Land law

Wanjiku v Wainaina (Sued on his Behalf and of the Estate of Teresiah Wanjiku Wainaina) & 2 others [2026] KEELC 6941 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Civil Suit 498 of 2015
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
AA. Omollo

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

In the amended plaint dated 25.10.2018, the Plaintiff sued the three Defendants and at paragraph 9(a), he set out particulars of fraud against each of the three (3) Defendants. In particular, the Plaintiff alleges that the 2nd Defendant conspired with the 1st Defendant to tamper with or forge the 2nd Defendant's records and issue a clearance certificate dated 7.2.2003, knowing that the suit property was already titled.

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

In conclusion, the application dated 24th November, 2025 is allowed with costs to the Applicant. The Applicant is directed to file and serve its Statement of Defence, witness statements and documents within 21 days of this ruling. The Plaintiff shall file a response to the statement of defence and any additional documents within 15 days of service. The matter to be mentioned on 10th December, 2026 for further directions on hearing.

Paragraph 15 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MILIMANI

CIVIL SUIT NO. 498 OF 2015

ZACHARY THIRU WANJIKU .....................PLAINTIFF / RESPONDENT

Versus

ALBERT NDICHI WAINAINA

(sued on his behalf and of the Estate of

TERESIAH WANJIKU WAINAINA) .................................................1ST DEFENDANT

GITHUNGURI CONSTITUENCY R. CO LTD .........2ND DEFENDANT / APPLICANT

THIKA DISTRICT L. REGISTRAR......................................................3RD DEFENDANT

RULING

1. In the amended plaint dated 25.10.2018, the Plaintiff sued the three Defendants and at paragraph 9(a), he set out particulars of fraud against each of the three (3) Defendants. In particular, the Plaintiff alleges that the 2nd Defendant conspired with the 1st Defendant to tamper with or forge the 2nd Defendant's records and issue a clearance certificate dated 7.2.2003, knowing that the suit property was already titled.

2. Subsequently, the Plaintiff obtained judgment in 2022, which was set aside on 21.11.2024 upon the application of the 1st Defendant. During the hearing of the 1st Defendant’s case, Counsel for the 1st Defendant informed the court that the Chairman of the 2nd Defendant was present and keen to participate. The Chairman had a statement of defence and witness statement yet to be filed, and I informed him to formally move the court before the statement of defence could be considered.

3. Immediately after the close of the 1st Defendant’s case, the plaintiff filed a notice withdrawing the suit against the 2nd Defendant. It is noteworthy that, from the court record, the notice of withdrawal of the suit has not been endorsed as a court order.

4. It is against this backdrop that the 2nd Defendant / Applicant moved the court vide its application dated 24.11.2025 seeking for orders that: -

(a) The Applicant be joined in this suit as a party as earlier directed by the Court as a 2nd Defendant.

(b) The Notice of Withdrawal / Discontinuance dated 10th November 2025 filed by the Plaintiff as against the 2nd Applicant be set aside in the interest of justice so as to allow the Applicant to participate in this trial.

(c) The Judgment and all consequential orders be set aside as they were entered without the participation, knowledge, or input of the 2nd Applicant.

(d) The 2nd Applicant be granted leave to file and serve its Defence and all supporting documents out of time as per the annexed copy of the same herewith attached.

(e) That this honourable court order for stay of execution of the judgment and determination of this Application.

(f) That this honourable court order for stay of execution of the judgment and all consequential orders be issued pending the hearing and determination of this suit.

(g) That the judgment and all consequential orders be set aside and the matter be reopened for hearing on the merits.

(h) That this honourable court be pleased to grant any other orders it may deem fit in the interest of justice.

(i) That the costs of this Application be provided for.

5. The application was supported by affidavits sworn by John Maina Mburu on 24.11.2025 and 2.6.2026, respectively. According to the Applicant, now that the Plaintiff has had sight of their documents, which will shed light on the company records, he chose to withdraw the suit. The Applicant affirmed that the Plaintiff has the right to sue any party, but this court has the prerogative to call for evidence that can assist it in arriving at a merited, just and fair decision.

6. The Plaintiff filed a replying affidavit sworn on 5th December, 2025 urging the court not to grant the orders sought. He deposed that he withdrew the suit against the Applicant because he had no claim against them, and that no law allows the court to undo the withdrawal. He deposed that when the Applicant told the court on 10th November 2025 that they had not been served with summons to enter appearance, he reconsidered his claim against the Applicant and decided to withdraw it. According to the Plaintiff, the Applicant cannot insist on being sued and he denies that they are a necessary party. They urged the court to dismiss the application with costs.

Submissions:

7. Directions were issued for prosecution, through written submissions. The Applicant’s submissions are dated 2nd February 2026, while the Plaintiff’s/Respondent’s submissions are dated 21.9.2026. Both the Applicant's and the Plaintiff/Respondent arguments are premised on Order 1 Rule 10 of the Civil Procedure Rules. I have read and considered them and will refer to them in my determination.

Analysis and Determination:

8. The Respondent cited Honourable Nambuye, J in the case Kingori vs. Chege & 3 Others [2002] 2 KLR 243, which stated the guiding principles on the question of joinder as follows:

“He must be a necessary party.

He must be a proper party.

In the case of a defendant, there must be a relief flowing from that defendant to the plaintiff.

The ultimate order or decree cannot be enforced without his presence in the matter.

His presence is necessary to enable the Court to effectively and completely adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the suit."

9. The Plaintiff/Respondent avers that the Applicant has no recognizable interest in the suit property and no orders have been claimed against it. On the other hand, the Applicant argues that the suit property traces its title to one originally held by them. The Applicant argues that it is a portion of this land they sold to the 1st Defendant that the Plaintiff is claiming.

10. Premised on this argument, it is discernible that the Plaintiff/Respondent does not have a direct claim against the Applicant. However, the bigger picture demonstrates otherwise, because the title the Plaintiff is challenging originates from the doorstep of the Applicant. For the Plaintiff’s case to succeed, proof must be made that the Applicant did not have a good title to pass to the 1st Defendant. It would be unfair to refuse the Applicant from defending what it sold to the 1st Defendant just because the Plaintiff has withdrawn the suit against it.

11. On whether this court can undo a notice of withdrawal, it is true that order 25 of the Civil Procedure Rules allows for withdrawal of suits subject to payment of costs. However, the withdrawal of suit is not a bar to applications under the provisions of Order 1 Rule 10 for a party seeking to join as long as the party demonstrates that it is a necessary party. Additionally, the court has no discretion where it appears there has been no proper service (Kanji Naran V Velji Ramji 1954 21 EACA 20).

12. Further, the Plaintiff argued that there was no judgment capable of being executed, hence no need for granting orders of stay of execution and/or setting aside of the judgment. I think the Applicant was taking precautions, having assumed that the judgment entered in 2022 was probably set aside only as against the 1st Defendant, who moved the court. It is clear that the judgment was set aside, and the Applicant required leave to file a statement of defence out of time.

13. Should this court grant the leave sought? The Plaintiff states that he withdrew the suit against the Applicant, inter alia, alleging that the Applicant had not been served with pleadings in this matter. Thus, the Plaintiff did not contest the allegation of lack of service upon the Applicant, who said they only learnt of this case through the 1st Defendant. The case may have been before the court for a long period, but the record does not show that the Applicant caused the delay.

14. The application was filed soon after learning of the existence of this case and before the file was reserved for judgment. It serves the interests of justice that for this dispute to be conclusively determined, all parties be given an opportunity to present their case. Therefore, I am persuaded to find that the application is merited.

15. In conclusion, the application dated 24th November, 2025 is allowed with costs to the Applicant. The Applicant is directed to file and serve its Statement of Defence, witness statements and documents within 21 days of this ruling. The Plaintiff shall file a response to the statement of defence and any additional documents within 15 days of service. The matter to be mentioned on 10th December, 2026 for further directions on hearing.

Dated, signed and delivered virtually at Kisii this 22nd of October, 2026.

A. OMOLLO

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder