a counterclaim to prove adverse possession.

33. Consequently ,.the Court must determine the identity of the suit property from verifiable documentary and oral evidence presented before the court. It is the finding of this court that the learned trial magistrate erred in its evaluation of the evidence and application of the principles governing the burden of proof.

ii) whether The root of title and validity of the allotment letters underlying allocations of plot No 624 and 26 were established.

34. In Ngarama v Kinyanjui & another [2022] KEELC 3067 (KLR) it was stated as follows

From a legal standpoint, a letter of allotment is not a title to property. It is a transient and often conditional right or offer to take the property. See Wreck Motor Enterprises Vs. Commissioner of Lands and others Nairobi Civil Appeal 71 of 1997 (unreported), Jaj Super Power Cash & Carry Limited Vs Nairobi City Council and others Nairobi, Civil Appeal 111 of 2002, Court of Appeal, (unreported). Mirrored against the 1st defendant’s registered interest in the land, and the evidence, the plaintiffs’ claim is on a quicksand. It may well be true that the 1st defendant did not pay the stand premium or other charges within the prescribed time in the letter of allotment. But payment was accepted. A registrable interest has been created and two lease titles issued. The registered interest ranks higher than the transient rights in the letters of allotment.”

35. The 1st Respondent relied on a letter of allotment dated 12 February 2014, showing that the Plot allotted to him was Plot No 624, Buruburu Riverside Estate, City Carton, Nairobi County . The letter required compliance with its conditions within thirty (30) days. However, the 1st respondent executed the acceptance letter dated 13 May 2015, nearly a year and three months after the prescribed compliance period had expired.

36. The payment receipts produced by the 1st Respondent reflected payment of

survey fees of Kshs. 23,500/=, stand premium of Kshs. 4,500/= and ground rent of Kshs. 3,000/= in June and July 2015, approximately one year after the stipulated period of compliance with set conditions in the letter of allotment. The survey fees was paid less the required Kshs. 25,000/=, while the stamps on the receipts were not legible and could not readily be verified.

37. Furthermore, the Declaration (PEXH 4) dated 1 August 2014, preceded the acceptance letter dated 13 May 2015. This chronological sequence of events raises a material question as to how the declaration could have been executed by Appellant before the offer was formally accepted. Even if the procedural inconsistency did not go to the root of title of 1st respondent in regard to plot No 624, the 2nd Respondent, in turn, relied on documentation substantially duplicating that of the 1st Respondent. she produced a Sale Agreement dated 29.11.2016 claiming to be a bona fide purchaser for value without notice for Kshs 600,000.00/-.In rebuttal to the above, the Appellants produced an allotment letter dated 14.10.2002 demonstrating that the land identified for allocation to Nancy Mweru(deceased) was Plot 26, not 624. As to whether an allotment letter conferred a legally enforceable interest capable of defeating the competing claim to 2nd respondent over plot no 624 is for scrutiny by this court. This court is guided by the case of Arap Ng'ok v. Ole Keiwua & 4 Others [1997] KECA 1 (KLR) where it was stated as follows:

“It is trite that such title to landed property can only come into existence after issuance of letter of allotment, meeting the conditions stated in such letter and actual issuance thereafter of title document pursuant to provisions in the Act under which the property is held.”

38. Similarly, the court in Lagat v Kebut [2023] KEELC 18432 (KLR) while setting out the procedure for allocation of land stipulated as follows: -

“The sixth step would be for the issuance of an allotment letter to the allotee. An allotment letter has been held not to be capable of conferring an interest in land, being nothing more than an offer, awaiting the fulfilment of the conditions stipulated therein by the offeree.

39. The cited judicial precedents /underscore the procedures material to establishing the legality of allocation of unalienated public land and an allotment letter not to be capable of transferring an interest in land, but an offer awaiting fulfilment of the conditions stipulated therein by the offeree. It is trite that due

process must be followed by a party relying on allotment letter as proof of acquisition of ownership of interest in land to wit identification of the plot, application for its acquisition, demonstrating issuance of a letter of allotment, existence of a requisite pard development plan, compliance with the stipulated conditions in the letter of allotment and the subsequent steps undertaken towards registration. A beacon certificate may also assist in establishing the identity and boundaries of the allocated parcel.

40. In the present case the underpayment of survey fees implies that the 1st Respondent was none compliant with the conditions stipulated in the letter of allotment letter dated 12.2.2014. Additionally, The Appellants’ evidence on record is that their late sister, Nancy Wambui Mweru, was allocated Plot No 26 under the Buruburu riverbank settlement scheme, City Carton, by the defunct Nairobi City Council and occupied the property/plot from 2002 until her demise in 2011. The Appellants maintained that they remained in possession of plot No 26 Buruburu Riverbank settlement scheme (City Carton,) since 2011 to date, despite the issuance of formalization letter dated 14.10.2002 prior to her death, no evidence was led by Appellants to prove that the deceased was ever issued with a certificate of lease for Plot No 26, Buruburu Riverbank settlement scheme (City Carton,)

41. The Court in Republic versus City Council of Nairobi & 3 others (2014) eKLR, had this to say about land that has already been allotted: -

“Once allotment letter is issued and the allottee meets the conditions therein, the land in question is no longer available for allotment since a letter of allotment confers absolute right of ownership unless it is challenged by the allotting authority or is acquired through fraud, mistake or misrepresentation or that the allotment was out rightly illegal or it was against public interest. In other words, where land has been allocated, the same land cannot be reallocated unless the first allocation is validly and lawfully cancelled.”

42. Based on the above-mentioned principle, The 2nd respondent’s testimony raises significant questions concerning her acquisition of the sui property without notice of competing interest. If she purchased the property from the 1st Respondent in 2016, she failed to demonstrate how she subsequently obtained an allotment letter dated 12.02.2014 of reference number as that of the 1st Respondent's letter of allotment. The duplication in particulars of allotment letters of respondents bear the date 12.02.2014 and reference number LS/02/SGM/Jwk/2338, yet the 2nd Respondent testified that her allotment letter was issued in April 2017. The explanation advanced by the Respondents

concerning the competing allotment letters unless corroborated by the defunct city council of Nairobi (which was not presented before the trial court) is not satisfactory.

43. The Appellants’ case was that their late sister Nancy Mweru occupied the property until her demise in 2011(refer to the death certificate) and that they remained in possession thereafter. In landmark case of Gitwany Investment Limited v. Tajmal Limited & 3 others [2006] KEHC 2519 (KLR) the court stipulated as follows: -

“it is a well settled principle of equity and law that where a public authority, by an admitted administrative error and in the absence of fraud, issues two distinct titles in respect the identical parcel of land the doctrine of priority in time apply (qui prior est tempora potior est jure)

consequently, if both competing certificates of title appear ex facie regular and procedurally sound, the title which was first in time must prevail. state, having fully alienated its interest under the initial grant is effectively divested of any property rights. it follows axiomatically, that there remains no substratum or residual interest capable of being subsequent allotted or transferred to a secondary party, any such subsequent allocations a nullity.

furthermore, as lawful title inherently vests in the registered proprietor the holder of the prior subsisting title is fully entitled to quiet enjoyment and may successfully maintain an action for trespass against any party whose subsequent occupation lacks a valid recognizable legal basis. "

44. The 1st Respondent stated that, personally, he never occupied the suit property because he lived far away. The 2nd Respondent testified that she took possession of the suit plot (No 624) in 2015 when the land was vacant but subsequently encountered a lady on the suit property when she returned in 2016. She also stated that she found the Appellants on the land when she returned to clear it in 2017.The Chief's letter dated 23.12.2016, acknowledged the 1st Respondent's claim to the land though, the 1st Respondents' documentary claims must still be examined against the chronology of the documentary evidence tendered by the appellants on record against the failure by respondents to prove occupation of plot No 624 by Appellants.

45. In the present case, neither the 1st nor 2nd Respondent demonstrated a registrable interest in plot No 624 Buru Buru riverbank settlement scheme( city carton ) capable of displacing the Appellants' claim merely by relying on the competing allotment documents. section 107 of the Evidence Act, places the legal burden of proof on he who alleges a fact as reaffirmed in George Owen Nandy v Ruth Watiri Kibe [2016] KECA 622 (KLR) stated: -

“The record is indeed bereft of any evidence that the mandatory procedure was followed. The burden of proof is placed on the party that alleges a particular fact as per Section 107 of the Evidence Act.”

46. The court in Ngarama v Kinyanjui & another [2022] KEELC 3067 (KLR stated as follows: -

"A property title is completely invalid if it is rooted in fraud, illegality, or forgery meaning that a subsequent buyer cannot claim protection as an innocent purchaser (Bonafide purchaser) if the title they bought was manufactured from a stolen or fake foundation".

47. In Mbuthi v Osman & another [2024] KEELC 387 (KLR) the court held that: -

" Proof of ownership of land is found in documentary evidence which leads to the root of title. There must be an unbroken chain of documents showing the true owner. Once proof of ownership is tendered then the holder of the documents is entitled to the protection of the law. There is no doubt that such proof will be on a balance of probabilities, but the court must be left in no doubt that the holder of the documents proved is the one entitled to the property."

48. Even if the 1st Respondent’s allotment letter dated 12.2.2014 was perfected through compliance with its conditions, which was not authenticated by the physical planning department of the Defunct City Council of Nairobi , it does not, by itself, confer transferable interest/ title upon the allottee as reaffirmed in the case of Torino Enterprises Ltd v Attorney General (Petition 5 (E006) of 2022) [2023] KESC 79 (KLR). Based on the established authoritative citation and judicial precedents reaffirming that an allotment letter is a letter of offer by the offeree not capable of transferring a registrable interest to the allottee, The 1st respondent had no transferrable interest in the suit plot (NO 624)Buruburu

riverside estate (City Carton,) to transfer to 2nd respondent upon execution of. the sale agreement on 19.11.2016.

iii) Whether the 2nd respondent was Bonafide purchaser for value without notice of plot No 624 buruburu riverside estate (city carton) (suit plot):

49. The 2nd Respondent claimed protection as a bona fide purchaser for value without notice. The court of Appeal in Arthi Highway Developers Limited v West End Butchery Limited & 6 Others [2015] eKLR stipulated that: - innocent purchaser for value cannot claim protection or a valid title through fraud, forgery or a flawed claim of ownership.

50. In the present case, the 2nd Respondent's own testimony casts doubts as to whether she acquired the suit property without notice of the competing claims. Although she stated that, initially, she found the suit land unoccupied and took possession in 2015, she acknowledged encountering a lady on the property upon her return in 2016. She further testified that she subsequently found the Appellants on the land when she returned to clear the plot in 2017.

51. The physical occupation of the suit property by 3rd parties called for exercise of due diligence by the 2nd respondent prior to executing the sale agreement on 19.11.2016). The 2nd respondent would have conducted a survey for verification of, the physical location of the suit property through a survey report, beacon certificate, report from the physical planning department, county government of Nairobi or called a professional surveyor as her witness. No documentary or professional evidence was presented by 2nd respondent to corroborate her claim over the suit property as a Bonafide purchaser for value without notice. Rather, the 2nd Respondent's evidence does not satisfactorily establish that she acquired the property without notice of the Appellants claim. The court is not satisfied that the 2nd Respondent established the defense of a bona fide purchaser for value without notice.

52. Furter more, Having found that the 1st Respondent had no transferable interest in plot No 624 Buru Buru Riverside estate (city carton) to transfer to 2nd respondent on the 19.11.2026, as such her purchase of the suit plot No 624 cannot be treated as one made without notice of competing interests. The 2nd respondent claim that she is a Bonafide purchaser for value without notice over plot number 624 Buru Buru riverside estate (city carton)fails.

53. In the circumstances this court finds that the Learned trial magistrate erred in both law and fact in holding that 2nd respondent established her claim over

plot no 624 as a Bonafide purchaser for value without notice. The learned trial magistrate’s finding, on a balance of probabilities, was flawed as it relied on 2nd respondent’s uncorroborated evidence of being shown the disputed plot by an official from the defunct Nairobi city council. absence of any documentary evidence to corroborate her claim against the appellants.

54. As to who to pay costs, in Rai & 3 others v Rai & 4 others [2014] KESC 31 (KLR), the Supreme Court affirmed that costs follow the event, subject to the Court’s discretion. Pursuant to section 27 of Civil Procedure Act,2010, the court finds no special circumstance to depart from the principle that costs follow events. Accordingly, the costs of this appeal are awarded to the Appellants.

55. Consequently, the court finds the appeal dated 30.7.2025 meritorious, and is hereby allowed on following terms:

a) The Judgement and decree of the learned trial magistrate in Milimani Commercial Court MCCC No. 1642 of 2018 as consolidated with MCELC No. E473 of 2023 delivered on the 23rd of July 2025) in the consolidated suit and all its consequential orders are set aside in their entirety.

b) And substituted with a judgment that The Respondents consolidated suit before the magistrate’s court in Milimani MELC NO 1642 consolidated with MCELC No E473 of 2023 against the Appellants is hereby dismissed with costs.

c) The Appellants (Defendants)in the magistrates' court) are awarded costs of the appeal.

It is so ordered accordingly.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED THIS 21ST OF OCTOBER 2026 VIRTUALLY

J. ORWA

JUDGE

In the presence of:

MS MAYEGA FOR MR NGARUIYA MAINA FOR THE APPELLANTS MR BWOIGARA FOR THE RSPONDENTS

MR LETISIA –COURT SSISTANT

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder