Land law

Wangai v National Social Security Fund & 4 others [2026] KEELC 7379 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Environment and Land Case 554 of 2008
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
LG Kimani

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Plaintiff/Decree Holder filed a Notice of Motion dated 10th March 2026 seeking, principally, that the ruling delivered by the Deputy Registrar on 26th February 2026 be vacated and set aside, together with costs of the application.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Counsel for the Plaintiff identifies three issues for determination: whether there was a subsisting Notice to Show Cause before the Deputy Registrar and whether the Court had become functus officio; whether the Deputy Registrar had jurisdiction to entertain the application for payment of the decretal sum by instalments; and whether the order permitting payment of Kshs.100,000 per month was reasonable.

Paragraph 14 →

Reasoning passage

Accordingly, the Court finds that the Notice of Motion dated 10th March 2026,

Paragraph 38 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENTAL & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

E.L.C CASE NO. 554 OF 2008

NANCY WANJIRU WANGAI……….…….………..…………PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

NATIONAL SOCIAL SECURITY FUND. …..……….….1st DEFENDANT

DAVID NJOROGE NGARU…………..…….…….….….2nd DEFENDANT

PATRICK NYAMU……………………………………......3rd DEFENDANT

FRED OYUGI……………….……………….……….…….4th DEFENDANT

JOSEPH OLE KIAMBU…..…………………..…….….….5th DEFENDANT

RULING

1. The Plaintiff/Decree Holder filed a Notice of Motion dated 10th March 2026 seeking, principally, that the ruling delivered by the Deputy Registrar on 26th February 2026 be vacated and set aside, together with costs of the application.

2. The application arises from execution proceedings following the judgment in favour of the Plaintiff, pursuant to which a decretal sum of Kshs.14,078,590.58 became payable by the 3rd Defendant.

3. The Plaintiff states that she obtained a Notice to Show Cause dated 21st May 2024 against the 3rd Defendant. The 3rd Defendant subsequently filed submissions, and the Court delivered a ruling on 31st July 2025 allowing the Notice to Show Cause. Following that ruling, the Plaintiff proceeded to extract warrants of arrest dated 4th August 2025.

4. Thereafter, on 11th August 2025, the 3rd Defendant filed an application seeking leave to liquidate the decretal sum by monthly instalments of Kshs.100,000.

5. The Plaintiff opposed that application, maintaining that the Court had already dealt with the Notice to Show Cause and was therefore functus officio. The Plaintiff filed a Replying Affidavit sworn on 20th August 2025 and submissions dated 24th February 2026. On 26th February 2026, the Deputy Registrar delivered a ruling allowing the 3rd Defendant to pay the decretal sum by monthly instalments of Kshs.100,000 until payment in full. The ruling also purported to set aside the warrants of arrest issued on 4th August 2025.

6. The Plaintiff challenges that ruling on the ground that the Deputy Registrar lacked jurisdiction to hear and determine the application for payment of the decretal sum by instalments and ought to have referred the matter to a Judge.

7. The Plaintiff further contends that the ruling effectively re-adjudicated the Notice to Show Cause dated 21st May 2024, which had already been determined by the ruling of 31st July 2025. She therefore argues that the subsequent determination was res judicata and/or contrary to the doctrine of functus officio.

8. The Plaintiff also challenges the practicality and reasonableness of the instalment order, contending that at Kshs.100,000 per month, the decretal sum of Kshs.14,078,590.58 would take an unreasonably long period to liquidate.

9. Lastly, the Plaintiff contends that the Deputy Registrar had no basis or jurisdiction to set aside the warrants of arrest dated 4th August 2025, which had been issued pursuant to the earlier ruling on the Notice to Show Cause.

10. The Plaintiff therefore maintains that the ruling of 26th February 2026 was made without jurisdiction and/or contrary to the previous orders of the Court, and urges the Court to vacate and set aside the said ruling in the interests of justice and to enable her enjoy the fruits of her judgment.

3rd Defendant’s Replying Affidavit

11. The 3rd Defendant/Judgment Debtor filed a Replying Affidavit in opposition to the Plaintiff’s application. He disputes the Plaintiff’s characterization of the Notice to Show Cause dated 21st May 2024. He contends that the Notice to Show Cause was issued for purposes of seeking attachment and sale of his movable property, and not for his arrest and committal to civil jail. He therefore suggests that the subsequent warrants of arrest may have been issued in error.

