Land law

Simiyu v Deputy Chairperson of the Rent Restriction Tribunal & another [2026] KEELC 7409 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Judicial Review Case E019 of 2024
Judgment date
22 October 2026
Judge(s)
LG Kimani

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This Judgment is in respect of the Notice of Motion dated 5th March 2026 filed by the Ex parte Applicant, Mercy Kagendo Simiyu, pursuant to leave granted by this Court on 29th January 2026. The application seeks judicial review orders as follows:

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The central issue for determination is whether the Rent Restriction Tribunal acted within its statutory jurisdiction when it issued the order of 4th July 2024 directing the Applicant to obtain alternative accommodation and deliver vacant possession of the suit premises by 4th August 2024. The Court must also determine whether the Applicant was denied a fair hearing and whether the remedies sought are available in the circumstances.

Paragraph 15 →

Decision / orders

In conclusion, the Court finds that the Applicant has established that the Rent Restriction Tribunal proceeded to determine the claim for possession without first ascertaining whether the premises fell within its statutory jurisdiction. The Notice of Motion dated 5th March 2026 is therefore allowed on that ground. The order issued by the Tribunal on 4th July 2024 is liable to be quashed by an order of Certiorari, and the Tribunal shall…

Paragraph 29 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

MILIMANI LAW COURTS

JUDICIAL REVIEW CASE NO. E019 OF 2024

IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION TO COMMENCE JUDICIAL REVIEW PROCEEDINGS

AND

IN THE MATTER OF THE RENT RESTRICTION ACT, CAP 296

AND

IN THE MATTER OF ARTICLE 162 (2) (b) OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA AND THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT ACT NO. 19 OF 2011

AND

IN THE MATTER OF: THE FAIR ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIONS ACT

AND

IN THE MATTER OF THE DECISION AND ORDER MADE EXPARTE BY THE DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE RENT RESTRICTION TRIBUNAL CASE NO. E534 OF 2024.

BETWEEN

MERCY KAGENDO SIMIYU……………………………………..APPLICANT DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE RENT

RESTRICTION TRIBUNAL……………………………………RESPONDENT

CONSOLATA NABWIRE ONYANGO........................ INTERESTED PARTY

JUDGEMENT

1. This Judgment is in respect of the Notice of Motion dated 5th March 2026 filed by the Ex parte Applicant, Mercy Kagendo Simiyu, pursuant to leave granted by this Court on 29th January 2026. The application seeks judicial review orders as follows:

1. THAT an order of PROHIBITION do issue prohibiting the Rent Restriction Tribunal from proceeding in any manner whatsoever with Rent Restriction Tribunal Case No. E534 of 2024 Consolata Nabwire Onyango vs Mercy Kagendo Simiyu.

2. THAT an order of CERTIORARI do issue to remove into this Honourable Court the decision of the Respondent and resultant Order of the Rent Restriction Tribunal issued on 4/7/2024 in respect of Nairobi Rent Restriction Tribunal Case No. E534 of 2024 between Consolata Nabwire Onyango vs Mercy Kagendo Simiyu.

3. Costs of Application be in the cause.

2. The substantive Motion is premised on the grounds set out on its face, the Statutory Statement and the Supporting Affidavit sworn by the Ex parte Applicant.

3. The Applicant states that the Interested Party commenced proceedings before the Tribunal through an application dated 14th March 2024, seeking vacant possession and eviction from Plot No. IR 105905, Syokimau Estate. On 4th July 2024, the Tribunal issued an ex parte order directing her to obtain alternative accommodation and deliver vacant possession by 4th August 2024, with the Officer Commanding Station (OCS), Syokimau Police Station, directed to ensure compliance.

4. The Applicant challenges the Tribunal’s jurisdiction on the ground that the alleged monthly rent of Kshs. 60,000 exceeded the statutory rent threshold of Kshs. 2,500 under the Rent Restriction Act. She contends that the Tribunal acted without jurisdiction by entertaining and determining the dispute without first establishing whether the premises fell within its statutory mandate, rendering the impugned order null and void.

5. The Applicant further maintains that no landlord-tenant relationship existed between her and the Interested Party, Consolata Nabwire Onyango. She asserts that the registered proprietor of the property is Mark Ouma Wandera, her husband from whom she is currently separated, and that she substantially contributed to the purchase and development of the property, including through loan facilities. She denies occupying the premises under a lease requiring her to pay the alleged monthly rent of Kshs. 60,000.

6. The Applicant contends that the Tribunal issued a final and prejudicial order without affording her an opportunity to be heard, contrary to the rules of natural justice and the requirements of fair administrative action. She maintains that the Tribunal had not lawfully established its jurisdiction before issuing the order and that the decision adversely affected her and her family.

7. The Applicant alleges that on 5th August 2024, at approximately 3.00 p.m., individuals accompanied by police officers entered the premises to enforce the impugned order and removed or damaged her household goods and belongings. She further alleges that her sister and house manager were assaulted and her eight-year-old daughter intimidated, causing loss, damage and distress to the family.

8. The Applicant maintains that unless the impugned proceedings and order are quashed and the Tribunal restrained from proceeding with the dispute, she will continue to suffer prejudice. She asserts that she has no other adequate remedy and consequently seeks judicial review orders to invalidate the proceedings and prevent further determination of the matter by the Tribunal.

9. The certified proceedings indicate that on 26th March 2024, the Tribunal, comprising Deputy Chairman J. K. Ikingi and Kirui, CC, recorded both parties as absent, certified the matter urgent and directed that it be served for an inter partes hearing, expressly noting that the orders sought were final in nature.

10. On 8th April 2024, counsel appeared for the Plaintiff/Applicant, while the Defendant/Respondent was absent. The Tribunal scheduled the matter for hearing on 30th April 2024 and directed counsel to serve and file hearing notices. On 20th April 2024, Mr. Rauto appeared for the landlord and informed the Tribunal that the tenant had accumulated rent arrears of Kshs. 300,000 for the period between December 2023 and April 2024, calculated at Kshs. 60,000 per month. Counsel stated that the landlord sought vacant possession rather than payment of the arrears.

11. Following the proceedings of 20th April 2024, the Tribunal directed the Plaintiff’s counsel to file and serve the tenancy agreement within seven days and ordered the Defendant to file and serve a defence and replying affidavit within fourteen days. The Plaintiff was granted a further fourteen days to respond, if necessary, and the Defendant was directed to continue paying rent as it fell due. The matter was scheduled for hearing on 4th July 2024.

12. On 4th July 2024, Mr. Rauto appeared for the landlord, while the Defendant was absent. Counsel informed the Tribunal that the Defendant had never entered appearance despite service of the relevant documents and that the rent arrears continued to accumulate. The Tribunal subsequently ordered the Defendant to obtain alternative accommodation and deliver vacant possession by 4th August 2024, directing the OCS Syokimau Police Station to enforce compliance. This order forms the subject of the Applicant’s judicial review challenge.

13. The Respondent and the Interested Party were served with the Notice of Motion herein and an affidavit of service by Penina Oloo Advocate sworn on 15th May 2026 was filed in Court. No response was filed and thus the Notice of Motion is deemed as undefended.

Analysis and Determination

14. The Court has considered the Notice of Motion dated 5th March 2026, the grounds in support, the Statutory Statement, the Supporting Affidavit and its annexures and the certified proceedings of the Rent Restriction Tribunal. The Applicant seeks judicial review orders of Certiorari and Prohibition on the ground that the Tribunal acted without jurisdiction and in breach of the requirements of procedural fairness.

15. The central issue for determination is whether the Rent Restriction Tribunal acted within its statutory jurisdiction when it issued the order of 4th July 2024 directing the Applicant to obtain alternative accommodation and deliver vacant possession of the suit premises by 4th August 2024. The Court must also determine whether the Applicant was denied a fair hearing and whether the remedies sought are available in the circumstances.

16. Section 2(1) of the Rent Restriction Act limits the application of the Act to dwelling-houses whose standard rent does not exceed Kshs. 2,500 per month, subject to the statutory exceptions. The Tribunal's jurisdiction therefore depends on the standard rent of the premises, rather than the agreed or alleged monthly rent alone.

17. Where a jurisdictional question arises, the Tribunal must first ascertain the standard rent and satisfy itself that the premises fall within the statutory threshold before determining the substantive dispute. This principle is supported by Johakim Abayo v Mokua Damacline Nyambita [2021] KEELC 4254 (KLR), where the Court emphasised that the Tribunal must assess the standard rent before assuming jurisdiction.

18. The Principle is also consistent with the decisions in Samuel Kamau Macharia & another v Kenya Commercial Bank Limited & 2 others [2012] eKLR, R v Karisa Chengo [2017] eKLR and Owners of Motor Vessel “Lillian S” v Caltex Oil (Kenya) Ltd [1989] KLR 1, which affirm that jurisdiction derives from the Constitution or legislation and cannot be assumed where it has not been conferred by law. The same principle was considered in Republic v Deputy Chairman, Rent Restriction Tribunal; Omondi (Ex parte Applicant); Mburu (Interested Party) [2024] KEELC 1420 (KLR).

19. In the present case, the proceedings of the Tribunal show that on 20th April 2024, the Tribunal was informed that the alleged monthly rent for the suit premises was Kshs. 60,000. The Tribunal directed the Interested Party's counsel to file and serve the tenancy agreement within seven days.

20. However, the record does not demonstrate that the Tribunal subsequently assessed or determined the standard rent, or made a finding that the premises fell within its statutory jurisdiction. Although the alleged rent of Kshs. 60,000 does not, by itself, conclusively establish the standard rent, it raised a jurisdictional question that the Tribunal was required to resolve before proceeding with the claim for possession.

21. Despite that unresolved question, the Tribunal proceeded on 4th July 2024 to issue the order directing the Applicant to obtain alternative accommodation and deliver vacant possession of the premises by 4th August 2024. In doing so, the Tribunal determined the substantive dispute without first establishing the jurisdictional foundation required under section 2(1)(c) of the Rent Restriction Act.

22. The Court therefore finds that the Tribunal acted without or in excess of its jurisdiction in issuing the impugned order.

23. On the question of procedural fairness, Article 47(1) of the Constitution guarantees every person the right to administrative action that is lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair. Section 4(3) of the Fair Administrative Action Act requires adequate notice and an opportunity to be heard where administrative action is likely to adversely affect a person's rights. However, the certified proceedings indicate that on 26th March 2024, the Tribunal directed service for an inter partes hearing because the orders sought were final in nature. On 8th April 2024, the matter was scheduled for hearing and service of hearing notices was directed. On 20th April 2024, the Applicant was directed to file and serve a defence and replying affidavit within fourteen days.

24. On 4th July 2024, the Tribunal recorded that the Applicant had never entered appearance despite service of the relevant documents. From the foregoing the Court is not satisfied that there is sufficient material establishing that the Applicant herein was not served with the application before the Tribunal or that the Applicant was prevented from participating in the proceedings.

25. Accordingly, the fact that the Tribunal proceeded in the Applicants absence does not, in the circumstances disclosed by the record, establish a denial of a fair hearing.

26. The Court therefore finds that the allegation of breach of natural justice has not been proved. This finding, however, does not cure the separate defect arising from the Tribunal's failure to establish its jurisdiction.

27. The order of 4th July 2024 is a completed decision that has been found to have been made without or in excess of jurisdiction. It is therefore amenable to Certiorari. Although the Applicant states that the order was enforced on 5th August 2024, the enforcement of an unlawful order does not validate it.

28. The Court is of the view that the order of Prohibition sought is appropriate to the extent that it prevents the Tribunal from proceeding to determine the substantive dispute without first establishing its jurisdiction in accordance with section 2(1)(c) of the Rent Restriction Act.

29. In conclusion, the Court finds that the Applicant has established that the Rent Restriction Tribunal proceeded to determine the claim for possession without first ascertaining whether the premises fell within its statutory jurisdiction. The Notice of Motion dated 5th March 2026 is therefore allowed on that ground. The order issued by the Tribunal on 4th July 2024 is liable to be quashed by an order of Certiorari, and the Tribunal shall be restrained by an order of Prohibition from proceeding to determine the substantive dispute.

30. Accordingly, the Notice of Motion dated 5th March 2026 is hereby allowed in the following terms:

1) THAT an order of PROHIBITION is hereby issued prohibiting the Rent Restriction Tribunal from proceeding in any manner whatsoever with Rent Restriction Tribunal Case No. E534 of 2024 Consolata Nabwire Onyango vs Mercy Kagendo Simiyu.

2) THAT an order of CERTIORARI is hereby issued to remove into this Court the decision of the Respondent and resultant Order of the Rent Restriction Tribunal issued on 4th July 2024 in respect of Nairobi Rent Restriction Tribunal Case No. E534 of 2024 between Consolata Nabwire Onyango vs Mercy Kagendo Simiyu.

3) The Applicant shall have the costs of these judicial review proceedings.

Delivered, dated and signed via Microsoft Teams this 22nd day of October 2026.

HON. L. G. KIMANI

JUDGE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

The Judgement is read in the presence of-

Mrs Oloo for Applicant

No appearance for Respondent.

No appearance for interested Party

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder