Background
The Applicant, Jimmy Sausi t/a Ochoki & Ochoki Associates Advocates, filed the Chamber Summons dated 22nd December 2025 seeking the following orders:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The Applicant, Jimmy Sausi t/a Ochoki & Ochoki Associates Advocates, filed the Chamber Summons dated 22nd December 2025 seeking the following orders:
Paragraph 1 →In the circumstances, the Court finds that the reference filed on 23rd December 2024 was filed outside the fourteen-day period stipulated in the order of 4th December 2024. The Applicant did not, therefore, comply with the deadline imposed by the Court. The remaining question is whether the late filing has been validly regularised by a subsequent order enlarging time or whether the Applicant has properly placed before the Court a basis…
Paragraph 46 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
MILIMANI LAW COURTS
ELC MISC. APPLICATION NO. E112 OF 2025
JIMMY SAUSI T/A OCHOKI & OCHOKI
ASSOCIATES ADVOCATES..............................................APPLICANT
VERSUS
KIHUMO PROPERTIES DEVELOPERS (K)
LIMITED………………………………………………….RESPONDENT
RULING
1. The Applicant, Jimmy Sausi t/a Ochoki & Ochoki Associates Advocates, filed the Chamber Summons dated 22nd December 2025 seeking the following orders:
1) Spent
2) Spent
3) Spent
4) THAT the ruling of the Honourable Taxing Master delivered on 25th February 2025, in so far as the same relates to the reasoning and determination pertaining to the of the Bill of Costs dated 24th April 2024, be set aside and/or vacated by way of reference and all consequential orders, be and are hereby set aside as the said ruling is anchored on a judgement whose determination was based on forged documents and signatures.
5) In the alternative to prayer 4 above, this Honourable Court exercises its inherent jurisdiction and refer the Bill of Costs dated 24th April 2024 to a different Taxing Officer for fits reconsideration and determination with proper directions thereto
6) THAT costs of the application be provided for.
2. The application is supported by the grounds set out on its face and the supporting affidavit of affidavit of Jimmy Sausi. The Applicant’s case is that the Respondent’s Bill of Costs dated 24th April 2024 arose from the judgment in ELC Suit No. 709 of 2016, delivered by Justice E.K. Wabwoto on 6th July 2023 in favour of the Respondent. The Bill of Costs was subsequently taxed on 25th February 2025 at Kshs. 956,629.56.
3. The Applicant contends that the judgment in the primary suit was substantially founded on a sale agreement which he alleges contained forged signatures and stamp impressions and bore inconsistent dates, namely 29th October 2004 and 29 October 2014. He further contends that Ochoki & Ochoki Associates Advocates was only registered in 2009, and could therefore not have prepared an agreement purportedly executed in 2004.
4. The Applicant states that the issue of the authenticity of the documents was raised during the proceedings in the primary suit. By a Notice of Motion dated 27th February 2020, the Applicant sought orders for the impugned sale agreement and a transfer dated 8th April 2015 to be subjected to forensic examination by the DCI Kiambu. He states that Lady Justice L. Komingoi, on 23rd September 2020, directed that the documents be forwarded for forensic examination.
5. According to the Applicant, the matter was subsequently mentioned on 17th February 2021 and 21st July 2021, and was again scheduled for mention on 5th October 2021, as the forensic report had not been received. He states that the documents were eventually forwarded to the DCI on 12th October 2021 and that the forensic report was prepared on 7th September 2023. His contention is that the report established that the signatures and stamp impressions appearing on the impugned sale agreement were forgeries. The report, however, was allegedly available only after judgment had already been delivered on 6th July 2023.
6. The Applicant therefore contends that the judgment upon which the Respondent’s Bill of Costs was founded was based on a document which was subsequently subjected to forensic examination and allegedly found to contain forged signatures and stamp impressions. He argues that the Taxing Master ought to have taken the alleged forensic evidence into account before proceeding with the taxation.
7. The Applicant further challenges the taxation on the ground that the Taxing Master failed to consider the alleged forensic evidence, the registration status of the Applicant’s law firm, and the affidavits of Dennis Okioi Mosoti and Peter Kihara Ndiba. He contends that the said affidavits demonstrate the circumstances in which monies were paid into his client account and subsequently distributed to persons whom he identifies as agents and/or directors of the Respondent, including James Njogu Njenga and Francis Mwangi Maina.
8. The Applicant also questions the existence of a valid advocate-client relationship between himself and the Respondent, contending that there was no company resolution or minutes appointing him to act for the Respondent. He consequently argues that the Taxing Master failed to properly consider the evidence relevant to the alleged advocate-client relationship.
9. On the quantum of the Bill, the Applicant challenges, among other items, Kshs. 71,973 allowed as disbursements; the application of 2% to Kshs. 19 million and 1.5% to Kshs. 8,322,904, resulting in Kshs. 124,843.56; attendance fees of Kshs. 1,900; and Kshs. 208,281 awarded as getting-up fees. He contends that the Taxing Master either failed to properly consider the evidence before her or arrived at an erroneous assessment of the items in the Bill.
10. The Applicant further states that he has filed Civil Appeal No. E786 of 2023 challenging the judgment in the primary suit and seeking, among other reliefs, admission of the forensic report and other documents as additional evidence. He maintains that the appeal is arguable and that the outcome may affect the judgment upon which the Respondent’s costs are founded.
11. On the question of stay, the Applicant invokes Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules and contends that unless execution is stayed, he will suffer substantial loss by being required to pay the taxed sum of Kshs. 956,629.56 before the pending proceedings are determined. He argues that recovery of the amount may become difficult if the judgment in the primary suit is subsequently overturned.
12. The Applicant consequently urges the Court to stay execution, set aside the Taxing Master’s ruling and consequential orders, or, in the alternative, remit the Bill of Costs to a different Taxing Officer for fresh taxation.
Respondent’s Replying Affidavit
13. The application is opposed through the Replying Affidavit sworn by James Njenga Njogu sworn on 2nd February 2026, a director of the Respondent, who states that he is duly authorised to swear the affidavit on behalf of the Respondent.
14. The Respondent contends that the application is misconceived, misplaced, frivolous, vexatious and an abuse of the Court process, and should be dismissed with costs. It maintains that the Applicant has filed numerous applications with the intention of delaying execution of the judgment delivered in ELC/709/2016.
15. The Respondent argues that the present proceedings ought properly to remain a Reference against the decision of the Taxing Master and that the Applicant is improperly attempting to transform the miscellaneous application into a substantive suit by introducing allegations concerning the merits of the judgment in the primary suit, alleged forgery and the conduct of the trial Judge.
16. The deponent further contends that the Applicant’s allegations against Justice E.K. Wabwoto, including the assertion that the Judge was “bent”, are serious and unsupported, and ought not to be entertained without evidence. He similarly denies the Applicant’s allegations concerning alleged threats to Peter Kihara Ndiba and the alleged death of Thomas Ontweke, describing them as speculative and unsubstantiated.
17. The Respondent denies the Applicant’s allegations that the Respondent’s directors received or distributed monies through the Applicant’s client account. In particular, the deponent denies knowing Dennis Okoi Mosoti and Peter Kihara Ndiba or receiving monies from the Applicant through them. He contends that the allegations are intended to tarnish the reputation of the Respondent’s directors.
18. The Respondent maintains that the Applicant was adjudged in ELC/709/2016 to have defrauded the Respondent and argues that the Applicant is merely raising the allegations of forgery and other matters after judgment in an attempt to delay execution and avoid satisfying the judgment debt.
19. The Respondent further states that Civil Appeal No. E786 of 2023 has remained inactive since November 2024, when the Court of Appeal allegedly allowed the Applicant’s application, and faults the Applicant for failing to take steps to progress the appeal. It is therefore contended that the pending appeal is being relied upon as another means of delaying the Respondent from enjoying the fruits of its judgment.
20. The Respondent asserts that the Applicant had sufficient opportunity during the hearing of ELC/709/2016, which had been pending since 2016, to present his defence and any forensic evidence upon which he now relies. It is therefore argued that the Applicant cannot, after judgment, continue introducing allegations and applications concerning matters which ought to have been dealt with in the primary suit.
21. The Respondent further relies on the principle of finality of litigation, contending that the Applicant has subjected the primary suit to numerous applications and appeals since judgment was delivered and that the continued delay has prejudiced the Respondent, which has been unable to enjoy the fruits of the judgment.
22. The Respondent therefore maintains that the present application is an afterthought and a further attempt to circumvent the judgment in ELC/709/2016, delay execution and frustrate recovery of the judgment debt. It urges the Court to dismiss the application with costs and allow the Reference to proceed in accordance with its proper scope.
Applicant’s Written Submissions
23. The Applicant submitted that the application arose from the Taxing Master’s ruling delivered on 25th February 2025, which permitted the Respondent to proceed with execution of the decree and Notice to Show Cause. He subsequently filed the present Reference and obtained interim status quo orders on 3rd January 2026.
24. The Applicant sought a stay of execution, the setting aside of the Taxing Master’s ruling in respect of the Bill of Costs dated 24th April 2024, or, in the alternative, the referral of the Bill of Costs to a different Taxing Officer for fresh taxation.
25. The Applicant’s principal contention was that the judgment in ELC No. 709 of 2016, upon which the Bill of Costs was founded, was based on forged documents.
26. The Applicant submitted that fraud vitiates judicial proceedings and that a judgment founded on forged documents cannot properly sustain taxation and enforcement of costs. He relied on Viran T/A Kisumu Beach Resort v Phoenix of East Africa Assurance Company Ltd (2004) 2 KLR 269 on the standard of proof applicable to allegations of fraud, and Wilfred N. Konosi t/a Konosi & Co. Advocates v Famco Limited [2017] eKLR on the advocate-client relationship as the basis of a valid bill of costs.
27. The Applicant further relied on Fredrick Otieno Outa v Jared Odoyo Okello & Others [2022] KESC and Rafai Gondaba Patel v Lalji Mkakuji (1957) EA 314 in support of his argument that decisions founded on fraud or forged documents may be set aside and that a taxing decision may be interfered with where its underlying foundation is fraudulent. He also cited GroundUp News NPC & 2 Others v South African Legal Practice Council & 4 Others [2023] ZAGPJHC 559 as persuasive authority on the investigation of allegations of forged signatures.
28. The Applicant maintained that the pending Civil Appeal No. E786 of 2023, together with the forensic report and other alleged new evidence, warranted intervention by the Court to prevent enforcement of costs arising from a judgment whose validity remained under challenge.
29. The Applicant consequently urged the Court to allow the application, stay execution, set aside the Taxing Master’s ruling and consequential execution proceedings, or alternatively remit the Bill of Costs to a different Taxing Officer for fresh consideration, with costs of the application.
Respondent’s Submissions
30. Counsel for the Respondent submitted that the Applicant had failed to establish any legal basis for interfering with the Taxing Master’s ruling or for granting a stay of execution. It argued that the application improperly sought to challenge the judgment in ELC No. 709 of 2016 through taxation proceedings.
31. On interference with taxation, the Respondent submitted that a taxing officer’s decision may only be disturbed where an error of principle is demonstrated or the taxation is manifestly excessive or inadequate. Relying on First American Bank of Kenya Ltd v Shah & Others and Kipkorir, Titoo & Kiara Advocates v Deposit Protection Fund Board, the Respondent contended that the Applicant had not identified any specific error in the application of the relevant scale, formula or principles of taxation.
32. The Respondent maintained that the allegations of forgery, fraud and reliance on a forensic report obtained after judgment concerned the merits of the underlying judgment delivered on 6th July 2023 and fell outside the scope of the taxation reference. It argued that those matters should be pursued in the pending appeal and could not, without more, constitute an error of principle by the Taxing Master.
33. On stay of execution, the Respondent relied on Order 42 Rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules and submitted that the Applicant had failed to satisfy the cumulative requirements of substantial loss, absence of unreasonable delay and security for the due performance of the decree. It contended that the Applicant had not demonstrated, by evidence, that execution would occasion substantial loss or render the appeal nugatory, and had neither offered nor proposed security. Reliance was placed on Kenya Shell Limited v Benjamin Karuga Kibiru & Another [1986] KECA 94 (KLR), James Kariuki Kihara v Daniel Wokabi Mathenge t/a Wokabi Mathenge & Co. Advocates [2020] KEHC 5209 (KLR) and Focin Motorcycle Co. Limited v Ann Wambui Wangui & Another [2018] KEHC 8358 (KLR).
34. The Respondent further submitted that the application constituted a collateral attack on the subsisting judgment in ELC No. 709 of 2016, pursuant to which its Party and Party Bill of Costs was taxed on 25th February 2025. It argued that the Applicant could not use a taxation reference to reopen factual and evidentiary issues already determined in the primary suit, particularly when an appeal against that judgment was pending before the Court of Appeal. It relied on Uhuru Highway Development Ltd v Central Bank of Kenya & Another [1996] KECA 102 (KLR) and Multichoice (Kenya) Limited v Wananchi Group (Kenya) Limited & 2 Others [2020] eKLR.
35. The Respondent contended that, as the successful litigant, it was entitled to the fruits of its judgment and to proceed with execution of the taxed costs in the absence of exceptional circumstances justifying a stay. Relying on Machira t/a Machira & Co Advocates v East African Standard [2002] KEHC 1167 (KLR), it maintained that the Applicant had not demonstrated sufficient grounds to suspend enforcement of the decree. It further characterised the application as an abuse of the court process for seeking to relitigate allegations of fraud and forgery rather than identify errors in taxation.
36. On costs, the Respondent relied on Section 27(1) of the Civil Procedure Act and submitted that costs should follow the event, given that the application was misconceived and had occasioned it unnecessary legal expenses.
37. The Respondent therefore urged the Court to dismiss the Chamber Summons dated 6th January 2026 with costs, uphold the Taxing Master’s ruling delivered on 25th February 2025, and allow execution of the Certificate of Taxation and consequential decree to proceed.
Analysis and Determination
38. The Court has considered the Chamber Summons application, the replying affidavit filed and submissions by counsel for the Parties. The issues that arise for determination at this stage are:
i. Whether the Reference was filed within the period granted by the Court?
ii. Whether the present Reference was properly instituted as a fresh Miscellaneous Application separate from ELC Suit No. 709 of 2016.
iii. Whether the application is properly confined to the taxation dispute?
iv. Whether the allegations concerning forgery, the forensic report, the alleged absence of an advocate-client relationship and the pending appeal justify setting aside the taxation.
v. Whether the Applicant has demonstrated an error of principle or other lawful basis for interference with the Taxing Officer’s decision.
vi. Whether the Applicant has satisfied the conditions for stay of execution.
vii. Whether the alternative prayer for fresh taxation before a different Taxing Officer is merited.
viii. Who should bear the costs of the application?
Before the court deals with the substantive issues raised in the application herein,
the Court must deal with procedural issues arising from the filing of the chamber
summons dated 22/12/25
Whether the Reference was filed within the period granted by the Court?
39. The Court notes that the ruling by the Taxing Master was delivered on 25th February 2025 while the Chamber summons herein though dated 22nd December 2025 was filed in Court on 23rd December 2025. The Applicant made an application for enlargement of time through a Chamber Summons dated 30th April 2025 and the Court, having considered the explanation advanced for the initial delay, exercised its discretion in favour of the Applicant and in a ruling delivered on 4th December 2026, expressly ordered that:
“Leave to file reference out of time is granted. Reference should be filed within 14 days.”
40. Did the Applicant comply with the above order of this Honourable Court granting leave to file a reference out of time and directing that the reference be filed within fourteen (14) days? If not, what are the legal consequences of such non-compliance.
41. The applicable law is found in paragraph 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order, which governs objections to decisions of taxing officers and references arising from taxation of bills of costs. Paragraph 11(1) provides for the giving of written notice of objection to the taxing officer within fourteen days of the decision on taxation, while paragraph 11(2) provides for the subsequent reference to a judge. Of particular relevance is paragraph 11(4), which empowers the Court, in its discretion, to enlarge the time fixed under subparagraphs (1) and (2) for taking any step. The provision expressly permits an application for enlargement to be made even after the prescribed time has expired.
42. The computation of time is governed by Section 57(a) of the Interpretation and General Provisions Act, Cap. 2, which provides that, in computing a period of days from the occurrence of an event, the day on which the event occurs is excluded unless a contrary intention appears. Applying that provision to the order made on 4th December 2024, the first day was 5th December 2024 and the fourteenth day was 18th December 2024. The reference filed on 23rd December 2024 was consequently filed five days after the period stipulated by the Court had expired.
43. It follows that the Applicant did not comply with the express terms of the order made on 4th December 2024. The grant of leave cannot reasonably be construed as an open-ended authorisation to file the reference at any subsequent date. The Applicant was bound to comply with the period imposed by the Court or seek a further enlargement of time in accordance with the law. The Applicant did not seek a further enlargement of time.
44. In Chaudhri & Associates v Lady Lori (K) Limited [2025] KEHC 6573 (KLR), the High Court considered the procedural requirements governing applications for enlargement of time under paragraph 11(4) of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order and emphasised the importance of following the prescribed procedure. The decision underscores that a party seeking to file a reference outside the applicable period must comply with the requirements governing enlargement of time and cannot automatically rely on the general provisions of Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution to cure a procedural defect.
45. Further, in Nderitu & Waturu Associates Advocates v Peter Kagunyu Kiragu [2021] KEELC 1941 (KLR), the Court considered the consequences of non-compliance with the timelines prescribed under paragraph 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order. The decision supports the proposition that compliance with the prescribed timelines is material to the competence of a taxation reference and that, in the absence of an effective extension of time, non-compliance may render the proceedings defective.
46. In the circumstances, the Court finds that the reference filed on 23rd December 2024 was filed outside the fourteen-day period stipulated in the order of 4th December 2024. The Applicant did not, therefore, comply with the deadline imposed by the Court. The remaining question is whether the late filing has been validly regularised by a subsequent order enlarging time or whether the Applicant has properly placed before the Court a basis for further enlargement.
47. Since no further enlargement has been granted and no proper application for enlargement is before the Court, the Court finds that the reference was filed outside the time stipulated in its order of 4 December 2024. The reference is found to have been incompetent and is liable to be struck out with costs.
48. The Court acknowledges that the Respondent did not raise the five-day delay in its opposition. That omission is relevant to the procedural history, but it does not alter the terms of the Court’s order or itself amount to an extension of time. The Court must determine whether the proceedings before it comply with the applicable procedural requirements, even where a party has not raised the point.
49. Ordinarily, where a Reference is not properly before the Court, the Court should not proceed as though the procedural defect has been cured. The merits cannot retrospectively regularise a Reference filed outside the period granted by the Court.
50. Nevertheless, the Applicant has sought several forms of relief, including stay of execution and setting aside of the taxation. The parties have also placed substantive arguments before the Court concerning the scope of a taxation Reference, the alleged forgery, the forensic report, the challenged taxation items and the requirements for stay of execution.
51. In the interests of clarity, I will therefore consider the substantive grounds in the alternative.
Whether the Reference was properly instituted as a fresh Miscellaneous Application?
52. Regarding whether the reference can be lodged by way of another fresh
proceeding other than that in which the taxation decision was made, the applicants argues that there is no express procedural prescription in paragraph 11(2) of how to invoke the court’s jurisdiction which leaves it open and one can file a miscellaneous application. The jurisdiction of this court under rule 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order is that the court exercises its jurisdiction on the platform of the suit in which the impugned decision of the Taxing Officer was made. It is not exercised in a separate or fresh suit. Exercise of that jurisdiction is invoked through the filing and service of an objection under rule 11 (1). Upon filing of the Notice of Objection within the suit, and upon service of the Notice, the Objector is required to file a reference to the Judge by way of Chamber Summons within the same suit. The Judge thereafter exercises jurisdiction under rule 11 on the platform of the suit in which the impugned decision of the Taxing Officer was made.
53. This was addressed in the case of F.A. Badia & Company Advocates v Malambu (Miscellaneous Application E166 of 2022) [2024] KEHC 10268 (KLR) (Family) (13 August 2024) Ruling) where the court stated as follows;
It is my understanding and I hold the view that the objection of the decision of the taxing officer envisaged in paragraph 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order should be filed in the same cause where the bill of costs was taxed.
54. In the current application, the applicant has filed a fresh and a different cause where this court will not have the benefit of making reference to the bill of costs and the proceedings being challenged.
55. The applicant has approached this court through the wrong procedure in which situation the court will find it hard to make decision on the issues placed before it.
56. A reference is not an appeal where separate proceedings are taken in a different file. The bills of costs are for all purposes taxed in the High Court save that they are done by a Deputy Registrar and not a Judge. References are referred to the same court but before a Judge. Letting parties open fresh files in matters of references will result to convolution of proceedings and most likely compromise dispensation and administration of justice.
57. Similarly, in Kimatta & Co Advocates v Joyce Wambui Jarvis [2005] eKLR the court held a similar view and stated
“I have carefully considered the submissions that were advanced by both counsel.
It is not in dispute that under paragraph 11(4) of the Advocates Remuneration Order, this court has power to enlarge time within which an applicant can file a reference to the High Court arising out of a taxation.
A proper reading of the entire paragraph 11 reveals that that such an application as envisaged under sub-paragraph (4) ought to be filed in the same cause under which the taxation was done.
under sub-paragraph (1) the party who objects to the decision of the taxing officer is given 14 days after the decision to give notice in writing to the taxing officer of the items of taxation which he objects to and then under sub-paragraph (2) the taxing officer records and forwards to the objector the reasons for his decision and the objector may, within 14 days from the date of receipt of the reasons apply to a Judge by Chamber Summons, setting out the grounds of his objection. Then we now come to subparagraph (4) by which a party who has not been able to comply with the time limits as set out by sub-paragraphs 1 or 2 can file an application for extension of time.It does not require to be stated that the application under sub-paragraph (4) has to be made in the same file or cause under which the objection was made in the first place, it is logical. The application has to be made in the cause under which the taxation was done so that the Judge, in exercising his discretion one way or the other can see when the objection as required under paragraph 11(1) was made and the sequence of other events that followed thereafter in order to determine whether there are good grounds upon which an extension of time can be allowed under paragraph 11(4).
I therefore hold that it was improper for the applicant to commence this application by way of a different miscellaneous civil application."
58. Accordingly, the Chamber Summons was not properly instituted as Reference under Paragraph 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order.
Whether the application is properly confined to the taxation dispute
59. The Applicant seeks to set aside the Taxing Officer’s decision substantially on the ground that the judgment in ELC Suit No. 709 of 2016 was founded on a sale agreement allegedly containing forged signatures and stamp impressions.
60. A Reference under paragraph 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order is directed at the Taxing Officer’s decision. Its purpose is to determine whether the taxation was conducted in accordance with the applicable remuneration scale and legal principles. It is not an appeal against the judgment from which the costs arose.
61. The judgment in the primary suit was delivered on 6th July 2023. The Bill of Costs was subsequently taxed on 25th February 2025. Unless and until the judgment or the order for costs is set aside, stayed or varied by a court with jurisdiction to do so, the taxation proceeds on the basis of the subsisting order for costs.
62. The Applicant’s allegations concerning the authenticity of the sale agreement, the circumstances in which the transaction was undertaken, the registration of his firm, the evidence of witnesses and the conduct of the trial principally concern the merits of the primary suit. They do not, without more, establish that the Taxing Officer applied the wrong remuneration scale, miscalculated a particular item or otherwise committed an error of principle in assessing costs.
63. The Applicant has also invoked the appellate jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal in Civil Appeal No. E786 of 2023. Questions concerning the admission of additional evidence, the alleged effect of the forensic report and the correctness of the findings in the primary judgment fall to be considered through the appropriate appellate process.
64. The Court cannot use a taxation Reference as a substitute for that appeal. Nor can the allegations against the trial court be determined in these proceedings merely because the judgment underlies the taxed costs.
65. The Court finds in the alternative, that the attempt to reopen the merits of the primary judgment through the taxation proceedings is not a proper ground for setting aside the Taxing Officer’s decision.
66. The Applicant places considerable reliance on the forensic report dated 7th September 2023, which he alleges established that the signatures and stamp impressions on the impugned sale agreement were made by different authors or instruments. He contends that the report was not available when judgment was delivered on 6th July 2023 and that its contents may materially affect Civil Appeal No. E786 of 2023.
Whether the Taxing Officer’s decision discloses an error of principle
66. The principles governing interference with taxation are settled. In First American
Bank of Kenya Ltd v Shah & Others (2002) 1 EA 64, the court stated as follows:
…
“this court cannot interfere with the taxing officer’s decision on taxation unless it is shown that either the decision was based on an error of principle, or the fee awarded was so manifestly excessive as to justify an inference that it was based on an error of principle. (See Steel & Petroleum (e.a) Ltd Vs. Uganda Sugar Factory (Supra). Of course.
…
If the court considers that the decision of the Taxing Officer discloses errors of principle, the normal practice is to remit it back to the Taxing Officer for re-assessment unless the Judge is satisfied that the error cannot materially have affected the assessment. (see Nanyuki Esso Service V Touring Cars Ltd; Steel & Petroleum (e.a.) Ltd V Uganda Sugar Factory; Thomas James Arthur V Nyeri Electricity Undertakers And Joreth V Kigano & Associates). However, the Judge does have jurisdiction and it is within his discretion to reassess the bill himself; (See Steel & Petroleum (E.A.) Ltd and Thomas James Arthur). The court is not entitled to upset a taxation because in its opinion, the amount awarded was high (See STeel Construction & Petroleum Engineering (e.a.) Ltd. The other general principle is that it is within the discretion of the Taxing Officer to increase or reduce the instruction fees and that the amount of the increase or reduction is discretionary. (See Thomas James Arthur V Nyeri Electricity Undertakers). In that respect, I must reject the submission made on behalf of the third defendant that the taxing officer has no discretion to reduce the basic instruction fees. On the contrary, I accept the submission made on behalf of the plaintiff that such discretion exists and that the only fees which cannot be reduced are those in respect of which it is provided that the amount thereof shall not be less than what is prescribed. An example is schedule VI (1) (g) (i): the instruction fees in matrimonial causes.”
67. The Court of Appeal reaffirmed the restricted nature of that jurisdiction in Kipkorir, Titoo & Kiara Advocates v Deposit Protection Fund Board [2005] KECA 325 (KLR), the court stated that:
“On a reference to a judge from the taxation by the Taxing Officer, the judge will not normally interfere with the exercise of discretion by the taxing officer unless the taxing officer, erred in principle in assessing the costs. In Arthur v Nyeri Electricity Undertaking [1961] EA 497, the predecessor of this Court said at page 492 paragraph I:
“where there has been an error in principle the court will interfere; but questions solely of quantum are regarded as matters with which the taxing officers are particularly fitted to deal and the court will interfere only in exceptional cases”.
68. These principles recognise that taxation is entrusted in the first instance to the Taxing Officer, who must apply the relevant remuneration scale and exercise judicial discretion in assessing costs properly recoverable. A judge hearing a Reference does not simply substitute a preferred figure for the assessment made by the Taxing Officer.
69. The ruling under challenge indicates that the subject-matter value was assessed at Kshs. 28,322,904, based on the amount reflected in the judgment in the primary suit. The Taxing Officer calculated the instruction fees as follows:
a. Kshs. 120,000 for the first Kshs. 1,000,000;
b. Kshs. 380,000 at 2% of the next Kshs. 19,000,000; and
c. Kshs. 124,843.56 at 1.5% of the remaining Kshs. 8,322,904.
d. The total instruction fees were therefore Kshs. 624,843.56.
70. The Taxing Officer further allowed getting-up fees of Kshs. 208,281, equivalent to one-third of the instruction fees. The ruling records that certain items were disallowed for want of proof and that specified attendance items were allowed at the amounts stated in the ruling.
71. The Court has looked at the Judgment of Wabwoto J. dated 6/7/2023 and the orders made were
“The court enters judgement for the Plaintiff against the Defendant as follows;
(a) A declaration that the Defendant acted fraudulently with the sole intention of defrauding the Plaintiff.
(b) Refund of Ksh. 28, 322, 904.
(c) Costs of the suit.
72. The Applicant challenges several specific items, including Kshs. 71,973 allowed as disbursements; the calculation yielding Kshs. 124,843.56; attendance fees of Kshs. 1,900; and getting-up fees of Kshs. 208,281.
73. Identification of the disputed items is necessary, but it is not, by itself, proof of an error of principle. The Applicant must demonstrate how the Taxing Officer misapplied the applicable scale, allowed an item not recoverable under the applicable law, failed to consider a material factor or arrived at an assessment so manifestly excessive that an error of principle may properly be inferred.
74. As regards the instruction fees, the Applicant must show that the applicable scale was incorrectly applied or that the subject-matter value was wrongly determined. The fact that the Taxing Officer calculated a percentage of the relevant value does not, without an identified error in the applicable scale or calculation, establish that the assessment was unlawful.
75. As regards getting-up fees, the Applicant must demonstrate that the legal basis for allowing the fee was absent or that the Taxing Officer exercised discretion on an erroneous basis. A disagreement with the amount allowed does not, by itself, justify interference.
76. The same principle applies to attendance fees. The Applicant must identify the relevant entry and demonstrate that the fee allowed was inconsistent with the applicable remuneration scale or unsupported by the record. The mere assertion that Kshs. 1,900 was excessive is not sufficient.
77. As regards the Kshs. 71,973 allowed as disbursements, the relevant question is whether the claimed disbursements were properly chargeable and supported by the material presented at taxation. That question requires examination of the Bill of Costs, the supporting vouchers or receipts, and the Taxing Officer’s reasons relating to those entries. The total amount, standing alone, does not establish that the disbursements were improperly allowed.
78. The Applicant’s allegations concerning the underlying sale agreement do not answer those questions. Even if the Applicant disputes the judgment from which the costs arose, he must still demonstrate an error in the taxation itself. On the material presented, the Applicant has not established that the Taxing Officer adopted the wrong scale, miscalculated the disputed items or otherwise exercised discretion on an erroneous principle.
79. I therefore find, in the alternative, that the Applicant has not demonstrated a sufficient basis for setting aside the Taxing Officer’s ruling or remitting the Bill of Costs for fresh taxation.
Whether the alleged absence of an advocate-client relationship affects the
taxation
80. The Applicant also questions whether a valid advocate-client relationship existed between himself and the Respondent, contending that there was no company resolution or minutes formally appointing him to act for the Respondent.
81. The nature of the Bill of Costs is material. The present dispute concerns the Respondent’s Party and Party Bill of Costs arising from ELC Suit No. 709 of 2016. A Party and Party Bill of Costs is distinct from an Advocate and Client Bill of Costs. The former concerns costs recoverable by one litigant from another pursuant to a court order, while the latter concerns remuneration payable by a client to an advocate.
82. The question whether a company resolution or other document formally appointed the Applicant as the Respondent’s advocate does not, by itself, determine whether the Respondent is entitled to Party and Party costs awarded in the primary suit. The entitlement to those costs arises from the subsisting order for costs and is not automatically extinguished by a dispute concerning an advocate-client retainer.
83. If the Applicant contends that the judgment or the order for costs was obtained through fraud, or that the underlying proceedings were fundamentally defective, the appropriate remedy must be pursued in proceedings competent to determine those matters. The present Reference cannot be converted into a trial of the alleged retainer, fraud or conduct of the parties.
84. The court therefore finds, that the alleged absence of a company resolution or formal appointment does not, establish an error of principle in the taxation of the Respondent’s Party and Party Bill of Costs.
Whether the forensic report and pending appeal justify setting aside the
Taxation
85. However, an allegation of forgery is not equivalent to a judicial determination that forgery occurred or that a subsisting judgment is invalid. The Court must distinguish between evidence which a party alleges supports an appeal and a determination by the competent court of the legal consequences of that evidence.
86. The Applicant’s contention that the forensic report should be admitted as additional evidence is one of the matters he says is pending before the Court of Appeal. It would be inappropriate for this Court, in a taxation Reference, to pre-empt that determination or to decide the effect of the report on the findings made in the primary suit.
87. The pending appeal does not automatically stay execution or proceedings equally, its existence does not automatically invalidate the certificate of taxation or the Taxing Officer’s decision. Unless an appropriate stay or other order is granted by a competent court, the subsisting judgment and consequential costs order remain operative.
88. The forensic report may be relevant to the appellate proceedings to the extent that it is properly before the appellate court and admitted or considered in accordance with the applicable law. Its alleged contents do not, without a demonstrated error in taxation or an order affecting the judgment and costs, justify setting aside the Taxing Officer’s decision.
89. I therefore find, that the forensic report and the pendency of Civil Appeal No. E786 of 2023 do not, on the material before this Court, provide a sufficient basis for setting aside the taxation or remitting the Bill of Costs for fresh taxation.
Whether stay of execution is merited
90. The Applicant seeks a stay of execution of the decree arising from the Taxing Officer’s ruling pending determination of the application and a further stay pending determination of the Reference. The Court is of the view that prayer 2 and 3 seeking stay of execution are spent for the reason that they are sought pending inter partes hearing of the application herein.
91. Further the prayer for stay pending determination of the Reference is affected by the finding that the Reference was filed outside the period granted by the Court and has not been regularised. In any event, the Applicant must establish the applicable legal threshold for stay.
92. Order 42 Rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules requires an applicant to demonstrate that substantial loss may result unless the order is made, that the application has been made without unreasonable delay, and that such security as the Court orders for the due performance of the decree has been provided. These requirements are cumulative.
93. In Kenya Shell Limited v Benjamin Karuga Kibiru & Another [1986] KECA 94 (KLR), the Court of Appeal emphasised the importance of demonstrating substantial loss in an application for stay. The fact that execution may proceed does not, without more, establish the required loss.
94. Similarly, in James Wangalwa & Another v Agnes Naliaka Cheseto [2012] eKLR, the Court explained that execution is a lawful process and that an applicant must establish additional circumstances showing that execution would create a state of affairs that would irreparably affect the essential substance of the appeal.
95. The Applicant contends that payment of Kshs. 956,629.56 may result in substantial loss because recovery could become difficult if the judgment in the primary suit is overturned. However, the material placed before the Court does not demonstrate, by specific evidence, that the Respondent would be unable to refund the money if the Applicant ultimately succeeds. Nor has the Applicant established that payment of the taxed costs would render the appeal nugatory.
96. The Applicant’s concern that recovery may become difficult remains speculative in the absence of supporting evidence. A general apprehension of difficulty in recovering money is not a substitute for proof of the likelihood of substantial loss.
97. The Applicant has also not demonstrated that security for the due performance of the decree has been offered or provided. Security protects the successful party while preserving the possibility of meaningful appellate relief. In Focin Motorcycle Co. Limited v Ann Wambui Wangui & Another [2018] KEHC 8358 (KLR), the Court considered the requirement of security in exercising discretion under Order 42 Rule 6.
98. The Court has also considered procedural history of the matter. The Applicant obtained leave to file the Reference on 4th December 2025, but failed to file it within the fourteen days expressly granted. No further extension was sought or obtained, and no explanation has been placed before the Court for the default.
99. The Respondent, as the successful party in the taxation proceedings, is ordinarily entitled to pursue lawful execution unless a sufficient legal basis for withholding it is established. In Machira t/a Machira & Co Advocates v East African Standard [2002] KEHC 1167 (KLR), the Court addressed the entitlement of a successful litigant to the fruits of the judgment and the need for a sufficient basis to interfere with that entitlement.
100. Balancing the parties’ respective positions, the Applicant has not established the necessary basis for a stay of execution. The pending appeal and the allegations concerning the forensic report do not, without the required evidence and compliance with the applicable procedural requirements, warrant suspension of execution.
101. I therefore find, that the substantive prayer for stay of execution is not merited.
Who should bear the costs?
102. Section 27(1) of the Civil Procedure Act provides that costs are in the discretion of the Court, subject to the principle that costs ordinarily follow the event unless the Court, for good reason, orders otherwise.
103. The Respondent opposed the application and seeks dismissal with costs. The Applicant has not succeeded in establishing a basis for the substantive reliefs sought. There is no sufficient reason on the material before the Court to depart from the ordinary rule on costs.
104. For the foregoing reasons, the Court finds that the Reference dated 22nd December 2025 and filed on 23rd December 2025 was filed outside the fourteen-day period granted by the Court on 4th December 2025. No further enlargement of time was sought or obtained, and no explanation has been offered for the failure to comply with the order.
105. The Court has nevertheless considered the substantive grounds in the alternative. The Applicant has not demonstrated a sufficient error of principle to warrant setting aside the Taxing Officer’s ruling, remitting the Bill of Costs for fresh taxation or granting a stay of execution.
106. Accordingly, the Court makes the following orders:
a. The Chamber Summons/Reference dated 22nd December 2025 and filed on 23rd December 2025 is struck out for having been filed outside the period granted by the Court, without a further order enlarging time.
b. The prayer to set aside or vacate the Taxing Officer’s Ruling dated 25th February 2025 and the consequential orders is declined.
c. The prayer to remit the Bill of Costs dated 24th April 2024 to a different Taxing Officer for fresh taxation is declined.
d. The prayer for stay of execution pending determination of the Reference is declined.
e. Any interim stay or status quo order issued in these proceedings shall cease to have effect upon delivery of this ruling, subject to any other subsisting order of a competent court.
f. The Respondent shall have the costs of the application.
It is so ordered.
Delivered, dated and signed via Microsoft Teams this 22nd day of October 2026.
HON. L. G. KIMANI
JUDGE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
The Judgement read in the presence of-
Sausi for Applicant
Rubia for Respondent