12. The 3rd Defendant maintains that the Deputy Registrar had jurisdiction to entertain and determine the application. He further contends that if the Plaintiff was dissatisfied with the Deputy Registrar’s ruling, the proper course was to appeal against the ruling, rather than seek to have it set aside through the present application.

13. He consequently urges the Court to reject the Plaintiff’s challenge to the Deputy Registrar’s ruling and maintains that the matters raised by the Plaintiff do not warrant setting aside the ruling of 26th February 2026.

Plaintiff/Decree Holder’s Written Submissions

14. Counsel for the Plaintiff identifies three issues for determination: whether there was a subsisting Notice to Show Cause before the Deputy Registrar and whether the Court had become functus officio; whether the Deputy Registrar had jurisdiction to entertain the application for payment of the decretal sum by instalments; and whether the order permitting payment of Kshs.100,000 per month was reasonable.

15. On the doctrine of functus officio, the Plaintiff submits that the Notice to Show Cause dated 21st May 2024 had been determined by the ruling delivered on 31st July 2025. She contends that the subsequent Notice of Motion dated 11th August 2025, filed by the 3rd Defendant seeking to pay the decretal sum by monthly instalments of Kshs.100,000, did not seek the setting aside, lifting or variation of the warrants of arrest issued on 4th August 2025. Accordingly, the Plaintiff argues that the Deputy Registrar acted beyond the relief sought by purporting to set aside the warrants in the ruling delivered on 26th February 2026. In support of this argument, she relies on Mohamed v Adan & 3 Others (Civil Appeal E680 of 2023) [2026] KECA 527 (KLR), in which the Court of Appeal affirmed that once a judicial officer has determined a dispute, the judicial function in respect of that dispute is spent, and the Court cannot reopen matters already determined.

16. On the reasonableness of the instalment order, the Plaintiff argues that the 3rd Defendant delayed for a prolonged period before seeking to settle the judgment debt and has not demonstrated any genuine efforts towards payment. She submits that the proposed monthly instalment of Kshs.100,000 would require approximately 140.79 months, equivalent to about 11 years and 9 months, to liquidate the decretal sum, rendering the proposal unreasonable and indicative of a lack of seriousness in settling the debt.

17. The Plaintiff further relies on Kabaru & Another v Maina (Miscellaneous Civil Application E172 of 2023) [2025] KEHC 4785 (KLR) for the proposition that a judgment debtor seeking to pay a decretal sum by instalments must demonstrate their financial circumstances and inability to settle the debt in full, ordinarily through supporting evidence such as financial records. She contends that the 3rd Defendant failed to provide the requisite evidence to justify the proposed payment arrangement.

The 3rd Defendant’s Submissions

18. The 3rd Defendant submits that the Plaintiff’s application is misconceived, devoid of merit and an abuse of the Court process. He identifies three issues for determination, namely whether the Deputy Registrar had jurisdiction to determine the application for payment of the decretal sum by instalments, whether the doctrines of functus officio and res judicata apply to the subsequent execution proceedings, and whether the Plaintiff has established sufficient grounds to warrant interference with the Deputy Registrar’s ruling.

19. On jurisdiction, the 3rd Defendant argues that the application dated 11th August 2025 concerned the mode of satisfying the decree and was properly before the Deputy Registrar. He relies on Section 34 of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 21 Rule 12 and Order 49 Rule 7(1)(b)(ix) of the Civil Procedure Rules as provisions empowering the executing Court and the Registrar to determine execution-related questions and permit payment by instalments where sufficient cause is established. He further submits that the Plaintiff’s proper remedy, if dissatisfied with the ruling, was to appeal rather than seek to set it aside, since the application neither challenged the judgment nor sought to reopen the earlier Notice to Show Cause proceedings.

20. On functus officio and res judicata, the 3rd Defendant distinguishes the earlier Notice to Show Cause proceedings, which determined whether execution could issue against the Judgment Debtor, from the subsequent application, which concerned the manner of satisfying the decretal sum. He contends that the mode of payment had not previously been determined and that Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act is therefore inapplicable. He further argues that execution is a continuing process and that the Court retains supervisory jurisdiction until the decree is fully satisfied. In support of this position, he relies on Jasbir Singh Rai & 3 Others v Tarlochan Singh Rai & 4 Others [2007] KECA 132 (KLR) for the proposition that the doctrine of functus officio does not prevent the Court from addressing ancillary or procedural matters arising after determination of the substantive dispute.

21. The 3rd Defendant further submits that the Plaintiff has not demonstrated any illegality, procedural impropriety, misdirection, error of principle or other sufficient grounds to justify interference with the Deputy Registrar’s exercise of discretion. He maintains that the Deputy Registrar properly exercised the discretion conferred by Order 21 Rule 12 to facilitate orderly satisfaction of the decree while balancing the interests of both parties. He argues that the relevant considerations in determining whether to permit payment by instalments include the debtor’s conduct, financial position, good faith and the surrounding circumstances. He contends that he demonstrated good faith by acknowledging the debt, approaching the Court before arrest and seeking a structured payment arrangement instead of evading his obligations. He further maintains that the fact that payment at Kshs.100,000 per month may take a considerable period does not, by itself, render the order unlawful.

22. Regarding the warrants of arrest, the 3rd Defendant submits that setting them aside was a consequential order arising from the decision to permit payment by instalments. He argues that the Deputy Registrar was entitled to suspend coercive execution measures for as long as the instalment order remained in force. Relying on Popatlal Madhavji & Bros Limited & Another v Purushotam Enterprises Limited & Another and Freight Forwarders Ltd v Elsek & Elsek (K) Ltd, he reiterates that payment by instalments is a matter of judicial discretion that must be exercised judiciously in light of the circumstances of each case.

Analysis and Determination

23. Before considering the merits of the Plaintiff’s application seeking to set aside the Ruling of the Deputy Registrar delivered on 26th February 2026, the Court must first determine whether the present Motion is properly before it.

24. The jurisdiction of the Deputy Registrar in respect of the application by the 3rd Defendant is expressly provided for under Order 49 Rule 7 1(b) Civil Procedure Rules on hearing of application and states that

1. The Registrar may –

b. hear and determine an application made under the following Orders and rules –

………

ix. Order 21, rule 12;

25. Order 21 Rule 12 of the Civil Procedure Rules is the provision governing payment of a decretal sum by instalments. Therefore under order 49 7 (1) (b) the Deputy Registrar was in the Courts view exercising a power expressly conferred by the Rules when he considered and determined the 3rd Defendant’s application for payment of the decretal sum by monthly instalments.

26. The fact that the Deputy Registrar had jurisdiction to determine the application does not, however, render his decision final and immune from challenge. The Civil Procedure Rules expressly prescribe the manner in which a decision made by the Registrar under Order 49 Rule 7 is to be challenged.

27. Order 49 Rule 7(2) & (3) provide for an appeal and the procedure to be followed in lodging an appeal. Rule 7 (2) states;

“An appeal from a decision of the registrar under the Orders referred to in subrule (1) shall be to a judge in chambers.”

While Order 49 Rule 7(3) provides:

“The memorandum of the appeal, setting out the grounds of the appeal shall be filed within seven days of the decision of the registrar.”

28. An aggrieved party challenging a decision of the Registrar made under any of the provisions specified in Order 49 Rule 7(1) is required to invoke the appellate mechanism prescribed by Rule 7(2), namely, an appeal to a Judge in chambers. The memorandum of appeal must, by virtue of Rule 7(3), be filed within seven days of the decision of the Registrar.

29. The position was considered in Midenga & Company Advocates v Mutua (Miscellaneous Application E436 of 2023) [2025] KEHC 15795 (KLR).

“From the above provisions, it is apparent that a Notice to Show Cause is provided for under the provisions of Order 22 Rule 18 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, thus it is one of the applications contemplated for under Order 49 of the Civil Procedure Rules, therefore, in the event that a party is dissatisfied with a decision of the Deputy Registrar in respect to a Notice to Show Cause, the party may challenge it in the manner provided for under Order 49 Rules 7(2) & (3) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010.

20.The aforesaid provisions state that an appeal from a decision of the Deputy Registrar, such as from the Ruling delivered on 7th November 2024, shall be to a Judge in Chambers and the dissatisfied party shall within seven (7) days of the decision file a Memorandum of Appeal setting out the grounds of appeal. The client has neither filed a Memorandum of Appeal against the Deputy Registrar’s decision nor sought for extension of time to do so. In the absence of compliance with the provisions under Order 49 Rules 7(2) & (3) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, this Court’s jurisdiction to interfere with the Deputy Registrar’s Ruling delivered on 7th November 2024 has not been properly invoked.”

30. The same principle has been applied in Kiplagat Kotut v Rose Jebor Kipngok; Standard Chartered Bank & another (Garnishees) [2020] KEELC 3404 (KLR),

“The Court has carefully considered the grounds on the notice of preliminary objection, the learned Counsel’s written submissions and come to the following findings;

(a)  That Order 49 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides for the Special Powers of Registrars.  That Rule 7(2) of the said Order provides as follows;

“An appeal from a decision of the Registrar under the orders referred to in sub-rule (1) shall be to a Judge in Chambers.”

That from the annexed ruling by the Deputy Registrar of 10th September, 2019, the issues before her were about execution and attachment for decree on costs which by virtue of Order 49 Rule 7(1)(x) and (xi) are matters to be determined by the Deputy Registrar.  That it follows that appeals from the Deputy Registrar decisions on such matters therefore lies to this court as aforementioned.”

31. In the present matter, the impugned ruling was delivered on 26th February 2026. By virtue of Order 49 Rule 7(3), the seven-day period for filing a memorandum of appeal expired on 5th March 2026. The Plaintiff did not file a Memorandum of Appeal within that period. Instead, the Plaintiff filed the present Notice of Motion dated 10th March 2026, seeking, principally, that the ruling of the Deputy Registrar delivered on 26th February 2026 be vacated and set aside.

32. The substance of that prayer is a challenge to the decision of the Deputy

Registrar. The Plaintiff is asking this Court to reconsider and interfere with a

judicial determination made by the Deputy Registrar in exercise of powers

expressly conferred by Order 49 Rule 7(1)(b)(ix).

33. There is, however, a statutory mechanism through which time may be enlarged

under the Civil Procedure Act. A party who wishes to challenge a decision of the

Deputy Registrar outside the period prescribed by Order 49 Rule 7(3) must seek

enlargement of time. The Applicant has not invoked the Courts power to enlarge

time.

34. In Peter M. Kariuki v Attorney General & 4 Others [2019] KEHC 11623

(KLR), the Court explained that in exercising the functions conferred upon the

Deputy Registrar under Order 49, the Deputy Registrar exercises a judicial

function and not an administrative function. The Court further recognised that decisions arising from the exercise of those functions are subject to the appellate mechanism provided under Order 49 Rule 7.

35. In the present case, the Plaintiff was entitled to challenge the Deputy Registrar's

decision, but was required to do so through the procedure prescribed by the Civil

Procedure Rules.

36. The Court is of the view that the failure to follow that procedure renders the

present challenge incompetent. The Court therefore finds that the Plaintiff has

not properly invoked its jurisdiction to interrogate the merits of the Deputy

Registrar's ruling delivered on 26th February 2026.

37. It follows that the Court need not proceed to determine whether the Deputy

Registrar properly exercised the discretion conferred by Order 21 Rule 12. That

issue would properly arise upon a competent appeal.

38. Accordingly, the Court finds that the Notice of Motion dated 10th March 2026,

insofar as it seeks to directly challenge and set aside the ruling of the Deputy

Registrar delivered on 26th February 2026, is procedurally incompetent for

failure to comply with Order 49 Rule 7(2) and (3) of the Civil Procedure Rules.

39. Accordingly the Notice of Motion dated 10th March 2026 is struck out for

being procedurally incompetent. Each party to bear its own Costs.

Delivered, dated and signed via Microsoft Teams this 22nd day of October 2026.

HON. L. G. KIMANI

JUDGE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

The Judgement is read in the presence of-

Ms Maina holding brief for Thuka for Decree holder/Applicant

Karuga for 3rd Defendant/Judgement debtor/ Respondent.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder